Randall is just impressive in every way. His persistance, kindness, honesty, and intelligence set him apart from any other geologist ive heard. He is the "Master of Disaster"!!!
I live in this area and recreate in the coulees. To now have a full understanding of what I see every day and how it was "created" is just awesome! It's stunningly beautiful here, and all due to catastrophic events.
5 ปีที่แล้ว
I get good bumps when flying over the grand canyon!!
Super interesting --- It seems that whenever a well versed and researched scientist is giving a presentation there never is, nor ever could be, enough time. I could have listened to this guy talk for another 4 hours on the subject. Amazing!
Great job Brad, the production value is getting better and better with each video!! I really like how you use the same images but actually integrate them into the video itself instead of filmed off the screen and the transitions between the two is seamless. And the arrows and notes on the images so you aren’t trying to find the laser pointer to find the different features Randall is talking about. I know I’ve said it before, but again thank you both for the great work and sharing it with the rest of us, you guys are appreciated !!!!
Greetings from Australia, a long way away from this spectacular landscape which in 1988 during my VW campervan trip through here on my way to Alaska I had no idea about including geology. However over the past few years I have been absolutely curious about the formation of the planet and it is totally enlightening to watch all of Randall's videos (and others) describing the awesomeness of size and volume of these floods backed up with fantastic imagery and discussion etc. I would love to have been part of a team exploring this area in more detail but instead I will watch these very interesting and informative videos to stimulate the mind and to try to actually visualise this amazing time in our planet's geological history. I hope there is plenty more videos coming. Thank you so much for teaching us and posting your very well explained videos. Cheers from the Train Lord
Australia has more land controlled and organized , to see , than anywhere on earth . The past is still present upon the land to understand the past beyond the lies presented ...
Man, I enjoy his lectures so much, and am fascinated by his theories. Geology was never that exciting when I was in school, lol. Randall would have been such a motivating instructor from whom to have taken courses.
Outstanding video presentation! I am watching this in 2018 and have just read Graham Hancock's "Magicians of the Gods," where in part II he discusses this same area's geology. He points out all the evidence we now have that a comet hit the ice field, causing massive melting and flooding. It is very convincing. This theory explains the mass flooding we see across North America, and it also explains flood "myths" from around the world. I recommend the book to those interested. Thanks again for this lecture, and I look forward to future ones.
I've been following this for years. Thank you for your work on this. As a HD mech with no high school education it's very nice to be able to,after all these years attend the lectures l missed out on. I'll leave with, to have sat on a mountain side and watched the flow go by.
Perfectly presented. If anyone's in any doubt that there was a mega flood after watching this then they not worthy of watching it in the first place...
What an absolute honor to sit in on another great presentation! And explained like any field of science should, so any layman can grasp the bigger picture. I had never given the last ice age much thought then watched a couple rogan podcasts and found my science spirit animal Randall. Since have digested a half dozen books on the subject, numerous articles and probably 90% of this content twice. My trip out west couldn't come sooner! June or July of 2019 I hope you guys will be out there touring or at least a lecture or two!
Man, I so love these videos. They not only teaach but they also make me question and think for myself too. Oh, those islands you were looking for a name for them. Got no suggestions for the name, but you might wanna look at some aerial photos of the Bahamas etc and compare their shapes and general similarity in looks between them and the ones that were in the talk. Thanks Brad and Randall!!!
Fascinating lecture. I grew up in and around these areas from the area of the ice dam in north Idaho, to the scablands in eastern Washington. It's amazing to me to think about the astounding events that lead to these features. I wish someone had been there with a video camera, to see that amazing outflow.
Fernbank, COOL! I grew up in Atlanta in the 60's, Fernbank was THE school field trip of the year 'til I started high school in '73. Plus Mr. Carlson isn't scared of the four letter word in the science disciplines, catastrophism. Also mentions Mars' debris fields, GENIUS!!!!!
Can you believe those museum administrators actually tried to cut Randall off at the end. It’s like telling DaVinci to stop painting because it’s wasting candle wax
Did this huge flood event impact the formation of the Grand Canyon? I love Randall's presentations, and discovered him and Graham Hancock on a Joe Rogan podcast.
Would love to see what would happen if you made a scaled down raised relief map of this area and supplied a constant flow of dirty water to it and watch it in action!
Yes, the only reasonable explanation for the immense amount of water in a short time period required to produce these flood features is very sudden melting if a huge amount of ice coupled with the breaking of large glacial ice dams. The only heat sources that are sudden enough and large enough are volcanoes or large meteor impacts. Since there are and were no active volcanoes in this area ("Active") then it must have been meteor impacts.
I live in this area. Driving along that highway from soap lake to coulee city is much more impressive in person. The level of destruction was truly unimaginable. North of dry falls has some massive cataracts right above the falls just a few miles outside if coulee city you wouldn't know where there unless you drove that stretch of highway.
