The princess of friendship, ruler of Equestria. The princess of love, ambassador of Equestria. The princess of light, hope of Equestria. The prince of force, protector of Equestria. Nice little family.
Friendships don't have the same kind of permanence as true love. There are many instance in MLP g4 where it is made clear that Cadence could not be the person she is without Shining Armor, that he is it for her and vise versa. Friendships on the other hand are something you gain and loose all the time. And yes an argument can be made that divorce happens, and this, that, the other with romantic relationships, but that obviously isn't going to be the case for Cadence and Shining Armor. Edit: Another person up above also has a theory that Cadence represents love for ones Husband, and Shining the love for ones Wife. This theory adds more weight, because I can't think of how the love between ones friends differs at all.
Shining armor would be the alicorn of Protection, like how Cadance’s love is both with spouse and daughter, his role would be like a fatherly love and protection to bring it to full circle
The alicorn of protection seems pretty fitting you might think but if you go back to the beginning you might remember Sawtooth saying something about all the alicorns being relationships and protecting aint a relationship. So ehat about brotherhood/ older brotherhood for twilight. But then we’re missing younger brotherhood so it doesn’t fit and we already ruled out romance and parenthood with cadence so maybe it is protection but in a different way. The protection of those you care about and those who care for you. Not strength but well not to sound cliche…love.
Shining Armor being an alicorn seems perfect and honestly in my opinion an huge missed opportunity. Since Shining Armor’s sister, wife, & daughter are alicorns, I feel that a perfect opportunity to do so was maybe after he became prince of the Crystal Empire in the first episode of season 3 “The Crystal Empire” since he and Cadence became the rulers there, i felt that could’ve been a perfect time for Shining Armor to become an alicorn similar of what happened to Twilight in the season 3 finale “Magical Mystery Cure”. That way he could be like his family that are in alicorn royalties Twilight princess of friendship, Cadence princess of love, & Flurry Heart princess of light, i wonder what alicorn title Shining Armor would have.
as he said shinning amour needs to create new magic even if he has flying sickness *very small problem * plussssss u had said starswil must have used the speel on himself so we can ask starswil to do the same
First of all:to be a alicorn you have to be a princess & prince Second of all:you have to learn magic not just being a alicorn immediately you have to earn it
He may be a alicorn of protection if you compare his cuty mark and his sisters you see she is the big star in the midle and is suranded by 5 more representing the mane 6 togeder But shaining armor is the star in the shild protecting 3 stars wich may represent eiter cadens, fllury hart and tgwiliaght or the second chaild we did not get to see in the show
So yeah, it wouldn't make sense for him to also represent romantic love, but he could also represent the love for one's child, since just like how the older sibling's love for the younger and the younger sibling's love for the older is different, so is a father's and mother's love different (that is not to say that one loves their child more than the other, but that the relationship between Cadence and Flurry is not the same as between Shining and Flurry).
There are Luna and Celestia as sister but Twilight and Shining armour are BROTHER and sister through something in and protector of magic as his young sister the princess of magic and I like your series on Alicorn
Maybe he’d be the alicorn of protection (although it doesn’t include bonds/relationships like the others it seems right since he did protect canterlot from the changlings)
My thought was the correlation not between shining and cadence but twilight and cadence. Thanks to shinings marriage it makes them sisters. It goes from sun and moon to love n light and friendship. Two qualities that go hand in hand and u can’t have one without the other . With the addition of flurry it reflects the previous hierarchy if u ask me . Before twilight there were 3 princesses. Twilight was always meant to replace celestia, cadence takes Luna’s position and then flurry takes cadence’s former position keeping the balance. What if the life span of an alicorn was dependent on how long they decide or able to serve.. would the princess of friendship and love be able to continue serving after their losses- hmm
That part where you say “they love each other as equals” that is true for the most part, unless your Peter & Lois Griffin from Family Guy but thats just Family Guy logic and this is My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic logic besides comparing the 2 popular long running shows MLP is better than Family Guy even though that show eventually ended while Family Guy is still going
Prince of warriors, he was Captain of the Royal Guard when we first saw him in the episode " Canterlot Wedding ". Warrior sounds right giving his background career.
