She's been in the media since she first gave birth proving it was always more about virtue signalling than (even in her twisted mind) raising her child as best she can. Her preteen daughter is "non binary" now as well. It's scary that she's experimenting using these children as petrie dish projects.
I would pose this question to these people. There are many medical treatments and drugs that base their applications and dosages on the sex of the patient. If you had a life threatening disease, and needed one of those treatments or drugs, what would you check off on your examination papers?
It is very telling that Matt Walsh who got virtually zero support from the audience (I think I heard one person start clapping after he made a point but immediately stopped) is the one who is saying Dr. Phil and his staff were very fair, and the other side who had so much support (clapping after everything they said) are saying how triggering the show was, and how they were made to look bad
There was one time his side a group of people clapped, but... that was for the man beside Matt Walsh, sadly. Matt Walsh himself didn't get any ovation from the audience (i could be wrong about Matt Walsh getting someone to clap for him after making a good point, unless you give me a timeline at a certain part of the episode :o)
Those people live their lives off victimhood. So even if everyone on earth clapped for them , they'd still have to lie and pretend they were mocked and humiliated, so they could perpetuate their victim narrative.
Because someone pointing out facts and reality makes them look bad. They are so used to living in their insanity bubble that hearing truth is harmful to their fragile self.
Matt walsh has no expertise in mental health and has no educational background in it either so why would the audience support him? He's just some guy with an opinion...
it's actual insanity. the bearded lady that was on the show with Matt said that he was traumatized and is having panic attacks and nightmares because of Matt. these are not sane people. they're actually crazy and manipulative.
@@adiracquetball oh well in that case, I can't tell you that "your truth" is any different from THE truth. I'd be a bigot if I did that, apparently lol :p.
@@famvids9627 No, in fact he was steel manning their argument. Those trans advocates were saying sex and gender must not be conflated. So, when Matt hears this one person mention their newborn's sex was unlisted because the kid doesn't know their gender, that parent conflated the two concepts as one. It might seem like a gotcha moment to you, but Matt was taking their strongest argument and flipped it over with ease.
@@thejuniorseas7683 no he wasn't steelmanning their argument... the government form conflate gender and sex together so they were simply doing their best given the limitations of the form as so many people do with a variety of government forms and he was trying to use the limitations of the governments form against them in a "gotcha moment". It's not like they wrote the government form... no they didn't but his question presupposes that they agreed with the government conflating both in their form that has virtually been unchanged for over a half a century.
@@famvids9627 A birth certificate doesn't say gender, it says sex. As in the biological sex of the child. If the child was born with male genitalia, the form should read "male". Again, the parent is conflating the two, not government that you so believe.
There are specific reason why government forms ask for the sex of an individual for identification purposes (reduces possibility of mixing up babies in the hospital by 50% for instance) and medical treatments which requires knowledge of how a patient will respond to treatment due to the differing responses of the cellular mechanisms and chemistry which are inherently different between the two sexes. This is not opinion, it is biological reality based on genetics and molecular biology. Gender stems from this biological reality unless there are underlying psychological issues driving it. Anyone of age who chooses any gender which does not match their biological sex is welcome to do so, but must also be capable of recognizing the lifetime of medical debt and psychological confusion that accompanies that choice. They should also recognize no one else should be coerced to enable such a choice by contorting their language, or allowing them to use restrooms and dressing rooms that don’t match their birth sex and thereby make others using that room uncomfortable or put themselves at physical risk. Neither should they be allowed to use their birth sex for advantage in sporting events by pretending they are a different sex than they were born. Parents should not be permitted to give medical permission for their child to be given surgery or hormones for the purpose of changing their sex prior to them turning 18 years old, at which point the child can make their own decisions. This should hold except for the approximately one in 10,000 people who actually have genetic abnormalities in their sex chromosomes which cause physical problems that need to be medically addressed after proper genetic diagnosis. Teachers should not address this issue at all with any child in their care.
Imagine people trying to "break societal norms" and "social constructs" by painting their faces and wearing bras... brandishing the very "societal norms" they're attempting to destroy.... 🤡🌎
@Rob Hodge who is trying to destroy bras? 😂 Many women need bras for comfort. I have large breasts, I need bras for comfort, especially when being active. Being comfortable is not antifeminist. If you were a woman, you'd understand that.
@@SM-so8hh trans activists. They rely on typical stereotypes to present themselves as male/female which goes against breaking societal norms lol ironic really.
@@famvids9627 Their definition is nonsensical. You can't define something by "whatever you feel it is". That is not a definition. Women are humans with XX chromosomes. Aka females. They get pregnant, give birth and breastfeed. Humans are mammals. It's basic biology.
@@EaglePicking also, when they make the argument that saying women give birth isn't valid because SOME women can't, refer to the fact that we don't base definitions based on the minorities. That is not to say someone who can't give birth isn't a woman, but the definition of what a woman is doesn't change because GENERALLY and in most cases, they can. Additionally, women are women down to their DNA and bone regardless of ability to give birth. Men who feel like and identify as women can't be that
@@EaglePicking this person on Dr. Phil isn't the best representation of the transgender phenomenon and doesn't speak for all transgender people. However you are all using it as your strawman and acting like matt walsh is somehow an expert in the field when he has zero education in anything mental health related and knows nothing about the research.
+Calee Tholen Gosh, that's powerful and inspirational. So how do the flocks and flocks and flocks of right wing rage cultists factor in this whole standing alone thing?
This line of reasoning could be an excuse for the rest of us to be passive, and I'm not going to let myself off the hook in that respect -- should any of us?
The question "why do you care?" Itself is stupid and makes no sense, they are the ones who forced people to participate in their stupid pronouns game. Anyone who doesn't care about their pronouns will be labeled bigot and misgendering.
@@Chromwel-A It's a deflection tactic. They fully expect everyone to fall in line behind their Godless ideology or to remain silent in fear and shame. If someone does start standing up against them and making good points here like Matt Walsh did, then instead of defending their indefensible and nonsensical position as they know they have no ground to stand on, they just deflect and rebut sound points with "Why do you care so much? It's not a big deal." It frames their opposition as the aggressor. It's a classic tactic of crying out in pain at you while they strike you.
@Scott Scotty If you want people on the internet to take you seriously and not just presume you to be a worthless troll, I'd highly recommend a better username than "Scott Scotty." Doesn't have to be your real name, even. But just know that with such a ridiculous and lazy name that you're presenting yourself as someone that reasonable people will not be predisposed to taking seriously. Now if by some off-chance you intend on having something approaching a reasonable discourse, which I highly doubt as you can't even be bothered to capitalize God let alone singularize Him, I AM staying with reality. It's those who think that gender is fluid and completely dependent upon the will of an individual subject who are outright refusing to live within reality. God created us male and female in His own image and likeness. He also gave us reason and rationality, something that the gender activists have spit upon with their perfidious and disgusting ideology.
Doctor Phil has no problem telling a lying drug addict that they are sick and need To change. However, he sits their like a bump on a log with this nonsense. Very disappointing but not at all surprised.
Yes i actually feel sorry for him (and for us all) because people who believe the gender oppression cause have by definition to be vocal and to participate in the sj war. This means he thinks like us sane people but needs to please the pc police to stay afloat. Really sad.
@@daisyviluck7932 Ding Ding Ding! Precisely. Who said it that you can figure out who rules over you by knowing who you’re not allowed to criticize? I have zero sympathy for people like this. They’re not poor little innocent victims. They’re activists with a political agenda and angle. They’re liars who take advantage of the confusion of the innocent in order to ram their anti-truth agenda down our throats. They use the full power of cancel culture to coerce and force others to deny objective, observable, plain, and obvious reality and play along with their fantasy as though it’s true. Classic propaganda and subversion tactic to get people to deny reality. To quote Captain Picard from Star Trek: “There are Four lights!”
Nobody really defines this clearly... Even Thomas Aquinas said that women were half finished or incomplete men.... Does that mean that we dismiss everything he ever said about women or men or man?
@@famvids9627 I’ll define it right now, men have xy chromosomes, women have xx. A dna test can easily determine which of the two you are. Your arbitrary sexual preferences have nothing to do with your chromosomes. Fetishism is a spectrum, chromosomes are not.
@@tyc6268 your definition is incorrect. People do not just have xx or yx chromosomes. There are over 140 million people in the world who are intersex and express themselves as either men or women. There are women who were born with some male characteristics according to their chromosomal makeup who express themselves as women. Obviously you didn't take a basic biology course but yet you are the person, the gate keeper, who is in charge of defining who is and who isn't a woman. Thank God our fate doesn't rest in your hands and you are not the person who makes that final determination. There was a time when your definition was used and intersex people were forced into expressing themselves according to some arbitrary definition that people such as yourself determined. This resulted in millions of forced surgeries of intersex people, forcing them at birth into some arbitrary gender that people like you decided based upon what you thought they most closely aligned with... the suffering was immense. Now, society is more compassionate and informed. We no longer force people into a gender but allow the person to make this decision for themselves. I would rather people have the freedom to choose rather than being compelled to fit some sort of arbitrary ideal that you have decided.
