@@fuckcancer8679 Not necessary must be 12 years old to feel it, granpa. If u had experience of losing someone that u love, then you'll understand this. Till then, u'll mock others. Age doesn't matter.
So true, sober is right up there though. Sober was a pretty great help when it was time to go through the rehab experience and made getting through it much easier
I lost my first husband to heroin addiction. I remember begging and crying for him to get help. He completely changed. From a sweetheart who bought me coffee every morning in college, to someone i barely recognized. This song has been with me a long time. It helped me get through it.
I lost my son to suicide in 2007 at the age of 23. My daughter sent me this video today and though it made me cry, it also brought back so many memories. The pain of losing him has become a part of me that I live with every day. There are a lot of good days now, but even on those days the pain is always there. I thank God and my faith that has gotten me through all these years, and my beautiful daughter who not only lost a father to suicide when she was 12 (she's now 47) but a brother also. My heart goes out to all those who have lost loved ones, and may God bless you each day ❤
My heart goes out to you Yvonne as long as their in you and your daughters hearts their not gone.just keep thinking about the great memories and good times
P!nk is one of the very few mainstream artists nowadays that actually makes me feel something whenever I listen to their music. This song never fails me... definitely one of my favorites by her. It was released eight years ago, but still gets played on the radio from time to time. Great example of a timeless song
I am so very sorry for your loss. This song is near and dear to me for the loss of my best friend, many years ago, to this disease. I pray that you get a bit more peace, day by day.
I've lost family members to diseases but the loss still hurts even to this day. I lost the love of my life in 1990, mother in 2017 and my brother in 2019. It still hurts now.
I’m so sorry for your loss😢 I lost my sister 7 years ago due to addiction. She had endocarditis (an infection from dirty needles). She was 23 & had a 3 year old. My parents were never the same after that. Praying for you
i honestly love P!nk. She is my favourite singer. She has pulled me through so much, her lyrics seen me through my teens, through the lost of my brother, through my mother abandoning her family... Being alone wasnt as bad with P!nks album; but this song tears me apart. Her music is so strong and meaningful, no matter what shes singing about, and that is exactly why she is loved. Such a strong woman who says exactly what she thinks and feels.
+Shadae Middleton Well put. I'm in my 50's and I can relate to the lyrics of her songs, Perfect, Conversations with my 13 year old self, Dear Mr President, Sober and many more resonate with me. She's a very underrated artist. She should be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, in my opinion.
13 years later and I still can’t listen to this song without crying. The older I get, the more I understand the line “time makes it harder.” When I was 21, I had to leave college to begin taking care of my sisters kids because she passed away. I finally returned to school to finish that degree and I graduate in May. As much as I want to be happy, it hurts so much that she won’t be there to see me walk across that stage as a college graduate. Every milestone event that happens makes you miss them more. Sending love and light to everyone that has lost someone that they love and must continue through life with that deep scar on your heart ❤️.
@@dakotaracine8842 losing a sibling is so hard. My sister passed in 2004 and I still have to catch myself when something big happens and I instinctively want to call and tell her about it, but then I remember that I can’t. I pray for your peace. One thing that I do know is that they become our guardian angels and watch over us for the rest of our lives 😇💖
im not sure if youve walked that stage yet, however i promise you our lost loved ones are always near. u just have to get familar with the sign their giving. IM SO PROUD OF YOU, if no one has told you as well. its an accomplishment im workin on myself. sending lots of love and support your way
@@tyriqsmith5211 thank you so much for the words of encouragement. I walk across it next month, and I’m sure you’ll be walking across it too in the near future. Sending good vibes and well wishes your way.
Lost my bestfriend in 2015 and my mom has always loved pink my entire life . Between her fighting her demons and losing my friend this song hits a tender spot no matter the mood I’m In. JUST ONLY IF …. 😢💙
I know this is about Pink’s loss of a friend due to addiction, but, it makes me think of losing my mom so fast to pancreatic cancer. Hugs to all those listening today.
It's about losing any loved one, from any reason. Could be a parent, a lover, or even a pet. I am sorry for your loss, just know that she cannot wait to be able to see you again.
I lost my best friend of 25 years to Pancreatic cancer 2 years ago. She was only 40. This song just hits me right in the heart. I am sorry for your loss. Pancreatic cancer can eff right off.
@@Cal90208 I lost my aunt I think I was only 2 when she died but my whole life I was told she was just my mums best friend until recently I found out she was actually my dads sister This song was played at the funeral and even tho I don’t remember her I feel like this song is the only connection I have with her so it makes me cry.. I also saw pictures of her recently and I look like her I just wish I could meet her and remember her “That last kiss I’ll cherish until we meet again” “I wish I could remember” “But I keep your memory you visit me in my sleep”- apparently when I was 3 I ran down to my mum and said “aunty lelly visited me in my sleep” and described her perfectly RIP lelly cole Until we meet again 💔❤️
@@lisapuma6059 I smile and laugh all the time thinking about his wry humor. Just this morning I thought about one of his little quips and it had me chuckling. When I see him again I'll let him know.
I remember a eulogy. "Remember me with happiness and laughter for if you can only remember me with saddness and tears it's better not to remember me at all." As Star Trek's Tasha Yar said "As long as someone remembers me I'm never truly dead."
I'm so sorry for your passing...I lost my sister 3 years ago and it still feels like yesterday. She left me her two boys behind and I'm still lost trying to raise them..time doesn't heal all wounds, everyone is different...just hang in there, she is with you every sunshine day and every beautiful clear starry night.. you will see her again ❤ Hold on to that in your heart!! It keeps you alive knowing that my friend 😊 trust me!
I didn’t understand the meaning of this song when I was a kid. Now all these years later I know what she’s talking about. One of my friends died from cancer almost 2 years ago. I think of him when I hear this song.
@@jennyphillips5589 yesterday i read something that made me smile and maybe it would help you. it said: when you walk into a garden to pick flowers what flowers do you look for? the answer, the prettiest. god chose the prettiest he could find. i hope this helps you
My dad, the most stable person in my life and my best friend, died yesterday in corona. He was by himself in the hospital. I could not say goodbye to him. Listening to this song and crying, how can I live without him.
This comment thread is filled with heartwarming but also depressing stories from people who have lost their loved ones :( I hope y'all are doing OK...my heart goes out to everyone who cried as they listened to this song
What made you cynical? Maybe the message and emotions in this song brings back the weakness you locked under that cynicism. I don't know you and I don't mean to presume, but I'm a little younger than you and a lot of sensitivity and pain I lock away I also answer with sarcasm and cynicism. I wish you all the best in life, man. Take care.
Never gave any attention to this song before last year... I listened to it while I was in a really bad mental state and boy the lyrics touched me so much. Great song, probably one of the best all time in my opinion, and that's coming from a metal fan.
@A7XdemesticPk I too love my metal, but cover both metal, hard rock ... and ballads lol. You are right, this song can touch us at any stage of our life. I played this on my piano channel and both the metal fans and pop music people love the interpretation because it is emotional 😘
I just randomly played this song on a Saturday morning and the moment it started I bawl my eyes out crying. I remember listening to it when I was 12-13 years old. Now at 25 it hits different. Thank you Pink for such a timeless song.
I saw an interview with Pink, and she commented that this song means different things to different people, and she liked that. I was four when my mother died, and soon my father threw all of his children in the street. I went to juvenile detention, near a dozen foster homes, and a state orphanage before running away to live however I could, sometimes on the street, until I was eighteen. The relevance of this to your song is that I was never, not even once, close enough to anyone to grieve their passing, but that changed February '21; my best friend and mentor who guided my career from eighteen until my retirement died, on my birthday. I've never grieved before, reminding myself in preparation for his passing when he got cancer, and, sadly, he soon lost his fight, leaving me to contend with thoughts and feelings I had not anticipated, not until the end. I'd already heard Who Knew, but, like many, I thought it was just a breakup song until I heard her interview. I'm sixty-five now and whenever I hear it I'm filled with memories of my great friend who loved me like a son. The tears come easily when, like her, I hope to see my friend again in that far beyond. Thank you, Pink. P.S., last night I dreamed that you called me on the phone, but then, like all such dreams, you were not there anymore as I woke up calling your name.
+Brandi Bozeman I'm so sorry for your loss... This song reminds me to my dad, who died almost 4 years ago, so I kind of get the feeling it gives. Stay strong.
