The Marxists were in charge of writing history in the last 70 years. Romila Thapar besides being a leftist was also a Christian. Irfan Habib another leftist was also a Muslim. The other guy Harbans Mukhia wrote, "The world citizens have to decide and choose one of the three:Christianity, Islam or Socialism." Clearly he presaged the disappearance of Hindus. That is scary. JNU hijacked our Grand Narrative. The great writers like Kalidas are rarely read in India. The great languages of India are in the danger of extinction. These tragedies are the result of these historians who should be made to answer for telling us lies. The dates given for events are to be reevaluated. The Aryan Invasion Theory has to be abandoned. In none of our books, Vedas, Upanishads, Ramayana, Mahabharata the word "aryans" is mentioned as a noun, nor is Dravidian. Arya is mentioned as an adjective. In Gita, the word "arya" is mentioned just once in the second chapter as an adjective. Max Muller was wrong in writing our history without evidence. Aryan is a Persian usage. It is also German. Dravidian is not a word in our books. It is Dravid. Brahmins speaking Gujarati, Maharashtra, Telugu, Tamil, Karnataka are called pancha Dravids (Rajatarangini, by Kalhana, 12th century). ADi Sankara described himself as "dravida sisuvu". In the Vemulavada region of Telangana there is a sect of Brahmins called "dravids." "Dravidians" was coined by British to divide and rule. The Justice Party took that concept and popularized. Rig Veda date is wrong. We have to accept Aryabhatta's date for Kaliyuga Feb 18, 3012. This was accepted in 1822 by John Playfair and Jean Sylvain Bailly. Bible and its followers changed it all pushing the date of Rig Veda to 15th century BCE. Our concept of cyclical time was replaced by Biblical linear time. This has to be changed. Jacoby gave a date of 6000 BCE for Rig Veda. Now the NASA gave a date of 7000 for Ram Setu after they determined it was built by Rama. The orientalists wrote a racist interpretation of Indian history. Edward Said wrote clearly the racist attitudes of orientalists in his book "Orientalism". Indians let orientalists write our history and suffered the consequences of lies and more lies. We should take it back and write our own Grand Narrative. Enough of Christians, Muslims and Marxists writing lies and presenting them as our history. Again Our Grand Narrative should be written by us- Sawdeshi Indology.
Follow the indian tradition is an option but it should be aware by all indian students....why media not questioning convent schools insists western culture and christian prayer to all students of school regardless of religion
जब इंसान अपना मानसिक संतुलन खो बैठे और पूर्वाग्रह के साथ ही बात करे तो उनसे किसी प्रकार का विचार विनिमय का अर्थ है - "अंधे के आगे रोये और अपनी अखियाँ खोये!" यही दशा इस समय इन कट्टर वादियों की है! *”अगर माँस खाना अच्छा समझते हो तो खुलकर खाओ। बुरा समझते हो तो मत खाओ; लेकिन अच्छा समझना और छिपकर खाना यह मेरी समझ में नहीं आता। मैं तो इसे कायरता भी कहता हूँ और धूर्तता भी, जो वास्तव में एक है।“ - मुंशी प्रेमचंद
This Batra has so many factual errors: 1. Pope never said "I have come to sell my own soap" or anything similar. I'm sure Pope Francis will agree with the principle of "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam" if he's asked, considering how liberal he is. 2. Germany do hue, par ab ek hai - okay. But Korea abhi bhi do hi hai. Mr. Batra said Korea do the, ab ek hai. In any case, there is a fallacy in comparing homogeneous cultures like the German and the Korean with the diverse Indian sub-continent. India was, unfortunately, divided on religious lines. Both Germany and Korea were purely on political lines between USSR and USA as their post-war loot. 3. At 15:30 , Mr. Batra mentioned Aruna Roy and Ors. v. Union of India (2002), a case decided by the Supreme Court. I have read the judgement (available here: indiankanoon.org/doc/509065/). It is only a petition against a University for including the teachings of Guru Nanak in the syllabus. The court said that it is upto the affiliated colleges to decide if they want to include the Guru's teachings or not. It only said that there is no prohibition in such teachings. Mr. Batra claims that the judgement says that "until the cultural pride is taught, the education is incomplete". I cannot find anything on those lines. At least stop lying in the name of the Supreme Court, please? Mr. Batra is mixing up his imaginary cultural territories and geography. Indian subcontinent (as a tectonic plate) is a distinct geographical entity which merged with the Eurasian tectonic plate. And this Indian plate currently has not just India, but also, Myanmar, Pakistan, Bangladesh, etc. But to say that Indian culture as existed some 2000 years ago was spread over these areas and hence should be one entity today is absurd. There was no idea of "India" until the British came and colonised it. If you want to stick to the extent of British India, then where did Tibet and Nepal come from? They were never a part of British India anyway. Afghanistan was hardly under direct British rule. Burma was divorced from British India in 1935. A better way would be to teach our children about the diversity this land possesses. We are the land of Tulsidas, of Kabir, and of Amir Khusrav. We have had so many different cultures in one. There is nothing called "one Indian culture". There are thousands of them. Embrace that. Maybe then, you'll realize that it is futile to draw Afghanistan as a part of your "Akhand Bharat" and focus more on what cultures exists in our own territory of North-Eastern States.
