it actually has the entire senate+1 since padme is a senator too. the gunship winning out in price/piece as well as price/senator is pretty damning evidence that its the better set.
The gunship could have been vastly improved if they gave it double doors, replaced the stud shooters with ball turrets (which would save on piece count, and you could move the stud shooters to the top where a missile rack should be) and if they gave us something to do with the hatch below the cockpit. These changes would not have drastically affected the part count. And not giving it double doors off the bat is so confusing. Just why? So many simple changes could have made this the best set of the year. Maybe 2 more clones, a better Fox.
They didn't give it double doors because they're too finicky for LEGO's newer playability standards. It's the same reason that LEGO mechs don't have knees anymore
@@nanorex_designs LEGO mechs not having knees or elbows because that stupid ninjago evo mech piece will forever kill me. I hate that piece with my entire soul
AT-TE by a landslide! 5 troopers and 3 droids over 3 troopers and 2 senators Accuracy on the AT-TE is much better. Color scheme is the one we really want.
Anakin will be in the Ahsoka show in ep 5, 7 and 8, in the world between worlds, as a hologram, and as a force ghost. Marrok is nobody important, and Ahsoka will have a near death experience of some kind.
Cmdr Cody is so cool in his P2 armor and he’s my fave clone, so when I was able to get my favorite SW walker, my favorite clone, and 3 212th troopers for $29 less than the normal price I was ecstatic
I agree with how changing up the color scheme on the new LAAT was an excellent choice. Also, the in universe Coruscant Guard LAAT doesn’t have clear bubble turrets, so the stud shooter ones aren’t as inaccurate as people say.
The point is that people have been waiting for a LAAT for years, and the one they get is a small, red very specific one, instead of the always cool white/green/red one. Otherwise: a disappointment
LOL! I love the intro! This was such an interesting comparison. I honestly love both sets but the AT-TE definitely takes first place. The Gunship could have at least gotten a weapons rack for the troops for the empty space. It’s exciting to see Commander Fox, but the printed cape and pink-ish chest kinda kills the hype. Let’s hope the next Gunship is improved and we don’t have to wait another decade 😅.
It's not even hard to give it double doors, and Fox desperately needed dual molded legs since he has no waist cape. He looks ridiculous from behind. (And I'm not talking LEGO Chewie ridiculous from behind.)
I actually don’t think the figures in either set are that bad compared to the worst we’ve ever gotten. I still see so much more value in the AT-TE though. Having the larger and more accessible interior space and a bigger footprint give it more of an appeal.
Really liked the skit in the beginning! Well done Ryan! The ATTE is a no brainer decision for me! It has great detail compared to the Coruscant Guard gunship and it is the correct color scheme. It also has a whopping 5 clones and 3 droids compared to the Coruscant Guard gunship with 3 clones and 2 senators 😢. Definitely for me the ATTE is the better buy here!
ATTE is definitely the better build, and I think has more play and display value, yes printing on the helmets themselves aren’t great, but I personally don’t have the helmet holes so when it comes to the gunship I just cannot complain about the two shock troopers, Fox certainly isn’t great though. Also that intro was great 😂 have a good day Ryan
I missed out on the older gunship sets, so I was super hyped when I found out there was a 2023 gunship. I don't think it's a bad set, but it's not quite what I want out of a LEGO gunship, so I'm probably gonna skip it, or at least wait for a sale. I wish they went with a different style of gunship instead of the Coruscant Guard. The original style is my favorite, but a muunilist or wolfpack variant would be pretty cool too.
Dont underestimate those spider droids. in the clone wars show you can see one shoot out a leg of an atte and take the whole thing out. Cant remember the season or episode though
AT-TE is the best. Excellent build and excellent Cody. Best bang for your buck for the $140. To me, when you have to modify the build so much to have accuracy it takes a big hit. The minifigs should be a bonus, not the star of the set. They need to just do SW CMFs if that’s the case.
Just wait it out and target has at-te for $113.99, Amazon $112 after 4 months of release. I think the Gunship will be thst price soon, but i got impatient , eventually I'll buy 5 of each when they are cheaper so I can make the venator and republic frigate mods.
The atte (besides maybe the odd inclusion of a spider droid and terrible 212th helmets) is the perfect star wars set phenomenal/definitive atte build and a phase 2 Cody. The new gunship is just that,a new gunship.