Pink's one of the only artists that really feels like she puts her all and real emotions into music. This is incredibly rare for music I listen to, and it gets me every time. She's even more incredible live, and that's pretty rare, too. She's really something special. To those of you bawling like I am: You're not alone. Keep moving forward.
21 years clean and 54 year old man. Lost a bunch of good people to addiction. Pink is always been my favorite non 80s singer. My list of recovery/ addiction song list just grew by 1
As the daughter of a H addict, you are doing absolutely INCREDIBLE!! I know it may mean nothing from a stranger but I am so so proud of you and you should be of yourself too! You're AMAZING 🫶
@billiebriers7961 thank you. Every day is a chance to live a better life. I never forget where I was and where I am. I am humbled that someone I don't know cares about me.
19 years ago I lost my Mom from a sudden cardiac death. And today when I hear this song it makes me bawl my eyes out. I'm 42 now and it feels like it just happened. Sending love to all who see this who lost a loved one in any manner. We are all human and all are connected by love and loss. Thank you P!nk for giving us a song (and so many others) that touch us so much.
I lost my soulmate, my best friend over 4 years ago to drug addiction. Not a day goes by that I don't think of him. So many failed him from as far back as he could remember. I wish I could have saved you. I know you are finally at peace. Rest in paradise, my dear friend. Until we meet again...
ThisIsTheMusicTV it remindes me of my ex that I have known since daycare we used to always hang out everyday then year 7 holidays his slut of a mother took him away won’t let me talk to him ever again😭 I miss him so much
over the years i'd remeember the (1st) chorus on & off, heard in full today & not just as background music in a mall, 1 of my fav pop choruses on its own but the way it progresses & how intense it gets at the end just unbelievable
Shoutout to the boy who's broken my heart so many times but for some reason I kept letting back into my life. He was my best friend for five years then one day that whole friendship became one sided on my part. I was in love with him, and I still am. He's moved on, but he still said forever...
Ethan, what a beautiful story. I'm sorry you had to go through that. Honestly, a similar story happened to me...with this SAME guy. I guess people don't like it when we point out things for the best. You saved her, Ethan. She'll realize that someday.
Time heals everything dear... I was in your situation where someone would cheat or hit me and I can't leave cause i cant imagine life without them..but when you get the courage and strength to let go... You'll do the greatest favour to yourself... Don't be too hard on yourself... Just give yourself time
I can totally relate. I had a very good male friend from 7-11th grade, whom I dated off and on. Just as we were getting close to each other, he had to go live with his grandparents out of state because his dad was verbally abusing him. I was crushed when he told me he had to leave. I must have cried for at least three hours and moped around for a month. Even though I'm engaged to another guy, I can't help thinking of him whenever I hear this song.
My boyfriend of 3 years, back when I was 18 died at a festival from a drug overdose; I was also present at this festival and had to give statements to the police and notify his parents when he was rushed to the hospital. Every year for the last 7 years I listen to this song on his death day or simply when I want to remember him. It has a very special place in my heart.
that must hurt that you were with him when he died but knowing he spent his final hours with you with the one he prob truly loved should be comforting. Really didn't listen to these lyrics until her and kelly performed it and pink explained the lyrics. such a good song it hit me hard miss you sarah rosenberg
A classic from my middle school days. Nostalgic. But now, with age, i realized this song is about grieving for a loss, and it's even more relevant and hits even harder. So it has become timeless
My friends died so young. One of my friends that I met in junior high school was battling cancer and was winning. So we thought. We spoke everyday and when she left a message for me Friday, saying how much she hurt from chemo, and then didn't return my call Saturday I knew something was wrong. I called her house Sunday morning and I knew she had passed. We always promised each other we would be forever be here for each other. I miss you so much, Linda...
Many people on the internet are just horrible, ngl i love bein a troll but when i read somet real like that it pains my heart, it makes me sad an ashamed that us as modern day humans are so fuxkin unkind, i dont get why people feel its necessary to down someone else to up your own ego, always said it an been told it, pass the 30 mark u gain humility an it all comes back to haunt your conscience, just be decent it really is life affirming, an don't ffs record it. Do it cos it decent not for brownie points
@@briancannon3987 you clearly have no idea what it is to be an addict. Different things take different people down the road to recovery. Not every person is the same.
Erin MCGOVERN I know. I've never gone to one of her concerts or met her or anything like that but you can tell by the way she sings, the amount of emotions she feels when writing them. These are the songs I grew up on, and today's music pretty much SUCKS. And this is coming from a 12 year old. But seriously she's one of the few celebrities who haven't changed their music styles.
"If someone said three years from now you'd be long gone I'd stand up and punch them out" "I'll keep you locked in my head" "And time makes it harder" "You visit me in my sleep" Typing this I'm in tears. It's been 3 years but it still feels unreal...feels like a nightmare RIP Mama
I'm so sorry for your loss. Sunday was 25 years since I lost my mom. I promise you, it will get easier. You will always miss her, I still miss mine, but the pain will lessen and she will always be in your heart.
To my aunt who passed away this morning... who knew you would be taken from us this soon. But I love and appreciate that I got to know your crazy personality and to love you until your last breath. I love you so much... Rest easy...
One of the most iconic talents of her generation. Some people are just born to be authentic and admired for raw talent. Pink is in a class of performers only a handful achieve and she earned every bit of it.
Who's listening this during quarantine?? This song is so good! Wish i could go back to 2006! Those years my childhood 😍 October 24, i'm still listening to 00s music in quarantine😂
This song taught me that nothing will ever be there forever it upsets me in a way but I it taught me that I need to be strong no matter who leaves or dies as it going to happen one day anyway.
As long as we keep living our lives and keep the ones we’ve lost in our hearts, we can do anything and take comfort in the fact that we’ll see them again
I lost my soulmate and love of my life just a little over 3 years into our marriage. This song gets to me every time I hear it. It has been 19 years and still hurts like yesterday. Love you forever Ronnie.
I just lost my fiance of 14 years 3 months ago. This song kills me too. So does I Hope You're Happy by Blue October. I'm sorry. It's the worst pain. We were so happy, just like you.
When I first heard this song I thought how sad, then in 2018 my wife suddenly died, leaving me and two boys. I thought of this and every time I hear it…….🤝
Song really hits you harder when you've lost a parent or family member you were close to. Like she sang, if someone had said to me 3 years ago that you'd be gone today, I'd have fought them tooth and nail over it. Time doesn't make it easier to live without you but I'll make it. Love you mama, you were taken from me too early. 1961-2017
Sorry to hear it, Ash. I just lost my Mom on the 6th of December. It hasn't gotten any easier for me yet. I hope you're doing alright. Really. Sorry for your loss.
This song was just played in the radio and for the first time I really paid attention to the lyrics. I burst into tears while driving. My stepdad passed in July. This song hits different now.
I'm 27 years old, and it has been just a few days ago I heard it for the first time. And thought it was a brand new song. Indeed it is stuck in my head.
im so glad i quit heroin when i did i wouldnt want my fiance to be planning a funeral when we r supposed to be planning a wedding this song speaks to my heart
Heard this at the furniture store the other day, the words sunk deep into my marrow. I didnt realise the value my first love had on me until a year later when i realised I had never loved or had such fun 'til I met them and foolishly thought id find something like that within a year. I searched for them in every guy and realised that I would never find a beautiful soul like that so easily. I hope hes out there laughing like he did when I was in his company, he is the best person out there and there are people passing by him not knowing how extraordinary he is. I wish i wasnt so scared of opening up to him when I couldve been putting myself out there a little bit more and laughing a lot more. Anyway, amost broke down twice at that store when I recalled a beaming face staring back at me.
That's nice of you to hope for the best for him and the other people around him. I hope that you find it again, and/or find the ability to be able to express how you'd like to.
+Suzy Lu There's a quote from the Argentine singer Gustavo Cerati, that says: "I love you forever, but forever is today" (Spanish: Yo te quiero para siempre, pero siempre es hoy)
I’m an ex drug addict. I’ve been clean for 12 years now. I related to this song so much in the summer of 2006. The peak year of my addiction! The part where she sings, count your blessings now for the long gone. So emotional! I’m glad I changed my life.
Congratulations! I counsel those addicted to alcohol and drugs. It kills me when my client overdoses and dies. But I do have so many clients that have beat addiction. Keep it up Michael!
