Why You Don't Want Teleportation
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 26 ก.ย. 2024
- People have always dreamed about being able to go from one place to another instantly, but should they? Kyle shows that it's more than it appears on this week's Because Science!
Grab your new Because Science merch here: shop.nerdist.c...
Subscribe for more Because Science: bit.ly/BecSciSub
More science: nerdist.com/top...
Watch more Because Science: nerdi.st/BecSci
Follow Kyle Hill: / sci_phile
Follow us on FB: / becausescience
Follow us on Twitter: / becausescience
Follow us on Instagram: / becausescience
Follow Nerdist: / nerdist
Because Science every Thursday.
Thanks for watching! Many of you bringing up the problem with relativity -- what is someone like Nightcrawler teleporting relative to? The Earth, the Sun, the Solar System? What happens to his velocity? This is my point. NONE of this is ever explained, and if we try, a number of problems present themselves. I don't like to just say "the super power takes care of it" because then what can we learn? See you in Footnotes! *And don't worry, I am working on episodes about super power you DO want* --KH
Love ya!
What were you measuring in the beginning kyle?!
This has always been my biggest problem with time travel too. Not sure if anyone has discussed this on here before as I'm new to the channel (it's great by the way) and this is my first comment on here but without the ability to teleport, time travel is effectively useless. If you did the classic back to future time jump going from 1985 back to 1955, over those 30 years the sun will have moved around the galaxy roughly 3.6x10^12 meters. If you went back in time without also teleporting through space you would end up an awful long way from where you wanted to be. Have you done an episode on time travel? If not, I think you should.
"...Falling to your death or into the sun." Or, you know, inside the earth (crust, mantle, core, or half in the ground half not).
@Because Science
What if that teleportation is similar to shooting moving target where you don't shoot where it is but where it will be? And when entering dimension you have your velocity and exiting you keep same velocity (dimension doesn't slow you down)?
P.S. If dimension would slow superhero down that would also put huge G forces to stop instantly if you go with Earth's speed. So if dimension do slow you down it shouldn't be instant stop but incremental. In time it takes to disappear and reaper you shouldn't lose that much of speed relevantly.
This dude literally just wants to horde all the superpowers for himself
I literally thought that for a second loool
I ja sam to pomislio
yh
hoard
Why "literally" so abused?
"You were born into cosmic speed" is something awesome and inspirational to hear
I was thinking the same thing I'm like.. Humans are so much cooler than I thought
So by that logic, any amount of acceleration would actually be 1,000+ mph so we're ALL breaking the law lol
With great speed comes great responsibility
with great power
*comes great electricity bill*
That'a right up there with Dr Neil Degrasse Tyson's "we are all made from stardust" for inspirational and actually quite spiritual science quotes.
Just because I don't believe in God, doesn't mean I don't see beauty and majesty in nature. The universe is an absolutely amazing place.
When I was a kid, I'd nod off while watching tv for just a few minutes then realize I am suddenly in my room and wearing pajamas. I somehow lost the ability to teleport when my mom got arthritis.
@@zhg4485 You can never go anywhere without a good curse.
Dark humor love it
sdk more like blurssed
ooooooooooooooooooooooooof same
Wow it must be linked or something. I think I had that too but I blacked out before I teleported
It's actually explained in the comics that nightcrawler has a sixth sense in addition to his teleportation he has control over how fast he reappears as well as the momentum when he enters back into our world and the orientation that he's facing. It's why he can teleport onto moving objects. His speed automatically matches the plane of existence he goes to.
He has a built-in calculator! If Rogue were to copy his power, would she end up in space after a jump?
@@jlinkous05 maybe
depends if she can copy secondary mutaions or not
see this is what i was thinking thru this whole video. these videos are great but sometimes he ignores some of the cannon explanations for powers/simple sulutions cos they are just never explained in siad movie/show, but they ARE there in the soruce material. you can't look at somthing's simplified explantaion and try to pick holes in it if you ignore the complicated explanation.
Night crawler really is the Swiss Army knife of mutants. His spatial awareness helps to explain that remarkable acrobatic ability he is known for.
@@Kiyomoto657 I never thought about that. In the same ways that he can accurately jump, he can also perform regular types of acrobatics. For him by this point, there really is no difference between acrobatics and short-range jumps.
You are wrong because i have seen a mgician pull a rabbit out of a hat that wasn’t there before and the rabbit didn’t fly to the wall at supersonic speeds.
I'd buy a ticket to that show 😂😂
Debunk that Because science
I wouldn't bet my head on the fact that rabbits can't fly at supersonic speeds... have you ever seen Monty Python and the Holy Grail?
Mishra Hamelin That explains everything.
Freaking i saw a guy with a normal flat notebook draw a bowling ball in it, close it, and opens it back up for a bowling ball to fall out....
Everyone gangsta until the teleporting kid gets stuck halfway through a wall.
Whoa.!
Garbage
@@josukehigashikata614 Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Jotaro Kujo Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Jotaro Kujo Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Jotaro Kujo Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Jotaro Kujo Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Jotaro Kujo Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Jotaro Kujo Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless UselessUseless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless Useless
is this some kind of hentai plot?
This aspect is kind of part of 1 of the flaws of teleportation that hasn't been discussed in this video that is also kind of important. The mechanics of the transportee. Do the cells transport through the alternate dimension theory. Or the whole body.
If the whole body it wouldn't successfully enter if there's a wall, because it would be bumped out of the way due to the inability to displace the solid mass, or if it does displace the solid mass would the wall subsequently teleport a distance equal to your teleportation if it was instant in the opposite direction.
Or if it's your cells/particles how does the teleportee dissolve and resubstantiate, and how painfull or how woul that effect you.
Effect: Would the teleportation process reset the polarity of energy stored, and would that as a result make you not have a mind afterwards.
Basically having to relearn everything the way a kid would since you don't know how to do any actions, like crying like a baby is already a step up from that.
Pain: I mean a punch impacts your atoms and cells. If you're whole body's cell's seperated that would be something your body wouldn't even be able to signal a warning of to you in regards to pain since pain is a signal that has to be transported in the first place. But I could imagine during reassembly that your body would truly be trying to signal it's disappreciation of what that was.
One of my favorite things about this is that it also applies to time travel.
He's making me look sooo dumb
Mind blown...
Time traveling is too much risk, I'd opt to see forward into the future if given the choice.
If you have a tardis you can also travel in space.
@@ericshun2552 if you go back in time or to the future you might catch a Bakteria or virus that doesn't exist in your time or bring it from your time into where you travel. If you're lucky you get a pandemic like corona. If you're unlucky, it's total human extinction. So you could only safely travel into the future for a couple of decades, maybe a century. There are bacteria and viruses in the cdc that no living human is carrying in their system anymore. Our bodies don't know them. Global extinction if those would get outside. In time travel, your body would be the cdc but without the security and all the doors are wide open
Also, when you "reappear" at your destination after a teleport, and assuming you are somewhere with an atmosphere, you could be arriving into a location that has atoms (the air). Either you would be atomically split (since your atoms and the air atoms would be "in the same place), or you would instantly displace those air atoms causing a rush of air around your reappearance.
Air atoms?
@@manueldouglas3435 he probably meant molecules that make up the atmosphere. You know, Nitrogen, Oxygen, Ozone (at higher altitude), CO2, etc. I said molecules because each of those things consist of more than 1 atoms.
This is the essential physical problem. Conversely, what happens to the space you occupied before? Does space collapse around the informational vacuum, and if so, how fast, and with what consequences?
I'd argue that the volume you teleport would switch between the two locations. So the void you left behind is replaced witht he volume you teleported into.
