What a wonderful interview! Thank you for this. I am a cradle Roman Catholic who left for Orthodoxy for a number of years, and I am coming back to communion with Rome, now, in the Byzantine Catholic Church. The closest one to me is Ukrainian. May God bless you and Michael. Lord have Mercy.
Mexican-American here, fiancee is slovak-hungarian, in her family they go to both Roman- byzantine rites. But for me I'm all about the Roman rite. I wear the scapulars, the crucifix, st. Jude statues and of course are Lady of Guadalupe, our Western Catholicism is embedded in who I'am. Eastern rites are just foriegn to our culture. I spent time playing in soccer in eastern and central europe, and can appreciate the eastern rites, but just doesnt fit in my culture. But one cool thing is they can blend, and we have similarities. Viva Cristo Rey! Viva La Santa Iglesia Catolica! Viva La Virgen De Guadalupe! Viva Sonora Mexico! 🇻🇦🇲🇽✝️
Mexican american here as well and I also grew up Roman Catholic but have been attending the Byzantine Ruthenian Catholic Church for over a year now and I'm currently discerning making a canonical transfer. I have fallen in love with the Byzantine Ruthenian Catholic Church. Fr Loyola , a Byzantine Catholic priest from Chicago said this "united in belief, divided by expression" Glory to Jesus Christ!🙏☦️♥️
@@Compulsive-Elk7103 sure go for it, i just have deep Roots in northern mexico, my parents are retired and have a ranch in sonora spend a lot of their time there now, growing up i would also spend time down their. We have are own devotions like padre kino. Like i said i spent time in eastern europe/central. Eastern orthodox would also be fascinated of our Roman ways. Gifted scapulars and rosarys to my friends that wanted them. So like i said everything of who I am is embedded in my catholicism. They way we talk, greet, celebrations etc.. im not an easterner im a prodoct of West, the Roman west.
@@Linkgt i attend both novus ordo and latin mass. Also attend slovak-greek catholic liturgy as well, cause of my fiancee. I'm mexican-american. To be Mexican is to be Catholic. We have fought and bled for our faith. It is embedded in who we are.
With the amount of hispanics in the united states, specifically on the coasts, byzantine catholic churches should consider celebrating the divine liturgy in spanish. I know Florida has orthodox churches celebrating in spanish. But i dont know of any BCC in NJ that celebrate the divine liturgy in spanish. I'd love that for my parents. I attend a NO and a byzantine church every week but want my parents to experience the byzantine church and understand it.
I have a Maronite Catholic Church in my Hometown of New Bedford, Massachusetts. It’s Syriac Catholicism because I don’t have a Byzantine Catholic Church in New Bedford.
As a Roman Catholic and Mexicano con sangre de indio de mi padre, I thought all Mexican Catholics practiced the Latin Rite before the 2nd Vatican Council. Thank you brother, I've learned something new. Crux Sacra sit mihi lux, Non drago sit mihi dux, Vade retro satana! St. Benedict pray for us. ✝️💜📿🌹🧎🏻♂️🇲🇽🇺🇲 I'm gonna start following your channel brother. 👊🏽
My family settled in New Mexico in the 1590s, Latin Rite for all those generations. During the 1970s when things were going wild (we were then living in San Diego) we sought refuge from the craziness in the Ruthenian and Ukranian Catholic parishes there. When we visited relatives in Riverside/San Bernardino we went to the Divine Liturgy in Fontana CA. While Vatican II called for a de-latinization of the Eastern Churches, it was the Latin Rite Catholics who wanted to remove the Infant of Prague and other Latin devotions to the parish hall, expressing that just as what the families from the Latin Rite saw as a stripping of our culture, we wanted to see a pure Eastern Devotion not imposed upon by Latin influences (within the Church itself) Those devotions were fine for home, but some of the Latin refugees wanted an Eastern Spirituality at the Parish level.
It's interesting to know that the number one question you get in your ministry is a question about the Rites and Churches in the universal Catholic Church. As a Filipino iconographer, the number one question I get for every icon I make of Mary is, "Oh, is that the Mother of Perpetual Help?" And then I'd go into great detail explaining that not all Byzantine icons of Our Lady is the Perpetual Help icon. 😄
Love the Byzantine tradition as expressed in both the Catholic Church and Orthodox churches. My only critique of the Byzantine Catholic tradition is that it sometimes feels “Latinized” (e.g., revised-revised Gregorian calendar and “forever and ever” as opposed to the “unto of the ages” in the liturgy) and sometimes lacks some of the key liturgical services such as “Orthros.” 😔🙏🏻
I believe that depends on the parish! At my Melkite parish there’s Orthros before Liturgy, and Vespers once or twice a week, and we get all the “unto the ages of ages” we could ask for. The priests around my area aren’t per-se anti-Latin but they’re certainly staunchly Melkite (Byzantine).
