I so appreciate that you continue to do in-depth reviews of palettes and collections, with swatches, comparisons and looks! This is becoming increasingly rare these days! Thank you!
I appreciate how beautiful this palette is, and I am contemplating making it my first Lethal purchase. That being said, the fact that the two previous palettes could nearly dupe this one is wild!
If you have ever watched “The discovery of witches” TV series about the book series, you would know exactly where the cover palette tree is from. It’s like the tree of life that created all the creatures. It looks just like that with the shining beams coming from it
My first thought when I saw this palette was "is this a re-release?" It looks so similar to Midnight Serenade imo and it's pretty much all my favorite shades but that just means I have them several times over
Very pretty. I love the colors and the button closure and that it has a mirror and that's it's magnetic. Beautiful eye look, not a fan of anything else.✔️💯👍🦃🎀❗
This palette is beautiful! It’s got the tones I love and that look great on me and compliment my green eyes! I think I like this palette better than Midnight Serenade mostly because of the theming and packaging, which makes it extra special for me. I’m excited to try a couple of those multichrome liners because I like the pastel-ish quality they have.
Midnight Serenade is one of my all time favourite eye shadow palettes and as soon as I saw Spellcraft, I couldn't believe how similar the vibe was. I love the packaging of Spellcraft, it looks gorgeous, but it just looks too similar to Midnight Serenade for me to justify buying it. I'm bummed because I adore the Lethal formula and was so excited for a new drop! Maybe if it goes on sale later...
I love the packaging and the palette. It’s very beautiful I’m not convinced it’s versatile enough for me. The shimmers seem very new and different. ❤ Thank you for sharing your thoughts
I love Lethal's colourful mascaras and I've been hoping for a dark red, so I will definitely get that one. I have some single eyeshadows from the brand and some are truly outstanding, some are just not what I expected from the way they were presented online. Which is not so much a quality issue as an expectation issue. I would really like to get a full palette so I can try different formulas, but I just cannot make up my mind which one 😩 the most special and unique shade I have from the brand is Singularity
Your commentary on the mattes is why I felt like I don’t need this palette because I have Midnight Serenade. So I would just really be looking at how much these shimmers are worth to my collection and those are cute but it’s not adding anything new to my collection. So although I adore this palette, I feel like I already have it
I just had to leave a comment to let you know that I of course appreciate your amazing reviews always- it’s obvious how much work you put into every video you post however, your end bloopers and random chit chats are my jam!!! It’s not uncommon for me to bust out laughing like a hyena at your antics and funny behavior or sometimes I want to reach through the screen to receive one of your loving hugs!! But most of all I needed to tell you that I LOVE YOUR FACE!!!!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤ I so appreciate watching your videos! Thank you!!!
I have similar feelings about this palette, wished it was a bit more cooltoned or at least few shades in different direction than here, I think it is too warmy pinky for what I would imagine and somehow looks very monochromatic ,but I love the dark shades in it. Also changed my mind on getting the blue eyeliner that I was so excited about and I think I will finally buy the silver one from Kaleidos instead.
So pretty and I’m drawn to all 3 of the palettes but didn’t purchase the last two. The Dollhouse has been on my wishlist for the longest time so I appreciate the comparison. Did I hear you say the Spellcraft palette is not magnetic (the pans)? That is one thing that has always put Lethal above other brands for me - being able to customize my palettes makes them more valuable to me. ❤
Even though I have many palettes that are similar to this color story, I really love it; but I will only pick up the palette, not the liners or the black lip lacquer. It looks good on you, even though I can’t see you or me wearing it off camera!
Hmmmmm not sure about this. It’s almost like Lethal said ‘ hey, we’ve got this super cool packaging guys, what do we put in it?’ Then pulled some already existing shades and made a collection. This feels a bit like something ColourPop would do (and has done about a trillion times). Are the shadows good quality? Yes. Is the collection attractive? Also yes. But do we ‘need’ it? Probably not.
when I saw your unboxing short, my 1st thought was why so much pink/red? on the same page there, w/out even comparing to other palettes. since they have a pretty large selection of colored mascaras, I get that they're trying to find unique colors, but other than the blue, I imagine the other 2 would look sickly on me. they don't have swatches of them up, so maybe I'll be surprised
I need a rec, Amanda can you help? Or anyone 😅I'm looking for a creme eyeshadow or shadow stick that's a cool matte brown, for everyday that i can be done with in 30 seconds, just swipe and blend with my fingers. But I am not finding anything cool toned 😭
Half of that palette screams Huda to me, it's absolutely gorgeous!! I love it, but I don't like the name, so I hope they come out with more of the book packaging, without the spell craft name. Still a gorgeous color story 💙💙
I so appreciate that you continue to do in-depth reviews of palettes and collections, with swatches, comparisons and looks! This is becoming increasingly rare these days! Thank you!
Thank for this comment. I think exactly the same.
I agree!
Well said!
Agreed 💯 I appreciate her time and effort
Wow that black lippie looks so good on you!!!
I appreciate how beautiful this palette is, and I am contemplating making it my first Lethal purchase. That being said, the fact that the two previous palettes could nearly dupe this one is wild!
