They are cult... Why did I say that? Kasi sinasabi nila na ang constitution ay parang ginagawa na nilang Biblia na perpekto at wala na dapat baguhin... Dapat baguhin ang constitution dahil nagbabago ang panahon at nagbabago ang pangangailangan Ng Tao at Hindi totoo na pro Filipino ang kasalukuyang constitution dahil Kung totoo Yan dapat Hindi intsik ang nagkucontrol Ng halos lahat Ng negosyo sa bansa.... Mga pagpapakitang Tao Lang at may pinuprotektahan Lang na interest ang mga kumukontra sa pagbabago Ng constitution...ayaw nila na mahaluhan Ng mga negosyante na mga American , European,Koreans ,and Japanese companies Kasi puro intsik ang negosyante dito.... Kasinungalingan at kahypokrituhan ang mga sinasabi na mga senador na nagsasabi na as if mga makafilipino... Gising mga kababayan, kailangan natin ang ibang bansa Hindi Lang ang mga intsik upang magkaroon Ng maayos na trabaho at magandang sahod dito mismo SA loob Ng bansa....huwag pauuto SA mga dating mga justices na nagpasa Ng batas na yan na may butas.... Na pinuprotektahan Ng mga negosyo kuno pero Hindi naprotectahan para SAga tsino
I subscribed to the stand of mr. SONNY AFRICA that restriction is not the hindrance to coming of investors , but it is corruption mentality. DID I GET IT?
Thank you Justice Davide and mendoza azcona for bright openion regarding to the 1987 constitutions.you have enlightened very much to the Filipino people.
I'm not enlightened because if they said that the present constitution is perfect at sinasabi nila pinuprotektahan nito ang ating mga Filipino SA kamay Ng mga dayuhan at Sabi nila businesses must be controlled by Filipinos pero totoo BA yon? Hindi BA controlled by Chinese nationals ang halos lahat Ng negosyo sa ating bansa ngayon? Kung ang sagot mo ay oo...it means Hindi totoo ang kanilang sinasabi at Hindi effective ang kasalukuyang constitution...at ang katutuhanan ay parang ang labas ay ang pinuprotektahan nila ay ang mga negosyo Ng mga intsik Hindi ang mga manggagawang Filipino... Ang labas Nyan ay natatakot sila na Hindi Lang mga tsino kundi papasok ang mga laying amerikano, Europeans, Japanese and Koreans .. Di BA SA ngayon mga intsik at dumadami Narin ang mga Bombay companies , so it means the constitution right now that they claims to protect Filipino companies must controlled by Filipinos dahil Hindi Naman yon nangyari at kahypokrituhan Lang.. gising na bayan... Hindi totoo Yan... KAHIBANGAN yan
Walang mamumuhunan sa pinas , lahat mahal! Tubig! Palagi pang brownout’s! Ang mahal na nga ng kuryente, public wifi waley! Adiktos!At nanunog pa ng gamit ang ibang tiwali pag hindi nabibigyan ng gusto nilang halaga! 3sulat lng sunog lahat pati bakho ! Thanks to all the justices 🙏& this is my opinion
You're all hunghang...the secret to success is not the economic provision but the integrity, honesty and faithfulness by people in government sa kaban ng bayan...
@@youwatch1995 competence, skill and knowledge are learned...but honesty and integrity are not taught...imagine...40% of our annual budget goes to corruption...it is systemic already down the line.
Peoples Initiative- simply means it comes fr the people n not fr congressman, senators, attys, mr. Onate, atty, abad or fr speaker MR….if it s bicameral …it should b approved 1st by both senate n congress before disseminating d info…. for transparency
Sen. Gatchalian, as Justice Azcuna said, one resolution - one subject matter. Listen so that questions will not be repeated - the aged Justices seems annoyed.
What is really the priority of this Gov't Economic Charter change or resolving the ff., smuggling, high power rates, too much corruption, agricultural productivity, creating jobs in the countryside, etc.??? I dont think land ownership is a come on or priority of foreign investors. Does China allow foreigners to own land?
China has different political system and their very own over BILLION population is a natural magnet for FDIs. China is a communist country, so even their own citizens don't own land but only given the RIGHTS to use the land. But what attracts FDIs in China are the huge billion population, stable government, "predictable laws and regulations" and of course China protects ths FDIs, allows 100% FDIs, allows 30% equity on local companies! The 30% alone is a huge profit return from the consumption of over billion population.
Kaya nga gusto baguhin ang constitution para maidadagdag Ng trabaho SA pagpasok Ng maraming investors ..Kaya ayaw nila Ng pagbabago Kasi sila ay corrupt pinuprotektahan nila ang mga negosyo nila , Hindi ang manggagawang Filipino kundi ang kanilang sariling interest... Kaya corrupt mga Yan Kasi mga Chino magagaling SA red tape ...sila ang totoong may control Ng negosyo dito SA bansa...KAHIBANGAN Lang ang sinasabi Ng mga justices na yan na ang kasalukuyang batas layong protektahan ang control Ng mga negosyo sa bansa Ng LAHING Filipino Kasi ang totoo LAHING intsik ang may control... Huwag pauuto SA mga senador na gusto pigilin ang cha cha... Ang cha cha ang makaoabuti SA bansa.... Upang magkaroon Ng desenta at magandang Kita ang mga ordinaryong Tao at Hindi ang mga oligarko na silang mga yumayaman Lang dito SA bansa
"WHATEVER CHANGES ON PROVISION THERE'S POSSIBLE REVISION" - TUTUKAN TALAGA MGA TAO KUNG MAGKAGANON MAN. GOODLUCK PHILIPPINES NAWAY PERSONAL INTEREST DI MATULOY.
EASE OF.DOING BUSINESS. REMOVE THE RESTRICTION. I SUPPORT THE ECONOMIC REFORM. Simple.lang naman kasi yan. Sila-sila lang nagpapagulo. Baguhin na din ang systema ng pagpili ng politiko. PARLIAMENTARY promotes accountability.
