Edifier R1700BT vs JBL LSR305 || Sound Demo
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 มิ.ย. 2024
- Edifier R1700BT on amazon US: amzn.to/2l9Nldd
Edifier R1700BT on amazon DE: amzn.to/2nH5Fi7
JBL LSR305 on amazon US: amzn.to/2lwHShG
JBL LSR305 on amazon DE: amzn.to/2nc3vDa
Twice the price equals twice the sound? Judge for yourself ;) If You are serious about sound quality than JBL should be on Your list. If You look for fun mutlimedia speakers, than more functional Edifier might be better choice, that saves You quite a lot of money. If You have any quastions, feel free to ask in the comment section. Cheers!
Tracks:
00:00 Moonshine - Katie Melua
01:11 Dumb Disco Ideas - Holy Ghost!
02:30 Shofukan - Snarky Puppy
03:46 Purania - Destrage
04:53 Voice - Hiromi, Anthony Jackson, Simon Phillips
06:12 Wthite Noise - Disclosure
Sound Recorded with Tascam DR-22WL recorder. Levels matched. - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![[Live] : ONE 167 วันนี้!! "ตะวันฉาย vs โจ"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/D9_dvfIa6Ao/mqdefault.jpg)
My full written review of Edifier R1700BT is available here: digitalstereophony.blogspot.com/2016/03/mackie-cr4-and-edifier-r1700bt-budget.html
My full written review of JBL LSR305 is available here: digitalstereophony.blogspot.com/2015/07/jbl-lsr305-review.html
1900 vs any?
Thanks for this updated test format where you seamlessly blend the speakers. This video really deserves far more views than all the useless opinion reviews where colorful terms are used to describe the speakers but you have no idea what the speakers sound like.
Thank You George! Me too, I was sick of reading to all those "reviews" and imagining how reviewed speakers actually sound. After listening to many different speakers and comparing them with the reviews I had read, I found them 90% marketing BS, than I decided it is time to create something (hopefully) more useful, hence this channel ;) Cheers!
You know what would be even better? A dynamic website that lets the user choose any 2 - 4 speakers to compare and then the website would dynamically blend the audio. Wouldn't even need the video and you would only need a photo of the speakers. Then let the user flip speakers when they want, and maybe even have a blind mode where the speakers are hidden from view.
Site like this is on my mind for quite some time now, except for blind test, it is also a good idea on You side ;) For now I am trying to grow my channel on YT, but in the near future I think this site will become a reality as well
@@DSAUDIOreview you're a hero!
I agree. In reviews they throw these terms that you dont know sound in reality. I found this channel last night and I like this kind of review of speakers. Of course the sound comes through TH-cam compression and every headphone sounds different, but still you can hear the difference.
Thank you so much for posting all of your videos. I have been trying to decide between many desktop/bookshelf speakers and because of your videos I've finally been able to decide to pull the trigger on the Edifier 1700bt! Before I thought they were some glamorized and highly praised speakers just on amazon by basic users but after hearing the sound tests, WOW they are great.
+NeverEndingProject for the money they are very good for sure. I can not say they are the last word in transparency or natural tone, but for what they are, which is fun multimedia speaker, they are great. Cheers!
Digital Stereophony thanks! And where do you get those small foam inserts that are placed under your speakers?
Look for something like this: amzn.to/2i7ZHFK , or like this www.thomann.de/pl/the_takustik_isopad.htm . I use the latter. Cheers!
Okay awesome thank you very much! Have a nice day!
I will own the R1700BT speakers. I think their v-shape would be great for low volume level Hi-Fi sound according to "Fletcher-Munson" curves and bonus that it has the boost treble and bass functions. I plan to listen to these below 40db 👍
Considering the price difference between the two (completely different brackets basically), Edifier sounds pretty darn good for what they are....
True
Btw, thanks for introducing me to Katie Meluna... I end up buying her Secret Symphony album :D. What a great voice!
i love mine, not as much room for expansion though but for the price you cant beat em.
Those Edifier are very impressive, i listen it on cheap genius that i want to change and i m very impressed by this r1700bt, thx for all your video, i think i will buy this edifier build but price is not so far than the r1800bt build so i check it, new subscriber here, cheers :)
The JBL's dominated, but for twice the price that's not surprising, lol.
Think I'm going to get the R1700BT's because they are the best speakers I've seen within my $150 budget.
wtf the edifier had more low response and warmer, but the JBL probably better with a sub
@@Healcraft That's true. But at double the price plus the cost of a sub? Maybe for that sort of money Swan has a superior alternative, e.g. D1090.
