3 of the Top Portable Column Line Array Speaker Systems on Pro Acoustics Tech Talk Episode 8
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ส.ค. 2024
- www.proacousticsusa.com
Check out our updated video: • Top 3 Bluetooth Portab...
On this episode of Pro Acoustics Tech Talk, Nathan and Coltin compare 3 of the top portable column line array speaker systems featuring products from Electro-Voice, Bose, and Behringer.
If you are interested in the products in this video, email sales@proacoustics.com or give us a call at (888) 256-4112.
Correction: The Electro-Voice Evolve 50 has Bluetooth streaming and Bluetooth control.
Find us on Facebook:
/ proacousticsusacom
Follow us on Instagram:
/ proacousticsusa
Electro-Voice Evolve 50: www.proacousticsusa.com/elect...
Bose L1 Compact: www.proacousticsusa.com/bose-...
Behringer C200: www.proacousticsusa.com/behri...
I ended up buying a pair of EV Evolve 50(in White), and I am extremely pleased. I bought them with use at home(guitar looping practice) and a few small gigs for church. No sooner than I got them, I was asked to supply sound for a church service in a large auditorium(seats 520) and they were MORE than enough for a band with Acoustic Drum Set, Bass Guitar, Electric Guitar, Keyboard, Acoustic Guitar and two Vocals. Miking up the drums was done with a Beta 52 and single Rode NT5, Bass, Guitars and Keys all went direct. They were mixed through an Allen & Heath QuPAC mixer via AB168 Stage Box and monitoring was done wire via Behringer Headphone amp and wired IEMs. Not only were the Evolve 50s loud enough, but the sound was incredibly smooth with very punchy bass. I was genuinely expecting the pair of Evolve 50s would not be enough. And boy I was surprised. There were even quite a few positive comments on the quality of sound. So yeah, I'm glad I bought the Electrovoice Evolve 50s.
Erich,
So glad you have been pleased with the Evolve 50s. They are a great product. Keep enjoying them!
Pro Acoustics
Very glad to hear this review... I'm in the market.. :)
I went to guitar center & played some Steely Dan, Kenny Loggins & Euge Groove through many column speakers with subs. I was listening for Highs, Mids, Midlows & Lows, clarity, punch & headroom. I played songs from these artist for close to flat mixes. Yes I used a cord from my iPhone & used Wave Files.
I played the music through Harbinger MLS900 & MLS1000, EV 30 & 50, Bose L1 Pro8, JBL PRX1 & the Yamaha Stagepas 1k. All flat, No eq & went from low volume to medium to cranked.
The salesman shut the doors & let me have at it.
The EV’s stood out with a great even frequency response with some midlows with the EV’s while the rest had little to none, highs were crisp with EV’s & the vocals, saxophones, guitars & keys sounded excellent. Bass GTR & kick were sweet also. Snare was excellent with the mids & highs. Nice snap.
For me personally I prefer the EV’s hands down.
Hoping to hear the RCF Evox 8 & 12, DB Es1203 ES 1002 & 503, HK Polar 10 & 12’s, LD Maui44’s. Yes there’s a price difference but you get what u pay for. It also depends on the size of event.
Hi Tim, Appreciate all the info! We always like to hear what others think of the equipment.
HI Nathan & Coltin, great job on this review! Question: which line array system would you recommend to accommodate 2 mic vocals AND 2 guitars, without having to add an external mixer? Thanks! Dee
Hi Dee, Thanks for watching! It looks like you were able to chat with Coltin earlier today. He'll be reaching back out to you via email to talk more about which line array system will be ideal for you. We're happy to be able to help!
I bought the Bose L1 Pro 8 and use it with Roland V Drums. When I use my headphones, the sound from streaming music and playing the kit is very clear. When I switch to the Bose, it will tend to drop out the streaming music volume and the drum sound stays level. How do I adjust the speaker so it doesn't lower the volume on the streaming music?
Hi there! It sounds like there may be some gain staging that needs to be done. I would start with the control app to ensure that the level for the Bluetooth is correct and work your way through the signal chain from there. If that doesn't resolve the issue feel free to give us a call at (888) 256-4112 to go through it further.
