SNSD needs more songs like Into the New World and Kissing You in my opinion. Their songs these days, yeah, they're great hits (Gee, Run Devil Run, Oh!) But they're not the type of songs that made me fall in love with SNSD in the first place. More acapellas and ballads please, SNSD!
I was expecting this to be awful from the amount of dislikes but i was surprised its quite good obviously not perfect because of the dance, i guess the anti fans decided to crawl all over this video, as usual they have nothing else to do than watch and criticize videos of groups they hate, sad lives
Most stable: Tiffany, TaeYeon, SooYoung and SeoHyun. Most unstable: Yoona. Yoona sometimes can't hear her voice, so it's unstable. At least they sing better than some other groups.
@izzyprechii that would depend on whether it was a good or a bad show! actually there was a time when SNSD had a concert and tiffany was having her solo stage. she was singing umbrella by rihanna and suddenly the background music stopped. and her acapella was wonderful. yeaa maybe this vid was of a bad performance but it doesn't mean they can't sing or anything(:
Funny how some SNSD haters just leap out when they find a bad mr removed performance, yet i can't find any of them say a word on those that are good. Sure, this is not the best Mr removed, but you can't base their talent on one video. Some people are just so ignorant to believe that SNSD is only popular because they're pretty ~ around 50% of SNSD fans are females, so you're saying all those females only like SNSD for their looks?
@strawberryskittleful well you're true some sones are like thatt but not all. for example. myself. i don't feel like they are perfect. of course they're number one in my heart but it doesn't mean i look bad on other idol groups. there are actually a lot of nice sones. MOST of the sones are nice. the rude ones just keeping doing rude things over and over and make it seem like many sones are like that. i'm thankful to you though, for not accounting sone's mistakes onto the girls(:
@dyschorde My point is that they only judge when they see a bad video and turn a blind eye when they see something good. And did you even read my comment? I said "Some people are just so ignorant to believe that SNSD is ONLY popular because they're pretty." My point is that i like SNSD, not only because they're pretty but for other factors as well, and its the same for many sones. I never said looks didn't count, because i agree, looks do count ~ but its not the only thing that counts.
@manm555 I do undertsand. People hate on SNSD because they're all pretty, can sing, and dance. Each group has their own different style. I do support SNSD, i'm not their biggest fan, but i do wish that they take care of themselves a little bit more. they're still young.
@Risu34is17x2 I just wanted to say that they are able to dance and sing (well) at the same time, and that even when some of this girls have just two or three lines they still can't do it. I know that not all of them are singers, but the five members of DBSK sang parts of a song almost equally, and Jaejoong, Junsu or Changmin with Taeyeon... they're not even comparison (though I know she's an amazing voice).
i think the people hating (who raped the dislike button) r indignant by the fact that snsd is often blessed with the name of "korea's best girl group" when they can't really sing and dance well.... but i must agree. i dun think sones r ingnoring the truth that snsd are below basic in singing and dancing, but it's just as the guy below said. all fandoms are protective of their idols in the case of antis....
I've seen other MR Hoot videos, which sounded just fine. Where did they sing this one? Because in this one they sounded very tired and it's all over the place.
i love how ppl are like "you try it i bet you cant!" and " they are dance singers if you cant do both at once why do you do it at all" how about we all just agree thee better then any of us, and if there not there still more popular then any of us and get payed to do it.
@strawberryskittleful i really don't understand yours either, i think you meant "staying alive". but please don't get mad be happy that SNSD is a successful girl group. all groups are going to have haters.
@nhoczayza that video didn't even sound like an MR removed video tbh. the background music was too loud. and add the fact that the uploader wouldn't even allow any comments or ratings...seems pretty defensive to me.
@oneskyee SNSD shouldn't care about what the haters are saying. So they have no reason to kill themselves. If go on with life caring about what people think about you, your not caring about yourself. I'm talking about 'fair critism' not no 'dumbass critism.' i don't do that.