@@maaikevreugdemaker9210 Or, alternately the information required to reconstitute what was sent would switch between the two locations and spacetime itself is broken down and reassembled as information at both ends. Instantaneous configuration change of every constituent atom at both ends into the thing it swaps with. Under certain conditions this might be informationally possible, but when you got there you wouldn't be the you that you left behind, you would be the you that was analyzed, broken down, deconstructed and rearranged according to information sent to make the you at the other end.
Somewhere in the world, there is a teleporter watching this and is feeling very grateful to this guy
😂
No because it's a fantasy
@@Resilience93 no it isn't
@@LittleFlareGuy grow up and be rational. This isn't the marvel cinematic universe
@@Resilience93 grow up and learn how to identify a joke
Kyle: “you don’t want teleportation”
Small particles that were used for science: *”teleporting go brrrrr”*
Its not teleportation, its quantum tunnelling and its not just a thing in a lab, it happens naturally all the time even inside you. Quantum particles only have a probability of being in a location until they interact with something, then they colllpse into a position. If the particle is high energy enough or the barrier thin enough then there is a significantly non zero chance that a particle could be on the other side of the wall when observed.
Nerd
@@debreceniszabolcs8494 entanglement doesn't let you swap places. It just makes the "spin" of the particle opposite to the particle you just observed.
@@debreceniszabolcs8494 also quantum entanhelment isn’t true teleportation cus its information teleportation, which mean ur mass didn’t teleport like what u think, its stay there, only information about particle that form ur body, thats why quantum entangelment its horible way to teleport but great new way for communication method
@@Jamesdavey358 tgeres a nonzero chance all particles in your body will displace 1 meter to the left
Just because you haven't figured out the antimatter requirements for a stable Einstein-Rosen Bridge doesn't mean I don't want teleportation, dammit.
Dammit Jim, traversable wormholes aren't teleportation!
Well okay, by the Sci-Fi definition of teleportation, projecting a wormhole mouth to a desired place and pushing your mass-energy through it would be theoretically viable. You can inflate a wormhole mouth from the far end. The trick is propelling the wormhole mouth... especially making it come to a stop. Because otherwise you come out of that mouth with the velocity of the mouth, which can end badly.
Though it would sure look cool, projecting a tiny wormhole mouth with a bright plasma jet coming out one end, propelling it to its destination...
That makes me wonder if an Einstein-Rosen Bridge would theoretically be able to have its entrances/exits move relative to each other. The theoretical use-case for this would allow for the ends of the bridge to be located at fixed points on two different planets' surfaces so you would have to worry about the planets moving relative to each other.
of course, the answer to all these hypotheticals is almost always, "further research is required"™
Actually you don't need antimatter for an Einstein-Rosen bridge,you would need a type of stable particle that gives energy to the Higs Field.It would need negative spacetime curvature,it would be a negative mass thing.And negative mass things are fundamentally impossible...
I love how smart people are in the comments.
I really love how there is no sound in space as there is nothing to carry the vibrations
I really love how there no poop in our intestines after we take a shit
@@Krawna you assume
I’m sure you’ll love it when nobody hears you screaming
@@Krawna And you can't *smell* the poop out in space either, even if it remains in orbit around Uranus.
So make sure to keep your ass-to-rhoid belt buckled cause nobody wants to see your full moon shine.
@@kenlieck7756 lmfao
I still don't feel like walking to school tho...
@Sonicthehedgehoggamer want some celery sticks and peanut butter with raisins on the side?
Sonicthehedgehoggamer Really? You had to go there?
@@turismo7649 what did he say
@@kuxentral7477 just some dumb shit
Bikes exist
No, I don't want the ability to teleport. I want the technology to teleport.
PaleGhost69 .. *THE FLY* movie... if you never saw the movie before ..I'm sorry
I believe they have managed to teleport grains of sand before
Chris Adler who has? Not in the Real World.
Aka...a death machine.
@@chrisadler8888 I think it wasn't grains of sand, but like... Electrons or molecules or something. Don't remember exactly
4:00 woah, he finally brought out his hammer
Ahahahahahaha
Bring me thanos
This could apply to basically any super power, fireballs, telekinesis, super strength, shapeshift, I wanna see you make an "why you don't want fireball superpower" that isn't just "it will burn your hands
How about the inability to propel them without some kind telekinesis
Well, for starters this guy moved to his own channel called ”Kyle Hill” and I don't think that he's allowed to do these kinds of videos due to copyright.
As for fireballs, I think it works by magic, and is difficult to invalidate scientifically.
Also, if you're just shooting literal fire, it wouldn't be able to blow things up as movies and shows might indicate, it would probably just either make things hot or light them on fire, which itself is kind of a niche use since we already have lighters and flamethrowers to do the exact same thing, making it only suitable in combat (or if you want, to commit arson and risk getting arrested and likely experimented on)
@@skillagerthevillagermain lighters do need combustible fuel, and while there are small animals can create a small combustible or venomous spray as a defense mechanism, the amount of daily calories needed to make a useful enough spark to light your gas-powered stove would require you to triple your intake for the following meal
I feel like basically EVERY superpower and magic has the required secondary power of, "You can produce enough energy to use this power"
Goes double for creation of matter.
The only franchises I've seen that really explain this are Worm (can't tell you how though, because spoilers) and Eragon (where all energy comes from the reserves of your own body, though it can be stored in some things, or, with enough skill, it can be gathered from other living beings)
Ok. Well that’s the night crawler version.
MY VERSION. I just go “poof” and “poof” and I’m there.
Mine would be more of the jumper version.
@@ladarriusjennings8914 why not want the portal gun 🔫 without danger and stuff he's talking about because it looks useful.
Okay vsauce
That is the Nightcrawler version.
Is no one going to comment the "jumper" version of teleportation where they literally just make a practical portal to where they wanted to go
That was a cool movie btw.
Yea and you can basically do way more things
In my opinion its one of the few teleportation powers that makes sense as to how it works and what it can do
We should ask him to do a video on this version of teleportation
xaldiac the issue is you would still have to know the relative position of where you are going in the actual solar orbit of the earth. Yea you may think “Paris France, that bench I know” but that bench is not technically anywhere near where it physically was when you were there, so you wouldn’t actually know it’s exact location. If anything the jumper version is actually a bit worse as you would essentially be opening a portal into open space every time (if it put the portal in the location you WERE at, you would be in space) I love the movie Jumper FYI just figured I’d throw my hat out there
You should make a video on the superpowers you would want and work.
In Scarlet Nexus, Luka has teleportation, and he explains that if he teleports somewhere that has changed, for example an empty field, but that field has a tree in it, if he teleports where the tree is and thus inside the tree, the result would be a nuclear explosion. I'm assuming it's because of the atoms colliding, but it is a video game so who knows if there is any science behind it. Would love to hear this teleportation explained!
Ay Scarlet Nexus is fire
@Welp I guess you would have a lot more air in your body and it may go boom if you are unlucky
Thats actually a really intriguing concept
Doesn't make any sense though, that just means he would explode every time he teleported
@@MS-pz9wd According to him, only if he teleports somewhere he knows, and something is standing in the spot he's teleporting. For example, he teleports to an open field he knows, but now there's an entire shopping mall there and he spawns in a wall. Boom. Probably not real science but would still be cool to see a video on nonetheless.
I want the power to teleport without any Consequences
A feminist and modern liberal approach to the dilemma , I think.
@@RadicalUnderstanding That would cause many problems. My solution is to make everyone equal!
@@TsunaXZ If everyone was rich wouldn't every one be thus equal?
If everyone was rich, nobody would be rich, as rich would just become a normal amount of money, which would then be devalued
with great power...
Hold on.. wait wait wait.. stop the freaking presses here...........
The Earth isnt flat?
No
kylo ren
r/woooosh?
