The problem is, when you compare two VOCALISTS in every sense of the word, it creates a lot of confusion as to who is better. But the point is that they are star level vocalists. They don't compare one to the other because they are above the rest. Even if one has better notes, the other also wins because her notes are also excellent!. These are things that happen with the BEST VOCALISTS
Like the eternal comparison among the vocal trinity of Whitney Mariah and Celine, or the comparison between the powerful duo of soul and gospel Patti Labelle and Aretha Franklin, we just gotta admire them and choose based on our subjective opinion
@@alanmagana Exactly! That's all that's left. Pick your favorite and you're done. The comparisons at the end are just that, fun. The greats are already great within their respective ranges and musicality. ✌🏻❤️
Apart from that, there are things that Beyonce's better than Whitney at like Lows and even give or take Upper Belts, even Vocal Agility, Vocal Dynamics, Breath Control (being able to sing and dance at the same time and still be on pitch), Versatility, Technique, and Musicianship (because she plays a musical intrument). But Whitney wins her in Power, Resonance, Musicality, Mid Belts, and just slightly in Head Voice. In terms of Pitch, Vibrato,and Range, they're give or take equals. Emotiveness and Tone are subjective (so it depends on whose tone you prefer and whose emotiveness that moves you more). But all this shows that Beyonce is a vocal force to be reckoned with and is Vocal Trinity material (at least for her generation) but for some reason many people (usually those who know nothing about vocals) underrate her vocal abilities. Many even think Adele, Alicia Keys, or Kelly Rowland are far better vocalists LMAO!
You can clearly hear in this very video that Beyonce's actually holding her own against Whitney. Not a lot of vocalists can do that. Also, Beyonce rivals Whitney in many vocal abilities, unless you don't know a lot about what Beyonce can do.
And some delusional people on the internet have the audacity to say that Kelly Rowland, Adele, Alicia Keys are far better vocalists than Beyonce (when none of them, except maybe Kelly a little bit, are vocalists just singers). Beyonce is over here going toe to toe with Whitney in ways that almost any other vocal would lose.
Whitney , Mariah and Beyonce are all gold standard master vocalists. Between them it literally comes down to style and tone preference. Whitney is better than Beyonce in some aspects and vice versa. For example Whitney’s power in her belt is unmatched. Beyonce has agility over her, low notes, and her growls will never be beat. While they’re on par with head voice. Both as close to flawless as it gets Btw you getting frustrated because there’s no clips is hilarious 🤣
He is about to do lara vs bey in few days watch him picking lara over beyonce (ofc the favouritism) He has zero knowledge of vocals he embarrassing himself in every video he just go with who he likes and say she is better the other one sucks like go get ur meds its not that hard to say that u hate someone or you like someone
The echo effect actually has more to do with the arena, not reverb. If it's a stadium (which most of these clips came from), then it would naturally echo. This happened in Whitney's clips too. That said, most of Whitney's clips were in music smaller venues, so they had less echoes. Now, Beyonce did have reverb on 2 clips (which I didn't like and think she doesn't need because she has raw power as shown plenty times).
Hell naw! Mariah's voice is light and soft and coloratura-esq. Now, though Beyonce has coloratura-like qualities too, her voice has far more power (or weight) than Mariah's. So, Beyonce's voice is more Whitney and Aretha like in terms of how raw/power it is. Mariah's voice is like butter but Beyonce's voice is more like a hammer or hurricane.
That C5 100% sounded like Celine lol. Celine also sounded like Whitney a little bit during a F#5 she did of the greatest love of all when she was younger :P
Whitney’s power is legendary. She blew the speaker out singing I Will Always Love You, her part in King Holiday and in Where Do Broken Hearts Go. She also blew the speakers out at a live party in 1999. Back when Whitney started there were no special mics like Beyoncé has. Whitney was just mind blowingly talented. Sons of your picks for Beyoncé especially head voice are so wrong. Plus in their upper register…Beyoncé used way more mixed voice than Whitney.
Your very biased.. Beyonce has slightly better vocal technique than Whitney. Whitney most of the times got tense above an D3/Eb5.. while beyonce consistently supports up to C3/F5. The thing that sets Whitney apart is her tone!
