I read all these comments as if it isa war for the declaration of the better between Asha Bhonsale and Noor Jahan....both exquisite and incomparable with classics no one can replicate. Music is to be enjoyed and the poetry to be cherished. Since they are both highly accomplished singers, anyone trying to make comments of comparison are fooling themselves. What they both have achieved is too large for nobody’s like us to comment!
Nothing can be better than original. That is why all the songs sung by Lataji and Ashaji are the best and no one can match them. Same rule applies to all the original renditions.
No one can sing like madam Noorjah ...she was one and only one... was still end of this world. she was able to expressed feeling of songs in her song or ghazal. Allah Tallah Jannat E Naseeb Karien
I am in 80s and have heard Noor Jehan sometime 40 years ago. She was a wonderful singer and now I am hearing Asha. She too is great and many a times better than her sister. Pronunciation is very correct. Greatly talented.
Sister of Maa Sarswati as the way Lata Ji sacrificed her whole life absolutely devoted to music, music and music. Howerver, Asha Ji has her own aura of music which shines through her excellency. Lata Ji was offrered Miraz-E-Ghazal to sing with Ghulam Ali Saab but she herself suggested Asha Ji's name. So they are not ordinary souls. God Bless.
Who is here in 2021.......? We should be grateful of Vividh Bharti, Doodrdarshan to provide such a gems of non filmi songs, gazals and parallel cinema of 70's to 90's. These mediums always brought quality songs, ghazals, artists & movies in their various programs. This helped a lot to refine choice of individuals who wanted to have something different from masala entertainment. Do u agree..?
Too beautiful to be praised.... Every nuance of the soulful voice touches the heart instantaneously... Very melodious tune and meaningful lyrics.. Class apart ... incomparable...👍
People like Asha G and Madam Noor Jahan are the Golden Pearls of this sub-continent. They both form a binding force that produces nothing but LOVE and brotherhood for the people of these two unfortunate contries. Their voices unite us and spread love. This piece of land was blessed to have people like them.
There is no competition .... Everyone is different so sang differently .... Beautiful .... But yes seeing madam Noor Jehan in the video while she sings this ghazal more of a connection is felt .... She is very expressive and the queen of the stage 🌟
@@MsMrutyunjay who are you to remark me like this.... she did not sing well. she sang in filmi style... this is my opinion and pls keep ur remarks with you...
FYI : When Madam Noor Jahan was at the age of 10 or 11 years old; Lata Jee, was the one who actually encouraged her and told her that one day she’ll be a great singer. Madam Noor Jahan, looked up to Lata Jee throughout her music career.
A grand ghazal with a out of this world rendition by Ashaji, the greatest ever. With due respects to Noor Jahan ji, her voice is to nasal & sharp that kills the very soul of song.
@Saregama Ghazal - Please change the title. It should be 'Shauq' and not 'Shaq'. This is one my favorite ghazals, and like various renditions of it sung by various artists. Always gives ultimate pleasure and solace whenever I listen to this piece of a gem.
Each composition has its own beauty and its own mood or expression, It is totally foolishness if we compare one to another. I read many comments, perheps they are not knowing what is Music?What is Ghazal-singing?So they are comparing... I admire both singers, Noorjahajee and Ashajee. Finally it depends how you consider ?music as music or something else. May the God bless you all...
Magical magical magical listening this on 8 th sept 90 th bday of asha ji she also immortalised noorjehan thru this gazal another magical Mallika e tarranum
Heard different singers performing this great composition but Ashaji has nailed it BANG ON infact better then the original sung by Madam NoorJehangir kudos to the Music Director by Mohsin Raza and heavenly lyrics by Nisar Kazmi ❤
I think this song is very nnice private album this song is tribute to Noorjahan madam very good singer I like hearing gems thanks to Asha didi for this nice gazal.
