I will say this, SM took every care to take care of the remaining members. It hurt a lot to lose jonghyun, for everyone. The 6 month tribute was very tastefully done and we all got to mourn with them.
On May 25th, it will be SHINee's 11th anniversary! Can you please make a SHINee special on that day and react to some of their songs? I recommend "Woof Woof" (live), "Get the treasure" (mv), "Your number" (dance ver.), "Stranger" (live swc4 ver.), and "Sherlock" (live swc4 ver.)
Beautiful song, touching lyrics and four guys who are strong in spirit. No matter how painful and difficult they continue to go. It deserves respect. I admire their devotion to each other, their sincerity and ability to give love to many people. Great job, SHINee.
25/5/2019 it's SHINee 11th anniversary, and to here this now make me so emotional~ happy SHINee and Shawols' day... love you so much guys, let's be together for a long time
Man, they had so much courage to be even able to film this type of mv when they were still mourning. It's not acting, their sad faces, everything is true.
It's beautiful how we can reference the lights that appear around them and the lamps being lit as they pass as the fans who are always on their side and are illuminating the way they will go, hold their hand and be there for anything that happen
Thank you for reacting to this song and reading the lyrics. I think they really add to the impact of the song and video. I've been a fan of SHINee since 2009 and honestly broke down crying when I saw the 5th microphone for Jonghyun. A very moving mv and song.
I haven't watched this Mv for so long cuz I still get emotional and overwhelmed by the fact Jonghyun is not longer here. And that song is so beautiful. Miss his voice. I'm here cuz I follow your reactions but definitely I think this my last time watching this Mv.
What I really love about this MV is that it deals with grief in a really raw and real way. After his death, they had to carry on. To make music. To act. To do their hobbies. To work out. They had to do everyday things despite it feeling incredibly empty. I felt it to a lesser degree but it was incredibly hard. To go to work everyday and pretend life was okay. I can't imagine how they felt.
I really love this song - such a beautiful and meaningful tribute to their brother. The song is very powerful, sad yet somehow uplifting... Especially the chorus, when they all sing in unison with their gorgeous vocals sounds almost like an anthem - a promise to always love him, never forget him and carry on his legacy to honor him and what he loved the most - which is the world, his loved ones and music... Argh, I love SHINee for being such an amazing group - not only 5 beautiful, talented, sweet and funny members, but 5 brothers - like a real family. They are the group I’m going to love and support forever ❤️
Thanks for reacting to Our Page. I think it's a brave thing to do for reactors to take on reviewing this video, knowing what it's going to be about. I personally can't watch it without crying - even now almost a year later (as I sit here blowing my nose). It's a great song though. A really great one. I'm curious if you would like SHINee's "Sherlock". It's a classic! From 2012. Of course since you liked "Good Evening", I'm confident you'll like "View" (2015). And you'll definitely dig a lot of songs from Key's recent solo album. The B-sides were FIRE.
Beautiful Song. A masterpiece. Plus the message of Hope and Promise to Move Forward, Still together as FIVE. Plus their voices.. Our Page and SHINee always pull my heartstrings.. 💕
Apparently this song still makes me sob...every time I see that empty mic... I lose it...Remember that if you ever need help there are plenty of hotlines and people out there to help you. Never be afraid to ask, and never suffer alone.
This is one of the most beautiful songs of SHINee's; a fitting tribute to Jonghyun. This song is the definition of perfection. If you want to finish the trilogy of The Story Of Light, you need to watch Countless. I'm excited for Stay but I'm surprised you're putting two slower songs back to back. Stay is a fun one though, more light hearted than others. Thank you for picking this beautiful song.
I just watched this mv once, right after it came out. I cried so so much at that time that I couldn't hear the song again since then. But I really wanted to see your reaction to SHINee and thought maybe it's time to rewatch it. I cried again, but I'm thankful to you for reacting to them.
This video shows them during the first days/weeks after Jonghyun's passing. Most of them were able to cancel their schedules and spend time as suited them (Onew working on music, Taemin working out, Key playing computer games and practicing dancing). Minho was in the middle of filming an action movie, I gather he was only able to take off the 3 days for the funeral before he had to go back to filming.