Kaya nga sya ang promotor pro bakit wala syang masabi baka nagsusuklay ng begote sa totoo lang parang d bagay..puro matatali o at english speaking cla dyan pro sya naka ulkot ang dila😂😂hay robinhood!
My personal stand is Caldero. . . . Thinking of wife,sons and daughters ? Yes , just like all members of the family are occupying different public elective offices, though living in one house address but on record live on other address to get away from political greed. Right ?
Rep Marcoleta was right when he said that the house offered the senate a hand to meet but the swell headed senate refused or ignored the congress' desire to meet up.
Ayaw Kasi nila na mahaluhan Ng ibang lahi ang mga malalaking negosyo dito.... Kaya puro intsik Lang ang mayayaman SA pinas...Kasi Yong ginawa nilang constitution daw para SA Filipino Kaya Ayan controlled Ng china ang economiya Ng bansa 😂
Sen Risa always questions her allies, if not Africa on this sub committee, its Chel Diokno on the PI Hearing. If you are a true Liberal Politician, you should have pushed a bill against red tape and have pushed for more powerful health reforms that will allow our Seniors and minimum wage earners to have free medicine or at least maintenance as long as they are PhilHealth Members
resolve corruption, boost infra, and resolve any current systemic problem. magsama man kayo or hindi may problema tayo na di kailangan ng change of consti.
Sana po lord kung ano man ang ipagkaloob mo yon po ang mangyayari sa mundong ito wag hahayaan na magtagumpay po ang kasamaan sa mundong ito bigyan nyo pong tuldok ang mga kurakot sana po proteksyonan nyo po kami sa mga taong ganid sa kapangyarihan at katungkolan wag nyo pong hayaan na magtagumpay ang kasamaan sa mundong ito maghari po kayo lalo na dito sa pilipinas kahit nasa ibat iba man kami religion po kami ikaw lang po naghari sa aming mga puso sana gabayan nyo po ang meeting na ito ikaw lang po ang may alam na nasa puso ng bawat isa .at ang iyong gabay ay lagi namin pinaniwalaan.so lord please guide us
Mas ayaw ng investor ang 60/40 dahil alam nilang makukurap lng din , kaya nga dapat hayaan silang mamuhunan ng buo , pero hndi nila dapat pag aari ng 100%
Corruption is already engrained in most of the govt officials...how to eradicate, is the question. It starts in the family how we raised our children, and children's exposure in a corrupt environment in school and in the community. Sad but that opinion is so true.
That’s what we are expecting.. BATTLES OF The Brain much more of DIFFERENT IDEAS .. not what CONGRESS WAS TRYING TO DO .. by which our Congressmen were just on the money side not for the benefit of our people. Let us VOTE WISELY .. we need intelligent and highly professional.. let us change now our policies and educate our Voters .. let us stop voting for popular brainless legislators .. God Bless the Philippines!
Puno at dulo dito sa corruption ay mababa ang pasweldo natin sa mga manggagawa na dahilan kung bakit walang maipon ang mga ito dahil isang kahig isang tuka ang majority ng mga Manggagawang Pilipino. Taasan ang sahod ng lahat ng mga manggagawa, mula sundalo, pulis, guro at mga trabahanteng Pilipino na i level ito sa antas ng Singapore, Taiwan, or Japan, at sigurado, magkakainteres na magnegosyo sa Pinas ang malalaking mamumuhunan dito dahil mataas ang purchasing power nating mga manggagawang Pinoy. #Senate?
Which comes first, chicken or eggs? You can't increase the salary of public sector workers if the government income (GDP) is limited. Paper money can't just be printed without limits as it will cause inflation! To increase the GDP is by creating jobs. The jobs creation is by FDIs! When jobs are created, more people will pay taxes, so THE GDP WILL INCREASE. When the GDP increases, the government will have sufficient income to increase the salary of government workers.
Mr. Dumdum, chismis lang iyang narinig mo. Support your statements with credible presentation and evidences, like that of Dir. Africa. Talk is cheap ...
They protect the present constitution so that corruption will not stop... Kasi mga intsik magagaling SA red tape Kaya sabi nila Davide and Mendoza businesses must be controlled by Filipinos daw... Wehh d nga... Saan ang controlled by Filipinos d BA controlled by Chinese?
See, the great minds (Constitution Body committee) said may the congress have powers if they (senate/ current administration) make mistake under sections could transition to parliamentary or any government form.
you raise a very good question or point senator rissa, bkit hndi yang nakikita ng mga congresista at ibng senador yung mga maling dpat gawan ng sulusyon na hndi kinakailangan ng pag amyenda ng batas.
What benefit can the proposal to liberalizing the education and advertising sector create or positively affect the whole economic picture of the country?
Education siguro malaki kasi Unang una yung yung filipino student least IQ in asean and asia ata - yung top1 university satin UP is not even in top 100 or 200 university in the world last year plus marami international student sa pinas - advertising siguro masgaganda na ads ng DOT hahahaha palpak yung love the philippines nila puro stock images ginamit
Liberalizing the education sector means allowing the foreign educational institution to enter the country. Top notch universities on earth have higher degree of ranking, knowledge and expertise than local institutions. That means they will help to increase the caliber of local education which will eventually support the supply of labor seeking the high degree of knowledge, examples are in technical education.
Philippines became the biggest BPO & call center without cha-cha. It's all about the govt creating incentives for foreign investors to set up the right kind of business in the Phil
Yes became, but supposedly mag grow pa Sana if walang restrictions. What happened after that then? Nag expand ba sila? Infact na instead mag expand sila they retain Lang Yung first level customer support/non technical and administrative only, yung the rest they give it to India, Vietnam and other countries. coz of that restrictions. We are better than Vietnam Sana dahil magagaling mga agents natin, but companies decided not to expand, instead, yung other scope of service sa Ibang countries na.
