Dzięki za taką pieśń i WSPANIAŁE WYKONANIE dla ŚWIATA to jest bardzo wskazane i mądre aby móc komentować do pracy n ad taką oprawę muzyczną do zobaczenia spasiba spasiba dla ludzi senk JU
Majestic in every respect! Great accompaniment, bravo Illya Rashkovsky, very good technique and nice wonderfull good playing, true! Hera Hyesasng Park - She is amazing young talented girl, just brillant Art of song singing, magnificent, emotionally and technically interpreted! Thank You Hera and Illya!
Hermosa voz de la Soprano , en la primera melodía , me encantó cómo terminó con una escala descendente , perfectamente ejecutada , hermosísima Melodía. El Pianista acompaña con maestría . Gracias por presentarnos Buena Música .La Soprano así como eleva su voz , nos eleva el Espíritu .Hermoso , hermoso .👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Bravoooo 🎹🎼🎵🎶🙏🙏🇲🇽💞💖🌼🌻🤗
저번에 박혜상 소프라노님의 유학시절 마스터 클래스를 녹화한 영상을 봤습니다. 그때의 그분은 약간 목소리를 뒤로 먹는 느낌이 있었어서 옆의 교수님께서 조언해주시면서 정말 하나하나 봐주시더라고요. 그 뒤로 열심히 맹훈련 하신 결과가 이렇게 드러나네요~!!자랑스럽고 대단하신 분b
Music for a while 음악은 잠시동안 Shall all your cares beguile: 모든 당신의 걱정을 잊게합니다: Wond'ring how your pains were eas'd 어떻게 당신의 고통이 경감되었는지 궁금해 하며 And disdaining to be pleas'd 그리고 기뻐하는 것을 업신여기며 Till Alecto free the dead 알렉토가 죽은 이를 자유롭게 할 때까지 From their eternal bands, 그들의 영원한 속박에서 (자유롭게 할 때까지), Till the snakes drop from her head, 그녀의 머리에서 뱀들이 떨어질 때까지, And the whip from out her hands. 그리고 그녀의 두 손에서 채찍이 떨어질 때까지.
Wow, Purcell in Japan! Lovely touch-I try to think how I would pronounce Japanese sounds not present in English. Just one comment, after Alecto frees the dead, there is a series of two note pairings on the word “immortal”. This may be opinion, but I have ALWAYS heard these sung in quarter tone intervals, not half tone intervals. The difference is stunning. Listen to Russell Oberlin or (sometimes) Alfred Deller, and you’ll see what I mean. But I am being the biggest of nit-pickers. She has a lovely voice and advanced skill set. Brava.
@@coco40775640 yes, I immediately noticed my egregious error and corrected my text in the following post. I’ll say it again, I’m sorry, I did not intend to be insensitive.
콜로라투라를 잘 이해못하신듯.. 최상고음에만 해당하는게 아니고 말씀하신대로 화려한기교에 해당하는 말입니다 체칠리아 바르톨리는 메조소프라노이지만 콜로라투라에 대표적인 가수입니다 밤의여왕아리아가 워낙 유명해서 마치 그 노래를 소화해야지만 콜로라투라이다 라는 인식이 생긴듯하네요 Una voce poco fa 는 대표적인 콜로라투라 곡입니다 보통 중저음가수는 발성상 화려한기교가 어려운반면 비교적 소프라노는 가벼운 고음에서 화려하게 장식음을 소화할수 있기에 하이소프라노=콜로라투라 그런인식이 생긴듯해요 이곡도 원래는 메조소프라노 곡으로 만들어진건데 반키올려서 소프라노들이 많이 부르는데 혜상님은 소프라노이면서 탄탄한 중저음을 바탕으로 원곡 그대로를 소화하셨네요 대단하세용!! 고로 아주 올바른 홍보라고 할수 있겠습니다!!