How would these work as home theatre speakers with a flat screen hooked to them either directly or with a small mixing board?? Seems like it would be great! :)
Hi there! Unfortunately these particular products are not recommended for home use. They are designed for professional audio, live performance and public address type applications. My initial concern with using one in a home would be that the horizontal coverage would be too wide for most home applications.
I hope this was helpful but feel free to reach out with more questions or contact us directly at www.proacousticsusa.com, email sales@proacoustics.com or call (888) 256-4112.
They'd be loud as PHUCK lol
Is it possible to use a external mixer with that Behringer c200?
Aser,
Thanks for watching our video. You can definitely use an external mixer with the Behringer C200. There are two inputs for line-level signal, so you can either sum the audio to one input (mono) or use two C200 for a stereo sound. Let us know if we can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
I only use my Eon One with a mixer as the Mic preamps on the Eon One are quite weak... but with a mixer the sound is amazing.
Can I use a pair of Behringer C200 for parties at my place? Or should I go for a traditional setup?
Hi there! Yes the Behringer C200 would work great for a small house party. Feel free to request a quote and an experienced sales engineer will reach out and make sure this is the best solution for your needs. www.proacousticsusa.com/behringer-c200-200w-powered-column-portable-bluetooth-sound-system-with-led-lighting-and-remote-control.html
Hello Guys, What about a small house party with about 40/50 people (outdoor) will the Behringer C200 do the job? Is it loud enough for occasional DJ applications?
Hi there Federico,
The Behringer C200 would work fine for a small outdoor pool party or house party. However, if you are wanting more kicking bass then I would look into the Bose L1 or Electro-Voice EVOLVE 50. You can email sales@proacoustics.com or call (888) 256-4112 and we'd be happy to talk with you more about the best option for your needs and budget.
Let us know if you have more questions!
Updated video out now! Check it out: th-cam.com/video/9vTkE41rlwU/w-d-xo.html
Do you typically use these in pairs for gigs or just one? It seems strange that they don’t come in pairs, one with mixer, one without. So if you do buy two for the stage, they both have the full mixer?
Joe,
Depending on the size of audience you're hoping to cover and the size of the space, you can definitely pair two systems together via line output from one to another system. In that scenario, you would just use the mixer in the primary system. Let us know if we can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
How's the sound quality of the Behringer VS the Bose in crisp, clean sound, as well as bass response?
Muranaman,
They are designed for different applications. The Behringer is designed for smaller spaces, like a home or small workout space, whereas the Bose L1 would work in larger applications where you have crowds of 200+ people. Let us know if we can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
@@ProAcoustics The Bose L1 Compact is designed for audience up to 100, The L1 Model 1S is designed for audiences up to 300. The Compact paired with a Bose ToneMatch mixer sounds great!
This video seems a little older and didnt include the Bose F1 812 column. How does that compare for a rock band that wants to play for small-mid size venues up to 250 people?
Hi Scott,
Thanks for watching! This video is a little over a year old and was not all-inclusive.
The Bose F1 Model 812 is a full-range array loudspeaker (meaning it spans a wide portion of the frequency spectrum) but it does not have a built-in subwoofer like some of the other models discussed in this video. It does have a low-frequency driver behind the array of 8 high-output drivers but the 12" LF is designed to fill out the lows and low mid-range. For additional bass response, the Bose F1 Subwoofer can be paired with the F1 Model 812 speaker array, which is designed to mount on top of the sub. While the other systems here already have a dedicated subwoofer to handle the bass frequencies. The F1 is also 1,000 watts alone versus the Electro-Voice Evolve 50 which is 1,000 watts across the column and the subwoofer. So there are slight variations between the Bose F1 Model 812 and the other models we are presenting here.
I hope that answers your question. However, if you'd like additional help finding the perfect portable system for your band feel free to visit our website at www.proacousticsusa.com, email sales@proacoustics.com or call (888) 256-4112. You'll be assigned a dedicated sales engineer who can walk you through the best options for your needs and budget.
do we need 2 units or 1 unit to a small band perform? thanks.
Hi there, 1 unit should be sufficient for a small band as long as you’re not needing more than 1 or 2 inputs. For example, if you needed 2 mics for singers and you also wanted to mic the drums. In that case, we’d recommend including a mixer to accommodate the additional microphones.
