The Real Reason ASL Signs Differ From Person to Person
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 มิ.ย. 2024
- Have you looked up signs on the internet and seen variations and wondered... Who is right? Am I signing it wrong? Are they signing it wrong? 🤔 Well, you're not alone, in this video we'll answer those questions and more. You will see diversity in signs because of regional variations, evolution of signs over time and personal/regional signing styles.
🤟 Follow us on FB: / learnhowtosign
🤟 Follow us on IG: / learnhowtosign_official
More From LHTS
✅ FREE RESOURCE | 10 DAY ASL JUMPSTART: eepurl.com/hfQY_X
✅ MEMBERSHIP | 🚀 LHTS ACCELERATED: learnhowtosign.org/accelerate...
✅ LIVE ASL COURSES | 🤟 LHTS INTENSIVES: learnhowtosign.org/intensives
✅ ON-DEMAND ASL COURSES: learnhowtosign.org/courses/
✅ WEBSITE: LearnHowToSign.org
✅ SKILLSHARE COURSES: skl.sh/3lTNbY2
✅ LHTS MERCH: learnhowtosign.org/store
NAVIGATION
0:00 - Intro
0:24 - Which is right? Who is wrong?
0:44 - 1. Regional Variations
2:41 - 2. Evolution of Signs Over Time
4:13 - 3. Personal / Regional Signing Styles
5:21 - The Answer
5:56 - Encouragement
#asl #learnasl #learnhowtosign
LIke you say, not all hearing impaired people sign the same around the world. My instructor taught me sooo many different signs "accents" from all over the world. It was so much fun to learn.
Yesterday I watched some videos about how the Indigenous people in America were forced to NOT use their Hand Signs, as they called it, but were forced to learn to lip read! Then, they were forced to use the ASL the teachers wanted them to use. Indigenous hand signs are starting to return. So you will see more and more of them come out. I, for one, am glad to see that THEY actually kept it alive to the point that they had something to go on! Very fascinating video. Thank you, Meredith.
Thank you!
Hearing impaired was a term used in the 1800s and the people who created the term did not know that it was offensive but, that term is no longer used!
I keep seeing the asl learning and the native asl communities arguing over wrong signing. I’m glad I came across this video. I’m from the south east. I know signs will be different here. So now I see why people are saying become a part of the asl community in your area.
It's always good to learn & know all the different signs that actually mean the same thing,
So when someone else signs it differently,
We will still know what their signing & still be able to comprehend the conversations.
You've always been superb with your vids, but now you're simply AMAZING. I LOVE IT
🥰
Meredith is my favorite asl teacher/interpreter.
I had such curiosity anout sign language across the globe. I'm learning ASL because we are getting people who are deaf/mute and not a lot of people in the office that know and/or understand ASL.
Thank you for that information! 😊 My daughter was learning to sign a song 🎶 for sign language class in school, and she was frustrated that each video she watched, they would sign certain words differently. 😤 And she would ask me which one is right? 🤔 And I had no idea!?! 🤷🏼♀️ Now I can tell her that it can vary depending on the region, kind of like an accent. 😉
I really enjoyed this! I love learning ASL, but with that comes a love for learning the culture and background behind ASL. Thank you, Meredith!
Thank you. I needed this video So Much! This channel is absolutely helpful but this is a reminder that ultimately ASL has a relational purpose, to speak with living people, not just theoretical rules and knowledge (though they can be very helpful).
YES!!!
I’m going to a Deaf Coffee Chat tomorrow for an assignment in my high school ASL 1 class, and what I’ve learned from the class and from you’re channel have both helped me and will definitely be of good use tomorrow night!
Hey, could you do a video that covers a lot of different C-shape words? I get them so confused because they feel so arbitrary -- just put the C-hand here and shake it like this and it means Computer or Cookie or Church or Cooking or whatever. I'm typically pretty good with forming mnemonics and ASL has a lot of non-arbitrary parts (compared to spoken languages), but these signs in particular just don't seem to stick. Would love to see similar signs compare-and-contrasted so that I can finally get them straight in my head!
Ideally you'd also contrast them with what the same location means without a letter-sign. Like, tapping fists together is Work, and maybe I can tie the C version done in similar fashion (tapping C on fist) to "work" in a mnemonic.
I have a question. I've been watching your content for about a year or so, and I love it. I find it really easy to remember the signs. However, I have a disability that involves involuntary muscle spasms, and in ASL, I think that would be considered a stutter because I can't use both hands when I'm having an attack. What would your advice be?
This was and is needed! I learned when I was much younger and boy how signs have changed since then.
I ❤ your videos!
SOOOOOOO INFORMATIVE!!! 💎💎
Where I work, many Hearing learn a few signs for my Deaf coworker, but they tend to learn them without the finesse, and the sign for "Paper" they do forward, like "Clean-up". My Deaf coworker even tried to gaslight me about this, as well as the Hearing coworker who she tends to write back/forth with, as she doesn't know sign. I learned from Bill Vicars who teaches most variations, learning 28 months, and I've seen where I work, how that alteration came about, Hearing coworkers' rigidity gets in the way so they do it badly, and my Deaf coworker capitulated.
I've started learning through an app that's really great.. but as soon as I turn on youtube and see different instructors and videos.. I begin to feel like I have to 're-learn' a lot of it again.
I truly enjoyed this video, very informative and interesting.
