Why a Trump presidency could see Putin defeated in Ukraine | Niall Ferguson
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 พ.ค. 2024
- “It's far from clear to me that they’ll pull the plug on support for Ukraine, they might actually step up support for Ukraine.”
A Trump reelection will not be “massively disastrous” as he could step up aid to Ukraine, says historian Niall Ferguson.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.co.uk/radio
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.co.uk/subscribe/...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.co.uk/radio/how-...
This guy doesn't know a thing! GOP held up funding for Ukraine.
Are you at all familiar with what the GOP wanted in exchange for funding Ukraine? No? Then perhaps you should do some research first.
Joe Biden could have had GOP support on Ukraine aid rather easily, but he refused to agree to do his job defending US borders.
Yes, and Trump was most likely one of the main people behind it! My opinion of Ferguson has gone down watching this.
I'm guessing you don't know WHY the GOP held up funding for Ukraine?
This is why they put fools like him on its embarrassing
He's either being a nefarious liar or he's a genuine idiot.
Yes, Trump could defeat Putin in Ukraine. And pigs could fly too.
😂😂😂😂So true
Who is this Bloke ?
He's either being a nefarious liar or he's a genuine idiot.
Fun fact: Trump is currently the only US president under who’s watch Putin didnt dare to invade a neghbor.
@@moonbus1743 Far from deterring Putin, Trump did the opposite. Thanks to Trump, Putin was able to take advantage of a period of apparent detente during which Trump actually pursued Putin’s own policies of weakening NATO and democracy and destabilizing the West - leaving Putin free to prepare his war against the free people of Ukraine and their democratically elected government.
-Politico
Trump would step up support for Ukraine? Someone please check Niall's meds he must be skipping doses.
He has just become another right wing dbag. The whole right wing thinktank apparatus is just focused on how to spin everything into 'Trump is the best", because he is the only GOP candidate who can garner enough votes to make an election close enough to steal, and the Billionairs who fund the right want total control so that is what they have gone with. If the billionaires who run the GOP were opposed to Trump...his campaign would collapse. The message would get sent to Murdoch, and anyone who didnt toe the line would get cut off from funding, and they need the billionaires because Trump hoovers up the small donors and uses it to pay his legal bills.
Yeah that is beyond ridiculous
Don't confuse conventional wisdom among the chattering classes with reality.
Perfect response. Trump would make a deal with Putin to sell out Ukraine.
Trump will be a better friend to Ukraine than Biden. Two points, Trumps sanctions against Russia were a lot more severe than Bidens….Biden lifted the sanctions against Nordstream before the invasion. And, Biden has helped Ukraine to extent that he has only armed them enough to not lose. How can they win fighting with one arm and not the full kit? Additionally, Pompeo et al, and Trump, will not have another Afghanistan like Bidens pathetic withdraw on their watch…no way
I have rarely seen someone discrediting himself as efficiently as that in a 20 min interview.
Lovely Scottish accent though.
This is not reality.
Who is this fool?
Must be the guy that backed Trump's golf course in Scotland., hehehehe
Can't listen any longer - can't get past his views on civilian suffering
A fanatical Zionist Rothschild's boy
Apaprently he's a Scotsman!😂😂😂
Is Times Radio running a contest for the guest who can come up with the daftest fantasy?
This guy is completely out of his mind. Give me a break
I could give you a break.. pop over to Poland
@@JimTimber Good idea. it's a lovely country, with great people.
This is a joke, right?
I think he's been dishonest and biased
At this point it would be fraudulent to call Niall an intellectual or expert on anything. Please for the love of all that is good DO NOT bring this con artist back on this program.
Yep. I’ve often disagreed with his take on many things but after that little statement I no longer feel the need to take anything he says seriously. Maga, the swivel-eyed Putin loving wingnuts who have taken over the GOP are going to INCREASE support for Putin’s ostensible victims? A non serious man. He’s a shill.