Beautiful brother... these are the exact thinking lines on which proud Indians like you and me should think... only then shall the sacrifice of millions be fruitful
If you don't know the history of India plz read about it...... don't spread your lack of knowledge here..... Afghanistan and Iran upto Isfahan and from there to entire south East Asia , Indonesia, even Vietnam was part of Indian cultura and civilizationall entity ..... Meaning of Indonesia is india island .....it's true that India as a modern nation is only 70 yrs old but as a civilizational entity it encompasses the whole south East Asia......hence you must distinguish between India as a political and a civilizational entity ...and I don't agree with any of Mr Batra's arachic n rigid views
Mahabharat (Myanmar to Chabahar) is much less diverse than your Muslim Ummah. But you and your fellow Indian muslims would any day prefer to be a part of the Ummah than India - even ask Saudi to attack India to save Kashmir - openly promoted by Pakistan and secretly wished by Indian muslims.
Prof. Apoorvanand is just brilliant. On d contrary, Batra Sahab (d leading academician of RSS) says, "korea do the, ek ho gaye...". This speaks about over all standard of RSS knowledge base. Akhand Bharat??? smells Nazi. Stop saffronization of education and save ur child's future
रविश जी मैं आपका program को बिशेष रूम से नियमित देखता हु और धन्यवाद देता हुँ आपको और दीनानाथ बत्रा जिको भी धन्यवाद देता हुँ अकल्पनीय सपना देखने के लिए जो इस उमर मे मोदी जी भी देखरहे है सपना देखना बुरीबात नहीं है
Sir,Remove history and geography from exams.A chartered accountant or a doctor has nothing to do with history and geography.A farmer or a factory worker or a techie has nothing to do with history or geography.School children are being taxed unnecessarily.These subjects need not have exams at all.If one is interested he will read himself.Instead teach children-how to behave with every one in a decent manner.How not to throw things in public places.Why plastics are dangerous.How not to waste water.how not to waste food or eatables.How to do water conservation,How and Why to plant trees.How to use roads and public transport,why not to waste any thing including paper.How and why to be punctual.etc.These are things essential for a civilised home,society,state and county.Not knowing these -what the hell is he going to do with Akbar or Baber or lord Clive ? Education department should sit and think SERIOUSLY.
Social sciences : History Literature Economics make a complete and mature person.We will remain factory hospital or office workers (robots )without a basic liberal education .Therefore an American fifth grader is today better than local MA Mtech orMS.Hence our compulsion to go as migrant worker (legal or illegal)to USA UK GERMANY.
आज जब मैं इन वामपंथीयों के बौद्धिक किले ढहते हुए देखता हूँ तो बहुत तरस आता है इनपर। ये अपनी विद्वता के अहंकार की पुष्टि भारतीय सरल चेतना की खिल्ली उड़ा कर करते हैं फिर वे उसे बेचते हैं।
कितना झूठ बोलोगे जो आज का राज्य है वो भी कभी एक पृशासनिक इकाई नही रहा गर्व करने से किसका फायदा होगा? मनुष्य के 5 शत्रुओ मे अंहकार एक महत्वपूर्ण भाग है।
Vishnu Sharma Aapki jaankari ke liye bata dun ki Japan east mein hai but wo completely "westernized" hai - in the sense that practically there is little difference between Japan and US. So, Ravish is bang on point.
@@smallbeginnings3497 but today youths are forgetting because our children are thought to praise invaders and hate Indian culture in our education system?
The Indian Batra must be asked about the cultural differences on account of the caste system within the country, have we exported our hatred towards the lower castes too outside India? Is hatred of lower castes a cultural achievement of the Indian culture ? Has Manuvadi thinking done good in the outside world ? Ask Batra how can he reduce hatred among the upper castes towards lower castes ? Ask him, by what time frame he will commit that upper castes will stop raping women?
Indian Hindu culture main aisa kaya he His or proud feel kiya jaye or students ko padaya have castism Dropadi pandwas one wife of all brothers Ram n Rawan battle. Rams waner sena cow is God mother war between Shiva Ganesh father n son not biological funny stories keep it up
भारतीय सभ्यता और संस्कृति पर गर्व केवल एक बोल मात्र है । तनिक सत्यता के धरातल पर उतर कर ईमानदारी से चिन्तन करें तो खान-पान , रहन-सहन, वेशभूषा में भारतीयों ने अधिकांशतः पाश्चात्य सभ्यता संस्कृति को अंगीकार कर लिया है । भारतीय सभ्यता संस्कृति का गुणगान केवल भाषणों तक सिमित है , वास्तविक रूप में लगभग पूर्णतः अप्रचलित तथा अप्रासंगिक है। बत्रा जी एक पूर्वाग्रहित , संकुचित, पाखण्डपूर्ण मानसिकता से ग्रस्त हैं। देशवासियों को पाखण्डियों के महिमा मंडन के लिए पूरी तरह प्रशिक्षित करने का एक अभियान इस लिए भी चलाया जा रहा है ताकि पाखण्डियों के प्रति लोग असहिष्णु न बन पायें और पाखण्ड से लाभ अबाध रूप से अर्जित किया जाता रहे।
There is nothing wrong in a Akhand Bharat and Sanskrutk Bharat .Greek and Roman cultural influence can be found in Europe/Asia though political boundaries of countries within it are different. Anchor is not able to grasp.
We should be working for a Asian union or United states of Asia . Common Asian currency is also a way forward. Ravish kumar basically a practical and daring journalist. He is the # in Asian community of journalists. Actually he is a gem of journalism And a diplomatic treasure. His colleague is also most valuable.
Yes our previous History was written by Mughals and Britishers( Non Indians). Now Indians have to rewrite the history and bring back the lost prideof India.