I can tell that the edifiers are missing some content, especially around the crossover region. I'm guessing between two and four kilohertz. That said, they are still very easy to listen to, not shouty, and are significantly less expensive. For non-critical listening, the edifiers are a steal
Good videos, you help me a lot. Could you take other songs for testing? I would like a Nightwish song in your tests, like "Sleeping Sun" for example.
These are the ones I have.......very happy with them.
i keep watching these to check out the edifiers, but as soon as the rock music hits the jbl's really start to shine
It is all about that midrange... R1700BT can not compete with JBL on midrange clarity and quality
i mainly listen to rock and heavier music is there anything you recommend around the same price range as the edifiers that pick up the full range better? i love how full the jbl's sound but am looking for something in the starters price range that i could work up from later
I really like the quality of my edifier speakers.
The Purania fragment doesn't sound better on the JBL , that's not what I would have expected and the sounds seems a bit more coloured in the 1 khz region.
Through my AKG K712's, the JBL wins on clarity. The Edifiers win on warmth, but at the cost of some clarity/transparency, and can be a little 'boomy' at times. btw, I have the R1700BT, using bluetooth, and find them very good on PC for gaming, films, TH-cam etc. My other PC has the Swan M200D+, costing double the price of the Edifiers but are a distinct step up for music of all genres.
Что за теплота, прозрачность?
Вы точно звук описываете?
@@back_to_life0 That's a simple question, but it's hard to answer. I say that partly because the Edifiers are better after I switched from bluetooth to PC optical >> Aune dac. Whilst they still sound quite different from the Swans, I can no longer judge either as being preferable to the other. I have to say though, that I now listen to the Edifiers more than the Swans. Considering this, the Edifiers may compare favorably to the JBL, but I've never heard the latter live. Regarding what I referred to as 'warmth', I think that entails a slightly higher output in the upper bass/lower mid frequencies, with less pronounced lower highs. 'Clarity' perhaps translates to 'low level of distortion' throughout the spectrum, plus an effective JBL wave guide configuration. It would need lab gear to verify. I have only my ears, and a sparce vocabulary :)
JBL really nailed a full sound and defined mid-range with these which is easier to accomplish with larger drivers and a higher price, but for $150 or less the Edifiers are great for the everyday listener.
are the 1700 good as tv speaker and as well as bluetooth speaker? thanks
so just got the edifiers for 87 euros !!! like 100 bucks , love em to death , even tho one day I'll get some higher end stuff for now they're amazing !
Well spent 87 euros ;) R1700BT is a nice speaker to start audio journey. Cheers!
Thanks for the videos. I've watched quite a few of them now and they're much appreciated.
My question: would a setup with the JBL LSR305's justify spending 3 times the amount that some Edifier R1800T3's would cost?
I have the money available for both, it's more of a question of whether or not they're worth it. This is under my current market circumstances. Unless I act soon on the Edifier's, it would be more like 2 times the cost to get the JBL's.
Honestly no, JBL is not worth 3 times as much as R1800. Get Edifier and save some money for other stuff ;)
Thanks. I've just ordered some R1800T3 speaks for £80.
Come back with Your thoughts on them!
Will do! By the way, if they were the same price would you pick the R1700 or R1800? Any advantages one has over the other? Noticed a lot more R1700 have sold on Amazon but can't quite put my finger on why. Is the finish on the sides of the R1800 a problem (scratch magnet?)
If you're comparing them the JBL speakers are like a lot better. The sound is much more rich and I can sense the smallest bit of distortion on the Edifiers, but when you're comparing them in terms of price to performance the Edifiers win without question
LSR305... great balance, great sound.
The JBL's bass port is on the back, you have to keep distance from the wall for their low-end to shine.
For half the price the Edifiers are not so bad
javierpumarodriguez actually both are champ in their own price. I am obsessed with both of them. I want both
they are cool for listen to music, but very not flat for mixing in a home studio ... and the R1280T too ... check the freq response on google ......
the JBL have a hollow around 9kHz but are more flat, better for a home studio than edifier .....
Minexpose B hey hey i have both myself but lsr 308 mkll instead and waiting for the edifier coming next week....cant wait to listen to them.
@@georcoteso how did those Edifiers R1700 turn out for your room and ears in compared to this video? :)
@@cjmaritz let me tell you! These little edifier sound superb, i can’t compare with my 8inches jbl because they are not covering the same range but they are just sounding beautifully quality is really nice, for the price you can’t be wrong! Also hard to answer your question because i am listening this video with the edifier so i don’t know how it sounds for you but for me it is perfect highs and low are present but just a little shy on mids.