I can't stop myself from crying every time I hear this song or watch an MV. I know I shouldn't, but I can't stop. Song gets me so emotional. Even while watching this reaction I'm crying a river. That moment with mics..Thanks for reacting to SHINee. I love them so much
Thanks for reacting to this, honestly for me is still difficult seeing and hearing this song, the boys emotions are so raw, and that was just in the MV, during their concert in japan (planned before jonghyun dead happened, but still decide to go trough it) when they decided to do that concert in a way to put out all their emotions in stage, really was something painful to see, but I love this group so much that the only think I want is for them to recover as much as they can and enjoy music again and of course that they are able again to share their talent with a light heart. I wish all of my other favorite groups like exo, and bts that loved shinee and support them, will live their lives at the fullest and enjoy as much their job as their personal lives, cos yes something that jonghyun left us is that you can be happy, you can give everything for music but your personal life is important too.
This song/MV keeps hurting me for so many reasons. Seen the boys like this just make me think a lot of things. Shinee was and still is my first love. It's been already nine years since I'm into them, II was just a eleven y/o girl when I first fell in love. I grow up with their music and Jonghyun was my first "love" since Hello Baby (a TV show). Is so hard to me see the pain and the hardships this five men had to go through. But this is really a beautiful song, the lyrics are amazing and is awesome that we had a chance to properly say goodbye to Dino due to this track. The "blue light" is the official color of the fandom/group, it's the color of our lightstick as well.
This song is so spl for shawols.... When ever I listen to this song I sing it louder for our angel jonghyun if I'm outside I do lipsync Thank you for reacting this song❤
so many great things happening in music and feeling so good about it day by day and then you said “feeling the loss of missing someone like that” and I lost it.. after watching you for a few months, I know this would have been out of your comfort zone to react publicly too, so thank you for a beautiful video and reminding me what life is all about.. 💜💜
That’s all them singing, I know it’s very breathtaking! 🥰🥰🥰🥺🥺🥺🥺 The four older ones are now in the military....Taemin is the remaining member right now until it’s his time to enlist, as far as i’ve heard and seen he’s still in Japan!
You can see from the members' eyes that they are missing that one vital part they had for a long time! This is them moving forward after Jonghyun passed on. A tribute at the same time a sort of letting go and moving forward!
We missed our shining boys. Can you do more reaction vids for them? Everybody, Ring Ding Dong, Sherlock, Tell Me what to do and more. Evil, Queen of new york and amigo live performances And some of their japanese songs like winter wonderland, 1000 years always by your side, fire, 3-2-1, lucky star and all hahaha . Thank you
I feel you did not understand it. First time i saw it i was in tears sobbing like a baby. This was the first time in my relatively short time as a kpop fan I ever cried during any song. It just left me heartbroken. Rest In Peace sweet Jonghyun. You did well.
Even though Jonghyun is no longer physically here with us, his presence & memory has never left their side or ours! 12+ years they’ve been a group all the hardships and experiences they went through together, that’s allot to process when you lose that person you were very close to like family like a brother. If you didn’t see it, they had a fifth glass mic stand alone in front of them!
And if you want to react to another touching song, I strongly recommend Before Our Spring, by Jonghyun (maybe with lyrics, if u find one). It's the final track of his last album. It was released on February, 2018 (2 months after the incident). The song is a metaphor for his struggle, saying that we don't have to worry, cuz his winter will pass soon and the spring will come to him too. It's a beautiful and meaningful song, accompanied by a piano.
To complete the series... next song is 'Countless' and i suggest one more song 'From Now On' from their latest concert th-cam.com/video/i0vdkEEFpUw/w-d-xo.html
You should listen to the song with its English translation. The lyrics are wonderful, expressive, and carry messages to Jonghun and painful at the same time.💔
I wish you could react to some SHINee B side track , such as Alarm Clock, farewell my love, like a fire and Evil, make sure u watch to their live version,it's so much awesome.
