@@JudithHunt-t7u you do realise infrastructure, rules and doctrines need to evolve over time to progress right? So does the constitution. God forbid this country could have the balls to change one good thing for the better. They are not taking your rights away from you. Hey tomorrow you still have to wake up and pay commbank your mortgage and buy your pasta sauce from coles. How does this really affect the average Australian? It doesn’t.
Mr. Mundine's experience based common sense cuts through the raft of nonsense and hype in the debate. His points ring true. Education. Economic participation. Reparation where appropriate. 55% of Australia already Indigenous owned and more on the way where appropriate. Mundine's voice is the voice Australia should be listening to.
I think the thing that had the biggest impact on me about his speech was near the end. He pointed out how this could divide the country after the vote and regardless of the votes outcome, there's real work that needs to be done. Will it get done or will this token effort sate their enthusiasm? Also ASPI has suggested the Misinformation and Disinformation bill to government for government to rubber stamp and pass through awarding more power over our ability to communicate with each other. I hope we can imprison anyone who approves of this bill in government as that is gross over reach and it needs to stop. Hope you all have a lovely day
@@abekane7038 Irrelevant to the issue of formal recognition of the First Nations people in our fundamental document, the constitution. And The Voice is more relevant right now than a Treaty or a Bill of Human Rights - the Voice has some chance of making positive change, immediately. All the other issues Mundine parroted can still be addressed, through the Voice - his speech was irrelevant, contributed nothing on THIS issue of constitutional change. Someone commented on this stream "ego out of control" - it's horrifying, disappointing beyond words.
@@JudithHunt-t7u Thanks for replying, I do appreciate more than "Irrelevant". I think it's quite possible that the voice could improve things. It's possible it will address the issues Mr Mundine pointed out, but at this point it doesn't exist...so share your crystal ball pls, it would make it faster than convincing people than through dialogue. I don't know what you've based your assumption on that its' more relevant than a treaty, just saying something is true doesn't shape reality. I appreciate the time you took to type a proper reply out regardless
@@abekane7038 "Relevant" means "appropriate for the issue in hand, now" A treaty would take years to nut out, and then it would need to be tested by debate, to be effective. Same for a Bill of Human Rights. A Voice could be effective immediately. Also, I imagine the opinion of the majority would be politically powerful if the referendum passed - a new reality :)
Warren Mundine is very much mistaken in his thinking on this issue, and yes, quite possibly deluded - his fixed attitude is not open to the possibility that he could be wrong - in my opinion, he is completely wrong - what a tragedy - he is letting his own people down and potentially misleading Australians who might think Mundine has some "inside" knowledge - shame shame shame.
I really enjoyed that- I think he’s right about education and getting all the kids into school- an older lady I work with said at the end of her education she asked her friend who she went through schooling with and was Aboriginal what she planned to do for work now they had finished school and was surprised when she shrugged and said ‘nothing! We don’t need to find jobs we just get paid to stay at home’- there were no expectations that that girl would ever get a job, buy a house, pay taxes or aspire to do great things. I think Warren and Jacinta Nampijinpa Price are great examples of getting to the top and I believe they can turn us all into one from many - a great time to be alive🫡
This man is becoming painful to listen to. One day he might wakeup and have to come to terms with the damage he has done to the indigenous people of this country. His people supposedly?
@@Barb467 So if 80% of indigenous believe it is a good idea we ignore them and listen to Price and Mundine? If the indigenous people of this country had been offered a treaty 200 years ago Mundine would have voted against it? It is a complete disgrace this country does not have a treaty. A voice is a very small step along the way. Price has made it very clear she is in the pay of the extreme right. Mundine may not be that bad but he is wrong on who is causing division.
![30 ชั่วโมงคนเดียว บนรถไฟชั้น 3 โซเวียต [Around The World Ep. 2]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MlE9boAVqDA/mqdefault.jpg)
Clear. Concise. Precise. Articulate.
And on the wrong side. Self interest, ego > over his people.
Yes, Mundine's logic points were irrelevant to THIS issue - vote "Yes" to changing the constitution, go somewhere else to make other changes
@@JudithHunt-t7u you do realise infrastructure, rules and doctrines need to evolve over time to progress right? So does the constitution. God forbid this country could have the balls to change one good thing for the better. They are not taking your rights away from you. Hey tomorrow you still have to wake up and pay commbank your mortgage and buy your pasta sauce from coles. How does this really affect the average Australian? It doesn’t.