@@mohamedmusse5926 Well, you shouldn't forget the originality of the show. It was first meant for little girls so they would buy their toys. The show was originally made for girls, which is why there aren't many male characters in the show, other than the Royal Guards, Big Mac, Spike, etc. I'm not trying to offend anyone, but it's so rare for there to be male characters in the show, even as background characters. The Mane 6 and the princesses are all girls; it's a show made for girls, so they want to make them comfortable. If there is a male character, he probably doesn't have any role in the whole story. (BTW I’m a male myself so I’m not offending anyone it just the truth)
Shining armour should be seen in the family of alicorn ,as almost everyone in his family are alicons, and as twilight sparkle was an unicorn 🦄 before i do not now why he should not be a alicorn as well.😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊❤❤❤
I think he would be the alicorn of love for one's family because his destiny is not just to protect the kingdom but the family as well as the people. Thus being the alicorn of protection
I like to imagine that Shining Armor became an alicorn during a crystaling or whatever, heck maybe his alicorn form would be different from the rest! Crystal ponies are just something else, yet the crystaling and all that similar stuffs are just as significant as the normal ponies. I will argue that Shining Armor became THE FIRST Crystal Alicorn. Though of course this theory is probably debunked given how such a significant and phenominal event wasn't shown on any glass windows in the future but it's cool to imagine.
Celestia and Luna represent Equity or Harmony, and its clear via many canon pictures, banners of Celestia and Luna forming a Yin Yang. They don't represent sisterhood as Alicorns. Sisters don't need to rule together, but counter forces Day/Night Sun/Moon working together in harmony, it's literally what Equestria (equity, equine, equinox) stands for.
Twilight is the only Alison of friendship because he was exposed to earth, uni, Pegasi magic for so long. Think about it, she's been with 2 earth ponies, 2 Pegasi, and 1 unicorn (while also being a unicorn) for song, AND being friends makes it exposed to their magic.
I think shining armor could have become an alicorn if he went to the same school as twilight because sunburst went to celestia’s school too, but if he didn’t get flunked out we might have seen him as an alicorn in the show
To borrow from The legend of the seeker, maybe male alicorns are more prone to corruption than female. in the lore of The legend of the seeker universe confessors are very powerful. Their touch alone can make someone do their will. The main confesser in Wizard's First Rule has a man castrate himself for well you can imagine. She even tells our hero that male confessors would be come corrupt and abuse their power so infant males born to them are killed. So maybe they tried to accend a male to alicorn status and while he asscended he became courrpt.
but there's a male alicorn(idk) the builder man he has orange skin, light brown hair,and has eyes like big mac,and freckles,i think the account is lighthart_shine6014,and the caption is "⚠️mlp scary⚠️"
If there isn’t a male alicorn other than Luna and clelestia’s father than how did he become an alicorn? Was he born one or became one? Was he an offspring of the royal family?
In theat one episode in mlp when shining puts a magical barial around the castle Although he deosnt show as much magic as his sister but maybe his magic passed the unicorn magic rate and unlocked the power of an stalicorn As my original answer in the comments i would guess the element of protection And if equestria has the first stalicorn just like flurry heart the first natural born alicorn then celestia will maybe make a holiday of shining being the first stalicorn in history Thank you for listing to my ted talk
He should be a stalicorn of one's protections so he can show everyone that all will be protected by a stalicorns shield and ones first stallion to be a stalicorn 😊😅
I wonder if gaining wings would help with flying sickness I'm also curious if there's immortality spells. As Twilight often says, what's the princess of friendship without her friends? Interesting conundrum indeed, especially considering pinkie and cheese. (Less so for the others, who's romantic love shouldn't have any issues as it pertains to immortality, but still crucial when considering non-romantic love)
I think only females become allicorns,because if males did shining armour would already be one as he had discovered a new spell to protect the crystal empire.
If we go by your previous video with relationships, he could be the alicorn of love for one's people/nation But it would just say something like defence (celestia and luna with sisterhood still go by sun and moon.)
it really doesnt make since why shining armor isnt a alicorn, he is pretty much has the same amount of authority as cadence so its very weird how he isn't.
Correction: we’ve never seen any alicorns other than female except a few glitches and fan-made ocs (Before you said “we’ve never seen male alicorns, except a few glitches and fan-made ocs, “but there are more genders than just male/female.)
Or from selected Luna time all the alicorn got extinct and only the females one more left have you ever thought the male population could be extinct of alicorns
Shining armor should be the alicorn of defense
Or protection. Since the role of a father/husband kinda reflects that
love for ones country or community?
I also said protection
i was thinking the same thing😊😊😊😊😊
WHAT!?
If Shining Armor became an alicorn, I think he would be the alicorn of protection.