What's make me really mad is that song is fucking amazing. I do not like to listen to her, 'cause i always tearing up a little every time i do, but, for me, it's one of the best song of them and i just... ARRG
This is a very deeply emotional tribute song about their brother and our beloved Kim Jonghyun who couldn’t handle the harshness of life(extreme depression, mental illness, insomnia etc) on top of being in the spotlight anymore even through his pain he always tried his best to keep a smile on his face for us but sadly he passed away in Dec 2017 which was an very shocking unexpected to us Shawols, his brothers(group members) and most of all his family and everyone else that knew him! After his death, his brothers did everything to keep his memory & presence alive in the music and within themselves...they even have used their fan color Pearl Aqua as his presence.
..... Please double check your information before writing what you perceive as facts. It was not because of fans wars. It's so much deeper and more complicated than that. It feels like your trivializing this amazing man that was unfortunately severely depressed and had been struggling with it for so long. It also feels like your disregarding people's feelings by saying it was harder for one person than others. It also hasn't been 2 years... it's been 1 year and 5 months... Please think before you speak....or type in this instance.
kanary90 im sorry if you misunderstood that’s not what i mean, i would never do that to him im apologises if you see it that i was just trying to make it more simpler for him, my bad for putting just the fan wars” part i was going off my memory....i may not remember all but i know the hardships and depression that he was suffering through I could see it in his eyes even when he smiled & i’ve read his note and rudeness that others said about him, I’ve been a kpopper for 12 years and Shawol since their predebut....i may not remember everything but i know Kim Jonghyun was most amazing angel that I will never get the chance to meet in this life!
@@ellie_jeann I do understand that. But not everyone does so I wanted to point out the incorrect info before ppl started quoting you. I'm just saying be careful before posting info you're not sure about or just think before you type something that might be easily misconstrued. I also understand that your love for SHINee/Jonghyun has nothing to do with said incorrect info. I just hate all the stuff going around nonshawols and don't want anything added to it. We've been through enough.
kanary90 Your right, i’m sincere apologizes to Shawols and future Shawols....i was just trying to find a way to make it more simpler for him to understand without going into too much detail!
If you want get more viewers try to react Indonesian song like "Alan Walker Al0ne koplo or L1LY" Also if you musician have you hear Indonesian Angklung? React it in TH-cam by KJRI Austria channel the old one 😅
![[ENG/JPN] SHINee's friendship rings put their bond to the test #SHINEE](/img/n.gif)
song was a tribute to Jonghyuns death and the lyrics are about him
I will say this, SM took every care to take care of the remaining members. It hurt a lot to lose jonghyun, for everyone. The 6 month tribute was very tastefully done and we all got to mourn with them.
Thanks for reviewing Shinee again. Beautiful song commemorating Jonghyun
I tear up every time I see the 5th microphone.
A beautiful tribute to a beautiful person
On May 25th, it will be SHINee's 11th anniversary! Can you please make a SHINee special on that day and react to some of their songs? I recommend "Woof Woof" (live), "Get the treasure" (mv), "Your number" (dance ver.), "Stranger" (live swc4 ver.), and "Sherlock" (live swc4 ver.)
Fantastic idea!
Couldn agree more...i think i will do that too..with wholeeee albums....😊😊😊
i think we have to comment more here so he may hear to our request
Beautiful song, touching lyrics and four guys who are strong in spirit. No matter how painful and difficult they continue to go. It deserves respect. I admire their devotion to each other, their sincerity and ability to give love to many people. Great job, SHINee.
25/5/2019 it's SHINee 11th anniversary, and to here this now make me so emotional~ happy SHINee and Shawols' day... love you so much guys, let's be together for a long time
💙💙💙💙
Thanks for the reaction. You should complete The Story of Light with Countless.
SHINee will be my favorite and they will always be five.
Man, they had so much courage to be even able to film this type of mv when they were still mourning. It's not acting, their sad faces, everything is true.
It's beautiful how we can reference the lights that appear around them and the lamps being lit as they pass as the fans who are always on their side and are illuminating the way they will go, hold their hand and be there for anything that happen
Thank you for reacting to this song and reading the lyrics. I think they really add to the impact of the song and video. I've been a fan of SHINee since 2009 and honestly broke down crying when I saw the 5th microphone for Jonghyun. A very moving mv and song.
I haven't watched this Mv for so long cuz I still get emotional and overwhelmed by the fact Jonghyun is not longer here. And that song is so beautiful. Miss his voice. I'm here cuz I follow your reactions but definitely I think this my last time watching this Mv.