It's great to see a more recent video. I have trouble with the stratification that indicates bursts. I thought it was supposed to be one great violent burst as the idea of an ice damn doesn't hold. Its notable that there is ash from Mount St. Helens of about the same age as the sudden end of the Ice Age. Just what was going on.
Some researchers propose that floods from glacial Lake Missoula formed Moses Coulee, while others suggest that subglacial floods from the Okanogan Lobe incised the canyon. So no, it's not just Glacial Lake Misoulla that is believed as the cause.
Question. If it was from an impact on the ice sheet wouldn't we see more evidence of this than in a few localized areas? Wouldn't we see this same type of flood erosion all along the edge of the ice sheet?
He said in the talk, that there were flows east however the gradient was much less, and the distance the water traveled to the ocean 3x as great, so not as much erosion.. There is some though I remember he spoke of by the twin city area in a different talk..
Im very interested in Durdle Door stone archway... How long could we say that this ancient archway has stood the tests of time and cataclysmic events.. Blows my mind. Surely any delicate or temporal shaped formations would be dessimated in a flood or similar... Its hard to imagine such gears grinding over millions of years
this is really a good dialogue about the missoula flood. and at the end, certainly raises some questions about the ponding before the wallula gap. I thought it was over many thousands of years. But the flow dynamics showing differing amounts so significant when the same formula is the same for the flow, makes me wonder, with the alta lake coulee. but my question is, why would they all break at the same time, unless the purcell channel had a dam at the bottom blocked both pools. This makes no sense. I do believe missoula lake formed, because the water marks define it. but where would the other water come from, and the water ran over the mt beside the dam, thus making the water over 900 ft deep. if it occurred once, it could have happened many times. all the till downstream shows the purcell lob, could have had a huge moraine, thus pushing mud up the clark fork, helping seal the bottom. filling the willamette vally with till.
The current explanation for the erosion accepts the sequential drainage of numerous Missoula Lake ice dams around 18ka after the Last Glacial Maximum. I see no reason why the same scenario would not have occurred after each and every one of the multiple ice ages over the past 2.5 million years. This may have left high and dry earlier scablands that were covered with ice lobes during the more recent ice age termination.
Because of the topography, geological features in place that cause a reset over and over in wait of climate to create the bullet to reload the gun? I see it all the time here in the Texas hill country with flash floods. Beautiful meadows with either dry creeks or shallow water sources flowing. Perfect lure for a people with no history of the area. Right out front of the cabin porch, a shallow crystal clear creek you can wade across ankle deep, flowers and wildlife. Upstream 20 miles in the hills a heavy thunderstorm hits, 2 hours later no trace of the pioneer, his cabin or any clue he ever existed. On a magnitude of the two ice sheets, its mind blowing to even imagine what and who was lost, ground into sediment & sand. No different then today, there is no reason N America was not a prime candidate for population and advanced as well, maybe even at the top except for the reason pictured in the video. It actually makes perfect sense. Prior to Quarternary, very long periods of warmth, perfect for explosions of human activity. If man came to be at a time prior to the onset of the last ice age, it would explain why he had no history to plan by. He would have been the pioneer, the settler not knowing the danger to his north. Same goes for coastal populations around the planet, both then and now. We, born in an inter glacial period of relative warmth populate those same areas, we are them all over again. Perhaps.
I'd go to that area any time. I'm an organic chemist, so it's far from my field, but this fascinates me. Id love to be there to hear you point out howit was formed. Have r.v. will travel.
Remember, there was a drastic warming at the end of the Elder Dryas, as well as the Younger Dryas, and some secondary and tertiary warming events that dwarf what the climate alarmists are currently concerned about. The idea of a couple of mega- events in addition to a few merely enormous events does not seem at all unlikely.
Approx 26min mark. Could The layering possibly be from the initial extraterrestrial impact? Looks shattered, and possibly the ice absorbed a major portion, but the shatter point be beneath ground zero kilometres below the impact point? Just a guess. Fascinating topic. Thanks Randall
Excellent. The magnitudes of these floods and the resulting effects on the landscape is just mind boggling. Maybe Moses and the Devil were really slugging it out in this area and this is where Moses practiced before he went to Egypt and parted the waters to let the Israelites escape Pharoah; it would have been easy after these massive floods...LOL..!!
34.00 is it not possible that the waters came from the eastern seaboard? some kind of event pushing the sea east over america towards the ice sheet.. salt water moving over an ice sheet might trigger the dams bursting...
Perhaps the ice dam, when it formed, happened so quickly (mastadons found with food in their mouths) that it did have the structural integrity needed to withstand the hydraulic potential until it began to melt, which RC has also mentioned happened rather quickly near the end of YDP.