I wanted to type that!🤬👹😡👺😤
@@mreganhp You're just mad I beat you to it. 😏
I agree
Or fatherhood
True
Love for one’s husband (cadence) and love for one’s wife (shining armour)
😍😘😍😄
I think shiny armor should be Hannah Peck of protection 4:16
And then you have paternal love and maternal love within their relationships to Flurry Heart!
Yeah
Cadance*
The princess of friendship, ruler of Equestria.
The princess of love, ambassador of Equestria.
The princess of light, hope of Equestria.
The prince of force, protector of Equestria.
Nice little family.
Shining Armor needs to be the Alicorn of Protection
He would be The Alicorn of Guardianship.
I got really sad when I saw the other 5 as aging. They should also theoretically live as long as twilight.
Friendships don't have the same kind of permanence as true love. There are many instance in MLP g4 where it is made clear that Cadence could not be the person she is without Shining Armor, that he is it for her and vise versa. Friendships on the other hand are something you gain and loose all the time. And yes an argument can be made that divorce happens, and this, that, the other with romantic relationships, but that obviously isn't going to be the case for Cadence and Shining Armor.
Edit: Another person up above also has a theory that Cadence represents love for ones Husband, and Shining the love for ones Wife. This theory adds more weight, because I can't think of how the love between ones friends differs at all.
Rtdfgtrfgrfgbf4fffggvsswwsfghNO
Alicorn of Protection?
i suddenly rememner Big Mac being an alicorn 😂
😂😂😂😂😂
“Rememner” 💀
i was going too say that too
Wtf
😂😂😂
Shining armor would be the alicorn of Protection, like how Cadance’s love is both with spouse and daughter, his role would be like a fatherly love and protection to bring it to full circle
He should be the alicorn of love for ones country/kingdom
The alicorn of protection seems pretty fitting you might think but if you go back to the beginning you might remember Sawtooth saying something about all the alicorns being relationships and protecting aint a relationship. So ehat about brotherhood/ older brotherhood for twilight. But then we’re missing younger brotherhood so it doesn’t fit and we already ruled out romance and parenthood with cadence so maybe it is protection but in a different way. The protection of those you care about and those who care for you. Not strength but well not to sound cliche…love.
Shining Armor being an alicorn seems perfect and honestly in my opinion an huge missed opportunity. Since Shining Armor’s sister, wife, & daughter are alicorns, I feel that a perfect opportunity to do so was maybe after he became prince of the Crystal Empire in the first episode of season 3 “The Crystal Empire” since he and Cadence became the rulers there, i felt that could’ve been a perfect time for Shining Armor to become an alicorn similar of what happened to Twilight in the season 3 finale “Magical Mystery Cure”. That way he could be like his family that are in alicorn royalties Twilight princess of friendship, Cadence princess of love, & Flurry Heart princess of light, i wonder what alicorn title Shining Armor would have.
Cadance*
@@siddhianishkala4543 what does that have to do with my coment?
Definitely defend or water😂
@@siddhianishkala4543😂
as he said shinning amour needs to create new magic even if he has flying sickness *very small problem * plussssss u had said starswil must have used the speel on himself so we can ask starswil to do the same
No matter what G5 says I believe Shining Armor became a ailcorn!
an Alicorn*
I really want shining armor to become an alicorn
Same!
Poor shining armor, her wife sister and daughter are alicorns ans hes just spectator
@@Redvelvetinfernofr and he had to die early without his wife and daughter
STALLICORN
Same!!!!!!!!❤❤
First of all:to be a alicorn you have to be a princess & prince
Second of all:you have to learn magic not just being a alicorn immediately you have to earn it
an Alicorn*
Umm this first comment is wrong ok and you need to create new magic and you need each. Kind to become a alicorn
Flurry heart ????
He may be a alicorn of protection if you compare his cuty mark and his sisters you see she is the big star in the midle and is suranded by 5 more representing the mane 6 togeder
But shaining armor is the star in the shild protecting 3 stars wich may represent eiter cadens, fllury hart and tgwiliaght or the second chaild we did not get to see in the show
I think the 3 stars could also represent his direct family aka his mom, dad, and twilight.
@@nyxrivers8449 after i wrote it I saw it also as A posibility but i lost The coment.
And tank you for adding it here 😊
Shining armour should Be the ALICORN of greatness
So yeah, it wouldn't make sense for him to also represent romantic love, but he could also represent the love for one's child, since just like how the older sibling's love for the younger and the younger sibling's love for the older is different, so is a father's and mother's love different (that is not to say that one loves their child more than the other, but that the relationship between Cadence and Flurry is not the same as between Shining and Flurry).
stallicorn of protection
Yes I think he should be the alicorn of protection
There are Luna and Celestia as sister but Twilight and Shining armour are BROTHER and sister through something in and protector of magic as his young sister the princess of magic and I like your series on Alicorn
The princess of Friendship not magic.