Darbadar phirte hue aaye hain is maqaam pe Hum, Aarzoo dil mein liye chalte hain har shaam se Hum, Thak gaye raahon mein kya kije Zara der lagi, Har guzargah pe likhte aaye unka naam hain hum Dhoop nikli rafta rafta aur peher dhalte gaye, Din guzarta gaya aur apne qadam badhte gaye, Waqt ka koi ilm humko na kabhi ho paaya, Hijr ka poora par hisaab kar aaye hain hum, Thoda betaab thoda bebas thoda farrukh hai dil, Kisi mulaqaat ki raahat nahi Kuch iske muqabil, Ik tarannum si chedti hai chandni shab yeh, Ik fasaane ka kar aaye intzaam hain hum, Mujhe na ahl-e-chaman aise badnaam Karo, Meri uljhano ka thoda ehtram karo, Unki khushboo aaye apne har ik gul se Kaho, Warna 'Bedaar' jaanta hai kyun nakaam hain hum...... A tribute from Bedaar to Nasir Sahab and Mallika-e-Tarannum Madame Noor Jahaan............ #Legends
I have read out all the comments. Why some people are compared between noor jahan and asha Bhosle don't understand. Please mind it both are legends. Both are top notch classical singer, so please don't be judgmental. Both were sung this wonderful ghazal in their own expertise way.
I read all these comments as if it isa war for the declaration of the better between Asha Bhonsale and Noor Jahan....both exquisite and incomparable with classics no one can replicate. Music is to be enjoyed and the poetry to be cherished. Since they are both highly accomplished singers, anyone trying to make comments of comparison are fooling themselves. What they both have achieved is too large for nobody’s like us to comment!
Exactly 👍
Yes. Fully agree, both exquisite and incomparable with classics no one can replicate. Music is to be enjoyed and the poetry to be cherished.
Fully agreed, just enjoying the song.
Perfectly right
You are outright madam... I reach in Heaven whenever I listen to Asha Bhonsle... What a great singer she is... My heart felt respect to her...
I have heard this ghazal by more than 10 artists....
All versions are fantastic...
Each one have it's own beauty ❤️
Nothing can be better than original. That is why all the songs sung by Lataji and Ashaji are the best and no one can match them. Same rule applies to all the original renditions.
आशा ताई की ये गज़ल कई गायकों ने गाने का सुन्दर प्रयास किया पर जो खुशबू है और कहीं नहीं । नमन हो आपकी गायकी को 🙏🙏💐💐
Great Poet 'Nasir Kazmi', Ms. Asha u performed excellent. respect from 🇵🇰
No one can sing like madam Noorjah ...she was one and only one... was still end of this world. she was able to expressed feeling of songs in her song or ghazal. Allah Tallah Jannat E Naseeb Karien
Madam noor Jehan I Miss you every time verey day 💞💞 😭😭😭
Allah ka talla tumko b jannat nasib kare...
that's not true! Antara Biswas has already sung and made it better
@@hasibhasan3432😹😂😂
I am in 80s and have heard Noor Jehan sometime 40 years ago. She was a wonderful singer and now I am hearing Asha. She too is great and many a times better than her sister. Pronunciation is very correct. Greatly talented.
Asha is better than Lata, True
What ??? @@mrwhitenoise376
I dont know why but this version of Niyat e shauq is very close to my heart 🖤
Me too ❤❤❤
Me too
change your heart! there are better versions out there
if this version is close to your heart them visit a doctor ASAP
इससे भी दिल भर जाएगा शायद,,,, नही कभी नहीं
Excellent lyrics. And I am a big fan of Asha Bhosale. Somehow Asha ji sings such kind of songs very beautifully. Really appreciable ❤.
Asha g gave tribute to Madam Noor Jahan
Asha Bhounsle voice is very perfect to this gazal
Ashaji singing this Gazhal is an honour n love for madam Noor Jahan...and the Gazhal is so tempting for any manza hua singer
A great tribute by great Asha ji to the legend of Noorjehan ji
वाह बहुत सुंदर, राग बहुत ही सुंदर है गोरख कल्याण इसको हर कोई छेड़ता भी नही है बहुत सॉफ्ट राग है बेसुरा होने में 2 सेकंड लगता 😄🙏
It's originally sang by madam noor jahan
Asha Gee also done Justice to this Gazal.