@무이유일 콜로라투라는 음색으로 구분하는게 아니고 화려한 기교있는곡을 잘 소화해내는 성악가를 말하는데요~ 소프라노를 크게 레쩨로, 리릭, 드라마틱으로 나눈다면 가장 가벼운음색의 레쩨로에 콜로라투라가 많은 편이긴 하지만 그렇다고 조수미님께서 콜로라투라곡만 하시는건 아니듯이 각자의 영역안에서 소화할수 있는 레퍼토리는 한정적이기에 영역을 넘나들기도 합니다 르네플레밍이라고 하는 소프라노가 있는데 리릭이지만 high G까지 소화하는데 고음역대에 스킬만 보면 콜로라투라인데 음색은 리릭이죠 그러면 듣는 레파토리에 따라 어디서는 콜로라투라라고 소개될것이고 또 어디서는 리릭이라고 소개할 것입니다 홍보하기 나름이라 생각됩니다~
@무이유일 네~ 잘알겠습니다~ 성악도로서 대학시절 교수님께 배우기로는 이와같이 배웠지만 활동하고 있는 지금 함께하는 여러 동료에 물었지만 선생님과 같은 생각이신분들이 많으시더라구요~ 통상적인 구분으로 나누자면 님의 의견이 맞다고 생각하지만 본질적으로 들여다 보면 제 의견 또한 틀리지는 않다고 봅니다~ 덕분에 공부 많이 했습니다~
@@lourdesm3818 Yo pienso que usted pertenece a la categoría de personas que consideran todo lo que es pasado siempre superior a lo que es presente, como algo mitológico, dogmático, que no se puede discutir. Yo, en cambio, pertenezco a la categoría de personas que juzgan las cosas con la mente abierta y libre de todo acondiciónamiento de cualquier tipo. Así que usted dice que la Callas no tiene NADA QUE VER con Hera, mientras que yo digo simplemente que Hera es superior a la Callas, bien sabiendo que estoy hablando de dos grandisimas cantantes. En resumen, usted liquìda Hera con un NADA QUE VER, lo que significa que la Callas es de otra categoría, otro planeta y que tampoco se puede comparar con la chica coreana. Y eso es claramente absurdo, considerado que Hera es indudablemente un autentico fenómeno, con una voz que es un milagro de la naturaleza, con una gran tecnica, una rara bellezza e increíble poder. Yo, por ejemplo, he escuchado "Amami Alfredo" cantada por Callas, Sutherland (decepcionantes), Tebaldi, Caballé (grandes, mucho mejores), pero, según yo, Anna Netrebko tiene algo más, especialmente en los puntos cruciales. He escuchado "Casta diva" cantada por Callas, Sutherland, Caballé (grandìsimas), pero, en este caso también, yo prefiero la Netrebko por su emisión más regular, uniforme, por su voz y timbre más redondos, suaves, pero, aquí también, es una cuestión de gustos, no me atrevería a decir que la Netrebko no tiene NADA QUE VER con las otras. Un consejo para ustedes siempre perpetuamente aferrados al pasado? Abran su mente, no saben lo que se pierden si no disfrutan con sopranos contemporáneos maravillosos como Anna Netrebko, Hera Hyesang Park, Albina Shagimuratova, Diana Damrau, Natalie Dessay...
Her coloratura is fine, her tone needs love resonating, hope, excitement and a dozen other emotions - @5:30 too shrill and repulsive... @5:50 Can't you hear that? Why record this and upload it? @6 minutes: You can't hear that repulsive tone? @8:12 Stop blasting ugly high notes. You have the musicality and technique, why are you doing this?
@@eliza-janecassey8594 Let me guess: you're not a professionally-trained bel canto operatic soprano with over 50 arias and ten languages in your repertoire - am I right?
@@WhirledPublishing I am a professional singer and PhD student with three previous music degrees, one of which is in opera (and yes, I trained in bel canto), and I speak four languages. I don't think professionalism is measured in quantity of arias, however. Mostly I just don't think it's very nice to write mean comments, even if her voice is not to your taste.
