Honestly I like this formula more than the vinyl formula. That one is sticky and feels heavy on my lips whereas this one dries down a little bit but feels comfortable. The only thing I dislike about this formula is that there’s a fragrance that I can taste when I put it on, but it fades with time.
I definitely can't taste the fragrance but everyone has different sensitivities! Yeah, everyone is going to have a different preference and priorities when it comes to lip feel! I'm glad that you like them. Have you tried them as a blush?
@ I have tried it and it looks nice for some shades. It’s a good trick for a monochromatic look. It doesn’t last as long on as a blush but that’s because I have oily skin so kind of expected.
My favorite lip tint/stain is the Revlon Colorstay Satin Ink. It lasts a long time but it’s not sticky or drying. They don’t last quite as long but still longer than a regular lipstick.
I haven’t tried those! I do like revlon’s suede ink matte lipsticks because they actually feel so weightless and not dry- one of the few I can still tolerate!
Thanks for this review. I've watched another beauty review, and I had some questions about the product that she didn't address. Yours is more thorough! ❤ I also chew my dry lips and I often tend to favor staining lip balms or tints. That said, the original SuperStay is what I preferred, but I applied it more in the K beauty style of sheered out and darker in the center of my lips. It takes some finagling to do I'll def give this a try. It similar to the K beauty lippies, but more readily available stateside. Also, I'm all about the red lip. Can't wait to see how this looks! ❤
If you like the SuperStay formula and you're already trying to sheer that out, you may actually really like these! There's definitely an audience for them out there.
Yeah I unfortunately bought like four of them right off the jump...😩. I never learn my lesson... They are sticky as heck and are patchy aaannnddd. They bleed into lip lines too... And I don't want to use him as blush cuz I have older skin, so that isn't going to work for me 😢. What I do love are the Milani lip stains those really are fantastic.... So I don't know why I didn't just stick with those probably because the Maybelline had lighter colors......💸💸💸
Have you tried them as blushes though? My skin gets very dry in winter and because of all the dimethicone in these, they still sit smooth on my cheeks. Might be a way to salvage them if you're willing to try them out. Apply them right before you shower just in case it doesn't work out you can take it off right away 🤪
@slashedbeauty I ended up returning the unopened ones.... i'll give him a shot for blush and see see how they look... but boy, these ripped up my lips. They took the moisture right out of them. My dermatologist told me to put nipple cream on them to recover..worked like a charm!
I had no problems going bold. It was a little sticky and did transfer on my coffee mug but after a couple of sips and a protein bar it didn’t transfer anymore. When I put a little gloss on for hydration it didn’t break down very much and it wasn’t patchy. When trying this out for the past 3 days I had 2 meals, coffee, water and Diet Coke so it was put to the test. I really like them. It was nice not having to reply except for my gloss. I don’t have dry lips so that could be a factor. I also wear lip balm when I’m not wearing any lip products. I don’t like the feeling of my lips feeling parched. 😊 I’m definitely going to try it as a blush too. I just hope it doesn’t leave a stain. 😂
Thank you for this review! Everytime something drops that I wanna try I come to see if you made a video lol a lot of the things you recommend are in my makeup collection and I love them. 😊
Same! All I saw was videos loving these but then the comments would say something completely different. I think these will be great for people who don't mind the dry feel, and like that blurred k-beauty look, but I just need more moisture in my lip products at my age!
Hmm. Almost sold me on the longevity even though I have zero interest in a matte lip currently I do love a stain-but it staying sticky & emphasizing texture I’m not into it. Will it stay in place if you let it dry down and put a gloss over top?
I hadn't tested it in that way yet but I've been wearing the Coquettish shade for a few hours today, it's dried down completely and I just put a gloss on top. Looks like it's doing well, didn't automatically break down or anything. I don't think I'd put a lip OIL on top though. Stay tuned-- I have a lip stains video coming next week!
Thank you for this review. I’m going to pass on these. I can’t stand that sticky feeling, even for a little while. I tried the Vinyl Inks last year which never dry down. 😢. I couldn’t wait to scrub it off.
Yeah the Vinyl Inks are meant to stay glossy but still give you a long lasting color, usually shiny/glossy finishes don't dry down but those are still my favorite over the matte inks! If stickiness drives you nuts though then these may not be for you! I appreciate you watching!
It’s the Moira Chroma Light shadow in Kiss and Tell! You can use my affiliate code for 15% off (SlashedBeauty) 💜 I just tapped it over the ColourPop shadow stix in Gimme a Sign
I haven't tried them, but I've been curious. I love the name(the shortened version) I think it's so cute. I'm a sucker for packaging and cute names. May God bless 💙💙
Is the sticking similar to the tacky feeling of the maybelline vinyl inks? Also you look gorgeous in that sweater- it really compliments your hair and face !
@ you’re welcome!! The vinyl doesn’t bother me either… I honestly think they are more hydrating or at least not as drying as a matte lip. I love a matte lip look but it’s harder in the winter when my lips are begging for balm lol
I love the color mascara tear 😢 Butttttt it was horrible on my lips it peels off and it's sticky. I don't know how anyone can wear them as a stain. Because it's so hard to get it off. I can use it as a blush !