Fans with AT-TE: We have you four to one! Lego with republic gunship: I like those odds. MandR: AT-TE is the winner! Love the videos, keep up the great work!
@@MandRproductions np ps every since this summer began your content has just been better as someone who has been watching since 2017 this has to be one of the best content upgrades you have made
*FUN FACT: HERE IN BELGIUM THE AT-TE IS ACTUALLY AROUND 40 EUROS CHEAPER!* I have bought this AT-TE set for 95 euros. I will also buy the Gunship in a lowered prize, it's a weaker version. It also needs some modifications to be accurate so that also brings the popularity and also the prize later on, down. I would only buy the Gunship in discount and will buy the Clone Shock Troopers seperately from Bricklink or other websites.
Just built the AT-TE, and I’d argue that it’s up there with the old Attack of the Clones gunship. So good. A fun, super solid build, that makes great use of its pieces.
I like this type of video, I've been wondering which double ship set (tie interceptor and fang fighter, and the Ahsoka one) to buy. I'd love to see that video!
I actually enjoy the helmet holes because they add a massive amount of play value to the minifig. However this is only useful if Lego makes more helmet accessories like the new macro visor, which it looks like the future may hold more of. It is my personal hope that the rumored plain clone battle pack will include some extra accessories like in the og battle packs!
At 4 minutes 20 seconds, the reason that the Coruscant Gunship has no stuff in the front is because they need to be able to fit troops in there, they can fit more in the empty space than in the ATTE, although the ATTE has enough space for 8 clone troopers, you could fit far more standing clones because of the empty space and the 2 large cavities inside the build.
They looked bad yesterday, they look bad today, and they’ll look bad tomorrow. My stance will never change and every set cursed with them will receive the same deserved criticism.
Thank you for doing a review on this lego set before I might spend $140 on a set that I might not even want. ;) (I didn't see the actual revive video. I'm watching it now.)
Managed to grab each of these for under $100 each recently. Definitely feels like a more appropriate price and a no brainer for me at that point. Glad a grabbed them!
Yeah, fox is pretty bad, but you can fix him up. Just give him a black visor and a Kama and you should be good if the torso doesn’t bother you all too much.
"You have a $140 decision to make: You take the orange pill,you get the best AT-TE ever, with a side of Lego's worst clone troopers. You take the red pill, you get Jyn Erso cosplaying as Padme, AND YOU ALSO GET THE SENATE."
Ive got the AT-TE so far (need another one though) and i love it, cant wait to get that gunship. Im doing a 212th moc so the AT-TE is good for filler clones i could use (personally i prefer getting custom minifigs with 360° printing). My only issue with the gunship is gonna be swapping all those maroon pieces for orange and black, but at least then ill have more maroon pieces to turn the new R2 set into R4 lol
Genuinely speaking, I like every of these minifigures. I might agree that for the collectors they may seem poor but as an army builder or playset, or peace of storytelling (for example, using it in a stop-motion movies) they are really nicely done. Maybe that is not a popular opinion, but I think that these minifigs are definitely not bad and not ugly. They may be not as properly made as people would like them to be, but I still think that they are good.
We bought the walker at full price at the Walmart when we were visiting grandma and we built it right away and my son and I had a great weekend of playing Legos and eating homemade anything at grandmas house that weekend. The walker is tough it’s sturdy. I can handle a bunch of kids playing with it even if one of the legs come off mini figures aside I thought it was a fun build for me and it looks cool on my shelf with all the other Star Wars things. I don’t think I’m going to pick up the gun ship after all everyone’s talking about how lame that the things are. I’m just not gonna grab it. Looking forward to the walker to be on sale a little bit more in the next couple of weeks so I can have two.
Incredible video Ryan! Loved the opening and the production quality on these comparison videos are always great. Definitely one of my favorite series you do and I think the AT-TE is better too!
consider the following: you get the entire senate in the gunship
IKR? It's not even close
it actually has the entire senate+1 since padme is a senator too. the gunship winning out in price/piece as well as price/senator is pretty damning evidence that its the better set.
@xSkye629x "I am the senate." According to papa Palpatine
@eitak12334
No the entire senate + the walking dead
Not yet
Hey everyone welcome to FILM THEORY! And today we are gonna be discussing if Ryan is a simp for padme!