@@villzam Where's your proof that BPO's aren't expanding, and that cha-cha is the reason? You say so many thing with ZERO evidences. BPOs didn't move to India from Phil, but the other way around. India ised to be the largest BPO center even before Philippines even has one. I know that for a fact because I was involved in outsiurcing BPO from US to India & Australia. Philippibes picked took thus business from India because of better incentives as well as better English speakers. India still holds a lead for non-oral BPO, such as writing legal docs, etc because they have better skills
@@leodeldominguiano2162 Many BPO are foreign owned operating under PEZA. But why do prefer BPO to be foreigners that sends their profit outside of Phil? Would it be better if owners are Filipinos so the profit stays in the Philippines? BTW, I'm not fully against majority foreign ownership. For me, it has to be studied carefully & objectively so that in benefits Filipinos and truly contributes to economic development, and not EXPLOITATIONN
Thank to 3 justices remain as part of phil constitution as they recomen ded whiethier or not the 1987 consti is preferble to economic progress of the nation and ❤😅
kaya di umuunlad ang bansa dahil sa mga pulitikong pansarili lanag ang iniisip, ang isang public servant ka dapat iniisip mo ang kapakanan ng bansa at kapakanan ng mamayang pilipino, dapat tayong mga mamamavang pilipino maging matalino po tayo sa susunod na eleksyon wag na natin iboto ang mga pulitikong pansarili lang iniisip at di para bansa ar sa mamamayang pilipino, tingnan nyo yung ibang senador ayaw sa pagbabago sa kaunlaran ng bansa,
United nation pls help pls help help help help help help help ganon den ang ibat ibang bansa nakipaglaban den sela sa bansa nila nagbuwes sela ng buhay para maiahon ang mamayang pilipino sa kaherapan amen
The reason why no investor will come in our country because it is very difficult to secure permit, license and our electricity and water is too high and not consistent at sobrang corrupt ng tao natin sa goberno.
I hate to say these, but the problem lies not with the restrictions of any country's constitutions, such as the Philippines now questioning about but the consistencies and the dependabilities of a long lasting national policies that could persist amidst changes of succeding governments. Governments may come and go, personalities may be elected and be succeded but policies regarding international investments MUST remain as is, otherwise why invest in Philippines if in every national elections rules of investments change over night???
Tinan nyo sa political sciences o itanong mo political analysis kung ano ano meaning ng charter changes people insiatve amendment o provions sasabihn sa iyo yun tamang paggamit ng mga ito
Section 10, Article XII of the Philippine Constitution provides that the Congress must reserve certain areas of investment to Filipinos or to corporations or associations of which at least 60 percent of capital is owned by Filipinos.Jul 23, 2013 Tama lng din.
Hindi ako nag aral ng batas ,gayun din kaunti lang ang nalalaman ko ,ngunit sa part ng deliberation na ito mas naramdaman ko at mas napamahal ako sa ating Bayang Pilipinas ,sa saligang batas ng bayang ito .At proud maging isang Pilipino, Dapat nagkakaisa tayo para sa kapakanan ng mahal nating bansa,bayan at kapwa Pilipino ,.Just love po
Ang inyong talakayan ay para sa inyong personal na iteres lamang. Pwede kayong manatili dyan, alisin ang pork barrel, maniniwala po kami na kayo ay makabayan
Walang economic push unless all Infrastructure are develop. All economic push will be for the benefit of businessman (export/import) not for ordinary people
Karamihan ng Senador, lalo na si Risa Hontiveros, isang opinyon lang gusto marinig, akala ko ba pag-konsulta sa lahat na sector, bakit yung gusto nya lang opinyon ang tinatanong nya at pinapakingan? Democrakrasya or Komonista?
Siguro dahil hindi credible yung responses nya.. If you'll listen sa opening statements or sma mga interjections nya, wala syang data na binibigay to support his statements..
Ang investor kailangan nila ang protection sa batas dahil corruption, stable ang governo sobra sa politics, mawala yong terrorista at kailangan tamang policy hindi pa ibaba ang policies.
I can give a concrete example regarding international investors pouring in some countries like China, Vietnam, Cambodia, or even countries which has some problems of drug mafias and narco politics like Mexico. Have you ever wonder why despite all our fears and biases against those countries still foreign investments into thier economies pouring in??? The answer is these countries have a long lasting FDI or national economic policies. Predictability is the name of the game, without it, forget changing the Philippine Constitution.
Cambodia, China and Vietnam are all with ONE political party states, and a practicing the parliamentary system for creating laws. Hence they have stable government and 100% controlled the politics. That's not the same in case of Philippines. So for Philippines to have predictable policies should trash the bicameral system, adopt the parliamentary system, and well become a communist country too!
@@alma09876 No need for me to elaborate my opinion , I guess we're on the same page here. The only difference is that I don't believe on changing the system as the only solution for the Philippines but just as I have said predictability and stability on policies, both internal and external is a must for an economy to flourish. Corruption exist in any kind of government all around the world, wether you have a communist system like China and North Korea or democratic form of govenment like the Philippines or South Africa as long as your economic policies are unstable no investments will come in.
Well the so called "prosperity of Philippine economy" until 1960s was because the Americans almost controlled 100% the local economy, through the Parity Rights given to them in 1946. It will help again now if the economy is open fully to foreigners. Let the free economic activity works.
This is Big Bruhaha.Justice Mendoza.Acuna and Puno with due respect Sirs why not just do the right thing and let these Lawmakers adopt the proposal.This is a CHALLENGE to the 1987 Constitutional Framers claimed to be perfect but in fact it is imperfect.Father Bernas a good comment that the Framers dont even agreed with the Bicameral and Unicameral mode of ammendments.Provisions and Articles contradict to each other.
51/49 ang poblema napaka TUSO ng mga pinoy ---- while many decent foreign investor are sincere in their investment and commitment their counterpart from the Philippines insidious and CORRUPT and considering our system will favor the local investor foreign investor are at a disadvantage and insecure.