I am thinking of getting the jbl lsr305s and i saw some post on the internet about then hissing and also some volume issues. have u heard any of that with your pair? thx in advance.
+STEPHEN BAILEY hissing is on par with other active monitors at this price level, not better not worse. I had no problems with volume though
congratulations for you videos.,. for music what is the best edifier or the other one., thanks.,
For the music JBL is top choice, it is worth the extra over Edifier. Cheers!
Love the Flat sound of the JBL speakers. They sound like monitors. The Edifiers are not half bad, but they have problems keeping up with the mid ranges, if you compare them to a Microlab speaker and these JBL.
JBL here is for music, choir, ballad, piano sonata
Edifier is for all around audio needs except record editing
Hi I really enjoyed your video? What do you think which is better between klipsch 2.1 promedia vs Harman Kardon soundsticks 3 vs edifier r1700bt? I typically play games and listen to music
I can not give You my opinion which is better, I only tested Edifier
thanks for the review, shows how the Edifier R1700BT matches up with speakers at that level. Currently running the R1280T, should i move up to the R1700BT?
Yes you must
@@cybercoretv1793 i bought them, no regrets!
Hola , Saludos desde Colombia 🇨🇴 para conectar con TV? Cuál es mejor?
what if we cut bass a little and raise treble slighlty? wouldnt be way closer to JBL, which doesnt need any adjustments at all IMO.
I use headphones 90% of time so i take edifiers r1600 to save money (dont need BT) If feel i need more sound i go for JBL as next step for sure - they sounds perfect. Great reviews BTW.
Rising the treble on R1700BT is the opposite of what I would do, it needs a bit of cut up there to sound more natural. Also bass needs to be tamed a bit as well...
if i buy one single speaker of jbl LSR305 is this would give good sound output ? or buy pair ? i have budget issue so.....
JJJ BBB wait till Christmas they will most likely be 200 for a pair
Your choice jbl studio 104 or edifier 1700 bt?
Listening to this on AKG K712 Pros which are fairly neutral and flat headphones on a Creative ZxR. These two speakers sound incredibly close in many of the tests. For the price difference, Edifier is a much better buy between these two. JBL may have a few subtle advantages, but the Edifier is offering FAR more sound for your money in this particular test. However, the JBLs obviously have stronger sound overall, as evidenced with the metal music. Much better distorted guitars.
The R2000DB is a much better comparison to the JBL LSR305s in price, and outperforms the R1700BT by a good margin.
I agree that R1700BT is great value for money and about 90% of sound quality of JBL, yet I will insist that those 10% in JBL is worth the extra for someone looking for more natural, honest and dynamic sound.
Regarding R2000DB, I already have tested them and the comparisons are coming, both with R1700BT and JBL, so stay tuned as the results may surprise You ;) Cheers!
I have the Edifier S1000DBs and they totally outperform my friend's JBL LSR305s in just about every category. However that may be due to my less than ideal placement of the JBLs when testing. I haven't done enough A to B testing to say definitively whether one or the other holds a major advantage. Just to my ears the Edifiers had a more pleasing sound especially sweeter treble. A little less harsh but with the same extension. Also brand bias is a factor here. I like Edifier and feel that JBL is over-rated a little.
Also, you can definitely hear the plastic sound in the JBLs. It's unmistakable.
Как вы думаете, с м JBL аудио 3-6 (3-8) в сравнении?
Regardless Price Tags = JBL
Half the Price = Edifier
Quite a match
For clarity , I go for JBL
thinking the same. the jbl is slightly superior. but for half the price I'll be happy with edifier.
i will pick JBL LSR305 but considered the price, R1700 still the best on it price.
If you want I sell my edifier r1700bt speakers like new with the box 35 € cheaper
I sell them because I'm moving and I can't have them anymore, they work perfectly
На этой демонстрации отлично слышно, что такое нейтральный мониторный звук во всём спектре, когда всё "сидит" на своих местах и никуда не вылезает. Thank You! ;)
JBL’s have brighter highs and mids and would be better for studio monitor, but if I’m going to listen to music for an hour or two, I’ll take the Edifiers.
Tenho uma R1700BT, perdi o controle remoto e , para minha decepção e incômodo, não existe botão para desligar a função bluetooth no corpo da caixa de som.
Resultado: quando ligo a caixa entra o som do vizinho!!!