I want to visit a Byzantine Catholic Church! There’s one about an hour away from me but I just gotta wake up really early to go lol I’m considering either converting to Latin rite or Byzantine. Orthodox is also pretty cool!
Historically, the "Byzantine Catholics" used to be Orthodox. Starting in the 1500s, a few Orthodox eparchies started uniting with Rome (this was usually a political strategy in order to preserve their "Eastern-ness" in the Austro-Hungarian empire). God bless!
Praised be Jesus Christ! I wanted to clarify for anyone interested, that we have always had vespers in the Roman Catholic rite. It is not the Saturday evening Mass. The word vesper itself is Latin ;)
There are no Eastern rite churches near me with a 3 hr drive. I'm a convert to Catholicism in the Latin rite. I would love to change to the Byzantine rite. Do they plant churches? Is there a a group that we can appeal to to have them begin a Byz rite church closer to us.
Im confused in what he attended before coming back. How different was it, what was latinozed exactly? Was it still the divine liturgy of st basil and st chrysostom? How different was it?
It's called a canonical transfer, or a transfer of ascription. After you've attended the Byzantine church for a bit you can ask the priest to start this. You have to write a letter saying why you'd like to transfer, and the priest will also write a letter. It gets sent to the bishop who can approve or disapprove.
@@RickW-HGWT I mean, technically, since Orthodox can receive Catholic sacraments, it does seem like a profession of faith is more of a formality. I didn't want to lead any astray, but unofficially, some Eastern Catholic priests, especially the ones from less Latinized churches, would probably be ok with that.
Yes, they just don't really talk or focus on it too much but yes they do believe in it. Please correct me if I'm wrong anyone Glory to Jesus Christ! 🙏☦️♥️
@@MrCoachdunhamlol that is a very Protestant take. Purgatory is supported in the Bible. If one is a Catholic they do believe in purgatory or they don’t hold all of the beliefs of Catholicism.
A quick answer is different form of liturgy, the Eastern Rite is mostly a sung liturgy, the communion form is different. Big plus is married men can become priests in the Eastern Rite, a married priest has perspectives that a celibate does not. Attend one and speak to the laity and priest after.
Not really. Rome always believed in the Filioque, but when the Nicene Creed was made it wasn’t included. Perhaps it wasn’t necessary, since it doesn’t contradict the Filioque (The Holy Spirit indeed comes from the Father). Later centuries a heresy was being developed in Spain. This heresy put in doubt the divinity of Christ, so they added the Filioque to fight against the heresy. It was later adopted by the whole Church of Rome. The East never had a problem with that until Photios. Eastern Catholic Churches believe in the theology of the Filioque, but for tradition’s sake they just don’t say it when they proclamate the creed, but it is usually in parentheses (and the Son). And this is perfectly acceptable, since they respect the theology, but also respect their own tradition, just like in the past.
What a wonderful interview! Thank you for this. I am a cradle Roman Catholic who left for Orthodoxy for a number of years, and I am coming back to communion with Rome, now, in the Byzantine Catholic Church. The closest one to me is Ukrainian. May God bless you and Michael. Lord have Mercy.
Welcome home brother!!!🤩🙏Glory to God forever!!!
Glory to Jesus Christ! Glory forever! I am born, raised and married in the Byzantine church.
🙏☦️♥️
🙏❤️☦️🇻🇦
Please keep giving us more information! There is such a lack of information for us Catholics and you are filling an important need for s. Thank you.
I’m not a Catholic but “Byzantine Symposium” sounds so cool. 👍
The russian greek catholic chruch sadly is one of the smallest eastern catholic churches we must pray that their numbers increase
The video I was waiting for! Many thanks 🙏
28:26 is where to start if you’re in a hurry.
Another banger
Thank you! Great Job Father Paul!
Mexican-American here, fiancee is slovak-hungarian, in her family they go to both Roman- byzantine rites. But for me I'm all about the Roman rite. I wear the scapulars, the crucifix, st. Jude statues and of course are Lady of Guadalupe, our Western Catholicism is embedded in who I'am. Eastern rites are just foriegn to our culture. I spent time playing in soccer in eastern and central europe, and can appreciate the eastern rites, but just doesnt fit in my culture. But one cool thing is they can blend, and we have similarities.
Viva Cristo Rey!
Viva La Santa Iglesia Catolica!