Pinoy sana sila lahat pero bakit english ng english dapat tagalog para maintindihan ng lahat. Gaya ni chiz escudero tagalog talaga ang gamit niya pag nag speech tsk
Kung babaguhin na rin naman constitution Gawin na lang siguromas meritocracy Sana taasan ang qualifications ng mga elected officials atleast college grad, with proven experience (professional not puchu puchu job) Kasi ngang normal na mamayan hirap makahanap ng work tapos politician napaka dali lang mga pasok sa government Kakahiya mga politiko sa pinas lalo mga congress Education siguro malaki effect kasi Unang una yung yung filipino student least IQ in asean and asia ata - yung top1 university satin UP is not even in top 100 or 200 university in the world last year plus marami international student sa pinas - advertising siguro masgaganda na ads ng DOT hahahaha palpak yung love the philippines nila puro stock images ginamit
How is ease of doing business related to the nationality requirements in our Constitution? Sicat is talking nonsense. Ease of doing business is not facilitated because officials deliberately make it difficult for investors to have business permits approved because of corruption, not because the Constitution has nationality requirements in certain industries or economic activities. We don't have to amend or revise the Constitution to make it easy to do business in the Philippines. Foreign investors will come because we have a competitive advantage in certain areas, like infrastructure, quality of labor and strong rule of law, not because we have nationality restrictions.
Sir justice, it is also pro-monopoly, if we will not change the constitution. Change the constitution in a way not to abolish the Senate.And have separate vote to congress.More jobs from the poor communities if we let foreign companies own a land but with Filipino partners.
humihingi agad ako ng pasinsya sa mga gumawa ng batas natin, bakit kasi hndi kaagad nilagyan ng mahigpit na safaguard ang batas? bakit hndi nila nilagay na walang sinu man man ang pwdng gumalaw ng batas kahit amending or revision man yan. just leave it and respect our highest of the land of the law.
Sana senador vellanueva congressman lahat ng presedente ng ibat ibang bansa manalo matalo sa kampanya maebegay paren ang total budjet ng manga pamelya ng trebo trebo sa pilipinas at ibat ibang bansa toloy paren ang legacy united nation pls help pls help help help help help help help
Proponent of Caldera in Taguig? Lack of political will? Because of political dynasty; caldero y caldera, old and young villar. Estrada inside and outside etc. The cause is corruption mentality and justice system. Few for the poor, much to the rich.
Dapat tawag dyan economic provions magdadagdag ka ng batas o magbabawas yan ang nalalagyan ng artikulo o article ang charter changes meaning nyan magpapalit ka ng gobyerno tawag dyan partlymentary goverment apat na uri yan communism democratic federalism o partylism
Tagal ng pinaguusapan yan wala namang nangyayari. Mangangamatay na lang ang mga resource persons wala pa ring napagkasundoan hehehe. Afterall yung framers mismo ng 1987 Constitution ang nagkulang. Ang totoo, they can do it (Senators) among themselves without inviting these personalities. Pag gusto may paraan, pag ayaw maraming dahilan. Nagiipon lang sila ng dahilan para hindi matuloy ang Constitutional Change.
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.83[1/2] เปิดแคมป์หลอนต้อนรับ 2 ตัวพ่อแห่งวงการผี!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2uPuHYHgwiI/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you chief justice Davide , Azcuna & Mendoza for your unending services to the country God bless you all.
These are the men we wanted to be in the Senate, Davide, Azcuna and Mendoza and not the kind of Robin Padilla, Bong Go and Bato dela Rosa. Naka kahiya
They are cult... Why did I say that? Kasi sinasabi nila na ang constitution ay parang ginagawa na nilang Biblia na perpekto at wala na dapat baguhin... Dapat baguhin ang constitution dahil nagbabago ang panahon at nagbabago ang pangangailangan Ng Tao at Hindi totoo na pro Filipino ang kasalukuyang constitution dahil Kung totoo Yan dapat Hindi intsik ang nagkucontrol Ng halos lahat Ng negosyo sa bansa.... Mga pagpapakitang Tao Lang at may pinuprotektahan Lang na interest ang mga kumukontra sa pagbabago Ng constitution...ayaw nila na mahaluhan Ng mga negosyante na mga American , European,Koreans ,and Japanese companies Kasi puro intsik ang negosyante dito.... Kasinungalingan at kahypokrituhan ang mga sinasabi na mga senador na nagsasabi na as if mga makafilipino... Gising mga kababayan, kailangan natin ang ibang bansa Hindi Lang ang mga intsik upang magkaroon Ng maayos na trabaho at magandang sahod dito mismo SA loob Ng bansa....huwag pauuto SA mga dating mga justices na nagpasa Ng batas na yan na may butas.... Na pinuprotektahan Ng mga negosyo kuno pero Hindi naprotectahan para SAga tsino
I subscribed to the stand of mr. SONNY AFRICA that restriction is not the hindrance to coming of investors , but it is corruption mentality. DID I GET IT?
One resolution - one subject matter, ... very clear, Chief Justice Azcuna , thank you 👍sir. A salute to you CJ.
Thank you Justice Davide and mendoza azcona for bright openion regarding to the 1987 constitutions.you have enlightened very much to the Filipino people.
I'm not enlightened because if they said that the present constitution is perfect at sinasabi nila pinuprotektahan nito ang ating mga Filipino SA kamay Ng mga dayuhan at Sabi nila businesses must be controlled by Filipinos pero totoo BA yon? Hindi BA controlled by Chinese nationals ang halos lahat Ng negosyo sa ating bansa ngayon? Kung ang sagot mo ay oo...it means Hindi totoo ang kanilang sinasabi at Hindi effective ang kasalukuyang constitution...at ang katutuhanan ay parang ang labas ay ang pinuprotektahan nila ay ang mga negosyo Ng mga intsik Hindi ang mga manggagawang Filipino... Ang labas Nyan ay natatakot sila na Hindi Lang mga tsino kundi papasok ang mga laying amerikano, Europeans, Japanese and Koreans .. Di BA SA ngayon mga intsik at dumadami Narin ang mga Bombay companies , so it means the constitution right now that they claims to protect Filipino companies must controlled by Filipinos dahil Hindi Naman yon nangyari at kahypokrituhan Lang.. gising na bayan... Hindi totoo Yan... KAHIBANGAN yan
Dir. Africa, thank you for your presentation and credible information. A salute to you, sir.
