India should pursue Thorium based power generation immediately as it is considered safer. Plus India has abundant Thorium reserves. This means less dependent on foreign countries.
@@sunnyboynfs That is not the reason. India didn't force India to sign panchsheel agreement. India lost Arunachal Pradesh in the 1962 war but China vacated that later.
Remember, the patent is still registered in the US, they ask our sovereignty as a mortgage! Remember 123 deal? If business is considered as pure business with no geopolitical strong attached, India will always be open to the opportunity...
Enriched Uranium and Plutonium 239 is preferred by all nations as it enables dual use. Nations want to retain the option to manufacture nuclear weapons should they choose.
Nice sales pitch for venture capitalists ! What sort of reactors would this Thorium-ANEEL utilize? The USA has recently cancelled its thorium-powered (NuScale) Small Modular Reactor project. Apparently too expensive to run, ie it was not cost-effective. How will the ANEEL idea overcome such cost hurdles ? Will ANEEL be planning small (quick build) reactors or something similar to UK's new Hinkley Point project?
If USA has cancelled it. Does that mean we should abandon our research as well? Although expensive, the reserves are pretty good enough. Larger resources can help to marginalise the cost perspective. I think of it as an alternative and it should be worked upon.
Sales pitch? You make it sound like viewers of this video even has chance to buy that fuel and the real customers who might buy this fuel wont make decisions based on youtube video. Nuclear reactors are costly, very costly. The decision to use what fuel needs changes to reactor design too. Real customers will obviously need all the data before making any commitment.😅
Nice and useful information towards attaining clean and sustainable power requirements of our country in the days to come. Has the power ministry of Bharat been approached by the company with full power point presentation regarding the cost of production and other technicalities with pros and cons of the usage of this thorium based clean energy in our country?
I think indian govt can collaborate with CleanCore to use one 220MhW PHWR to test this fuel. I am very skeptical of it because they haven't shared test results from the US test reactors or explained why fuel doesnt need processing to remove protactinium. But hoping it works. Nuclear is only hope for the world.
You haven't said anything about the cost of energy generation by using thorium /aneel. Also you said the nuclear waste can be handled easily but how and will it be possible to use this fuel on a long run. This is important as now onwards every country is looking for a clean most energy generation to avoid contributions in global warming. India has land in abundance for solar and wind and also the long sea shore ( for wave energy) which are considered as the clean most energy sources.
It is too early to talk about costs, but because we are using thorium, it will be cheaper than today's nuclear energy. It is my understanding that it is not difficult to handle wastes of thorium based fuels. I agree that wave energy (along with tidal and underwater current) should be encourage, but that is a separate topic. Thanks and regards,. Ramesh
@@RameshMatham0507 Thank you for clarifying this point. The cost of retrofit & associated payback period will determine whether or not this is financially viable.
fingers crossed if this gets successful. India will become Energy sufficient for centuries and We need most of this energy for this Generation which will be largest population of Indians ever in history . In future this will only decrease. If all our ppl gets energy cheap they can contribute max to economy and we can push india to be Great nation again.
Dr.A P J Kalam; Recommended to use cheaply available ;Thorium from Assam.. use Dual stage ; nuclear fusion to produce cheap Energy; Use FRENCH Technology using this FUEL. and now start cheap energy; clean energy.
If it is true, it's great news. But because so precious little actual technical information was contained in this video, I would stay cautious, lest this too turns out to be like those earlier con jobs of making gasoline from water.
Guess is that if it is workable at relative costs; it needs no marketing like this. Just set it up and generate electricity and invite all countries to see for themselves. Just collaborate with each country to set up in their country and you (Mehul) can run it yourselves and become the largest power producer in the world! Cheers!
Had it been any other country that was in this unique situation where it has plenty of sources of POTENTIAL energy source at its disposal & at the same time it had to spend lot of its resources in importing EXISTING & PROVEN energy sources from another country, any other country would have developed & became a world leader in utilizing the ON HAND energy source. But unfortunately it is India that is endowed with this natural resource. So the world community at large had to wait for new technology to be developed by someone else who doesn't have this natural resource. India has traditionally has relied on technology transfer from others & never developed anything substantial.