Johanna Diaz I know how you feel...It still hurts
Hey, baby. Keep strong. Someday, we'll be capable of look to this video and only remember the good moments and everything he teached to us. 💙
Whew, this is so hard to watch without crying 😢 but man those guys loved their brother so much. 💜
What I really love about this MV is that it deals with grief in a really raw and real way. After his death, they had to carry on. To make music. To act. To do their hobbies. To work out. They had to do everyday things despite it feeling incredibly empty. I felt it to a lesser degree but it was incredibly hard. To go to work everyday and pretend life was okay. I can't imagine how they felt.
I really love this song - such a beautiful and meaningful tribute to their brother. The song is very powerful, sad yet somehow uplifting... Especially the chorus, when they all sing in unison with their gorgeous vocals sounds almost like an anthem - a promise to always love him, never forget him and carry on his legacy to honor him and what he loved the most - which is the world, his loved ones and music... Argh, I love SHINee for being such an amazing group - not only 5 beautiful, talented, sweet and funny members, but 5 brothers - like a real family. They are the group I’m going to love and support forever ❤️
Thanks for reacting to Our Page. I think it's a brave thing to do for reactors to take on reviewing this video, knowing what it's going to be about. I personally can't watch it without crying - even now almost a year later (as I sit here blowing my nose). It's a great song though. A really great one. I'm curious if you would like SHINee's "Sherlock". It's a classic! From 2012. Of course since you liked "Good Evening", I'm confident you'll like "View" (2015). And you'll definitely dig a lot of songs from Key's recent solo album. The B-sides were FIRE.
Beautiful Song. A masterpiece.
Plus the message of Hope and Promise to Move Forward, Still together as FIVE.
Plus their voices.. Our Page and SHINee always pull my heartstrings.. 💕
Apparently this song still makes me sob...every time I see that empty mic... I lose it...Remember that if you ever need help there are plenty of hotlines and people out there to help you. Never be afraid to ask, and never suffer alone.
So painful to watch, and yet so beautiful. They are so brave! Thanks Ellis
This is one of the most beautiful songs of SHINee's; a fitting tribute to Jonghyun. This song is the definition of perfection. If you want to finish the trilogy of The Story Of Light, you need to watch Countless. I'm excited for Stay but I'm surprised you're putting two slower songs back to back. Stay is a fun one though, more light hearted than others. Thank you for picking this beautiful song.
I just watched this mv once, right after it came out. I cried so so much at that time that I couldn't hear the song again since then. But I really wanted to see your reaction to SHINee and thought maybe it's time to rewatch it. I cried again, but I'm thankful to you for reacting to them.
i still cry over that onew's "you did well" TT_TT
This video shows them during the first days/weeks after Jonghyun's passing. Most of them were able to cancel their schedules and spend time as suited them (Onew working on music, Taemin working out, Key playing computer games and practicing dancing). Minho was in the middle of filming an action movie, I gather he was only able to take off the 3 days for the funeral before he had to go back to filming.
Thank you for your reaction!❤ I love this song and I love ❤SHINee❤!
Yayyyyyy thank you so much for react to this MV. Thanks a lot!!
I cannot watch this MV without breaking down and ugly crying...but I have to watch this to support Ellis...bring on the tears and feels
I can't stop myself from crying every time I hear this song or watch an MV. I know I shouldn't, but I can't stop. Song gets me so emotional. Even while watching this reaction I'm crying a river. That moment with mics..Thanks for reacting to SHINee. I love them so much
Thanks for reacting to this, honestly for me is still difficult seeing and hearing this song, the boys emotions are so raw, and that was just in the MV, during their concert in japan (planned before jonghyun dead happened, but still decide to go trough it) when they decided to do that concert in a way to put out all their emotions in stage, really was something painful to see, but I love this group so much that the only think I want is for them to recover as much as they can and enjoy music again and of course that they are able again to share their talent with a light heart. I wish all of my other favorite groups like exo, and bts that loved shinee and support them, will live their lives at the fullest and enjoy as much their job as their personal lives, cos yes something that jonghyun left us is that you can be happy, you can give everything for music but your personal life is important too.