I hated these, but I should have known bc I don’t like matte lip products. On a different note, what is the pinky/purple glitter on your eyes? It’s beautiful and I need it!
Thank you!! It’s the Moira Chroma Light shadow in Kiss and Tell! You can use my affiliate code for 15% off (SlashedBeauty) 💜 I just tapped it over the ColourPop shadow stix in Gimme a Sign!
I have never been able to wear matte lip products. It's a big no for me. I am resigned to the fact that I'll just be re-applying my lip color throughout the day, not a problem for me! But if you can tolerate it, more power to you!!!😉
I bought 2 different colors and I regret it. Super drying and now they will go in the trash. I paid $15.99 each, so $30 total and it was a bad choice. I even added a lip balm ahead of time and the formula turned really nasty, I had to wipe it off.
@@slashedbeautyI will take you up on that. Thanks for the response, that’s awesome. 😀😀😀 Fingers crossed they apply well on my cheeks. P.S I love your channel, super informative.
Honestly I like this formula more than the vinyl formula. That one is sticky and feels heavy on my lips whereas this one dries down a little bit but feels comfortable. The only thing I dislike about this formula is that there’s a fragrance that I can taste when I put it on, but it fades with time.
I definitely can't taste the fragrance but everyone has different sensitivities! Yeah, everyone is going to have a different preference and priorities when it comes to lip feel! I'm glad that you like them. Have you tried them as a blush?
@ I have tried it and it looks nice for some shades. It’s a good trick for a monochromatic look. It doesn’t last as long on as a blush but that’s because I have oily skin so kind of expected.
I hate any sticky lip product so this review is really helpful. I like Matte formulas that dry down completely and are not drying.
The sheer layer will completely dry down BUT then you're gonna have that dry feeling 🤪
@slashedbeauty I hear ya LOL At my age I need something really pigmented anyway
Thank you for such a thorough investigation and report!! Excellent video. 😍
Thank you so much for watching!
Could you please show lipsticks for dry lips? I have all the same bad habbits you have😖
That is a great idea, thank you for the recommendation! Writing it down ❤️
My favorite lip tint/stain is the Revlon Colorstay Satin Ink. It lasts a long time but it’s not sticky or drying. They don’t last quite as long but still longer than a regular lipstick.
I haven’t tried those! I do like revlon’s suede ink matte lipsticks because they actually feel so weightless and not dry- one of the few I can still tolerate!
Excellent & thorough review! Thank you. I think I'll skip these, but looking forward to your lip stain review next week ❤
Thank you for tuning in!!
Thanks for this review. I've watched another beauty review, and I had some questions about the product that she didn't address. Yours is more thorough! ❤
I also chew my dry lips and I often tend to favor staining lip balms or tints. That said, the original SuperStay is what I preferred, but I applied it more in the K beauty style of sheered out and darker in the center of my lips. It takes some finagling to do
I'll def give this a try. It similar to the K beauty lippies, but more readily available stateside. Also, I'm all about the red lip. Can't wait to see how this looks! ❤
If you like the SuperStay formula and you're already trying to sheer that out, you may actually really like these! There's definitely an audience for them out there.
Yeah I unfortunately bought like four of them right off the jump...😩. I never learn my lesson... They are sticky as heck and are patchy aaannnddd. They bleed into lip lines too... And I don't want to use him as blush cuz I have older skin, so that isn't going to work for me 😢. What I do love are the Milani lip stains those really are fantastic.... So I don't know why I didn't just stick with those probably because the Maybelline had lighter colors......💸💸💸
Have you tried them as blushes though? My skin gets very dry in winter and because of all the dimethicone in these, they still sit smooth on my cheeks. Might be a way to salvage them if you're willing to try them out. Apply them right before you shower just in case it doesn't work out you can take it off right away 🤪
@slashedbeauty I ended up returning the unopened ones.... i'll give him a shot for blush and see see how they look... but boy, these ripped up my lips. They took the moisture right out of them. My dermatologist told me to put nipple cream on them to recover..worked like a charm!
I wish Maybelline would release new shades of the Superstay Ink Crayon. That's my favorite Maybelline lip product!
Those are SO GOOD! I think you’ve inspired me to pick up a few again.
Agree! And I use it as a base to help some other lip products stay on longer. But, not many of the shades are what I’m looking for.
I had no problems going bold. It was a little sticky and did transfer on my coffee mug but after a couple of sips and a protein bar it didn’t transfer anymore. When I put a little gloss on for hydration it didn’t break down very much and it wasn’t patchy. When trying this out for the past 3 days I had 2 meals, coffee, water and Diet Coke so it was put to the test. I really like them. It was nice not having to reply except for my gloss. I don’t have dry lips so that could be a factor. I also wear lip balm when I’m not wearing any lip products. I don’t like the feeling of my lips feeling parched. 😊
I’m definitely going to try it as a blush too. I just hope it doesn’t leave a stain. 😂
I'm super glad you had a good experience with them! I don't find that they stain the lips or cheeks when wearing so I hope you like them that way too!