If we don't get caught up in the details, the broad argument of Shri Dinanath Batra appears to be right. If Indian history books using rigorous scholarship highlight the commonality of thought and philosophy among these nations, that can only strengthen the bonds between them. Such a thing has to be done acknowledging and respecting the political identity of those other nations.
How will any Pakistani make an Akhand Pakistan (or so) Map, when it never existed before 1947!! It's a Historical Reality that Akhand Bhaarat was broken into many Countries, at different points of time...
Hello Ravish Kumar! In parallel why not you do the programs in English? Many people do not understand Hindi(outside India). Although I don't know good Hindi, but your Hindi is very clear to me than others. Maybe some words I don't understand , but that is ok.
Ramanujam Narayan accha Whatsapp University wali history sahi h wah re bhadve IT Cell wah
7 ปีที่แล้ว +9
There is no record of St thomas visiting India in any of the western text. Its more of a missionary propaganda to convert. They have successfully done it in Kerala
Batra ji- if you are in for unity, please stop mob lynching,eliminate caste-ism. this will help shape better India than glorifying Akhand Bharat. First human was born in Africa. Everyone moved in different time period.
In the past I had not disliked this anchor despite him being an Ndtv anchor. But this program left an indelible mark as highly biased against Batra and his viewpoint. When he couldn't refute Batra based on substance, used innuendo, sarcasm and pointless bias to castigate as archaic and hegemoniastic
if Pakistan and Bangladesh declares to unite with India ,modi and bhagwat will soon join neerav modi as early as possible RSS is a cultural organization you know yes we want a united and unified India
Pradeep D.H. Pakistan map is the same with Indian kashmir. Both countries have lost connection with actual people in that region and are thirsty for power. Sanity should prevail.
Dekho jese ye rss ka dara hua betha he usi prakar cmt krne bale bhi pagla gaye he.ye logical bate he pade likhon ke smjh me ayegi.yaha rss ki manobegyanic soch ni chalti
It don't criticise Hinduism you moron. Even budha himself was an Hindu and his disciple after 300-400 years after his death created this religion. He himself never ask anyone to be a Buddhist as there is no such religion.
आदरणीय रवीश जी आपने दीनानाथ बत्रा जी जैसे लोगों को अपने कार्यक्रम में बुलाकर और उनके संगठन का पक्ष रखने का जो मौका दिया है इससे दीनानाथ बत्रा जी चर्चा में आकर और अपना परिचय देकर जो स्वार्थ हासिल किया है उसमें बत्रा जी और उनका संगठन आपका दुरुपयोग करने में सफल हुआ है जो अच्छा नहीं हुआ है
Ravish Sir, why no news channel are talking about India-Myanmar Border issue in Manipur... Is Manipur less important than Kashmir or Arunachal? I request you to kindly raise this issue through ur channel.
There is no need to merge these countries because they were divided to remain free with their own law and order. Today we just need to unite these countries and make a super friendly relations between all these countries from Afghanistan to Indonesia and help each other in development, Trade, tourism, industrialization, transport, natural calamities etc. We should make without visa-passport traveling to these countries with only a valid ID card like we have with Nepal and Bhutan.
mr Ravish doesn't understand the concept of oneness. that his guest is explaining. it has nothing to do with the clothes or food of the birthday celebration. . it is a matter of unity in the country.
संस्कृति आदमी के लिए है , आदमी संस्कृति के किये नही , दीनानाथ बत्रा सिर ढके बिना आये है , जब कि 100 साल पहले सिर ढके बिना घर से बाहर नही निकलना चाहिए इस तरह की संस्कृति रीति रिवाज थे ।
Not a good idea by the anchor in attempting to outsmart his guests. Please learn to engage them in a way that viewers can benefit more from their contribution rather than constant disruption which does not look good for the program a neither to me a viewer.
वाह! दीनानाथ जी बेहतरीन।पूरे डिबेट में रविश और अपूर्वानंद कोई अच्छा तर्क रखने की बजाय बस लफ्फाजी करते दिख रहे हैं।ये दोनों दीनानाथ जी की बातों को समझ ही नहीं पा रहे हैं।
पांडे जी, लेकिन जनता दीनानाथ बत्रा की छोटी सोच और भाजपाई ऐजेन्डे को समझने मे कामयाब रही है, बत्रा फिर से बुलाकर लपेटना चाहिए, इस बार तो नंगा होकर गये हैं। ये RSS और भाजपा को नंगा करवा गये।
Yes, it's absolutely necessary to rewrite the true History. Copies of *History books by Romilla Thaper* and associates *can be used as toilet papers* for the same school children. That's the true worth of the Romilla Thaperian version of History.
All stories are needed as employment and business creating excercise for writers , researchers , printers TV and Film It is therefore good to have aseveral versuions of history as that adds to the diversity for market demand and competition
सोच बहुत बड़ी भी है पर ये विचार भौतिकता में बहुत ही कठिन है असम्भव नहीं है वास्तव में ये आध्यात्मिकता की सोच है और वो भी त्याग से होता है और इसका निर्माण भी उसी कमी से हुआ बाकियों को छोड़ो अपने ही लोग इसे नहीं समर्थन करेगे हा बापेई तक कुछ हो सकता था वो भी इसलिए की बो त्याग को समझते थे अब हराने कि सोच नहीं है अब ख़तम करने की भावना है ये अपर लेवल से अब लोअर लेवल तक फैल गई है जिससे ये असम्भव लगता है
Apporvanand ne jo kah rahe hain ki Pakistan v sochtà hai ki greater Pakistan ki ek jabardasti kah rahe hai. Is Indian subcontinent mein Hindu sanskriti thi Islamic sanskriti thi nahi greater Pakistan kabhi nahi ban Sakta. Jab Akhand bharat ki baat karte hein ye toh prachin bharat ka satya hai . chankya Akhand bharat ki baat kahi hai
kamal hai apurvanad ji ....bujurg batra ji se puri CBSE ghabra jati hai......matlab man me chor hoga tabhi to ghabrati hogi.....unke pas court me javab dene ko nahi hai kya...sahi javab de ....agar batra ji galat hai to mukadma kharij ho jayega....