The video says it can go into existing reactors. Kerala is a goldmine for thorium. I think kerala has around 80% of the thorium in the world. If Aneel is as true as being said, India has the capacity to leapfrog the USA in terms of gdp
India can definitely use this kind of fuel in its fast breeder reactor. That will increase the speed to build up its reserve of more thorium based nuclear fuel. It can also pave the way to build small moduler rectors??
One side world is biding on thorium and on other side fusion tech. I'm not a scientist but I wish for nuclear fusion to see reality light soon. Its best what world wants. I wish India on personal level also starts its own research on nuclear fusion. If already started govt must speed it up many times more.
1. Ramesh could have given update on India's thorium reactor at Kalpakkam so that we could have better understood the importance of ANEEL. It was reported that this Kalpakakm unit is close to being operationalized. But we need confirmed and updated news on it. 2. ANEEL looks definitely potential but we need to know how it is to be used in reactors- whether current reactors can take it or there is something else? Any response on ANEEL from our Atomic Energy Dept or any of our scientists? 3. Mehul can always start a company in India and promote ANEEL. Modi should invite him to India and two Guju bhai s can decide over fafda and jalebi on this project!!! Of course, the project should come to Maharashtra otherwise Shiv Sena of UBT will start accusing Modi of taking away all projects to Gujarat!! 4. India should look to convert all coal plants of 1960s and 70s to nuclear power plants - whether small nuclear reactors ( we are talking USA an France on this anyway!) or based on new technologies like ANEEL, if feasible. This is the fastest way forward to green energy for India. And we must focus more on our Thorium nuclear plants with gusto.
I was in school, in 1970 when we were told about abundant Thorium in the beaches of kerala, and how we could Generate electricity.....we are in 2024, i am an old man but see no sign of it being used !
THORIUM; Dr. APJKalam already Advised; so work on it and be self reliant and self sufficient; BE ATMA NIRBHAAR; So you can save money , which you use on Education; Research Innovation. work fast and be Rich and Prosperous. and be HAPPY
Why on earth would we buy or import electrical energy from China??? We have enough of our own Solar, Wind, Hydrogen available to not only power our country but other parts of the world also.
Solar or wind cant replace nuclear or coal. You can’t go 100% renewables. You need some minimum base load electricity generation sources like nuclear or coal.
I can't disagree with you. But the only scientific explanation needed here is the formula of the fuel, which the company says is its secret. Yet, I decided to talk about it because people like Dr Anil Kakodkar think there is something in the fuel, and it has been taken note of a few times in the Western media. Also, Clean Core has a tie-up with the Canadian nuclear establishment, which, even if preliminary, lends some credibility. When more details come out, I'll update you.
Thorium has been keeping all of us on the edge of our seats with it's cheap, clean, almost unlimited energy promise for more than 2 decades now. Will this be the final breakthrough? Or will this be another dud? Let's hope for the former.
Why we have to take US technology? Our own scientists are now capable of developing Made in India technologies for India. Akanda Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 Jai Hind
Sir. When I was a teenager Raja Ramanna promised that this technology (fast breeder reactor) would become realized in a decade. Raja Ramanna is long gone and I have become a senior citizen. How long do you want the youth of India to wait?
Can you build one in any northern states or even in Kannada, Andra or in Kerala. No one is going to allow. Why dont you try to build in Uttar pradesh or Bihar then talk about it.
Thorium fuel is not an Indian innovation. USA first used it. Then switch to Uranium reactors to produce energy as well as materials for its nuclear arsenal. China now already has an operational Thorium-molten salt reactor.
lead the world, dear India! lead the world! buona fortuna!! BUT...why did that Indian Innovators have to Start-UP in the USA?!! Why NOT in his India? I'm in SW FL, USA, and know nothing, but is India's Innovative StartUPs support institutions NOT offering such Innovators the Appropriate Investment strategies? Fix THAT, too, Indian-friends!! And...use ActCAD (Andhra Pradesh) instead of AutoCAD :-) I do NOW!! Support excellent made-in-India CAD software Companies!!!