Hope this helps!
If you'd like help choosing the best column line array system or system mixer combo, feel free to email us at sales@proacoustics.com, call (888) 256-4112 or visit our site www.proacousticsusa.com
@@ProAcoustics thank you so much!!
Hi guys nice video , " but " you have to include JBL eon one or the JBL eon one pro battery powered , in the video are more comparable to ev or Bose , even better portability against the ev or Bose.
Daniel,
Thanks so much for tuning in to our video and for your interest in the products. We appreciate you watching. We're always looking at additional products to review & we'll get the Eon One/Eon One Pro on the list. If there are additional products that you would like to see reviewed, feel free to let us know. Thanks!
Pro Acoustics
In my oppinion, the MAUI 5 go is closer to Bose.
Please make a review pf the behringer c200, there is no videos in youtube about it, thank you great video 👍
Hi Jonathan,
Thanks for viewing and for the feedback. We are always looking for new ideas to include in future videos, so we appreciate you letting us know that you would like to see a review of the Behringer C200. Let us know if we can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
Hi guys, about the c200 itself, I'd like to know about its power, is it the same as the BoseL1?
@@edgardeviaje
Hi Edgar,
The Behringer C200 and Bose L1 Compact System are both rated at 200 Watts. However, when side by side the Bose system produces more sound.
- Robin
Nice guys ! ….Without the screaming ! and yelling like the others! Others Need To Follow These Guys!
Thanks for watching Jimi!
nice video, turn up the recording volume next time
Kenneth,
Thanks for watching our video. We will work on getting that recording volume up next time. Thanks!
Pro Acoustics
I have a church. Room is 20 feet wide, 60 foot long. Right now we are using high wattage QSC speakers.
Would these sound better?
Hi Doug, Are you unhappy with the performance of your current system?
QSC makes some great speakers. However, column arrays have inherently different characteristics than traditional loudspeakers. Column arrays tend to have better vocal intelligibility in a small form factor and also less of differentiation in volume from the front to the back of the room for a more even coverage. It will also depend on if you're looking for a super high output volume and bass level output or if this is a more traditional worship environment. A column array might be a good solution for you, but I'd recommend one of the larger models for a room your size.
If you're interested in a new system or have more questions, feel free to visit our website www.proacousticsusa.com or contact us directly at sales@proacoustics.com or call (888) 256-4112.
@@ProAcoustics Just doesn’t push like it should and the clarity isn’t what I’d like
@@douglasboyd8475 We'd be more than happy to help you find a solution that you'd be happier with!
Free to visit our website www.proacousticsusa.com and request a quote or contact us directly at sales@proacoustics.com or call (888) 256-4112. You'll be assigned a dedicated Sales Engineer that will work with you to meet all your needs and budget.
I've heard 2 of these and they sound like a column with 3 inch speakers in them in other words very middy sounding
John,
Thanks for watching our video and for the feedback. It's always helpful to hear how these products are working in the field.
Pro Acoustics
No TurboSound IP?
ALS News Now,
Thanks for watching and reaching out. We are always open to product ideas to include in our videos. We will make note of the TurboSound IP as a potential product to highlight in the future. Let us know if we can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
Correction: The Evolve 50 has Bluetooth streaming & Bluetooth control
David,
You are correct, the Evolve 50 does have Bluetooth streaming and Bluetooth control. Thank you for pointing that out. We will add a correction in the video description. Thank you for watching and for reaching out. Let us know if we can ever help with anything.
Pro Acoustics
Will these handle a 4 piece Rock band? With 3 voices?
Hi there!
Thanks so much for watching! I took another look at the specs and at most, you have 2 balanced inputs on any of these systems. You could however accommodate multiple microphones, instruments, etc. if you add an external mixer to any of these.
Bose has a 4 and 8 channel mixers that are specifically designed to work well with the L1 line (TS4 and TS8). Here is a link to those if you're interested: www.proacousticsusa.com/catalogsearch/result/index/?cat=1612&manufacturer%5B0%5D=Bose+Pro+Audio&q=Bose+Tonematch
Of course, if you have another preferred mixer brand or model you can go with that as well.
