And obviously many of u don't realize how hard it is to sing jazz style, the rhythm and tempo are all different, it's MUCH harder than just singing the song straight through! And to be able to sing it so perfectly at such a high pitch, only Gary can do it.
I chances across the Yang and xiao version of this song, remembers Gary also likes to this song, watch the 3 of them...my personal conclusion is, (purely personal)...I love Gary's singing, as an overall...this is a brilliantly sang song like all his other songs.....Yang's singing was great...especially this particular song he sung...it was touching...simple and touching...while Xiao is not bad, he can sing very well...but I kinda like Gary's and Yangs more.
"the original singer was Wang Fang but not so popular till gary sing it"??? oh please, keep ur ignorance to yourself this version blends beautifully with the music =D
@shineluvslambiel oh my god! it's not about who cares about it, i was just wondering whether he sang with the original key, just wonder okay?! also i thought it's really hard for a man to sing with the key of a female singer, and everyone knows singing is about emotion and expression!
Gary's got the malaysian look...though i prefer Jam's version, I think he did a good job with this rendition... as for yang's supposed 一绝, no doubt is good, but competition aside, it should not be used so frequently for comparison for something as subjective as music. I am sure if Gary or Jam had wanted to interpret this song that way they can dish out that "一绝" too. All that said, I am sure there will be some who can't handle comments like this :)
Come kitties... stop fighting. Both singers are good in different areas. Xiao obviously need more experience and training coz Gary is afterall a pro already. Xiao has explosiveness in his voice while Gary's is very clear and sweet. Cant compare apple to orange!
![เบิ้ล ปทุมราช - อ้ายกินดอง น้องลาบงัว ft. สแน็ก อัจฉรีย์ [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-OK--KaSPcI/mqdefault.jpg)
萬芳版本原Key無誤，牛！
他的高音,尖得來是舒服的,有夠誇張
And obviously many of u don't realize how hard it is to sing jazz style, the rhythm and tempo are all different, it's MUCH harder than just singing the song straight through! And to be able to sing it so perfectly at such a high pitch, only Gary can do it.
曹格的高音令人聽得很舒服, 他的唱功很了得!
喜歡唱第二次的″痛苦的相思忘不了″這句 轉音很好聽👍👍👍
曹格是亞洲數一數二的歌手吧!!!
一首令人心動的歌曲...歌手演繹出牽動人心 so good^^
I like the both of them.... Gary sing in a higher pitch and Jam sing it in a lower pitch.....
这首歌由曹格唱又有了另一种味道~
我突然幻想自己在一个pub里，在半醉半醒下和其他听众安安静静地聆听着这首蓝蓝的歌~。。。
曹格超贊﹗﹗﹗贊贊贊﹗﹗﹗
什麼key也不重要, 曹格的高音令人聽起來舒服, 有技巧, 有感情, 聲靚, 歌好, 情緒都被他的歌聲牽動.....
OMG Gary I m listening to this now n u awesome, ! Still the best version of this song. Really miss yr singing.
喜歡這首歌很久
就他的最好聽了
天 太好聽了 大馬幫 萬歲！
his voice makes women melt for him...
beautiful voice~~~~ gary nice work there!!!!!
超好聽~
曹格太强了~~~=D
He can stand on the platform of the world.
講得太好了。
Gary u are the best!
讲得好！分析的非常清楚！
I think Gary is the only singer nowadays that I like. Other singers nowadays don't know how to pronounce words correctly.
brilliant!!! I like it... sing so great!!
incredible singer....i'm in awe
好聽，能唱出自己的風格
Such a nice and beautiful voice
his voice is POWER!
this is really jazzzz... love it so much
I am really proud of him...
awesome....a powerful voice
他的聲音真的會把別人融化ＸＤ
沒錯！
The Best!!!
Very Good Vocal.
very darn refreshing.
like his bluesy impro, but somehow i think its abit jerky. the guitar too.
Amazing Jazz!!!!!
i like him always...
我的青春😂
I like this .
more than bravo!
Very Good~ It is a rare sound ~
anyway he did put emotion...the emotion is not the mind only...but the tone.He did it already!
amazing!!!!!
awesome!!!
wow...amazing...
i like gary version...
gary sound touch!!!
wow...soo good, the jazz part was VERY hard to sing, yet he sang it so well!! =)
This a lighter and milder version of the song.Very good.
bravo!!!!!!!!
nice rendition:D
the guitar solo sounds peculiarly arranged for this song!