@@eliza-janecassey8594 Professionalism is not measured in the number of "degrees" one achieves at low level institutions. Your lack of ear training is conspicuous - you would never graduate with any degree from a reputable music conservatory. You also need to discern truth from fiction - her coloratura is fine - her tone on her high notes is horrendous because she is pushing and shoving instead of simply opening up and allowing the glorious tones to flow. As a Doctoral Scholar who knows the difference between telling the truth and being cruel, I trust you will develop some maturity and learn that helping a singer to tune in more clearly to the sounds she is projecting is more important than applauding her. I care more about her professional potential than her feelings at the moment - she knows she has a great future as an opera star - she's not stupid - but pushing and shoving her high notes is making them sound ugly - I'm not hearing her tender emotions of joy or elation - it's her fear of her high notes I'm hearing - and she should stop - she needs to open up her throat as if she's yawning for each breath she takes, she needs to lift her soft palate with each inhalation - to reach her high notes, she needs to open up the hinge of her jaw by lowering her jaw - she needs to this with passion and commitment - not to follow directions but to achieve the glorious artistry and beauty that she is capable of achieving. She needs to expand her lungs and throat more by inhaling more air - in to her lungs and into her throat - this expansion will stretch her soft tissue which will provide more resonance - this is why she needs to lift her soft palate to transform the "jelly" of her tissues into a hard surface that can help her create more resonance with her tone, then she will have a gorgeous round tone in her high notes instead of giving us this nightmare. If you're doing this same nonsense with your high notes that she does, you should stop it too. If you aspire to be a professional opera singer, find someone you know with perfect pitch, find an opera house, barrel-vaulted church or some other structure with decent acoustics, go in there and sing your arias a capella to your friend with perfect pitch - when he or she winces, that's your clue that you're singing off pitch - this will help you to tune in which will improve the quality of your singing. By the way, to brag about an Associate's degree in Music is to broadcast that you're ten years behind your competition who learned Music Theory as a child - typically as pianists or violinists. When you have over 50 arias by Mozart, Puccini, Rossini, Strauss, Verdi, Vivialdi and dozens of other composers - in your performance repertoire - come back and let's have an intelligent conversation about "professionalism". To sing this repertoire, massive technique is required - no one will help you develop this vocal technique until your ear training is highly developed.
@@WhirledPublishing University of Toronto and McGill are not low-level institutions, and mine are not Associate's degrees, and you did ask about my qualifications. I have sung all of those composers and also know how to spell their names. All I was trying to say was that a good instructor would not give such brutish "feedback" on TH-cam and would know the difference between subjective technical decisions and the very high esteem in which they hold their own opinion. But thank you for your essay, very moving.
![[박혜상 Hera Hyesang Park & 일리야 라쉬코프스키] 퍼셀: 음악은 잠시동안 Purcell: Music for a while](/img/n.gif)
And excellent Italian pronuciation
I've been looking for a kind of modern opera. Finally found it..
Not modern at all Purcell is very old. 400 years more
I agree it ~!👍
최고! 또 듣고 듣네요.
Hola a todos, amo la profundidad de sus graves, los agudos, ya sabemos no son un problema. Saludos desde Corrientes Argentina.
어서
무대서
뵙고싶습니다
사랑스럽고
준비잘된연주
배경도 얼마나
근사한지요
행복하게
감상했습니다
고맙습니다!!
꺠끗하고 청아한 목소리, 세계 톱 오브 톱 클래스입니다. 자랑스럽습니다. 오늘 부터 팬 입니다.
Fantastic.....singer and pianist!!
너무 아름답습니다.. 자랑스럽고 그래서 기쁩니다.
피아노 연주도 좋네요 감사합니다
Dzięki za taką pieśń i WSPANIAŁE WYKONANIE dla ŚWIATA to jest bardzo wskazane i mądre aby móc komentować do pracy n ad taką oprawę muzyczną do zobaczenia spasiba spasiba dla ludzi senk JU
Majestic in every respect! Great accompaniment, bravo Illya Rashkovsky, very good technique and nice wonderfull good playing, true! Hera Hyesasng Park - She is amazing young talented girl, just brillant Art of song singing, magnificent, emotionally and technically interpreted! Thank You Hera and Illya!