It’s a turtle
Yes. It is a triangle. Ugh, people these days
The Global Flat Earther Society Lied to me! I need to get my deposit back!
Ah TH-cam. The only place i can genuinely learn something and feel more confused because of it.
School: am i joke to you?
@@tahahayder4624 yes it is a joke xd
@@FireStorm56 fr hahahaha xddd lollollololol lmaolmaolmao hehehe hu hah lmfaolmfao
Fr after this 1:39 to 1:49 I don’t even get teleportation anymore
Well maybe a higher iq would sove that problem
what happens if instead of how night crawler does it instead you do it like a wormhole where space folds on its self and you just instantly appear there
It's actually possible according to science ! . . . . Oh and a small creator called Veritasium
@@Yami_gd yea thanks I was just wondering because im studying them in my college
I don’t know, just hope you don’t appear in something solid or a star?
@@imthegoat94 yea true
That basically IS how Nightcrawler does it.
Kyle is out on a mission to debunk every super power ever.
A spooky, scary little man to TRY to debunk
Crushing my hopes of having a cool superpower every episode
He just wants you to be safe! Think of the problems as simple obstacles you must overcome to become super! Use science!
Coming up next - Why You Don’t Want...Common Sense.
Well, there's one power he can't debunk. Being a Mad Scientist... because Science.
I think a good Teleportation ability would be the Flying Raijin from Naruto.
You can only teleport to specifically-placed markers, which can be placed pretty much anywhere. And since most of them would be attached to the earth, you'd arrive at that location at the same velocity and position as the marker.
DEEPWOKEN TELEPORTATION BELL🦅🦅🦅🗣🗣🗣🗣🫵🫵🫵🫵
Actually a pretty good point. Who would have thought that Naruto of all sources to pull from what actually offer a pretty solid solution to this?
So three possibilities.
1. after the tp you arrive with 0 velocity and gonna be killed by the earth
2. You arrive with the speed before the tp and pretty much can be killed by the diferent speeds on different diractions
3. You arrive with the exectly amount of speed that you make the mark and by the earth spinning around towards the sun and the sun towards the central blackhole of the galaxy you would be killed
(Edith: i was writing that at 5 am and as a non native speaker make some serious mistakes , than i thought that i didn't had the patience to read all of it and only really make one tiny correction 😂)
Or i the most simple one that i dont thought at the time arrive with the velocity of the mark 😅
Which is basically the same concept as the Stargates; base teleporters that are linked together that can calculate ideal relative velocities for transported users using 4 dimensional coordinates. I feel like this is the most realistic version of sci-fi teleportation.
The risks:
You might be upside down.
Your hands may be inverted.
It may be a mess.
Ears of others may pop (due to air stopping existence breifly).
The benefit:
You will move to the place.
The inverted hands part? Only if it’s atom by atom, or limb by limb.
Worth
Yeh.
Why not using portal like Dr. Strange
Worth
Instantaneous teleportation solves all those problems. That's the type of teleportation you wish for.
but... you'll die and be replaced by an identical copy of you, and since portals aren't really viable....
Henry Stickmin says no.
Not really. If you teleport from where I am to the equator you'll go from about 800 mph to an environment spinning about 1000 mph. Even if you do that instantly you're going to die horribly.
I think what you want are tunnels where you travel from tunnel location A to tunnel location B. And, as you travel through the tunnels your speed adjusts in a safe manner to match the speed of the receiving tunnel location. Almost like a pneumatic tube system.
@IamnotJohnFord Incorrect, if no time passes, then you'd maintain your initial speed and acceleration, which would match the planet. It would be as if you were always there, so no flying off or feeling the g forces of a rotating and moving planet
@@23TDJ Maybe I'm wrong, but everything and everyone on the planet isn't moving at the same rate. At the poles you are barely spinning. But, at the equator you are booking at 1000 mph. If your change in velocity is zero to 1000 mph you'll be ripped apart. In fact, the closer to instanteous the teleportation the worse the damage.
The safest way to do it would be buffer zones that either speed up or slow down your body so that it matches you new environment. But, now we're talking about tunnels.
stop
stop it
stop ruining my dreams
It's Time to Stop
"Insert Filthy Frank meme"
this ability is litteraly my dream since im like 8 and despite being 20 now i kind of still want it ^^
@@bigtutubi6731 and become like you no thanks
@@bigtutubi6731 so many people have this attitude, and yet people like Elon Musk, Nikola Tesla and the Wright Brothers continue to make humanity's dreams come true. In a few decades, scientists and engineers with both the vision, and the will to do so, could be bringing about the technological singularity, at which point all the problems he mentions will be as laughable as contemporary arguments against flight, electricity or space travel.
Christopher Lee wow it was a joke my guy
Imagine having an ability to appear in any place in the universe in a blink of an eye and just teleporting around the watery hot rock you were born on.
well any other place you would be a fish out of water. No air no life. Some places are too hot or cold. Some places have way too much gravity. Teleport to a black hole and you will never escape.
Ah yes.. the classic internet comment that attempts to sound cool but makes a stupid point while being liked by other stupid people.
There is something called the goldilocks zone for a star system that indicates the exclusive region in which planetary conditions to support life can exist.
So even with the power to traverse the universe, this 'hot wet rock you were born on' is the only place you want to be, unless you have found another planet with the exact same conditions ahead of the rest of humanity.
So your smart-Alec comment insinuating a lack of imagination on the part of a teleporter, merely speaks to your lack of common sense.
@@Aceinine it's just a joke tho. I think.
@@Aceinine clearly an internet genius over here
I would absolutely love it!
Space must literally be littered with dead time travelers then O_o
Holy heck your right,does that mean we don't ever unlock the secrets of time travel because we don't see a billion dead or alive people floating in space?
well, maybe.. there ARE NO TIME TRAVELERS. Time travel is just scientifically impossible.
@@jonathanmoody7129 Time indeed is not a force of the Universe such as gravity. However, individual perception of time and the amount of this change is very real, and so is relativity. When you travel at light- or near-lightspeed, your perception of time and the amount of change you'll endure will be different from the rest of the Universe not moving at such speed. Therefore, time travel to the future is indeed possible, although not with our current technologies.
@@Lernos1 if we consider the fourth dimension time, I see absolutely no reason it wouldn't be possible to travel in it. Just every time you do you make so many alternate timelines that you'll never get to the one you wanted to be in. In other words: You WILL Trunks it up.
@@Gr3nadgr3gory Yeah, well, that's outside of our scientific understanding for now. Currently we don't consider time to be the fourth dimension, and we only know how to theoretically travel to the future by basically slowing down the relative time around yourself. We lack the technology for that anyway. All other stuff, including the creation of alternate universes, is pure speculation.
When you're moving 40,000 kilometers every day but still gain weight
@thunderlifestudios8630 😂 literally
@Thunder Life Studios no wonder why it's called fast food
Well, only if you're on the equator. The funny thing is I bet that if you traveled to either of the poles, you'd end up losing weight. 🙃
Update to my previous. If Nightcrawler moves through another dimension, then we can imagine how this works with a two-dimensional metaphor.
Consider a two dimensional creature living on a tabletop, unable to see the third dimension. If I pick it up, move it, and set it down, then, from a two dimensional perspective, it will seem to have teleported. But we know that isn't what happened because we can see the third dimension. If the table is moving or similar, that isn't a problem. That two-dimensional world is just a slice of the three-dimensional reality. Everything is connected.
Perhaps Nightcrawler lives in a three-dimensional slice of a four-dimensional universe. In that case, his power could make a fourth-dimensional step, move him the required distance, then take another fourth-dimensional step to set him back into his own reality. Because all of reality is connected, he doesn't need to worry about any changes in momentum or the movement of the Earth. All of the forces upon him are preserved because he never left reality; he just moved through it in an unconventional way.
