I hope we all know that it doesn't matter who is in the 'top job' because this is a systemic problem -- greed. We have allowed many of our economic sectors, to take advantage of the American people. It's disgusting and frightening for the future of our country. My husband and I will be retiring in the next two years n another country. We are absolutely worried that SSI will no longer be funded. we'll have to rely on his pension, a 403 (b) and a very prolific lnvestment account with my Abby Joseph Cohen my FA. Our national debt is bloating and expanding every month. Our government needs to get spending under control and cut the federal budget.
I went from no money to lnvest with to busting my A** off on Uber eats for four months to raise about $20k to start trading with Abby Joseph Cohen. I am at $128k right now and LOVING that you have to bring this up here
Abby Joseph Cohen Services has really set the standard for others to follow, we love her here in Canada 🇨🇦 as she has been really helpful and changed lots of life's
It definitely does matter who gets the top job. I don't disagree with your point about systemic issues at all, but don't fall into the trap of believing it doesn't matter.
@ Wrong. The current immigrants are the ones who settled in USA. Europeans actually colonized the US by getting rid of native American population. Almost 90% of native American population were wiped off due to European colonization.
1. Born.. and 2. Subject to jurisdiction. These are coupled requirements. Just getting pregnant and deliver baby in the US does not make anyone automatically become a citizen. That’s absurd!
@@Tellmewhynow It's very clearly written in the 14th amendment. It can't be changed by executive order, only by a new amendment which is not likely. It's purposely made difficult to change.
if an ilegal emigrant breaks the law his is considered to be subject to jurisdiction of America. Diplomats when they break the low they are not considered to be subject to jurisdiction of America and the process to persecute them is much more complex. So yes even ilegal emigrants are subject to jurisdiction of America when they are in the country,
This is part of Project 2025. They are going to just go ahead and do all this illegal shit, because who's going to stop them? Heritage Society wants to see how much crap they can get away with to bring forth their grand design. Please graciously inform us how Biden Ignored the constitution.
Then the 3rd Mrs Trump and her psrents wouldn't have been so lucky! Not to mention all the politicians and others he knows who fall into the same club with marriages & births
As an Indian I agree. Else this will just become a thing where everyone who comes to any country to work will simply birth kids there and take advantage of the system. This should esp be a policy in countries where quality of life is very good. Why are so many ppl flocking to US? Obv it's better than the quality of the lifestyle they had in their home country. Unless they have permanent citizenship, ban this practice. Immigration and citizenship should be strictly on how well they can contribute to the country, the better they can, process the citizenship faster. The less they can, process it slower or simply don't give it. A nation's economy and safety is dependent on the ppl who live there and contribute. And that includes legal immigrants as well. Many times if they commit a crime, deporting becomes an issue if they already are an American citizen. And if they are sent to prison while on work visa or green cards, but their kids got citizenship, this makes it even more tough and foreign embassies get involved. Be very careful to those who you give that citizenship to. This will also control the massive flood of work visas. Allowing ppl to can truly contribute really well to enter the US confidently, knowing they can set up a family there. A country's future depends on that. In India we had the "Any child born in India, foreign or Indian is automatically Indian citizen" We scraped this act in 1950. Thing is Indian citizenship is not that glamorous. Only illegals from neighboring countries want to enter India because conditions here are better than there and since country is so populated, they stay hidden.
As an Indian you don't know a damn thing about our Constitutional Rights. Maybe your Third World nation forbids birthright citizenship as a way of denying human rights to people, but human rights are upheld by the Constitution of the United States of America. As a non-citizen you need to get educated and avoid speaking on subjects you know nothing about. It only makes you look foolish.
Finally a sane comment with understanding of how stuff works. I'm seeing a lot of stupidity in the comments section otherwise. A lot of stupid americans themselves not understanding that he's doing it for their own good.
I agree with Trump. Citizenship for babies from an alien should only be granted to greencard holders, ancestry citizenship, or citizenship by way of naturalization. That's the way it is in my country as well.
You are likely a product of citizenship by birthright, So, when you leaving? Unless you are an indigenous native, pre-European invasion, you are the product of immigrants and this ineligible for citizenship. Buh bye
Your country is an autocratic Third World farm, and trump's word for it rhymes with "Withhold", accent on the first syllable. And you're what it's full of.
I'm a second generation birthright citizen and this is wrong no matter what you think about it.I know people in this country that their parents are dead so what are they supposed to do,leave I don't think.If you agree with this your inhumane.
@@christinaweibel5747If they are here illegally they should leave or try to get a green card. I’m sure there will be exceptions made in extreme circumstance’s for certain people depending on the situation…? The main focus of this is to stop people from using pregnancy for citizenship and other things
You just need ONE citizen parent or a immigrant parent that has their green card. Trump is a citizen so Baron is also entitled to citizenship regardless of his mother's status. Also it's not a retroactive law, so even if both of his parents were illegals, he would be safe (for now at least)
The UK abolished it in 1983. I live in the Nederlands, no automatic birth rights here. America was one of the few western countries still giving automatic birthrights. In Europe most countries stopped in years ago. Please check your facts mainstream media. The lies you tell, we are all fed up of them.