@@jobuck879 That's a lie. You could clearly hear Whitney tensing above D3/Eb5. There was no ease there, compared to Beyonce. Whitney's greatest strengths are her Vocal Power, Musicality, Tone, and Head Voice. That combo is very dangerous in a singer. But there are things Beyonce equals or surpasses her in.
Beyonce would laugh at this and tell you 😂 🤣 that she is not on Whitney level of singing there will never be another Whitney Houston that woman is in a lane of her own that's why she is the Greatest Female singer hands down and definitely The greatest of her generation plus Beyonce grew up watching Whitney that was her inspiration but Beyonce is the greatest singer of her generation I will also say this now if they would say greatest singers living today hands down I would put Beyonce on that list because she is a great singer but Beyonce and Whitney Houston are two type of singers with two different type of tones you can't even compare them you and even hear in the headvoice Beyonce is more rougher compared to Whitney sweet warm beautiful tone there.
@@_brunoduarte_06 The Eb5 note when you was saying they are singing the same song lol. Whitney was singing I Am Changing. Beyoncé was singing Why Don’t You Love Me if I’m not mistaken. The power differences you pointed out are so on point. Whitney was so powerful she has blew out speakers. She had a power that could resonate a whole building for days. I think they use just the photos in order to not have the video struck for copyright infringement.
Beyoncé would lose to Mariah if we use prime vocals for sure. She would also lose to Lisa Fischer and Ledisi as well. Anyone else, it would be either very close or Beyoncé just wins 🤷♀️ For the new girlies, the only person that has a chance of going against Beyoncé is Chloe Bailey. If you haven’t, check out her live performance of Feeling Good that she did on GMA.
Beyonce wouldn't lose to Prime Mariah. Beyonce has better Technique, a far far more developed and connected Head Voice, far more Vocal Power, even better Pitch (Mariah had moments in her prime where she was off or flat). Beyonce also has better Lows and Dynamic Control. Better Breath Control/Vocal Stamina. Mariah has better Resonance, better Musicality, greater Agility, and a far wider Range. Beyonce is a tremendous belter and will make Mimi struggle more often than not. With Lisa FIscher, I kinda agree (she's a beast, even in her 50s?) but Beyonce also equals or supercedes her in other vocal abilities. I don't know Ledisi that well but in what vocal ability is she equal or better than Beyonce? As for Chloe, she's got GREAT potential to one of the greats but Beyonce edges her out vocal so so so much, it's going to be laughable. But yeah, I see what you mean.
Well, it depends on which register and techniques we are talking about, Beyoncé is better at mid beltings than Mariah, but Mariah is better at upper beltings.
Have you ever done a Céline Dion range video? I want one that is only Céline Dion. Maybe our live range video? My suggestion would be pick only videos by Céline Dion fans, ones that have the name “Celine something“ as the username and not buy some other person that doesn’t already know her best performances is and just picks up any clips at random.
If I remember correctly this video is pretty old so maybe that's why you think the clips aren't that good for B. That said, Beyhive here and either way Whitney wins. She's arguably the best ever at belting in this range, with some competition from Céline & maybe idk... Shirley Bassey.
He is trying so hard to be different im crying 😂😂😂
The problem is, when you compare two VOCALISTS in every sense of the word, it creates a lot of confusion as to who is better. But the point is that they are star level vocalists. They don't compare one to the other because they are above the rest. Even if one has better notes, the other also wins because her notes are also excellent!. These are things that happen with the BEST VOCALISTS
Exactly, the only thing left to do is to choose based on personal taste of the tone, timbre and musicality elections cause they’re just so perfect ❤❤❤
Like the eternal comparison among the vocal trinity of Whitney Mariah and Celine, or the comparison between the powerful duo of soul and gospel Patti Labelle and Aretha Franklin, we just gotta admire them and choose based on our subjective opinion
@@alanmagana Exactly! That's all that's left. Pick your favorite and you're done. The comparisons at the end are just that, fun. The greats are already great within their respective ranges and musicality. ✌🏻❤️
I think Whitney is better in mid belts (A4-Eb5) than Beyoncé. But Beyoncé is better than Whitney in upper belts.(E5-G#5). But yeah both are very good.