I don't understand how on earth is nuclear fuel branded clean by every one on this earth....WHAT ABOUT THE NUCLEAR WASTE?are you planning to dump them in the sea or do you need bunkers to store them for years to come?
It's all great news because we've been hearing about thorium reactors for decades now but nothing to show for it. By the way, the fake interview wasn't very professional.
Nuclear is "clean & green" energy??? woh!! why not build ANEEL is US first if it is so cheap??? NTPC is building 600 MW solar plant with just Rs 1700 crores. What is the cost of nuclear power plant for same power? Atleast 18,000 crores. And how many year it takes to build?? 8-10 years!! India has abundant solar & hydro energy & is cheap, clean.
Don't forget NTPC's 600 MW for Rs 1,700 crore will need coal continuously which has to be paid for. As for solar and hydro, we need them too, obviously.
So we export our Thorium to America(which happens either way illegally) and import a finsihed and expensive product to fuel our enrgy needs? Sounds fishy to me.
India should pursue Thorium based power generation immediately as it is considered safer. Plus India has abundant Thorium reserves. This means less dependent on foreign countries.
Even China is after Thorium reserves in Aruranchal Pradesh. Hence the reason China is using salami slicing tactic to grab that state.
@@sunnyboynfs That is not the reason. India didn't force India to sign panchsheel agreement. India lost Arunachal Pradesh in the 1962 war but China vacated that later.
You do it.
@@vinsin328 Not really. 1962 war was fought in Aksai Chin not Aruranchal Pradesh
@@sunnyboynfs It was fought there.
*Absolutely Excellent and Innovative Concept by Mehul
Shah to develop Nuclear Fuel ANEEL*
Remember, the patent is still registered in the US, they ask our sovereignty as a mortgage! Remember 123 deal?
If business is considered as pure business with no geopolitical strong attached, India will always be open to the opportunity...
@@bharathikannankumarasamy7250 >they ask our sovereignty as a mortgage!
You got a source for that?
The Hindu is now a advertisement outlet for U.S. companies.
The moment he said "Please do watch this video" , I said now I have to finish this video at all costs.
The best thing about this is from invention to ground reality in a short span of time, if it happens. Time is the most important aspect.
Been hearing about thorium reactors for years. Haven't heard any decent breakthroughs.
This is not like making a gas stove.
Enriched Uranium and Plutonium 239 is preferred by all nations as it enables dual use. Nations want to retain the option to manufacture nuclear weapons should they choose.
Chinese have make some some progress with molten salt reactor.
Mayyybe there is a lobby?
There's already a thorium reactor in Tamil Nadu
Nice sales pitch for venture capitalists ! What sort of reactors would this Thorium-ANEEL utilize? The USA has recently cancelled its thorium-powered (NuScale) Small Modular Reactor project. Apparently too expensive to run, ie it was not cost-effective. How will the ANEEL idea overcome such cost hurdles ? Will ANEEL be planning small (quick build) reactors or something similar to UK's new Hinkley Point project?
If USA has cancelled it. Does that mean we should abandon our research as well? Although expensive, the reserves are pretty good enough. Larger resources can help to marginalise the cost perspective. I think of it as an alternative and it should be worked upon.
Sales pitch? You make it sound like viewers of this video even has chance to buy that fuel and the real customers who might buy this fuel wont make decisions based on youtube video. Nuclear reactors are costly, very costly. The decision to use what fuel needs changes to reactor design too. Real customers will obviously need all the data before making any commitment.😅
Good to see an update on thorium.
Hat's off... precisely it's very important for our available resources utilisation... wishing Speedy implementation with best economical viability...