Yourrrrrr an idiot, his wife came to the US LEE-GAL-EE. Legal = citizenship Illegal criminal behavior = pay the consiquences Play stipid games, get stipid prizes
Hallo. Ich folge dir und alle deine Videos sind eine große Hilfe! Meine Frage ist: Wie beginne ich mit dem Krypto-Handel? Mein neuer Händler, der für mich handelt und
JA! Das ist genau ihr Name (Mrs Janie). Ich habe ihr Interview bei CNN News gesehen und so viele Leute haben sie und ihre Handelsfähigkeiten wärmstens empfohlen❤️
He's a criminal... he does care. He'll sign whatever they shove under his nose. He's just a rubber stamp figurehead for what religious wackos want to get done.
@louniece1650 just goes to show the cult members how dumb trump is he can not use a executive order to change constitutional amendment that takes a act of congress
It should apply to ANYONE who is NOT a legal citizen -- and THAT includes people, who are here on a "Visa" and Green cards -- you are NOT a legal citizen! Neither of these things should have EVER given you a right to what "legally" BELONGS to citizens ONLY! It's that simple; THIS is NOT complicated! You're TRYING to complicate this because you've been taking ADVANTAGE of this and US and have been getting away with it for YEARS!!
Your US govt allowed it. If they had not allowed it from the beginning... No question of even mentioning it. So US has been at fault for allowing birth right citizenship. But anyways in US everyone is an immigrant except native americans if u really go by the book. ... Just very pale skin doesn't make you a native... U guys mostly came from Europe, shitty Ireland ( weather wise) and England and else where... Go back to Europe"
Your yapping isn't gonna do anything the richest person in your country is also an legal immigrant. If that got cancelled nobody is gonna come to us have to say good bye to capitalism. Can you guys even do that, u guys will die without capitalism
@infinitecosmos917 Our govt. may have allowed for whatever reason; that doesn't change the fact that it was NEVER legal. And your weak attempt to claim that "everyone" is an immigrant is just that -- weak. We've established "legal laws" since that time and then and NOW everyone is NOT an immigrant. And your argument ONLY proves that you and others -- like you -- already KNOW that you're here "illegally". And that your intent was to exploit and take advantage of this law -- which Trump will NOW put a stop to. The "legal" American people have made it CLEAR (back in November of 2024) that we're NOT going to stand by and allow you (and others) to exploit us and our laws ANYMORE -- and it's "you" who will be going back to wherever you came from...
@@hara_reddy My yapping is doing so much -- you're reacting to it! And we don't need anybody "coming" to our country. The ones coming are the ones benefitting the MOST -- not those of us who already here. I'm sure capitalism isn't gonna ANYWHERE, no matter who we prevent from coming. And we definitely won't die without it -- try again...
@yvettepitts5467 u saying weak doesn't make it weak ... Look at the facts and talk... I am not in US u moron, I am in my country may be ur grand pa went to US illegally and produced u bunch. I know whites in America don't consider themselves as immigrants... But they are!!! Stop being in denial. And don't assume who ever is posting msg here is illegally in US... Ha ha ha... Ur thinking is tht limited? FYI I have visited ur country bit never thought of moving there like many....
Nope… president trump is just protecting the Americans from this abusers of the system…. Indians have destroyed Canadian immigration system… they are coming here as tourist and they are pregnant…intentionally giving birth in Canada to make their children Canadian citizen.
@@haridaspr4606come back to india ... Do the Modi ..Modi...Modi ...chants here ....why should we Indians alone should have all the fun....let the NRIs in USA too share the fun
@@Mrsplanetmaster9you have no idea what a true dictator is. You’re parroting what you hear. Research, read history books, study the wars and then claim he’s a dictator. Nice try. Stop parroting other idiots
Banning citizenship by birth is insane! The phrase he has interpreted does not mean he can do that, it means you are subject to the laws of the country.
@@Glenna10 also you only need one parent to be a citizen or have a greencard for citizenship to apply. It sounds like it only doesn’t apply if the greencard holder or citizen has a spouse that is illegally in the country. If the non-citizen or non-greencard holder parent is on a legal visa, the child would still get citizenship.
Donald Trump's grandparents and mother didnt come legally 😂 but since they white, they had no issues. Per constitution, if you care about your own laws, it says everyone born in US soil is American... now, there is people who abuse this and ofc they should control, but what you're saying is wrong. If anything, 99% of "Americans" are not. The only Americans are native people!!!
@@dennisg4053i have. It clearly states anyone born under US jurisdiction is a US citizen. That means anyone not a foreign dignitary or diplomat on US soil. Or do you honestly believe US laws don't apply to illegals on US soil? They can just do whatever they want then, huh? If the laws apply to them, then they're under US jurisdiction. If they're under US jurisdiction, then the 14th amendment gives their kids US citizenship. Not that complicated to comprehend basic English, comrade.
The constitution is an openly interpreted document to this day. The first and second amendment debates reflect that, as well as the interpretation used to legalize abortion and interracial marriage. Because the vague clause that was referenced in the video is in the document, its implementation is open to interpretation.
No, because he’s a citizen. If one parent is a citizen, they can pass citizenship to their children. It only applies if neither parent is a citizen or on a greencard.
If the parents do not have legal documents or permanent residency, it shall not be granted because somebody is born here, it's not controversial at all it's common sense. And I'm not a trump supporter I never will be.