@@famvids9627 I’m not talking about the details of their genitals or their arbitrary sexual orientation, I’m talking about their chromosomes. Sometimes people are born with deformed reproductive organs, they still only either produce eggs or sperm. There’s never been a human that produces both. Obviously you don’t know the difference between objective truth and public consensus. Maybe you should’ve taken a basic biology course. Was that whole paragraph just you showing that you can’t tell the difference between sex and gender again? Gender is arbitrary and based on personal whim. Sex on the other hand has everything to do with the organ and chromosomes you were born with (deformed or not). I would rather people have the freedom to choose too but you don’t have the right to choose to be ignorant and also choose to push that ignorance on me. What you choose to do with your body will never change your chromosomes. That is a scientific fact.
I remember Ben ( if you don't know which Ben, then I'm sorry ) asking a person about what gender people identify as. He asked her what age she was. I believe the answer was in her 20's. Then he asked her why isn't she 60-something? She looked confused until Ben clarified if she can choose her gender, which is 99% of the time an absolute, why can't she choose her age as well? It was priceless.
Matt is my hero. Literally says everything I’ve been saying the past couple year just in a simple, better way than I could ever say it. Ahhh I hope to meet him or hear him speak in person one day 🤞🤞🤞
You should search him on TH-cam and watch his dating advice clips. Also the ones where he addresses Reddit questions on "Am I the Ahole?" Hilarious at it gets.
Matt Walsh is awesome! I just discovered him about a month ago on his TH-cam channel. Very smart guy that says what a lot of people are afraid to say nowadays.
@@michelegray5970 I just learned about Matt Walsh watching this video. I watched his other videos and I have to say he has this very dry sense of humor which doesn’t work for a lot of people but it works extremely well for him
@@NickCADA why specifically Is it because you believe god is real? In witch case you don’t have to be straight you just can be in a intimate relationship with another male.
I'm angry at Dr. Phil, and feel strongly he sold out, allowing more time and speakers for gender benders, giving them the last word towards the end of the show. Dr. Phil usually will call a spade a spade, obviously held back his opinions that the gender benders were delusional, which he has to know as a licensed clinical psychologist. Now some will say he held back to referee the discussion, but towards the end Dr. Phil made a short summary that social construction of gender will continue to cause debate---A hint that gender benders will continue to come on his show in the future to attract ratings. He all but gave his tacit approval of the behavior to protect his wallet and appease his Woke Hollywood masters.
He does call a spade of spade... It's just that he understands the research and how complicated this situation is. For people like yourself that don't understand the research at all it's easy to oversimplify it because you do over simplify it because you don't understand the full perspective active and you don't understand the research. Being that you're a non scientist what you even consider research is probably not research.
@@famvids9627 I don't need to be a scientist to read studies by scientists who determined transgenders suffer from mental disporara, afflicted with depression, substance abuse, and high risk to commit suicide. So you can cease with your condescending attitude treating me as being ignorant. Transgenders need compassionate help, but no one should be held hostage to accept their delusions by playing up to their expectations to be treated as a man or woman when they are not. Dr. Phil knows better, but won't say so.
He’s not in charge. It’s his team and producer. He signed a contract. He’s a red hot republican and had tomi Lahren on to give a message to men to grow up and stop being soy boys. Like….. I feel bad for Dr Phil honestly because he’s in a contract and can’t really change it. So yes, In a way he sold out
Ah yes the parent of a 4 year old who has been denied the dignity of having their biological sex isn't going to dignify "ridiculous" questions with an answer. They have it together so well and are so confident of the position they've taken that they have to completely change the subject and refuse to address any discussion of their child's gender when asked. They're also hoping for their four year old to "finally decide" their gender. I mean is this for real? This child abuser should be in jail as a sex offender.
Yes! You are aware that parents are not just allowing but praising their “Trans” children, you know, anywhere from 4-8 years old, for claiming gender dysphoria and wanting to start taking certain drugs that inhibit the normal processes of development in order to prepare them to become the opposite sex. These drugs are very harmful and will screw up their bodies for life. This is very real and it’s all over the place. We all need to take a stand against this demonic movement before it’s too late.
I am a man, married to a woman and have 2 daughters. My wife and daughters are "Real" women. They have all the natural parts that a woman has. There is no way that these people could be classed as a "woman".
Brilliant debate matt, that simple question and the mental gymnastics they had to perform to avoid them and they still failed, like watching the verbal equivalent of Bruce Lee.
@@potatojoe3050 the sentance "watching the verbal equivalent of Bruce Lee" follows a description of the "transgender" guys, thus, Bruce Lee is being linked to the "transgender" guys, and not Matt. so my comment refers to the "transgender" guys and not Matt
They took down the clip from Dr. Phil’s TH-cam channel. The comments were overwhelmingly in Matt’s favor, so they took it down. Even when everything was stacked against him, he still came out on top.
This all feels like a frog in a pot of boiling water. First they said, “Of course sex and gender are different. Sex is biological.” Now, they are blurring the lines between the two, saying that sex should be listed as “unknown” until the child makes a choice. And the children can change their minds as many times as they want anyway. Addison kept saying that this topic is so complex and confusing. I don’t think it’s confusing. It’s not consistent.
It really is inconsistent. But keep in mind that if Gender Identity Politics did not make claims like "Gender is a social construct" and bring social issues into play, and instead stuck to basic biology, they would not be able to push this agenda. Their goal, ultimately, is to redesign our society, which they reaslize is something they can do. What they cannot do is redesign basic biology.
He's been destroying it for so many years that he's got some very sensible and simple AND short answers that are impossible to cut out otherwise they would edit him out completely and erase themselves ... LOL.
@@highwayxj9397 It's very disappointing when people with true FU money are afraid of saying FU. I get it, if you are basically a couple pay checks from being homeless, that's a big deterrent but MILLIONAIRES. You should not be be afraid.
@@Future_Imperfect I agree with you. It just sucks having decades of being sensational and then going out being “cancelled” However I’m confident cancel culture will be fought against. We just need more millionaires to fight back as well as everyone else
That classifies as child abuse to me. I just would've assumed Matt would've been prepared for that and had it set up an agreed upon that he could bring in some of his people to record if they wanted to use him on their show. Not only for the rights to post that himself but for protection too.
Matt brought up a really good point right at the end of this clip - they bounce between gender and sex in an attempt to confuse the topic, there is no consistence and it literally changes depending on who you are talking to because one will say gender is fluid while the other says sex yet they are talking about the same thing. But then they will be the first to say " you are confusing A with B" or " I am taking about A, not B" to try and prove you wrong. When they use that double-talk and constantly change terms, it is them trying to rig the fight so anytime you counter what they say, they can say you are not talking about the right thing.
Exactly. A very important rhetorical tool is to recognize whether you’re talking to an honest person or not. Not everyone or every interaction is all about open discourse and discussion and debate. Many are only interested in manipulating others.
Sex and gender have always been references to different things. The only thing that’s changed is how the term “gender” is used in a Sociological context. But it has never been entirely synonymous with sex grammatically. Practically everyone acknowledges sex as biological and set in stone, so Conservatives like Walsh aren’t making any slam dunks when they act like their opponents don’t admit even that. Secondly, defining a gender (reflected in Addison’s reluctance to do so) is like trying to make a single definition for a concept as abstract as Justice or Knowledge. People who have been commenting on this debate from the Right-wing position typically saw this as a weakness on their part, except it was actually a very consistent response, because they weren’t going to capitulate to Matt’s absurd and easily contestable definition, and precisely because they were not going to reduce a gender identity into nothing more than mere stereotypes.
@@ManoverSuperman *"Sex and gender have always been references to different things."* That's flat-out false. Sex is a biological reality, and gender has _always_ been the _conceptual equivalent_ of that reality. 'Masculine' is derived from 'male' and 'feminine' is derived from 'female'. You have no legitimate evidence whatever to the contrary. What you _do_ have is a desire to _believe_ the contrary combined with a lack of honesty, which allows you to dispense with reality in order to maintain your beliefs, rather than vice versa.