If shining armour becomes a alicon he should be the alicon of protection
Maybe he’d be the alicorn of protection (although it doesn’t include bonds/relationships like the others it seems right since he did protect canterlot from the changlings)
Shine Armour should be a alicorn of Joyfulness 😊.
My thought was the correlation not between shining and cadence but twilight and cadence. Thanks to shinings marriage it makes them sisters. It goes from sun and moon to love n light and friendship. Two qualities that go hand in hand and u can’t have one without the other . With the addition of flurry it reflects the previous hierarchy if u ask me . Before twilight there were 3 princesses. Twilight was always meant to replace celestia, cadence takes Luna’s position and then flurry takes cadence’s former position keeping the balance. What if the life span of an alicorn was dependent on how long they decide or able to serve.. would the princess of friendship and love be able to continue serving after their losses- hmm
That part where you say “they love each other as equals” that is true for the most part, unless your Peter & Lois Griffin from Family Guy but thats just Family Guy logic and this is My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic logic besides comparing the 2 popular long running shows MLP is better than Family Guy even though that show eventually ended while Family Guy is still going
Big Mac became one in the shared dream, but I am not sure if that counts
alicorn of Love
Prince of warriors, he was Captain of the Royal Guard when we first saw him in the episode " Canterlot Wedding ". Warrior sounds right giving his background career.
The princesses just don’t want a boy alicorn
How dare you mlp is the best do not say anything to the princess or else !!!
@@mohamedmusse5926 Well, you shouldn't forget the originality of the show. It was first meant for little girls so they would buy their toys. The show was originally made for girls, which is why there aren't many male characters in the show, other than the Royal Guards, Big Mac, Spike, etc. I'm not trying to offend anyone, but it's so rare for there to be male characters in the show, even as background characters. The Mane 6 and the princesses are all girls; it's a show made for girls, so they want to make them comfortable. If there is a male character, he probably doesn't have any role in the whole story.
(BTW I’m a male myself so I’m not offending anyone it just the truth)
He have to earn it like Twilight did❤
It would be really sad if shining armor died and cadence and flurry heart were still ruling the Crystal Empire without him 😢
Shining armour should be seen in the family of alicorn ,as almost everyone in his family are alicons, and as twilight sparkle was an unicorn 🦄 before i do not now why he should not be a alicorn as well.😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊❤❤❤
We kinda see Bigmac in an alicorn form but it was a dream 🤣
Alicorn of gards
I think he would be the alicorn of love for one's family because his destiny is not just to protect the kingdom but the family as well as the people. Thus being the alicorn of protection
..this is starting to resemble the Olympian gods soon there’s gonna be twelve of them
The alicorn of love for his family because he’s one of the only people who is a main character with a kid and a wife so love for one’s family
I like to imagine that Shining Armor became an alicorn during a crystaling or whatever, heck maybe his alicorn form would be different from the rest! Crystal ponies are just something else, yet the crystaling and all that similar stuffs are just as significant as the normal ponies. I will argue that Shining Armor became THE FIRST Crystal Alicorn. Though of course this theory is probably debunked given how such a significant and phenominal event wasn't shown on any glass windows in the future but it's cool to imagine.
Shining armor got that Alicorn family
Celestia and Luna represent Equity or Harmony, and its clear via many canon pictures, banners of Celestia and Luna forming a Yin Yang. They don't represent sisterhood as Alicorns. Sisters don't need to rule together, but counter forces Day/Night Sun/Moon working together in harmony, it's literally what Equestria (equity, equine, equinox) stands for.
Twilight is the only Alison of friendship because he was exposed to earth, uni, Pegasi magic for so long. Think about it, she's been with 2 earth ponies, 2 Pegasi, and 1 unicorn (while also being a unicorn) for song, AND being friends makes it exposed to their magic.
The question is…why does (My Little Pony) have any male alicorn’s❓
Shining armor should be the alicorn of hope because to have love you need hope and to have light you need hope.
There is a stalicorn king cosmos
I know I’m a little late but wasn’t Celestine dad a stallioncorn?