Meraviglioso
Normally I don’t really like this type of voice, but this, and the aria, and the singer are beautiful - a lovely package. Congratulations.
What do you mean by these kind of voice please 🙏 if you do not mind... thank you in advance
Grandiosa, impressionante, straordinaria !!! E anche fine, bellissima!
Bravi tutti due!!!!
A very gifted pianist too.
Voice of an angel
한국적인 아름다운 공간, 아름다운 혜상님의 목소리와 외모, 아름다운 연주 모든것이 조화롭네요🌸🌸🌸
Bravissimo!!!!!!
너무 멋진 풍경과 황홀한 음악에 감사합니다~
Brava e bella HERA !!!
천사가 따로 없습니다
정말 아름다운 노래입니다
Hermosa voz de la Soprano , en la primera melodía , me encantó cómo terminó con una escala descendente , perfectamente ejecutada , hermosísima Melodía. El Pianista acompaña con maestría . Gracias por presentarnos Buena Música .La Soprano así como eleva su voz , nos eleva el Espíritu .Hermoso , hermoso .👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Bravoooo 🎹🎼🎵🎶🙏🙏🇲🇽💞💖🌼🌻🤗
magnifici, voce meravigliosa.
배경은 고풍스럽고 혜상님의 음색은 아름답고 연주도 좋아요.
늘어지는 주말에 빠져들며 보고 있어요.
한옥에서의 소프라노음성
또다른 분위기와
하모니가 느껴집니다 🤗🤗🤗
9⁸9el
아름답고 여린데 어쩜 우렁찬 목소리로 마음을 사로잡는지 듣고 있노라면 요식업을하는 저에게 그 어느것과도 바꿀수없는 보약이네요 하염없이 예 쁘기만 하니 어쩜 좋을까요 혜상님 부모님은 얼마나 좋으실까 모습이 그려지네요 ~^^ ♡♡♡
저렇게 예쁜 정상급의 소프라노가 내 딸이라면 밥 안 먹어도 배부르실 듯.
Bravos
okay WOW 🤩
좋은 목소리군요
천사의 목소리~~
Cudownie, pięknie czysty, ciepły głos 👏👏👏👏👏👏
Gracias, hermosa interpretación.
Woooow me encantó!!!!
Exquisita voz e Interpresentacion.
Bravo!
Excelso. Lenguaje solo de nuestras huestes celestiales AL ALTISIMO..
Dziękuję
Że
Mogła
Cię
Usłyszeć
W tak
Pięknym
Głosie
Dziękuję
Pozdrawiam
Ela
Maravilloso 😍
쏘 뷰리플♡
아름다워요♡ 행복하고 감사한 아침을 여는 소리네요:)
Amazing! Minutely worked out technique!
Preciosa voz!
Bellísimo
너무 좋아요ㅠㅠ
Splendid
So beautiful, this voice is wonderful
And the piano Player la excellent 👍
Beautiful!
great!
너무 아름다워요!!!!
Exquisite! ✨
Beautiful,!!!! Thank you 🙏
잘했어요!😉
Wow! Beautiful..such a pleasure to watch and hear. Thank you very much for the music!
Q%Q
환상적입니다. 반주도 노래도 최고입니다.
perfect~
반해버렸어요.
Gracias
Exquisito
Ohhh 💘
병원 입원중인데 너무 감동 받았고 은혜로운 심금을 울리는 하나님계 감사합니다
muy muy bonito
y una ejecución admirable ...
목소리를 음정에 떨어지지않고 발음도 입안의뒤로먹지않고서양의본토top성악가처럼 잘부르십니다!!👌
저번에 박혜상 소프라노님의 유학시절 마스터 클래스를 녹화한 영상을 봤습니다.
그때의 그분은 약간 목소리를 뒤로 먹는 느낌이 있었어서 옆의 교수님께서 조언해주시면서 정말 하나하나 봐주시더라고요.
그 뒤로 열심히 맹훈련 하신 결과가 이렇게 드러나네요~!!자랑스럽고 대단하신 분b
Marávilosa
Hermosa vos !!