I hope this helps. Let me know if you have any more questions.
go with the rcf j8 .....sound just like the ev 50 for 500$ less and has a real speaker pole so you can turn the head and raise the pole higher if needed to get over the ppl on te dance floor and you can clamp lights to it with a reg O clamp if you need to bring lights
DJ MIZ,
Thanks for viewing and thanks for the feedback. We will look into reviewing the RCF J8 in the future.
Pro Acoustics
Line array is an adaptation of fresnel light theory taken into sound
Look into k-array speakers
Hi Phillip, Thanks for the recommendation! We always love hearing from our viewers.
@@ProAcoustics also look into the FBT cs-1000 speakers
Why no sound comparison?
Lee,
Thanks for watching and reaching out. We didn't include a specific sound comparison because we want our viewers to be able to take all of the included facts about each product and decide which one is best for their application. Let us know if we can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
Because they are stupid motherfuckers.
Behringer one of the best? Sorry, but there are too much things wrong. You can't disable the annoying light effect, the maximum height is 1.38 meters, MAUI 5 has 1.99 meters and Bose L1 compact too, so the top is too low for listeners who stand, the microphone ins has jack.
How does the Behri C200 sound with only 4 x 2.5-inch HF drivers? All the other colum systems have at least 8 HF drivers. I am also thinking, a single 8-inch woofer for the low freq is just not going to be enough for much. Also, the LED light bar makes it too gimicky, fortunately you can just not install that light bar and install the HF bar right on top the base unit.
Frank,
Thanks for viewing and for the feedback. It's true that the C200 doesn't have the size or power of a larger column array, but while you are not going to get a kick to the chest with bass performance, you still get a well-balanced sound for small workout spaces and other areas where a super loud system isn't required. Let us know if we can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
And JBL EON ONE ?
Sergio,
Thanks for your feedback. We currently have the JBL Eon One/Eon One Pro on our list of products to review. Be on the lookout for it in the coming months. Let us know if we can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
The JBL can be called "one of the best", the Bose not. When persons who needs a column speaker, saw, what the C 200 can do and can't, they will come to the conclusion, that the MAUI 5 price is not so expensive at all. And persons who would like the flickering light, doesn't need column speakers.
@@ProAcoustics I own an Eon One. It took weeks of fighting with JBL for them to improve the pitifully inadequate microphone preamps. JBL claims that the mic preamps have been redesigned with the Pro. The Yamaha 1X seems really good...
These are mini systems. Good only for small house party venues less than 60 people
Hi there, You may want to check out our more recent video with more large to mid-sized portable line arrays. th-cam.com/video/9vTkE41rlwU/w-d-xo.html
HK put those to shame
I CAN ALMOST NOT HEAR YOU FOLKS TALK. GREAT AUDIO & MIXING TECH.
Hello Frank,
Thanks for watching and for the feedback. We are still fairly new at our video channel, and we are always working to improve our video and audio quality. Keep watching and hopefully you will see improvements with each video.
Pro Acoustics
Maui 5 and maui 5 go are way better thsn behringer, Bose is a very expensive system and EV actually looks weird not being a constant column from the bottom.
69 Sound,
Thanks for watching the video and for the feedback. We always appreciate hearing from our viewers. Let us know if we can ever help with anything.
Pro Acoustics
Just talk talk talk....on sound test
Hi Wintro,
Thanks for taking the time to watch and comment on our video. In this Tech Talk, we focused more on explaining what line array speaker systems are and all the different features and specs of the 3 products as opposed to performing a sound test. We appreciate your suggestion for a new video! Let us know if we can help with anything else!
This 3 are not battery powered???🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Hello,
No - none of these units have a built-in battery. We do have plans to show some battery-powered units in the coming weeks. Stay tuned and let us know if we can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
@@ProAcoustics i will love to know witch is better for didgeridooñ mackie freeplay or jbl partybox300
Hello,
Thanks for the reply. I don't have a ton of familiarity with the didgeridoo, but we appreciate your interest. Many of these speakers sound great regardless of the type of genre or region. I will certainly take note of your requests. Thanks again and let me know if I can help with anything else.