Understood, but what about the poof, and we are effectively living in 4 dimensions, but unable to perceive directly, time, so nightcrawler would have to move 5th dimensionally
Time is not a spacial dimension
@@Tallnerdyguy The poof may be some piece of the dimension he's moving into - or just a cool effect they threw in for the movie. It's not clear.
Regarding time, that's also a dimension to consider. We've seen mutants travel through time as well as other dimensions, so they must have at least five dimensions of travel. Either Nightcrawler's direction or time could be considered the fourth dimension - I'm unsure if the order matters or how you would decide which comes first.
I can disprove your theory.
for your example imagine the world is a lazy susan. it is spinning very quickly, if you pick the salt shaker off it and tried to put it down again two things happen, 1 you have to STOP the shaker from moving and then you have to speed it back up to put it down.
@@robertshort9487 only if the space I pick it up into isn't spinning at the same speed. In my example, everything is connected and so everything in that higher (or lower) dimension is also moving.
This mans TH-cam channel is basically ruining everyone’s childhood dream Edit: Damn thanks for 1k likes
Ruining everyone's childhood dream must have been his childhood dream.
João Jacinto lol
Haha true
Yeah! Fucking FASCIST! 😂
yep
Imagine if one day we actually make a teleporter. Then we test it with a monkey and the monkey flies out of the machine at Mach 1.4
I need some one to draw that now XD
Jason Miller: Yep. It's basically a Heisenberg-proof Xerox Airlines.
In the Polity series by Neal Asher he posits a wormhole-esque transport system that requires massive energy dumping infrastructure just to handle the galactic rotational inertia of those passing through it. In his story someone disables this system, resulting in one human passender exiting the target gate at near lightspeed. With unpleasant results.
That made me laugh
@@RellimDaMonkeyMan so would the same instance of your brain come back or would you fully die with a copy of the brain
Well, Dragon Ball teleportation essentially accounts for this. Goku needs to concentrate on a target in order to teleport. Since he can sense the target he can also sense it's velocity and position
I still want teleportation
Midori Dad - 5 movies later and I still think a Dinosaur zoo is a good idea.
@Danny SJ the thing is Nightcrawler's ability is explained, and you have to be a comic fan of his to know that. He's also not limited in the way this video is explaining.
The Goku's teleportation is a bit less troublesome because it locks to the relative position of objects in the planet (namely people).
He's also super fast. So even if he did suddenly appear in the middle of the atmosphere with winds moving at hypersonic relative speeds, I'm pretty sure he could just adjust his own velocity without problem. But that's jusT A THEORY!
@@OtherDoorFilms a theme theory
Kyle, you are also forgetting how fast the sun is travelling around Sagittarius A, (around 230,000 m/s) or how fast the Milky Way Galaxy is travelling in our local super cluster (I don't know, but fast). Those speeds dwarf your original calculations by several orders of magnitude. I think the crux of your entire argument (and it's Achilles Heel) is the concept of absolute or relative position. Effectively there's no particularly poignant point that can be attributed as the origin point in our universe without some sort of perfectly valid and legitimate argument as to why it shouldn't be. Ergo, ALL positions in space are actually relative positions. So however many metres away you are travelling, if you were using the centre of the earth as the fixed point that your teleportations are relative to, then ALL the math you just said after the rotational differential is utterly meaningless, as the position you're moving to or from is relative not to some arbitrary fixed origin, and rather is relative to the large massive body you want to remain on. If this is the case, then nightcrawlers teleportation limit of a few miles makes sense and can be considered "safe" WITHOUT some kind of quantuum supercomputer doing the calculations for him. Although your statement about the air-replacing is completely valid, lol.
What I came here to say.
Also not included is how fast our galaxy is moving away from the center of the universe. Standing perfectly still for even a fraction of a second would have severe consequences.
yeah but with quantum teleportation, you keep all your prorpiety... So you would still be moving and the TP is instant.
Welcome to the footnotes :D
Yes, the whole episode was about frames of reference. I was expecting to hear some additional reasons not to want the power.
With the example of Portal's portals, the entry and exit points are fixed relative to the moving reference frame of Earth's surface and momentum is preserved relative to those points. Teleportation, of the type described, should be able to work the same way, almost regardless of the conditions of the means of travel (other dimensions) between those points. It's also possible for the alternate dimension to be linked somehow to the movement of the Earth.
Just like the perception of a 3D object in 2D space, if you pick up a chess piece (the surface of the board is what's visible) the circle representing its mass would disappear when picked up and reappear when set back down. It can be moved faster this way than by sliding it and can avoid obstacles not possible while sliding but it still shares the same reference frame for momentum and everything else.
Since teleportation is a superpower, im sure part of the package includes safely landing without worrying about earth's rotation.
The bigger issue with teleportation is: You don't know what may lie where you want to teleport to so you could end up intertwined with an object or in front of a moving object, and so on
Imagine drunk-porting. Accidentally poof into a innocent women
well if you can observe your landing spot, which we assume you can, then there are no issues. :)
@@neutrino78x Actual drunk drivers can see where they are going but they still run into things as well. Nothing saying that just because you can perceive the target location, that you can get there without making a miscalculation or other error.
@@Warwynd2010 I guess by your logic we should ban all types of transportation because it's possible someone could make a miscalculation or other error, as happens on the road all the time. This is hardly a reason not to have a teleporter lol.
I would never set foot in one that did it Star Trek style, moving your body atom by atom: there is no way to be certain that I wouldn't die in the process, as the copy of me would believe himself to be me. THAT is the reason not have a transporter as seen on Star Trek. :)
One that operates by creating a small traversable wormhole, on the other hand, that one I would use. :)
@@neutrino78x I never said anything about banning anything. My comment is simply stating that just because you can see the target destination doesn't mean you can get there safely.
I think the only good thing about teleportation is that you could use space warping teleportation, this teleportation moves the space around you 😅
Then there's also the speed at which our solar system is travelling in the galaxy, and how fast our galaxy is travelling in the universal expansion.
True and if u want to mention the endless possibilities of what else could be out there (multiverse?)
And how fast the universal expansion is traveling within the extended universal expansion. Mhm
@@Spartan-oq1yw you see, not impossible just incredibly difficult.
And the universal expansion is _literally_ faster than lightspeed (due to physics working unintuitively), so you're still screwed no matter how much correction you make.
Spartan 07613 or maybe none of that is actually happening
If Nightcrawler is already travelling at Earth speed when he pops into another dimension, the examples you give would indicate he spontaneously comes to an absolute stop in that dimension, before coming back into Earth at that dead stop. Given the time difference between his disappearing and reappearing in the film, wouldn't he have maintained his momentum and so not need to calculate anything? That might also explain why he can't teleport places he can't actually see. Not Because Science, Because Momentum
the speed ting for how fast he would be reentering in his video does not make sense for how fast the Earth would be in relation to how fast night crawler would be that is true and that probably is part of why it takes him a second to travel that far and why the odd amounts for left and right compared to front and back
Damn It I didn't read this before I made my comment, thumbs up, sir!
Yes this was in my head the whole time. Since Nightcrawler was already within the momentum of Earth, he wouldn't have stopped moving in those milliseconds he was off Earth's dimension and would probably pop back in with that momentum as such.
For that to be true, he would need to teleport in the same direction and in the same longitude relative to the earth surface, otherwise he would "pop" at even faster than mach 1.4. And that doesnt solve the other relative velocities he might encouter. (earth orbit, solar system orbit, even galaxy movement)
Also, if he gradually improved the distances to which he teleported, he'd learn how to compensate for any of these difficulties, even without thinking.
Or do you think Tony Hawk calculates his momentum before each jump?