I lost my mom too 2020 i cry n remember her whenever i listen to this song same with home by chris daughtry. If someone said 3years from now u will b long gone ill stand up n punch their mouth
I listen to this all the time ... I miss my daughter so much. My Foster sister sent this song to me and I just fell in love with this song. I cry like a baby but it comforts me . she was taken from me and she had a lot to live for she leaves behind two beautiful children ... miss you everyday my christmas baby
Melissa Curcuy I lost my friend to heroin a couple of years ago I was dreaming about him just before I woke up and heard him whisper in my ear. A couple of hours later I find out he had passed away. That day was so strange cos I kinda already knew the news wasn't as shocking as it should have been. RIP Kurt. True story
My dad grandad both died a year after yours dad on valentines n grandad 4 days later n little bro in my arms that Xmas he survived tho. I was only 18. I had my head bashed off the floor 30 odd times n shaken so violently I felt nausea spacey think I had mild concussion also that year by abuser older brother while defending my sister.
I'm so sorry sweetheart I lost my mum to motor neuron disease during covid i the pain will go and you'll remember the love you had and the good memories but you'll feel raw emotions for a while bit now that your not alone and if you need to talk to someone it'll help.
Story of my life right here. The chorus line hits so fucking hard. Three and a half years of my life wasted because I chose to remain with someone who thought they could always walk all over me. They thought I'd never leave just because I loved them. Even when it came down to them cheating on me I couldn't leave... We broke up for 6 months yet every waking moment was torture. I couldn't move on, couldn't let go. He knew this... He begged for a second chance, begged and swore he'd treat me right. He did for awhile... but I guess it was just too late for us. I tried my damn hardest to forget and let go of the pain, tried to forgive him... yet I couldn't. I'd cry at random times when the thought of him in another woman's arms hit me. I tried to keep up the smile, yet he knew I wasn't happy with him like I once was. Even though there were good and bad times, even though I tried to be perfect for him... it didn't work. He went back to his old ways, then every time we fought he would swear it wouldn't happen again. He lied, over and over again, and I was a fool because I believed every lie that came out of his mouth. I let him go... and even though it was I who did the breaking up this time, once again I feel like I'm back in the spot I was last time we broke up. He wanted to break up but never had the guts to, so he just dragged me along. Yet, even though he said that we would never work out, he wanted to try, He said he didn't want to give up on what we had because he loved me more than anyone else in this world. How can he want to try, yet break up at the same time? He wanted to see how much I could take before I broke. He wanted to see how long I'd be willing to stay around even when he treated me like I was a pile of dog shit he stepped in. I feel like all I had worked towards has fallen apart again. The tiny little pieces of my heart that he had slowly helped me put back in place have fallen, broken yet again. I lay in bed at night and grab onto his pillow like it's my lifeline, soaking it with tears, praying to every God there is that it will somehow morph into him. I imagine his skin where there is only fabric. I want to place my head on his shoulder and have him wrap his arms around me as we fall asleep at night. I want to wake up and pillow fight him again, to wrestle around and end up being late for work because time just flies by when I'm with him. I want to hear him whisper my name as he kisses my neck... I want things to go back to how they used to be! I want to stop feeling so fucking broken, so fucking USELESS! I want him back so bad... yet I know that things will never be as they once were. I know I deserve better. I know that eventually I'll be able to move on... but I don't want to. I want him. Sad as it is, he's the best boyfriend [fiance] I had ever had. He was my best friend whom I told all my dark secrets to, secrets that no other living soul on this planet knew. He never judged me, he always said that no one could compare to me. He said I was beautiful on the inside and out. He was my life, my rock. He was my reason for everything I did... Why couldn't I be good enough? Why?! We had so many good times... So many days of just sitting at home just enjoying the presence of each other as we talked about everything and nothing. Talked about the tiny things we had never told each other. I wanted to know every thing that made him the man he had become, and he wanted to know everything about me. I opened up too much and dug my own grave. He knew all my insecurities and used them against me in the end. He knew why I was sometimes temperamental. He knew how to get under my skin in the worst way possible. Why do I still LOVE him after everything he has put me through? Why is it that I sit here crying because of the pain he has caused me, yet I still whimper out his name like a child whose lost its parents? He's cheated on me, belittled me, talked to women behind my back, talked about ME behind my back! He walked all over me as if I was a Welcoming Mat! He abused me mentally... and I feel like I'll always carry the scars of the years I was with him. I can't forget him, not any second of any day. Every road in this town we have traveled on, every where I look we have been. I look in the mirror and see his name tattooed above my heart. I swore I'd love him forever, and I meant it. I swore I'd never cheat on him, and I didn't. I swore I'd try my best to be everything he wanted me to be... I CAN'T BE PERFECT. I'm human! I'm not a machine that you can tweak around to do everything you want it to do! I'm not a mind reader, I don't understand what goes on inside any one's brain other than my own! And yet, I know that while I sit here ranting to people who don't care about my words on TH-cam, he's probably happy as can be 100 miles from the place he left me. Why... why can't I move on... If someone said three years from now, you'd be long gone I'd stand up and punch them all out! Cause they're all wrong.. I know better cause you said forever and ever... Who knew...
Hi there. Erm...I'm not usually one for replying to this sort of stuff, but your story and feelings are eerily similar to my own feelings as little as six months ago. I fell in love with a guy roughly...four years ago now. He was everything Id ever looked for in a man. Tall, handsome, funny and very gentlemanly. He was, at least in my eyes, perfect for me. And I thought he felt the same way about me too. Boy was I ever wrong. We were in an LDR but we'd managed a few months. Then the arguments started and I got super paranoid. Creepily so. Everyday I wasn't with him, I was working myself up into a state wondering if he was in the arms of another woman. Eventually, I just couldn't take it anymore and I made the biggest mistake of my life. I let him slip away. The very next morning, the emptiness hit me as soon as I woke up. A part of me had vanished and fluttered off to join him. Everyday since then for two entire years I thought about him. I cried and I screamed and I even tried to kill myself because I felt so lonely without him. But then... Well I met somebody else. It was hard at first as I was extremely shy and scared to do anything. It took me a good six months before I started talking openly with him. But...he was patient and is amazingly still with me today. That's why I can say that old cliche. It gets better over time. It won't be tomorrow. Hell, it may not even be another year from now. But trust me. When you find someone else, hell, even just something to take your mind off of him, it gets so so much better. And you'll be able to look back on your memories fondly. I know I cherished the time I spent with him a lot more now and I laugh at how ridiculous I was being back then. Of course, it isn't perfect. I still have the odd bad day, but they are so few and far between now, I am basically myself again. I love my current boyfriend so much. And I love the first guy still too. But I know now, he wasn't perfect. Cause if he was, he wouldn't have let me let him go. Keep strong! :)
Emma Nicholson I'm surprised someone actually took the time to read all that. I kind of went into a fit and ranted everything I felt. I needed to get it all out one way or another... More so surprised you actually wrote out more than a couple sentences... But anyways, thanks for the words. I know one day things will be okay, I'm aware it will take time to get over him. I know, since he was the first I've honestly fell in love with that he'll always hold some part of my heart... but he won't have the power to control me. I'm sorry you had to go through feelings similar as to what I'm going through. It hurts. There was a quote I saw on the internet the other day that went something along the lines of. "At some point you have to realize that there will be some people who can remain in your heart, but not in your life."
How the heck does she make so many songs that you can listen to and enjoy when you are a kid, and then listen to and understand when you get older? It's amazing how deep and downright tragic most of her songs are when you actually understand them
Yeah it's the same with RHCP scar tissue when u read between the lines of the lyrics u find out the deeper meaning of the song then it starts to hit u.
She does it by not being just a singer like britney, she’s a professional entertainer and rockstar. When she does a show she’s giving it her all and doing the acrobatics and singing and dancing for real, I think she has some songwriters helping her behind the scenes and putting songs together for her but everyone is doing that these days
"I'll keep you locked in my head
Until we meet again"
This. Is. Really. Painful.
Chazz Wanie ya. If you’re 12
@@fuckcancer8679 Not necessary must be 12 years old to feel it, granpa. If u had experience of losing someone that u love, then you'll understand this. Till then, u'll mock others. Age doesn't matter.
I read at the exact moment it came on
😢❤️
And I won't forget you my friend, what happened?
This is easily her best song, and is standing the test of time. The lyrics are even more heartbreaking and profound the older you become..
So true, sober is right up there though. Sober was a pretty great help when it was time to go through the rehab experience and made getting through it much easier
Congrats, Frankie! Stay strong and sober!