03:50 Una voce poco fa
목소리가훌륭한악기네요~~정말아름답네요~~감사히듣고있습니다~~
Impressionante l'emissione vocale rispetto all'apertura della bocca!
Are you the same like the organist and the pianist?
😱😲😯😮😦🤤🥇🏆🌟🎇🎉🎆🎊🍾🎂👌👍 bravísimo
I wants You on Poland! 🥰
전율이 흐르고 소름이돋고,끝 부분엔
답답함이 확 뚫리는 느낌이듭니다!
Bueno
이쁘고 날씬한데 어떻게 그런 소리가 나죠?!?
노래는 살하고 관계가 없나봐요~!!!
Que voz mas hermosa!!!
아름답습니다.
И это реальность!!!
Wow
❤️💜❤️💜❤️💜
Music for a while
음악은 잠시동안
Shall all your cares beguile:
모든 당신의 걱정을 잊게합니다:
Wond'ring how your pains were eas'd
어떻게 당신의 고통이 경감되었는지 궁금해 하며
And disdaining to be pleas'd
그리고 기뻐하는 것을 업신여기며
Till Alecto free the dead
알렉토가 죽은 이를 자유롭게 할 때까지
From their eternal bands,
그들의 영원한 속박에서 (자유롭게 할 때까지),
Till the snakes drop from her head,
그녀의 머리에서 뱀들이 떨어질 때까지,
And the whip from out her hands.
그리고 그녀의 두 손에서 채찍이 떨어질 때까지.
😍😍🤩🤩💖💖💖
😮😮😮💙🎶
Wow, Purcell in Japan! Lovely touch-I try to think how I would pronounce Japanese sounds not present in English. Just one comment, after Alecto frees the dead, there is a series of two note pairings on the word “immortal”. This may be opinion, but I have ALWAYS heard these sung in quarter tone intervals, not half tone intervals. The difference is stunning. Listen to Russell Oberlin or (sometimes) Alfred Deller, and you’ll see what I mean. But I am being the biggest of nit-pickers. She has a lovely voice and advanced skill set. Brava.
she is korean & this is seoul^^
@@coco40775640 yes, I immediately noticed my egregious error and corrected my text in the following post. I’ll say it again, I’m sorry, I did not intend to be insensitive.
엠비씨 에술무대 티비 ( 밤 프로) 에서 뵈었습니다~
Béllísìmás
자기소계도 ? 구금합니다.
아름다운 소리 잘 들었습니다.
더 넓은 곳을 향하시리라 기도드립니다.
아름다운 목소리는 가꾸는게 아니고
가지고
태어난것 같아요
너무 좋아요 !
목소리가좋아서 자꾸듣게되네요♡
어쩜 에쁘게 잘부르는지...
So sorry, Korean not Japanese. Not being sure (beauty is international) I should have written “Asian”.
이거올리신분.. 박혜상님은 콜로라투라는아니죠
콜로라투라는 조수미 담라우 유성녀 이런분들이죠
최상고음과 화려한기교...
모르는분이 보면 오해하시겠네요 ...
홍보는좋지만 이런식은...아닌듯하네요
성악에대한이해도 최고시고 감정표현도 최고의소프라노라고생각해요
잘감사히 감상하고 가요
갑분성녀
콜로라투라를 잘 이해못하신듯..
최상고음에만 해당하는게 아니고 말씀하신대로 화려한기교에 해당하는 말입니다
체칠리아 바르톨리는 메조소프라노이지만 콜로라투라에 대표적인 가수입니다
밤의여왕아리아가 워낙 유명해서 마치 그 노래를 소화해야지만 콜로라투라이다 라는 인식이 생긴듯하네요
Una voce poco fa 는 대표적인 콜로라투라 곡입니다
보통 중저음가수는 발성상 화려한기교가 어려운반면 비교적 소프라노는 가벼운 고음에서 화려하게 장식음을 소화할수 있기에 하이소프라노=콜로라투라 그런인식이 생긴듯해요
이곡도 원래는 메조소프라노 곡으로 만들어진건데 반키올려서 소프라노들이 많이 부르는데 혜상님은 소프라노이면서 탄탄한 중저음을 바탕으로 원곡 그대로를 소화하셨네요 대단하세용!!