Since when did we sones think that SNSD is PERFECT? We just like their imperfects that made them beautiful. In all the sones comments, there are sones saying that whoever did not do very well this time. This shows that they are saying they are still not perfect if they think they are perfect then their comment should be "This voice is perfect, no one can win them". GET IT?
Just because they did bad here, doesn't mean they are bad singers. Listen to any live version of The Boys or I Got A Boy. They really did well those two comebacks.
@strawberryskittleful Yeah, well not everybody thinks so positively to negative criticism. And as a general question, why are celebrities having a difficult time, 'staying a live' when they 'shouldn't' care? I didn't really understand your english, so I don't know what else to reply to :p good day now.
@pansitkantonify well i watched ugly and they don't dance much and i didn't blame anyone i mean did i said that 2ne1 is bad or something? no it's just i'm sick that people say snsd is so bad and they don't deserve this and that and bla bla bla snsd work hard for their fame and fans love them for their talent and not for their looks and you can't always have great mr removes since they're also human as well
@KimChii11 Of course you can't ~ you don't even bother to get to know them. I'm a girl and i think SNSD deserves to be the best kpop idol group as of now. I'm a girl and i used to hate/dislike them, for the same reason why you and many other people do ~ i would've never guessed that i would become a sone, but i did, because i truly tried to get to know them.
@shan33aa1 aren't all k-pop fans are like that? example: if u are an ELF aren't u protective towards Super junior too,If someone bashes them aren't you going to protect them too? I think not only Sones are always so protective of their idols but all fandoms are like that..
@selty yeah, hoot is pretty bad for singing live, but there are other mr removed videos of hoot that are better tho. this is not so bad either, I'm just happy that they made effort to sing the whole thing and not sound bad in the real performance. (other groups either don't sing the chorus or sing the chorus but sound bad even without the mr removed...)
@Bommieeful excuse me but jessica is the only one who trained for 7 years and i don't think you can compare snsd and 2ne1 becuz 2ne1 has very easy choreographies compared to snsd's
@dyschorde well yea but girls generation was formed as a mixed group with singers and dancers so their style is different from Miss A. I mean Miss A all of them can sing really well and dance really well but that's different from SNSD. actually snsd are good singers too, if you listen to their singles, esp for the ones in the vocal line. you can't really compare them girls in the dance line to Miss A members cause they are trained to be professional singers in the singer line.
I didn't say they are better than Boa. I only said they are better than other girl groups from other companies which usually only one person in the group sing almost the entire song and barely dance. Not saying you're wrong either. You obviously have higher standard. I still like SNSD for being the way the are~
@MsChidinma if u are going to debut in korea, u should know their are some dances involved and if u cant keep up with both then u are not ready onnviously, so pls stop defending them, i love hyuna- bubble pop, and i agree shes everything but a good singer. if i love a group and they cant sing, ill admit it, but it doesnt mean ill stop listening to them.
And i'm not anti SNSD i'm saying this just prove that some sones is not honest about their favourite idol is not good in singing live and non SNSD fans / SNSD fans saying SNSD can't sing live not honest sones starts to call others antis... so how about that NOT HONEST SONES just admit it instead of defending SNSD which that this video proves alot about their singing...
well, it's hard to sing and dance at the same time and even though they've had some intense training, everyone's allowed to have their off days. Also, consider their hectic schedules. During this time, they were doing things back and forth in the japanese and korean ent markets (and performing in both countries). As well as preparing for their first japanese album. I mean really...give them a break. They don't always sound like this.
@1997megaabi try to sing this song with dancing like them it's really hard do u know that??!! N seriously they r sooooooo tired check out their lives when they first debuted...it was awesome they do have talent
Honestly, I love SNSD, to the point that I'm probably a SONE by now. But I'm not biased. This live song is bad, and I'm not going to make up excuses for them. Neither them nor true fans would want that. But I do wish that if people have truly hateful comments to say then keep them to yourself. Not because they aren't true but because even though some performances may not be good, they only serve to waste SNSD's hard work. Because SNSD worked damn hard like other groups and that deserves respect.