@@frankielove31 congrats 🥺 keep going
@@frankielove31 well done we all have our demons lifes hard
It is a classic! Great voice and a lot of pathos to this song.. Heartbreaking. And she sings the notes just right for effect. Love her!
I'm telling you when you get older these songs aren't just "fun" to listen to anymore.
They will creep up and hit right in the heart.
its really true
Yes!
Haunt
FOR THOSE WHO STILL HAVE A HEART!
As a kid, I knew the song was sad. But as an adult, I've listened to it during sad times.
RIP Matthew Brown. We haven’t forgotten you my friend. I enjoyed being around you, and how protective you were of me. Rest easy
I lost my first husband to heroin addiction. I remember begging and crying for him to get help. He completely changed. From a sweetheart who bought me coffee every morning in college, to someone i barely recognized. This song has been with me a long time. It helped me get through it.
I’m so sorry. The same happened to me.
I am so sorry for your loss ❤ sending you a gentle hug 🙏 I wish you peace and joy ❤❤❤
So sorry
I’m so sorry for your loss❤️
Same story here😢
I lost my son to suicide in 2007 at the age of 23. My daughter sent me this video today and though it made me cry, it also brought back so many memories. The pain of losing him has become a part of me that I live with every day. There are a lot of good days now, but even on those days the pain is always there. I thank God and my faith that has gotten me through all these years, and my beautiful daughter who not only lost a father to suicide when she was 12 (she's now 47) but a brother also. My heart goes out to all those who have lost loved ones, and may God bless you each day ❤
Meus sentimentos ! Hugs From Brazil
@@joseflorencio7469 Thank you. May God bless you always 🙏❤️
Lost my best friend due to heroin, 2 yrs ago
My heart goes out to you Yvonne as long as their in you and your daughters hearts their not gone.just keep thinking about the great memories and good times
I'm so sorry for your losses!
P!nk is one of the very few mainstream artists nowadays that actually makes me feel something whenever I listen to their music. This song never fails me... definitely one of my favorites by her. It was released eight years ago, but still gets played on the radio from time to time. Great example of a timeless song
I know right!!!!
too bad her music sucks major ass
totally agree to u
fizzle mygrizzle Then why are you on this WONDERFUL music video? Huh? You must like it if you're listening to it.
Meow Meow not true. Someone on my skype chat sent me the link and I clicked it.
My son died of fentanyl poisoning 9 months ago. He was 39. My heart aches for him every day. My condolences to all who are missing a loved one.
Condolencees😢
I am so very sorry for your loss. This song is near and dear to me for the loss of my best friend, many years ago, to this disease. I pray that you get a bit more peace, day by day.
I've lost family members to diseases but the loss still hurts even to this day. I lost the love of my life in 1990, mother in 2017 and my brother in 2019. It still hurts now.
Соболезную вам! Боритесь с капитализмом - это он причина всех этих бед!
I’m so sorry for your loss😢 I lost my sister 7 years ago due to addiction. She had endocarditis (an infection from dirty needles). She was 23 & had a 3 year old. My parents were never the same after that. Praying for you
Man, when you get older this is a hard song to listen to.
I cry every time
🥺
So true......TOUCHES U TO THE CORE!! Specially -1:00...-0:53 smh...
Replayed like 5x.....onto 6x now.....Back to back.....
Its heart wrenching if u actually understand the meaning behind
very emotional for sure
It's been 3 years since I lost my beloved Kate. She loved this song. 😢 this one's for you, babe. Chris. 2023.
You will meet again, Chris. Keep her locked in your head and heart. How are you?
@HoneyQuint I appreciate the good vibes. Thanks for asking . I'm good. Better these days. 🙂
@@chrisveraghoststories7353 praying always helps.
💙
Best wishes Chris
i honestly love P!nk. She is my favourite singer. She has pulled me through so much, her lyrics seen me through my teens, through the lost of my brother, through my mother abandoning her family... Being alone wasnt as bad with P!nks album; but this song tears me apart. Her music is so strong and meaningful, no matter what shes singing about, and that is exactly why she is loved. Such a strong woman who says exactly what she thinks and feels.
+Shadae Middleton Well put. I'm in my 50's and I can relate to the lyrics of her songs, Perfect, Conversations with my 13 year old self, Dear Mr President, Sober and many more resonate with me. She's a very underrated artist. She should be inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, in my opinion.
Absolutely!!!!!
that was deep man
I'm sorry man :). but imma randommaly say this.... my favorite singer is MØ. the one that sings Lean On
Yes thats right. Most pop singers just Singing some shit. But Pink is singing the truth. I love you Pink
"You visit me in my sleep".. so true. I'll see you soon little brother
My condolences 😢
Life is too short. Spare ur time❤️
Sad. I'm sorry for u. Really
@@damsterdam6369 Thank u very much! Means alot
13 years later and I still can’t listen to this song without crying. The older I get, the more I understand the line “time makes it harder.” When I was 21, I had to leave college to begin taking care of my sisters kids because she passed away. I finally returned to school to finish that degree and I graduate in May. As much as I want to be happy, it hurts so much that she won’t be there to see me walk across that stage as a college graduate. Every milestone event that happens makes you miss them more. Sending love and light to everyone that has lost someone that they love and must continue through life with that deep scar on your heart ❤️.
I never thought about it like that lost my sister last year and it makes me sad to think about her missing out on my milestones and vice versa 😭😭
@@dakotaracine8842 losing a sibling is so hard. My sister passed in 2004 and I still have to catch myself when something big happens and I instinctively want to call and tell her about it, but then I remember that I can’t. I pray for your peace. One thing that I do know is that they become our guardian angels and watch over us for the rest of our lives 😇💖
im not sure if youve walked that stage yet, however i promise you our lost loved ones are always near. u just have to get familar with the sign their giving. IM SO PROUD OF YOU, if no one has told you as well. its an accomplishment im workin on myself. sending lots of love and support your way
@@tyriqsmith5211 thank you so much for the words of encouragement. I walk across it next month, and I’m sure you’ll be walking across it too in the near future. Sending good vibes and well wishes your way.
Lost my bestfriend in 2015 and my mom has always loved pink my entire life . Between her fighting her demons and losing my friend this song hits a tender spot no matter the mood I’m In. JUST ONLY IF …. 😢💙
I know this is about Pink’s loss of a friend due to addiction, but, it makes me think of losing my mom so fast to pancreatic cancer. Hugs to all those listening today.
It's about losing any loved one, from any reason. Could be a parent, a lover, or even a pet. I am sorry for your loss, just know that she cannot wait to be able to see you again.
I'm sorry
I lost my best friend of 25 years to Pancreatic cancer 2 years ago. She was only 40. This song just hits me right in the heart.
I am sorry for your loss.
Pancreatic cancer can eff right off.
@@Cal90208 I lost my aunt I think I was only 2 when she died but my whole life I was told she was just my mums best friend until recently I found out she was actually my dads sister
This song was played at the funeral and even tho I don’t remember her I feel like this song is the only connection I have with her so it makes me cry..
I also saw pictures of her recently and I look like her
I just wish I could meet her and remember her
“That last kiss I’ll cherish until we meet again”
“I wish I could remember”
“But I keep your memory you visit me in my sleep”- apparently when I was 3 I ran down to my mum and said “aunty lelly visited me in my sleep” and described her perfectly
RIP lelly cole
Until we meet again 💔❤️
@@ThePixie78 I lost both parents to cancer and a few friends. I am sorry for your loss.
My husband died 10 days ago, he was 46. I love him so much I never knew our time would be cut so short. Sleep well Peter. -Wifey
i'm so sorry for your loss :(
I'm so sorry. Trust that someday, hopefully sooner rather than later, you'll think of him and smile.
@@lisapuma6059 I smile and laugh all the time thinking about his wry humor. Just this morning I thought about one of his little quips and it had me chuckling. When I see him again I'll let him know.
Aaaaw. Sorry for your loss💜
I remember a eulogy. "Remember me with happiness and laughter for if you can only remember me with saddness and tears it's better not to remember me at all."
As Star Trek's Tasha Yar said "As long as someone remembers me I'm never truly dead."
My wife passed away at 39. She was my soulmate. This song will make you cry and scream. I miss you laura
I'm so sorry for your passing...I lost my sister 3 years ago and it still feels like yesterday. She left me her two boys behind and I'm still lost trying to raise them..time doesn't heal all wounds, everyone is different...just hang in there, she is with you every sunshine day and every beautiful clear starry night.. you will see her again ❤ Hold on to that in your heart!! It keeps you alive knowing that my friend 😊 trust me!