Batra surname is of Punjabis and they are most COMMUNAL ! Before 1947 Lala Jagat Nairain Chopra was running a press at Lahore and writing against Muslims and created hatred and Pakistan was created . After 1947 he shifted to Jallandhar , Punjab and started writing against the Sikhs and their Gurus ! He was shot by Sikh youth and now Punjabis /Sikhs are on the verge of creating Khalistan !
Bhutan + Maldives + Nepal + Srilanka + Pakistan +India +Bangladesh =? A golden land there u can live with pride and love. Combination of this entities will reduce security expenditure dramatically. This proposition is for the new lovely generation. At least take this issue once in a week into your casual discussion. Please try to understand why Western countries don’t go for war with each other? And one thing is for sure, it is inevitably impossible for any communal and ultra-nationalist force to lead such huge task. Because both forces are defected by false superiority understanding. But Hinduttiya of Raja Ram Moahan Roy and nonviolent Sufism of Islam can play role as inspiration. Thank u all. QUAMRUL H. SIDDIQUI DHAKA, BNGLDESH.
The Marxists were in charge of writing history in the last 70 years. Romila Thapar besides being a leftist was also a Christian. Irfan Habib another leftist was also a Muslim. The other guy Harbans Mukhia wrote, "The world citizens have to decide and choose one of the three:Christianity, Islam or Socialism." Clearly he presaged the disappearance of Hindus. That is scary. JNU hijacked our Grand Narrative. The great writers like Kalidas are rarely read in India. The great languages of India are in the danger of extinction. These tragedies are the result of these historians who should be made to answer for telling us lies. The dates given for events are to be reevaluated. The Aryan Invasion Theory has to be abandoned. In none of our books, Vedas, Upanishads, Ramayana, Mahabharata the word "aryans" is mentioned as a noun, nor is Dravidian. Arya is mentioned as an adjective. In Gita, the word "arya" is mentioned just once in the second chapter as an adjective. Max Muller was wrong in writing our history without evidence. Aryan is a Persian usage. It is also German. Dravidian is not a word in our books. It is Dravid. Brahmins speaking Gujarati, Maharashtra, Telugu, Tamil, Karnataka are called pancha Dravids (Rajatarangini, by Kalhana, 12th century). ADi Sankara described himself as "dravida sisuvu". In the Vemulavada region of Telangana there is a sect of Brahmins called "dravids." "Dravidians" was coined by British to divide and rule. The Justice Party took that concept and popularized. Rig Veda date is wrong. We have to accept Aryabhatta's date for Kaliyuga Feb 18, 3012. This was accepted in 1822 by John Playfair and Jean Sylvain Bailly. Bible and its followers changed it all pushing the date of Rig Veda to 15th century BCE. Our concept of cyclical time was replaced by Biblical linear time. This has to be changed. Jacoby gave a date of 6000 BCE for Rig Veda. Now the NASA gave a date of 7000 for Ram Setu after they determined it was built by Rama. The orientalists wrote a racist interpretation of Indian history. Edward Said wrote clearly the racist attitudes of orientalists in his book "Orientalism". Indians let orientalists write our history and suffered the consequences of lies and more lies. We should take it back and write our own Grand Narrative. Enough of Christians, Muslims and Marxists writing lies and presenting them as our history. Again Our Grand Narrative should be written by us- Sawdeshi Indology.
Follow the indian tradition is an option but it should be aware by all indian students....why media not questioning convent schools insists western culture and christian prayer to all students of school regardless of religion
@112355361076503250859 They made me pray to jesus in english.
i also went to convent school for ten years ...and they made me do the same...no noise of intolerance was heard..
जब इंसान अपना मानसिक संतुलन खो बैठे और पूर्वाग्रह के साथ ही बात करे तो उनसे किसी प्रकार का विचार विनिमय का अर्थ है - "अंधे के आगे रोये और अपनी अखियाँ खोये!"
यही दशा इस समय इन कट्टर वादियों की है!
*”अगर माँस खाना अच्छा समझते हो तो खुलकर खाओ। बुरा समझते हो तो मत खाओ; लेकिन अच्छा समझना और छिपकर खाना यह मेरी समझ में नहीं आता। मैं तो इसे कायरता भी कहता हूँ और धूर्तता भी, जो वास्तव में एक है।“ - मुंशी प्रेमचंद
बिल्कुल सही कहा आपने, ये बत्रा साहब छोटी सोच के स्वामी हैं।
This Batra has so many factual errors:
1. Pope never said "I have come to sell my own soap" or anything similar. I'm sure Pope Francis will agree with the principle of "Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam" if he's asked, considering how liberal he is.
2. Germany do hue, par ab ek hai - okay. But Korea abhi bhi do hi hai. Mr. Batra said Korea do the, ab ek hai. In any case, there is a fallacy in comparing homogeneous cultures like the German and the Korean with the diverse Indian sub-continent. India was, unfortunately, divided on religious lines. Both Germany and Korea were purely on political lines between USSR and USA as their post-war loot.