@jacobwiththeface Taeyeon has a likeable voice as well (better than Hyorin in my taste), but I feel Luna and Hyorin seem more comfortable singing the high range. I guess it's debatable for Luna but Hyorin is definitely better in skill and is probably the best in her generation so far since she can sing high notes and doesn't even need to stop dancing.
SNSD ARE A GREAT GROUP! Im a SONE but I know that they do have bad performances but come on! They have a bad performance and you say "they cant sing" "theyre just a bunch of pretty faces" and things like that but when they actually have an OUTSTANDING performance what do u say then? *waits for it*...exactly! There is a difference between constructive critizism and BASHING! No matter what I LOVE SNSD!
1:35 -1:39 .....???? I dunno... seems like taeyun is the only one who actually practiced singing for 4 to 5 years in SNSD... all the others are just.. really gorgeous
i can understand people saying this is a bad performance and i agree. but some people are thinking, they never get any rest. it might not have anything to do with this performance but they perform in a few citied in japan then go on tour for smtown then go back to japan to finish their tour but still they have to film MV's do music station performances. not even the best of singers can take the strain on their throat eventually everyone tires out. not many people perform this much.
@strawberryskittleful Now I understand you... Thank you :) But you also have to understand that SNSD is one of the most hated girls groups, so we SONES are defending them... If you know that they work hard, you know that they don't deserve all this hating from another people. Its sad to see our girls weak, without rest and trying to show their best. But us SONES love them whatever they do. :D Hope you understand my part too :3
@alexholic1 =.=" I assure that this version just a fake MR Remove, this is a MR version and MR Removed is different from MR ... If you don't believe it, alright....... bcoz they're your idols. I can't do anything to change this ^^ _peace_
@oneskyee Yeah I should indeed have said 'they sucked' instead of 'they suck.' LOL. I guess I'm just jealous and I can't take the fact that I can sing better than every single one of them but they got famous, and I'll never be able to make a living out of my passion just because looks matter more than the voice. I shouldn't be this jealous I know. It's just unfair to me. :P
@TheMapleTroll Sure, for now. I'm not even a BJ but seriously, these comments are hilarious to me. Let me know if SNSD finally achieves the same success as Kara in Japan and they're actually famous not because of their "legs". that's the only thing going for them there.
These comments are ridiculous. Looking at these comments i was expecting much worse. There weren't any times where they weren't singing and it sound like the recorded version enough for me. they was some breathy-ness but that was the worst of it. You guys are being way harsh.
@sashahawkins if you know the jpop industry well and look at the charts and stuff SNSD is not famous in japan only for their legs. i have to admit, Kara is really successful in Japan (would be more successful if DSP put mroe effort and money in them instead of Rainbow!) and they beat SNSD sometimes but SNSD broke many records in japan for foreign singers too and i don't think it's just because their legss. let's just say both Kara and SNSD were really successful in japan because they deserve it
i like snsd's hits, but i don't like their MR videos because there are ALL these delusional fans commenting. seriously...... admit it. your bias doesn't have to be perfect 100% of the time. and snsd isn't known for their singing
Yes, let admit it. SNSD didn't give out their full-potential for this performance but its still considered alright, its not that bad ._. Because SNSD is one of the most famous girl bands doesn't mean they have to be perfect in everything. But there should be better mr-removed of SNSD. I'm not a hater, i like SNSD.
@lucinesa Really? There was a poll released, where Kara was chosen as the most popular due to their talent and their fluency in Japanese. SNSD was second for this reason: "THEIR LONG GORGEOUS LEGS". I'd be pretty embarassed to be a Sone if that's the one thing they're famous for. Those records they beat are always being beaten but none of that would be possible without DBSK, Boa and even Kara. I'm sorry, SNSD is successful there no doubt but to say they're equal with Kara is just sad.
@mssummerbird let's not compare snsd to emilys2kyuhyun, ofcourse they have better voice than emilys2kyuhyun, "they have mich better voices than yours" ofcourse they do, they're singers, they were trained for years, so they would be better, but still their voices are the same, i feel they didn't improve, but cuz i like them i'm gonna support them.