@@ManoverSuperman Justice, knowledge and gender are concepts that we can define and we know what they mean. Gender is fluid, there is a spectrum with femininity on one end and masculinity on the other, but that is still connected to biological sex. Trans activists want to completely sever gender from sex so that it can mean anything to anyone. For instance, a biological man identifies as a woman but can't define what a woman is. So what does he mean when he calls himself a "woman" then? Is the rest of society supposed to play along with this silly game? We all know that a woman is an adult human female, i.e. a human with XX chromosomes.
@@famvids9627 I've seen your replies on numerous comments in this video. If anyone is ideologically driven in their rationale, it's you. You reject readily observable scientific evidence like sex characteristics, in favor of emotions and subjective perception determining whether a man is a man or a woman. How can someone possess so tenuous a grasp on the world they live in? It's honestly pitiable.
I have a lot of respect for a man that stands for something than a man that falls for anything.. people are cowards nowadays.its all about pleasing society. Much respect to you Matt
This situation shows conservative values are getting some traction in the culture war. From Matt Walsh getting an invite to Dr Phil, to the actual airing the show (instead of shelving it like they did Blair Whites interview) to the way clips from the debate were shared all over social media, I feel hope for our society ❤️
This was actually my point, literally at the start of the debate: you Don't use your pronouns. PEOPLE use your pronouns, to describe you. If i see this Addison Rose is a man, he cannot compell me to lie and say he's a woman, much less a hybrid which I Don't See (because it's not there). Also i want to see a non binary person who didn't hear of the existence of this condition from someone else. I want to see a boy, happy, healthy and satisfied with their life throw away their health and social condition to be regarded as a zoo animal. Narcissists.
Bingo. It’s long past time to call out this crap for what it is. I heard Carl Benjamin put it well recently. He said how starting off an interaction by listing pronouns is an act of wielding power over another as though to say: “You will address me in the manner in which I approve. I set the terms here.” It’s akin to how a nobleman of old would make the lowly plebs tip their cap to him as he passed by and refer to him as “my liege” or “my lord” etc. It’s a way of establishing rank. Also, it’s basically says that your faculty of reason, your ability to make observations and assessments of the world around you is either faulty or is not allowed. I will inform you of what your senses are incapable. And, I will also intentionally over share about my personal life and if that makes you uncomfortable, that’s your problem and you have to just deal with it because, again, I set the terms here and you just have to conform to them.
@@jefffinkbonner9551 Excellent observation. It very well is an attempt to diminish our reason. This diminishes our humanity which includes our likeness to God, their ultimate goal. They want us to become like them: "They exchanged their Glory for an image of a grass eating bullock." Psalm 106:20
@@happylittletrees5668 "Their glory is in their shame." "Their god is in their gullet." Yep, we're basically seeing the late stages of Romans 1 on a societal level.
Also when she said that her child goes by the pronoun "him" , "everybody is a him" but then she kept referring to "him" as "they". She wont accept the "him" because it's not what she wants, too normal. Watch it again you'll see she doesn't even respect her own way of thinking.
Yes should be labeled as child abuse.. hard to imagine the amount of therapy the child would need to extinguish inevitable future anger towards the parent. Imagine the insecurity of not being shown the minimal safe boundaries of life in society, while being burdened with responsibility of making all the choices.
The “DISRESPECT” I FEEL….. as a REAL WOMAN is really making me fighting mad- it’s a slap in my face to have these MEN dressing up as women and trying to convince themselves they are WO-MEN! I was BORN with the ability to BIRTH my 3 BABIES… BREAST FEED THEM - if I chose to… I spent HOURS in LABOR…. On all three babies…. to birth them into this world! Now these foolish people step forward trying to FORCE people to accept them as A WOMAN! It will NEVER happen.
Amen. As women we gave life to all on this planet and now we need to compete with the delusional on what a women is. Also, why does this group get a whole month to celebrate and the mothers and fathers of the world get 1 day a year to celebrate. This is George Orwells nightmare "1984" come true.
I loved when u said “you are a man because when u die, yr bones will say you are a man NOT a woman” how true! And that mother at the end ….should be analyzed by a therapist! I feel terrible for her son!
That poor 'genderless' child! Does that child have a father? Will she ask the child what species he wants to be? I wanted to be a bird when I grew up when I was a kid. My mom played along until she realized that I was going to jump out of our apartment window because I thought I could fly.
Matt Walsh handles the situation so respectfully and polite. He has a different opinion and he makes that clear but he also carries that opinion with the utmost respect in order to understand other people's ideas and to debate the topic. It's funny because I can't imagine any other way a Conservative Christian with Matt's opinions could present his opinions in any nicer of a way. It's something to think about, these people say they were triggered and made to look bad however I would love to ask them how else would you like Matt to ask you these questions how else would you like Christian conservatives that don't agree with you and what you are teaching children and what you are saying is reality? This is literally the only way Matt or other people could possibly talk about these subjects without being aggressive. It is usually the left that becomes aggressive immediately however just like in this case they are always the first people to claim victimhood. They always talk about being tolerant to everyone's lifestyles and feelings but the moment a Christian conservative comes along then those ideas of being tolerant and welcoming go out the window
Actually he doesn't have a different opinion. He's fighting against them trying to make an opinion factual, and fantasy a reality. He's not of the OPINION that the your gender is connected to your biological makeup it is a fact. They are trying to separate the two but at the same time connect the two which makes no sense.
I would love to see Dr. Phil have an actual woman or actual feminist on his show (opposing the ladydix and enbies) since they are the ones who've been the most vocal and consistent against the trance movement for decades. Of course they'll only ever allow conservatives as the oppositional voice, particularly men. That's because they know how bad it looks to have men vs women arguing about ~womens~ rights and ~womens~ spaces. It's too obvious. That said, what Matt said was the truth and I'm glad he said it and continues to say it. I'm thankful this is at long last becoming a more mainstream issue, because now it's only a matter of time before the whole house of cards comes falling down. The more people who see this and realize it for what it is, how absolutely batshit crazy it is, it surely can't last too much longer.
There was a kid being raised gender less in the school i worked in this year. We had to tip toe around alot with communication to this kid. So glad the school year is over, I still technically don't know if it was a girl or boy. Couldn't ask or we would get in "trouble"
It's really sad because some people like Buck Angel, Blaire White, Rose of Dawn, Debbie Haydon -- all suffer from gender dysphoria which is a debilitating mental health condition where you are uncomfortable with your body (beyond the typical teenage angst). Most people grow past it, some never do and they transition in order to ease their suffering. These 'trans-activists' do SUCH a disservice to real transexuals who struggle so much, for whome gender ideology is not entertaining and there's no pride for them in being a trans person. Debbie Haydon, a transexual woman from the UK went viral for wearing a T-shirt saying 'trans-women are men'. Please check out any of the above mentioned people and you will find that transgender people are not crazy - but unfortunately they ARE a super minority within the 'transgender' community.
Yeah, they don’t want people to know how many people who actually had the surgery ended up taking their own lives or who now try to be what they were originally only with the wrong sexual organs. Something that traumatizes them for the rest of their lives
I just moved to California and have discovered I identify as a African American women, after 63 years I know who I am. I’m really looking forward to the reparations check to start my future. Thanks Newsome.
The image of the man/lady with the beard and lipstick haunts my nights. I think Dr. Phil sold out. He's hardly the expert of things like he used to be. I think the society problems are way above his paygrade now.
Sincere people can debate most subjects openly and freely. Intelligence is required when you wish to be informed of a subject you do not know and wish to be educated on. Thank you for posting this video.
adjective: female of or denoting the sex that can bear offspring or produce eggs, distinguished biologically by the production of gametes (ova) which can be fertilized
Thank you for standing up for sanity!! These people are delusional, but I don't care what they want to call themselves (even though it's not remotely true), just don't ask me or any of us trying to live in the normal world, to go along with it. It's mental illness!!!
I’ll tell you what has happened with all this craziness is wow I love woman real woman , they literally bring forth new life ,how could anyone not be so happy when they see real woman 😍
@@famvids9627 It would make more sense if the example said "chicken". All hens are chickens, but not all chickens are hens. So if someone said 'chickens lay eggs', I would correct them and say 'only hens'.
props to this guy.. extremely brave hes pretty much go against the world he live in.. trust me you might feel alone but actually there are many people agrees with you more than those delusional people
Why are we even having this discussion? This is nuts. I’m waiting for the show where people come on denying gravity exists and calling you a bigot if you say it does
Race is more of a social construct than gender is.. these people are nuts.. literally mentally ill & we started accepting it as to not hurt feelings but now its mainstream & affecting kids.. IDK how we fix it.. scary when thinking about having kids..
So I wanted you to know guys. That I'm actually a fly trapped in a spider body, Trapped in a bird body, trapped in a cat body, trapped in a dog body trapped in a snake body trapped in an eagle body, trapped in fish body, trapped in a shark body, trapped in a man body.