He is a simp for padme
@@cassettelord2008who isnt?
@@smoothyodaproductions4373me?
@@smoothyodaproductions4373nvm i just saw her figure
I mens who isn’t??? I sure am
The gunship could have been vastly improved if they gave it double doors, replaced the stud shooters with ball turrets (which would save on piece count, and you could move the stud shooters to the top where a missile rack should be) and if they gave us something to do with the hatch below the cockpit. These changes would not have drastically affected the part count. And not giving it double doors off the bat is so confusing. Just why? So many simple changes could have made this the best set of the year. Maybe 2 more clones, a better Fox.
Fax, and maybe thorn instead of fox
They didn't give it double doors because they're too finicky for LEGO's newer playability standards. It's the same reason that LEGO mechs don't have knees anymore
@@nanorex_designs LEGO mechs not having knees or elbows because that stupid ninjago evo mech piece will forever kill me.
I hate that piece with my entire soul
@@Fulcrumn9I'd prefer they save thorn for the future to give him a better look with a potential waste cape and better printing
@@mrpenguinkro1213 true, i didn't think of that
AT-TE by a landslide! 5 troopers and 3 droids over 3 troopers and 2 senators
Accuracy on the AT-TE is much better.
Color scheme is the one we really want.
Anakin will be in the Ahsoka show in ep 5, 7 and 8, in the world between worlds, as a hologram, and as a force ghost. Marrok is nobody important, and Ahsoka will have a near death experience of some kind.
You mean "3 troopers and the entire Senate"?
yo how did you predict that, do you have inside information? He posted his comment before the episode released! Spoiler by the way!@@ncard00
If the gunship was also larger and not this scaled down size that would help a lot too.
Just looking at the box art and how much more value you get the AT-TE blows it out of the water
Cmdr Cody is so cool in his P2 armor and he’s my fave clone, so when I was able to get my favorite SW walker, my favorite clone, and 3 212th troopers for $29 less than the normal price I was ecstatic
The AT-TE is just the superior build the gunship is absolutely trash
@@JackLovin-xq7ujyeah the selection overall was far below decent but for playing its really decent(bought the at te)
I agree with how changing up the color scheme on the new LAAT was an excellent choice. Also, the in universe Coruscant Guard LAAT doesn’t have clear bubble turrets, so the stud shooter ones aren’t as inaccurate as people say.
It actually does have the wing bubbles. Just not the side mounted bubble turrets.
@@Agrimirthe turrets on the wings aren’t clear, they’re grey
I dont even think they look that bad to be honest
The point is that people have been waiting for a LAAT for years, and the one they get is a small, red very specific one, instead of the always cool white/green/red one. Otherwise: a disappointment
When will you stop complaining about helmet holes
For him most likely never
Yeah kamas are so much worse yet he doesn’t complain about those nearly as much
Tbh the printed waste capes deserve the hate but the helmet holes aren't bad
@@YodaFitnessOfficial It’s just kinda depressing to know that phase two helmets peaked 2 years ago, but I’m just happy I can get named clones
@@Sashin-d8tI personally like the current state of clone sets, there seems to be a pretty good amount of cool minifigures.
LOL! I love the intro! This was such an interesting comparison. I honestly love both sets but the AT-TE definitely takes first place. The Gunship could have at least gotten a weapons rack for the troops for the empty space. It’s exciting to see Commander Fox, but the printed cape and pink-ish chest kinda kills the hype. Let’s hope the next Gunship is improved and we don’t have to wait another decade 😅.
yeah fox should had more of a dark red, the same in the show
It's not even hard to give it double doors, and Fox desperately needed dual molded legs since he has no waist cape. He looks ridiculous from behind. (And I'm not talking LEGO Chewie ridiculous from behind.)
I actually don’t think the figures in either set are that bad compared to the worst we’ve ever gotten. I still see so much more value in the AT-TE though. Having the larger and more accessible interior space and a bigger footprint give it more of an appeal.
Yeah, the figures are definitely not bad just because they have helmet holes. The Coruscant guards specifically look really nice in my opinion
Commander Fox is the one that doesn't look very good. The armor looking pink instead of white is not a good look
@@spencerboerboom4043 Fox also has a completely wrong and inaccurate torso, too...