@allisonLayne86 I'm sorry for your losses, for the both of you. At least you're there for the boys.
I never realised the meaning of this song until now. To everyone who relates to this song in some way, I hope you're doing okay
I didn’t understand the meaning of this song when I was a kid. Now all these years later I know what she’s talking about. One of my friends died from cancer almost 2 years ago. I think of him when I hear this song.
@@mitchellwagoner6631 i"m sorry for your loss. i hope you're coping well
He never promised though.....his words 😞
@@jennyphillips5589 yesterday i read something that made me smile and maybe it would help you. it said: when you walk into a garden to pick flowers what flowers do you look for? the answer, the prettiest. god chose the prettiest he could find. i hope this helps you
Thank you ❣️
My dad, the most stable person in my life and my best friend, died yesterday in corona. He was by himself in the hospital. I could not say goodbye to him. Listening to this song and crying, how can I live without him.
You made me cry, im so sorry for your loss
God bless you x
I am so so so very sorry. My heart aches for you.
Literally crying while typing this... so so sorry for your loss..🙏 prayers for you. Stay strong, life is fleeting. You will see him again one day.
God bless you. Sending you good thoughts.
One of her most under-appreciated songs .. bursting with emotion it speaks to anyone who has lost someone
Jim Pickard my local radio station recently played this song again and I had to come back to it.
i feel so lonely sometimes---
and worst..lost someone because drugs... no words for it... an eternal courage
Jim Pickard I can feel her pain .... I lost my dad at five and for your comment you just earned a new subscriber
Jim Pickard
True story
End of 2024 and this song still makes me bawl. The older I get, the more the pain truly hits me like a brick wall
This comment thread is filled with heartwarming but also depressing stories from people who have lost their loved ones :( I hope y'all are doing OK...my heart goes out to everyone who cried as they listened to this song
Sophia Kim 🤍🕊🦋
Ich libe dich. Madina. From hamburg.
Hode hoda morgen. Kome na na sanfranziko
Thanks
Thank you Sophia ❤
When an artist can bring tears to the eyes of a cynical 45yr old man, you know they're doing something right. The best P!nk song.
As a 44 year old man in the same position, I completely agree with you!
What made you cynical? Maybe the message and emotions in this song brings back the weakness you locked under that cynicism. I don't know you and I don't mean to presume, but I'm a little younger than you and a lot of sensitivity and pain I lock away I also answer with sarcasm and cynicism. I wish you all the best in life, man. Take care.
Please , i want to know where is pink , because i saw her in a vidéo FB , i think it' her , but she was durty and not normaly ( drug of zombie)
th-cam.com/video/ZzN6dZEGEa8/w-d-xo.html
Surely, the best P!nk song!
As a kid you like the song. As an adult you feel the song.
So , so true.
G’day Jesse, getting ready to play this on my piano channel on TH-cam.... hope I can give it the emotion it deserves (as it deserves) 😘
Never gave any attention to this song before last year... I listened to it while I was in a really bad mental state and boy the lyrics touched me so much. Great song, probably one of the best all time in my opinion, and that's coming from a metal fan.
@A7XdemesticPk I too love my metal, but cover both metal, hard rock ... and ballads lol. You are right, this song can touch us at any stage of our life. I played this on my piano channel and both the metal fans and pop music people love the interpretation because it is emotional 😘
carai jess, tu veio com esse comentário ein
P!NK's most iconic song
“I’ll keep you locked in my head …..until we meet again.” My absolute favorite P!nk song.
"But I'll keep your memory, you visit me in my sleep"
Indeed
Same 💯, best lyrics, I feel it in my soul
Engineer did it better
Mine too ❤❤
It's 2021 and still giving me chills hearing this song.
Likewise
I wish I had a girlfriend who would stand up and punch someone out
Same
Everytime❤️
Same here
I swear this song hits so hard..
Her best song.
Music just hits different the older you get 😢
I just randomly played this song on a Saturday morning and the moment it started I bawl my eyes out crying. I remember listening to it when I was 12-13 years old. Now at 25 it hits different. Thank you Pink for such a timeless song.
X
I remember listening to it at 25 (the best year of my life). Im 48 now. Hits different.
I'm the same I'm now 25 and it hits even more
I just stumbled into this song at 35 for the first time and holy hell I was not ready for these feels.
I saw an interview with Pink, and she commented that this song means different things to different people, and she liked that. I was four when my mother died, and soon my father threw all of his children in the street. I went to juvenile detention, near a dozen foster homes, and a state orphanage before running away to live however I could, sometimes on the street, until I was eighteen. The relevance of this to your song is that I was never, not even once, close enough to anyone to grieve their passing, but that changed February '21; my best friend and mentor who guided my career from eighteen until my retirement died, on my birthday. I've never grieved before, reminding myself in preparation for his passing when he got cancer, and, sadly, he soon lost his fight, leaving me to contend with thoughts and feelings I had not anticipated, not until the end. I'd already heard Who Knew, but, like many, I thought it was just a breakup song until I heard her interview. I'm sixty-five now and whenever I hear it I'm filled with memories of my great friend who loved me like a son. The tears come easily when, like her, I hope to see my friend again in that far beyond. Thank you, Pink. P.S., last night I dreamed that you called me on the phone, but then, like all such dreams, you were not there anymore as I woke up calling your name.
that's the great thing about songs like this, people can interpret in a way that means something to them ❤❤❤
This song really hits home for me. Reminds me of my son I lost 8 years ago. I miss you my peanut...
+Brandi Bozeman I'm so sorry for your loss... This song reminds me to my dad, who died almost 4 years ago, so I kind of get the feeling it gives. Stay strong.
+Brandi Bozeman im so sorry best of luck
I'm so sorry for your lost 💔
+Brandi Bozeman sorry for your loss, its wrong when our kids go first, xxx
So sorry
This song always makes me cry, but the heart-breaking comments made me cry harder.
Sending so much love to everyone
💔
Pink's one of the only artists that really feels like she puts her all and real emotions into music. This is incredibly rare for music I listen to, and it gets me every time. She's even more incredible live, and that's pretty rare, too. She's really something special.
To those of you bawling like I am: You're not alone. Keep moving forward.
Good cuz I didn't last 3 seconds but now I'm trying to watch family portrait it's just one of those days
+Minori B. Theres millions of artists who put real emotions into their music, perhaps just not ones whom attract millions of fans.
+Anthony Norris : Beyonce who?
+Minori B. I agree
21 years clean and 54 year old man. Lost a bunch of good people to addiction. Pink is always been my favorite non 80s singer.
My list of recovery/ addiction song list just grew by 1
Keep going buddy, you can do this.
As the daughter of a H addict, you are doing absolutely INCREDIBLE!! I know it may mean nothing from a stranger but I am so so proud of you and you should be of yourself too! You're AMAZING 🫶
@billiebriers7961 thank you. Every day is a chance to live a better life.
I never forget where I was and where I am. I am humbled that someone I don't know cares about me.
I'm still watching this video in 2022. Pink is a legend and this song is a classic. The vibe is everything!
Same
Forreal
2023
February 15, 2023
9:29pm ♥️
2023🫶🏻
I knew this wasn’t about lovers breaking up😢
I miss my love but I know heaven gained an angel.
I dont know why i decided to watch this at 4 am but im crying and i cant stop. Pink is so underappreciated...
phangasm she’s really not, everyone understands her talent
I know
Brings back memories
What are you talkin about pink is one of the best singers of all time
4:40am I watched it. Funny I have seen the video but I guess never really watched it until now and am crying too.
I cry because my mom left and reminds me how much I need you
it's alright to be emotional from time to time, but don't allow that to control your life. Parents make mistakes too !
DARLENE PERRIELLO thank you that's very inspiring I won't let it control my life anymore it did before
Who Knew Aw I'm sorry be strong (: ❤
Who Knew
This song is like a wine. The older it gets the better it sounds.
do you mean tastes? you can’t hear wine lol 😂
You should've said the older it gets, the better it is
then older u get, the harder it is listen this song
You should have said the older it gets the better it gets
I understood what he meant. We all make grammar mistakes.
Im so happy she was given that icon award 👏 timeless artist
I always think
of my mom when I hear this song. I was 17 when she died.
This song is me singing to her.
Sorry😭
Natalie Eberling can imagine the feeling. I'm sorry for your loss
Natalie Eberling me too my mom loved P!no as an artist nd wen my mom died this is the song that makes me cry Every time I hear it.