In twenty to thirty years there will be a whole spew of angry adults that went through unecessary surgical procedures as children or youngcadults; encouraged and enabled by lunatics with superiority complexes; lunatics who think they know whats best for a child. I wonder if they would be able to take legal action against those that would facilitate such procedures?
Bro i share your frustration,because clearly anyone can tell its been edited to fit their agender. I support you 100%. Im a black man, who resides in South Africa, we dont have that problem here, we have gays and lesbians but we just don't entertain their motives.
Gays and Lesbians are completely separate from this whole gender debacle in the first place, and a lot of them are against it (but will get cancelled as soon as they speak out) The LGB movement has been taken over by literally insane people that can't even explain their own point of view.
Gender is a big part of your identity . It does NOT limit you, thanks to feminism! A woman can be an Army general, so can a guy. A man can be a first grade teacher, so can a woman. The only job I will never qualify for because I am a woman is sperm donor. Guys, none of you can ever be a surrogate mother. True, some people born with physical or hormonal problems that make gender hard to determine. I have great compassion for these people, and they deserve the best medical and psychological treatment we have. But these folks make up a very small portion of the population. Some people won't like this, but here goes: There are only 2 genders, male and female.
@@jocec3283 oh, I agree! Both men and women can be feminists. My point was that your gender is PART of your identity. And your gender does not limit you these days. In the past, it sure did! It was hard for women to get many jobs. But thanks to feminism, that is no longer the case in most of the world.
@@shoshanadvora8932 Right, but is still has nothing to do with gender. I fail to see you point. The point of the debate is that there is only TWO genders. Not as many that some THINK there are... And to "identfy" yourself as something, doesn't make you one.
You know I've taken a few debate classes and have learned apart from the introduction of course the first thing talked about and a massive foundation in the debate is definitions. Without definitions, you literally can't argue a point because there is no set point to argue and that point can just keep changing. These people literally can't get past the most basic part of definitions, and what that means is that their arguments truly have no meaning, no point, no worth, and are not able to be debated. It's truly sad just how far they have gotten and how many people they've turned to their side without having any form of a reasonable argument because their argument really isn't even worthy of being considered an argument.
I'm a half- unicorn,half-mermaid-fairy hybrid, non-binary woman who identifies as a man who identifies as a feminist banana, and I agree with Matt Walsh😆
@@famvids9627 genuine question, have you polled a large number of intersex people to ask how they feel about being used to defend trans/non-binary ideology? You would probably find that most of them are just trying to live their lives instead of being activists to push an “agenda” that really doesn’t have anything to do with them.
@@famvids9627 just because some warped weirdo in academia writes something down, doesn't make it true your "research" is as credible as the most stupid conspiracy theories out there
Exactly what I woulda done, if gender and sex are both social constructs and “man made” according to these atheist secularists, then so is race “Bc I said so. I identify as a blk man so gimme my reparations for slavery, Dems”…
The fact that a woman is literally rasing her child to be "genderless" with an "x" on the birth certificate honestly terrifies me...
*many many women and womanly “men”
That is their agenda.
She's been in the media since she first gave birth proving it was always more about virtue signalling than (even in her twisted mind) raising her child as best she can. Her preteen daughter is "non binary" now as well. It's scary that she's experimenting using these children as petrie dish projects.
It feels like she is using her child as a means to conduct a social experiment
I would pose this question to these people. There are many medical treatments and drugs that base their applications and dosages on the sex of the patient. If you had a life threatening disease, and needed one of those treatments or drugs, what would you check off on your examination papers?
It is very telling that Matt Walsh who got virtually zero support from the audience (I think I heard one person start clapping after he made a point but immediately stopped) is the one who is saying Dr. Phil and his staff were very fair, and the other side who had so much support (clapping after everything they said) are saying how triggering the show was, and how they were made to look bad
Its because they looked dumb bc its a dumb topic.
There was one time his side a group of people clapped, but... that was for the man beside Matt Walsh, sadly. Matt Walsh himself didn't get any ovation from the audience (i could be wrong about Matt Walsh getting someone to clap for him after making a good point, unless you give me a timeline at a certain part of the episode :o)
Those people live their lives off victimhood. So even if everyone on earth clapped for them , they'd still have to lie and pretend they were mocked and humiliated, so they could perpetuate their victim narrative.
Because someone pointing out facts and reality makes them look bad. They are so used to living in their insanity bubble that hearing truth is harmful to their fragile self.
Matt walsh has no expertise in mental health and has no educational background in it either so why would the audience support him? He's just some guy with an opinion...
it's actual insanity. the bearded lady that was on the show with Matt said that he was traumatized and is having panic attacks and nightmares because of Matt. these are not sane people. they're actually crazy and manipulative.
That was no lady. That be a dude.
@@adiracquetball uh oh. Be careful or else the alphabet people will come for you.
@@old3rbrother But Older Brother I'm just being my true authentic self.........gag gag cough cough
@@adiracquetball oh well in that case, I can't tell you that "your truth" is any different from THE truth. I'd be a bigot if I did that, apparently lol :p.
@@adiracquetball true that! Too many confused humans 😜
"I won't dignify that question with a response." Translation: I don't want to reveal my double standards and illogical point of view.
It has more to do with the fact that he was doing the whole gotcha question thing...
@@famvids9627 No, in fact he was steel manning their argument. Those trans advocates were saying sex and gender must not be conflated. So, when Matt hears this one person mention their newborn's sex was unlisted because the kid doesn't know their gender, that parent conflated the two concepts as one. It might seem like a gotcha moment to you, but Matt was taking their strongest argument and flipped it over with ease.
@@thejuniorseas7683 no he wasn't steelmanning their argument... the government form conflate gender and sex together so they were simply doing their best given the limitations of the form as so many people do with a variety of government forms and he was trying to use the limitations of the governments form against them in a "gotcha moment". It's not like they wrote the government form... no they didn't but his question presupposes that they agreed with the government conflating both in their form that has virtually been unchanged for over a half a century.
@@famvids9627 A birth certificate doesn't say gender, it says sex. As in the biological sex of the child. If the child was born with male genitalia, the form should read "male". Again, the parent is conflating the two, not government that you so believe.
There are specific reason why government forms ask for the sex of an individual for identification purposes (reduces possibility of mixing up babies in the hospital by 50% for instance) and medical treatments which requires knowledge of how a patient will respond to treatment due to the differing responses of the cellular mechanisms and chemistry which are inherently different between the two sexes. This is not opinion, it is biological reality based on genetics and molecular biology.
Gender stems from this biological reality unless there are underlying psychological issues driving it. Anyone of age who chooses any gender which does not match their biological sex is welcome to do so, but must also be capable of recognizing the lifetime of medical debt and psychological confusion that accompanies that choice. They should also recognize no one else should be coerced to enable such a choice by contorting their language, or allowing them to use restrooms and dressing rooms that don’t match their birth sex and thereby make others using that room uncomfortable or put themselves at physical risk. Neither should they be allowed to use their birth sex for advantage in sporting events by pretending they are a different sex than they were born.
Parents should not be permitted to give medical permission for their child to be given surgery or hormones for the purpose of changing their sex prior to them turning 18 years old, at which point the child can make their own decisions. This should hold except for the approximately one in 10,000 people who actually have genetic abnormalities in their sex chromosomes which cause physical problems that need to be medically addressed after proper genetic diagnosis. Teachers should not address this issue at all with any child in their care.
Imagine people who can't (or won't) define what a woman is claim the moral high ground...
Imagine people trying to "break societal norms" and "social constructs" by painting their faces and wearing bras... brandishing the very "societal norms" they're attempting to destroy....
🤡🌎
Isn't the simplest response to just point to the Merriam-Webster dictionary?
@Rob Hodge who is trying to destroy bras? 😂 Many women need bras for comfort. I have large breasts, I need bras for comfort, especially when being active. Being comfortable is not antifeminist. If you were a woman, you'd understand that.
@@SM-so8hh trans activists. They rely on typical stereotypes to present themselves as male/female which goes against breaking societal norms lol ironic really.
SM, I think he meant men who do that not real women.
Matt Walsh: “What’s a woman?”
Confused weirdo person: “I have no idea, but I’m definitely one of them.”
What is a woman? = What color are the Emperor's clothes?
I don't know,but I'm definitely one of them🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@andrewjones6295 so women don’t exist?
@@TandJgaming Did you watch the actual clip of the show? 🤔
@@mikepriestey2547 are you familiar with the emperors clothes story? He doesn’t have clothes he just thinks he does
What's truly ironic is that the people who claim to be authorities on gender and womanhood, can't define either.