3. At 15:30 , Mr. Batra mentioned Aruna Roy and Ors. v. Union of India (2002), a case decided by the Supreme Court. I have read the judgement (available here: indiankanoon.org/doc/509065/). It is only a petition against a University for including the teachings of Guru Nanak in the syllabus. The court said that it is upto the affiliated colleges to decide if they want to include the Guru's teachings or not. It only said that there is no prohibition in such teachings. Mr. Batra claims that the judgement says that "until the cultural pride is taught, the education is incomplete". I cannot find anything on those lines. At least stop lying in the name of the Supreme Court, please?
Mr. Batra is mixing up his imaginary cultural territories and geography. Indian subcontinent (as a tectonic plate) is a distinct geographical entity which merged with the Eurasian tectonic plate. And this Indian plate currently has not just India, but also, Myanmar, Pakistan, Bangladesh, etc. But to say that Indian culture as existed some 2000 years ago was spread over these areas and hence should be one entity today is absurd. There was no idea of "India" until the British came and colonised it. If you want to stick to the extent of British India, then where did Tibet and Nepal come from? They were never a part of British India anyway. Afghanistan was hardly under direct British rule. Burma was divorced from British India in 1935.
A better way would be to teach our children about the diversity this land possesses. We are the land of Tulsidas, of Kabir, and of Amir Khusrav. We have had so many different cultures in one. There is nothing called "one Indian culture". There are thousands of them. Embrace that. Maybe then, you'll realize that it is futile to draw Afghanistan as a part of your "Akhand Bharat" and focus more on what cultures exists in our own territory of North-Eastern States.
Mohammad Asadulla Shareef I agree with everything you said except there is nothing wrong with teaching Guru Nanak Dev Ji
Pope gave orders for , goan inquisition .
Beautiful brother... these are the exact thinking lines on which proud Indians like you and me should think... only then shall the sacrifice of millions be fruitful
If you don't know the history of India plz read about it...... don't spread your lack of knowledge here..... Afghanistan and Iran upto Isfahan and from there to entire south East Asia , Indonesia, even Vietnam was part of Indian cultura and civilizationall entity ..... Meaning of Indonesia is india island .....it's true that India as a modern nation is only 70 yrs old but as a civilizational entity it encompasses the whole south East Asia......hence you must distinguish between India as a political and a civilizational entity ...and I don't agree with any of Mr Batra's arachic n rigid views
Mahabharat (Myanmar to Chabahar) is much less diverse than your Muslim Ummah. But you and your fellow Indian muslims would any day prefer to be a part of the Ummah than India - even ask Saudi to attack India to save Kashmir - openly promoted by Pakistan and secretly wished by Indian muslims.
ब्राह्मण अपनी सँस्कृति को महान मानने को स्वतन्त्र हैं।लेकिन उन्हें दूसरों की संस्कृतियों को विकृत करने का अधिकार नहीं है।
सही कहा आपने
Bilkul bilkul
Modernization without westernization huge respect 👌💐
The subject is not at all about changing the Political Borders today, but to let the country know the real History...
If the history been taught is not factual it should be replaced by fact.
kya baat boli hai apooravanand ji ,,,
this guy Batra was 10 times more decent than both of them, very humble guy:-)
Prof. Apoorvanand is just brilliant. On d contrary, Batra Sahab (d leading academician of RSS) says, "korea do the, ek ho gaye...". This speaks about over all standard of RSS knowledge base. Akhand Bharat??? smells Nazi. Stop saffronization of education and save ur child's future
Ya mr a de and so called intellectual gadha what about germany
Ravishji very good information thanks
sir aap kaha ye sab communist ke pass aa gaye, ye sab bakchodi karne me mahir hai
रविश जी मैं आपका program को बिशेष रूम से नियमित देखता हु और धन्यवाद देता हुँ आपको और दीनानाथ बत्रा जिको भी धन्यवाद देता हुँ अकल्पनीय सपना देखने के लिए जो इस उमर मे मोदी जी भी देखरहे है सपना देखना बुरीबात नहीं है
Sir,Remove history and geography from exams.A chartered accountant or a doctor has nothing to do with history and geography.A farmer or a factory worker or a techie has nothing to do with history or geography.School children are being taxed unnecessarily.These subjects need not have exams at all.If one is interested he will read himself.Instead teach children-how to behave with every one in a decent manner.How not to throw things in public places.Why plastics are dangerous.How not to waste water.how not to waste food or eatables.How to do water conservation,How and Why to plant trees.How to use roads and public transport,why not to waste any thing including paper.How and why to be punctual.etc.These are things essential for a civilised home,society,state and county.Not knowing these -what the hell is he going to do with Akbar or Baber or lord Clive ? Education department should sit and think SERIOUSLY.
Social sciences : History Literature Economics make a complete and mature person.We will remain factory hospital or office workers (robots )without a basic liberal education .Therefore an American fifth grader is today better than local MA Mtech orMS.Hence our compulsion to go as migrant worker (legal or illegal)to USA UK GERMANY.
Among all reporter Ravis is sincere journalists. He work with 100% right.
आज जब मैं इन वामपंथीयों के बौद्धिक किले ढहते हुए देखता हूँ तो बहुत तरस आता है इनपर।
ये अपनी विद्वता के अहंकार की पुष्टि भारतीय सरल चेतना की खिल्ली उड़ा कर करते हैं फिर वे उसे बेचते हैं।
completely disagree with dhinanath batra
He is not dogma-tic. He is luna-tic. There's a difference, Ravish Bhai. Surely you see that.