"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof..." isn't applicable to undocumented (illegal) or temporary status immigrants; they are subjected to the jurisdiction of their country of origin. The original intent of the 14th amendment of the United States was to establish birthright citizenship to the former African American slaves post Civil War; it was never intended to be utilized as a pathway for undocumented (illegal) or temporary status immigrants to establish legal permanent status and/or birthright citizenship (anchor baby loophole. The original intent of the law has been corrupted. US v Wong Kim Ark 1898 decision was successful because his parents had legal permanent status, although his parents were still subjected to the jurisdiction of their country of origin(CCP). Trump has been game planning this since his first term and will stack the deck even more by the time this reaches the SCOTUS. He is going to replace 2 retiring Justices who will vote in favor of ending birthright citizenship/anchor baby loophole, then using the arguments posted to end birthright citizenship. This isn't changing an amendment... it's redefining the intent of the law via the Supreme Court of the United States. Presidential executive order is granted by the power of the executive branch and constitutional interpretation of laws are granted by the judicial branch of the United States Government.
Oh Lord… so many uninformed comments here. Good luck Mr. President on your executive order. Last I checked a presidential executive order cannot change an amendment to the constitution. It’s an arduous process that includes both houses of congress as well as the states… sigh
I hate to say this and I know this is ignorant, but I think this just applies to the Mexican border more than anything like it’s really sad and it’s really degrading because there’s so many people that want to come here to this country and make a difference, but after these past four years enough is enough, Democrats have broken. The rules have made our democracy more struggling than ever before and not I’m not saying that the Republicans are doing this as well but enough is enough but I believe in general that this applies to all countries that want becomes citizens they all have to go by the book now
There goes the economy. And why is trump surrounding himself with just rich people. 🤔 are you seriously thinking he will do anything for us littke people?
They have to refine it just for illegal immigrants and tourist. The Chinese here in Los Angeles comes here in IS just to give birth, so the child will have a dual citizen.
This only applies to non citizens. If a kid is born to citizens that kid is still a citizen regardless of Trump's executive orders unless it specifically targets that.
One should challenge this in court. Take an example of French father and Philippine mother, working in US, giving birth to a child in US. What should be the citizenship of the child. Principle of natural justice should prevail. This should be challenged in international courts
Not necessarily. The US is one of only a few western countries that actually has historically granted birthright citizenship. Many European countries would not grant it in that case either.
If this is applicable for illegal immigrants i agree to this. But being an H1b holder waiting in queue for green card long wait years, paid all.the tax, and it impacts legal immigrants Very ungrateful decision by our president, he always attacks legal immigrants on Imdians H1b legal workers
Isn’t it ironic! His mother born in Scotland, two of his wives born in Europe. He also chain migrated his in-laws. You think he would have some empathy and compassion of people emigrating to the USA. Strange isn’t it.
It doesnt work that way. He is a vengeful psychotic monster who thinks he owns the world. Whats COMPASSION have to do with anything? I wish he would take back mine, for what good it ever did me. Sorry I lived to reach this moment in history
They came the right way like everyone should do if they want to be a proud American. Not trespass and break into our country with their hands out for American tax payers to have to take care of.
They came the right way and were American citizens when their kids were born. Why are so many Americans so ignorant they don’t understand simple immigration laws? If anything Trump should do something about the education system that is making Americans dumber and dumber and it shows
I like to migrate to usa and become a honoured citizen in usa, maybe i didnt get any opportunity to live a peaceful,good life eventhough i am educated,and had god blessed talents in this peninsula.this life in this country is a tragedy for me..may God bless me for that .
Reliance group Mukesh luckily got grandchildren born in USA last year. See the power of money : do u like to have your children or grand children born and have USA citizenship? Please reply. thank you
Should do this as well by the next prime minister of Canada bec.theres a lot of people here in Canada who is not pr or Canadian citizen does this system taking advantage there is one person I know right now who is pregnant again but no status not working came here as tourist and now applying as refugees she told me that if she don't get here pr they just make a lot of babies and get a lot of child benefits what a shame people like me who has triple job just to make an end a lot of people taking advantage bec.of the system right now.
Why are all of you look so worried about this. only legal immigrants from india in USA from just two states in india and illegal immigrants from two more states in india should be worried 😂😂😂😂 the rest are minuscule
Dear Indians , we welcome you back to india where you can probably earn as much as in the USA pay taxes that are higher than in USA and get benefits like in Somalia 😂😂😂
Only if the baby is born in a hospital and the parents are known... People will give bith at home and drop off thier babies at any hospitals door step..
It will be good for Hindus who are intelligent and try to stay in America. Let them come and use their intellectual brain to Indian society development. You will earn less money, lot of corruption is there still they can stay in India and contribute to Indian economy. Now next destination for Indians is Russia and Canada. If they really want to migrate.
That means you can't just illegaly cross border, give birth and call yourself "american" without proper documents, have same rights as native americans. Its same rules in Europe, some of them are broken now by putin agents, but this will stop soon. Every country should protect their native people intrasts first, and allow other people to come in legaly with suitable documents, wich with time your children and granchildren gradualy will be native, not an instant like now, without knowing the language or knowing traditions and culture of America. People never respect what comes easy without an effort, and treat it like a trash. Healthy boundaries benefit everyone, even people who want to come to your country. Its also safety. I'm not american, but that how I see it.
@@spicyboy5330 America is not Europe. Most Americans are of immigrant background. It's not like Europe or Asia or Africa where regions have their native populations as the majority. Even Trump's parents are German immigrants and his wives are from Eastern Europe. That's why American identity is not a strong one.