My dream : *exists*
Because science : I'm about to end this man's whole career
Lol
Lel
You know what would *really* suck -- imagine getting teledeported!
Wow. You literally destroyed my dream. Well done!
Me too
That's the only reason that i would like earth be flat
If you are serious, dont worry, there are other ways to teleport instead of going into another demension and back again
Just wait about 5000 years... oh wait
Why did I have the same dream
How about this: You bend space-time, bringing the location to yourself. Once the portal closes, reality repairs itself.
Thats what I was thinking. People tend to forget perspective is also a variable. To us it may look as if he is suddenly disappearing, but to the teleporter they could be bringing the location to them except crazily fast. Imagine what it looks like when you zoom into a camera, that'd be their view while everyone else just sees them suddenly disappear.
StewieRS - Micro-Black holes probably, and they'd likely exist for infinity small amounts of time, similar concerns were raised with the LHC built by CERN.
It is the same. What is location? How do you pin it to Earth?
StewieRS - Honestly depends on the size of the black hole, it's influence on it's surroundings are proportional to how long it is present in that location and it's over-all size,
if they only exist for 10 billionths of a Pico-second and are insanely small then they will likely wink out of existence before any noticeable change takes place.
At most we would see it's left over radiation or some other secondary effect, but with that said take it with a large pinch of salt my field of expertise is I.T and computer systems. Not theoretical physics. lol
@@asc3nded132 why would that create a Black hole as you aren't crunching mass and energy into a singularity.
So, you're saying that it would work if you had some sort of machine that would calculate your Time And Relative Dimension In Space?
I see what you did there.
@@tylermalmberg1252 and I like it
Well done!
*NO SPOILING*
Like a TARDIS!
I've heard something similar about time travel, in order for your time machine to work it also has to send you to the point in space where the Earth was at the time you want to go back to.
But what if your superpower is having superpowers without their consequences?
That's a lot of superpowers. Maybe have another one to be able to sustain and control them all.
//music plays//
In x-men they evolved to use their power.
But what if you are original?
Then watch him make a video about why u wouldn't want to have superpowers without the drawbacks
No one:
This channel: Why u don’t want to live
Because science
@@ariansk9011: Sienk*
#PitchMeetings
#Makesnosense
Stfu
@Thy nigga Bitch
You had a movie like "Jumper" and you didn´t even use it :(
Jumper was a terrible movie... just sayin
blame the writer instead
I really liked it, but I mean, whatever you are into
majinfreecell same, maybe he hate it because its editing not as good as today, CGI when the movie was made not as good as today
The books by Steven Gould explore a lot of these ideas. In a later book, one of the "Jumpers" realizes that if she can instinctively match her velocity to the velocity of the Earth when she teleports, then she can also jump in place but change her velocity (or jump anywhere with any velocity), effectively giving her the ability to fly. She goes on to create her own space station. Read the books!
Utilizing a machine, I agree the calculations can be complicated, but I'd always assumed that personal superpower teleportation would indeed come with its internal super compensation device, much the same way as we don't calculate our steps even when transitioning from typical everyday high-traction carpet to slippery sloped icy walks. We've just learned to do so over time. Step by step. Particularly if its a mutation step as shown in X-Men. (Doctor Manhattan, however, is likely doing calculations even if he doesn't need to.)
"we don't calculate our steps even when transitioning from typical everyday high-traction carpet to slippery sloped icy walks"
Yeah, but how many people would slip in that scenario? XD
Really though, I'm sure any comic book writer would just casually write in some "super human instinctual calculations" or something for teleporting characters, if they were asked. But if somehow something did develop a natural way to teleport, it would probably take hundreds of thousands of years of evolution for a species to be able to properly utilize it.
MalinDeMunich Doctor manhattan probably calculates the saturation of his cereal milk.
congratulations!! u r a supa nerd
Samuel R. Delany's novel "The Fall of the Towers" uses technology that employs something called a transit ribbon. But that's more like being sent across data lines and an after affect is you're rendered temporarily invisible in dim light.
Well teleporters unconsciously doing a lot of math is the case in the A Certain series
Well it's true for all Espers
And iirc their "we do it by projecting a personal reality thing" explanation would ignore the speed problems, unless you told them about it
You look like you'll scream "IM THE GOD OF THUNDER"
@@thorodinson292 holy fuck. I have only 1 thing to tell you... YOU SHOULD HAVE GONE FOR THE HEAD
Thor Odinson i love you 3000 beergut Odinspawn
@@alexochoa8862 Spoilers XD
@Amarion Anderson is that sarcasm i smell?
😂
This is why, when I write teleportation, I always make my users have an object they touch and then teleport to
Do Shape-shifting next, the biology behind that must be insane to impossible.
Varsocona ... Yep
BUT: OCTOPI
I would assume you have control over your exterior cell tissue, but if you mean changing into nonorganic constructions?
It would be impossible if your including the ability to change into something a different size than yourself. Because you have the whole “where did the extra mass come from or go?”problem.
However if someone somehow had the conscious ability to manipulate their DNA to change their appearance into anything that’s the same mass as they are then it could work.
Tho if the mutant had super dence mass the redistributed mass would be correct tho that just makes more problems
This is why Goku needs to lock on to somebody’s ki- he needs a reference to match their relative velocity!
yeah because the one thing DBZ/DBS is worried about is scientific accuracy, clearly
@@vicc6790 d BS
Vic C no but they got a weirdly logical explanation (logical in dbz canon obviously) xD
Tanner Patton Minato have better teleportation
Vic C they surprisingly care about scientific accuracy to the fullest extent that they can, but fail in many aspects, just like most science fiction
Because Science, the channel that destroys our childhood dreams one video at a time.
Coming back to these vids as an engineering student makes these vids way more understandable and appreciated 👏🏾
ah yes, a fellow riven main
also what about teleporting by being faster than time itself
for example: jotaro and dio from jjba can stop time so would it be considered teleporting if they move through stopped time
@@drubliinz6599 ohhh wow 🤔 that’s a very good question 😂
Don't forget the sun orbiting in the galaxy, and the galaxy orbiting in it's cluster, and the accelerating growth of the univeverse.......
Everything is relative. Like, what is absolute location? How is it defined in infinite space. Yeah relative to the sun we’re moving a lot, but relative to where we’re standing you haven’t moved. I think the most logical way this power works is your location relative to earth
My favorite examples of Teleportation in fiction are the ones shown in the "A Certain" Franchise (made up of the series "A Certain Magical Index", "A Certain Scientific Railgun" and "A Certain Scientific Accelerator"). In this franchise, Teleportation exists in 5 different variants, all of which have their own advantages and disadvantages.
The most commonly seen type is just called "Teleportation", as used by the character Shirai Kuroko. She can teleport up to 81.5 meters at a time, and in order to teleport at all, she has to calculate her original coordinates and the destination coordinates in 11 dimensions, and if she tries to teleport further than 50 meters I think it is, her accuracy drops from a few millimeters to 1.5 meters, which could lead to her teleporting into a wall, or out in front of a train, depending on where she uses it. She can also teleport any object she touches, up to a maximum weight of 138 kilograms, regardless of size, and again, the closer to the limit, the lower the accuracy.
The second-most commonly seen type is called "Move Point", and is used by another character, Musujima Awami, who can teleport objects without having to touch them, up to a maximum range of just over 1 kilometer, with a weight limit of around 4 metric tons. Enough to drop a building on her enemies. Naturally, this sounds like a more powerful ability, but unlike Teleportation, Move Point doesn't cause matter in the destination coordinates to be displaced when an object is teleported, so teleporting into a wall could cause serious injury. In fact, this is explained early on as the reason why Musujima doesn't teleport herself around unless she has no other choice at all, because she's already been close to dying after teleporting into a wall.