Hey dude, Nagaland celebrated independence with their own flag on this 14 August. Jhandudaas
Ravish ji, you are the best reporter. God bless you
Dinanath is preserving indian culture and civilization.
कितना झूठ बोलोगे जो आज का राज्य है वो भी कभी एक पृशासनिक इकाई नही रहा गर्व करने से किसका फायदा होगा? मनुष्य के 5 शत्रुओ मे अंहकार एक महत्वपूर्ण भाग है।
ye egoist nahi harami beiman hei dogle bharst
It's mental poperness of the writer
dina nath batra sir hats off to you simply awesome
Prof. Appurvanand ji you are great person.
First keep the existing citizens of Republic of India happy, then go abt preaching such expansion.
What you mean Modernization? Casteism ?????
Comments padh ke aisa lagta hai. All muslims are against Hindu culture. Unfortunate!!
कामेन्ट पढ कर ऐसा लगा मानो भाजपाई ऐजेन्डे को नंगा करवा गये बत्रा जी।
26:30 was the all time best answer to all pseudo secularists...look at them baffled and searching for words to answer
Vishnu Sharma Aapki jaankari ke liye bata dun ki Japan east mein hai but wo completely "westernized" hai - in the sense that practically there is little difference between Japan and US. So, Ravish is bang on point.
Pranay4323 gandu japan still have their culture in their place
@@shivnanda3112 Homogeneity and small size is the reason and who says India have forgotten its culture?
Its lies
@@shivnanda3112 and Gandu is not the etiqque according to our culture you are referring to.
Begin the change from yourself before preaching.
@@smallbeginnings3497 but today youths are forgetting because our children are thought to praise invaders and hate Indian culture in our education system?
Yes, it is necessary to re-write history of India.
History never changed in Present,
You are great mr Ravish Kumar 👌
Ravish kumar is # 1
His opinion goes to the heart of his viewers and just not to the ears
The Indian Batra must be asked about the cultural differences on account of the caste system within the country, have we exported our hatred towards the lower castes too outside India? Is hatred of lower castes a cultural achievement of the Indian culture ? Has Manuvadi thinking done good in the outside world ? Ask Batra how can he reduce hatred among the upper castes towards lower castes ? Ask him, by what time frame he will commit that upper castes will stop raping women?
Indian Hindu culture main aisa kaya he His or proud feel kiya jaye or students ko padaya have castism Dropadi pandwas one wife of all brothers Ram n Rawan battle. Rams waner sena cow is God mother war between Shiva Ganesh father n son not biological funny stories keep it up
भारतीय सभ्यता और संस्कृति पर गर्व केवल एक बोल मात्र है । तनिक सत्यता के धरातल पर उतर कर ईमानदारी से चिन्तन करें तो खान-पान , रहन-सहन, वेशभूषा में भारतीयों ने अधिकांशतः पाश्चात्य सभ्यता संस्कृति को अंगीकार कर लिया है । भारतीय सभ्यता संस्कृति का गुणगान केवल भाषणों तक सिमित है , वास्तविक रूप में लगभग पूर्णतः अप्रचलित तथा अप्रासंगिक है। बत्रा जी एक पूर्वाग्रहित , संकुचित, पाखण्डपूर्ण मानसिकता से ग्रस्त हैं। देशवासियों को पाखण्डियों के महिमा मंडन के लिए पूरी तरह प्रशिक्षित करने का एक अभियान इस लिए भी चलाया जा रहा है ताकि पाखण्डियों के प्रति लोग असहिष्णु न बन पायें और पाखण्ड से लाभ अबाध रूप से अर्जित किया जाता रहे।
स्वर्ग और नर्क को भी नक्शे में शामिल कर दीजिए बत्रा जी ,
Bahut barhiya.
और स्वर्ग नरक के नक़्शे में Rajni Faria को नरक में शामिल करना भूलिए गए नहीं बत्राजी।
There is nothing wrong in a Akhand Bharat and Sanskrutk Bharat .Greek and Roman cultural influence can be found in Europe/Asia though political boundaries of countries within it are different. Anchor is not able to grasp.
Modernisation means to upgrade our own culture by taking good ideas from other cultures. Modernisation doesn't mean to adapt foreign culture.
We should be working for a Asian union or United states of Asia .
Common Asian currency is also a way forward. Ravish kumar basically a practical and daring journalist. He is the # in Asian community of journalists.
Actually he is a gem of journalism
And a diplomatic treasure.
His colleague is also most valuable.
Yes our previous History was written by Mughals and Britishers( Non Indians). Now Indians have to rewrite the history and bring back the lost prideof India.
Very polite person huge respect
Ravish sir batra ji vasudhav kutumbkam wali bat no kaha Tak mante hai.
If we don't get caught up in the details, the broad argument of Shri Dinanath Batra appears to be right. If Indian history books using rigorous scholarship highlight the commonality of thought and philosophy among these nations, that can only strengthen the bonds between them. Such a thing has to be done acknowledging and respecting the political identity of those other nations.
How will any Pakistani make an Akhand Pakistan (or so) Map, when it never existed before 1947!!
It's a Historical Reality that Akhand Bhaarat was broken into many Countries, at different points of time...
How about Thailand Indonesia and Pakistan even ?