Brilhante! Parabéns a quem projetou esse trambolho!
You can turn the btooth on/off without remote
The speakers are not level-matched - the JBLs are louder.
Hi, did you listen to the Edifier R1700BT via bluetooth (is there any difference compared to rca inputs)? Do you know something about the built-in dac quality and what's the max bitrate when using via bluetooth? Thanks
Bluetooth quality in R1700BT is OK, but is a downgrade audible from the sound quality compared to analog inputs. I do not know its exect specification though. I find R1800BT to be a bit better in this department (R1800BT has Bluetooth 4.0 where R1700BT has Bluetooth 3.0)
Digital Stereophony thanks, it would be really intresting to listening to your comparsions between rca and bluetooth input at the exact models. If you could do this, I would really appreciate that :)
And one more question: do you have an option to test the R2730DB 3-way speakers?
rly appreciate inclusion of "white noise" great track for comparison
It is a cool track with interesting bass effects, that is why it's here. Cheers!
can you review F&D B60bt?
Hello!
i have a question , do Jbl lsr 305 & 308 have a hiss when they are not conected with audio cable , just powered ?
Thank You
Hey.Just did a test with my LSR 305 pair.The result after I closed all the windows and shut down everything that could make noises in the room is a very silent hiss than can be heard within a 0,5-1m radius.With a normal working PC it's' impossible to hear if you don't put your head like 20-30 cm near them.
What Egor Bobich said. JBL and most active speakers I tested, have a bit of hiss. Should this bother You depends on Your room and the distance between You and the speakers. If You have very silent room and often listen to music on low levels than this may bother You. But more often than not, this hiss disappears in the backgroud noise of the room.
Digital Stereophony.I want to thank you for all the tests that you provide! Because of them, I'm a happy owner of the LSR 305 for 3 months now and completely satisfied with my purchase.As well my friends when we get to hang out outside the city ;)
Egor Bobich Thanks, I appreciate that. It always makes me happy when my work is usefull to anybody ;) Cheers!
Thank you .Iwas thinking I am the only one that hear this hiss I use a fanless PC .
Oddly enough I preferred the female vocals on the Edifier, which is strange to me since the LSR305 is in a different league in all other categories. They just sounded more natural, organic.
I would choose JBL LSR305.
Here is the thing, i also liked 305s sound more, but i bought 1700bt. Why? because
1)i dont wanna have 2 speakers which BOTH need to be connected to the socket (i have reason for that... Also, too many cables... :)
2)They are a little too big for my not so big desk.(im not a studio guy, just need good desktop speakers for entertainment).
3)JBL have no grill i guess?And they look too "professional" maybe :)i like edifiers design more, as desktop speakers.
4)bluetooth better than no bluetooth:)and lower price also better.
So... everyone has different needs... And in soundquality, there is not a huuuge difference.
may i ask you to describe/compare hiss level of the two?
thanks in advance!
+ihmazoh Edifier has big upper bass boost and less extension down low compared to JBL, it is also a bit slow due to heavy bass reflex use. JBL is much more natural and extended, also more detailed in low end without artificial upper bass boost.
I got Edifier R1800TIII speakers which have similar specs as R1700BT version. I realized that when I turn the volume max. up without any source connected i can hear quite loud hiss coming out of the speakers. I like JBL's sound however curious whether they are quieter comparing to R1700BT ?
Hi Digital Stereophony,
I'm between the JBL LSR305 with an audio interface (Steinberg UR22 MK2) and the Soundblasterx Katana soundbar (by Creative). Do you have any experience regarding the Katana ? I only listen to music and play somes games time to time. The Katana is 300euros and the JBL with the Steinberg is 430 euros. Can you please tell me your opinion ?
Thank you
+George PNF If Your main focus is music than do not hasitate and get JBL. You can also spare Yourself some money and go for cheaper interface like Lexicon Alpha or Behringer UMC22. I use UMC22 as a spare solution and it works very well with JBL. The difference in sound quality between those two and Steinberg will be rather small.
Thank you for your quick responce. Which is better the Behringer UMC22 or the Lexicon Alpha ? I don't produce music. And another thing that I like to have physical knobs for treble, bass, volume not the pc's equalizers. Do you have any idea ?
Kind regards
I would say they are about equal soundwise but UMC22 is a bit better build and better looking. Regarding physical tone controls, unfortunately neither of interfaces will have them (including Steinberg). There are tone switches for bass and treble (+2dB, 0dB, -2dB) on back of JBL monitors though.