@manm555 Sorry, i know that other fanclubs do that too. because they stupid people in each one of the fanclubs have to say something to make them look bad. I like too many artist to be in ONE fanclub (2NE1, U-Kiss, block B, etc..) I know SNSD has talent. I never said they did. I don't hate them, its just that I feel like that the don't have much freedom, and they work too hard. Because they have so many fans watching them. Because they have to be perfect all the time.
i don't think that this song is an easy song to sing live becuz they had to sing very deep and then very high at that hoot hoot hoot part and you all know that snsd has too much work so of course they're tired at least you should be happy that they tried to sing the whole song INCLUDING the chorus ( what many other groups don't do) +*cough* miss a *cough*
@emilys2kyuhyun they debuted due to their talent and if their voices make you SICK. what about yours? i see you have nothing better to do than to bash them. i bet they have voices much better than yours so its better to keep ur comments to yourself. i accept the fact that they have tons of haters but i wish you would at least show them the very least of respect. the fact that their the leading girl group means they have talent
Honestly, you can't expect EVERYBODY to be perfect. Yeah, it's their jobs, but how about other people that've messed up before? Doctors who couldn't save lives? Basketball players who couldn't shoot hoops? Teachers who taught the wrong subject? There are better things you could be doing right now than downgrading someone because they aren't 'perfect' when they sweat and work their butts off. And really, you should ask yourselves, do you want to be treated this way as well?
@TheGossipgirl911 : lol, you asked us to sing and dance like them??? Remember, they were training several years to become singers, therefore they have to do their jobs. We are just amateurs, don't ask us to do that. Many others singers and bands do better than S9. I don't want to compare shit to DBSK because DBSK is a legend, let's compare Shit to 2NE1 or Sistar, 2 girl group bands that debuted after Shit, but let listen to their MR Removed video, you will see the difference
I wish SNSD made more songs like Into the New World ... Or made more ballads. These songs that have to dance more aren't good for their vocal side. I remember when they first debuted. Their songs were much better, in my opinion. Now, SM is just showing them for their image.
![เจ็บที่ยังฮัก - ม่อน วรวิทย์ [ Official Mv ] จอนนี่มิวสิค](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KALIGSRSjFs/mqdefault.jpg)
![Girls' Generation - One Last Time [MALE VERSION]](/img/n.gif)
this is better than most of 3rd gen girl groups
SNSD needs more songs like Into the New World and Kissing You in my opinion. Their songs these days, yeah, they're great hits (Gee, Run Devil Run, Oh!) But they're not the type of songs that made me fall in love with SNSD in the first place.
More acapellas and ballads please, SNSD!
I was expecting this to be awful from the amount of dislikes but i was surprised its quite good obviously not perfect because of the dance, i guess the anti fans decided to crawl all over this video, as usual they have nothing else to do than watch and criticize videos of groups they hate, sad lives
Most stable: Tiffany, TaeYeon, SooYoung and SeoHyun.
Most unstable: Yoona.
Yoona sometimes can't hear her voice, so it's unstable.
At least they sing better than some other groups.
I am amazed these stability debates existed 9 years ago
Yoona is actually stable here 😌
@izzyprechii that would depend on whether it was a good or a bad show! actually there was a time when SNSD had a concert and tiffany was having her solo stage. she was singing umbrella by rihanna and suddenly the background music stopped. and her acapella was wonderful. yeaa maybe this vid was of a bad performance but it doesn't mean they can't sing or anything(:
Funny how some SNSD haters just leap out when they find a bad mr removed performance, yet i can't find any of them say a word on those that are good. Sure, this is not the best Mr removed, but you can't base their talent on one video. Some people are just so ignorant to believe that SNSD is only popular because they're pretty ~ around 50% of SNSD fans are females, so you're saying all those females only like SNSD for their looks?