Sure they can... You just haven't listened to them
@@famvids9627 "Its whatever definition _that_ individual chooses", is a big 'ol NON answer. Don't pretend it is
@@famvids9627 Their definition is nonsensical. You can't define something by "whatever you feel it is". That is not a definition.
Women are humans with XX chromosomes. Aka females. They get pregnant, give birth and breastfeed.
Humans are mammals. It's basic biology.
@@EaglePicking also, when they make the argument that saying women give birth isn't valid because SOME women can't, refer to the fact that we don't base definitions based on the minorities. That is not to say someone who can't give birth isn't a woman, but the definition of what a woman is doesn't change because GENERALLY and in most cases, they can. Additionally, women are women down to their DNA and bone regardless of ability to give birth. Men who feel like and identify as women can't be that
@@EaglePicking this person on Dr. Phil isn't the best representation of the transgender phenomenon and doesn't speak for all transgender people. However you are all using it as your strawman and acting like matt walsh is somehow an expert in the field when he has zero education in anything mental health related and knows nothing about the research.
Through out history, most true hero’s have stood alone. Stay strong Matt Walsh❤️
+Calee Tholen Gosh, that's powerful and inspirational. So how do the flocks and flocks and flocks of right wing rage cultists factor in this whole standing alone thing?
This line of reasoning could be an excuse for the rest of us to be passive, and I'm not going to let myself off the hook in that respect -- should any of us?
@@lawrenceharold8599 Well they weren't on the show, were they?
Bold of you to think Matt is standing alone. I am with him, millions of humans stand together with him and we are not silent.
Absolutely
"Why do you care?"
"Because I'm a father."
I wish too he would have asked "Why don't you care?" but she would have just went into circles with the argument of everything in life is whatever.
The question "why do you care?" Itself is stupid and makes no sense, they are the ones who forced people to participate in their stupid pronouns game. Anyone who doesn't care about their pronouns will be labeled bigot and misgendering.
@@Chromwel-A It's a deflection tactic. They fully expect everyone to fall in line behind their Godless ideology or to remain silent in fear and shame. If someone does start standing up against them and making good points here like Matt Walsh did, then instead of defending their indefensible and nonsensical position as they know they have no ground to stand on, they just deflect and rebut sound points with "Why do you care so much? It's not a big deal." It frames their opposition as the aggressor. It's a classic tactic of crying out in pain at you while they strike you.
@Scott Scotty do you realize what show you’re commenting under?
@Scott Scotty If you want people on the internet to take you seriously and not just presume you to be a worthless troll, I'd highly recommend a better username than "Scott Scotty." Doesn't have to be your real name, even. But just know that with such a ridiculous and lazy name that you're presenting yourself as someone that reasonable people will not be predisposed to taking seriously.
Now if by some off-chance you intend on having something approaching a reasonable discourse, which I highly doubt as you can't even be bothered to capitalize God let alone singularize Him, I AM staying with reality. It's those who think that gender is fluid and completely dependent upon the will of an individual subject who are outright refusing to live within reality. God created us male and female in His own image and likeness. He also gave us reason and rationality, something that the gender activists have spit upon with their perfidious and disgusting ideology.
Doctor Phil has no problem telling a lying drug addict that they are sick and need
To change. However, he sits their like a bump on a log with this nonsense. Very disappointing but not at all surprised.
That was my reaction, too.
Because this Very Oppressed Group wields way more power than most normies realize
Yes i actually feel sorry for him (and for us all) because people who believe the gender oppression cause have by definition to be vocal and to participate in the sj war. This means he thinks like us sane people but needs to please the pc police to stay afloat. Really sad.
if he said anything of the sort, he would be in huge trouble.
@@daisyviluck7932 Ding Ding Ding!
Precisely. Who said it that you can figure out who rules over you by knowing who you’re not allowed to criticize?
I have zero sympathy for people like this. They’re not poor little innocent victims. They’re activists with a political agenda and angle. They’re liars who take advantage of the confusion of the innocent in order to ram their anti-truth agenda down our throats. They use the full power of cancel culture to coerce and force others to deny objective, observable, plain, and obvious reality and play along with their fantasy as though it’s true. Classic propaganda and subversion tactic to get people to deny reality.
To quote Captain Picard from Star Trek: “There are Four lights!”
That poor kid being raised "genderless" is going to be so screwed up.
I see a potential serial killer developing.
Child abuse is what it is.
💔 hoping against hope not, though, for the child’s sake
@@thejuniorseas7683 Your the crazy one
@@babygaga9415 That's not child abuse lmao
Let’s leave the fate of the term “woman” in the hands the people who can define it clearly.
I say "If you don't know what bathroom to use you shouldn't be teaching anyone"!
Nobody really defines this clearly... Even Thomas Aquinas said that women were half finished or incomplete men.... Does that mean that we dismiss everything he ever said about women or men or man?
@@famvids9627 I’ll define it right now, men have xy chromosomes, women have xx. A dna test can easily determine which of the two you are. Your arbitrary sexual preferences have nothing to do with your chromosomes. Fetishism is a spectrum, chromosomes are not.
@@tyc6268 your definition is incorrect. People do not just have xx or yx chromosomes. There are over 140 million people in the world who are intersex and express themselves as either men or women. There are women who were born with some male characteristics according to their chromosomal makeup who express themselves as women. Obviously you didn't take a basic biology course but yet you are the person, the gate keeper, who is in charge of defining who is and who isn't a woman. Thank God our fate doesn't rest in your hands and you are not the person who makes that final determination.
There was a time when your definition was used and intersex people were forced into expressing themselves according to some arbitrary definition that people such as yourself determined. This resulted in millions of forced surgeries of intersex people, forcing them at birth into some arbitrary gender that people like you decided based upon what you thought they most closely aligned with... the suffering was immense. Now, society is more compassionate and informed. We no longer force people into a gender but allow the person to make this decision for themselves.
I would rather people have the freedom to choose rather than being compelled to fit some sort of arbitrary ideal that you have decided.
@@famvids9627 I’m not talking about the details of their genitals or their arbitrary sexual orientation, I’m talking about their chromosomes. Sometimes people are born with deformed reproductive organs, they still only either produce eggs or sperm. There’s never been a human that produces both. Obviously you don’t know the difference between objective truth and public consensus. Maybe you should’ve taken a basic biology course.
Was that whole paragraph just you showing that you can’t tell the difference between sex and gender again? Gender is arbitrary and based on personal whim. Sex on the other hand has everything to do with the organ and chromosomes you were born with (deformed or not).
I would rather people have the freedom to choose too but you don’t have the right to choose to be ignorant and also choose to push that ignorance on me. What you choose to do with your body will never change your chromosomes. That is a scientific fact.
I remember Ben ( if you don't know which Ben, then I'm sorry ) asking a person about what gender people identify as. He asked her what age she was. I believe the answer was in her 20's. Then he asked her why isn't she 60-something? She looked confused until Ben clarified if she can choose her gender, which is 99% of the time an absolute, why can't she choose her age as well? It was priceless.
well, it's an absolute 100% of the time, but yes
Schapiro. Great call out vid. Chick was stumped
"Age is just a number"
@@sdrc92126 true, and numbers are facts, not debatable .
Shapiro!
Matt is my hero. Literally says everything I’ve been saying the past couple year just in a simple, better way than I could ever say it. Ahhh I hope to meet him or hear him speak in person one day 🤞🤞🤞
Extremely informative. I haven’t heard of this Matt Walsh guy. He’s so logical and down to earth
You should search him on TH-cam and watch his dating advice clips. Also the ones where he addresses Reddit questions on "Am I the Ahole?" Hilarious at it gets.
@@justlina2769 I found the Matt Walsh show on TH-cam and subscribed. Thank you very much for the information
@@sukt00 I found the Matt Walsh show on TH-cam and subscribed. Thank you very much for the information
Matt Walsh is awesome! I just discovered him about a month ago on his TH-cam channel. Very smart guy that says what a lot of people are afraid to say nowadays.
@@michelegray5970 I just learned about Matt Walsh watching this video. I watched his other videos and I have to say he has this very dry sense of humor which doesn’t work for a lot of people but it works extremely well for him
I love Matt's directness. It's refreshing and effective. We can all learn tips from him on how to confront lunacy.
As a Homosexual male....Matt Walsh is who I look up too. He is a great inspiration to my generation. Thank you Matt
As a gay man i’ve tried to become attracted to women many times yet I just can’t
@@NickCADA Please don't do it, why are you trying to do that?
@@jesusiscomingback8438 your name is literally Jesus is coming back, and you’re going to ask why he’s trying to get away from his immoral sexuality?
@@NickCADA why specifically Is it because you believe god is real? In witch case you don’t have to be straight you just can be in a intimate relationship with another male.