I hope we all know that it doesn't matter who is in the 'top job' because this is a systemic problem -- greed. We have allowed many of our economic sectors, to take advantage of the American people. It's disgusting and frightening for the future of our country. My husband and I will be retiring in the next two years n another country. We are absolutely worried that SSI will no longer be funded. we'll have to rely on his pension, a 403 (b) and a very prolific lnvestment account with my Abby Joseph Cohen my FA. Our national debt is bloating and expanding every month. Our government needs to get spending under control and cut the federal budget.
I went from no money to lnvest with to busting my A** off on Uber eats for four months to raise about $20k to start trading with Abby Joseph Cohen. I am at $128k right now and LOVING that you have to bring this up here
Well her name is 'ABBY JOSEPH COHEN SERVICES'. Just research the name. You'd find her details to set up an appointment.
Abby Joseph Cohen Services has really set the standard for others to follow, we love her here in Canada 🇨🇦 as she has been really helpful and changed lots of life's
The very first time we tried, we invested $7000 and after a week, we received $9500. That really helped us a lot to pay up our bills.
It definitely does matter who gets the top job. I don't disagree with your point about systemic issues at all, but don't fall into the trap of believing it doesn't matter.
What an irony coz US itself is a land of European immigrants 😃
Exactly
Don't be a dumb ass. This policy has been taken advantage of.
The US was settled by Europeans so there's a bit of a difference between that and being an immigrant.
@ Wrong. The current immigrants are the ones who settled in USA. Europeans actually colonized the US by getting rid of native American population. Almost 90% of native American population were wiped off due to European colonization.
Right
1. Born.. and
2. Subject to jurisdiction. These are coupled requirements. Just getting pregnant and deliver baby in the US does not make anyone automatically become a citizen. That’s absurd!
@@Tellmewhynow Don't understand the Constitution, eh?
Like Donald Trump it self and his wife? 😅
The USA is a land of immigrants, and you only ever had to be born there to be American
@@Tellmewhynow It's very clearly written in the 14th amendment. It can't be changed by executive order, only by a new amendment which is not likely. It's purposely made difficult to change.
if an ilegal emigrant breaks the law his is considered to be subject to jurisdiction of America. Diplomats when they break the low they are not considered to be subject to jurisdiction of America and the process to persecute them is much more complex. So yes even ilegal emigrants are subject to jurisdiction of America when they are in the country,
It hasn't been yet. It would require constitutionality ammendment and will be definitely challenged in court
Correct, this will most likely not work...
Do you know who owns and runs the Supreme Court? Democracy is dead. The fall of America has begun.
And we're prepared to "back" Trump UP -- on this...
@@beyourself2444 It will -- work just watch...
WRONG....14th amendment does NOT guarantee birthright....try reading it....NOT THERE!!!!! Unless one of your parents is a citizen it does not apply.
By the way no one is American except aboriginal American.
Nope sorry Neanderthals have you beat.
Mike,stop coping my guy
They came from Asia. Native Americans don't exist. We are all immigrants to the Americas.
lol probably they should revoke their own citizenship as well 🤣
They got whooped a looooong time ago. Bye Felicia
Isnt he a birthright citizen
His kids are!
he's white though
They are LEGAL!
@@lolalustarbirthright citizen apply to legal too
Some intentionally choose birth-tourism just to get an American passport.
You can't blatantly ignore the constitution with an executive order.
Why not, that’s what Biden did!
Where does the Constitution guarantee birth right citizenship to the children of illegal aliens in the commission of a crime?
@@MAGA-z1h Exactly
@@jeffsaxton716 biden did foh
This is part of Project 2025. They are going to just go ahead and do all this illegal shit, because who's going to stop them? Heritage Society wants to see how much crap they can get away with to bring forth their grand design. Please graciously inform us how Biden Ignored the constitution.
Great decision. Should have happened decades ago.
Then the 3rd Mrs Trump and her psrents wouldn't have been so lucky! Not to mention all the politicians and others he knows who fall into the same club with marriages & births
Wow..what kind of human r u😮😊
It will be struck.down
Trump has no authority on stopping birthright citizenship only Congress and the states have that power to remove it
Decades ago would mean you'd be kicked out.
As an Indian I agree. Else this will just become a thing where everyone who comes to any country to work will simply birth kids there and take advantage of the system. This should esp be a policy in countries where quality of life is very good. Why are so many ppl flocking to US? Obv it's better than the quality of the lifestyle they had in their home country. Unless they have permanent citizenship, ban this practice. Immigration and citizenship should be strictly on how well they can contribute to the country, the better they can, process the citizenship faster. The less they can, process it slower or simply don't give it. A nation's economy and safety is dependent on the ppl who live there and contribute. And that includes legal immigrants as well. Many times if they commit a crime, deporting becomes an issue if they already are an American citizen. And if they are sent to prison while on work visa or green cards, but their kids got citizenship, this makes it even more tough and foreign embassies get involved. Be very careful to those who you give that citizenship to. This will also control the massive flood of work visas. Allowing ppl to can truly contribute really well to enter the US confidently, knowing they can set up a family there. A country's future depends on that. In India we had the "Any child born in India, foreign or Indian is automatically Indian citizen" We scraped this act in 1950. Thing is Indian citizenship is not that glamorous. Only illegals from neighboring countries want to enter India because conditions here are better than there and since country is so populated, they stay hidden.