Thank you for this review! Everytime something drops that I wanna try I come to see if you made a video lol a lot of the things you recommend are in my makeup collection and I love them. 😊
That makes me so happy to hear! 😊 Thank you so much for watching!
Best review for this! Thank you.
Glad it was helpful!
Thank you for the HONEST review!! All I've seen is hype, especially on T*k T*k, so I'm so happy to hear an unbiased opinion bad on real wear!!
Same! All I saw was videos loving these but then the comments would say something completely different. I think these will be great for people who don't mind the dry feel, and like that blurred k-beauty look, but I just need more moisture in my lip products at my age!
I’ve wanted to try this as I’m obsessed with the Vinyl ones. I might buy one and give it a go. Thanks for the review.
I loooove the vinyl inks!! Let me know how it goes!
Love this stuff!
I'm glad it worked for you!
Hmm. Almost sold me on the longevity even though I have zero interest in a matte lip currently I do love a stain-but it staying sticky & emphasizing texture I’m not into it. Will it stay in place if you let it dry down and put a gloss over top?
I hadn't tested it in that way yet but I've been wearing the Coquettish shade for a few hours today, it's dried down completely and I just put a gloss on top. Looks like it's doing well, didn't automatically break down or anything. I don't think I'd put a lip OIL on top though. Stay tuned-- I have a lip stains video coming next week!
@ yay! Love a lip stain!
@slashedbeauty Awesome! I love lip stains too!
Thank you for this review. I’m going to pass on these. I can’t stand that sticky feeling, even for a little while. I tried the Vinyl Inks last year which never dry down. 😢. I couldn’t wait to scrub it off.
Yeah the Vinyl Inks are meant to stay glossy but still give you a long lasting color, usually shiny/glossy finishes don't dry down but those are still my favorite over the matte inks! If stickiness drives you nuts though then these may not be for you! I appreciate you watching!
Thank you so much so mentioning the sensory issues.
It can drive a person crazy!
The whole video I couldn't stop looking at our eye look! What purple shadow are you wearing?
It’s the Moira Chroma Light shadow in Kiss and Tell! You can use my affiliate code for 15% off (SlashedBeauty) 💜 I just tapped it over the ColourPop shadow stix in Gimme a Sign
I think the climate that you live in also plays a factor in how these will wear. I loved this review.I may have to try them.
Very true, though I did travel for that second test so I wasn’t in the desert anymore!
I haven't tried them, but I've been curious. I love the name(the shortened version) I think it's so cute. I'm a sucker for packaging and cute names. May God bless 💙💙
It really is cute packaging!
Is the sticking similar to the tacky feeling of the maybelline vinyl inks?
Also you look gorgeous in that sweater- it really compliments your hair and face !
For some reason the Vinyls don't bother me as much but yes, it is similar! And thank you!!
@ you’re welcome!! The vinyl doesn’t bother me either… I honestly think they are more hydrating or at least not as drying as a matte lip. I love a matte lip look but it’s harder in the winter when my lips are begging for balm lol
I love the color mascara tear 😢 Butttttt it was horrible on my lips it peels off and it's sticky. I don't know how anyone can wear them as a stain. Because it's so hard to get it off. I can use it as a blush !
I’m glad you’re at least able to use it as a blush!
@slashedbeauty me too I love the color 🩷
I hated these, but I should have known bc I don’t like matte lip products. On a different note, what is the pinky/purple glitter on your eyes? It’s beautiful and I need it!
Thank you!! It’s the Moira Chroma Light shadow in Kiss and Tell! You can use my affiliate code for 15% off (SlashedBeauty) 💜 I just tapped it over the ColourPop shadow stix in Gimme a Sign!
I have never been able to wear matte lip products. It's a big no for me. I am resigned to the fact that I'll just be re-applying my lip color throughout the day, not a problem for me! But if you can tolerate it, more power to you!!!😉
I get that! I'm not a matte lip person either unless it’s a comfort formula like the Milani color fetish matte lipsticks, or the revlon ones!
I feel like these would work for me, because I don't like glompy lipstick.
❤❤❤
Thanks for watching!!
I bought 2 different colors and I regret it. Super drying and now they will go in the trash. I paid $15.99 each, so $30 total and it was a bad choice. I even added a lip balm ahead of time and the formula turned really nasty, I had to wipe it off.
Before you trash them, try them as blushes! Could be a better way for you to get use out of them and not have it be a complete waste!
@@slashedbeautyI will take you up on that. Thanks for the response, that’s awesome. 😀😀😀 Fingers crossed they apply well on my cheeks. P.S I love your channel, super informative.
Hello girl from your neighbor from Vegas
Hey there!!
Hate this product. The stickiness is too much and not comfortable at all. Don’t waste your money.
it's definitely a love it or hate it product!
First 🎉
Glad you're here!!