Some commentators like to be told only what they want to hear and not the truth
What a fool to bring on the show.
@@mrvgranfield non intelligent individuals don't understand this very intelligent wonderful human being
Times radio is losing its reputation with this interview. With Trump president, he will take USA out of nato and Putin will have his dreams come true.
I know. What is this nonsense?
As if the GOP is going to lean on Putin. Arrant nonsense.
Not altogether a bad thing.
Not altogether a bad thing.
@Flintknappingtips the worst thing is that some people are going to believe this bs. It is very sad.
What kind of drugs is he on?
Mushrooms....the really strong ones
Truth serum
@@JimTimber *bs. serum
@@JimTimber When has Trump /ever/ opposed Putin? Don't answer, just be honest with yourself.
@@ArcaneCowboy Tried to strengthen nato countries that border Russia, air strikes on Putin’s ally and friend Assad, commissioned a space force so we can get an upper hand there before the Russians do, tried to lessen our dependance on Russian oil, armed Ukrainians, put emphasis on keeping the US military strong so we can continue to counterbalance Russia, was the only 21st century president under who’s watch Russia did not dare to invade a neighboring country.
Where did this guy learn about current American politics? Marvel Comics?
Team America World Police is what he should be watching 👀 just imagine those puppets have *no* strings
From the Bush administration
BS. You are seriously losing all credit with your so-called experts talking about American politics. This fool knows nothing about American politics and particularly about the GOP and Trump.
Sorry Niall, you have lost the plot!! There is no way that Trump will help Ukraine… Ridiculous interview!
Hilarious how he put on his “mildly” Scottish accent when discussing the SNP and reverts back to his “plummy” English accent when waffling on about nonsense….guy is a total charleton 🤣🤣🤣
Still the same feeble pushing of the Trump myth…..
He’s not exactly a big fan of Trump you know
@@michaelmccomb2594 Yet, here he is saying that Trump will be more effective than Biden against Putin.
@@tureytayno3154 which shows how low an opinion he has of Biden.
Well then please explain how it is possible that it took 6 months to pass the support bill in congres, some baloney 😒
It took several (not 6) months to pass a bill because the GOP wanted Biden to agree to defend the US border if he was asking for money for Ukraine. Biden would not agree to do his job because that would be very unpopular with his base.
Its ok the nurse is coming to take him back , please dont shout .
Except for the fact that Trump is completely on Putin’s side this makes complete sense.
I think he is on the side of peace.
@@dalecrocker3213 I think you are mistaken. Trump is a Putin ally.
@@dalecrocker3213 Trump is on the side of whatever makes him money and strokes his narcissistic ego
@@dalecrocker3213 you might want to up the meds
@@fred166 Are you a total prat, or just pretending?
''Historian'' Lol. More like a fantast
I have also a bridge to sell😂😂😂
Hunter will sell it to you like his paintings
Trump cannot tie his shoes. He is also beholden to Putin and will do everything Putin tells him, both because of his debts to Putin but also because he loves authoritarianism. He claimed that attacking Ukraine was very smart of Putin. Niall is nuts, as most people know.
Putin wants JB reelected. He endorsed him twice a couple of months ago on video so the connection with Trump is a Media invention that has nothing to do with reality.
Dream on
I reported this entire video for misinformation.
Times Radio needs to do a whole lot better, because this is not just preposterous, it's misleading and dangerous.
Oh please. That is his perception and his opinion. I fear he is wrong but he has a right to make his points and Times Radio has a right to ask.
Yes, I agree this crosses the line into misinformation. I suspect that his finances wouldn't stand a deep scrutiny.
@@macmcleod1188 Other vast majority of guests on TR with opposing opinions have to be checked as well
@@Rtg5637 well I basically have had a problem with times radio for nearly two years. They frequently seem strongly pro-russian. Even as Russia does terrible things to ukrainians.
@@macmcleod1188 It is laughable that TR is pro Russian. 9 out of 10 of their guests are against Russia and the hosts question aggressively the 1 out of 10 guests that are objective and realistic.