This song/MV keeps hurting me for so many reasons. Seen the boys like this just make me think a lot of things. Shinee was and still is my first love. It's been already nine years since I'm into them, II was just a eleven y/o girl when I first fell in love. I grow up with their music and Jonghyun was my first "love" since Hello Baby (a TV show). Is so hard to me see the pain and the hardships this five men had to go through. But this is really a beautiful song, the lyrics are amazing and is awesome that we had a chance to properly say goodbye to Dino due to this track. The "blue light" is the official color of the fandom/group, it's the color of our lightstick as well.
This song is so spl for shawols.... When ever I listen to this song I sing it louder for our angel jonghyun if I'm outside I do lipsync
Thank you for reacting this song❤
💎 Keep going SHINee. The most painful thing to do is listening to Our Page... 😭😭😭#alwaysbewithyou
There is one more they released- Countless which I love!
so many great things happening in music and feeling so good about it day by day and then you said “feeling the loss of missing someone like that” and I lost it.. after watching you for a few months, I know this would have been out of your comfort zone to react publicly too, so thank you for a beautiful video and reminding me what life is all about.. 💜💜
I found your channel today. Thank you for reacting to this video, May 25 is the 11th anniversary of shinee, it's like a gift, thank you very much.
R I P to our king
I don’t know if there will ever be a day I watch this MV or hear this song that I don’t burst into tears. 💎💎💎💎✨💎✨ Forever Five
Thanks for being gentle even though it's not your favorite type of song. Hope the next one is a banger. You earned it!!
That’s all them singing, I know it’s very breathtaking! 🥰🥰🥰🥺🥺🥺🥺 The four older ones are now in the military....Taemin is the remaining member right now until it’s his time to enlist, as far as i’ve heard and seen he’s still in Japan!
You can see from the members' eyes that they are missing that one vital part they had for a long time! This is them moving forward after Jonghyun passed on. A tribute at the same time a sort of letting go and moving forward!
Shinee five forever i love this song and i am crying I am a shawol for 8 years
We hope you see live shinee shows like Evil, Strnger , Sherlock and Picasso, it's so great
Never heard the song before, but it really fits my mood for today. Great song!
We missed our shining boys. Can you do more reaction vids for them?
Everybody, Ring Ding Dong, Sherlock, Tell Me what to do and more. Evil, Queen of new york and amigo live performances
And some of their japanese songs like winter wonderland, 1000 years always by your side, fire, 3-2-1, lucky star and all hahaha . Thank you
Amo todas tus reacciones😍😍😍😍 pero esta es super especial para mi.......😘😘😘😘
Im crying, its beautiful song💕
I feel you did not understand it. First time i saw it i was in tears sobbing like a baby. This was the first time in my relatively short time as a kpop fan I ever cried during any song. It just left me heartbroken. Rest In Peace sweet Jonghyun. You did well.
Thank’s 2008 05 25 SHINEE DEBUT
It's also about Jonghyun, the member who left us for Heaven. Of how there's a hole left behind.
I cried a lot 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Even though Jonghyun is no longer physically here with us, his presence & memory has never left their side or ours! 12+ years they’ve been a group all the hardships and experiences they went through together, that’s allot to process when you lose that person you were very close to like family like a brother. If you didn’t see it, they had a fifth glass mic stand alone in front of them!
Shinee 😥💚
I can't watch this again, but I do appreciate your reactions (I skipped to the end).
yesssssss shinnneeeee
oh god that song makes me cry again😔😔😔 I miss jonghyun
My sweet jjong! 😢 kiss to the sky 🥺
Awww Shinee. This is their first song after Jonghyun...
No it's not
Please chek out Taemin under my skin mv
Thank you!
I think i only watched this mv once it made me so sad when it came out
this song make me so sad, i think this is there first song after death of Jonghyun💔💔
And if you want to react to another touching song, I strongly recommend Before Our Spring, by Jonghyun (maybe with lyrics, if u find one). It's the final track of his last album. It was released on February, 2018 (2 months after the incident). The song is a metaphor for his struggle, saying that we don't have to worry, cuz his winter will pass soon and the spring will come to him too. It's a beautiful and meaningful song, accompanied by a piano.