The third type is called "Asportation", and is considered a stronger version of Teleportation and Move Point, as it has the accuracy and speed of Teleportation, but the range of Move Point, except the limits are increased since it's a Level 5 ability, where the other are Level 4. It is only ever seen used by a dead person, whose powers have been amplified to make it Level 5, even though originally they were Level 3 and much weaker than "Teleportation".
Also, all these types of teleportation are mentally taxing, leading to a limit to how many times in a row a teleporter can use their ability. And they require one to focus on nothing but the calculations, meaning that in most cases, they're 100% worthless in battle, unlike Nightcrawler's which doesn't seem to have any limits at all...
Witch is why the real, superpower of espers in the "A Certain" Franchise isn't actually, what ever they can do with their abillities, but the brainpower to acually calculate al that complicated shit. I mean, those guys are basicly human supercomputers
@@felixreichel4772 Yeah, it's from an Undertale web comic, which i know, cringe, but I think 1 of the most surprisingly badass lines is
"We're in Canada right?"
"... Yeah"
"Good that will make the maths a lot easier" before someone just pulls out a calculator and teleports everyone out of a battle.
There's not much detail put into what the maths is for teleporting but it's clear it at least involves displacing air in the target location so it doesn't show up in your blood and instantly kill you with 17 strokes, matching velocities with longitude and latitude and accounting for higher dimensions.
@@stm7810 No shame in it being from an Undertale Web Comic. I read tons of those back in the day. It’s what got me into Web Comics in the first place. And second, it’s a really good example of some writer taking Teleportation more serious like it’s supposed to be.
@@felixreichel4772 Yeah, the author paid attention to a lot of stuff, including explaining the physics behind SOULs, the limits of different magic, like how healing magic can't be used to replace a removed limb, but can perform months of repair your body would do naturally such as fixing 2 broken legs. acknowledging Sans doesn't move super fast since that would create winds that would drop his 1HP, and instead he alters the flow of time, and there's even tracking of HP and MP.
Another to aru enjoyer based.
But doesn't nightcrawler teleport to the place not its location or cordinates like he isn't thinking that building is a mile away thats how much i have to teleport he's thinking of the building and would teleport to the building not where it was so he wouldn't really end up in space because he is teleporting to a place he is thinking of not it's coordinates so even if it was moving he would teleport exactly at the place because even though it takes some time to teleport it doesn't take time to appear. ... I confused myself
To add to that excellent point. the smoke we see could be the atomic echo of the time dilation adjusting to phasing jump in and out of the current space time.
Also I thought at one point he said he has to be able to see his location.
Actually that smoke is supposed to be the brimstone dimension leaking out every time he passes through there.
I think he means relative location. From what i get in the episode, Kyle talks about absolute location only.
So are you trying to say that he is basically homing in or the place he wants teleport to (kind of like aiming at a moving target) and then he jumps to where the earth is rotating that location too? Because if you are their is still the problem with the distance he would need to jump in order to have a safe landing.
I know that this video is over 4 years old, but thanks for taking all the fun out of it.😢
I always worried that during teleportation you might end up teleporting in between walls like half of your body in the other way and viceversa or even teleporting inside a concrete ground. You just get spaghettified . Was I the only one ?
2 objects cannot occupy the same space at the same time. Either the stone gives, or you do would. It would also be physically impossible for you to teleport into something. That would be like trying to push your hand into a rock, wont happen. Even if your hand appeared in the rock, well it just couldn't. Possibly the molecules could be crammed together, still killing you, however I doubt it. A Star Trek transporter, for example, could beam you into solid rock because it separates your molecules to move you from one space to another. But a dimensional form of teleportation could not.
ME TO
Nope. Philadelphia experiment comes to mind.
mhakhio kikon if you teleport like they do in the movie jumper you don't have to worry about that. If anything is in the space they teleport to it gets destroyed or pushed out of the way because cannot occupy the same space. Also this guy is making assumptions on things that aren't proven anyways.
Nightcrawler states the very same fear. I don't care if it's possible or not, we're not afraid of possible things only.
One little issue I have with this argument. It seems to be predicated on any point in space having some sort of absolute location. It seems to echo the old ether theory. The Earth is spinning, the Earth is orbiting, the sun is orbiting the galactic core, the galaxy is moving even faster through the universe. But there is no universal space coordinate system. That implies there is some sort of origin point that we can measure everything from. Some fixed center of the universe. As near as we can tell no such point exists. Therefore there's no way to measure "absolute velocity". As Einstein proved, everything is relative.
This is a common mistake. I remember Shad from Shadiversity talking about time travel and suggesting that you would end up somewhere in space if you didn't also space travel. Kyle, I think, said something similar. I'm fairly certain that the only origin point that exists would be a reference point that is stationary relative to you. So if I marked an X on my living room floor and stood on it, it could be said that I am not moving in space. If I disappeared and reappeared a day later on that same X then it could be said that I moved in time but not space. No other coordinate system even makes sense. All locations in space need to be stated relative to some reference point. As you say, there is no absolute coordinate system. In fact, the universe doesn't even have a center. All points in space are the center of the universe. Everything is expanding in all directions.
Terry Prothero can you use the earth as the reference point?
@@destitution25 well yh, but if your not careful kyle's first point may or may not apply
I recommend taking up music.
Scale of C Major
Pattern of C Major
Move pattern of C Major
Compute?
The only concern is what your powers regard as a reference point. Mutant powers like night crawler where all you do is think would likely keep earth as a reference (and no reason to say the brimstone universe doesn't have an earth sized planet in it right? I could be wrong but I didn't think we had much detail about it).
I would assume Tech would more likely not have a frame of reference and might need calculations but not sure. Haven't done any physics since 1st year University.
By the look of scorpion's teleport, he disintegrates and reemrges at a different point in space...so basically he dies everytime and gets reborn!
Kinda he goes to another dimension and then reappears in another area. So its similar to night crawlers only it's a hole and a pop
In mortal kombat he teleports to the nether realm and teleports back to where he came from
I AM A NEW MAN!!!!
All I want to do is teleport from one end to the basketball court to the other.
1.3k flat earthers were triggered in the making of this video.
Let's hope that's all there is
1.5k
1.5k 😂😂😂
Oblique spheroid Earther's were triggered too.
That planet was all kinds of bruised egg jacked up.
Now 200 more F l a t t i e s
Going to "another dimension" does not mean the same as "leaving this reality" . Imagine that he is just traveling through a 4th spacial dimension. This dimension would still be bound by all the same physics that the "normal" 3 spacial dimensions are . He doesnt have to adjust his velocity or account for any of the factors mentioned in the video because that 4th dimension is ON earth just like the rest of us are.
The geometry of that 4th dimension could explain the limitations he describes . so imagine that you were a two dimensional being, there was a line 100 miles long on the ground and you want to get to the other side of it . If we assume you are in the center of that line then the shortest route to get to the other side of the line is 50 miles (or 100 if you actually want to end up directly across the line from where you started . However; if you could utilize the third dimension, then you could step over the line and your total distance traveled is just the width of the line . The longest distance you could travel "instantly" would be limited to how far "up" you could step. Now factor in that the earth is not perfectly spherical and you could imagine that your step length (relative to the ground) might be a different distance east to west than it would be north to south.
I see what you mean but going to another reality does mean leaving this one what you mean is utilizing another reality
Nightcrawler teleports through a hell dimension/reality/parallel world.
Somewhere I heard the dimensions we can't sense were made up as part of what ifs to explain feats that could also be explained by illusionists.
I also have distinct memories that Nightcrawler typically ONLY teleports to places he can physically see, which means he's moving maybe 100ft at most
@@jasonlisonbee Yea I heard that everything we ever think of exists infinitely in a different dimension.