Sorry dor your loss😢❤
19 years ago I lost my Mom from a sudden cardiac death. And today when I hear this song it makes me bawl my eyes out. I'm 42 now and it feels like it just happened. Sending love to all who see this who lost a loved one in any manner. We are all human and all are connected by love and loss. Thank you P!nk for giving us a song (and so many others) that touch us so much.
I'm so sorry life isn't fair
I am sorry for your loss, I lost my mom just over a year ago, she was so young with a lot of life to live.
@@sharib1916 Awe, no. My condolences to you. It's so hard, isn't it? Try to hold on to all the memories you have. It does help...even a little.
@@erika8627 may I suggest keep a journal to remember all the special things about her.
@@charleskaneshiro6060 Thank you. That's a wonderful idea.
its 2015 and this song still makes me cry
nessa Me too, this song means a lot to me.
It's 2015 and now I realise what this really means..
nessa me too!
me too :(
nessa Me too
This song pulls at your heart strings when you get older 😢
Right 😢.
I lost my soulmate, my best friend over 4 years ago to drug addiction. Not a day goes by that I don't think of him. So many failed him from as far back as he could remember. I wish I could have saved you.
I know you are finally at peace. Rest in paradise, my dear friend. Until we meet again...
like this
my deepest condolences for your loss, I hope you find him in everything you do
Oohhh😢😢😢😢
This song makes my cry :(
ThisIsTheMusicTv.....,Awww sorry 💙
Same here
RIGHT ‼️‼️💪
ThisIsTheMusicTV same
ThisIsTheMusicTV it remindes me of my ex that I have known since daycare we used to always hang out everyday then year 7 holidays his slut of a mother took him away won’t let me talk to him ever again😭
I miss him so much
When I was younger I was thinking this song is about a break up.. listening to this after years.. goosebumps...
Same
Same 😩
over the years i'd remeember the (1st) chorus on & off, heard in full today & not just as background music in a mall, 1 of my fav pop choruses on its own but the way it progresses & how intense it gets at the end just unbelievable
Same...it could be though...s'pose it could be related to that individual situation
To everyone who lost their loved ones, may you find solace in the memories you shared together.
Till this day, I consider this one of the most powerful songs. I love you - Pink!
Shoutout to the boy who's broken my heart so many times but for some reason I kept letting back into my life. He was my best friend for five years then one day that whole friendship became one sided on my part. I was in love with him, and I still am. He's moved on, but he still said forever...
Ethan, what a beautiful story. I'm sorry you had to go through that. Honestly, a similar story happened to me...with this SAME guy. I guess people don't like it when we point out things for the best. You saved her, Ethan. She'll realize that someday.
+Shane Johnson damn bro, maybe you should try contacting her
Time heals everything dear... I was in your situation where someone would cheat or hit me and I can't leave cause i cant imagine life without them..but when you get the courage and strength to let go... You'll do the greatest favour to yourself... Don't be too hard on yourself... Just give yourself time
I can totally relate. I had a very good male friend from 7-11th grade, whom I dated off and on. Just as we were getting close to each other, he had to go live with his grandparents out of state because his dad was verbally abusing him. I was crushed when he told me he had to leave. I must have cried for at least three hours and moped around for a month. Even though I'm engaged to another guy, I can't help thinking of him whenever I hear this song.
+hi im hailee dammit who's cutting onions?
How the heck does she sing this song without bursting in to tears? I can't even hear it without.
Matt Stevenson yes yes every bit yes
Drugs and alotta takes.
SERIOUS.
EXPOSE MK ULTRA.
how does he sing the song pink is a dude
i burst into tears when i hear it. and sart saying please someone make it stop.
Because he said forever and ever
I lost my husband last month and when I say this song has a whole new meaning. Married 38 years and now alone, I can hardly take it 💔💔💔
😢❤
i am so sorry. ❤️
😭
I lost the love of my life in a tragic accident and this song makes me bawl so hard every single time. Sorry for your loss
I can never finish this song. It hits way too hard....
same
+GustavoBravo Where I work, the radio always plays this song. And other 00s songs.
I can't finish this song without crying a bit😢
My boyfriend of 3 years, back when I was 18 died at a festival from a drug overdose; I was also present at this festival and had to give statements to the police and notify his parents when he was rushed to the hospital. Every year for the last 7 years I listen to this song on his death day or simply when I want to remember him. It has a very special place in my heart.
that must hurt that you were with him when he died but knowing he spent his final hours with you with the one he prob truly loved should be comforting. Really didn't listen to these lyrics until her and kelly performed it and pink explained the lyrics. such a good song it hit me hard miss you sarah rosenberg
😢
❤
😢 you are so broken and I feel your heart
Every p!nk song gives me chills. They're so meaningful and sincere :)
What's her best songs to you? I want to look them up. Tyia
Tammi Beckworth Try(at the moment thats my favorite) I would watch her live preformance where shes dancing with that one guy.
+DerpHatsuneMiku
Absolutely no contest! the dance and colored powder is exacting! Love your taste! 😎
+Tammi Beckworth Just give me a reason is also a great song
You're probably ill. You should go see a doctor.
A classic from my middle school days. Nostalgic. But now, with age, i realized this song is about grieving for a loss, and it's even more relevant and hits even harder. So it has become timeless
Her Voice Is Soooo Beautiful And Genuine 😩😩😍😍😍 I Love This Woman 💕
My friends died so young. One of my friends that I met in junior high school was battling cancer and was winning. So we thought. We spoke everyday and when she left a message for me Friday, saying how much she hurt from chemo, and then didn't return my call Saturday I knew something was wrong. I called her house Sunday morning and I knew she had passed. We always promised each other we would be forever be here for each other. I miss you so much, Linda...
Human mortality suck....I feel your pain.......Hug from a total stranger on you tube..
Many people on the internet are just horrible, ngl i love bein a troll but when i read somet real like that it pains my heart, it makes me sad an ashamed that us as modern day humans are so fuxkin unkind, i dont get why people feel its necessary to down someone else to up your own ego, always said it an been told it, pass the 30 mark u gain humility an it all comes back to haunt your conscience, just be decent it really is life affirming, an don't ffs record it. Do it cos it decent not for brownie points
rip xxx
So sorry.
I had been a addict for 5 years when this song & video came out….I quit using because of this song! Thank you Pink for giving my life back!
If that's true... u wearnt addicted
The power of music
I love u
@@briancannon3987 you clearly have no idea what it is to be an addict. Different things take different people down the road to recovery. Not every person is the same.
@@briancannon3987 addiction is addiction #punchyourmouth #causetheyallshet #pinkslyrics not mine 😂☺
my uncle died yesterday... he was basically my father. i love him so much. i will do anything to take care of his little 10 year old...
P!nk does not have one bad song, FACT
She is amazing.
Layla Lay la I know, and you have a very good taste in music lol
i think she's underrated she's an amazing artist witch should get more recognize for her talent !!!
Erin MCGOVERN I know. I've never gone to one of her concerts or met her or anything like that but you can tell by the way she sings, the amount of emotions she feels when writing them. These are the songs I grew up on, and today's music pretty much SUCKS. And this is coming from a 12 year old. But seriously she's one of the few celebrities who haven't changed their music styles.
Hanna Seen P!NK twice in concert and is amazing, totally love her music
"If someone said three years from now you'd be long gone I'd stand up and punch them out"
"I'll keep you locked in my head"
"And time makes it harder"
"You visit me in my sleep"
Typing this I'm in tears. It's been 3 years but it still feels unreal...feels like a nightmare
RIP Mama
I'm so sorry for your loss. Sunday was 25 years since I lost my mom. I promise you, it will get easier. You will always miss her, I still miss mine, but the pain will lessen and she will always be in your heart.
Same . My mom was murdered 4/24/20 . I feel like it’s a nightmare I’m going to wake up from
Same my dad died nearly 5 years ago and it still feels raw that he didn't get to see his eldest daughter go to prom and turn 18 this year. 😓😓 Rip dad
@@zariaharion4670 my mother passed away 4/4/20 for unknown reasons unexpectedly :(
💔🕊🙏🏽
To my aunt who passed away this morning... who knew you would be taken from us this soon. But I love and appreciate that I got to know your crazy personality and to love you until your last breath. I love you so much... Rest easy...
may your aunt and my mother rest in paradise
Jade book 💖💖💖
Alex Bodelier thank you. I appreciate that. 😏
***** thank you... 😏
So sorry to hear that may she rest in peace god bless xxx
One of the most iconic talents of her generation. Some people are just born to be authentic and admired for raw talent. Pink is in a class of performers only a handful achieve and she earned every bit of it.