Hello Ravish Kumar! In parallel why not you do the programs in English? Many people do not understand Hindi(outside India). Although I don't know good Hindi, but your Hindi is very clear to me than others. Maybe some words I don't understand , but that is ok.
Yes. The present history is totally distorted than the history thought to us in school
Ramanujam Narayan accha Whatsapp University wali history sahi h wah re bhadve IT Cell wah
There is no record of St thomas visiting India in any of the western text. Its more of a missionary propaganda to convert. They have successfully done it in Kerala
Batra ji- if you are in for unity, please stop mob lynching,eliminate caste-ism. this will help shape better India than glorifying Akhand Bharat. First human was born in Africa. Everyone moved in different time period.
In the past I had not disliked this anchor despite him being an Ndtv anchor. But this program left an indelible mark as highly biased against Batra and his viewpoint. When he couldn't refute Batra based on substance, used innuendo, sarcasm and pointless bias to castigate as archaic and hegemoniastic
if Pakistan and Bangladesh declares to unite with India ,modi and bhagwat will soon join neerav modi as early as possible RSS is a cultural organization you know yes we want a united and unified India
this apurvanand dude is the awsomest troll ever!!
:D
brutus is an honorable man!
:D
Why are PoK and CoK still shown in our maps as part of modern India? Either send the army and capture it or stop creating such confusion.
Pradeep D.H. Pakistan map is the same with Indian kashmir. Both countries have lost connection with actual people in that region and are thirsty for power. Sanity should prevail.
Dekho jese ye rss ka dara hua betha he usi prakar cmt krne bale bhi pagla gaye he.ye logical bate he pade likhon ke smjh me ayegi.yaha rss ki manobegyanic soch ni chalti
Great man Pro. Apirvanand Sir your thoughts is great, great job Ravish sir.......
वर्तमान भारत को संभाल ले ये प्रवक्ता मुंगेरी लाल के हसीन सपना देख रहा है मनुवााद के सड़ी गली ब्वस्था को दुनिया क्यों माने????
akhand bhart me aap iran ko bhi count kare usko kyu nahi karte vo bhi bharat ka hissa tha
WASTE MUCH haan Sahi kha America bhi Akhand Bharat ka hissa tha Europe bhi Bharat ka hissa tha.
WASTE MUCH abe bhangee mulle converted shoodar bhaag jaa pakistan, tere liye hindustan me koi jagah nhi
Afghanistan bhi India ka hissa tha usko bhi akhand Bharat kaho
भारत ने ब्राह्मण सँस्कृति को कभी स्वीकार नहीं किया।
buddhism neither does rely on hinduism nor a part of a it. on the other hand it contradicts and criticise the hinduism.
KAHA PADA MR. VICEROY MENTALETY. BODH OR JAIN KI KOI BOOK PEDLE PAHLE BHAI LAGJEGA PATA.
It don't criticise Hinduism you moron. Even budha himself was an Hindu and his disciple after 300-400 years after his death created this religion. He himself never ask anyone to be a Buddhist as there is no such religion.
Budhisim is a Subset of Sanatan Dharma.
Apoorvnand aap to jabardast hai
Suitable title would be "the roast of a right-winger fanatic"!🤣
Ravish g, dil khush ho jata hai aapka program sun kar. Aisa lagta hai Geo News Ka capital talk chal raha hai.
Ravish bhai u r the best journalist in india.
to imagine, there is no limits
approva sir ur excellent
Shyla S ur right
Please Do Repeat TeleCast, of All Important, PrimeTime Report of Ravish Kumar
बाकी चाहे जो भी हो पर बत्रा जी निर्दोष हैं😀😀
Apurvaji ko bat karne dijiye, please. Please bring him again because this time you've not given him more time
Who will rewrite history
आदरणीय रवीश जी आपने दीनानाथ बत्रा जी जैसे लोगों को अपने कार्यक्रम में बुलाकर और उनके संगठन का पक्ष रखने का जो मौका दिया है इससे दीनानाथ बत्रा जी चर्चा में आकर और अपना परिचय देकर जो स्वार्थ हासिल किया है उसमें बत्रा जी और उनका संगठन आपका दुरुपयोग करने में सफल हुआ है जो अच्छा नहीं हुआ है
सर, जनता इनके भाजपाई ऐजेन्डे को भी समझ गई है, ये भी तो देखिये ।
Ravish Sir, why no news channel are talking about India-Myanmar Border issue in Manipur... Is Manipur less important than Kashmir or Arunachal? I request you to kindly raise this issue through ur channel.
Ky hai ye sab........stupidity.......... Outdated hai .....English medium school chaihiye but happy birthday wala wish nehi chahiye.....wa wa wa
Hum ghaas khane ko tayar hai, lekin POK wapas chahiye
There is no need to merge these countries because they were divided to remain free with their own law and order.
Today we just need to unite these countries and make a super friendly relations between all these countries from Afghanistan to Indonesia and help each other in development, Trade, tourism, industrialization, transport, natural calamities etc. We should make without visa-passport traveling to these countries with only a valid ID card like we have with Nepal and Bhutan.
From where you have cought and brought this man i believe he is from MARS OR JUPITER VERY INTERESTING
😁
INDIAN SUBCONTINENT AND REPUBLIC OF INDIA ARE TWO DIFFERENT THINGS! I AM NEITHER AN INDIAN NOR A HINDU BUT I THINK MR. BATRA IS RIGHT.
How Mr. Batra is right?
India was divided into more than 600 states under as many rulers.