@strawberryskittleful well you're true some sones are like thatt but not all. for example. myself. i don't feel like they are perfect. of course they're number one in my heart but it doesn't mean i look bad on other idol groups. there are actually a lot of nice sones. MOST of the sones are nice. the rude ones just keeping doing rude things over and over and make it seem like many sones are like that. i'm thankful to you though, for not accounting sone's mistakes onto the girls(:
@rinakanishi sometimes that's more difficult to dance than something powerful cause it requires a lot of precision
@dyschorde My point is that they only judge when they see a bad video and turn a blind eye when they see something good. And did you even read my comment? I said "Some people are just so ignorant to believe that SNSD is ONLY popular because they're pretty." My point is that i like SNSD, not only because they're pretty but for other factors as well, and its the same for many sones. I never said looks didn't count, because i agree, looks do count ~ but its not the only thing that counts.
@manm555 I do undertsand. People hate on SNSD because they're all pretty, can sing, and dance. Each group has their own different style. I do support SNSD, i'm not their biggest fan, but i do wish that they take care of themselves a little bit more. they're still young.
I can't even believe that they are the most POPULAR Kpop Group... =.=
@Risu34is17x2 I just wanted to say that they are able to dance and sing (well) at the same time, and that even when some of this girls have just two or three lines they still can't do it. I know that not all of them are singers, but the five members of DBSK sang parts of a song almost equally, and Jaejoong, Junsu or Changmin with Taeyeon... they're not even comparison (though I know she's an amazing voice).
@oneskyee If I did bad on a concert and it was my job I would appreciate the criticism. So please don't give me advise I've already taken in account.
They sound fine in all other MR Removed videos, they must be really tired >.
OMG. THEY'RE VOICES R SOOOO GOOD! SNSD FTW!!!
i think the people hating (who raped the dislike button) r indignant by the fact that snsd is often blessed with the name of "korea's best girl group" when they can't really sing and dance well.... but i must agree. i dun think sones r ingnoring the truth that snsd are below basic in singing and dancing, but it's just as the guy below said. all fandoms are protective of their idols in the case of antis....
I've seen other MR Hoot videos, which sounded just fine.
Where did they sing this one? Because in this one they sounded very tired and it's all over the place.
i love how ppl are like "you try it i bet you cant!" and " they are dance singers if you cant do both at once why do you do it at all" how about we all just agree thee better then any of us, and if there not there still more popular then any of us and get payed to do it.
@strawberryskittleful i really don't understand yours either, i think you meant "staying alive". but please don't get mad be happy that SNSD is a successful girl group. all groups are going to have haters.
@nhoczayza that video didn't even sound like an MR removed video tbh. the background music was too loud. and add the fact that the uploader wouldn't even allow any comments or ratings...seems pretty defensive to me.
my heart stops beating everytime they sing their hight notes OMG they all should siing backup for sunny hill or IU.
@oneskyee SNSD shouldn't care about what the haters are saying. So they have no reason to kill themselves. If go on with life caring about what people think about you, your not caring about yourself. I'm talking about 'fair critism' not no 'dumbass critism.' i don't do that.
@lucinesa oooh do you know where i can watch that video
This sounds a lot like the CD version to me.......
I'm proud that they, in fact, all SM groups, sing the whole song, unlike some artists nowadays :)
Since when did we sones think that SNSD is PERFECT? We just like their imperfects that made them beautiful. In all the sones comments, there are sones saying that whoever did not do very well this time. This shows that they are saying they are still not perfect if they think they are perfect then their comment should be "This voice is perfect, no one can win them". GET IT?
@SuperJuniorKHforever: If you compare TVXQ dance routines with SNSD', you could see that DBSK routines are more complex and powerful.
Just because they did bad here, doesn't mean they are bad singers. Listen to any live version of The Boys or I Got A Boy. They really did well those two comebacks.
@strawberryskittleful
Yeah, well not everybody thinks so positively to negative criticism. And as a general question, why are celebrities having a difficult time, 'staying a live' when they 'shouldn't' care?
I didn't really understand your english, so I don't know what else to reply to :p good day now.