Sana lang nxt time ng pag boto natin ng congressman at senador sana mga lawyer kakahiya taga gawa ng batas walang alam sa batas
Eh di butas not batas
Vote for technocrats, but not lawyers.
Favorably a lawyer, yes a technocrat particularly in policy making.
We have been talking so much with issues but we have not been making proposals to totally stop corruption. Thanks.
We are in favor of economic provision of our constitution...dont change the longer terms of polpoliticos.
Walang mamumuhunan sa pinas , lahat mahal! Tubig! Palagi pang brownout’s! Ang mahal na nga ng kuryente, public wifi waley! Adiktos!At nanunog pa ng gamit ang ibang tiwali pag hindi nabibigyan ng gusto nilang halaga! 3sulat lng sunog lahat pati bakho ! Thanks to all the justices 🙏& this is my opinion
You're all hunghang...the secret to success is not the economic provision but the integrity, honesty and faithfulness by people in government sa kaban ng bayan...
And how are we going to achieved it in a bad system? System change that encourage leaders to be more honest and competent is what we need
@@youwatch1995 competence, skill and knowledge are learned...but honesty and integrity are not taught...imagine...40% of our annual budget goes to corruption...it is systemic already down the line.
We have every great mind in ceafting laws but we always lack great excutors and principled implementors 2:31
Peoples Initiative- simply means it comes fr the people n not fr congressman, senators, attys, mr. Onate, atty, abad or fr speaker MR….if it s bicameral …it should b approved 1st by both senate n congress before disseminating d info…. for transparency
Sen. Gatchalian, as Justice Azcuna said, one resolution - one subject matter. Listen so that questions will not be repeated - the aged Justices seems annoyed.
What is really the priority of this Gov't Economic Charter change or resolving the ff., smuggling, high power rates, too much corruption, agricultural productivity, creating jobs in the countryside, etc.??? I dont think land ownership is a come on or priority of foreign investors. Does China allow foreigners to own land?
China has different political system and their very own over BILLION population is a natural magnet for FDIs. China is a communist country, so even their own citizens don't own land but only given the RIGHTS to use the land. But what attracts FDIs in China are the huge billion population, stable government, "predictable laws and regulations" and of course China protects ths FDIs, allows 100% FDIs, allows 30% equity on local companies! The 30% alone is a huge profit return from the consumption of over billion population.
Kaya nga gusto baguhin ang constitution para maidadagdag Ng trabaho SA pagpasok Ng maraming investors ..Kaya ayaw nila Ng pagbabago Kasi sila ay corrupt pinuprotektahan nila ang mga negosyo nila , Hindi ang manggagawang Filipino kundi ang kanilang sariling interest... Kaya corrupt mga Yan Kasi mga Chino magagaling SA red tape ...sila ang totoong may control Ng negosyo dito SA bansa...KAHIBANGAN Lang ang sinasabi Ng mga justices na yan na ang kasalukuyang batas layong protektahan ang control Ng mga negosyo sa bansa Ng LAHING Filipino Kasi ang totoo LAHING intsik ang may control... Huwag pauuto SA mga senador na gusto pigilin ang cha cha... Ang cha cha ang makaoabuti SA bansa.... Upang magkaroon Ng desenta at magandang Kita ang mga ordinaryong Tao at Hindi ang mga oligarko na silang mga yumayaman Lang dito SA bansa
"WHATEVER CHANGES ON PROVISION THERE'S POSSIBLE REVISION" - TUTUKAN TALAGA MGA TAO KUNG MAGKAGANON MAN. GOODLUCK PHILIPPINES NAWAY PERSONAL INTEREST DI MATULOY.
EASE OF.DOING BUSINESS. REMOVE THE RESTRICTION. I SUPPORT THE ECONOMIC REFORM. Simple.lang naman kasi yan. Sila-sila lang nagpapagulo. Baguhin na din ang systema ng pagpili ng politiko. PARLIAMENTARY promotes accountability.
kawawang robinhud committee chairman consti amendmnt & revision pero iba ang humawak? bat kasi sya nandyan?
sana tumulong sya sa pamamahagi ng meryenda sa mga bisita ng mapakinabangan
Kaya nga sya ang promotor pro bakit wala syang masabi baka nagsusuklay ng begote sa totoo lang parang d bagay..puro matatali o at english speaking cla dyan pro sya naka ulkot ang dila😂😂hay robinhood!
Kong may hiya si Robin, magresign na lang. Huwag magpanggap marunong. Ang mag panggap marunong ay mabahu pa sa bulok na tahong.
Cherish
My personal stand is Caldero. . . . Thinking of wife,sons and daughters ? Yes , just like all members of the family are occupying different public elective offices, though living in one house address but on record live on other address to get away from political greed. Right ?
Rep Marcoleta was right when he said that the house offered the senate a hand to meet but the swell headed senate refused or ignored the congress' desire to meet up.
Ayaw Kasi nila na mahaluhan Ng ibang lahi ang mga malalaking negosyo dito.... Kaya puro intsik Lang ang mayayaman SA pinas...Kasi Yong ginawa nilang constitution daw para SA Filipino Kaya Ayan controlled Ng china ang economiya Ng bansa 😂
Tao sa Gobyerno ang dapat magbago,, kahit ano ka gandang Consti kung corrupt ang namamahala,, babagsak pa rin tayo
Sen Risa always questions her allies, if not Africa on this sub committee, its Chel Diokno on the PI Hearing. If you are a true Liberal Politician, you should have pushed a bill against red tape and have pushed for more powerful health reforms that will allow our Seniors and minimum wage earners to have free medicine or at least maintenance as long as they are PhilHealth Members
Well, that is not the priority of Risa Hontivirus. What is more important to her is to make grandstanding for the reason of 2025 election.