@@justinbombach9873no he doesnt😂😂😂
@@AnAverageGamer662What are you smoking and can I have some?
Those first few seconds are amazing 😂
brother
Really liked the skit in the beginning! Well done Ryan! The ATTE is a no brainer decision for me! It has great detail compared to the Coruscant Guard gunship and it is the correct color scheme. It also has a whopping 5 clones and 3 droids compared to the Coruscant Guard gunship with 3 clones and 2 senators 😢. Definitely for me the ATTE is the better buy here!
Correction, the gunship has 3 clones, a senator, and the entire senate.
ATTE is definitely the better build, and I think has more play and display value, yes printing on the helmets themselves aren’t great, but I personally don’t have the helmet holes so when it comes to the gunship I just cannot complain about the two shock troopers, Fox certainly isn’t great though.
Also that intro was great 😂 have a good day Ryan
Why don't you have the holes? Did you mean it's not a big deal for you?
@@RJ_200 oh lol, ya they don’t bother me 😂.
I have the coruscant guard gunship and find nothing wrong with it dude
Who needs Leonardo DiCaprio, when you have Ryan. Top tier acting skills.
I missed out on the older gunship sets, so I was super hyped when I found out there was a 2023 gunship. I don't think it's a bad set, but it's not quite what I want out of a LEGO gunship, so I'm probably gonna skip it, or at least wait for a sale. I wish they went with a different style of gunship instead of the Coruscant Guard. The original style is my favorite, but a muunilist or wolfpack variant would be pretty cool too.
Yeah it’s just way too niche for such a popular ship that barely ever gets made
I don't mind the choice for the gunship, but to my the problem is the coloration is off, the color used just makes the set look bad
I dont think it looks bad personally plus i actually like it cuz red is my favorite color, also i like the characters and minifigs
Dont underestimate those spider droids. in the clone wars show you can see one shoot out a leg of an atte and take the whole thing out. Cant remember the season or episode though
I think that was in the Clone Wars movie when Ashoka and Anakin scaled the wall of the monastery to rescue Rotta or something
bro was sold at Padme
AT-TE is the best. Excellent build and excellent Cody. Best bang for your buck for the $140. To me, when you have to modify the build so much to have accuracy it takes a big hit. The minifigs should be a bonus, not the star of the set. They need to just do SW CMFs if that’s the case.
Just wait it out and target has at-te for $113.99, Amazon $112 after 4 months of release. I think the Gunship will be thst price soon, but i got impatient , eventually I'll buy 5 of each when they are cheaper so I can make the venator and republic frigate mods.
The background music adds extra depth and a hint of suspense / drama to your video. Love this addition to your collection
One thing the gunship is better than my homemade one
I never thought id hear "Clubbed to Death" in a lego review but here we are
"You get-" You had me at padme
I think a Ghost and Phantom II vs. Justifier comparison would be a great sequel!
I’m trying to decide between those sets.
I got the Justifier during the last Wal-Mart clearance. The Ghost will be harder to find deals due to it being an Amazon exclusive.
That intro got you the like, didn't even need to watch the rest of the video. Perfection.
Nice job on the editing for this video, it seems like it’s substantially improved. Although the editing on your other videos is still great
Appreciate it I spent a long time on this one!!
Can I just say, I want to see more of that Clone Army. That looks INSANE!
The beginning 😁🤌. Very funny.
in australia, the atte costs 229 and the gunship cost 249. for one extra piece i am paying 20 dollars
The atte (besides maybe the odd inclusion of a spider droid and terrible 212th helmets) is the perfect star wars set phenomenal/definitive atte build and a phase 2 Cody. The new gunship is just that,a new gunship.
Those awful new helmets are probably going to make me have to buy the overpriced 2nd version 212th clones
Why the clones's helmets are bad ? I can't see the problem ?
@@elliotdelecaut1990The printing is not good at all, and the holes, I personally like them tho
No way that intro is one of the most creative thing i’ve seen on this app
This is fire🔥🔥
The best thing in my opinion about the at te is that that if you own the old 501st battle pack all the seats will be filled.
Fans with AT-TE: We have you four to one! Lego with republic gunship: I like those odds. MandR: AT-TE is the winner!
Love the videos, keep up the great work!