Si senor
It would be nice NOT to cry to this song everytime I listen to it...
+Claudio Paz I cry every time she says "Still, you said forever."
***** what's "fgt?"
being fabulous
Hyper EDM Oh I just love being fabulous!
+Oscar Turnbull you are such a dumbass baby
Who's listening this during quarantine?? This song is so good! Wish i could go back to 2006! Those years my childhood 😍
October 24, i'm still listening to 00s music in quarantine😂
instagram vndresgt97 omg same
I love pink listening in quarantine please stay safe and healthy.
2006 was my childhood as well, considering that it was the year I was born
Omg I do too I miss my fun childhood 😭!!
I was born in 2006! Never too late to appreciate great music!
This song taught me that nothing will ever be there forever it upsets me in a way but I it taught me that I need to be strong no matter who leaves or dies as it going to happen one day anyway.
so true, the deeper meaning of life
iku
As long as we keep living our lives and keep the ones we’ve lost in our hearts, we can do anything and take comfort in the fact that we’ll see them again
Feel you
It hits different when ur grown 🥺
After all these years that final chorus still doesn’t not fail to bring a tear to my eyes
X2
Its fucken epic!!!!!
This song makes you cry................
Engineer did it better
I cry the entire song
This will always be my favoeite p!nk song. ❤
favorite*
me too💚
ditto
mine too
Gina H yessss mine too ❤
I lost my soulmate and love of my life just a little over 3 years into our marriage. This song gets to me every time I hear it. It has been 19 years and still hurts like yesterday. Love you forever Ronnie.
I’m so sorry for your loss xx
I just lost my fiance of 14 years 3 months ago. This song kills me too. So does I Hope You're Happy by Blue October. I'm sorry. It's the worst pain. We were so happy, just like you.
When I first heard this song I thought how sad, then in 2018 my wife suddenly died, leaving me and two boys. I thought of this and every time I hear it…….🤝
Virtual hugs!
I'm so sorry you had to go through that, stay strong
The last kiss, I'll cherish. 😢❤
Song really hits you harder when you've lost a parent or family member you were close to. Like she sang, if someone had said to me 3 years ago that you'd be gone today, I'd have fought them tooth and nail over it. Time doesn't make it easier to live without you but I'll make it. Love you mama, you were taken from me too early. 1961-2017
Oh
She wrote this about a friend that od'd. Still i lost my soulmate when he was 19. I need him more than i need myself right now.
@@WillBlindYouWithLight be it friend, mother, or soulmate the burden is always hard. I'm sorry for your loss.
Sorry to hear it, Ash. I just lost my Mom on the 6th of December. It hasn't gotten any easier for me yet. I hope you're doing alright. Really. Sorry for your loss.
My best friend 2006- 2020 I miss her everyday
Very tempted to link this video to my ex best friend I miss her so much
Same but my ex friend blocked me the sad thing is this song predicted what would happen between me and a few ex friends
Ik im a bit late but if u haven't already, do it!!!!
I knew I'm so late but if you didn't do it do it. It's cheesy but you do only live once. What do you have to lose?
Me too. I miss her...
I'm tempted to send this to my ex he moved away and his parents won't let us even text 😭😭
This song was just played in the radio and for the first time I really paid attention to the lyrics. I burst into tears while driving. My stepdad passed in July. This song hits different now.
I'm sorry for your loss
Lost my mom a year ago and this song punches me in the gut everytime I listen to it. I feel you.
This song means so much to me, it's the epitome of pain and trauma. 🖤
The comments on this song are heartbreaking. I'm so sorry to hear all your tragic stories. Send you my love. Beautiful song. Tears everytime ❤️
If someone said nine years from now... you'd still have this song stuck in your head...
Andrew Feinberg 12 years 😂😂 it was released in 2006
@@kianmcdonald6397 OMG really??How old is she right now???
제니와 정국일본 국 39
I'm 27 years old, and it has been just a few days ago I heard it for the first time. And thought it was a brand new song. Indeed it is stuck in my head.
...who knew
Reading the comments and suddenly notice the tears in my eyes. We are are human. Not more not less. Thank you.
This is 15 years old and yet it is one of the best songs i've listened to
Because today's songs are worse and worse...
im so glad i quit heroin when i did i wouldnt want my fiance to be planning a funeral when we r supposed to be planning a wedding this song speaks to my heart
❤
I'm so happy for you.
congratulations...that is a huge step....very happy for you.
Heroin is a terrible thing. My mom's older brother lost his wife due to a heroin overdose. Her one year is in two days. But anyways, congrats!
I'm on a Pink spree...Her songs are amazing
Same
Same,
Me too lol
i love her songs
ME TOO
Is it wrong that I cry every time I hear this song?
No. Im doing it too :(
I cry everytime I hear this song also. But I still keep listening to it over and over again...
Not at all, I cry every single time I listen to this.
Not at all wrong...sometimes we don't know what we had until it's gone.
No not at all
Heard this at the furniture store the other day, the words sunk deep into my marrow. I didnt realise the value my first love had on me until a year later when i realised I had never loved or had such fun 'til I met them and foolishly thought id find something like that within a year. I searched for them in every guy and realised that I would never find a beautiful soul like that so easily. I hope hes out there laughing like he did when I was in his company, he is the best person out there and there are people passing by him not knowing how extraordinary he is. I wish i wasnt so scared of opening up to him when I couldve been putting myself out there a little bit more and laughing a lot more. Anyway, amost broke down twice at that store when I recalled a beaming face staring back at me.
That's nice of you to hope for the best for him and the other people around him. I hope that you find it again, and/or find the ability to be able to express how you'd like to.
Played this song at my sister's funeral, she loved it, she died of a brain tumor , coming up 9 year ago, it's her birthday tomorrow, she loved pink 😀
I'm so sorry. Love and prayers. ❤
@@caranelson7457 verry sorry for your loss. Love from Scotland :)
verry sorry for your loss. Love from Scotland :)
my condolences 😀
😢😢❤❤❤sorry for you
I lost my twin to suicide 11 yrs ago. I played this song at his funeral... I still miss him so much
Hope you’re doing ok
Ahh man just be strong
I hope you’re doing okay… I lost my sister to suicide 2019 and I can’t help but listen to this and drops of Jupiter whenever I miss her.
sorry to ask but was there any signs or anything you think you missed?
Forever is temporary...
Shame forever isn't for FOREVER.....
U know it
+Suzy Lu There's a quote from the Argentine singer Gustavo Cerati, that says: "I love you forever, but forever is today" (Spanish: Yo te quiero para siempre, pero siempre es hoy)
+Suzy Lu i hope you're wrong..
F1shBr4In Streams I hope too!
Мой любимый клип.слушаю в 2025 супер.
I’m an ex drug addict. I’ve been clean for 12 years now. I related to this song so much in the summer of 2006. The peak year of my addiction!
The part where she sings, count your blessings now for the long gone. So emotional!
I’m glad I changed my life.
Good for you. 👍
So am i.2yrs sober
Congratulations! I counsel those addicted to alcohol and drugs. It kills me when my client overdoses and dies. But I do have so many clients that have beat addiction. Keep it up Michael!
@@alisonmorton9465 thank you.
@@jonathancarberry1084 keep it up. 👍🏼👍🏼
this song makes me cry every time I listen to it... 😢😞
This song make me think of my parents, they were my best friends and I lost both of them to covid in the same year... I miss you mom and dad..💖
I am genuinely sorry. I lost my dad too last November. My heart goes out to you❤️
sending you all my love 💛
I lost my dad too for covid
So sorry for your loss. I pray for comfort for you and your family.
I lost my mom too 2020 i cry n remember her whenever i listen to this song same with home by chris daughtry. If someone said 3years from now u will b long gone ill stand up n punch their mouth
I lost my first love not three, but four years before this song (2006). Thank you P!NK for this ballade. It's my life song.