To the English public. if Trumpo comes near the white house again the American project is over. Educate yourselves
It was not over in his last tenure but may be over if JB is reelected
Biden is well and truly ending the American enterprise.
@@Rtg5637 He tried to end it on Jan 6 2021, but, like most things he tries, failed
@@dougstorky3223 JB is unprecedentedly persecuting his opponent with all the government powers and is a sever danger to democracy
Astonishing headline! Given all Trump's said over the years and that he is such a warm admirer and envier of Putin...
Excuse me , but the Republicans were holding up legalisation to fund Ukraine and took ages to pass it.
Mr Trump keeps on complaining of the cost of funding the Ukraine. So I question you motives.
The SNP were voted into power in a parliament that was constructed to make sure that parties had to make deals and cooperate. Quite an achievement in proportional system. It may not happen again but just as in the rest of the UK you can vote for what you want. You can then be happy or regret it
Most unlikely
who tf is this guy?
“It's far from clear to me that they’ll pull the plug on support for Ukraine, they might actually step up support for Ukraine.”
reality seems not clear to this fool.
Some commentators fail to understand Trump because of Media extreme bias that inundates readers with negativity and makes them repeat what they are told without applying self thinking
The fact of the matter is Trump hasn't said anything about his support for or against Ukraine. TBH I don't think Trump himself knows where he stands on Ukraine other than classifying all support as a "Loan" that even he knows won't be paid back. Anybody saying otherwise doesn't know what he's talking about.
@@smithb0134 Trump keeps his opinion about Ukraine close to his vest so that he can surprise when in office again
@@Rtg5637
It's not an election issue. Most Americans sympathize and support Ukraine but it won't have any bearing on how they vote.
@@smithb0134 Some Americans are die hard determined to vote based on the interests of Ukraine, a foreign country not even a NATO member, urge others to do the same and pester their elected representatives about aid support.
This is mind boggling in my opinion if you watch Ukraine friendly channels.
We are definitely living in the worst timeline. Mirror universe without the beards..
Delusional
Wow just found this channel last week and putting someone like this on discredits your other commentators and guests. Really not sure how I feel about continuing this channel tbh
hear hear.
Please bring back General Hodges!
Had the same thought
Quite a bizarre nonentity
Trump will do whatever his BOSS tells him to do. Not once has Trump criticised Putin, not one single time, that should tell you all you need to know about what is going on here.
Trump would give him the keys to the whitehouse front door . The man is a 🐍
Snp are finished the party is over
I'm glad to see that almost everyone commenting sees how out of touch this guy is. Trump won't listen to his advisors and is already in Putin's pocket.
This guy is just sayin' 5h!t...
Trump has already said he will talk to his mate pootin, pull the plug on Ukraine support and save the Divided States a bunch of bucks. The idiocy and short sightedness of what he has said convinces me that is what he will do, why would he change his form suddenly?
Wut?
This is what you say when you have no credibility whatsoever.
He had spoken about the protesters and how to behave around the law and avoid violation of others rights.
The only way Trump will step up support for Ukraine is if Zelensky compliments Trump by saying, " You are the bestest, most smartest, terrific, handsome and perfect president the world has ever seen."
Not even then!
@@bgs03548 Yeah, you're probably correct.
"Zelensky came to me with tears in his eyes and said, 'Sir, you are a true defender of democracy. The world needs you now.'
"Or was that Stormy? Can't remember."
@@alana8863 Hahahaha! On point with the "Sir"
And if he has a video of Trump "enjoying" himself with two "working" girls.
Niall is a right wing protagonist. Can't trust anything he says.
When I fell asleep last night, did I wake up in another timeline? donald would be tougher?
Or, is Niall Ferguson's saddle on too tight?
Niall is auditioning to be a comedian, Trump being elected would be a catastrophe of epic proportions
Peace in the world under Trump presidency is indeed catrastophic
Its a long long joke and I still don't get it .