고로 아주 올바른 홍보라고 할수 있겠습니다!!
@무이유일 콜로라투라는 음색으로 구분하는게 아니고 화려한 기교있는곡을 잘 소화해내는 성악가를 말하는데요~ 소프라노를 크게 레쩨로, 리릭, 드라마틱으로 나눈다면 가장 가벼운음색의 레쩨로에 콜로라투라가 많은 편이긴 하지만 그렇다고 조수미님께서 콜로라투라곡만 하시는건 아니듯이 각자의 영역안에서 소화할수 있는 레퍼토리는 한정적이기에 영역을 넘나들기도 합니다
르네플레밍이라고 하는 소프라노가 있는데 리릭이지만 high G까지 소화하는데 고음역대에 스킬만 보면 콜로라투라인데 음색은 리릭이죠 그러면 듣는 레파토리에 따라 어디서는 콜로라투라라고 소개될것이고 또 어디서는 리릭이라고 소개할 것입니다 홍보하기 나름이라 생각됩니다~
@무이유일 네~ 잘알겠습니다~ 성악도로서 대학시절 교수님께 배우기로는 이와같이 배웠지만 활동하고 있는 지금 함께하는 여러 동료에 물었지만 선생님과 같은 생각이신분들이 많으시더라구요~ 통상적인 구분으로 나누자면 님의 의견이 맞다고 생각하지만 본질적으로 들여다 보면 제 의견 또한 틀리지는 않다고 봅니다~
덕분에 공부 많이 했습니다~
ㅣ
.
6:15
.
...CARECE. DE CALOR Y DE ALMA..
...además intenta imittar el estilo de LA CALLAS...NO LO CONSIGGUE...
@@lourdesm3818 Es superior a la Callas.
Què????????
@@ANTONIOTONI68 ...he escuchado a MARIA CALLAS CON ALFREDO KRAUS, en PORTUGAL, sin ARREGLOS , desde un escenario...NADA QUE VER...
@@lourdesm3818 Yo pienso que usted pertenece a la categoría de personas que consideran todo lo que es pasado siempre superior a lo que es presente, como algo mitológico, dogmático, que no se puede discutir. Yo, en cambio, pertenezco a la categoría de personas que juzgan las cosas con la mente abierta y libre de todo acondiciónamiento de cualquier tipo. Así que usted dice que la Callas no tiene NADA QUE VER con Hera, mientras que yo digo simplemente que Hera es superior a la Callas, bien sabiendo que estoy hablando de dos grandisimas cantantes. En resumen, usted liquìda Hera con un NADA QUE VER, lo que significa que la Callas es de otra categoría, otro planeta y que tampoco se puede comparar con la chica coreana. Y eso es claramente absurdo, considerado que Hera es indudablemente un autentico fenómeno, con una voz que es un milagro de la naturaleza, con una gran tecnica, una rara bellezza e increíble poder. Yo, por ejemplo, he escuchado "Amami Alfredo" cantada por Callas, Sutherland (decepcionantes), Tebaldi, Caballé (grandes, mucho mejores), pero, según yo, Anna Netrebko tiene algo más, especialmente en los puntos cruciales. He escuchado "Casta diva" cantada por Callas, Sutherland, Caballé (grandìsimas), pero, en este caso también, yo prefiero la Netrebko por su emisión más regular, uniforme, por su voz y timbre más redondos, suaves, pero, aquí también, es una cuestión de gustos, no me atrevería a decir que la Netrebko no tiene NADA QUE VER con las otras. Un consejo para ustedes siempre perpetuamente aferrados al pasado? Abran su mente, no saben lo que se pierden si no disfrutan con sopranos contemporáneos maravillosos como Anna Netrebko, Hera Hyesang Park, Albina Shagimuratova, Diana Damrau, Natalie Dessay...