Wonderful explanation from Randall Carlson, don't miss out of this! ( And I am not even a geologist) Great bolders however, will flow on the water+debris substance, much easier than just on water. In that case, they would have been half-sunken only, as we see happening on minor catastrophic flows around the world. If the stream of water-debris becomes thinner, by a wider gap or an incoming 'fresh' water flow, they come to a hald and shows us wat happened. But the bolders which Randall showed us, are mind boggling and hard to come to terms with. Thanks GeoCosmic REX for letting us in. :-)
Interesting. However, his theory of one or two catastrophic flood events does contradict other evidence. Here is another video on this subject: th-cam.com/video/YdiwsZMcxFg/w-d-xo.html I would watch the whole thing but you can skip to 46:23 where they present significant evidence of numerous flood events over thousands of years. I would like to hear from others educated on this subject on what you think.
All rocky bodies within our solar system display similar features- including Mars. Similar features suggest similar mechanisms for their creation. Every moon in our solar system have hexagonal creators for example. Every one. Scientists have thrown projectiles of every shape and description, from every angle at piles of sand and dirt- not a single impact in the lab has replicated these abundant hexagonal flat bottomed creators. However, electrical machining experiments in the lab have replicated such creators and many other common features besides- such as rills and secondary creators on the lip of larger creators. We live within a Plasma Bubble within a Plasma driven and created Cosmos. Today is the day we question everything.
Moses: what if a massive rain event coincided with the melting ice? Warmer temperatures (from catastrophe?) causing massive rain and melting all at the same time, adding to the volume. That could explain the amount of water, and wouldn't leave any signature geologically. Unfortunately this hypothesis is also very difficult to discover and confirm now.
Yes, a massive TEMPORARY lake formed in the valleys of western Montana, perhaps multiple times to various depths. The problems with the current model involve the length of time that the Clark Fork Valley blockage remained in place, and the difficulty of it reforming and resealing numerous times, while everywhere else the climate is warming and glaciers are receding. See this article by RC: geocosmicrex.com/rc-responds/ice-dam-viability/
What about massive solar mass ejection events as a potential energie source for the quick melting? Maybe something like that can liberate sufficient quantities of water without the need for ice dams?
No need for impact when plasma discharge events can make a few Great lakes through the Laurentide Glacier in perhaps minutes. saturniancosmology.org is one sketching out drawing from many sources. The electrical nature of the Cosmos is no more apparent to us than to birds on a hight tension wire. But while some prefer Solar sources plasma events, the ENTIRE Mythic record supports Planetary events as an actual history - symbolised, ritualised and structuring to our very consciousness as the archetypes through which we experience our world and each other though a lens of fearful dissociation and control (defence) by which we effectively re-enact our separation trauma as a species.
I think there was northern and a southern icecaps and the initial thaw was abrupt and tremendous, and then gradual thawing with the icecaps as a possible seasonal warmer climate continues! this dissolved great mountains and then water filled the great canyons we know today as The Sea(s) ! maybe caused / cause... planetary alignment, earth slowing down or vice versa, God was bored, idk! maybe this time around just like last time folks will be living at the bottom of the sea, after it dries up of course, due it the tropical location!
I like a lot of Randall's talks and ideas, but this one is just too controversial and he just didn't have enough arguments. The shorelines in Missoula lake arent from single discharge/surge - it is known beach form found in other places due to glacial rebound - actually little to no tide is the reason behind this kind of very even pan-cake erosion. The dated deposits of Mount St. Helens’ ash sandwiched between very distinct layers is too much of a fact to be that easily bulldozer-thru. Studies have shown cracks between the layers, even burrows - all pointing to time between them. Also that focus in YD as if it was the only geological active period. We have 400 000 years of ice-core records - you can get lost in many similar YD cooling events - no way we are watching only 12 000 years of activity here!!! His argument that the Channeled Scablands are from single flood - "because of those massive erosion forms" - is simply deceiving. Time can move even rocks with wind - literally. The oldest of the Pleistocene Missoula floods happened before 1.5 million years ago - some sources even estimate activity at the beginning of the Pleistocene - or about 2.58 million years ago. He desnt talk about that - why?
Wow at 0:26 he says "300 million cubic feet per second" that would take Lake Missoula less 68 hours to drain completely. This sounds a bit far fetched to me. Especially since the water would have slowed considerably in the almost 200 miles it had to travel and been split up into multiple paths and ran smack dab into Lake Spokane, which was existent about the same time. By the time water was draining the Grand Coulee the ice sheet had melted enough that the Okanogan lobe (as well as the other lobes) of the ice sheet had melted so much there couldnt have been a break out flood any more. I guess Randall hasn't seen my video after all LOL
The Purcell Glacier is digging out the deep part of Lake Pend O'Reille, an inland fjord. While it is doing that, the moraine is piling up the Clark Fork and out Farragut toward Spokane. That moraine might have enough stiffness, being rock, to hold back 2,000 feet of head of water. Then when it gives way, the moraines wash away. This can happen repeatedly, including when triggered by the Hiawatha Crater Impact.