@@mrvgranfield many individuals have a hard time accepting hard and painful truths
@@Rtg5637 put your self high on that list
@@mrvgranfield it's obvious that reality and facts don't have any importance for you
His time in America has not been kind to his former objectivity.
This man is a malinformed tool.
This is typical of Niall's oddball politics.
Wow.... gaslighting! Dude needs clicks.
This guy doesn't understand the USA
This guy has smoked all the blunt in the US 😂😂😂
Trump is more likely to sell Ukraine to Russia 😂😂😂
My theory has always been that Putin somehow helped Trump get elected in 2016, this is the "secret" Putin is holding over him.... and Trump is now saying in all but words, get me in again and you can have Ukraine. The art of the deal right 🙄 I'm afraid it might be that simple
Do you also believe the "Trump-colluded-with-Russia" lie that has been proved to have been started by Hillary's campaign in 2016?
Ok. I misunderstood that part of the interview.
Assuming for the sake of argument the national security Republicans mentioned would be tough on Ukraine, why is there the slightest reason to believe Trump would appoint them. Pottinger in particular, who worked seriously on the pandemic and resigned after January 6 is unlikely.
Bad ending: the whole world is now Brazil.
Commenters here should find the Brookings listing of the many US sanctions imposed on Russia in 2017-2019. The questionable thing Mr. Ferguson says is that a future t-Rump administration would be any better.
Trump had to be argued into finally imposing sanctions, and agreed to "the level of Europe" meaning, Trump thought, the level of a European country. Instead the administration made the US sanctions the same as the TOTAL of Europe, and Trump was absolutely furious. Also, study how Trump's administration's #1 project was removing sanctions both from the US and from Europe against RUSAL, the firm owned by the guy who had paid well over $20M in political contributions to Republicans in Congress and in Trump's cabinet as well as Trump himself.
@@lqr824 Absolutely none of this is true.
On the other hand JB, son and brother were paid handsomely to their private accounts due to his position in government. He even bragged about it in a 2018 video.
@@Rtg5637 > Absolutely none of this is true.
No, it's all true. Just go out an inform yourself.
> On the other hand JB, son and brother were paid handsomely to their private accounts due to his position in government. He even bragged about it in a 2018 video
Biden wasn't even in govt in 2018. What universe are you in bro? It was Trump who was paid handsomely to their private accounts due to his position in government. He even bragged about it, not in "a video" that you cannot cite because it doesn't exist, but on national TV pretty much constantly. And he WAS in office.
I'll meet you half-way: any crime you can pin on the Bidens, give them the maximum sentence. Joe too. In return will you agree to the same for Trump? hehe, thought not...
Is it the growing procentige of Latino voters in the US the reason there is so much oversight on 6 January insurrection?
Why the stock footage of King’s College Cambridge when talking about the researcher from Emmanuel?
There seem to be two basic flaws with Niall's argument re a Trump presidency and Ukraine. Firstly, that the individuals he mentioned would be in positions of power, and secondly that they'd have any sort of ability to influence his hostility towards the country.
Don't start implying that a Trump presidency could be a good thing in any way.
And Biden is better?
@@markblanchard9049 yup
@@user-ex7no4bf3p The world is in turmoil under Biden. This is what makes him better than Trump for nincompoops.
Came here for the LOLZZZZ
All I can say is that it would seem to be a real blessing that the Scot's didn't go their own way.....
This guy is completely clueless.
We have a problem with CORRUPTION in England, but in Scotland the problem is FAR WORSE.
His comments on the SNP are spot on.
Niall Ferguson has been a low dog for a very long time.
In other news, black is white, up is down, and cold is hot
and War is Peace, and freedom is slavery 😊😊😊😊😊
Haha
Directly from the Ministry of Truth.
What - the 45th would throw Ukraine to the Orcs. What has happened to Niall F train of thought, sounds totally derailed?