@@JudithHunt-t7u just voted for less division.
@@DistractedTrader or … you are wrong.
Great guy Warren! U should be if not u Jacinta Price as our nxt pm !
Mr. Mundine's experience based common sense cuts through the raft of nonsense and hype in the debate. His points ring true. Education. Economic participation. Reparation where appropriate. 55% of Australia already Indigenous owned and more on the way where appropriate. Mundine's voice is the voice Australia should be listening to.
His seemingly logical points are irrelevant to this debate - vote "Yes" to this change in the constitution
Worth listening to. Thank you Mr Mundine.
I think the thing that had the biggest impact on me about his speech was near the end. He pointed out how this could divide the country after the vote and regardless of the votes outcome, there's real work that needs to be done. Will it get done or will this token effort sate their enthusiasm?
Also ASPI has suggested the Misinformation and Disinformation bill to government for government to rubber stamp and pass through awarding more power over our ability to communicate with each other. I hope we can imprison anyone who approves of this bill in government as that is gross over reach and it needs to stop.
Hope you all have a lovely day
Irrelevant
@@JudithHunt-t7u Yet all relevant for me...more relevant than your single word that added nothing to the conversation
@@abekane7038 Irrelevant to the issue of formal recognition of the First Nations people in our fundamental document, the constitution. And The Voice is more relevant right now than a Treaty or a Bill of Human Rights - the Voice has some chance of making positive change, immediately. All the other issues Mundine parroted can still be addressed, through the Voice - his speech was irrelevant, contributed nothing on THIS issue of constitutional change. Someone commented on this stream "ego out of control" - it's horrifying, disappointing beyond words.
@@JudithHunt-t7u Thanks for replying, I do appreciate more than "Irrelevant".
I think it's quite possible that the voice could improve things. It's possible it will address the issues Mr Mundine pointed out, but at this point it doesn't exist...so share your crystal ball pls, it would make it faster than convincing people than through dialogue.
I don't know what you've based your assumption on that its' more relevant than a treaty, just saying something is true doesn't shape reality.
I appreciate the time you took to type a proper reply out regardless
@@abekane7038 "Relevant" means "appropriate for the issue in hand, now" A treaty would take years to nut out, and then it would need to be tested by debate, to be effective. Same for a Bill of Human Rights. A Voice could be effective immediately. Also, I imagine the opinion of the majority would be politically powerful if the referendum passed - a new reality :)
Always remember Catholicism .. is what he's Sayin ... poor white fella ...
Warren Mundine is very much mistaken in his thinking on this issue, and yes, quite possibly deluded - his fixed attitude is not open to the possibility that he could be wrong - in my opinion, he is completely wrong - what a tragedy - he is letting his own people down and potentially misleading Australians who might think Mundine has some "inside" knowledge - shame shame shame.
nicely said
I really enjoyed that- I think he’s right about education and getting all the kids into school- an older lady I work with said at the end of her education she asked her friend who she went through schooling with and was Aboriginal what she planned to do for work now they had finished school and was surprised when she shrugged and said ‘nothing! We don’t need to find jobs we just get paid to stay at home’- there were no expectations that that girl would ever get a job, buy a house, pay taxes or aspire to do great things. I think Warren and Jacinta Nampijinpa Price are great examples of getting to the top and I believe they can turn us all into one from many - a great time to be alive🫡
This man is becoming painful to listen to. One day he might wakeup and have to come to terms with the damage he has done to the indigenous people of this country. His people supposedly?
Pray tell... what damage has he done?
What specifically do you think was damage to the indigenous people? I think you probably had trouble listening before you hit play
I can’t agree. He makes more sense than so many who have spoken on this subject
@@Barb467 So if 80% of indigenous believe it is a good idea we ignore them and listen to Price and Mundine? If the indigenous people of this country had been offered a treaty 200 years ago Mundine would have voted against it? It is a complete disgrace this country does not have a treaty. A voice is a very small step along the way. Price has made it very clear she is in the pay of the extreme right. Mundine may not be that bad but he is wrong on who is causing division.
Those stats are debatable
He is only using the voice and words his boss Tony Abbott has told him to use ... Mundine is a puppet