Since ive been watching ive been piecing together something that probably is worth looking into with these floods, so the smoking gun could be the greenland impact, if this is so it would explain alot of things. What are the odds of the celestial body that hit that area hit at the same time these ice shelfs existed. I feel that the domino effect would basically cause this
The timeline u gave is close to what i believe with the greenland impact, so many crucial moments in our planets history point to this being the main cause of humanity reset
Also if this happened and a astroid type body hit the earth around that time, how much water was evaporated, and fell back down for how many days? Not only that but the ice melting into the artic seas, and other areas.
@@Melchizedek_USN randel has somethings he does not want to admit, like evidence for the number of flood outburst (around 100) and when they started (18,000 years ago not 13,000). the greenland meteor could have not even effected this area. Greenland is on a different landmass and the PNW ice sheet was separated from the larger Canadian ice sheet.
I came here from another video with Randall Carlson - this was uploaded recently in relation to the discovery of the impact site near greenland that could have potentially led to these floods as well as the death of the megafauna you are asking about: th-cam.com/video/lrrLeJXBwVw/w-d-xo.html
The fluvial dunes are evidence of flow about 400' deep indeed because that's the depth similar sized ones form in the ocean, but it only provides a minimum depth, not a maximum depth! Surfs up
turnerr44, think about this. As of today, we understand the sea levels to have been 180 feet lower. Now we see, as you state, 400 feet higher than ground level. I don't know how far above current sea level the mean is, but the magnitude is staggering.
In the Pacific Northwest much of the land has been covered by huge deep basalt floes. You can find granite outcroppings too, but the most common surface rock in most localities is probably basalt.
What about tidal floods of "biblical" proportions, brought about by close contact with a large celestial body passing near to ancient Earth or through our solar system? Watch the documentary "David Talbott symbols of an alien sky". Interesting stuff.
Randall is the greatest natural philosopher of our time.
Randall is just impressive in every way. His persistance, kindness, honesty, and intelligence set him apart from any other geologist ive heard. He is the "Master of Disaster"!!!
I live in this area and recreate in the coulees. To now have a full understanding of what I see every day and how it was "created" is just awesome! It's stunningly beautiful here, and all due to catastrophic events.
I get good bumps when flying over the grand canyon!!
i wnt to high scool in the east side of lake wa. spent at last 100 weekends in these places.awesome program
Outside of coulee,on pinto ridge headed towards moses has some really interesting features he hasn't covered.
Super interesting --- It seems that whenever a well versed and researched scientist is giving a presentation there never is, nor ever could be, enough time. I could have listened to this guy talk for another 4 hours on the subject. Amazing!
I spend every flight between Boise and Seattle in awe of what this flood has created in my backyard.
Great job Brad, the production value is getting better and better with each video!! I really like how you use the same images but actually integrate them into the video itself instead of filmed off the screen and the transitions between the two is seamless. And the arrows and notes on the images so you aren’t trying to find the laser pointer to find the different features Randall is talking about. I know I’ve said it before, but again thank you both for the great work and sharing it with the rest of us, you guys are appreciated !!!!
Yess I agree
I like that old man and he LOVES what he dose and I trust that!
Immersed innerversd
Never boring! This man is truly a genius!
Absolutely Fascinating! Thank you so much for posting this!
Greetings from Australia, a long way away from this spectacular landscape which in 1988 during my VW campervan trip through here on my way to Alaska I had no idea about including geology. However over the past few years I have been absolutely curious about the formation of the planet and it is totally enlightening to watch all of Randall's videos (and others) describing the awesomeness of size and volume of these floods backed up with fantastic imagery and discussion etc. I would love to have been part of a team exploring this area in more detail but instead I will watch these very interesting and informative videos to stimulate the mind and to try to actually visualise this amazing time in our planet's geological history. I hope there is plenty more videos coming. Thank you so much for teaching us and posting your very well explained videos. Cheers from the Train Lord
Australia has more land controlled and organized , to see , than anywhere on earth . The past is still present upon the land to understand the past beyond the lies presented ...
Man, I enjoy his lectures so much, and am fascinated by his theories.
Geology was never that exciting when I was in school, lol. Randall would have been such a motivating instructor from whom to have taken courses.
The Ice Age Floods are so dang interesting. Thank you Randall.
Fantastic, as always... Brain candy... Thank you for making the material available...