Nice and useful information towards attaining clean and sustainable power requirements of our country in the days to come.
Has the power ministry of Bharat been approached by the company with full power point presentation regarding the cost of production and other technicalities with pros and cons of the usage of this thorium based clean energy in our country?
Massively important information!! Many thanks.
This is very good channel. Thank You
I think indian govt can collaborate with CleanCore to use one 220MhW PHWR to test this fuel. I am very skeptical of it because they haven't shared test results from the US test reactors or explained why fuel doesnt need processing to remove protactinium. But hoping it works. Nuclear is only hope for the world.
good info about the clean energy , may the entire country will use it one day as a clean energy to deliver every house with the electricity
Super this will definitely change the complete environments which will definitely creates entire environment pollution free.
Wonderful news Thank you Sir
Too good to believe. If it meets the claims, it will be a game changer for India.
GOOD INFORMATION
Has there been any new developments in thorium reactors?
China is in the game now, Google it
We are in between 2nd and 3rd stage, we need enough quantity of plutonium
Thank you for your information
Nice, why the click sounds in between? It’s distracting and unhelpful.
🎉super ANEEL FUEL
Good news indeed!
You haven't said anything about the cost of energy generation by using thorium /aneel. Also you said the nuclear waste can be handled easily but how and will it be possible to use this fuel on a long run. This is important as now onwards every country is looking for a clean most energy generation to avoid contributions in global warming. India has land in abundance for solar and wind and also the long sea shore ( for wave energy) which are considered as the clean most energy sources.
It is too early to talk about costs, but because we are using thorium, it will be cheaper than today's nuclear energy. It is my understanding that it is not difficult to handle wastes of thorium based fuels. I agree that wave energy (along with tidal and underwater current) should be encourage, but that is a separate topic. Thanks and regards,. Ramesh
Energy is the basis of civilization. Advances are long overdue.
Thank you for your excellent presentation
Grateful thanks
Thank you for this update about the advances in thorium nuclear power. Can existing PHWRs be retrofitted to accommodate ANEEL fuel?
That is what Mehul Shah told me and I have no reason to disbelieve him. The retrofitting can happen when the fuel rods are to be replaced
@@RameshMatham0507 Thank you for clarifying this point. The cost of retrofit & associated payback period will determine whether or not this is financially viable.
Very good achievement sir by our Indian
he is not an Indian
should we invest in them ?
fingers crossed if this gets successful. India will become Energy sufficient for centuries and We need most of this energy for this Generation which will be largest population of Indians ever in history . In future this will only decrease. If all our ppl gets energy cheap they can contribute max to economy and we can push india to be Great nation again.
Dr.A P J Kalam; Recommended to use cheaply available ;Thorium from Assam..
use Dual stage ; nuclear fusion to produce cheap Energy;
Use FRENCH Technology using this FUEL.
and now start cheap energy;
clean energy.
Thorium is also available in Kerala
If it is true, it's great news. But because so precious little actual technical information was contained in this video, I would stay cautious, lest this too turns out to be like those earlier con jobs of making gasoline from water.
Please inform PMO . They may encourage you .
Good evening sirji
Mehlul shah looks like our Somanath sir.
Who is he? Some scam artist?
Any stock in this sector
Great great great news
Guess is that if it is workable at relative costs; it needs no marketing like this. Just set it up and generate electricity and invite all countries to see for themselves. Just collaborate with each country to set up in their country and you (Mehul) can run it yourselves and become the largest power producer in the world! Cheers!
Good news
Had it been any other country that was in this unique situation where it has plenty of sources of POTENTIAL energy source at its disposal & at the same time it had to spend lot of its resources in importing EXISTING & PROVEN energy sources from another country, any other country would have developed & became a world leader in utilizing the ON HAND energy source.
But unfortunately it is India that is endowed with this natural resource. So the world community at large had to wait for new technology to be developed by someone else who doesn't have this natural resource.
India has traditionally has relied on technology transfer from others & never developed anything substantial.