@@NickCADA As a straight man I keep wondering why gay men think they can turn me gay?
I'm angry at Dr. Phil, and feel strongly he sold out, allowing more time and speakers for gender benders, giving them the last word towards the end of the show. Dr. Phil usually will call a spade a spade, obviously held back his opinions that the gender benders were delusional, which he has to know as a licensed clinical psychologist. Now some will say he held back to referee the discussion, but towards the end Dr. Phil made a short summary that social construction of gender will continue to cause debate---A hint that gender benders will continue to come on his show in the future to attract ratings. He all but gave his tacit approval of the behavior to protect his wallet and appease his Woke Hollywood masters.
He does call a spade of spade... It's just that he understands the research and how complicated this situation is. For people like yourself that don't understand the research at all it's easy to oversimplify it because you do over simplify it because you don't understand the full perspective active and you don't understand the research. Being that you're a non scientist what you even consider research is probably not research.
@@famvids9627 I don't need to be a scientist to read studies by scientists who determined transgenders suffer from mental disporara, afflicted with depression, substance abuse, and high risk to commit suicide. So you can cease with your condescending attitude treating me as being ignorant. Transgenders need compassionate help, but no one should be held hostage to accept their delusions by playing up to their expectations to be treated as a man or woman when they are not. Dr. Phil knows better, but won't say so.
Don't forget to keep the dialogue open. Bull!!.
Dr. Phil has done some great work no doubt, but I’ve watched enough to know that he will at times put his ratings and ego above all else.
He’s not in charge. It’s his team and producer. He signed a contract. He’s a red hot republican and had tomi Lahren on to give a message to men to grow up and stop being soy boys. Like….. I feel bad for Dr Phil honestly because he’s in a contract and can’t really change it. So yes, In a way he sold out
Ah yes the parent of a 4 year old who has been denied the dignity of having their biological sex isn't going to dignify "ridiculous" questions with an answer. They have it together so well and are so confident of the position they've taken that they have to completely change the subject and refuse to address any discussion of their child's gender when asked. They're also hoping for their four year old to "finally decide" their gender. I mean is this for real? This child abuser should be in jail as a sex offender.
How can a person yet alone a child choose their gender if gender is fluid. It's so contrary to their position. Makes my head spin
Not sexual abuse, just psychological abuse of a child.
Yessssss...people need to stand up..enough is enough.we gave lgbtq a foot they took the whole yard
@@ClydeCashCwCville they stole 10 trillion miles!
Yes! You are aware that parents are not just allowing but praising their “Trans” children, you know, anywhere from 4-8 years old, for claiming gender dysphoria and wanting to start taking certain drugs that inhibit the normal processes of development in order to prepare them to become the opposite sex. These drugs are very harmful and will screw up their bodies for life. This is very real and it’s all over the place. We all need to take a stand against this demonic movement before it’s too late.
I am a man, married to a woman and have 2 daughters. My wife and daughters are "Real" women. They have all the natural parts that a woman has. There is no way that these people could be classed as a "woman".
And... if by birth defect or surgery those parts were gone, they'd still be women based on their chromosomes and over 1500 sex hormones!
They don't mind offering insult to women but don't you dare come right out say, despite the camouflage 'you're a man, so act like one'.
Brilliant debate matt, that simple question and the mental gymnastics they had to perform to avoid them and they still failed, like watching the verbal equivalent of Bruce Lee.
except Bruce Lee actually wins his fights lol
@@justindesouza977
So did Matt.
@@potatojoe3050 the sentance "watching the verbal equivalent of Bruce Lee" follows a description of the "transgender" guys, thus, Bruce Lee is being linked to the "transgender" guys, and not Matt.
so my comment refers to the "transgender" guys and not Matt
@@justindesouza977 no, no I meant matt to be the verbal Bruce lee
@@robertjames9181 oh sorry, mb.... the way the sentance is constructed, it gave the opposite impression
They took down the clip from Dr. Phil’s TH-cam channel. The comments were overwhelmingly in Matt’s favor, so they took it down. Even when everything was stacked against him, he still came out on top.
that's why no mainstream websites have comments anymore.
They know perfectly well that the opinions they push are unpopular
This all feels like a frog in a pot of boiling water. First they said, “Of course sex and gender are different. Sex is biological.” Now, they are blurring the lines between the two, saying that sex should be listed as “unknown” until the child makes a choice. And the children can change their minds as many times as they want anyway.
Addison kept saying that this topic is so complex and confusing. I don’t think it’s confusing. It’s not consistent.
it just seems like entitled people with no sense of logic
It really is inconsistent. But keep in mind that if Gender Identity Politics did not make claims like "Gender is a social construct" and bring social issues into play, and instead stuck to basic biology, they would not be able to push this agenda. Their goal, ultimately, is to redesign our society, which they reaslize is something they can do. What they cannot do is redesign basic biology.
The reality that we have to get on TV and debate what a man and a woman is just is beyond scary.
Cope
If you were asked to pick out the audience member who had a "genderless child" every person would have guessed her.
"I wouldn't dignify that with an answer" == "You got me."
When you are sitting in a room with people who claim to be dogs; you don't pet them; you tell them the truth; you are not a dog.
For real though
strawman
@@pokerface7061 strawman cannot be strawwoman
Better to tell them: Sorry but you are not a dog or a wolf and you should see immediately a psychiatrist (a normal one hopefully).
@@pokerface7061 Why? What makes identifying as "non-binary" or "moongender" more valid than identifying as a dog?
They've removed all the clips from TH-cam, the Dr. Phil website and Hulu.
wow! no wonder i cant find the official uploads. what are they afraid of? lol
Here is the episode.
th-cam.com/video/iU4uD9qXcUs/w-d-xo.html
What’s funny is even with the producers “cutting for time” Matt still destroyed their entire position! Can you imagine what we didn’t see???🤣👍🏻
He's been destroying it for so many years that he's got some very sensible and simple AND short answers that are impossible to cut out otherwise they would edit him out completely and erase themselves ... LOL.
I could see Dr.Phil's face during all this...i think he quietly agrees with Walsh
Phil is not known for staying quiet or neutral. That strongly indicates that he was afraid to say what he actually thought.
Most people do
@@Future_Imperfect of course he was afraid. He’s not ready to retire yet. He wants a couple million more dollars and he wasn’t ready to be canceled
@@highwayxj9397 It's very disappointing when people with true FU money are afraid of saying FU. I get it, if you are basically a couple pay checks from being homeless, that's a big deterrent but MILLIONAIRES. You should not be be afraid.
@@Future_Imperfect I agree with you. It just sucks having decades of being sensational and then going out being “cancelled”
However I’m confident cancel culture will be fought against. We just need more millionaires to fight back as well as everyone else
That classifies as child abuse to me.
I just would've assumed Matt would've been prepared for that and had it set up an agreed upon that he could bring in some of his people to record if they wanted to use him on their show. Not only for the rights to post that himself but for protection too.
Matt brought up a really good point right at the end of this clip - they bounce between gender and sex in an attempt to confuse the topic, there is no consistence and it literally changes depending on who you are talking to because one will say gender is fluid while the other says sex yet they are talking about the same thing. But then they will be the first to say " you are confusing A with B" or " I am taking about A, not B" to try and prove you wrong. When they use that double-talk and constantly change terms, it is them trying to rig the fight so anytime you counter what they say, they can say you are not talking about the right thing.
Exactly. A very important rhetorical tool is to recognize whether you’re talking to an honest person or not. Not everyone or every interaction is all about open discourse and discussion and debate. Many are only interested in manipulating others.
Sex and gender have always been references to different things. The only thing that’s changed is how the term “gender” is used in a Sociological context. But it has never been entirely synonymous with sex grammatically. Practically everyone acknowledges sex as biological and set in stone, so Conservatives like Walsh aren’t making any slam dunks when they act like their opponents don’t admit even that. Secondly, defining a gender (reflected in Addison’s reluctance to do so) is like trying to make a single definition for a concept as abstract as Justice or Knowledge. People who have been commenting on this debate from the Right-wing position typically saw this as a weakness on their part, except it was actually a very consistent response, because they weren’t going to capitulate to Matt’s absurd and easily contestable definition, and precisely because they were not going to reduce a gender identity into nothing more than mere stereotypes.
Some people do but to say that's everyone is false
@@ManoverSuperman *"Sex and gender have always been references to different things."*
That's flat-out false. Sex is a biological reality, and gender has _always_ been the _conceptual equivalent_ of that reality. 'Masculine' is derived from 'male' and 'feminine' is derived from 'female'. You have no legitimate evidence whatever to the contrary.