Bro THIS INTRO GOT ME SPEECHLESS amazing work
Glad you like it
@@MandRproductions np ps every since this summer began your content has just been better as someone who has been watching since 2017 this has to be one of the best content upgrades you have made
*FUN FACT: HERE IN BELGIUM THE AT-TE IS ACTUALLY AROUND 40 EUROS CHEAPER!*
I have bought this AT-TE set for 95 euros. I will also buy the Gunship in a lowered prize, it's a weaker version. It also needs some modifications to be accurate so that also brings the popularity and also the prize later on, down. I would only buy the Gunship in discount and will buy the Clone Shock Troopers seperately from Bricklink or other websites.
In Germany the AT-TE also is about 40 euros cheaper. I bought one in may for only 85 euros.
@@n.baecker1280 Yea it's insane that people would buy those sets without even checking prizes haha
I honestly like the coruscant guard gunship a lot
Same
Because it's a gunship but severally downgrade compared to the older models
Yeah one of my problems with it is that the wings at the side look kind of long and kind of make the rest of the gunship look really small
I feel the mini figures in the gunship will be worth more years later
Victoria Secrets Commander Fox😊
I love the skit at the start.
Red pill. Padme is such a baddie
Seriously tho, I’d take the orange. Personally I like the atte set better
Just built the AT-TE, and I’d argue that it’s up there with the old Attack of the Clones gunship. So good. A fun, super solid build, that makes great use of its pieces.
I like this type of video, I've been wondering which double ship set (tie interceptor and fang fighter, and the Ahsoka one) to buy. I'd love to see that video!
Been looking forward to this video for a while, and it looks like it will not disappoint.
I actually enjoy the helmet holes because they add a massive amount of play value to the minifig. However this is only useful if Lego makes more helmet accessories like the new macro visor, which it looks like the future may hold more of. It is my personal hope that the rumored plain clone battle pack will include some extra accessories like in the og battle packs!
Definitely
At first I didn’t really feel these videos, but after a lot of research on what to buy by watching these videos, I love them. Thanks MandR
Is it only me who loves the look of Fox? I think he looks really cool. Maby not 100% accurate but still cool
Another great feature with the Gunship is that Fox doubles as a pilot. Does Cody? No. Gunship wins.
/s
AT-TE is superior in every way literally like how is this a discussion
You can put more troops it you tempery remove the technic piece in the middle from the doors
Red pill: Fix the clone helmet warts.
Blue pill: Fix the clone prints.
I would only buy the coruscant guard gunship if it was on sale tbh I prefer the AT-TE
Please do a ghost vs gunship video, I need to know how to spend my money lol.
Dwarf spider droids were shown blowing up AT-TEs in the clone wars. Think of it like a javelin missile team vs a T72.
Bro woke up and chose violence
At 4 minutes 20 seconds, the reason that the Coruscant Gunship has no stuff in the front is because they need to be able to fit troops in there, they can fit more in the empty space than in the ATTE, although the ATTE has enough space for 8 clone troopers, you could fit far more standing clones because of the empty space and the 2 large cavities inside the build.
Ryan thank you for these amazing videos
Ryan will never stop complaining about helmet holes and I love it
They looked bad yesterday, they look bad today, and they’ll look bad tomorrow. My stance will never change and every set cursed with them will receive the same deserved criticism.
how is it bad? it doesnt even change a lot@@MandRproductions
@@baimo_ofcI see what you are trying to say but Lego made it worse than it was before helmet holes dropping quality
@@MandRproductionsi really don't care about holes
Me personally I only think the 212th troopers are mid, but the clone gunner and shock troopers look good IMO
But Ryan how did LEGO stick a Gunship into such a tiny box?😊
Everyone should be taking the real Orange Pill IYKYK
Thank you for doing a review on this lego set before I might spend $140 on a set that I might not even want. ;) (I didn't see the actual revive video. I'm watching it now.)
HAHA love the intro ryan that was great stuff right there.
Decided to finally build my AT TE a few days ago, enjoyed it. Also the republic icon is actually the Bendu symbol.
Walmart has the at-te for $112 so a good deal in comparison
Is the sticker on your Atte upsidedown
dawg i had this choice from my parents and i went for the corrosunt but instead of a gunship im gonna make it into a dropship so wish me luck guys
Best intro you ever done
I love the good the bad the ugly reference
Just got the AT TE on sale about $30 off at target, so excited to build it and add it to my collection
Managed to grab each of these for under $100 each recently. Definitely feels like a more appropriate price and a no brainer for me at that point. Glad a grabbed them!