Why is a show claiming expertise in clean tech still using condensation tower to show pollution?
ANEEL had a good future , how can we harness this thorium based Aneel.
The video says it can go into existing reactors. Kerala is a goldmine for thorium. I think kerala has around 80% of the thorium in the world.
If Aneel is as true as being said, India has the capacity to leapfrog the USA in terms of gdp
Let's see.
Best part is thoruim is abundance in India. So we will not have to depend on raw material on others .
Then, why is the MODY guarantee is not atracted to this innovation?
I believe that if India go big time on battery technology like sodium, flow batteries and others , then that will help a lot.
Why believe?
India needs every tech available battery or nuclear. India needs to implement all those tech as fast as possible.
India can definitely use this kind of fuel in its fast breeder reactor. That will increase the speed to build up its reserve of more thorium based nuclear fuel. It can also pave the way to build small moduler rectors??
One side world is biding on thorium and on other side fusion tech. I'm not a scientist but I wish for nuclear fusion to see reality light soon. Its best what world wants. I wish India on personal level also starts its own research on nuclear fusion. If already started govt must speed it up many times more.
SST-1 and upcoming SST-2 are Indian Fusion Reactors.
This is a major development.
1. Ramesh could have given update on India's thorium reactor at Kalpakkam so that we could have better understood the importance of ANEEL. It was reported that this Kalpakakm unit is close to being operationalized. But we need confirmed and updated news on it. 2. ANEEL looks definitely potential but we need to know how it is to be used in reactors- whether current reactors can take it or there is something else? Any response on ANEEL from our Atomic Energy Dept or any of our scientists? 3. Mehul can always start a company in India and promote ANEEL. Modi should invite him to India and two Guju bhai s can decide over fafda and jalebi on this project!!! Of course, the project should come to Maharashtra otherwise Shiv Sena of UBT will start accusing Modi of taking away all projects to Gujarat!! 4. India should look to convert all coal plants of 1960s and 70s to nuclear power plants - whether small nuclear reactors ( we are talking USA an France on this anyway!) or based on new technologies like ANEEL, if feasible. This is the fastest way forward to green energy for India. And we must focus more on our Thorium nuclear plants with gusto.
Since this company is in the USA, can USA authorities block the transfer of this technology?
Jay Hind Jay Bharat 🙏
I hope Indian government is in contact with Me. mehul.
What are we waiting... get thorium reactor out asap.
Congratulations..... 👏👏👌👌....
When india will start producing thorium energy with all the research work done in india
Will this company go public in future?
Coal makes New Delhi air visible.
I was in school, in 1970 when we were told about abundant Thorium in the beaches of kerala, and how we could Generate electricity.....we are in 2024, i am an old man but see no sign of it being used !
Amazing! I made exactly the same comment before I saw yours! Raja Ramanna was the one who told us in National College.
THORIUM; Dr. APJKalam already Advised;
so work on it
and be self reliant and self sufficient;
BE ATMA NIRBHAAR;
So you can save money , which you use on Education;
Research
Innovation.
work fast and be Rich and Prosperous.
and be HAPPY
More difficult than power is to decarbonise steel and cement sectors both as big polluter as power
Sir CHina is building enough solar cpacity in its desert that can fuel all our needs.
Why on earth would we buy or import electrical energy from China??? We have enough of our own Solar, Wind, Hydrogen available to not only power our country but other parts of the world also.
Solar or wind cant replace nuclear or coal. You can’t go 100% renewables. You need some minimum base load electricity generation sources like nuclear or coal.
Shanti se information
Its great news ..adani or reliance will jump to buy patency or rights to start building in india .
Apparently their fuel is approved for testing by the DOE, will see..
This is like watching kids discuss what jobs they would like to do in future! No scientific explanation no hard facts only baseless claims!