What you _do_ have is a desire to _believe_ the contrary combined with a lack of honesty, which allows you to dispense with reality in order to maintain your beliefs, rather than vice versa.
@@ManoverSuperman Justice, knowledge and gender are concepts that we can define and we know what they mean. Gender is fluid, there is a spectrum with femininity on one end and masculinity on the other, but that is still connected to biological sex. Trans activists want to completely sever gender from sex so that it can mean anything to anyone. For instance, a biological man identifies as a woman but can't define what a woman is. So what does he mean when he calls himself a "woman" then? Is the rest of society supposed to play along with this silly game? We all know that a woman is an adult human female, i.e. a human with XX chromosomes.
I'm hoping that there is more of this truth being told.
Amen Linda,it's a slippery slope unless we do speak up
It's not truth instead it is dogma or ideology
@@famvids9627 well we believe the Bible is truth ,so it's our choice to hold onto what we believe is truth
@@famvids9627 I've seen your replies on numerous comments in this video.
If anyone is ideologically driven in their rationale, it's you. You reject readily observable scientific evidence like sex characteristics, in favor of emotions and subjective perception determining whether a man is a man or a woman.
How can someone possess so tenuous a grasp on the world they live in? It's honestly pitiable.
I have a lot of respect for a man that stands for something than a man that falls for anything.. people are cowards nowadays.its all about pleasing society. Much respect to you Matt
I cannot believe we are at this point in society
I’m with you, it’s quite mind bogglingly terrifying.
Time to fight back! Society will be improved by our efforts my friend :)
This situation shows conservative values are getting some traction in the culture war. From Matt Walsh getting an invite to Dr Phil, to the actual airing the show (instead of shelving it like they did Blair Whites interview) to the way clips from the debate were shared all over social media, I feel hope for our society ❤️
I'm not a conservative, yet back Matt's position. Belief in truth, logic, health, fairness and good policy is not restricted to the right.
Yes, but “DR.(?)” Phil …edited the positive applause!!!
This was actually my point, literally at the start of the debate: you Don't use your pronouns. PEOPLE use your pronouns, to describe you. If i see this Addison Rose is a man, he cannot compell me to lie and say he's a woman, much less a hybrid which I Don't See
(because it's not there).
Also i want to see a non binary person who didn't hear of the existence of this condition from someone else.
I want to see a boy, happy, healthy and satisfied with their life throw away their health and social condition to be regarded as a zoo animal.
Narcissists.
Bingo. It’s long past time to call out this crap for what it is.
I heard Carl Benjamin put it well recently. He said how starting off an interaction by listing pronouns is an act of wielding power over another as though to say: “You will address me in the manner in which I approve. I set the terms here.” It’s akin to how a nobleman of old would make the lowly plebs tip their cap to him as he passed by and refer to him as “my liege” or “my lord” etc. It’s a way of establishing rank.
Also, it’s basically says that your faculty of reason, your ability to make observations and assessments of the world around you is either faulty or is not allowed. I will inform you of what your senses are incapable. And, I will also intentionally over share about my personal life and if that makes you uncomfortable, that’s your problem and you have to just deal with it because, again, I set the terms here and you just have to conform to them.
@@jefffinkbonner9551 Excellent observation. It very well is an attempt to diminish our reason. This diminishes our humanity which includes our likeness to God, their ultimate goal. They want us to become like them: "They exchanged their Glory for an image of a grass eating bullock." Psalm 106:20
More specific " vunerable narcasisim" all progressive activists have it!
@@happylittletrees5668 "Their glory is in their shame." "Their god is in their gullet." Yep, we're basically seeing the late stages of Romans 1 on a societal level.
Thanks for standing up to this madness! God help our children.
Thanks! Very informative...
Also when she said that her child goes by the pronoun "him" , "everybody is a him" but then she kept referring to "him" as "they". She wont accept the "him" because it's not what she wants, too normal. Watch it again you'll see she doesn't even respect her own way of thinking.
Nice catch!
Yes should be labeled as child abuse.. hard to imagine the amount of therapy the child would need to extinguish inevitable future anger towards the parent. Imagine the insecurity of not being shown the minimal safe boundaries of life in society, while being burdened with responsibility of making all the choices.
You made some good points, but, I noticed they never clapped for you! Thank you for being real!
Awesome! Thank you for the facts , reality and COMMON SENSE. 🙌
The “DISRESPECT” I FEEL…..
as a REAL WOMAN is really making me fighting mad- it’s a slap in my face to have these MEN dressing up as women and trying to convince themselves they are WO-MEN!
I was BORN with the ability
to BIRTH my 3 BABIES…
BREAST FEED THEM -
if I chose to…
I spent HOURS in LABOR….
On all three babies….
to birth them into this world!
Now these foolish people step forward trying to FORCE people to accept them as A WOMAN!
It will NEVER happen.
Equally offense to me as a man when they think because they talk deeper and grow a beard that makes them a man
Amen. As women we gave life to all on this planet and now we need to compete with the delusional on what a women is. Also, why does this group get a whole month to celebrate and the mothers and fathers of the world get 1 day a year to celebrate. This is George Orwells nightmare "1984" come true.
@@zumiaurareadings1538 Pride month = 1984
I loved when u said “you are a man because when u die, yr bones will say you are a man NOT a woman” how true! And that mother at the end ….should be analyzed by a therapist! I feel terrible for her son!
That poor 'genderless' child! Does that child have a father? Will she ask the child what species he wants to be? I wanted to be a bird when I grew up when I was a kid. My mom played along until she realized that I was going to jump out of our apartment window because I thought I could fly.
Matt Walsh handles the situation so respectfully and polite. He has a different opinion and he makes that clear but he also carries that opinion with the utmost respect in order to understand other people's ideas and to debate the topic. It's funny because I can't imagine any other way a Conservative Christian with Matt's opinions could present his opinions in any nicer of a way. It's something to think about, these people say they were triggered and made to look bad however I would love to ask them how else would you like Matt to ask you these questions how else would you like Christian conservatives that don't agree with you and what you are teaching children and what you are saying is reality? This is literally the only way Matt or other people could possibly talk about these subjects without being aggressive. It is usually the left that becomes aggressive immediately however just like in this case they are always the first people to claim victimhood. They always talk about being tolerant to everyone's lifestyles and feelings but the moment a Christian conservative comes along then those ideas of being tolerant and welcoming go out the window
Actually he doesn't have a different opinion. He's fighting against them trying to make an opinion factual, and fantasy a reality. He's not of the OPINION that the your gender is connected to your biological makeup it is a fact. They are trying to separate the two but at the same time connect the two which makes no sense.
I would love to see Dr. Phil have an actual woman or actual feminist on his show (opposing the ladydix and enbies) since they are the ones who've been the most vocal and consistent against the trance movement for decades. Of course they'll only ever allow conservatives as the oppositional voice, particularly men. That's because they know how bad it looks to have men vs women arguing about ~womens~ rights and ~womens~ spaces. It's too obvious.
That said, what Matt said was the truth and I'm glad he said it and continues to say it. I'm thankful this is at long last becoming a more mainstream issue, because now it's only a matter of time before the whole house of cards comes falling down. The more people who see this and realize it for what it is, how absolutely batshit crazy it is, it surely can't last too much longer.
Matt is smart.
“Brilliant and handsome”
Nah, he’s just normal…that’s the point. You don’t have to be smart or an expert on anything to know what the truth is
"I won't dignify that question with an answer" roughly translates to:
"I just contradicted myself but I'm not going to admit it."
Best remark ever: "if it was a complex topic that required you to be smart"
When i first saw Walsh on Dr.Phil and saw the other guests ....i slowley started grinning like the Joker.
Quality beard.
There was a kid being raised gender less in the school i worked in this year. We had to tip toe around alot with communication to this kid.
So glad the school year is over, I still technically don't know if it was a girl or boy. Couldn't ask or we would get in "trouble"
Thank God for both of you. Common sense is & of itself brilliant, if you take the time to seriously consider it, as Matt has so well mastered.
It's really sad because some people like Buck Angel, Blaire White, Rose of Dawn, Debbie Haydon -- all suffer from gender dysphoria which is a debilitating mental health condition where you are uncomfortable with your body (beyond the typical teenage angst). Most people grow past it, some never do and they transition in order to ease their suffering. These 'trans-activists' do SUCH a disservice to real transexuals who struggle so much, for whome gender ideology is not entertaining and there's no pride for them in being a trans person. Debbie Haydon, a transexual woman from the UK went viral for wearing a T-shirt saying 'trans-women are men'. Please check out any of the above mentioned people and you will find that transgender people are not crazy - but unfortunately they ARE a super minority within the 'transgender' community.
you mean MAJORITY are fucking crazy
Blair White at least acknowledges that he's biologically male and that there are differences. Last I checked anyway.