Pr jo baat noor g kr gye andaz m w lana mushkil h
But I like Asha Ji one
So what?
Yeah i feel it’s better sung by madam Noor Jahan 💯
No one have the capacity to compare such Legendary singers.They are more greater than us.So stop foolishness.And give them proper respect .
Of all the versions this is my most favourite ❤ as it is Maa Saraswati herself singing 🙏🏼✨
Shundori go dohai dohai...Love you Srijani,from Bangladesh.
Sister of Maa Sarswati as the way Lata Ji sacrificed her whole life absolutely devoted to music, music and music. Howerver, Asha Ji has her own aura of music which shines through her excellency. Lata Ji was offrered Miraz-E-Ghazal to sing with Ghulam Ali Saab but she herself suggested Asha Ji's name. So they are not ordinary souls. God Bless.
Only medam norjaha bs
Who is here in 2021.......?
We should be grateful of Vividh Bharti, Doodrdarshan to provide such a gems of non filmi songs, gazals and parallel cinema of 70's to 90's. These mediums always brought quality songs, ghazals, artists & movies in their various programs. This helped a lot to refine choice of individuals who wanted to have something different from masala entertainment.
Do u agree..?
Mee
This is by youtube. 7 years ago. You saw in 2021@!!!!.
Wow what a beautiful Composition N Singing Asha Tai 👌👌🙏🙏
Ye sab ,maa saraswati ke ansh hai❤❤She is a goddess obviously.🙏🙏🙏🙏
Too beautiful to be praised....
Every nuance of the soulful voice touches the heart instantaneously...
Very melodious tune and meaningful lyrics..
Class apart ... incomparable...👍
A tribute from a legendary voice to another legendary voice. 👏👏
People like Asha G and Madam Noor Jahan are the Golden Pearls of this sub-continent. They both form a binding force that produces nothing but LOVE and brotherhood for the people of these two unfortunate contries. Their voices unite us and spread love. This piece of land was blessed to have people like them.
No one can beat Madam NOOR JAHAN may ALLAH SOBHANA WA'TA'ALLAH bless her soul Aameen
There is no competition .... Everyone is different so sang differently .... Beautiful .... But yes seeing madam Noor Jehan in the video while she sings this ghazal more of a connection is felt .... She is very expressive and the queen of the stage 🌟
Ashaji and only Ashaji can sing this song so excellently. Praying to God to give you a longer life.
I think you are not listening the original ghazal by noor jahan ASHA ji sings it good but so far from madum noor jahan
not really, Antara biswas has sung it way better than her
Asha sings very professionally, with excellent voice control whereas Noor Jehan sings like a village woman.
A great tribute given to noor jehan by a legend singer. Loves
BUT Asha G is failed in this tribute....
@@Fareed63 Not at all.
Madam noor Jehan ji is great singer I miss you madam ji
@@Fareed63 who are you to judge.....she sang reallly nice....why to copy the great Noor jahan ji
@@MsMrutyunjay who are you to remark me like this.... she did not sing well. she sang in filmi style... this is my opinion and pls keep ur remarks with you...
The pathos hidden in the song is explored to its maximum.Only Ashaji can work this magic.
Asha ji is unparallel ❤️🙏💎👌🌟
Jo no 1 ha woh no 1 ha. Or woh noor jahan ha.
Asha ji ne kmaal Gaya ha.. clear crystal voice ... Noorjahan ji ka bhi mene suna but aapka jawab nhi mam🙏👏👏👏👏
Noor Jahan sung so well than Ash bhosle.
Listen Noor.jahan again same ghazal....
@@Rizwankhan-uw4gpBoth are great , ❤❤
Wahh !Asha Ji 🌹🌹🌹 Bahut hi shakun milta hai
80 s superhit ghazal
I used to listen to this beautiful ghazal almost everyday on my way to work in the mid 80's on my car's cassette player. Wonderful memory.
It's originally sang by madam noor jahan
Me too. Somebody stole my cassette .
Wow. I love this version. This is the best version.
No comparison of this Gajol. This song is above all disputes when it is sung by an Empress like Ahahji or a prominent singer of this continent.