I'm not even a geologist but manoman...was this ever a fantastic lecture.
This lecture could’ve been twice as long and I wouldn’t even notice. That’s the problem with Randall he has to go home eventually!
ironic DICHOTOMY Randall is a gift to humanity
Outstanding video presentation! I am watching this in 2018 and have just read Graham Hancock's "Magicians of the Gods," where in part II he discusses this same area's geology. He points out all the evidence we now have that a comet hit the ice field, causing massive melting and flooding. It is very convincing. This theory explains the mass flooding we see across North America, and it also explains flood "myths" from around the world. I recommend the book to those interested. Thanks again for this lecture, and I look forward to future ones.
or plasma discharge that does not involve 'impact' - such as Tunguska
I've been following this for years. Thank you for your work on this. As a HD mech with no high school education it's very nice to be able to,after all these years attend the lectures l missed out on. I'll leave with, to have sat on a mountain side and watched the flow go by.
This answers many questions I have had. Thank you!
Perfectly presented. If anyone's in any doubt that there was a mega flood after watching this then they not worthy of watching it in the first place...
What an absolute honor to sit in on another great presentation! And explained like any field of science should, so any layman can grasp the bigger picture. I had never given the last ice age much thought then watched a couple rogan podcasts and found my science spirit animal Randall. Since have digested a half dozen books on the subject, numerous articles and probably 90% of this content twice. My trip out west couldn't come sooner! June or July of 2019 I hope you guys will be out there touring or at least a lecture or two!
Thats because he is a layman. Watching him is like going to a Bigfoot convention to learn about primates.
Carlson Cataract. Thats what i'll call it from now on.
Frequent Flyer yes
Yes
Awesome
That sounds fair. His commitment to discovery of this area has earned at least this honor.
I love you Randall. I tell everyone.
Man, I so love these videos. They not only teaach but they also make me question and think for myself too.
Oh, those islands you were looking for a name for them. Got no suggestions for the name, but you might wanna look at some aerial photos of the Bahamas etc and compare their shapes and general similarity in looks between them and the ones that were in the talk. Thanks Brad and Randall!!!
big mountains dissolved by big icecap ...whoa dude!!!
Randal, du är wunderbar!!!
I've been hooked on his work since I seen him on how Rogan podcast.
Randall never skips a beat.
Randall would make an awesome Noah
Fascinating lecture. I grew up in and around these areas from the area of the ice dam in north Idaho, to the scablands in eastern Washington. It's amazing to me to think about the astounding events that lead to these features. I wish someone had been there with a video camera, to see that amazing outflow.
That guy standing there would of said "Oh, Schist"
Not a gneiss thing to say.
Fernbank, COOL! I grew up in Atlanta in the 60's, Fernbank was THE school field trip of the year 'til I started high school in '73. Plus Mr. Carlson isn't scared of the four letter word in the science disciplines, catastrophism. Also mentions Mars' debris fields, GENIUS!!!!!
Randall has really polished his presentation compared to his 2008 lectures. 👍
Legend
This man needs a lecture series
Poor Randall has so much information to impart and not enough time to do it in . Wonderful guy.
Can you believe those museum administrators actually tried to cut Randall off at the end. It’s like telling DaVinci to stop painting because it’s wasting candle wax
Did this huge flood event impact the formation of the Grand Canyon? I love Randall's presentations, and discovered him and Graham Hancock on a Joe Rogan podcast.
Great again. Thank you.
Would love to see what would happen if you made a scaled down raised relief map of this area and supplied a constant flow of dirty water to it and watch it in action!
Thank You 2
He tries hard not to say "Took 10 days . Far too big to be caused by a simple lake. Probably a comet impact causing instant melting."
Wow, great information!!
Is his further to the explanation of the possibilities causing the flood an allusion to comet impacts?
Yes, the only reasonable explanation for the immense amount of water in a short time period required to produce these flood features is very sudden melting if a huge amount of ice coupled with the breaking of large glacial ice dams. The only heat sources that are sudden enough and large enough are volcanoes or large meteor impacts. Since there are and were no active volcanoes in this area ("Active") then it must have been meteor impacts.
Thank you, very, very interesting.
I was so attentive it could have lasted a few more hours. Are there other video meetings on Lake Missoula and ice age floods?
Really well presented! Thank you!
I live in this area. Driving along that highway from soap lake to coulee city is much more impressive in person. The level of destruction was truly unimaginable. North of dry falls has some massive cataracts right above the falls just a few miles outside if coulee city you wouldn't know where there unless you drove that stretch of highway.
It's great to see a more recent video. I have trouble with the stratification that indicates bursts. I thought it was supposed to be one great violent burst as the idea of an ice damn doesn't hold. Its notable that there is ash from Mount St. Helens of about the same age as the sudden end of the Ice Age. Just what was going on.