Hindus and Buddhists were fighting for thousands of year. if the religions were same why were they fighting.
संघी बौरा गए हैं।।
jhoothe gappodi lutere ayyash dhomgiyon ka gang hei
Germany 2 the ek hogaye toh samjha par korea bhi 2 the ek hogaye?? Yeh samajh nahi aaya🤔 time 32:25
There were 2 germanies after ww2 east occupied by communist Soviet Union and west occupied by US
mr Ravish doesn't understand the concept of oneness. that his guest is explaining. it has nothing to do with the clothes or food of the birthday celebration. . it is a matter of unity in the country.
संस्कृति आदमी के लिए है , आदमी संस्कृति के किये नही , दीनानाथ बत्रा सिर ढके बिना आये है , जब कि 100 साल पहले सिर ढके बिना घर से बाहर नही निकलना चाहिए इस तरह की संस्कृति रीति रिवाज थे ।
अखण्ड भारत इनका पॉलिटिकल प्रोपेगण्डा है।
Not a good idea by the anchor in attempting to outsmart his guests. Please learn to engage them in a way that viewers can benefit more from their contribution rather than constant disruption which does not look good for the program a neither to me a viewer.
First speaker has gone mad. I am from Bangladesh and I love to be independent.
वाह! दीनानाथ जी बेहतरीन।पूरे डिबेट में रविश और अपूर्वानंद कोई अच्छा तर्क रखने की बजाय बस लफ्फाजी करते दिख रहे हैं।ये दोनों दीनानाथ जी की बातों को समझ ही नहीं पा रहे हैं।
पांडे जी, लेकिन जनता दीनानाथ बत्रा की छोटी सोच और भाजपाई ऐजेन्डे को समझने मे कामयाब रही है, बत्रा फिर से बुलाकर लपेटना चाहिए, इस बार तो नंगा होकर गये हैं।
ये RSS और भाजपा को नंगा करवा गये।
Bhaiya ravish kumar ji aap jabardast hai.plz mere comment pe like kar dijiye
Yes, it's absolutely necessary to rewrite the true History.
Copies of *History books by Romilla Thaper* and associates *can be used as toilet papers* for the same school children. That's the true worth of the Romilla Thaperian version of History.
All stories are needed as employment and business creating excercise for writers , researchers , printers TV and Film It is therefore good to have aseveral versuions of history as that adds to the diversity for market demand and competition
सोच बहुत बड़ी भी है पर ये विचार भौतिकता में बहुत ही कठिन है असम्भव नहीं है वास्तव में ये आध्यात्मिकता की सोच है और वो भी त्याग से होता है और इसका निर्माण भी उसी कमी से हुआ बाकियों को छोड़ो अपने ही लोग इसे नहीं समर्थन करेगे हा बापेई तक कुछ हो सकता था वो भी इसलिए की बो त्याग को समझते थे अब हराने कि सोच नहीं है अब ख़तम करने की भावना है ये अपर लेवल से अब लोअर लेवल तक फैल गई है जिससे ये असम्भव लगता है
Apporvanand ne jo kah rahe hain ki Pakistan v sochtà hai ki greater Pakistan ki ek jabardasti kah rahe hai. Is Indian subcontinent mein Hindu sanskriti thi Islamic sanskriti thi nahi greater Pakistan kabhi nahi ban Sakta. Jab Akhand bharat ki baat karte hein ye toh prachin bharat ka satya hai . chankya Akhand bharat ki baat kahi hai
kamal hai apurvanad ji ....bujurg batra ji se puri CBSE ghabra jati hai......matlab man me chor hoga tabhi to ghabrati hogi.....unke pas court me javab dene ko nahi hai kya...sahi javab de ....agar batra ji galat hai to mukadma kharij ho jayega....
Sorry sir jee main bhi chahta hoon ki ASIA poora milkar UNITED STATES OF AMERICA ki tarah REUNITED STATES OF ASIA banna chahiahiyye
Batra surname is of Punjabis and they are most COMMUNAL ! Before 1947 Lala Jagat Nairain Chopra was running a press at Lahore and writing against Muslims and created hatred and Pakistan was created . After 1947 he shifted to Jallandhar , Punjab and started writing against the Sikhs and their Gurus ! He was shot by Sikh youth and now Punjabis /Sikhs are on the verge of creating Khalistan !
Bhutan + Maldives + Nepal + Srilanka + Pakistan +India +Bangladesh =? A golden land there u can live with pride and love. Combination of this entities will reduce security expenditure dramatically. This proposition is for the new lovely generation. At least take this issue once in a week into your casual discussion. Please try to understand why Western countries don’t go for war with each other? And one thing is for sure, it is inevitably impossible for any communal and ultra-nationalist force to lead such huge task. Because both forces are defected by false superiority understanding. But Hinduttiya of Raja Ram Moahan Roy and nonviolent Sufism of Islam can play role as inspiration. Thank u all.
QUAMRUL H. SIDDIQUI
DHAKA, BNGLDESH.
why is NDTV against Hindu ?
krishna nitturkar NDTV are rational people
रविश कुमार ये दिखाने की कोशिश करता है की वो बहुत ज्ञानवाला है , हालाँकि आता जाता कुछ नहीं है
Anshul Verma tum ko khuch nahi samajh aata
Bahut sahi mudda uthai hai
यहाँ दो भइओ के बीच जमीन विवाद हो जाये तो वो खत्म नहीं हो पा रहा है और इनको लग रहा है दो देश आपस में मिल जायेंगे
बिल्कुल सही