Thank you Sen Hontiveros for asking people who knows the real facts.
resolve corruption, boost infra, and resolve any current systemic problem. magsama man kayo or hindi may problema tayo na di kailangan ng change of consti.
Dapat unahin ung mga bilihin kc sobra talaga mahal lahat ng mga needs sa isang pamilya. Mabuti pa noon mura pa same nman lahat.
Sana po lord kung ano man ang ipagkaloob mo yon po ang mangyayari sa mundong ito wag hahayaan na magtagumpay po ang kasamaan sa mundong ito bigyan nyo pong tuldok ang mga kurakot sana po proteksyonan nyo po kami sa mga taong ganid sa kapangyarihan at katungkolan wag nyo pong hayaan na magtagumpay ang kasamaan sa mundong ito maghari po kayo lalo na dito sa pilipinas kahit nasa ibat iba man kami religion po kami ikaw lang po naghari sa aming mga puso sana gabayan nyo po ang meeting na ito ikaw lang po ang may alam na nasa puso ng bawat isa .at ang iyong gabay ay lagi namin pinaniwalaan.so lord please guide us
ALISIN ANG CORRUPTION CORRUPTION, CORRUPTION
Investors' hates corrupt officials
Parliamentary system federalismo mawawala na Ang corruption
D na mawala yan curruption? Milliones gasto election hahaha
Mas ayaw ng investor ang 60/40 dahil alam nilang makukurap lng din , kaya nga dapat hayaan silang mamuhunan ng buo , pero hndi nila dapat pag aari ng 100%
Corruption is already engrained in most of the govt officials...how to eradicate, is the question. It starts in the family how we raised our children, and children's exposure in a corrupt environment in school and in the community. Sad but that opinion is so true.
That’s what we are expecting.. BATTLES OF The Brain much more of DIFFERENT IDEAS ..
not what CONGRESS WAS TRYING TO DO .. by which our Congressmen were just on the money side not for the benefit of our people.
Let us VOTE WISELY .. we need intelligent and highly professional.. let us change now our policies and educate our Voters .. let us stop voting for popular brainless legislators ..
God Bless the Philippines!
Regarding the constitution , those who were convicted of crime and in prison charged of felony must not be allowed to vote for life.
Ay nako paano pagasenso sa bansa natin ang nakaupo mga korakot sila ang magmayaman kawawa ang taong bayan
Puno at dulo dito sa corruption ay mababa ang pasweldo natin sa mga manggagawa na dahilan kung bakit walang maipon ang mga ito dahil isang kahig isang tuka ang majority ng mga Manggagawang Pilipino.
Taasan ang sahod ng lahat ng mga manggagawa, mula sundalo, pulis, guro at mga trabahanteng Pilipino na i level ito sa antas ng Singapore, Taiwan, or Japan, at sigurado, magkakainteres na magnegosyo sa Pinas ang malalaking mamumuhunan dito dahil mataas ang purchasing power nating mga manggagawang Pinoy.
#Senate?
Which comes first, chicken or eggs?
You can't increase the salary of public sector workers if the government income (GDP) is limited. Paper money can't just be printed without limits as it will cause inflation!
To increase the GDP is by creating jobs. The jobs creation is by FDIs! When jobs are created, more people will pay taxes, so THE GDP WILL INCREASE. When the GDP increases, the government will have sufficient income to increase the salary of government workers.
Mr. Dumdum, chismis lang iyang narinig mo. Support your statements with credible presentation and evidences, like that of Dir. Africa. Talk is cheap ...
thank you so much cheif justice senate for economic investors businese is good for discusion meeting @
Stop corruption and crime. No charter change.
They protect the present constitution so that corruption will not stop... Kasi mga intsik magagaling SA red tape Kaya sabi nila Davide and Mendoza businesses must be controlled by Filipinos daw... Wehh d nga... Saan ang controlled by Filipinos d BA controlled by Chinese?
See, the great minds (Constitution Body committee) said may the congress have powers if they (senate/ current administration) make mistake under sections could transition to parliamentary or any government form.
Mr. Teves, do you think the foreign investors who plans to invest in our country will not consult local legal experts? What the heck...
Dapat si justice divide ang naging president.i salute you former justice davide.we love that comment of yours
No way. Davide is a certified YELLOW!
you raise a very good question or point senator rissa, bkit hndi yang nakikita ng mga congresista at ibng senador yung mga maling dpat gawan ng sulusyon na hndi kinakailangan ng pag amyenda ng batas.
Davide is still very active very sharp mind
This is maybe the first time that all members of the senate are united in this issue.
Kaya naman sana natin ang investment,in part of economy. Kaso lng sa dami ba naman ng kurakot na nakaupo sa gobyerno?,paano tayo uunlad?
What benefit can the proposal to liberalizing the education and advertising sector create or positively affect the whole economic picture of the country?
Para di ma biktima ng gaya ni tambaloslos
Education siguro malaki kasi
Unang una yung yung filipino student least IQ in asean and asia ata
- yung top1 university satin UP is not even in top 100 or 200 university in the world last year plus marami international student sa pinas
- advertising siguro masgaganda na ads ng DOT hahahaha palpak yung love the philippines nila puro stock images ginamit
Liberalizing the education sector means allowing the foreign educational institution to enter the country. Top notch universities on earth have higher degree of ranking, knowledge and expertise than local institutions. That means they will help to increase the caliber of local education which will eventually support the supply of labor seeking the high degree of knowledge, examples are in technical education.
Philippines became the biggest BPO & call center without cha-cha. It's all about the govt creating incentives for foreign investors to set up the right kind of business in the Phil
Need din baguhin para sa pag unlad
Yes became, but supposedly mag grow pa Sana if walang restrictions. What happened after that then? Nag expand ba sila? Infact na instead mag expand sila they retain Lang Yung first level customer support/non technical and administrative only, yung the rest they give it to India, Vietnam and other countries. coz of that restrictions. We are better than Vietnam Sana dahil magagaling mga agents natin, but companies decided not to expand, instead, yung other scope of service sa Ibang countries na.