I listen to this all the time ... I miss my daughter so much. My Foster sister sent this song to me and I just fell in love with this song. I cry like a baby but it comforts me . she was taken from me and she had a lot to live for she leaves behind two beautiful children ... miss you everyday my christmas baby
Lisa Mae David until we meet again
having another bad day my girl miss you so much
This made me tear up
+Lisa Mae David I wish you the best of luck. You will soon be with them. All
+Katiebuggy88 lol
This reminds me of my best friend. I lost him this year
I miss him so much
Melissa Curcuy
Melissa Curcuy I lost my best "girl"friend this year too
Melissa Curcuy I lost my friend to heroin a couple of years ago I was dreaming about him just before I woke up and heard him whisper in my ear. A couple of hours later I find out he had passed away. That day was so strange cos I kinda already knew the news wasn't as shocking as it should have been. RIP Kurt. True story
dicky mint I'm sorry
You are a beautiful person Melissa. Love from Portugal
my favourite P!nk song!!!
It is one of the best!
November 2024 just love this song 🎵 ❤️ can so relate 😢
My dad passed away in 2006, I was 21, this song was on the radio on the way home from the hospital. Now I’m 38 and I’ll never forget
REST IN PARADISE
Sorry to hear that.
Sorry to hear that! Be strong!!!❤❤❤
My dad grandad both died a year after yours dad on valentines n grandad 4 days later n little bro in my arms that Xmas he survived tho. I was only 18. I had my head bashed off the floor 30 odd times n shaken so violently I felt nausea spacey think I had mild concussion also that year by abuser older brother while defending my sister.
I'm so sorry sweetheart I lost my mum to motor neuron disease during covid i the pain will go and you'll remember the love you had and the good memories but you'll feel raw emotions for a while bit now that your not alone and if you need to talk to someone it'll help.
Story of my life right here. The chorus line hits so fucking hard. Three and a half years of my life wasted because I chose to remain with someone who thought they could always walk all over me. They thought I'd never leave just because I loved them. Even when it came down to them cheating on me I couldn't leave... We broke up for 6 months yet every waking moment was torture. I couldn't move on, couldn't let go. He knew this... He begged for a second chance, begged and swore he'd treat me right. He did for awhile... but I guess it was just too late for us.
I tried my damn hardest to forget and let go of the pain, tried to forgive him... yet I couldn't. I'd cry at random times when the thought of him in another woman's arms hit me. I tried to keep up the smile, yet he knew I wasn't happy with him like I once was. Even though there were good and bad times, even though I tried to be perfect for him... it didn't work. He went back to his old ways, then every time we fought he would swear it wouldn't happen again. He lied, over and over again, and I was a fool because I believed every lie that came out of his mouth.
I let him go... and even though it was I who did the breaking up this time, once again I feel like I'm back in the spot I was last time we broke up. He wanted to break up but never had the guts to, so he just dragged me along. Yet, even though he said that we would never work out, he wanted to try, He said he didn't want to give up on what we had because he loved me more than anyone else in this world. How can he want to try, yet break up at the same time? He wanted to see how much I could take before I broke. He wanted to see how long I'd be willing to stay around even when he treated me like I was a pile of dog shit he stepped in.
I feel like all I had worked towards has fallen apart again. The tiny little pieces of my heart that he had slowly helped me put back in place have fallen, broken yet again. I lay in bed at night and grab onto his pillow like it's my lifeline, soaking it with tears, praying to every God there is that it will somehow morph into him. I imagine his skin where there is only fabric. I want to place my head on his shoulder and have him wrap his arms around me as we fall asleep at night. I want to wake up and pillow fight him again, to wrestle around and end up being late for work because time just flies by when I'm with him. I want to hear him whisper my name as he kisses my neck... I want things to go back to how they used to be! I want to stop feeling so fucking broken, so fucking USELESS!
I want him back so bad... yet I know that things will never be as they once were. I know I deserve better. I know that eventually I'll be able to move on... but I don't want to. I want him. Sad as it is, he's the best boyfriend [fiance] I had ever had. He was my best friend whom I told all my dark secrets to, secrets that no other living soul on this planet knew. He never judged me, he always said that no one could compare to me. He said I was beautiful on the inside and out. He was my life, my rock. He was my reason for everything I did...
Why couldn't I be good enough? Why?! We had so many good times... So many days of just sitting at home just enjoying the presence of each other as we talked about everything and nothing. Talked about the tiny things we had never told each other. I wanted to know every thing that made him the man he had become, and he wanted to know everything about me. I opened up too much and dug my own grave. He knew all my insecurities and used them against me in the end. He knew why I was sometimes temperamental. He knew how to get under my skin in the worst way possible.
Why do I still LOVE him after everything he has put me through? Why is it that I sit here crying because of the pain he has caused me, yet I still whimper out his name like a child whose lost its parents? He's cheated on me, belittled me, talked to women behind my back, talked about ME behind my back! He walked all over me as if I was a Welcoming Mat! He abused me mentally... and I feel like I'll always carry the scars of the years I was with him. I can't forget him, not any second of any day. Every road in this town we have traveled on, every where I look we have been. I look in the mirror and see his name tattooed above my heart. I swore I'd love him forever, and I meant it. I swore I'd never cheat on him, and I didn't. I swore I'd try my best to be everything he wanted me to be... I CAN'T BE PERFECT. I'm human! I'm not a machine that you can tweak around to do everything you want it to do! I'm not a mind reader, I don't understand what goes on inside any one's brain other than my own! And yet, I know that while I sit here ranting to people who don't care about my words on TH-cam, he's probably happy as can be 100 miles from the place he left me.
Why... why can't I move on...
If someone said three years from now, you'd be long gone
I'd stand up and punch them all out!
Cause they're all wrong..
I know better cause you said forever and ever...
Who knew...
Hi there. Erm...I'm not usually one for replying to this sort of stuff, but your story and feelings are eerily similar to my own feelings as little as six months ago. I fell in love with a guy roughly...four years ago now. He was everything Id ever looked for in a man. Tall, handsome, funny and very gentlemanly. He was, at least in my eyes, perfect for me. And I thought he felt the same way about me too.
Boy was I ever wrong.
We were in an LDR but we'd managed a few months. Then the arguments started and I got super paranoid. Creepily so. Everyday I wasn't with him, I was working myself up into a state wondering if he was in the arms of another woman. Eventually, I just couldn't take it anymore and I made the biggest mistake of my life. I let him slip away.
The very next morning, the emptiness hit me as soon as I woke up. A part of me had vanished and fluttered off to join him. Everyday since then for two entire years I thought about him. I cried and I screamed and I even tried to kill myself because I felt so lonely without him. But then...
Well I met somebody else. It was hard at first as I was extremely shy and scared to do anything. It took me a good six months before I started talking openly with him. But...he was patient and is amazingly still with me today.
That's why I can say that old cliche. It gets better over time. It won't be tomorrow. Hell, it may not even be another year from now. But trust me. When you find someone else, hell, even just something to take your mind off of him, it gets so so much better. And you'll be able to look back on your memories fondly. I know I cherished the time I spent with him a lot more now and I laugh at how ridiculous I was being back then. Of course, it isn't perfect. I still have the odd bad day, but they are so few and far between now, I am basically myself again.
I love my current boyfriend so much. And I love the first guy still too. But I know now, he wasn't perfect. Cause if he was, he wouldn't have let me let him go.
Keep strong! :)
Emma Nicholson I'm surprised someone actually took the time to read all that. I kind of went into a fit and ranted everything I felt. I needed to get it all out one way or another... More so surprised you actually wrote out more than a couple sentences... But anyways, thanks for the words. I know one day things will be okay, I'm aware it will take time to get over him. I know, since he was the first I've honestly fell in love with that he'll always hold some part of my heart... but he won't have the power to control me. I'm sorry you had to go through feelings similar as to what I'm going through. It hurts.
There was a quote I saw on the internet the other day that went something along the lines of. "At some point you have to realize that there will be some people who can remain in your heart, but not in your life."
be tough girl!
DemonsxXxHeart with your looks tell him to fuck off, your the boss.
Keep your chin up
How the heck does she make so many songs that you can listen to and enjoy when you are a kid, and then listen to and understand when you get older? It's amazing how deep and downright tragic most of her songs are when you actually understand them
Yeah it's the same with RHCP scar tissue when u read between the lines of the lyrics u find out the deeper meaning of the song then it starts to hit u.
She does it by not being just a singer like britney, she’s a professional entertainer and rockstar. When she does a show she’s giving it her all and doing the acrobatics and singing and dancing for real, I think she has some songwriters helping her behind the scenes and putting songs together for her but everyone is doing that these days
My stepdad and I jammed to her when I was 13. He was my "that's right" part. lol
He passed 2 days ago 😢
Sorry for your loss