As an Indian you don't know a damn thing about our Constitutional Rights. Maybe your Third World nation forbids birthright citizenship as a way of denying human rights to people, but human rights are upheld by the Constitution of the United States of America. As a non-citizen you need to get educated and avoid speaking on subjects you know nothing about. It only makes you look foolish.
Finally a sane comment with understanding of how stuff works. I'm seeing a lot of stupidity in the comments section otherwise. A lot of stupid americans themselves not understanding that he's doing it for their own good.
I agree with Trump. Citizenship for babies from an alien should only be granted to greencard holders, ancestry citizenship, or citizenship by way of naturalization.
That's the way it is in my country as well.
You are likely a product of citizenship by birthright, So, when you leaving? Unless you are an indigenous native, pre-European invasion, you are the product of immigrants and this ineligible for citizenship. Buh bye
Your country is an autocratic Third World farm, and trump's word for it rhymes with "Withhold", accent on the first syllable. And you're what it's full of.
I'm a second generation birthright citizen and this is wrong no matter what you think about it.I know people in this country that their parents are dead so what are they supposed to do,leave I don't think.If you agree with this your inhumane.
@@christinaweibel5747If they are here illegally they should leave or try to get a green card. I’m sure there will be exceptions made in extreme circumstance’s for certain people depending on the situation…? The main focus of this is to stop people from using pregnancy for citizenship and other things
@christinaweibel57not our problem its theirs 47
Well Baron is not a citizen and neither are his other children.
the law is not retroactive. So it doesn't apply to him. Also barron recieves his citzenship from his dad.
BS
If one parent is a citizen or on a greencard, the kid is a citizen under the executive order.
yes he is dummy
You just need ONE citizen parent or a immigrant parent that has their green card. Trump is a citizen so Baron is also entitled to citizenship regardless of his mother's status. Also it's not a retroactive law, so even if both of his parents were illegals, he would be safe (for now at least)
He hasn't done a damned thing. This is unconstitutional. But anyone who voted for him should have seen this coming.
have you read the constitution?
ha ha ha!I knew famous people traveling to the US just to deliver and get citizenship for their children .😊
The UK abolished it in 1983.
I live in the Nederlands, no automatic birth rights here.
America was one of the few western countries still giving automatic birthrights.
In Europe most countries stopped in years ago.
Please check your facts mainstream media.
The lies you tell, we are all fed up of them.
So does that mean he is going to deport his own kids??
This was a dumbass comment
His grandmother is illegal, so he should have his own citizenship revoked and deported.
Yourrrrrr an idiot, his wife came to the US LEE-GAL-EE. Legal = citizenship
Illegal criminal behavior = pay the consiquences
Play stipid games, get stipid prizes
😂😂😂😂
I doubt it. He'll just pardon them probably. The man is a hypocritical crook.
Hallo. Ich folge dir und alle deine Videos sind eine große Hilfe! Meine Frage ist: Wie beginne ich mit dem Krypto-Handel? Mein neuer Händler, der für mich handelt und
Was muss ich als Anfänger tun? Wie kann ich investieren, auf welcher Plattform? Wenn Sie etwas wissen, teilen Sie es uns bitte mit.
Ja, 253.000 von Janie TDM, freue mich auf den Erwerb eines neuen Hauses, Segen.
Danke, Janie, die mir immer mit detaillierten Analysen und Empfehlungen geholfen hat, zu denen ich sonst keinen Zugriff gehabt hätte.
JA! Das ist genau ihr Name (Mrs Janie). Ich habe ihr Interview bei CNN News gesehen und so viele Leute haben sie und ihre Handelsfähigkeiten wärmstens empfohlen❤️
Kann ich mit nur 1.000 $ beginnen?
Wait a minute does it take an act of Congress to actually do this after all we are talking about constitutional law right?
Yep. A LOT of the folks in congress. trump don' know dat, nor would he care if he did.
Maybe you never actually READ the 14th Amendment ?
He's a criminal... he does care. He'll sign whatever they shove under his nose. He's just a rubber stamp figurehead for what religious wackos want to get done.
@dennisg4053 I'm not even going to bother to respond to your illness
@@phiksitEducate yourself
I support this decision !!
He can’t do it! Needs Constitutional Amendment!!!
He just did it. 🤣🤣🤣😂😖😖😣
@louniece1650 just goes to show the cult members how dumb trump is he can not use a executive order to change constitutional amendment that takes a act of congress
Keep crying peasant
As an Indian this is the right way to stop infiltration of illegal immigrants .
Well, he just did hahaha😂😂😂
@@louniece1650🖕🏻🐏, and your Nazi leader
Trump ban citizenship by birth for non US citizens and non green card holder..
Of course that would be challenge in the courts. An executive order cannot prevail over the constitution.
Maybe you never actually READ the 14th Amendment ?
@dennisg4053 I'm pretty sure you havent
@@dennisg4053 its very short stupid...
All Hail Trump...he single handedly halted BrainDrain from India...to some extent😊
Definitely y all should too think of your original existence and give original Americans their native land lol
@varthikagupta6682 💥
It should apply to ANYONE who is NOT a legal citizen -- and THAT includes people, who are here on a "Visa" and Green cards -- you are NOT a legal citizen! Neither of these things should have EVER given you a right to what "legally" BELONGS to citizens ONLY! It's that simple; THIS is NOT complicated! You're TRYING to complicate this because you've been taking ADVANTAGE of this and US and have been getting away with it for YEARS!!