Apart from that, there are things that Beyonce's better than Whitney at like Lows and even give or take Upper Belts, even Vocal Agility, Vocal Dynamics, Breath Control (being able to sing and dance at the same time and still be on pitch), Versatility, Technique, and Musicianship (because she plays a musical intrument). But Whitney wins her in Power, Resonance, Musicality, Mid Belts, and just slightly in Head Voice. In terms of Pitch, Vibrato,and Range, they're give or take equals. Emotiveness and Tone are subjective (so it depends on whose tone you prefer and whose emotiveness that moves you more).
But all this shows that Beyonce is a vocal force to be reckoned with and is Vocal Trinity material (at least for her generation) but for some reason many people (usually those who know nothing about vocals) underrate her vocal abilities. Many even think Adele, Alicia Keys, or Kelly Rowland are far better vocalists LMAO!
Their head voices sounds pretty close
Right but he wanted to choose Beyoncé when Beyonce did the same note the whole head voice section
beyonce is no where near whitney
Stop underrating beyonce vocal skills, top S vocalist
You can clearly hear in this very video that Beyonce's actually holding her own against Whitney. Not a lot of vocalists can do that. Also, Beyonce rivals Whitney in many vocal abilities, unless you don't know a lot about what Beyonce can do.
And some delusional people on the internet have the audacity to say that Kelly Rowland, Adele, Alicia Keys are far better vocalists than Beyonce (when none of them, except maybe Kelly a little bit, are vocalists just singers). Beyonce is over here going toe to toe with Whitney in ways that almost any other vocal would lose.
Imo Whitney takes belting and Beyoncé takes head voice. Two wonderful vocalists.
Literally Whitney's head voice trumps Bey even worse than belting
@@romanarts6645 Idts...
@mikel4531 u think wrong since vocal technique isn't opinion based, it's objective
Beyonce takes head voice? On what planet?
Whitney head voice is very good too.
Whitney , Mariah and Beyonce are all gold standard master vocalists. Between them it literally comes down to style and tone preference. Whitney is better than Beyonce in some aspects and vice versa. For example Whitney’s power in her belt is unmatched. Beyonce has agility over her, low notes, and her growls will never be beat. While they’re on par with head voice. Both as close to flawless as it gets
Btw you getting frustrated because there’s no clips is hilarious 🤣
Whitney is my vocal inspiration love Beyoncé and I admire both but Whitney vocally is something else
He is about to do lara vs bey in few days watch him picking lara over beyonce (ofc the favouritism)
He has zero knowledge of vocals he embarrassing himself in every video he just go with who he likes and say she is better the other one sucks like go get ur meds its not that hard to say that u hate someone or you like someone
The echo effect is there to make Beyonce sound more powerful. That's why she always uses it. Whitney was just pure power always.
To me it takes away the power
The echo effect actually has more to do with the arena, not reverb. If it's a stadium (which most of these clips came from), then it would naturally echo. This happened in Whitney's clips too. That said, most of Whitney's clips were in music smaller venues, so they had less echoes. Now, Beyonce did have reverb on 2 clips (which I didn't like and think she doesn't need because she has raw power as shown plenty times).
I love them both, but it's Whitney ✨😭
Sohyang beats Beyonce but their voice types are so different but I’m just technique it’s Sohyang.
He’s so cute ❤
I always felt Beyoncé is way more similar to Mariah especially with approach and tone
Hell naw! Mariah's voice is light and soft and coloratura-esq. Now, though Beyonce has coloratura-like qualities too, her voice has far more power (or weight) than Mariah's. So, Beyonce's voice is more Whitney and Aretha like in terms of how raw/power it is. Mariah's voice is like butter but Beyonce's voice is more like a hammer or hurricane.
That C5 100% sounded like Celine lol. Celine also sounded like Whitney a little bit during a F#5 she did of the greatest love of all when she was younger :P
Whitney’s power is legendary. She blew the speaker out singing I Will Always Love You, her part in King Holiday and in Where Do Broken Hearts Go. She also blew the speakers out at a live party in 1999. Back when Whitney started there were no special mics like Beyoncé has. Whitney was just mind blowingly talented. Sons of your picks for Beyoncé especially head voice are so wrong. Plus in their upper register…Beyoncé used way more mixed voice than Whitney.
Your very biased.. Beyonce has slightly better vocal technique than Whitney. Whitney most of the times got tense above an D3/Eb5.. while beyonce consistently supports up to C3/F5. The thing that sets Whitney apart is her tone!