That’s great and it’s an awesome video but it really deterred me from learning any more asl. I learned Japanese and it was easier than asl. The fact that there are several signs for the same word across the country is daunting. I struggle with anxiety ptsd and depression. I do not need people making fun of me for using the wrong sign. This was good to know because at least I won’t waste my time learning only to find out I have to learn what all regions use. Maybe I will go learn German or something 😊
Wow. Thanks so much. I always was aware of regional variations in spoken language. I speak several. I had never applied that concept to ASL. 😊
Im from Guatemala and we have the same situation bc in south of the country we have a lot tourist so the show different signs so in the City we signs different but we understand it
Love your videos you have helped me so much😁
Great video.
I used to work at a coffee shop with a woman who was deaf. I tried to learn sign language, so I could communicate with her, which I must admit, was incredibly difficult. I learned the sign for coffee, which, as you know, looks like you're hand-grinding coffee. She would use this same sign to refer to the bar where lattes were made. To me, those are very different things, but looking back, there was no one there to communicate a different sign for the different items, and maybe she just threw it into a general category. It's frustrating that I never got good enough to really communicate with her, but I've learned so much about the deaf community as a result. It's a shame ASL isn't taught to everyone at the elementary school level. Deaf people are very much left out of our society because we can't communicate using their language. I know that there aren't even many deaf individuals who are able to sign, and I think that would change if it were made more universal.
SALAAM ALYKUMA THANKS MY TEACHER 🎉🎉🎉
I have a question, why do I have to use my dominant hand? Can't I use any that to sign?
INTRO CUTE, VIDEO INFORMATIVE. Sometimes I think the word pop sounds like the ASL slang PAH. Thank you always for your work to help us improve.
You are so welcome!
I borrow a lot of signs for Italian cities from Italian Sign because my Deaf school had a partnership with a deaf school there. And, I sign birthday p close to what you do, but different movement. Deaf plus - with Parkinson’s cerebral palsy MS and degenerative conditions of the joint’s will have different styles b/c brains and bodies work different.
WOW. I didn't know that there were millions of ways to sign language in a different way. With "can't" I did that sign. Look how they came up with "COVID" and text or playing video games. Each technology or disease changes every year and I know when I was little I was signing chicken and then pox (as pointing on arm with flicking popcorn) as chick pox. It's was crazy how things change over the past year. I even gave my daughter this site so she can brush up her sign language again.
Interesting! I took Level 1 ASL with Sign Language Center, my teacher was Deaf and she told that hearing impaired was a term in the 1800s and that the people who created the term didn’t know it was offensive, still, the term is no longer used. I find the term offensive and I personally got very angry when one of my COMHAB Workers said that had a hearing impairment.
Also, I asked my teacher how to sign “French” in ASL so, I could show my best friend (who I met at an African-American Heritage Festival) who was unable to take the class with me because we met through sign language since I was mute when I met him but, found another way to communicate with me!
Thx
I want to see more shopping signs
it'a kinda like accents i imagine. like how someone from southern america (like florida) sounds dif from someone in northern america (like new york).
Hello, could you, tell me what would be the differencse for Canada region? Thank you I love your chanel!
same
I knew about sign language when I watched the movie Dawn of the planet of the apes. Will you make a video about the signs used by the apes in this movie in future ?
Ive been wanting to learn asl for quite some time and I came across your videos the most. They are so helpful and informative, thank you! I do have a question though, does asl change the meaning or grammar for those who are left hand, right hand or even Ambidextral? Cause I tend to be both although I use my right hand for writing only.
No, which hand you use does not change the meaning of the word. But...try not to switch in between hands, that gets confusing for other people.
Recently saw a 3rd sign for the word "grace".
Definitely confusing for those of us just learning.
Noticed your articulating hand on the shelf. Ordered one to help teach my grandson, but it couldn't make all the letters. Can you recommend one that can?
ihad my captions on and it said fighting style instead of signing style
❤❤❤
How do I fully learn ASL from videos
Videos are helpful, but I recommend practicing with people who are Deaf. They are the best to learn from because it is their language. Some Starbucks have deaf chat, an informal gathering of Deaf and folks learning ASL. When I attended deaf chats, I found that Deaf were welcoming and helpful because they knew I was learning ASL. Additionally, there are different meet up groups, deaf plays with voice interpretation, college courses, and many other avenues to practice. Go online to find one you might like and then try it. Enjoy your learning curve.
THIS!
@@LearnHowtoSign You are so funny, Meredith ✌🏼
POP
💜
Man talk about mean girls😂
Northern and Midwest folks: you want some pop??
Southerners: Gretchen stop tryin to make pop happen!!! It's not going to happen,!!!
🥰👏🏼👏🏼
🎉🎉🎉🎉
I heard that you are fluent in ASL when you know all 26 signs but, if language keeps changing as our world keeps changing, is there REALLY such a thing as being fluent in the language? 🤷🏾♀️🤔
My best friend lost a significant portion of his tongue to oral cancer a tad over a year ago. He beat the cancer, but was left mute with ASL as his main form of communication. Add to this the fact that Finnish is his first language, not English. This makes him a hearing person who speaks ASL as a third language. As you can predict, his signing style is rather unique to him at times. We regularly attend silent chats, deaf coffees, etc. together and it's never proven an issue. The deaf people we've come across at these events have been more than happy help direct him when he's way off. I've loved watching him grow into his new language.
how to sign pneumonoultramicroscopicsilicovolcanoconiosis in ASL
do you just spell it?