Science Thor is so cool
Yee
Yee
Double Yee
All of these are great points, but miss a very important one, air displacement. If you were instantaneously teleporting from one location to another, you would instantaneously be displaying a human size amount of air, which would not only leave a thunderclap where you left, but a massive shockwave where you arrive.
So, in theory, Dr Strange style Teleportation is the one you want, and the time to establish the portal we see in the movie could be logically explained as anchoring the portal to the relative cosmic location and velocity and other Sciencey calculations. On the other hand, Doctor Strange ties into your comment about secondary powers because he has just All the powers...
because magic -.-
Thank you for letting me keep my childish dream of having teleportation. Science is such a party pooper sometimes! :D I want Dr Strange style teleportation!
Yes, all you need is an anchor point to eliminate the issues.
How to find and plant an anchor point? Well that's another issue. Maybe like Minato from Naruto series, just place a "bookmark" everywhere.
=P
But what about atmospheric pressure differences between the two locations (if they're on different planets)? You could open a portal and be violently sucked in or blasted backwards.
Not certain about other planets, but the portals we see Doctor Strange open start small and gradually Dilate. When the portal is still small you would feel that sucking force and close the portal before the forces become large enough to suck you through into unwanted locations. the big, unforeseeable problem is toxicity of the other atmosphere. Which you couldn't know about before breathing it in, at least, with human perceptions.
magic is science we don't understand
because science :D
why i don't want to teleport??
because science
I think the more effective and useful version of teleportation would be the manipulation of the probability of Quantum Tunneling. If you had this power (Dr. Manhattan I think) you could simply raise the probability that all the particles in your body quantum tunneled to wherever you wanted to go.
I believe that you forgot to mention that not only is our planet moving through our solar system, our solar system is also moving through our galaxy, and our galaxy itself is moving through our universe. I did some of the calculations myself a few years ago to figure out just how deadly obeying the posted speed limits would be. Basically if a person would limit their velocity to 100mph, then everything moving so fast around them would instantly kill them, and they wouldn’t have time to feel the pain.
solar system and galaxy would be the same thing lol
@@justanotherrandomdude8472 it really isn't
@@justanotherrandomdude8472 a solar system is a group of planets that revolve around a sun/star. A galaxy is a large amount of solar systems that revolve around a black hole.
Our galaxy is also both moving and accelerating on its way to a collision with the Andromeda galaxy.
I want every episode of Because Science to have wind machines blowing Kyle's hair
nah it's just people blowing on him
You mean a fan?
lol wind machines are like fans but can make kyle's hair oh so much... blowyer!
Water is tremendously wet. Big water. Ocean water.
Reading this without hearing Trumps voice is really hard.
the JaYoe Nation what about *_FrËŠh_* wÆter?
Water isn't wet
@@kabzel8909 what you've just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
Raef G That quote doesn’t quite work when the dude only said 3 words. Nice try, though.
I am a big fan of the “Jumper” series of books by Stephen Gould. A visually stunning, but otherwise mediocre film with Hayden Christensen was loosely based on the first book. There is no blond Sam Jackson character in the books. The teleportation rules were fairly typical. A jumper can jump anywhere they can see or can remember well enough. It is learned through experimentation that jumpers don't carry momentum through a jump (you can be falling off a tall building and jump to the ground without any momentum) but they do match the local frame and thus don't experience any of the issues Kyle describes. In the last two books it is discovered jumpers can come out of a jump with whatever momentum they want. In the last book, the 17-year-old daughter of the main characters from the first two books starts her own space program.
Are you just guessing what he’s going to talk about or did you watch this on project Alpha first and pasted your comment when the video dropped.
I love how the teleportation create a shockwave in Jumper (the movie, I didn't know it was based on books) even if it is much less powerful than what would probably happen, it is one of the most "accurate" depiction of teleportation.
I want these books
The TH-cam Premius series Impulse is based on the books as well. SERIOUSLY awesome stuff.
I was posting the same info when I saw yours!
What if teleportation comes with the power to stop time itself, that way you pop up where you want to with the earth stationery
Tobirama is confused with his flying raijin jutsu
Yup
What a coincidence, obito is as confused too
Then I guess kamui won’t work then
No! I'm late! Hopefully Kyle will see this. It fixes everything (although a bit convenient).
.
What if Nightcrawler teleports to another dimension with a planet the same size as the Earth, moving at the same speed in the same direction, with the same gravity, and while he is teleporting, the portal remains in the same location in relation to the Earth and the planet in the other dimension?
He does actually!!! (Unless that got RetConned)
I thought about this exact same thing! It does seem extremely lucky for him tho.
Timothy Kurdt yeah, does seem convenient... then again, the infinite multiverse theory says there can be billions of world exactly the same with the difference of two atoms being in different locations at the same time. So maybe it makes a bit more sense...
Yes this is another method for transportation. Entering a duplicate universe traversing it and then re-entering your original universe in your new position (Titanfall 2's phase shift ability works like this) - the time spent in the duplicate could be equal to the original, different, or have no affect allowing for instant teleportation.
And one way could be time stop while you teleport so nothing would have move making it easier to do.
Im now too lazy to even teleport,sounds like too much work
@Omit Chw it means that you cant get a simple joke
@Omit Chw r/whoosh
@@Gaxxor r/Yuuseittho
Yeah I mean.... What if when you teleport somewhere it takes so much energy you much as well have walked there
@@javianbrown8627 it'd basically turn into stopping time momentarily at that point.
I think it would be a fairly same assumption that teleportation is based on where you are relative stuff, so it changes your position relative to the earth or a vehicle, which negates quite a few problems, and you could just go farther and say that it keeps your velocity or whatever you want to call it relative as well, so teleporting to the other side of the earth wouldn’t be a problem at all because you’re not being thrown into space because you’re moving relative to the earth, and you’re not getting ripped apart because you’re moving the same way relative to where you ended up, not relative to where you started, so you’re still moving with the earth
“Let’s assume fiction deals with all of teleportation’s problems”
I wish fiction dealt with all of my problems :’^)
in naruto, i think the teleportation is more acceptable.
since you need the mark to locate where you would end up teleporting, that mark could act as a speed and position references.
But what about obito's teleportation? I seriously want that power 😞. You can just go to anywhere and also can just stay in your dimension and have some fun if you want to. Or just have a first fight with someone without taking a hit!
Surya Chandra And then you go blind because sharingan. And since you're the only person with a sharingan, you can never obtain the eternal mangekyou sharingan.
@@ILNSuryaChandra Obito just sort of goes to the Kamui dimension and then pops back out at the location he wants to be in
@@salem1451 I think neither obito not Kakashi has an eternal one and still they didn't go blind
Salem , kakashi used to show side effects of using kamui, but obito was pretty fine using it all the time, not even close to going blind
You underestimate how powerful the subconscious is at making complex calculations.
Tennis players arent using mathematics to make drop shots lmao they just 'feel it out' when they hit the ball.
If you were born with the ability im sure youd hack it in a lifetime...
FENCE yea right, and now imagine every shot a tennis player miss and hit the net, it is you hitting a concrete wall at hundreds of mp/h...
@@ArgStyleRlz lol his example was bad but he's not wrong.
Humans and animals do alot of smart things without thinking even walking and standing requires you to balance the weight of your body so if your in a world where you have super powers it's not unreasonable to think you will adapt to compensate for it
@Eudura but even with your example of Walking, the argumentstill holds true.
It takes humans a year to walk (ok animals take less time but on 4 or more legs walking is significantly easier than on 2) and Teleportation would probably be harder still. And every time they (which is a lot) would be equivalent to a failed Teleportation, and certain death.