Shining armor should be the alicorn defenser of magic
I think shining armor could have become an alicorn if he went to the same school as twilight because sunburst went to celestia’s school too, but if he didn’t get flunked out we might have seen him as an alicorn in the show
Blueblood and Shining Armor are the only known Equestrian princes to my knowledge so it’s weird that neither of them are alicorns.
To borrow from The legend of the seeker, maybe male alicorns are more prone to corruption than female. in the lore of The legend of the seeker universe confessors are very powerful. Their touch alone can make someone do their will. The main confesser in Wizard's First Rule has a man castrate himself for well you can imagine. She even tells our hero that male confessors would be come corrupt and abuse their power so infant males born to them are killed. So maybe they tried to accend a male to alicorn status and while he asscended he became courrpt.
Element element of of of of of of of Shield❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Fatherhood vs motherhood
He should be love for one’s partner
Shining armor should be the king of protection to
Shining Armor should be the Alicorn protection of love and friendship.
Technically in Equestrian History we have one Stallicorn the father of Princess Celestia and Princess Luna
The Prince of Protection….it sounds right.
The stalacorn of protection🛡️
His wings will be like cadence (white and Navy blue
Loving someone’s wife or sister, it’s one of them
Alicorn of leadership
good man in your own way 😂😇😙
Brotherhood
he should be an alicorn of child support 💀
JK he should be the alicorn of guards
but there's a male alicorn(idk) the builder man he has orange skin, light brown hair,and has eyes like big mac,and freckles,i think the account is lighthart_shine6014,and the caption is "⚠️mlp scary⚠️"
I like the idea but my idea is this:
I think flurry hearts became an alicorn because she took shiningarmors wings.
Signing armour should be the shining armour should be the Ali corn of unity
he will be the alicorn of protector for peoples love
If there isn’t a male alicorn other than Luna and clelestia’s father than how did he become an alicorn? Was he born one or became one? Was he an offspring of the royal family?
Maybe he will be in Alcorn in the future. We just haven’t seen it yet. He might be an Anti-kight
In theat one episode in mlp when shining puts a magical barial around the castle
Although he deosnt show as much magic as his sister but maybe his magic passed the unicorn magic rate and unlocked the power of an stalicorn
As my original answer in the comments i would guess the element of protection
And if equestria has the first stalicorn just like flurry heart the first natural born alicorn then celestia will maybe make a holiday of shining being the first stalicorn in history
Thank you for listing to my ted talk
He should be a stalicorn of one's protections so he can show everyone that all will be protected by a stalicorns shield and ones first stallion to be a stalicorn 😊😅
Because he didn't understand the friend. He didn't understand the anything
Shining armour should be the alicorn of loyalty
Shining armor should be the Alcorn of guarding that’s a word
The alicorn of protection
I thing that shining armor should be an alicorn of helping
The love of ones kingdom
Prince of justice and protection
I don't know,
maybe, I can't decide
I wonder if gaining wings would help with flying sickness
I'm also curious if there's immortality spells. As Twilight often says, what's the princess of friendship without her friends? Interesting conundrum indeed, especially considering pinkie and cheese. (Less so for the others, who's romantic love shouldn't have any issues as it pertains to immortality, but still crucial when considering non-romantic love)
I think only females become allicorns,because if males did shining armour would already be one as he had discovered a new spell to protect the crystal empire.
Shining on my should become the king of protection that way you can become alicorn
If we go by your previous video with relationships, he could be the alicorn of love for one's people/nation
But it would just say something like defence (celestia and luna with sisterhood still go by sun and moon.)
Shinning armor would be some kind of different alicorn
Alicorn of Magic protection
it really doesnt make since why shining armor isnt a alicorn, he is pretty much has the same amount of authority as cadence so its very weird how he isn't.
If he were to be a alicor, he would be the alicorn of protection.
Cadance*
King of friendship
No.
Correction: we’ve never seen any alicorns other than female except a few glitches and fan-made ocs
(Before you said “we’ve never seen male alicorns, except a few glitches and fan-made ocs, “but there are more genders than just male/female.)
alicorn of protection
Yes marmor should be an alicorn of the crystal empires guard
And she's the king of the star and heart 💙
prince of magic
Alicorn of the roayle guards
Shining Armor will be the first Stallicorn
King of the stars
I know why flurry is a alicorn.its because cadence was a pegasis and shining armour is a unicord,Does this make sence?
Or from selected Luna time all the alicorn got extinct and only the females one more left have you ever thought the male population could be extinct of alicorns
1Year, lol!
Because he's already a captain of the Royal guards?
Protection alicorn