Your US govt allowed it. If they had not allowed it from the beginning... No question of even mentioning it. So US has been at fault for allowing birth right citizenship. But anyways in US everyone is an immigrant except native americans if u really go by the book. ... Just very pale skin doesn't make you a native... U guys mostly came from Europe, shitty Ireland ( weather wise) and England and else where... Go back to Europe"
Your yapping isn't gonna do anything the richest person in your country is also an legal immigrant. If that got cancelled nobody is gonna come to us have to say good bye to capitalism. Can you guys even do that, u guys will die without capitalism
@infinitecosmos917 Our govt. may have allowed for whatever reason; that doesn't change the fact that it was NEVER legal. And your weak attempt to claim that "everyone" is an immigrant is just that -- weak. We've established "legal laws" since that time and then and NOW everyone is NOT an immigrant. And your argument ONLY proves that you and others -- like you -- already KNOW that you're here "illegally". And that your intent was to exploit and take advantage of this law -- which Trump will NOW put a stop to. The "legal" American people have made it CLEAR (back in November of 2024) that we're NOT going to stand by and allow you (and others) to exploit us and our laws ANYMORE -- and it's "you" who will be going back to wherever you came from...
@@hara_reddy My yapping is doing so much -- you're reacting to it! And we don't need anybody "coming" to our country. The ones coming are the ones benefitting the MOST -- not those of us who already here. I'm sure capitalism isn't gonna ANYWHERE, no matter who we prevent from coming. And we definitely won't die without it -- try again...
@yvettepitts5467 u saying weak doesn't make it weak ... Look at the facts and talk... I am not in US u moron, I am in my country may be ur grand pa went to US illegally and produced u bunch. I know whites in America don't consider themselves as immigrants... But they are!!! Stop being in denial. And don't assume who ever is posting msg here is illegally in US... Ha ha ha... Ur thinking is tht limited? FYI I have visited ur country bit never thought of moving there like many....
This is great …do this in Canada
No, we want YOU f king deported.
They're not doing it here. It's against the law
WHAT A PIECE A WICKEDNESS!! THIS WICKED MAN IS GONNA MESS UP A LOT OF PEOPLE'S LIFE....BUT GOD WILL STOP HIM!!😢
Nope… president trump is just protecting the Americans from this abusers of the system…. Indians have destroyed Canadian immigration system… they are coming here as tourist and they are pregnant…intentionally giving birth in Canada to make their children Canadian citizen.
Outsiders cannot question his decision.
SAYS A TRUMP TARDED MORON!!!
I m indian but this is great decision by Mr.Trump
It's seen that most of the Indians in US would like to pull the bridge behind them.
How and why. Just jealous?
What way good decision
@@haridaspr4606why jealous thier own country and their own laws
@@haridaspr4606come back to india ... Do the Modi ..Modi...Modi ...chants here ....why should we Indians alone should have all the fun....let the NRIs in USA too share the fun
Birthright citizenship is not banned. It must be fought in court us a constitutional amendment
Ha, the President doesn't have the authority to make law by decree
Not yet. Patience.
@@Mrsplanetmaster9you have no idea what a true dictator is. You’re parroting what you hear. Research, read history books, study the wars and then claim he’s a dictator. Nice try. Stop parroting other idiots
@@Mrsplanetmaster9your confusing him with biden
Banning citizenship by birth is insane! The phrase he has interpreted does not mean he can do that, it means you are subject to the laws of the country.
Meanwhile ,bro the current law is wicked,if u came here on tourist visa in usa,and a baby born here,they are citizen
he didnt ban shit. gtfoh lying.
He ain't lying in HIS head--I bet he thinks he can do it.
Hopefully he's in for a BIG surprise.
He can’t change the constitution. He is a legend in his own mind, and, critically out of his mind!
Implement this in India also
Its already implemented here, only people who is doin this in US are mostly Indians😂
@@selva279 stupid comment to make. Hardly any Indians are doing this. It would mostly be happening from illegal immigrants.
What? How is violating the 14th amendment amendment an Indian issue?
14th amendment does NOT guarantee birth right...try reading it dummy
Wasn’t the 14th amendment for recently emancipated slaves? Wasn’t meant for illegal immigrates or temporary visa holders who have children here.
Listen to all the non Americans complaining.
He can't do that by executive order. It's in our constitution. It's nothing but a show for MAGA.
Wrong
This should include his children as well!!!
Why? His wives were American citizens when their kids were born. Educate yourself
No, because Melania is legal, not illegal like the Venezuelans who came to the US to invade and have children to steal and make a profit.
@@Glenna10 also you only need one parent to be a citizen or have a greencard for citizenship to apply. It sounds like it only doesn’t apply if the greencard holder or citizen has a spouse that is illegally in the country. If the non-citizen or non-greencard holder parent is on a legal visa, the child would still get citizenship.
Can a constitutional provision as citizenship by birth be revoked by an executive order? I think this is ultra vires the constitution.
Where is it guaranteed in the Constitution?
It's not!
@@chrisfarrell9894 14th Amendment.