@@safrussalmus9056 the point was we can do it without thinking about it and if you had powers why wouldn't your body naturally become adjusted to it sense it's now part of your own nature.
Birds learn to fly with a low death rate on it
@@safrussalmus9056 it's the same... you could start teleporting yourself short distaces, couple of meters, then a few miles, then as far as your sight can reach and after some years of that, lets imagine you could feel the speed forces and a 3-dimensional geoposition at differnt spots of earth. And all of this is just sci-fi, so yeah, i'd like to be in another country just like that and enjoy life. I recommend you to watch the movie "Jumper"
I've always personally been of the opinion that you don't want teleportation, you want anchored portals.
Naruto's Flying Raijin jutsu has to be the most scientifically accurate teleportation in fiction. It uses markers which you instantly teleport to so you are always locked accurately to the Earth and as Minato demonstrated, you are constantly moving at the same speed in and out of the space time barrier so you appear with no adverse side effects
I think the Jumper series does a good job of explaining these problems. In the second book the main character, David, who can teleport, experiments with his powers. They find that he is folding space-time, not like a wormhole but he over laps to places in space and time so he is standing in two places at once for a couple milliseconds. In doing this he matches frames of reference, so he can teleport from a "stationary" place to like a plane, and be standing still on the plane. Later he and his daughter are able to change their velocity consciously when they teleport. So they can teleport in place but increase their velocity upward and launch themselves into the sky along with other applications. He teleports by visualizing the place he wants to go and has to have been there before. I think its not like space-time coordinates but position in relation to other things. Later his daughter is able to teleport based on gps and altitude coordinates. The main problems they face is that when they teleport from one altitude to another they have a sudden altitude change so ear popping and stuff, and in more extreme cases David teleports to altitudes in between to adjust to the new pressure before moving on to his next destination.
Jarrett Spurlock
This was the first thing I thought of when I watched this video. Glad I’m not the only one to appreciate all the details the author put into making this power work. I’d also like to add, in the movie when David jumps, there is a shockwave that pushes matter out of his way. He created a crater in the bank vault when he is inexperienced and doesn’t have the ‘landing site’ quite right, and in the hospital when he jumps while distracted. Griffin used uses multiple jumps to reinforce the shockwave as a weapon. This shockwave would prevent a jumper from getting stuck inside a wall or rock at the landing site.
When David or Griffin is calm and jumps precisely then the air from the landing site precisely replaces the vacuum from the departure site so there is no BOOM or shockwave.
Lastly because space is warped around him he is able to bring his immediate surroundings with him. When he learn to ‘twin’ he can hold the space warp open and high pressure air, water, and other atmospheric particles travel thru the warp.
Griffin seams to be able to bring things traveling at the same speeds as him (cars) thru the warp. If it can be lifted or move under its own power thru the warp it’s ‘jumpable’.
I should read this series
I thought of the movie during this video, it seems well thought out for a super power
The problem I see with this is that when you stand in two places at once you cannot close the jump frame because the particles that make up your bory would be ripped appart.
@@timwatz2948 No its not really like standing in 2 places at once, its actually making the two places the same place. So your standing in place A then space time over laps and your standing in place AB, which is one place but an outside observer would see two of you, then spacetime unfolds and now you are in place B.
I watch these not because i understand anything, just so i feel smart.
ElectricHamster same
I watched a dude eat 8 or 9 meals in 14 hours!!!!! It did something.
Maybe it’s like the way birds know to fly south for the winter or why some animals know how to hunt, it’s all instincts and you just do what you do.
In the Dragonriders of Pern series, the dragons use a dimension they call "Between" where there is literally nothing. Dragons could enter and leave Between at any time, space, velocity, and acceleration, done entirely by instinct, while the Humans have to think about each of these, then relay them to the Dragons. Also, it is well known, and common enough, that badly done jumps would end with a Dragon in some object and die, like stone walls and cliffs, which is why all jumps are done in the air.
As for the popping sound, Harry Potter's Apparation is known to have that affect when used.
I love that you used Dragonriders of Pern as a reference. Kudos.
Kudos again to the reference 👍 and that popping sound is rapid air displacement. A subtle but realistic touch that I like.
Decently complicated Space Time coordinate calculations = Is Water Wet
Yes!!!!
No. Because in order for something to be wet, it has to have a dry state. Water cannot by dry. Just as when you are submerged, you are not wet. However, once you come out of the water, you will be.
@@Iliadic you fuckin dare to make me use my brain
if Nightcrawler is jumping into an extra dimension, then this video I feel is very wrong. People think of "extra dimension" as "another universe", but in reality, it would be far simpler, and far safer. Kyle I'm sure is familiar with the concept of Flat Land, where a 3D object appears 2D, but moving through the 2D plane makes it appear as though a 2D circle is appearing and disappearing from existence. That 3D object could intersect the 2D plane and stay in it, but moving along the Z axis would appear as though it's disappearing/reappearing. The same would happen with a 4D object moving through the 3D plane. Moving a 4D sphere along the W axis (not XYZ) would appear as though a 3D sphere suddenly popped into, then out of existence. Nightcrawler is simply moving along the W axis. Because he's still on earth (albeit a 4D earth), he would maintain any relative velocities he carried both into and out of each dimension.
Still, loved the video, and I admit this is still a better fate than being disassembled atom-by-atom and reconstructed on the other side (teleportation technology)
Exactly, this is what I think when someone talk about teleportation on sci-fi
Yeah, I hoped he would mention this :(
I think it is important that you say that you mean the 4th dimension of space. The normal 4th dimension is ofc. Time ;)
Sheldon: Here's the problem with teleportation.
Leonard: Lay it on me.
Sheldon: Assuming a device could be invented, which would identify the quantum state of matter of an individual in one location and transmit that pattern to a distant location for reassembly. You would not have actually transported the individual, you would have destroyed him in one location and recreated him in another.
Leonard: How about that.
Sheldon: Personally, I would never use a transporter because the original Sheldon would have to be dissintegrated in order to create a new Sheldon.
Leonard: Would the new Sheldon be in any way an improvement on the old Sheldon?
Sheldon: No, he would be exactly the same.
Leonard: That is a problem.
U remind me of Thor. And you definitely milked the thought when u pulled out the hammer.
He pulls out Mjolnir on the regular exactly because people are always telling him he reminds them of Thor, haha!
I was watching that exact part when i read your comment lmao
So what ur saying is, earth is just a big minecraft server, and that nightcrawler disconnects and reconnects to teleport
More like he just gets to the nether, travel, and reemerges 8 or a million times further than he actually walked
He uses a mine cart track in the nether OBVIOUSLY.
nightcrawler unplugs the LAN cable
“It takes the earth a full day to do one revolution”
Crazy
BULLSHIT IT DOESN'T FUCKIN MOVE
@@atsuiwong Man, you're so smort.
If the earth is moving by itself does that mean that The Earth is alive?
@@eattheboard1684 Man, that's some Greek mythology thinking.
@@bucket4255 lol
I just now thought of the fact that Generation 4's My Little Pony's way of teleportation could takes care of a lot of these points. If you've watched the show then you'll see that anypony (by that I mean unicorn or Alicorn) who can teleport usually does so with a magic bubble surrounding them before and after they have teleported to their destination. When ever a pony teleports, they do so with a lightning sound effect which could be the rapid displacent of air molicules that would be in the same place that the pony would teleport to. Then there's some other more magical elements that would do things like stopping them from bumping into another living creature or a wall, and stuff like that. But still, eventhough it was probably unintentional, I think that it's nice to spot some similarities in how telortation is explained here, and how it is shown in mlp.
Hey Nightcrawler, I have a solution for you: don't let Kyle Hill pick your frames of reference.