@ That is a blatant lie. Whitney was very comfortable Eb5 and upwards. She was never tense.
@@jobuck879 That's a lie. You could clearly hear Whitney tensing above D3/Eb5. There was no ease there, compared to Beyonce. Whitney's greatest strengths are her Vocal Power, Musicality, Tone, and Head Voice. That combo is very dangerous in a singer. But there are things Beyonce equals or surpasses her in.
Beyonce would laugh at this and tell you 😂 🤣 that she is not on Whitney level of singing there will never be another Whitney Houston that woman is in a lane of her own that's why she is the Greatest Female singer hands down and definitely The greatest of her generation plus Beyonce grew up watching Whitney that was her inspiration but Beyonce is the greatest singer of her generation I will also say this now if they would say greatest singers living today hands down I would put Beyonce on that list because she is a great singer but Beyonce and Whitney Houston are two type of singers with two different type of tones you can't even compare them you and even hear in the headvoice Beyonce is more rougher compared to Whitney sweet warm beautiful tone there.
Why are there always flies in your room?😂😅
"always" and its literally the second time
They're trying to escape the cold winter air and they find refuge in his cozy space
@@_brunoduarte_06 The Eb5 note when you was saying they are singing the same song lol. Whitney was singing I Am Changing. Beyoncé was singing Why Don’t You Love Me if I’m not mistaken. The power differences you pointed out are so on point. Whitney was so powerful she has blew out speakers. She had a power that could resonate a whole building for days. I think they use just the photos in order to not have the video struck for copyright infringement.
Beyoncé would lose to Mariah if we use prime vocals for sure. She would also lose to Lisa Fischer and Ledisi as well. Anyone else, it would be either very close or Beyoncé just wins 🤷♀️
For the new girlies, the only person that has a chance of going against Beyoncé is Chloe Bailey. If you haven’t, check out her live performance of Feeling Good that she did on GMA.
Beyonce wouldn't lose to Prime Mariah. Beyonce has better Technique, a far far more developed and connected Head Voice, far more Vocal Power, even better Pitch (Mariah had moments in her prime where she was off or flat). Beyonce also has better Lows and Dynamic Control. Better Breath Control/Vocal Stamina. Mariah has better Resonance, better Musicality, greater Agility, and a far wider Range. Beyonce is a tremendous belter and will make Mimi struggle more often than not.
With Lisa FIscher, I kinda agree (she's a beast, even in her 50s?) but Beyonce also equals or supercedes her in other vocal abilities. I don't know Ledisi that well but in what vocal ability is she equal or better than Beyonce?
As for Chloe, she's got GREAT potential to one of the greats but Beyonce edges her out vocal so so so much, it's going to be laughable. But yeah, I see what you mean.
24:18 Lani Misalucha
Whitney is the best.
Beyoncé don't win against anyone in the Vocal Trinity. Actually, nobody wins
Fanaticism is bad.
@YonceMimi This is a technical afirmation. "Vocal trinity" are the pinacle of the music scene in the 90's and 00's. Just learn about.
Well, it depends on which register and techniques we are talking about, Beyoncé is better at mid beltings than Mariah, but Mariah is better at upper beltings.
Wrong
Shows you're either not paying attention. Beyonce is better at some vocal abilities than Whitney, Mariah, or Celine and vice versa.
Have you ever done a Céline Dion range video? I want one that is only Céline Dion. Maybe our live range video? My suggestion would be pick only videos by Céline Dion fans, ones that have the name “Celine something“ as the username and not buy some other person that doesn’t already know her best performances is and just picks up any clips at random.
Don't bother w this weirdo. He claims ariana is a better singer than céline
@@celiniac Yet here you are watching🤣🤣
@_brunoduarte_06 I love comedies, what can I say
@@celiniacI mean Ariana can literally sing as Celine if she wanted to and then has her own talent on top of that 😅
Celine Dion is SUCH a vocal BEAST!
I need u to lock in and focus
If I remember correctly this video is pretty old so maybe that's why you think the clips aren't that good for B.
That said, Beyhive here and either way Whitney wins. She's arguably the best ever at belting in this range, with some competition from Céline & maybe idk... Shirley Bassey.
Shirley Bassey is a belting beast. Yeah, Whitney would struggle in her prime because Shirley also has the vocal power to match.