Magnat multimonitor 220 vs jbl?
I vote for the edifier r1700bt
Better frequency response
If you want I sell my edifier r1700bt speakers like new with the box 35 € cheaper
I sell them because I'm moving and I can't have them anymore
They work perfectly
Edifier 👍👍
JBL: Well balanced, clear mids, crisp highs, flat response
Edifier: Doesn't sound too bad but it's more like a Coloring Boom Box
I think Edifier Team targets the Masses- men, boys, ladies, party people. regular joes, kitchen moms etc etc.
JBL team targets sophisticated ears
How would you hook the jbl’s up to a turntable.
Try cables like this: amzn.to/2ztjZ1v just remember that JBL has two independent volume regulators on back of each speaker so it would be a plus if Your turntable had variable output and a remote. This way You set the volume on JBL once and control it from turntable from there.
I think the Edifer's sound way richer. Speakers that utilize horn tweeters sound way to bright for me and will cause listener fatigue. They are typically way more efficient though, and should go way louder.
Greetings, I want to start composing music and I´d like to ask if these JBL are good choice. Thank you. :)
JBL is the best choice in this price range ;)
Ok, thanks for quick response. :)
Edifier here is colored, not good for monitoring musical instruments
just picked up R1700BT 105USD in indo
LMAO for the price Edifiers are definitely a win.... $97 vs $270
Adjust the treble +3dB and i think these can match the JBL's if you're a college student like me
Aizad Nik Here its Like 150€ vs 205€ for the jbl
$97, serously? I paid $150 but love my Edifiers. The days when I could afford whatever I want are behind me. Great to see awesome technology at steal-deal prices, these days.
$97.. Where?
3:49 says it all!
What's that thing in the middle of the two monitors?
Rogers the microphone
Microphone- to pick up the sound of the speakers
JBL é um verdadeiro monitor de áudio, enquanto a R1700BT uma caixa multimídia de excelente qualidade. As frequências do JBL são balanceadas em equilíbrio para se produzir música (inputs profissionais). No entanto, a Edifier ganha no custo benefício se a intenção for diversão (inputs RCA).
HI dear , i loved your videos. and thanks for using this audio capturing device.
i need some advice. i need to place a studio under budget what best for refrencing audio among edifier R1600/1700/1800/1900. Since 1900 has a bigger cone i find highs and mids argueble. thanks mate and love u for this.
I have tested R1700BT, R1800BT and R2000DB and out of these three R2000DB is the best sounding speaker but only by a very little marging over R1700BT and R1800BT (which sound the same). If the price difference between R2000DB and two other is very small than I would go with it, but If the price difference is bigger than 20% than R1700BT/R1800BT is better value for money.
man ! amzing ~ one more point that i have in mind is R1900 tv has a bigger cone/woofer size that really is pushing me to discuss 1900TV again and again .
bcz the store here in my location only offer 1700,1800Tiii and 1900 . I love 2000DB but no ones shipping it to Pakistan cost effectively.
Great review first an foremost. Second, please include 1 or two rap/hip-hop songs so that viewers can check for the bass reproduction in songs they are more familiar with. Some suggestions:
Kanye West: Can't tell me nothing
Lecrae: Welcome to America.
Jay-Z: Somewhereinamerica
J Cole: Change
Kanye West: Father stretch my hands (part 1 and especially part 2)
I will try to include some hip hop tracks soon, but they will not be anything like the tracks You mentioned because of copyright issues.
studio monitor vs hi fi speaker sound
True
soundcloud.com/dedskin/dedskin-g-funk-feat-eminem-big-g this is me
im educated in electronics 4 years , phd in electroacoustics 3 years , 10 years in studio ... so if you need i guy like me , im here
and , then its true it can be heard over recorded , even compressed material :)
I want a pair of speakers for my computer.Which would yo recommend.The jbl 305s edifier 1700 or krk rokit5?II just want the one thatll sound best for gaming and watching videos
Even from a recording, the relative difference in quality between these speakers can be heard. It is clear that LSR305 has much more defined bass. The mid range on LSR305 is better but not significant, as the female vocal of Moonshire sounds quite natural on the R1700BT. Treble is both brighter and clearer from the LSR305 as we can hear more "air" details from it.