@@chrisfarrell9894the 14 th Amendment, he can not.
@@chrisfarrell9894a little something called the 14th Amendment.
@@chrisfarrell9894That is very clearly stated in the first sentence of the 14th amendment.
Better than making usa americastan.
Congress needs to do ammendments to the constitution, not the president
If your parents are here and are not citizens, not an American Citizen !
Donald Trump's grandparents and mother didnt come legally 😂 but since they white, they had no issues. Per constitution, if you care about your own laws, it says everyone born in US soil is American... now, there is people who abuse this and ofc they should control, but what you're saying is wrong. If anything, 99% of "Americans" are not. The only Americans are native people!!!
Trump can’t revoke constitutional rights
Maybe you never actually READ the 14th Amendment ?
@@dennisg4053 Maybe if YOU had, you'd notice that there's no constitutional way that trump could be president.
@@dennisg4053i have. It clearly states anyone born under US jurisdiction is a US citizen. That means anyone not a foreign dignitary or diplomat on US soil. Or do you honestly believe US laws don't apply to illegals on US soil? They can just do whatever they want then, huh? If the laws apply to them, then they're under US jurisdiction. If they're under US jurisdiction, then the 14th amendment gives their kids US citizenship. Not that complicated to comprehend basic English, comrade.
The constitution is an openly interpreted document to this day. The first and second amendment debates reflect that, as well as the interpretation used to legalize abortion and interracial marriage. Because the vague clause that was referenced in the video is in the document, its implementation is open to interpretation.
That is illegal. It is UNconstitutional and several lawsuits have already been filed. All but one of his own children would be deported!
It's his plan . It's needed 😂
No, because he’s a citizen. If one parent is a citizen, they can pass citizenship to their children. It only applies if neither parent is a citizen or on a greencard.
Explain how it's illegal.
Good, otherwise it will be called United States of India
😂
Indians for Trump, take note. MAGA got your vote and now they are coming after you. You get what you voted for!
If the parents do not have legal documents or permanent residency, it shall not be granted because somebody is born here, it's not controversial at all it's common sense. And I'm not a trump supporter I never will be.
"All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof..." isn't applicable to undocumented (illegal) or temporary status immigrants; they are subjected to the jurisdiction of their country of origin.
The original intent of the 14th amendment of the United States was to establish birthright citizenship to the former African American slaves post Civil War; it was never intended to be utilized as a pathway for undocumented (illegal) or temporary status immigrants to establish legal permanent status and/or birthright citizenship (anchor baby loophole. The original intent of the law has been corrupted.
US v Wong Kim Ark 1898 decision was successful because his parents had legal permanent status, although his parents were still subjected to the jurisdiction of their country of origin(CCP).
Trump has been game planning this since his first term and will stack the deck even more by the time this reaches the SCOTUS. He is going to replace 2 retiring Justices who will vote in favor of ending birthright citizenship/anchor baby loophole, then using the arguments posted to end birthright citizenship.
This isn't changing an amendment... it's redefining the intent of the law via the Supreme Court of the United States. Presidential executive order is granted by the power of the executive branch and constitutional interpretation of laws are granted by the judicial branch of the United States Government.
Oh Lord… so many uninformed comments here. Good luck Mr. President on your executive order. Last I checked a presidential executive order cannot change an amendment to the constitution. It’s an arduous process that includes both houses of congress as well as the states… sigh
I hate to say this and I know this is ignorant, but I think this just applies to the Mexican border more than anything like it’s really sad and it’s really degrading because there’s so many people that want to come here to this country and make a difference, but after these past four years enough is enough, Democrats have broken. The rules have made our democracy more struggling than ever before and not I’m not saying that the Republicans are doing this as well but enough is enough but I believe in general that this applies to all countries that want becomes citizens they all have to go by the book now
Does that mean he shipping his children back where there Mother's came 😮😂😮from??
Are you guys seriously this dense?
So he's illegal now?
Great Leader best of Luck Mr Trump all about his country
Its in our constitution..he cant do this ..he will get taken to court...what about his dam wife😢.He needs a damn wake up call guick!😢😢
Though it may disappoint a lot of Indians...I think it was the logical step.
There goes the economy. And why is trump surrounding himself with just rich people. 🤔 are you seriously thinking he will do anything for us littke people?
@carmensaavedra1096 Yes, sadly they do.
every day i see how right johnny silverhand was
cyberpunk 2077 wasnt a game
it was a warning
u give the rich power they take from us
Why don't Trump and his people realize that this will end citizenship to Trump and ALL of us born here in the US???
They have to refine it just for illegal immigrants and tourist. The Chinese here in Los Angeles comes here in IS just to give birth, so the child will have a dual citizen.
Educate yourself
This only applies to non citizens. If a kid is born to citizens that kid is still a citizen regardless of Trump's executive orders unless it specifically targets that.
Someone needs serious education of the defintion of citizenship.
You know that this goes into effect only from February 20th 2025 right ?
Yall voted for this man this what we got to deal with for 4 years.
Better than last 4 years I barely survive
One should challenge this in court. Take an example of French father and Philippine mother, working in US, giving birth to a child in US. What should be the citizenship of the child. Principle of natural justice should prevail. This should be challenged in international courts
It is very simple, the baby can claim both citizenships, except US.