Listening to this song is fine but watching the mv is still hard for me... Thank you reaction to this
SHINEE'S VIEW PLEAASEE
I wish there's Shinee reaction on their anniversary this 25th May..
To complete the series... next song is 'Countless' and i suggest one more song 'From Now On' from their latest concert th-cam.com/video/i0vdkEEFpUw/w-d-xo.html
This song hurts so much
Actually, Minho was filming a movie in that time so, yeah.
You should listen to the song with its English translation. The lyrics are wonderful, expressive, and carry messages to Jonghun and painful at the same time.💔
Do you know many do react but you are the best enthusiastic a lot if you received a logo from you I worked hard and I am very happy 🌸❤️
Even the cat likes it 😻
I wish you could react to some SHINee B side track , such as Alarm Clock, farewell my love, like a fire and Evil, make sure u watch to their live version,it's so much awesome.
please react shinee "tell me what to do"......
please react to SHINee's VIEW!
😢😢😢😢 I miss you Jonghyun !!!
Plz react to jonghyun solo
What's make me really mad is that song is fucking amazing. I do not like to listen to her, 'cause i always tearing up a little every time i do, but, for me, it's one of the best song of them and i just... ARRG
I miss jonghyun:')
♥️
This is a very deeply emotional tribute song about their brother and our beloved Kim Jonghyun who couldn’t handle the harshness of life(extreme depression, mental illness, insomnia etc) on top of being in the spotlight anymore even through his pain he always tried his best to keep a smile on his face for us but sadly he passed away in Dec 2017 which was an very shocking unexpected to us Shawols, his brothers(group members) and most of all his family and everyone else that knew him! After his death, his brothers did everything to keep his memory & presence alive in the music and within themselves...they even have used their fan color Pearl Aqua as his presence.
.....
Please double check your information before writing what you perceive as facts. It was not because of fans wars. It's so much deeper and more complicated than that. It feels like your trivializing this amazing man that was unfortunately severely depressed and had been struggling with it for so long. It also feels like your disregarding people's feelings by saying it was harder for one person than others. It also hasn't been 2 years... it's been 1 year and 5 months...
Please think before you speak....or type in this instance.
kanary90 im sorry if you misunderstood that’s not what i mean, i would never do that to him im apologises if you see it that i was just trying to make it more simpler for him, my bad for putting just the fan wars” part i was going off my memory....i may not remember all but i know the hardships and depression that he was suffering through I could see it in his eyes even when he smiled & i’ve read his note and rudeness that others said about him, I’ve been a kpopper for 12 years and Shawol since their predebut....i may not remember everything but i know Kim Jonghyun was most amazing angel that I will never get the chance to meet in this life!
@@ellie_jeann I do understand that. But not everyone does so I wanted to point out the incorrect info before ppl started quoting you. I'm just saying be careful before posting info you're not sure about or just think before you type something that might be easily misconstrued. I also understand that your love for SHINee/Jonghyun has nothing to do with said incorrect info. I just hate all the stuff going around nonshawols and don't want anything added to it. We've been through enough.
kanary90 Your right, i’m sincere apologizes to Shawols and future Shawols....i was just trying to find a way to make it more simpler for him to understand without going into too much detail!
Please react to "Wanted"
Please reaction to rainy blue by Onew
PLEASE REACT TO SHINEE RING DING DONG !
Can you react to tell me what to do(live version) -Shinee and 1 of 1 Mv-Shinee?? please
please react to f(X), SHINees sister group and overall one of the best groups ever ❤️
react to 2PM MY HOUSE. its so good
Could you please react to shinee countless.
React to Undercover by A.C.E please it was released today !!
If you want get more viewers try to react Indonesian song like "Alan Walker Al0ne koplo or L1LY"
Also if you musician have you hear Indonesian Angklung?
React it in TH-cam by KJRI Austria channel the old one 😅
More EXO 👑 pleaseeee 😘🇧🇷
Please react to TVXQ - Spellbound
😥
OT5 😪
Please react to EXO Stay
Please exo transformer
He reacted to the version live at the MAMAs :)
Shawna Brooks I know but I mean the exordume version
they lose their soulmate...thats all
Thank you!