I am listening this masterpiece on 15th december 2024🤗😚❤❤
No one can touch the aura of Queen of Melody Noor Jahan. Lata M & Asha B also worship her as their guru idol.
FYI : When Madam Noor Jahan was at the age of 10 or 11 years old; Lata Jee, was the one who actually encouraged her and told her that one day she’ll be a great singer. Madam Noor Jahan, looked up to Lata Jee throughout her music career.
@@Tfapawhat are you even cooking bro? Madam Noor Jahan is 3 years senior to Lata ji.
Kya kamaal Gaya hai Asha ji ne. Another gem of dinanath Mangeshkar.
Superb 👍 what a great tribute by a great Artist to Madam Noor jahan.
A grand ghazal with a out of this world rendition by Ashaji, the greatest ever. With due respects to Noor Jahan ji, her voice is to nasal & sharp that kills the very soul of song.
Kiya baat hai Bihar achchi compose hai lyrics main Bihar feel hai❤
Mai roz sunti hu par dil nahi bharta.....asha ji ❤❤❤❤❤
What a soulful voice Asha ji has ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Absolutely beautiful rendition!
Qalaam aur aawaz donon mein Kamal ki mithaas hai 🌷🌷
Qalaam. Ye kia cheez hai
Kalaam to hota hai
Great asha ji♥️♥️♥️🧡💙💛👌👌👌🇮🇳
Never compare with a hit that is original.... but praise all good versions of it as each effort offers differences of the songs beauty
You always compare and give the credit to who it really deserves
Oh my god ! How I didn’t listen this before ! My
God ! Incredible 🎧🖤🖤🌙
@Saregama Ghazal - Please change the title. It should be 'Shauq' and not 'Shaq'.
This is one my favorite ghazals, and like various renditions of it sung by various artists. Always gives ultimate pleasure and solace whenever I listen to this piece of a gem.
So soothing,so melodious,what a great rendition by legendary Ashaji❤
Each composition has its own beauty and its own mood or expression, It is totally foolishness if we compare one to another. I read many comments, perheps they are not knowing what is Music?What is Ghazal-singing?So they are comparing...
I admire both singers, Noorjahajee and Ashajee.
Finally it depends how you consider ?music as music or something else.
May the God bless you all...
Aarzu hai ke TU yahan Aaye.. ❤ Aur phir Umar Bhar Na Jaye kahin🥰🥰❤❤🌺🌺
I like Asha Bhosle ji's version She is Professional singer!!!
Yes, I do like Madam Noor Jahan also!!!
Bhai jo madam ne ga dya uss ka koi match nahi...
You like everything that means you don't really understand and you don't dare to say who is better
Both are Legends & have a unique style of their own!@@hasibhasan3432
Accomplished Singers noorjahan Mam,Ashaji,Music lovers only enjoy good poetry, composers,singer delivery of song with unique style
No 1 noor jahan original
School days ki bahot hi sunahri yaade judhi h❤️❤️❤️bas aankhe band karo aur kho jao 💝💝💝
इतने साल से ग़ज़ल में वही जादू।
आशा जी ग्रेट।
Malka e Tarannam MADAM NOOR JAHAN K qareeb se bhi na guzar na saki. MADAM ko sirf aur sirf MADAM hi ga sakti hain. She is an ultimate singer.
100% right. no one till now reached near Madam Noor Jehan singing..
Aapne bilkul sahi kha mai bhi madam ji ka bahut bada fan hu I m 17 year old live mumbai
Yanha koi compitition nahi ho rahi bhaiyo
I also big fan of noor jahan jii
Was knew Asha gi sung Nasir kazmi … one of best gazal poet …
Wah wah wah asha dai kya baat hai
Subhanalla kya gazal hai Kya aawaz ashaji Dil he nahi pura vajud hil gaya. U R Superb.
ایک دور تھا ، چراغ سے چراغ روشن تھے
اب یہ دور ہے ، اسی چراغ سے گھر جلے ہیں ،
Its all about lyrics...