Viva La Virgen De Guadalupe!
Viva Sonora Mexico! 🇻🇦🇲🇽✝️
Mexican american here as well and I also grew up Roman Catholic but have been attending the Byzantine Ruthenian Catholic Church for over a year now and I'm currently discerning making a canonical transfer.
I have fallen in love with the Byzantine Ruthenian Catholic Church.
Fr Loyola , a Byzantine Catholic priest from Chicago said this "united in belief, divided by expression"
Glory to Jesus Christ!🙏☦️♥️
Im curious, do you attend the Novus ordo or Traditional Latin mass?
@@Compulsive-Elk7103 sure go for it, i just have deep Roots in northern mexico, my parents are retired and have a ranch in sonora spend a lot of their time there now, growing up i would also spend time down their. We have are own devotions like padre kino. Like i said i spent time in eastern europe/central. Eastern orthodox would also be fascinated of our Roman ways. Gifted scapulars and rosarys to my friends that wanted them. So like i said everything of who I am is embedded in my catholicism. They way we talk, greet, celebrations etc.. im not an easterner im a prodoct of West, the Roman west.
@@Linkgt i attend both novus ordo and latin mass. Also attend slovak-greek catholic liturgy as well, cause of my fiancee. I'm mexican-american. To be Mexican is to be Catholic. We have fought and bled for our faith. It is embedded in who we are.
God Bless
With the amount of hispanics in the united states, specifically on the coasts, byzantine catholic churches should consider celebrating the divine liturgy in spanish. I know Florida has orthodox churches celebrating in spanish. But i dont know of any BCC in NJ that celebrate the divine liturgy in spanish. I'd love that for my parents. I attend a NO and a byzantine church every week but want my parents to experience the byzantine church and understand it.
I have a Maronite Catholic Church in my Hometown of New Bedford, Massachusetts. It’s Syriac Catholicism because I don’t have a Byzantine Catholic Church in New Bedford.
As a Roman Catholic and Mexicano con sangre de indio de mi padre, I thought all Mexican Catholics practiced the Latin Rite before the 2nd Vatican Council. Thank you brother, I've learned something new.
Crux Sacra sit mihi lux,
Non drago sit mihi dux,
Vade retro satana!
St. Benedict pray for us. ✝️💜📿🌹🧎🏻♂️🇲🇽🇺🇲
I'm gonna start following your channel brother. 👊🏽
My family settled in New Mexico in the 1590s, Latin Rite for all those generations. During the 1970s when things were going wild (we were then living in San Diego) we sought refuge from the craziness in the Ruthenian and Ukranian Catholic parishes there. When we visited relatives in Riverside/San Bernardino we went to the Divine Liturgy in Fontana CA. While Vatican II called for a de-latinization of the Eastern Churches, it was the Latin Rite Catholics who wanted to remove the Infant of Prague and other Latin devotions to the parish hall, expressing that just as what the families from the Latin Rite saw as a stripping of our culture, we wanted to see a pure Eastern Devotion not imposed upon by Latin influences (within the Church itself) Those devotions were fine for home, but some of the Latin refugees wanted an Eastern Spirituality at the Parish level.
Great interview! I can’t recall if this book was mentioned or not, but I would highly recommend Nicholas Cabasilas’s Commentary on the Divine Liturgy.
It makes much more sense why it's called the great entrance now
It's interesting to know that the number one question you get in your ministry is a question about the Rites and Churches in the universal Catholic Church. As a Filipino iconographer, the number one question I get for every icon I make of Mary is, "Oh, is that the Mother of Perpetual Help?" And then I'd go into great detail explaining that not all Byzantine icons of Our Lady is the Perpetual Help icon. 😄
Good interview.
Just as notice, you have an awesome voice, could be perfect for a death metal band
Can you do a video on the Jerusalem rite and one of the Dominican rite please. TH-cam doesn't have enough on that.
53:41 the 10th time we use St Basil is on his feast day on January 1st 🙃
Love the Byzantine tradition as expressed in both the Catholic Church and Orthodox churches. My only critique of the Byzantine Catholic tradition is that it sometimes feels “Latinized” (e.g., revised-revised Gregorian calendar and “forever and ever” as opposed to the “unto of the ages” in the liturgy) and sometimes lacks some of the key liturgical services such as “Orthros.” 😔🙏🏻
I believe that depends on the parish! At my Melkite parish there’s Orthros before Liturgy, and Vespers once or twice a week, and we get all the “unto the ages of ages” we could ask for. The priests around my area aren’t per-se anti-Latin but they’re certainly staunchly Melkite (Byzantine).