Have a good interpretation the role with the music thats good the voice is light soprano a little screams but not bad
QUE BELLEZA Y HERMOSA VOZ
FELICIDADES
전성기 조수미씨보다도 못하지 않은 것 같습니다. 감사합니다. 잘 들었습니다
chinoise extraordinaire
Coréenne
no Ab3. but brava
Ja takze
Si pero respira por la boca y se le escucha 🤔
내 솔직히...더 열심히...자랑질하지말고...백번 들었나.ㅎㅎ..ㅣ소리
Her coloratura is fine, her tone needs love resonating, hope, excitement and a dozen other emotions - @5:30 too shrill and repulsive... @5:50 Can't you hear that? Why record this and upload it? @6 minutes: You can't hear that repulsive tone? @8:12 Stop blasting ugly high notes. You have the musicality and technique, why are you doing this?
You have too much time on your hands.. I think she sounds like Callas
@@eliza-janecassey8594 Let me guess: you're not a professionally-trained bel canto operatic soprano with over 50 arias and ten languages in your repertoire - am I right?
@@WhirledPublishing I am a professional singer and PhD student with three previous music degrees, one of which is in opera (and yes, I trained in bel canto), and I speak four languages. I don't think professionalism is measured in quantity of arias, however. Mostly I just don't think it's very nice to write mean comments, even if her voice is not to your taste.
@@eliza-janecassey8594 Professionalism is not measured in the number of "degrees" one achieves at low level institutions. Your lack of ear training is conspicuous - you would never graduate with any degree from a reputable music conservatory.
You also need to discern truth from fiction - her coloratura is fine - her tone on her high notes is horrendous because she is pushing and shoving instead of simply opening up and allowing the glorious tones to flow.
As a Doctoral Scholar who knows the difference between telling the truth and being cruel, I trust you will develop some maturity and learn that helping a singer to tune in more clearly to the sounds she is projecting is more important than applauding her.
I care more about her professional potential than her feelings at the moment - she knows she has a great future as an opera star - she's not stupid - but pushing and shoving her high notes is making them sound ugly - I'm not hearing her tender emotions of joy or elation - it's her fear of her high notes I'm hearing - and she should stop - she needs to open up her throat as if she's yawning for each breath she takes, she needs to lift her soft palate with each inhalation - to reach her high notes, she needs to open up the hinge of her jaw by lowering her jaw - she needs to this with passion and commitment - not to follow directions but to achieve the glorious artistry and beauty that she is capable of achieving.
She needs to expand her lungs and throat more by inhaling more air - in to her lungs and into her throat - this expansion will stretch her soft tissue which will provide more resonance - this is why she needs to lift her soft palate to transform the "jelly" of her tissues into a hard surface that can help her create more resonance with her tone, then she will have a gorgeous round tone in her high notes instead of giving us this nightmare.
If you're doing this same nonsense with your high notes that she does, you should stop it too.
If you aspire to be a professional opera singer, find someone you know with perfect pitch, find an opera house, barrel-vaulted church or some other structure with decent acoustics, go in there and sing your arias a capella to your friend with perfect pitch - when he or she winces, that's your clue that you're singing off pitch - this will help you to tune in which will improve the quality of your singing.
By the way, to brag about an Associate's degree in Music is to broadcast that you're ten years behind your competition who learned Music Theory as a child - typically as pianists or violinists.
When you have over 50 arias by Mozart, Puccini, Rossini, Strauss, Verdi, Vivialdi and dozens of other composers - in your performance repertoire - come back and let's have an intelligent conversation about "professionalism". To sing this repertoire, massive technique is required - no one will help you develop this vocal technique until your ear training is highly developed.
@@WhirledPublishing University of Toronto and McGill are not low-level institutions, and mine are not Associate's degrees, and you did ask about my qualifications. I have sung all of those composers and also know how to spell their names. All I was trying to say was that a good instructor would not give such brutish "feedback" on TH-cam and would know the difference between subjective technical decisions and the very high esteem in which they hold their own opinion. But thank you for your essay, very moving.