Some researchers propose that floods from glacial Lake Missoula formed Moses Coulee, while others suggest that subglacial floods from the Okanogan Lobe incised the canyon.
So no, it's not just Glacial Lake Misoulla that is believed as the cause.
Carlson's Cataract is the name I'd use for that unnamed fossil falls.
What to call it??? 24:30 Undrained cross-channel rippling
Question. If it was from an impact on the ice sheet wouldn't we see more evidence of this than in a few localized areas? Wouldn't we see this same type of flood erosion all along the edge of the ice sheet?
He said in the talk, that there were flows east however the gradient was much less, and the distance the water traveled to the ocean 3x as great, so not as much erosion.. There is some though I remember he spoke of by the twin city area in a different talk..
Thank you.
The impact crater has now been found in western Greenland. 31km wide. VINDICATION Randall!
Except it now looks like those two large impacts occured at least 1.5 million years ago, and not 13,600 years ago.
Eriches the Knowledge of Topography , Just Wow :o QC
Im very interested in Durdle Door stone archway... How long could we say that this ancient archway has stood the tests of time and cataclysmic events.. Blows my mind. Surely any delicate or temporal shaped formations would be dessimated in a flood or similar... Its hard to imagine such gears grinding over millions of years
this is really a good dialogue about the missoula flood. and at the end, certainly raises some questions about the ponding before the wallula gap. I thought it was over many thousands of years. But the flow dynamics showing differing amounts so significant when the same formula is the same for the flow, makes me wonder, with the alta lake coulee. but my question is, why would they all break at the same time, unless the purcell channel had a dam at the bottom blocked both pools. This makes no sense. I do believe missoula lake formed, because the water marks define it. but where would the other water come from, and the water ran over the mt beside the dam, thus making the water over 900 ft deep. if it occurred once, it could have happened many times. all the till downstream shows the purcell lob, could have had a huge moraine, thus pushing mud up the clark fork, helping seal the bottom. filling the willamette vally with till.
Where do we go to find these things in order? Thanks
The current explanation for the erosion accepts the sequential drainage of numerous Missoula Lake ice dams around 18ka after the Last Glacial Maximum. I see no reason why the same scenario would not have occurred after each and every one of the multiple ice ages over the past 2.5 million years. This may have left high and dry earlier scablands that were covered with ice lobes during the more recent ice age termination.
Because of the topography, geological features in place that cause a reset over and over in wait of climate to create the bullet to reload the gun? I see it all the time here in the Texas hill country with flash floods. Beautiful meadows with either dry creeks or shallow water sources flowing. Perfect lure for a people with no history of the area. Right out front of the cabin porch, a shallow crystal clear creek you can wade across ankle deep, flowers and wildlife. Upstream 20 miles in the hills a heavy thunderstorm hits, 2 hours later no trace of the pioneer, his cabin or any clue he ever existed. On a magnitude of the two ice sheets, its mind blowing to even imagine what and who was lost, ground into sediment & sand. No different then today, there is no reason N America was not a prime candidate for population and advanced as well, maybe even at the top except for the reason pictured in the video. It actually makes perfect sense. Prior to Quarternary, very long periods of warmth, perfect for explosions of human activity. If man came to be at a time prior to the onset of the last ice age, it would explain why he had no history to plan by. He would have been the pioneer, the settler not knowing the danger to his north. Same goes for coastal populations around the planet, both then and now. We, born in an inter glacial period of relative warmth populate those same areas, we are them all over again. Perhaps.
I'd go to that area any time. I'm an organic chemist, so it's far from my field, but this fascinates me. Id love to be there to hear you point out howit was formed. Have r.v. will travel.
Remember, there was a drastic warming at the end of the Elder Dryas, as well as the Younger Dryas, and some secondary and tertiary warming events that dwarf what the climate alarmists are currently concerned about.
The idea of a couple of mega- events in addition to a few merely enormous events does not seem at all unlikely.
How many Great Ice Age Mega Floods occurred in the later part of the Ice Sheet Retreats?
evidence of rythmelites suggest around 100 starting 18,000 years ago.
Approx 26min mark. Could The layering possibly be from the initial extraterrestrial impact? Looks shattered, and possibly the ice absorbed a major portion, but the shatter point be beneath ground zero kilometres below the impact point? Just a guess. Fascinating topic. Thanks Randall
Excellent. The magnitudes of these floods and the resulting effects on the landscape is just mind boggling. Maybe Moses and the Devil were really slugging it out in this area and this is where Moses practiced before he went to Egypt and parted the waters to let the Israelites escape Pharoah; it would have been easy after these massive floods...LOL..!!