I want to visit a Byzantine Catholic Church! There’s one about an hour away from me but I just gotta wake up really early to go lol I’m considering either converting to Latin rite or Byzantine. Orthodox is also pretty cool!
Go Byzantine Catholic, if you like the rite more.
Historically, the "Byzantine Catholics" used to be Orthodox. Starting in the 1500s, a few Orthodox eparchies started uniting with Rome (this was usually a political strategy in order to preserve their "Eastern-ness" in the Austro-Hungarian empire). God bless!
Praised be Jesus Christ!
I wanted to clarify for anyone interested, that we have always had vespers in the Roman Catholic rite. It is not the Saturday evening Mass. The word vesper itself is Latin ;)
There are no Eastern rite churches near me with a 3 hr drive. I'm a convert to Catholicism in the Latin rite. I would love to change to the Byzantine rite. Do they plant churches? Is there a a group that we can appeal to to have them begin a Byz rite church closer to us.
Next do a video on syro malabar and syro malankara from kerala
What I have noticed is that their is alot of Catholic influences online, including the Catholics
Im confused in what he attended before coming back. How different was it, what was latinozed exactly? Was it still the divine liturgy of st basil and st chrysostom? How different was it?
Was the Byzantine Rite reformed after V 2?
How does one become an Eastern Rite Catholic?
It's called a canonical transfer, or a transfer of ascription. After you've attended the Byzantine church for a bit you can ask the priest to start this. You have to write a letter saying why you'd like to transfer, and the priest will also write a letter. It gets sent to the bishop who can approve or disapprove.
@@junicornplays980 im currently Eastern Orthodox
@@treytrapani9813 Oh then it's super easy for you. Talk to an Eastern Catholic priest. I think it's just a simple profession of faith.
I never did that, I just started going there after I came back to the church.
@@RickW-HGWT I mean, technically, since Orthodox can receive Catholic sacraments, it does seem like a profession of faith is more of a formality. I didn't want to lead any astray, but unofficially, some Eastern Catholic priests, especially the ones from less Latinized churches, would probably be ok with that.
1:10:45 starts book references
Do Byzantine Catholics believe in purgatory or tollhouses?
They call purgatory that I think but they do believe in purgatory they just call it that I think
Yes, they just don't really talk or focus on it too much but yes they do believe in it.
Please correct me if I'm wrong anyone
Glory to Jesus Christ! 🙏☦️♥️
If one is truly Byzantine Catholic, no. Many ByzCatholics I know do not. They accept that the West does though.
I am Catholic of byzantine rite from Romania and we do believe in Purgatory, we pray for the souls in Purgatory at every Mass.
@@MrCoachdunhamlol that is a very Protestant take. Purgatory is supported in the Bible. If one is a Catholic they do believe in purgatory or they don’t hold all of the beliefs of Catholicism.
What is the difference between Romain Catholic and eastern Catholic?
A quick answer is different form of liturgy, the Eastern Rite is mostly a sung liturgy, the communion form is different. Big plus is married men can become priests in the Eastern Rite, a married priest has perspectives that a celibate does not. Attend one and speak to the laity and priest after.
Is the st basil divine liturgy earlier then the pre-tridentine liturgy (the mass before the tlm)
Yes. The Pre-Tridentine Mass generally dates to around the late 1500s
off topic but does anyone know any good bible study channels or videos with catholic interpretation
Hey brother, I have to ask, what is your view on saint michael the archangel?
bro handsome
Restriction mode was on lol
Please add a bibliography.
It's the blackest of pagan rites.
So wait!!! You guys are not Roman Catholics?
The Bible is the rule book
Same church different creed🤔
It's incoherent(contradiction).
Could you explain your stance to someone looking for which church to follow or not follow@@StrugglingProtestant
What?
@@StrugglingProtestant Imagine a protestant telling Catholics about "incoherence" and "Contradictions" ... The lack of self-awareness is STRONG
Not really. Rome always believed in the Filioque, but when the Nicene Creed was made it wasn’t included. Perhaps it wasn’t necessary, since it doesn’t contradict the Filioque (The Holy Spirit indeed comes from the Father).
Later centuries a heresy was being developed in Spain. This heresy put in doubt the divinity of Christ, so they added the Filioque to fight against the heresy. It was later adopted by the whole Church of Rome. The East never had a problem with that until Photios.
Eastern Catholic Churches believe in the theology of the Filioque, but for tradition’s sake they just don’t say it when they proclamate the creed, but it is usually in parentheses (and the Son). And this is perfectly acceptable, since they respect the theology, but also respect their own tradition, just like in the past.
There is no Trinity