Or unka kya hi kehna🌺🌺🌺
All versions of it are just ...vao vao
Madam noorjehan ji and asha Bhosle are both legends who have done full justice in their own styles. Hats off to both of them.
Ashaji, Bahot badhiya.
what an improvisation. real asha bhonsle at her best
gone are those golden days of great music
It's originally sung by madam Noor Jahan
@@georgemoore5005 ll0lll
Wah the great Gazal found another maestra voice.
Bhtt ummmda ❤
Love you Asha ji !!! ❤️❤️
Magical magical magical listening this on 8 th sept 90 th bday of asha ji she also immortalised noorjehan thru this gazal another magical Mallika e tarranum
Thanks for uploading the credits. Others should follow too.
This is the beauty of music that everyone loves and feels the charm of best ghazals, it is a tribute by Asha ji to Noor Jahan didi.
😍👏👏
অপূর্ব
Speechless ❤🙌🙌🥺
Noor jahaan is best 👍💯
Legendary voice of Asha ji ! Immortal forever
Heard different singers performing this great composition but Ashaji has nailed it BANG ON infact better then the original sung by Madam NoorJehangir kudos to the Music Director by Mohsin Raza and heavenly lyrics by Nisar Kazmi ❤
Asha is a better singer technically, but Noor Jahan's version felt more soulful.
I think this song is very nnice private album this song is tribute to Noorjahan madam very good singer I like hearing gems thanks to Asha didi for this nice gazal.
Love from late Noor jahan Ji .....😢😢😢😢😢
Tribute to Madam noor jehan and legend poet Nasir kazmi❤
yaad agya woh din .cassette ka zamana phir laut ke Ana.
Ghazal writer writer syed nasir ali kazmi sahib.. Singing. Madam Noor Jahan...
जितनी बार सुनो उतनी बार नया सा लगता है।...
Medam jaisa koi nai . Wsy nai uny kaha jata malika e tarannum noor jahan
Ise kahte hyin, gazal gana, asha bhonsle ke saamne noor jahan ke bas ki baat nahi
Old is Gold
Wow I listen this many times ❤❤❤❤
Darbadar phirte hue aaye hain is maqaam pe Hum,
Aarzoo dil mein liye chalte hain har shaam se Hum,
Thak gaye raahon mein kya kije Zara der lagi,
Har guzargah pe likhte aaye unka naam hain hum
Dhoop nikli rafta rafta aur peher dhalte gaye,
Din guzarta gaya aur apne qadam badhte gaye,
Waqt ka koi ilm humko na kabhi ho paaya,
Hijr ka poora par hisaab kar aaye hain hum,
Thoda betaab thoda bebas thoda farrukh hai dil,
Kisi mulaqaat ki raahat nahi Kuch iske muqabil,
Ik tarannum si chedti hai chandni shab yeh,
Ik fasaane ka kar aaye intzaam hain hum,
Mujhe na ahl-e-chaman aise badnaam Karo,
Meri uljhano ka thoda ehtram karo,
Unki khushboo aaye apne har ik gul se Kaho,
Warna 'Bedaar' jaanta hai kyun nakaam hain hum......
A tribute from Bedaar to Nasir Sahab and Mallika-e-Tarannum Madame Noor Jahaan............
#Legends
I have read out all the comments. Why some people are compared between noor jahan and asha Bhosle don't understand. Please mind it both are legends. Both are top notch classical singer, so please don't be judgmental. Both were sung this wonderful ghazal in their own expertise way.
ONE AND ONLY MALKA-E-TARANUM NOORJHAN
Noor jahan Ne best Gazal gai hai
🙏Ashaji
Miss u since many days
Very strong voice, and the music composition is more like a movie version.
Very nice.
I have been listening to this ghazal of Asha tai since 1997 and feel the same charm of listening it again and again❤❤
What a mellifluous voice... pronunciation at its best.... Urdu words...too good....ASHA ji aap jiyo hazaron Saal
awesome no words👌👌👌👌👌
Kiya baat
So beautiful✨✨✨ Asha tai.
Meri bahena. Ashaji is the best