WOW!!! Great .. No comments
Gary was born in SABAH ( 沙巴 ）Malaysia.
He sure is. Please never leave da house GARY CHAW!!!!!!!
he singing jazz thats why it like too much drag variations,but it should be in this genre that why its good...
good!!!!!!
I chances across the Yang and xiao version of this song, remembers Gary also likes to this song, watch the 3 of them...my personal conclusion is, (purely personal)...I love Gary's singing, as an overall...this is a brilliantly sang song like all his other songs.....Yang's singing was great...especially this particular song he sung...it was touching...simple and touching...while Xiao is not bad, he can sing very well...but I kinda like Gary's and Yangs more.
original singer was Wan Fang if i am not wrong...and its not easy to sing in her key especially for guys.
Wow the original singer (girl) sings in the same key!
实力
What can i say..... music runs in his veins....
Totally sexy guy to me~ love his voice! Muackz Gary.
@wongpaksum who cares about the original key. Singing is about expressing feelings, emotions and soul.
I think I understand it perfectly. As I AM a chinese living abroad myself. I just don't make such a deal out of it.
hehehe... actually i can wrote more but i got no comment so i just say its great!!!
救命啊!
好像上帝的声音啊。
太好听了。
好讚哦！！
"the original singer was Wang Fang but not so popular till gary sing it"???
oh please, keep ur ignorance to yourself
this version blends beautifully with the music =D
马来西亚万岁！！
anyone have any idea where to download this version of this song by cao ge??
jacky cheung's version is the best
@wongpaksum yes
can i ask ya~ chaoge / lin wei zhong / xiao jing teng witch 1 is the best??
@waihong001 他高音一般都用混音，因爲他練得很好所以聼起來就像很高的真音但同時有假音很明亮的感覺.
曹格唱得好有味道 好棒
雖然蕭敬騰的唱歌手法像曹格 但他唱出來的感覺味道不像曹格或者其它人
那是他獨有的蕭式風格
can anyone cut this video inti mp3 sound?
what does the nationality have anything to do with singing abilities?
but he is an awesome singer
G KEY！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！bossa nova !!!!!!!!!!aaaaaaarRRR!!!love !!!!
爵士風味阿 不簡單
@shineluvslambiel yes... 'cause my ENG is really bad haaa, so i dunno what word i should use to express myself except OMG. sorry:)
R&B
@shineluvslambiel oh my god! it's not about who cares about it, i was just wondering whether he sang with the original key, just wonder okay?! also i thought it's really hard for a man to sing with the key of a female singer, and everyone knows singing is about emotion and expression!
not all call sing like Gary.
only Gary can sing like tat.
i don't really like the song, but gary sure made it sound good
amazing singer
杨最厉害了。。。
Where can I download this song?
i always find him quite noisy when he try to change the feel of the song
its true, like it or not.
he most best.. 黄明志 just sing the chorus nia, no need to use much energy for singing, but 曹格 use G key for whole song, this is perfect!!
gary is not even popular before, if it wasnt for 超級星光大道 楊宗緯-新不了情 一絕 2007/5/25 終極版! 指定踢館賽 Gary would be no one still
還是曹格唱的好聽..
有他這樣大的音域在歌唱上真的佔十分大的優勢.
Gary's got the malaysian look...though i prefer Jam's version, I think he did a good job with this rendition... as for yang's supposed 一绝, no doubt is good, but competition aside, it should not be used so frequently for comparison for something as subjective as music. I am sure if Gary or Jam had wanted to interpret this song that way they can dish out that "一绝" too. All that said, I am sure there will be some who can't handle comments like this :)
但是我覺得同樣的groove
我會比較喜歡蕭來詮釋耶
他的聲音比較飽滿 jazzy groove 慢慢帶出來的感覺會比較舒服
曹格唱的有點激情
best in tw? he was born n raised in malaysia..
Come kitties... stop fighting. Both singers are good in different areas. Xiao obviously need more experience and training coz Gary is afterall a pro already. Xiao has explosiveness in his voice while Gary's is very clear and sweet. Cant compare apple to orange!
你都很会听歌哦......
Gary 為什麽你唱得那麽好聽?
无可否认，这是所有男翻唱者中唱得最好的，也比大部分女翻唱唱得更有味道。
G key