Bro ive never seen mandr make a skit lol it was great
Awesome comparison. I'm actually in the middle of building the AT-TE right now!
Amazing video!🐐🔥
That intro deserves a like
Great video, thanks for the content. 👍
What the?? There’s 2 of you!!!
I was pleased to recently find the AT-TE on rollback at Walmart for $112.
ahhhh i love the backing music please use more in your vids as it sets the moods also greeeaaat vids
"Spins 360 degrees"
*gun turret breaks* may he rest in peace 💀
Guys he gunship is a good set and it’s all good double doors might be a bit hard
Thanks. I was debating between the two but the walker definetely looks better. Thank you.
When the gunship was rumored I wanted to wait and get it but eventually got impatient and bought the At-te. Now I'm glad of my decision
Yeah, fox is pretty bad, but you can fix him up. Just give him a black visor and a Kama and you should be good if the torso doesn’t bother you all too much.
The matrix reference was a inclusion I didn't know I needed
Would love a comparison of the Tie-Interceptor/Mandalorian Fang Fighter vs the E-Wing/Shin Hati Starfighter sets
You should do a comparison like this with the 2020 AAT and the 2022 Republic Fighter Tank!
Ryan: "Commander Fox is the worst Clone Trooper Lego has ever made."
2002-2007 clone troopers: "Am I a joke to you?"
Cool I got both fo Christmas
"You have a $140 decision to make: You take the orange pill,you get the best AT-TE ever, with a side of Lego's worst clone troopers. You take the red pill, you get Jyn Erso cosplaying as Padme, AND YOU ALSO GET THE SENATE."
Ive got the AT-TE so far (need another one though) and i love it, cant wait to get that gunship. Im doing a 212th moc so the AT-TE is good for filler clones i could use (personally i prefer getting custom minifigs with 360° printing). My only issue with the gunship is gonna be swapping all those maroon pieces for orange and black, but at least then ill have more maroon pieces to turn the new R2 set into R4 lol
I'm definitely getting the atte for my birthday, and maybe the gunship later on
If you are saying that padmes outfit is inacurate to what we see in clone wars. Wouldn’t that mean fox is inaccurate and should have been thorn
This is getting out of hand! Now, there are two of them! 😁 Good comparison video.
"One extra piece compared to the AT-TE" is crazy
I got both anyway because I was a toddler when good legos came so this is the best for me
You should make a video where you take the AT-TE Walker into a gunship, and turn the gunship into a AT-TE
The AT-TE is currently $113. Slam dunk IMO. Maybe the Gunship will get there next year too.
Where did you find it for $113
@StarNameKev pretty much everywhere online now...Amazon is where I got mine
@ryanhuff745 might have to snag one then, thanks for letting me know 🫡
Just picked up the ATTE for about $90 new, plus two 501st packs to help bulk it out for an extra $30.
Genuinely speaking, I like every of these minifigures. I might agree that for the collectors they may seem poor but as an army builder or playset, or peace of storytelling (for example, using it in a stop-motion movies) they are really nicely done. Maybe that is not a popular opinion, but I think that these minifigs are definitely not bad and not ugly. They may be not as properly made as people would like them to be, but I still think that they are good.
I recently got the ATTE for 112$ and have loved it, and I do not intend on getting the LAAT, and this video proves it
Ryan should make a documentary about helmet holes
We bought the walker at full price at the Walmart when we were visiting grandma and we built it right away and my son and I had a great weekend of playing Legos and eating homemade anything at grandmas house that weekend. The walker is tough it’s sturdy. I can handle a bunch of kids playing with it even if one of the legs come off mini figures aside I thought it was a fun build for me and it looks cool on my shelf with all the other Star Wars things. I don’t think I’m going to pick up the gun ship after all everyone’s talking about how lame that the things are. I’m just not gonna grab it. Looking forward to the walker to be on sale a little bit more in the next couple of weeks so I can have two.
Incredible video Ryan! Loved the opening and the production quality on these comparison videos are always great. Definitely one of my favorite series you do and I think the AT-TE is better too!