@@nonyabidness5708 yea, she still does
Yeah, they don’t want people to know how many people who actually had the surgery ended up taking their own lives or who now try to be what they were originally only with the wrong sexual organs. Something that traumatizes them for the rest of their lives
I was sure they would leave stuff out (usually the case) Good to know what it was. All credit to Matt Walsh
What a great guy Matt is God bless him🙏
He is such a smart guy and a great personality🙏
Man, that "Why don't you let your child choose his race?" question would have been a solid counterpoint--shame it didn't make it.
I just moved to California and have discovered I identify as a African American women, after 63 years I know who I am. I’m really looking forward to the reparations check to start my future. Thanks Newsome.
I don't usually watch Dr. Phil. I've not watched it in YEARS. when I saw the commercial for this I had to record it and watch it. It was awesome!
The image of the man/lady with the beard and lipstick haunts my nights. I think Dr. Phil sold out. He's hardly the expert of things like he used to be. I think the society problems are way above his paygrade now.
Those people are literally insane. Bravo to Matt Walsh 👏 the documentary was perfect 👌
Matt Welsh you're a hero for standing up for the truth
when facts and since are by your side, you have nothing to worry about. It's all about staying calm and not being sidetracked.
Sincere people can debate most subjects openly and freely. Intelligence is required when you wish to be informed of a subject you do not know and wish to be educated on.
Thank you for posting this video.
adjective: female
of or denoting the sex that can bear offspring or produce eggs, distinguished biologically by the production of gametes (ova) which can be fertilized
Thank you for standing up for sanity!! These people are delusional, but I don't care what they want to call themselves (even though it's not remotely true), just don't ask me or any of us trying to live in the normal world, to go along with it. It's mental illness!!!
Thanks for standing up for truth.
St. John Bosco Guide, Teacher and Model for Priests th-cam.com/video/QxnYt9Q3YtI/w-d-xo.html
I love this man for standing up for TRUTH!❤🥰😍🤗
i was just thinking about this, because it seems like there are heavily edited parts of matt’s talking points. things seem to abruptly cut off.
I’ll tell you what has happened with all this craziness is wow I love woman real woman , they literally bring forth new life ,how could anyone not be so happy when they see real woman 😍
Jesus, Mary, I love you save souls!
Viva Cristo Rey
Mary does not save souls!
@The New Knights Templar How does she do that? Can you show that from the Holy Scriptures?
@@Bullcutter how about this...you find out what Martin Luther (he started the protestant refermation) believed about Mary.
@@Bullcutter also find out who made the bible and find out why your bible is missing 7 books
Little child: "Mommy what's that?"
Wokeish mom: Johnny, "That's a rooster. It lays eggs."
- another example of mental child abuse
This is a straw man...
@@famvids9627 It would make more sense if the example said "chicken". All hens are chickens, but not all chickens are hens. So if someone said 'chickens lay eggs', I would correct them and say 'only hens'.
@@famvids9627 Only in your mind. That statement is spot on !!
@Joce C
Exactly!
A 'THEYSTER'😂
props to this guy.. extremely brave hes pretty much go against the world he live in.. trust me you might feel alone but actually there are many people agrees with you more than those delusional people
We need a deleted scene of that conversation
The fact that we have to debate this now🥺is proof (if we ever needed it ) that we're living in dystopia..
Come Lord Jesus...
Hell yeah, Matt. Keep exposing the Orwellian creepers and standing behind facts.
Why are we even having this discussion? This is nuts. I’m waiting for the show where people come on denying gravity exists and calling you a bigot if you say it does
Race is more of a social construct than gender is.. these people are nuts.. literally mentally ill & we started accepting it as to not hurt feelings but now its mainstream & affecting kids.. IDK how we fix it.. scary when thinking about having kids..
i forgot why i became a raging fireball when i once was a peaceful circle of fire.
"I won't dignify that question with an answer, because I can't."
It’s so easy being a democrat, you don’t have to stand for anything, you just have to be against everything normal.
You dont have to worry about what your saying when its the truth 👍
I wouldn't dignify that with an answer. Lmao, these people couldn't answer that if they wanted to.
I like how this guy says he went in so confident he knew he was right. Right on!
Am a apache helicopter and that's how I feel, I would like to be respected and be seen/called that way. Thank you ..
I agree with Matt; Dr Phil was extremely fair and basically just mediated the conversation. I was actually impressed with Dr Phil.
So I wanted you to know guys. That I'm actually a fly trapped in a spider body,
Trapped in a bird body, trapped in a cat body, trapped in a dog body trapped in a snake body trapped in an eagle body, trapped in fish body, trapped in a shark body, trapped in a man body.
Are you the old lady who swallowed a fly???
Matt: "Dr. Phil was pretty fair overall, neat experience"
Weird bearded lady: "I SHIDDED and NUDDED at the same time AND YOU WILL RESPECT THAT BIGOT"
In twenty to thirty years there will be a whole spew of angry adults that went through unecessary surgical procedures as children or youngcadults; encouraged and enabled by lunatics with superiority complexes; lunatics who think they know whats best for a child.
I wonder if they would be able to take legal action against those that would facilitate such procedures?
Bro i share your frustration,because clearly anyone can tell its been edited to fit their agender. I support you 100%. Im a black man, who resides in South Africa, we dont have that problem here, we have gays and lesbians but we just don't entertain their motives.
Gays and Lesbians are completely separate from this whole gender debacle in the first place, and a lot of them are against it (but will get cancelled as soon as they speak out)
The LGB movement has been taken over by literally insane people that can't even explain their own point of view.
Gender is a big part of your identity . It does NOT limit you, thanks to feminism! A woman can be an Army general, so can a guy. A man can be a first grade teacher, so can a woman. The only job I will never qualify for because I am a woman is sperm donor. Guys, none of you can ever be a surrogate mother. True, some people born with physical or hormonal problems that make gender hard to determine. I have great compassion for these people, and they deserve the best medical and psychological treatment we have. But these folks make up a very small portion of the population. Some people won't like this, but here goes: There are only 2 genders, male and female.
Sorry, but Gender has NOTHING to do with feminism.
But i still agree with you : TWO genders.
@@jocec3283 oh, I agree! Both men and women can be feminists. My point was that your gender is PART of your identity. And your gender does not limit you these days. In the past, it sure did! It was hard for women to get many jobs. But thanks to feminism, that is no longer the case in most of the world.
@@shoshanadvora8932 Right, but is still has nothing to do with gender. I fail to see you point. The point of the debate is that there is only TWO genders.
Not as many that some THINK there are...
And to "identfy" yourself as something, doesn't make you one.
You know I've taken a few debate classes and have learned apart from the introduction of course the first thing talked about and a massive foundation in the debate is definitions. Without definitions, you literally can't argue a point because there is no set point to argue and that point can just keep changing. These people literally can't get past the most basic part of definitions, and what that means is that their arguments truly have no meaning, no point, no worth, and are not able to be debated. It's truly sad just how far they have gotten and how many people they've turned to their side without having any form of a reasonable argument because their argument really isn't even worthy of being considered an argument.
I WANT that Dostoyevsky t-shirt!!
I could have preferred if you allowed us to see the parts of the interview that were deleted...but thank you for having Mike on your program.
Thanks Matt for speaking up and pointing out the obvious
I'm a half- unicorn,half-mermaid-fairy hybrid, non-binary woman who identifies as a man who identifies as a feminist banana, and I agree with Matt Walsh😆
People that make these comments have no idea about the research involved with this and probably don't even know much about intersex people
@@famvids9627 stop being weak these people are a very small minority and they are trying to force this on the entire population makes 0 sense
@@famvids9627 genuine question, have you polled a large number of intersex people to ask how they feel about being used to defend trans/non-binary ideology? You would probably find that most of them are just trying to live their lives instead of being activists to push an “agenda” that really doesn’t have anything to do with them.
That's quite a mix !!! Can I date the Mermaid ??? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@famvids9627
just because some warped weirdo in academia writes something down, doesn't make it true
your "research" is as credible as the most stupid conspiracy theories out there
Americans are going CRAZY !
It’s not just Americans….but we are leading in this insanity
@@quondamchoir6615 and whose leading the Americans? Who runs the deep state of America ? Any idea
@@bloodoranges2631 Satan does
Exactly what I woulda done, if gender and sex are both social constructs and “man made” according to these atheist secularists, then so is race “Bc I said so. I identify as a blk man so gimme my reparations for slavery, Dems”…
Thank God for you Matt! Thank you for your dedication to this work.
U didnt show what they cut as u suggested on your thumnail