@@villzam Where's your proof that BPO's aren't expanding, and that cha-cha is the reason? You say so many thing with ZERO evidences. BPOs didn't move to India from Phil, but the other way around. India ised to be the largest BPO center even before Philippines even has one. I know that for a fact because I was involved in outsiurcing BPO from US to India & Australia. Philippibes picked took thus business from India because of better incentives as well as better English speakers. India still holds a lead for non-oral BPO, such as writing legal docs, etc because they have better skills
I think yung mga BPO filipino parin may ari it's just that they cater to international clients?
@@leodeldominguiano2162 Many BPO are foreign owned operating under PEZA. But why do prefer BPO to be foreigners that sends their profit outside of Phil? Would it be better if owners are Filipinos so the profit stays in the Philippines?
BTW, I'm not fully against majority foreign ownership. For me, it has to be studied carefully & objectively so that in benefits Filipinos and truly contributes to economic development, and not EXPLOITATIONN
Dapat gumawa ng objective, exhaustive, at independent study para malaman kung ano talaga ang ayaw ng foreign investors
Obvious sir na ayaw nila sa 60-40 ownership.
Thank to 3 justices remain as part of phil constitution as they recomen ded whiethier or not the 1987 consti is preferble to economic progress of the nation and ❤😅
kaya di umuunlad ang bansa dahil sa mga pulitikong pansarili lanag ang iniisip, ang isang public servant ka dapat iniisip mo ang kapakanan ng bansa at kapakanan ng mamayang pilipino, dapat tayong mga mamamavang pilipino maging matalino po tayo sa susunod na eleksyon wag na natin iboto ang mga pulitikong pansarili lang iniisip at di para bansa ar sa mamamayang pilipino, tingnan nyo yung ibang senador ayaw sa pagbabago sa kaunlaran ng bansa,
How about jndustrialization policy of the country...we need to industrialize steel electronics micro chip and IT
United nation pls help pls help help help help help help help ganon den ang ibat ibang bansa nakipaglaban den sela sa bansa nila nagbuwes sela ng buhay para maiahon ang mamayang pilipino sa kaherapan amen
The reason why no investor will come in our country because it is very difficult to secure permit, license and our electricity and water is too high and not consistent at sobrang corrupt ng tao natin sa goberno.
I wanna hug Chief Justice Davide 😢
He is a YELLOW, Hug a YELLOW.
I hate to say these, but the problem lies not with the restrictions of any country's constitutions, such as the Philippines now questioning about but the consistencies and the dependabilities of a long lasting national policies that could persist amidst changes of succeding governments. Governments may come and go, personalities may be elected and be succeded but policies regarding international investments MUST remain as is, otherwise why invest in Philippines if in every national elections rules of investments change over night???
Nice
Tinan nyo sa political sciences o itanong mo political analysis kung ano ano meaning ng charter changes people insiatve amendment o provions sasabihn sa iyo yun tamang paggamit ng mga ito
Section 10, Article XII of the Philippine Constitution provides that the Congress must reserve certain areas of investment to Filipinos or to corporations or associations of which at least 60 percent of capital is owned by Filipinos.Jul 23, 2013
Tama lng din.
That's related to the NEGATIVE LIST that Congress amends yearly.
Hindi ako nag aral ng batas ,gayun din kaunti lang ang nalalaman ko ,ngunit sa part ng deliberation na ito mas naramdaman ko at mas napamahal ako sa ating Bayang Pilipinas ,sa saligang batas ng bayang ito .At proud maging isang Pilipino, Dapat nagkakaisa tayo para sa kapakanan ng mahal nating bansa,bayan at kapwa Pilipino ,.Just love po
Ang inyong talakayan ay para sa inyong personal na iteres lamang.
Pwede kayong manatili dyan, alisin ang pork barrel, maniniwala po kami na kayo ay makabayan
Bravo Risa .....
Hinahaluan nu na naman Ng politika, Filipinos are watching, vested interest nangangamoy
Walang economic push unless all Infrastructure are develop. All economic push will be for the benefit of businessman (export/import) not for ordinary people
Sana pinasasagot ung tumaas ung kamay para patas Ang sagutan Hindi iisa lang nag papaliwanag
Karamihan ng Senador, lalo na si Risa Hontiveros, isang opinyon lang gusto marinig, akala ko ba pag-konsulta sa lahat na sector, bakit yung gusto nya lang opinyon ang tinatanong nya at pinapakingan? Democrakrasya or Komonista?
Siguro dahil hindi credible yung responses nya.. If you'll listen sa opening statements or sma mga interjections nya, wala syang data na binibigay to support his statements..
Ang investor kailangan nila ang protection sa batas dahil corruption, stable ang governo sobra sa politics, mawala yong terrorista at kailangan tamang policy hindi pa ibaba ang policies.
I can give a concrete example regarding international investors pouring in some countries like China, Vietnam, Cambodia, or even countries which has some problems of drug mafias and narco politics like Mexico. Have you ever wonder why despite all our fears and biases against those countries still foreign investments into thier economies pouring in??? The answer is these countries have a long lasting FDI or national economic policies. Predictability is the name of the game, without it, forget changing the Philippine Constitution.
Cambodia, China and Vietnam are all with ONE political party states, and a practicing the parliamentary system for creating laws. Hence they have stable government and 100% controlled the politics. That's not the same in case of Philippines. So for Philippines to have predictable policies should trash the bicameral system, adopt the parliamentary system, and well become a communist country too!
@@alma09876 No need for me to elaborate my opinion , I guess we're on the same page here. The only difference is that I don't believe on changing the system as the only solution for the Philippines but just as I have said predictability and stability on policies, both internal and external is a must for an economy to flourish. Corruption exist in any kind of government all around the world, wether you have a communist system like China and North Korea or democratic form of govenment like the Philippines or South Africa as long as your economic policies are unstable no investments will come in.