@pansitkantonify well i watched ugly and they don't dance much
and i didn't blame anyone i mean did i said that 2ne1 is bad or something? no
it's just i'm sick that people say snsd is so bad and they don't deserve this and that and bla bla bla
snsd work hard for their fame and fans love them for their talent and not for their looks
and you can't always have great mr removes since they're also human as well
@KimChii11 Of course you can't ~ you don't even bother to get to know them. I'm a girl and i think SNSD deserves to be the best kpop idol group as of now. I'm a girl and i used to hate/dislike them, for the same reason why you and many other people do ~ i would've never guessed that i would become a sone, but i did, because i truly tried to get to know them.
@shan33aa1 aren't all k-pop fans are like that? example: if u are an ELF aren't u protective towards Super junior too,If someone bashes them aren't you going to protect them too?
I think not only Sones are always so protective of their idols but all fandoms are like that..
Just accept the fact that not every performance is gonna be perfect. Haters are still going to hate.
@harrypoter123lover Sone pronounced as So Won = SNSD fans.
We have to understand that they are really good in singing, its just that they are dancing so their voices are some how like bouncy.
@selty yeah, hoot is pretty bad for singing live, but there are other mr removed videos of hoot that are better tho. this is not so bad either, I'm just happy that they made effort to sing the whole thing and not sound bad in the real performance. (other groups either don't sing the chorus or sing the chorus but sound bad even without the mr removed...)
@Bommieeful excuse me but jessica is the only one who trained for 7 years and i don't think you can compare snsd and 2ne1 becuz 2ne1 has very easy choreographies compared to snsd's
@dyschorde well yea but girls generation was formed as a mixed group with singers and dancers so their style is different from Miss A. I mean Miss A all of them can sing really well and dance really well but that's different from SNSD. actually snsd are good singers too, if you listen to their singles, esp for the ones in the vocal line. you can't really compare them girls in the dance line to Miss A members cause they are trained to be professional singers in the singer line.
I didn't say they are better than Boa. I only said they are better than other girl groups from other companies which usually only one person in the group sing almost the entire song and barely dance.
Not saying you're wrong either. You obviously have higher standard.
I still like SNSD for being the way the are~
@MsChidinma if u are going to debut in korea, u should know their are some dances involved and if u cant keep up with both then u are not ready onnviously, so pls stop defending them, i love hyuna- bubble pop, and i agree shes everything but a good singer. if i love a group and they cant sing, ill admit it, but it doesnt mean ill stop listening to them.
y?? they still sound nice^^ i love them^^
And i'm not anti SNSD i'm saying this just prove that some sones is not honest about their favourite idol is not good in singing live and non SNSD fans / SNSD fans saying SNSD can't sing live not honest sones starts to call others antis... so how about that NOT HONEST SONES just admit it instead of defending SNSD which that this video proves alot about their singing...
So none of you have ever listened to KARA without MR before, huh? It's a tragedy compared to this.
well, it's hard to sing and dance at the same time and even though they've had some intense training, everyone's allowed to have their off days. Also, consider their hectic schedules. During this time, they were doing things back and forth in the japanese and korean ent markets (and performing in both countries). As well as preparing for their first japanese album. I mean really...give them a break. They don't always sound like this.
@1997megaabi try to sing this song with dancing like them
it's really hard do u know that??!!
N seriously they r sooooooo tired
check out their lives when they first debuted...it was awesome
they do have talent
@strawberryskittleful u go girl!!!! exactly what i wanted to hear!!!!
@awaw10000
Well, that's a general comment that should be applied to ALL fans and not only SONE.
You have to admit to that :p
I am not an anti but they have spent years practicing
they should be able to sing and dance at the same time like other groups?
Honestly, I love SNSD, to the point that I'm probably a SONE by now. But I'm not biased. This live song is bad, and I'm not going to make up excuses for them. Neither them nor true fans would want that. But I do wish that if people have truly hateful comments to say then keep them to yourself. Not because they aren't true but because even though some performances may not be good, they only serve to waste SNSD's hard work. Because SNSD worked damn hard like other groups and that deserves respect.
@Risu34is17x2 Then... what about Dong Bang Shin Ki? Have you seen Mirotic's mr removed?
guys, they are dancing, can you sing perfectly while running? i wanna see that..