I'm amazed at the obvious lack of acknowledgement of the historical context when discussing Israel's defence strategy outside of it's perilous location.
There is no inclusion of the fact that they now are a small remnant of the population of Jews that historically existed.
Taking historical demographics as the base the population of Jews should be closer to 110 million people not the 15 million that exist in the world.
From the perspective of persistent genocide, we are seeing it occur over the centuries and Jews are very much in that category today.
Of course all races are equal No One races more intelligent than the other
It astounds me that Niall still doesn’t realise that Trump is insane. It’s a tragic demise of an until recently brilliant career
But it's more than just a few right-wing professors like Ferguson. There has been a growing parade of previous never-Trumpers who now can't remember that they ever disliked the guy. Gov. Sununu of New Hampshire, Bill Barr, the list goes on. Something hideous is afoot.
Pompeo will not be in the Trump admin.😅
Only an idiot would think he would be. One has to question this Ferguson chap's sanity or motives.
15:32 too bad, pal, you had been making a certain amount of sense up till this.
To mention Pottinger, is to demonstrate a bias or wishful thinking that makes no sense. Pottinger to his credit, testified against Trump
Magical thinking
He has got a point, look at Syria
Disappointing that he dodged the academia question.
Trump is a big, giant question mark (❓). He sent the Javelins. Not Obama. If he could be convinced to back Ukraine, his administration would double down on doing more. But it's a huge IF.
Keep taking the meds. Obama?🥴😂😂😂
What a sensible guy he's spot on about the SNP...an awful cancer on Scotland.
At an eating contest maybe. 😂
If that were true it would be a win for Ukraine for NATO and American security with a stable Europe that wont have to see war for years to come but I have my doubts with Trump.
Did he just compare hamas to Japan?
You are right there, Niall, American politics is becoming more Latin American - but with Trump in it will be like Maduro's Venezuela.
Yet, Maduro's political preferences are much, much closer to Biden's than Trump's.
@@FactCheckerGuy Really, just remind us, who said, "On day one, I will be a dictator"? Who hates women? How has they threatened to jail anyone who opposes him? Jail any member of the judiciary who doesn't toe the line? Free hundreds of violent criminals who were doing his bidding? Urged a dictator to attack America's allies?
@@FactCheckerGuy You fact checked that wrong. It's to do with dictatorship vs democracy, not any fancy political preferences. Biden, and by extension the Democrat party, is answerable to the whole US electorate, Maduro only to his few supporters.
This guy is clueless. Should not have a mic.
Does anyone remember the video when two tribes go to war?
Wow, I used to respect him, but he's wrong on so many points
On every point. He's a loon.
why you see putin defeat in ukraine. while they increase alot off territory day by day. and military industries capability far better then ukraine. they have factory and and own material resource for produce. even NATO is way behind them for quantitiy to produce 155mm shell
A lot of pearl clutching in the comments. I find that more entertaining than the usual bot comments at least.
@fatfeline1086 'Bot' comments, it's a propaganda channel!
This guy doesn't have the slightest clue, or maybe he has delusions, about the American political system. The US has a strong executive presidential system which means it doesn't matter how many Republican Ukraine hawks there are in Washington, the number could be 1 or it could be 10,000. The president will set international policy, full stop.
It’s like Putin himself said, he prefers having a guy like Biden in office because he’s more predictable.
I recall Trump trusting Putin over his own CIA when it came to election interference. So there's that
Klar tydlig
If Niall’s not on Putin’s payroll he’s missing out a good paycheck that’s he’s earned here.
Far from it, I think Trump will send troops to help Putin for a piece of Ukrainian real state.
Niall needs a reality check. Trump and his cronies have and will always support Putin over Ukraine ... what he is suggesting utter nonsense.
Nial is clueless or dillusional, in not wanting to recognise Trumps hand in blocking aid
Well, Trump might enjoy being a war-time president, but the trashing he'd give Europe concurrently would leave it humiliated