34.00 is it not possible that the waters came from the eastern seaboard? some kind of event pushing the sea east over america towards the ice sheet.. salt water moving over an ice sheet might trigger the dams bursting...
I'm so turned on by geology !so down to basics of how we can understand our earth.
That area north of Potholes Reservoir should be called "Randall's Archipelago"
Perhaps the ice dam, when it formed, happened so quickly (mastadons found with food in their mouths) that it did have the structural integrity needed to withstand the hydraulic potential until it began to melt, which RC has also mentioned happened rather quickly near the end of YDP.
Wonderful explanation from Randall Carlson, don't miss out of this!
( And I am not even a geologist)
Great bolders however, will flow on the water+debris substance, much easier than just on water.
In that case, they would have been half-sunken only, as we see happening on minor catastrophic flows around the world.
If the stream of water-debris becomes thinner, by a wider gap or an incoming 'fresh' water flow, they come to a hald and shows us wat happened.
But the bolders which Randall showed us, are mind boggling and hard to come to terms with.
Thanks GeoCosmic REX for letting us in. :-)
Thanks B-)
You da man Randell 😎🤔
Interesting. However, his theory of one or two catastrophic flood events does contradict other evidence. Here is another video on this subject: th-cam.com/video/YdiwsZMcxFg/w-d-xo.html I would watch the whole thing but you can skip to 46:23 where they present significant evidence of numerous flood events over thousands of years. I would like to hear from others educated on this subject on what you think.
All rocky bodies within our solar system display similar features- including Mars.
Similar features suggest similar mechanisms for their creation.
Every moon in our solar system have hexagonal creators for example. Every one.
Scientists have thrown projectiles of every shape and description, from every angle at piles of sand and dirt- not a single impact in the lab has replicated these abundant hexagonal flat bottomed creators.
However, electrical machining experiments in the lab have replicated such creators and many other common features besides- such as rills and secondary creators on the lip of larger creators.
We live within a Plasma Bubble within a Plasma driven and created Cosmos.
Today is the day we question everything.
Moses: what if a massive rain event coincided with the melting ice? Warmer temperatures (from catastrophe?) causing massive rain and melting all at the same time, adding to the volume. That could explain the amount of water, and wouldn't leave any signature geologically. Unfortunately this hypothesis is also very difficult to discover and confirm now.
this section of Washington is in the low lands, its also in a rain shadow, chance of heavy rains is low.
Why won't it happen again?
Randall questions the ability of an ice dam to contain Glacial Lake Missoula but does not deny that it was 2100 feet deep. Any thoughts?
Yes, a massive TEMPORARY lake formed in the valleys of western Montana, perhaps multiple times to various depths. The problems with the current model involve the length of time that the Clark Fork Valley blockage remained in place, and the difficulty of it reforming and resealing numerous times, while everywhere else the climate is warming and glaciers are receding. See this article by RC: geocosmicrex.com/rc-responds/ice-dam-viability/
@@GeoCosmicREX So you agree that it was 2100 feet deep. If not the Purcell-Trench lobe what held the water back, once or multiple times?
Randall and Graham Hancock should do a programme
Holy ya... I'm in Okanogan Vernon an it everywhere..
Check out the Mabel lake near the upper Shuswap river
What about massive solar mass ejection events as a potential energie source for the quick melting? Maybe something like that can liberate sufficient quantities of water without the need for ice dams?
Impact at the start of the Younger Dryas, solar outburst to melt the ice and end it.
This is Robert Schoks theory. See his latest JRE.
No need for impact when plasma discharge events can make a few Great lakes through the Laurentide Glacier in perhaps minutes.
saturniancosmology.org
is one sketching out drawing from many sources.
The electrical nature of the Cosmos is no more apparent to us than to birds on a hight tension wire.
But while some prefer Solar sources plasma events, the ENTIRE Mythic record supports Planetary events as an actual history - symbolised, ritualised and structuring to our very consciousness as the archetypes through which we experience our world and each other though a lens of fearful dissociation and control (defence) by which we effectively re-enact our separation trauma as a species.
I think there was northern and a southern icecaps and the initial thaw was abrupt and tremendous,
and then gradual thawing with the icecaps as a possible seasonal warmer climate continues!
this dissolved great mountains and then water filled the great canyons we know today as The Sea(s) !
maybe caused / cause... planetary alignment, earth slowing down or vice versa, God was bored, idk!
maybe this time around just like last time folks will be living at the bottom of the sea,
after it dries up of course, due it the tropical location!
I like a lot of Randall's talks and ideas, but this one is just too controversial and he just didn't have enough arguments.
The shorelines in Missoula lake arent from single discharge/surge - it is known beach form found in other places due to glacial rebound
- actually little to no tide is the reason behind this kind of very even pan-cake erosion.
