C'est bien beau ces tutoriels, mais allez-vous enfin mettre à jour le bot d'entrainement de Magic Arena ? Qu'ils puissent enfin avoir une intelligence convenable et la possibilité de choisir le deck qu'il joue, voire, de lui en faire un, si cela nous plaît ? Votre bot d'entrainement est dépassé depuis des années, en plus de faire des erreurs incompréhensibles la plupart du temps, sans oublier qu'une fois qu'il n'a plus de carte en main, le bot ne représente plus de menace. Puis, nous ne pouvons pas choisir la difficulté du bot d'entrainement, ce qui est frustrant si nous débutons ou non au jeu, car peu importe le deck qu'il prend, il fonce sur son adversaire sans lui laisser de répit et selon moi, ce n'est pas de la stratégie que de bourriner. Traduction : Tutorials are all well and good, but will you finally update the Magic Arena training bot? So that it can finally have decent intelligence and the ability to choose the deck it plays, or even make one for it, if we like? Your training bot has been outdated for years, making incomprehensible mistakes most of the time, not to mention the fact that once it has no cards in its hand, the bot no longer poses a threat. Then there's the fact that we can't choose the difficulty of the training bot, which is frustrating if you're new to the game or not, because no matter what deck it picks up, it rushes at its opponent without giving him a break, and in my opinion, it's not strategy to drudge.
What happens if I target my own food token and sacrifice it as a bargain, but then sacrifice it with it's own ability as a response to the bargain sacrifice effect?
Bargain is an additional cost, so you must sacrifice your Food in order to pay for the spell you attempt to put on the stack. And since sac'ing the food to bargain happens before the spell is even on the stack, you don't have the ability to "respond" to it, and you simply won't be able to activate it's ability to gain some life, as you'd already have sac'ed to bargain the spell. Plus, if you target your food but use it to pay for the spell, it will most probably fizzle
You are correct in that activated abilities are using the stack and work at "instant speed". You can answer to your own abilities once they are paid for and put on the stack, or answer to one of your own spells on the stack with any accentuate ability (same say explicitly "use only when you could cast a sorcery"). However in order for the *first* ability and the spell to even be on the stack, all conditions have to be met and all costs have to be paid. Since bargain is an alternate (added) cost, your food token will already have been sacrificed when the spell in on the stack and therefore cannot be targeted by the very spell it helped to cast. This prevents multiple or infinite uses of resources; what constitutes a cost is crucial in magic (mana values, and for abilities, anything previous to the semi-colon "X [cost] : Z [effect]). Good luck and have fun!
Sorceries can't be cast while there are spells or abilities on the stack. You can only play them when the stack is empty, and only on your turn. (Unless there's some ability that lets you cast them anytime you could cast an Instant, in which case it works just like an instant)
This is a good foundation for people to understand the stack at its simplest form but a good one
Now I understand how I’ve been messing up 😂
The 2nd example really made me get it.
This video needs an example with an activated ability of a creature that is getting destroyed
C'est bien beau ces tutoriels, mais allez-vous enfin mettre à jour le bot d'entrainement de Magic Arena ? Qu'ils puissent enfin avoir une intelligence convenable et la possibilité de choisir le deck qu'il joue, voire, de lui en faire un, si cela nous plaît ? Votre bot d'entrainement est dépassé depuis des années, en plus de faire des erreurs incompréhensibles la plupart du temps, sans oublier qu'une fois qu'il n'a plus de carte en main, le bot ne représente plus de menace. Puis, nous ne pouvons pas choisir la difficulté du bot d'entrainement, ce qui est frustrant si nous débutons ou non au jeu, car peu importe le deck qu'il prend, il fonce sur son adversaire sans lui laisser de répit et selon moi, ce n'est pas de la stratégie que de bourriner.
Traduction :
Tutorials are all well and good, but will you finally update the Magic Arena training bot? So that it can finally have decent intelligence and the ability to choose the deck it plays, or even make one for it, if we like? Your training bot has been outdated for years, making incomprehensible mistakes most of the time, not to mention the fact that once it has no cards in its hand, the bot no longer poses a threat. Then there's the fact that we can't choose the difficulty of the training bot, which is frustrating if you're new to the game or not, because no matter what deck it picks up, it rushes at its opponent without giving him a break, and in my opinion, it's not strategy to drudge.
Mon ami, pardonnez mes écrits, mais je pense que nous ne sommes pas les seuls à avoir réalisé que cette IA est à l’envers.
What happens if I target my own food token and sacrifice it as a bargain, but then sacrifice it with it's own ability as a response to the bargain sacrifice effect?
Bargain is an additional cost, so you must sacrifice your Food in order to pay for the spell you attempt to put on the stack. And since sac'ing the food to bargain happens before the spell is even on the stack, you don't have the ability to "respond" to it, and you simply won't be able to activate it's ability to gain some life, as you'd already have sac'ed to bargain the spell.
Plus, if you target your food but use it to pay for the spell, it will most probably fizzle
You are correct in that activated abilities are using the stack and work at "instant speed". You can answer to your own abilities once they are paid for and put on the stack, or answer to one of your own spells on the stack with any accentuate ability (same say explicitly "use only when you could cast a sorcery"). However in order for the *first* ability and the spell to even be on the stack, all conditions have to be met and all costs have to be paid. Since bargain is an alternate (added) cost, your food token will already have been sacrificed when the spell in on the stack and therefore cannot be targeted by the very spell it helped to cast. This prevents multiple or infinite uses of resources; what constitutes a cost is crucial in magic (mana values, and for abilities, anything previous to the semi-colon "X [cost] : Z [effect]). Good luck and have fun!
If that 3rd spell was a sorcery does the scenario still resolve the same or do card type gain priority?
Sorceries can't be cast while there are spells or abilities on the stack. You can only play them when the stack is empty, and only on your turn.
(Unless there's some ability that lets you cast them anytime you could cast an Instant, in which case it works just like an instant)
Après tu peux jouer contre des joueurs