Pro Acoustics
Im looking for a good busk amp but didgeridoo is very complicated . Im looking that amp is good at bass, mid and high frequencies. I mix techno and play didgeridoo for busk!
There is a battery powered version of LD Systems MAUI 5, the MAUI 5 go, I would recommend. This system is not so far from Bose L1 compact, ok, there is no tonematch, so I would also recommend to use for the microphone a TC Helicon Mic Mechanic, that makes the sound crisp (you can feed it into MAUI 5's microphone in) and for guitar a battery powered digital acoustic guitar effect.
The Bose L1 Compact is now kind of obsolete, replaced by the L1 Pro8 which costs $1200. the Behringer now is the C210B which costs $330; a bit of a price drop. I'd also look at a JBL Eon One Pro, which has had a $300 price drop and now costs below $500. Back in 2018, I bought a JBL Eon One, costing around $900, a big, fat, ugly speaker but sounding really good! :) It does not have a battery like the Eon One Pro which has replaced it.
Hi Raja,
Thanks for watching and providing your helpful feedback! We're definitely looking at doing an updated version of this video. Let us know if you have any other products or brands you'd like to see.
@@ProAcoustics yes, indeed, the Yamaha STAGEPAS 1K please!
Great suggestion!
@@OnlineMD I just wanted to let you know that we just released a new version of this video that includes the Yamaha STAGEPAS 1K - Check it out th-cam.com/video/9vTkE41rlwU/w-d-xo.html
lol… it’s weird hearing your own name in a video.
It took you over three damned minutes to even describe what brand of speakers you we're going to talk about. I had to go back to lunch...
Hi there, We appreciate your honest feedback and will definitely take this into consideration for future videos. We hope you'll continue watching our channel.
The reverb from the prxone is no more than a cheep reverb from a $10 cheep guitar amplifier.the app don't work correctly winding knobs and cannot connect a separate reverb unit as there is no send&return do not waist your money like 100%
9 Minutes with no Hearing it..Ridiculous
Mark,
Thanks for watching our video and for the feedback. We are continually working to improve the videos in our series, so will take your feedback and apply it to future videos. Let us know if we can ever help you with anything.
Pro Acoustics
Behringer is junk where is the Yamaha Stagepass 1k?
Hi Nigel, This is an older video before the Yamaha Stagepass 1k was released. We have an updated one you can check out that includes this one th-cam.com/video/9vTkE41rlwU/w-d-xo.html
For the price you can purchase x2 mackie 15inch 1000watt powered speakers with tripods. These might be fine for small conference speaking but as for music in a noisy bar they would get drowned out… and the fact they are $1300 a pop x 2 would be $2,600 😳 whaaa? Not worth the money & not up to any pro kind of music performance. Just a fad. Buy Active speakers & have STEREO. This mono arrangement is just crazy.
Talk for 8 minutes and not say anything about the products? Why would I reach out to you?
Hi Jed, Thanks for watching. We're sorry if we didn't go over the specification you were looking for. If you have some specific questions about any of these products, we'd be happy to help. You may also want to check out our updated video that goes over some newer models. We get a little more technical about each: th-cam.com/video/9vTkE41rlwU/w-d-xo.html
not a real critique/comparison but a promo for all of them...not too helpful
Thanks for watching! We appreciate your honest feedback. We'll certainly take this into consideration for future videos and we hope you'll keep watching!
Harbinger MLS900 blows away the Bose L1 compact. FYI. Half the price.
Pianodon,
Thanks for viewing and for the feedback. We are always looking for additional products to review in the future, so thanks for sharing.
Pro Acoustics
@@ProAcoustics
I will be real interested to see your review on the Harbinger MLS900. I know a DJ locally who carries a stack of speakers in his van. But he will often pull out a couple of the harbingers unless it's a huge room. I was actually blown away the first time I heard him with only one of them.
they are all crap only colum speaker i would use is the nexo
Hi Byrom, We are glad that you found a system that works for you.
@@ProAcoustics ....yeah yamaha DSR ..tops n bottoms...would love a column array but they are all crap
all talk and no demo makes me give this a big thumbs down
Hi there, We appreciate your honest feedback. We were focusing on explaining the features of each model for this video but perhaps we'll do a demo in the future! Have a great week!