@jacobwiththeface Taeyeon has a likeable voice as well (better than Hyorin in my taste), but I feel Luna and Hyorin seem more comfortable singing the high range. I guess it's debatable for Luna but Hyorin is definitely better in skill and is probably the best in her generation so far since she can sing high notes and doesn't even need to stop dancing.
i would like it if in one performance, the background vocals were removed completely... just to see what would happen...
of course...listen DBSK RM Removed. True talent
SNSD ARE A GREAT GROUP! Im a SONE but I know that they do have bad performances but come on! They have a bad performance and you say "they cant sing" "theyre just a bunch of pretty faces" and things like that but when they actually have an OUTSTANDING performance what do u say then? *waits for it*...exactly! There is a difference between constructive critizism and BASHING! No matter what I LOVE SNSD!
Still great ! :) At least this proved to the antis tht they are not lip-sync
1:35 -1:39 .....???? I dunno... seems like taeyun is the only one who actually practiced singing for 4 to 5 years in SNSD... all the others are just.. really gorgeous
Dispute the girls have no times to rest, this is still OK...
@SuperSNSDlove of what? pleeeaze, I neeeed to know what i'm hatin' on.... cause this shit right here ain't it.
- True talent. Yes, DBSK is an excellent group, but you should understand that SNSD is a girl group.
i can understand people saying this is a bad performance and i agree. but some people are thinking, they never get any rest. it might not have anything to do with this performance but they perform in a few citied in japan then go on tour for smtown then go back to japan to finish their tour but still they have to film MV's do music station performances. not even the best of singers can take the strain on their throat eventually everyone tires out. not many people perform this much.
why do they sound like they are crying?
@strawberryskittleful Now I understand you... Thank you :) But you also have to understand that SNSD is one of the most hated girls groups, so we SONES are defending them... If you know that they work hard, you know that they don't deserve all this hating from another people. Its sad to see our girls weak, without rest and trying to show their best. But us SONES love them whatever they do. :D Hope you understand my part too :3
@alexholic1 =.=" I assure that this version just a fake MR Remove, this is a MR version and MR Removed is different from MR ... If you don't believe it, alright....... bcoz they're your idols. I can't do anything to change this ^^
_peace_
@lucinesa your very welcome. :)
@oneskyee Yeah I should indeed have said 'they sucked' instead of 'they suck.' LOL. I guess I'm just jealous and I can't take the fact that I can sing better than every single one of them but they got famous, and I'll never be able to make a living out of my passion just because looks matter more than the voice. I shouldn't be this jealous I know. It's just unfair to me. :P
They sound fine
how did this video gain so many dislikes? this sounds like a legit mv to me O_O
And the girls sound pretty good.
jessica! i expected more from yooouuu!! damn this is a hot mess
Taeyeon is like the best in this performance LOL! she sang like the cd.
@TheMapleTroll Sure, for now. I'm not even a BJ but seriously, these comments are hilarious to me. Let me know if SNSD finally achieves the same success as Kara in Japan and they're actually famous not because of their "legs". that's the only thing going for them there.
These comments are ridiculous. Looking at these comments i was expecting much worse. There weren't any times where they weren't singing and it sound like the recorded version enough for me. they was some breathy-ness but that was the worst of it. You guys are being way harsh.
@PoKemOnUs5gUrU to hear the singers sing without the background vocals
@sashahawkins if you know the jpop industry well and look at the charts and stuff SNSD is not famous in japan only for their legs. i have to admit, Kara is really successful in Japan (would be more successful if DSP put mroe effort and money in them instead of Rainbow!) and they beat SNSD sometimes but SNSD broke many records in japan for foreign singers too and i don't think it's just because their legss. let's just say both Kara and SNSD were really successful in japan because they deserve it
i like snsd's hits, but i don't like their MR videos because there are ALL these delusional fans commenting.
seriously...... admit it.
your bias doesn't have to be perfect 100% of the time.
and snsd isn't known for their singing
@axeaxeaxer Because it is SNSD, so people gonna hate...