@@Mgr-fr5ek😂😂 That was smart
Not necessarily. The US is one of only a few western countries that actually has historically granted birthright citizenship. Many European countries would not grant it in that case either.
@@aGeographicNatureJournalMany other countries in the Americas have birthright citizenship, but not Europe as you noted.
Will it be challenged in courts and can it be applied retroactively to Trump himself 😂😂😂
So does this mean we gotta earn our citizenship now?
From what I hear it most likely won’t get approved
If this is applicable for illegal immigrants i agree to this. But being an H1b holder waiting in queue for green card long wait years, paid all.the tax, and it impacts legal immigrants
Very ungrateful decision by our president, he always attacks legal immigrants on Imdians H1b legal workers
Isn’t it ironic! His mother born in Scotland, two of his wives born in Europe. He also chain migrated his in-laws.
You think he would have some empathy and compassion of people emigrating to the USA. Strange isn’t it.
You obviously don't even know what the document is about 🙄
It doesnt work that way. He is a vengeful psychotic monster who thinks he owns the world. Whats COMPASSION have to do with anything? I wish he would take back mine, for what good it ever did me. Sorry I lived to reach this moment in history
Not strange, his inside is dark as the darkness of night
They came the right way like everyone should do if they want to be a proud American. Not trespass and break into our country with their hands out for American tax payers to have to take care of.
THANKS TRUMP STAND TALL, THAT WHY WE VOTED FOR YOUSTAND STRONG WE HAVE SPOKEN ?!!!
Including Trump it self dan his anchestor and his wife.
Yes , please do it
Gud decision for us citizens
His parents came here from Germany he was born here why is he here his sister and himself should leave
maybe there is differences between legal and illegal crossing border law.
They came the right way and were American citizens when their kids were born. Why are so many Americans so ignorant they don’t understand simple immigration laws? If anything Trump should do something about the education system that is making Americans dumber and dumber and it shows
I like to migrate to usa and become a honoured citizen in usa, maybe i didnt get any opportunity to live a peaceful,good life eventhough i am educated,and had god blessed talents in this peninsula.this life in this country is a tragedy for me..may God bless me for that .
Of course if child was born in any country
They can get citizenship ? Its has to be same category , what parents have?
Many countries have birthright citizenship, but many do not.
Makes sense👌
Trump's order will include himself!!!!!!
Reliance group Mukesh luckily got grandchildren born in USA last year. See the power of money : do u like to have your children or grand children born and have USA citizenship? Please reply. thank you
No he hasn’t
I think trump is mental to come up this idea.. can trump take out his sons citicenship too.
Despite tge executive order its still not going to pass through .. Thisnis not going to stay or stick
They voted for this
No
Should do this as well by the next prime minister of Canada bec.theres a lot of people here in Canada who is not pr or Canadian citizen does this system taking advantage there is one person I know right now who is pregnant again but no status not working came here as tourist and now applying as refugees she told me that if she don't get here pr they just make a lot of babies and get a lot of child benefits what a shame people like me who has triple job just to make an end a lot of people taking advantage bec.of the system right now.
Why are all of you look so worried about this. only legal immigrants from india in USA from just two states in india and illegal immigrants from two more states in india should be worried 😂😂😂😂 the rest are minuscule
Pl ban L1 n h1 visas
TO BACK TO INDIA!!
Dear Indians , we welcome you back to india where you can probably earn as much as in the USA pay taxes that are higher than in USA and get benefits like in Somalia 😂😂😂
Only if the baby is born in a hospital and the parents are known... People will give bith at home and drop off thier babies at any hospitals door step..
The Evil has landed
No wonder Vivek Ramaswammy can’t get a break.
Best decision
What our namo fans do now, oh God!
Super. Cancel all green cards
Good
Do not redeem
It will be good for Hindus who are intelligent and try to stay in America. Let them come and use their intellectual brain to Indian society development. You will earn less money, lot of corruption is there still they can stay in India and contribute to Indian economy. Now next destination for Indians is Russia and Canada. If they really want to migrate.
WTF does this mean indeed? Of all the priorities to focus on… wow we’re doomed
This is EXACTLY what we want. Too many foreigners who don't value what America is
We’re not doomed lefty!
Who is we
Your Joe Biden never did anything good for country . This is the right step taken by Mr trump
That means you can't just illegaly cross border, give birth and call yourself "american" without proper documents, have same rights as native americans. Its same rules in Europe, some of them are broken now by putin agents, but this will stop soon.
Every country should protect their native people intrasts first, and allow other people to come in legaly with suitable documents, wich with time your children and granchildren gradualy will be native, not an instant like now, without knowing the language or knowing traditions and culture of America. People never respect what comes easy without an effort, and treat it like a trash. Healthy boundaries benefit everyone, even people who want to come to your country. Its also safety.
I'm not american, but that how I see it.
@@spicyboy5330 America is not Europe. Most Americans are of immigrant background. It's not like Europe or Asia or Africa where regions have their native populations as the majority. Even Trump's parents are German immigrants and his wives are from Eastern Europe. That's why American identity is not a strong one.
CNBC had to put Indian for this one
What you mean put Indian for this one, this is an Indian news channel.
Yea get em all outta here buddy 😂
About time, if you ask NC
Wonderful
Now that's great news!
OUTSTANDING!!!
"Trump signed the executive order with the flair of an autograph, barely glancing at the contents 😂😂😂
Good good
It applies to anyone