I can't disagree with you. But the only scientific explanation needed here is the formula of the fuel, which the company says is its secret. Yet, I decided to talk about it because people like Dr Anil Kakodkar think there is something in the fuel, and it has been taken note of a few times in the Western media. Also, Clean Core has a tie-up with the Canadian nuclear establishment, which, even if preliminary, lends some credibility. When more details come out, I'll update you.
If only we had some meritocracy in higher education and work, we would have been better off
We hardly need 5 years time max... thorium reactor will be reality.
Some south Indians tie their tongues in knots with the English alphabets 😂. Ye Yen Yee Yee Yel 😂
Mein thorioum ke baare mein sun sun ke pak chuka hu.jis din iska practical use ho uss din baat krna.
Thorium has been keeping all of us on the edge of our seats with it's cheap, clean, almost unlimited energy promise for more than 2 decades now. Will this be the final breakthrough? Or will this be another dud? Let's hope for the former.
That is called fast breeder reactor my dear friend😂🎉
Why we have to take US technology? Our own scientists are now capable of developing Made in India technologies for India. Akanda Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 Jai Hind
Sir. When I was a teenager Raja Ramanna promised that this technology (fast breeder reactor) would become realized in a decade. Raja Ramanna is long gone and I have become a senior citizen. How long do you want the youth of India to wait?
Can you build one in any northern states or even in Kannada, Andra or in Kerala. No one is going to allow. Why dont you try to build in Uttar pradesh or Bihar then talk about it.
India will forever remain in planning stage, whereas China has already built and is using thorium power plant to generate energy.
Coal is the greenest fuel and nuclear is a swindle!
The gujrati man is real deshbhakt who started company in usa and not here.
Thorium fuel is not an Indian innovation. USA first used it. Then switch to Uranium reactors to produce energy as well as materials for its nuclear arsenal. China now already has an operational Thorium-molten salt reactor.
nuclear did you say?
lead the world, dear India! lead the world! buona fortuna!! BUT...why did that Indian Innovators have to Start-UP in the USA?!! Why NOT in his India? I'm in SW FL, USA, and know nothing, but is India's Innovative StartUPs support institutions NOT offering such Innovators the Appropriate Investment strategies? Fix THAT, too, Indian-friends!! And...use ActCAD (Andhra Pradesh) instead of AutoCAD :-) I do NOW!! Support excellent made-in-India CAD software Companies!!!
India is still hard place to have start ups. Crony capitalism rules Indian culture. Example, Ambani's and Adani's.
I don't understand how on earth is nuclear fuel branded clean by every one on this earth....WHAT ABOUT THE NUCLEAR WASTE?are you planning to dump them in the sea or do you need bunkers to store them for years to come?
Yes. King cobra is the safest cobra 😅
Germanyandchinahascrackedthethoriumsaltnuclearreactorsandkeralahassomeofthelargestthoriumreservesintheworld
it could have happen only in united states
Are you sure ??????
It's all great news because we've been hearing about thorium reactors for decades now but nothing to show for it.
By the way, the fake interview wasn't very professional.
I sent him questions and asked him to send me back recorded answers. If that is 'fake', ok.
Nuclear is "clean & green" energy??? woh!! why not build ANEEL is US first if it is so cheap??? NTPC is building 600 MW solar plant with just Rs 1700 crores. What is the cost of nuclear power plant for same power? Atleast 18,000 crores. And how many year it takes to build?? 8-10 years!! India has abundant solar & hydro energy & is cheap, clean.
Don't forget NTPC's 600 MW for Rs 1,700 crore will need coal continuously which has to be paid for. As for solar and hydro, we need them too, obviously.
So we export our Thorium to America(which happens either way illegally) and import a finsihed and expensive product to fuel our enrgy needs?
Sounds fishy to me.
This is the oldest game played on India. Was India not exporting iron ore and importing high quality steel?
Hope he is not a scammer?
Aneel fule?😂😂😂😂
Bullshit claim.
Why that irritating click sound?
At which point? I'd be grateful if you could point it out, so that we can avoid it in future.
Wonderful news Thank you Sir