I read the description, the funny thing is I'd prefer "sound quality" for "fun multimedia speakers". XD
Overwhelm bass and unbalanced tonal make me sad.
but the edifiers have treble and bass knobs for a bit of adjustment to your liking
Edifier has impressive bass but not natural. Because of this, many will prefer buying it for practical reasons
Dicen que son dificiles de eq porque en digital domina su controlador en todo momento
Good video but these are totally different speakers. Jbl are mid entry level monitors with flat response. The edifiers are for multimedia and music listening
Edifier still has a solid quality for less price. Edifier has more bass and a bit held back mids while JBL hss more pronounced mids. But kudos to Edifier.....
Thank you Digital stereophony for this vid. Now i have a picture of hiw a *flat* speaker should sounds like foremost *studio monitor* . My FR sounds like this but with less bass since it has 4.5".
Edifer R1700BT vs Alesis Elevate 5 any opinions?
Take the R1700BT. I will post comparison between R1700BT and Elevate 5 soon so stay tuned!
Will do, Thank's Champ
Thank's Champ, i bought the R1700BT arrived today, Sounds GREAT to Me, im no audio expert, still i know when i hear shit speakers and these are not that kind, nice sound hehehe.. thumbs up for these great reviews YOU do..
I am happy to hear that! Cheers!
1st demo :Female vocals has more presence on JBL.
HOLY GHOST: Edifier has tighter bass
Here in Perú this Edifier cost $201
Octubre 2020 , Perú 215$. Pero creo que aun lo vale 😄
JBL hands down. Not a fair comparison tho.
There is no competition, Edifier are more balanced and clean than JbL sound that seem boxed.
Below average speaker.Local RCA cables
Edifier R1700BT i vote for price is not so far
The JBL LSR305 outgun, outpower & outpunch the R1700BT on treble, vocal & especially bass without a muddy bass at all. The R1700BT are not a bad speaker but the LSR305 are just better & definitely worth the upgrade.
У JBL LSR305 || середина очень окрашена - это со временем надоест. У Edifier R1700BT звук более нейтрален. За Edifier R1700BT+!
у Edifier R1700BT как не удивительно вылезают басы и порой гулкие, что добавляет драйва! :) у JBL LSR305 бас стучит и совсем не гудит! )
Подтверждаю,,, у 1700 гудящий бас, колонки не способны играть низ, но им накрутили низ, в итоге получаем гудящий не читаемый низ, если крутили повернуть то пропадет гул но и пропадет звук вообще на низах
.
Так же на 1700 плохие вч как на 2850 они не натуральные..
1700единственнре что красиво выглядит больше ничего
Edifier R1700)
Jbl сильно приближены к стене, от туда и меньше баса
damned, video not available in germany.
Sorry to hear that. You have some strict internet and copyright laws there TBH...
yes indeed.
you are right. problem occured only with ipad - on pc its fine, but i dont know why *confused*
Horst Schimanski it's the same in Romania on all mobile devices .
I'm from Germany and I have no trouble watching tis vid at all???
Edifier smoother
소리 크기 레벨이 안맞네요. JBL 꺼가 더 크게 들립니다.
In this price：Sure Edirier,for Home Hi fi👍👍, if for studio monitior:JBL 👍
in real life, edifier lacks of stereo image and compress the bass too much. I had edifier r200t and jbl 305 and edifier is good for tv.
LSR305 sound too good. No match. Effortlessly. For the price, r1700bt won the best value buy.
Two good speakers but bass sounds more natural on the Edifier. JBL sounds “tinny”.........
Edifier r1700 bt
Edifier is certainly more boomier, for some it's a downside and some enjoys it. the JBL is on th other hand is a flat sounding studio monitor.
JE vais paraitre dur avec JBL mais je trouve que les EDIFIER sonne bien mieux c’est plus chaleureux moins sec que JBL
Si vous voulez je vends mes Edifiers r1700bt en parfait état de marche quasiment neuves avec le carton etc 35€ moins chères sur leboncoin
Je les vends car je déménage et je ne peux plus me permettre de les garder
acabo de comprar los 1700 y me han decepcionado un poco, sonido poco claro y distorsionado
Depende del genero musical. En musica acustica suena perfecto para mi. Como boleros, soul, jazz, etc
For me, JBLs sound a bit better.
same xd
Edifier sound better to me...
Edifiers sound muddy bass. JBL bass is more defined and less boomy.
Edifiers sound cleaner to me definitely!
Calidad sonido: JBL
Estética: EDIFIER
Precio calidad: ?
i was about to buy edifier but in every comparison video edifier crashed by others
Jbl much more better
JBL better but cost twice
Купил r1700bt, что бы слушать Пинк Флойд. Разочаровался блин, звук отвратительный(
Jbl win