Sana lahatng pilipno mabigyan ng trabajo. Pero marMing negatibo sa paksang ito.
Well the so called "prosperity of Philippine economy" until 1960s was because the Americans almost controlled 100% the local economy, through the Parity Rights given to them in 1946. It will help again now if the economy is open fully to foreigners. Let the free economic activity works.
This is Big Bruhaha.Justice Mendoza.Acuna and Puno with due respect Sirs why not just do the right thing and let these Lawmakers adopt the proposal.This is a CHALLENGE to the 1987 Constitutional Framers claimed to be perfect but in fact it is imperfect.Father Bernas a good comment that the Framers dont even agreed with the Bicameral and Unicameral mode of ammendments.Provisions and Articles contradict to each other.
Dito mahina si tulfo.
51/49 ang poblema napaka TUSO ng mga pinoy ---- while many decent foreign investor are sincere in their investment and commitment their counterpart from the Philippines insidious and CORRUPT and considering our system will favor the local investor foreign investor are at a disadvantage and insecure.
Andami namin pong mga mahihirap na gustong manouud peru nawawalan nang gana kasi ala kami maintindihan po.
No matter
Pinoy sana sila lahat pero bakit english ng english dapat tagalog para maintindihan ng lahat. Gaya ni chiz escudero tagalog talaga ang gamit niya pag nag speech tsk
Ang suma total dyan Taong Bayan No To Charter Change. Nag-aksaya lang ng pera. Bankarote Kaban gagastos ps sa Cha-Cha.
Di Bale gumastos matuloy lang Ang federal parliamentary para I was corruption
Include the industrialization of Artificial Intelegence please
Paanong pipindot ang manga trebo trebo ng rescue 911walang instelation wiring telephone ang bahay for emergency
Kung babaguhin na rin naman constitution
Gawin na lang siguromas meritocracy
Sana taasan ang qualifications ng mga elected officials atleast college grad, with proven experience (professional not puchu puchu job)
Kasi ngang normal na mamayan hirap makahanap ng work tapos politician napaka dali lang mga pasok sa government
Kakahiya mga politiko sa pinas lalo mga congress
Education siguro malaki effect
kasi
Unang una yung yung filipino student least IQ in asean and asia ata
- yung top1 university satin UP is not even in top 100 or 200 university in the world last year plus marami international student sa pinas
- advertising siguro masgaganda na ads ng DOT hahahaha palpak yung love the philippines nila puro stock images ginamit
Documents
Taohumaya
Perfectua
How is ease of doing business related to the nationality requirements in our Constitution? Sicat is talking nonsense. Ease of doing business is not facilitated because officials deliberately make it difficult for investors to have business permits approved because of corruption, not because the Constitution has nationality requirements in certain industries or economic activities. We don't have to amend or revise the Constitution to make it easy to do business in the Philippines. Foreign investors will come because we have a competitive advantage in certain areas, like infrastructure, quality of labor and strong rule of law, not because we have nationality restrictions.
Person of interest
Ur right ,all of d senate n govt. officer must be a lawyer or statesman...period
Sir justice, it is also pro-monopoly, if we will not change the constitution. Change the constitution in a way not to abolish the Senate.And have separate vote to congress.More jobs from the poor communities if we let foreign companies own a land but with Filipino partners.
hnd na mkkpag explore ng oil ang pilipinas, kapos sa pananalapi at machineries.
Frame? UP.
Pag po ba chinese new year sumasabay ba tayo non?
Ang mga foreign owned ride-hailing apps, ay isang example ng "rent seeking" company, extractive.
dapat po pag ganyan ang usapen nag tatagalog kayo para na eentendehan ng nga pilipino
Wag na maniwala sa mga economics na yan!!!!
humihingi agad ako ng pasinsya sa mga gumawa ng batas natin, bakit kasi hndi kaagad nilagyan ng mahigpit na safaguard ang batas? bakit hndi nila nilagay na walang sinu man man ang pwdng gumalaw ng batas kahit amending or revision man yan. just leave it and respect our highest of the land of the law.
Sana senador vellanueva congressman lahat ng presedente ng ibat ibang bansa manalo matalo sa kampanya maebegay paren ang total budjet ng manga pamelya ng trebo trebo sa pilipinas at ibat ibang bansa toloy paren ang legacy united nation pls help pls help help help help help help help
Bakit putol?
Dapat ganon
Proponent of Caldera in Taguig? Lack of political will? Because of political dynasty; caldero y caldera, old and young villar. Estrada inside and outside etc. The cause is corruption mentality and justice system. Few for the poor, much to the rich.
Dapat tawag dyan economic provions magdadagdag ka ng batas o magbabawas yan ang nalalagyan ng artikulo o article ang charter changes meaning nyan magpapalit ka ng gobyerno tawag dyan partlymentary goverment apat na uri yan communism democratic federalism o partylism
Doctrine?
Kompadre pakelagay nalang yung krus sa tabe ng kabaong nakekeramay ang sandatahang lakas ng pangkapayapaan
San si Robin? Wala ba siyang tanong?
Wag na maniniwala dian sa mga sinungaling gian sa malacanyang!!!!
Abacada
Hayst.bkit itong mga top brass people didnt mention about corruption kaya walang investor n pumapasok..nkakasukang makinig
we can if wala lang jud kurakot. 😔
Tagal ng pinaguusapan yan wala namang nangyayari. Mangangamatay na lang ang mga resource persons wala pa ring napagkasundoan hehehe. Afterall yung framers mismo ng 1987 Constitution ang nagkulang. Ang totoo, they can do it (Senators) among themselves without inviting these personalities. Pag gusto may paraan, pag ayaw maraming dahilan. Nagiipon lang sila ng dahilan para hindi matuloy ang Constitutional Change.
And sad to say, the one who invent intel chip is a Filipino. Now owned by American. It's not too late, invest also for Filipino inventor.