Yes, let admit it. SNSD didn't give out their full-potential for this performance but its still considered alright, its not that bad ._. Because SNSD is one of the most famous girl bands doesn't mean they have to be perfect in everything. But there should be better mr-removed of SNSD. I'm not a hater, i like SNSD.
I think it's one of the best..listen to other kpop girl groups,doubt it would be that good though.seriously.but well antis just love to flame..haha
@lucinesa Really? There was a poll released, where Kara was chosen as the most popular due to their talent and their fluency in Japanese. SNSD was second for this reason: "THEIR LONG GORGEOUS LEGS". I'd be pretty embarassed to be a Sone if that's the one thing they're famous for. Those records they beat are always being beaten but none of that would be possible without DBSK, Boa and even Kara. I'm sorry, SNSD is successful there no doubt but to say they're equal with Kara is just sad.
@mssummerbird let's not compare snsd to emilys2kyuhyun, ofcourse they have better voice than emilys2kyuhyun, "they have mich better voices than yours" ofcourse they do, they're singers, they were trained for years, so they would be better, but still their voices are the same, i feel they didn't improve, but cuz i like them i'm gonna support them.
@manm555 Sorry, i know that other fanclubs do that too. because they stupid people in each one of the fanclubs have to say something to make them look bad. I like too many artist to be in ONE fanclub (2NE1, U-Kiss, block B, etc..) I know SNSD has talent. I never said they did. I don't hate them, its just that I feel like that the don't have much freedom, and they work too hard. Because they have so many fans watching them. Because they have to be perfect all the time.
WAT THE HELL IS A FREAKING SONE
Gila , suaranya sunny nge-bass banget
@TheMapleTroll True true, so true.
the quality plaese!!!!! i
i don't think that this song is an easy song to sing live becuz they had to sing very deep and then very high at that hoot hoot hoot part
and you all know that snsd has too much work so of course they're tired
at least you should be happy that they tried to sing the whole song INCLUDING the chorus ( what many other groups don't do) +*cough* miss a *cough*
this is giving me an heart attack...........
@emilys2kyuhyun they debuted due to their talent and if their voices make you SICK. what about yours? i see you have nothing better to do than to bash them. i bet they have voices much better than yours so its better to keep ur comments to yourself. i accept the fact that they have tons of haters but i wish you would at least show them the very least of respect. the fact that their the leading girl group means they have talent
.....oh yeah, everybody here, i wanna see u dance and sing at the same time, at least they are singing live.......the chorus is the only bad part here
This is ridiculous ... and they are classified as signers???
Tae sang very well! :)
Honestly, you can't expect EVERYBODY to be perfect. Yeah, it's their jobs, but how about other people that've messed up before? Doctors who couldn't save lives? Basketball players who couldn't shoot hoops? Teachers who taught the wrong subject? There are better things you could be doing right now than downgrading someone because they aren't 'perfect' when they sweat and work their butts off. And really, you should ask yourselves, do you want to be treated this way as well?
Taeyeon !! ♥
Exactly!
tbh i'm disappointed.. can somebody tell me other mr removed of hoot?
lol i can't stop laughing @some parts XDD terrible but funny hehe
Tae's voice is still good tho (:
@TheGossipgirl911 : lol, you asked us to sing and dance like them???
Remember, they were training several years to become singers, therefore they have to do their jobs.
We are just amateurs, don't ask us to do that. Many others singers and bands do better than S9. I don't want to compare shit to DBSK because DBSK is a legend, let's compare Shit to 2NE1 or Sistar, 2 girl group bands that debuted after Shit, but let listen to their MR Removed video, you will see the difference
I wish SNSD made more songs like Into the New World ... Or made more ballads. These songs that have to dance more aren't good for their vocal side. I remember when they first debuted. Their songs were much better, in my opinion. Now, SM is just showing them for their image.
@lazysleeperz They accidentally press the 'dislike' button when their jealousies are burning inside ;D
why I still hear the beat and the music? .___.
they are men, and they have been in the industry a lot longer