If you have ever watched “The discovery of witches” TV series about the book series, you would know exactly where the cover palette tree is from. It’s like the tree of life that created all the creatures. It looks just like that with the shining beams coming from it
I don’t have any Lethal so this would be the perfect first palette for me ❤
I love Lethal"s eyeshadow formula and they do rosy tones so well 😍
My first thought when I saw this palette was "is this a re-release?" It looks so similar to Midnight Serenade imo and it's pretty much all my favorite shades but that just means I have them several times over
I had those thoughts, too. At first, I wanted it, but the more I looked at it, the less I wanted it.
Very pretty. I love the colors and the button closure and that it has a mirror and that's it's magnetic. Beautiful eye look, not a fan of anything else.✔️💯👍🦃🎀❗
This palette is beautiful! It’s got the tones I love and that look great on me and compliment my green eyes! I think I like this palette better than Midnight Serenade mostly because of the theming and packaging, which makes it extra special for me. I’m excited to try a couple of those multichrome liners because I like the pastel-ish quality they have.
Yes! I've been waiting to see your swatches and comparisons!
Midnight Serenade is one of my all time favourite eye shadow palettes and as soon as I saw Spellcraft, I couldn't believe how similar the vibe was. I love the packaging of Spellcraft, it looks gorgeous, but it just looks too similar to Midnight Serenade for me to justify buying it. I'm bummed because I adore the Lethal formula and was so excited for a new drop! Maybe if it goes on sale later...
I love the packaging and the palette. It’s very beautiful I’m not convinced it’s versatile enough for me. The shimmers seem very new and different. ❤ Thank you for sharing your thoughts
I'm so drawn to this color story and agree that it's similar to their other palettes. I'm going to hold off for now.
Your comparisons are always so helpful! 😊
Awesome review. This may be my first Lethal palette!
Have all the comparisons palettes so going to give this amiss but beautiful look x
Love your face, Amanda!! 💜
I love Lethal's colourful mascaras and I've been hoping for a dark red, so I will definitely get that one.
I have some single eyeshadows from the brand and some are truly outstanding, some are just not what I expected from the way they were presented online. Which is not so much a quality issue as an expectation issue.
I would really like to get a full palette so I can try different formulas, but I just cannot make up my mind which one 😩 the most special and unique shade I have from the brand is Singularity
Your commentary on the mattes is why I felt like I don’t need this palette because I have Midnight Serenade. So I would just really be looking at how much these shimmers are worth to my collection and those are cute but it’s not adding anything new to my collection. So although I adore this palette, I feel like I already have it
Oh my this whole collection is amazing 🤩 I think this one is going to be my holiday gift this year lol 😆 I’m obsessed with the palette!!
I just had to leave a comment to let you know that I of course appreciate your amazing reviews always- it’s obvious how much work you put into every video you post however, your end bloopers and random chit chats are my jam!!! It’s not uncommon for me to bust out laughing like a hyena at your antics and funny behavior or sometimes I want to reach through the screen to receive one of your loving hugs!! But most of all I needed to tell you that I LOVE YOUR FACE!!!!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤ I so appreciate watching your videos! Thank you!!!
I have similar feelings about this palette, wished it was a bit more cooltoned or at least few shades in different direction than here, I think it is too warmy pinky for what I would imagine and somehow looks very monochromatic ,but I love the dark shades in it. Also changed my mind on getting the blue eyeliner that I was so excited about and I think I will finally buy the silver one from Kaleidos instead.
So pretty and I’m drawn to all 3 of the palettes but didn’t purchase the last two. The Dollhouse has been on my wishlist for the longest time so I appreciate the comparison. Did I hear you say the Spellcraft palette is not magnetic (the pans)? That is one thing that has always put Lethal above other brands for me - being able to customize my palettes makes them more valuable to me. ❤
Even though I have many palettes that are similar to this color story, I really love it; but I will only pick up the palette, not the liners or the black lip lacquer. It looks good on you, even though I can’t see you or me wearing it off camera!
Hmmmmm not sure about this. It’s almost like Lethal said ‘ hey, we’ve got this super cool packaging guys, what do we put in it?’ Then pulled some already existing shades and made a collection. This feels a bit like something ColourPop would do (and has done about a trillion times). Are the shadows good quality? Yes. Is the collection attractive? Also yes. But do we ‘need’ it? Probably not.
The purple is beautiful💜. Although I get that the black lip isn’t your look, it does look pretty on your lips.
when I saw your unboxing short, my 1st thought was why so much pink/red? on the same page there, w/out even comparing to other palettes. since they have a pretty large selection of colored mascaras, I get that they're trying to find unique colors, but other than the blue, I imagine the other 2 would look sickly on me. they don't have swatches of them up, so maybe I'll be surprised
Purple is your colour
How does it compare to the CB Gothic palette?
Also, is the lipstick transfer proof?
I need a rec, Amanda can you help? Or anyone 😅I'm looking for a creme eyeshadow or shadow stick that's a cool matte brown, for everyday that i can be done with in 30 seconds, just swipe and blend with my fingers. But I am not finding anything cool toned 😭
Did the black lipstick feeling dry/drying on your lips?? What is the transfer like?
Multichrome liners… uh hem cough cough, colourpop does it betta! Hahahahhaha
This is nice, but I am on a low buy.
❤
Half of that palette screams Huda to me, it's absolutely gorgeous!! I love it, but I don't like the name, so I hope they come out with more of the book packaging, without the spell craft name. Still a gorgeous color story 💙💙
Im with you about loving the book packaging!! Out of curiosity, why don’t you like the name?