The dated deposits of Mount St. Helens’ ash sandwiched between very distinct layers is too much of a fact to be that easily bulldozer-thru. Studies have shown cracks between the layers, even burrows - all pointing to time between them.
Also that focus in YD as if it was the only geological active period. We have 400 000 years of ice-core records - you can get lost in many similar YD cooling events - no way we are watching only 12 000 years of activity here!!! His argument that the Channeled Scablands are from single flood - "because of those massive erosion forms" - is simply deceiving. Time can move even rocks with wind - literally. The oldest of the Pleistocene Missoula floods happened before 1.5 million years ago - some sources even estimate activity at the beginning of the Pleistocene - or about 2.58 million years ago. He desnt talk about that - why?
awesome... who is this Guy...
i like what i saw , i will be back
Wow at 0:26 he says "300 million cubic feet per second" that would take Lake Missoula less 68 hours to drain completely. This sounds a bit far fetched to me. Especially since the water would have slowed considerably in the almost 200 miles it had to travel and been split up into multiple paths and ran smack dab into Lake Spokane, which was existent about the same time. By the time water was draining the Grand Coulee the ice sheet had melted enough that the Okanogan lobe (as well as the other lobes) of the ice sheet had melted so much there couldnt have been a break out flood any more. I guess Randall hasn't seen my video after all LOL
Just watched the rest and at the end Randall talks about the same thing I've been talking about, the entire sheet melting.
Looking up Moses coulee 👀
The Purcell Glacier is digging out the deep part of Lake Pend O'Reille, an inland fjord. While it is doing that, the moraine is piling up the Clark Fork and out Farragut toward Spokane. That moraine might have enough stiffness, being rock, to hold back 2,000 feet of head of water. Then when it gives way, the moraines wash away. This can happen repeatedly, including when triggered by the Hiawatha Crater Impact.
Since ive been watching ive been piecing together something that probably is worth looking into with these floods, so the smoking gun could be the greenland impact, if this is so it would explain alot of things. What are the odds of the celestial body that hit that area hit at the same time these ice shelfs existed. I feel that the domino effect would basically cause this
If you could do a video with the two or even discount it that would be awesome
The timeline u gave is close to what i believe with the greenland impact, so many crucial moments in our planets history point to this being the main cause of humanity reset
Also if this happened and a astroid type body hit the earth around that time, how much water was evaporated, and fell back down for how many days? Not only that but the ice melting into the artic seas, and other areas.
The more that i think and ponder and study into where i can, where i have access, the more this makes sense
@@Melchizedek_USN randel has somethings he does not want to admit, like evidence for the number of flood outburst (around 100) and when they started (18,000 years ago not 13,000).
the greenland meteor could have not even effected this area. Greenland is on a different landmass and the PNW ice sheet was separated from the larger Canadian ice sheet.
3:14 "Simpson Canyon" or "Doh!!! Canyon" cause it looks like Homer Simpson !!! lol :D
So this is was what killed the megafauna at the end of the ice age?
I came here from another video with Randall Carlson - this was uploaded recently in relation to the discovery of the impact site near greenland that could have potentially led to these floods as well as the death of the megafauna you are asking about: th-cam.com/video/lrrLeJXBwVw/w-d-xo.html
@@davedunks4647 Mammoths still lived on Wrangel island up to 4,500 years ago...
nope, floods happened over 100 times between 18k-13.8k years ago.
@@odisy64 troll
The fluvial dunes are evidence of flow about 400' deep indeed because that's the depth similar sized ones form in the ocean, but it only provides a minimum depth, not a maximum depth! Surfs up
turnerr44, think about this. As of today, we understand the sea levels to have been 180 feet lower. Now we see, as you state, 400 feet higher than ground level. I don't know how far above current sea level the mean is, but the magnitude is staggering.
That's a treestump from before the. Great Flood
I would like to travel there with a person that knows what we are looking at.
So.....I'm available.
This guy is like a father to me if he had have fell off the stage I think I might have cried 🤣🤣
Luvs me sum Randall😊
all hes placs in E wa . are my old stomping grounds
Is pink granite only from Canada? Cause I do underground construction in Ohio and we see it all the time.
In the Pacific Northwest much of the land has been covered by huge deep basalt floes. You can find granite outcroppings too, but the most common surface rock in most localities is probably basalt.
We have in SW Missouri also at elephant rocks state park wear it was mined👍🏻
You might be intersted in this information also:
th-cam.com/video/VQhjkemEyUo/w-d-xo.html
thats a lot of water yo
big bats there at dry falls
What about tidal floods of "biblical" proportions, brought about by close contact with a large celestial body passing near to ancient Earth or through our solar system?
Watch the documentary "David Talbott symbols of an alien sky". Interesting stuff.
MuddFossil University on you tube. You will look with new eyes at our planet.