The fact is that Ms Lisa Wang cannot perform Cantonese opera....she has neither the voice not the basic skills to carry off any role...she might have wormed herself into the top post of the Pat Woh Association but she is still considered an outsider by most...she thinks that by pairing herself with the top Man Mou Sangs of the day like Ting Fan etc will enhance her image n standing...but sad to say it only exposes herself to ridicule n showcase to viewers n the audience her deficiencies...neither can Law Kar Ying help her...he was only a so so Sang during his heydays...not at all outstanding... his rise to prominence is largely due to his association n the time he was performing opposite the great one n only Ms Lee PY....she might think it an easy passage to transform herself from a small box series actress into a stage performer....but she neither had the stature, presence,voice not skills to impress....I think she might fit into the Mui Heong roles like those Lor San Lui etc...pls stop torturing us n know yr own limitations...
Agreed. But we do have to appreciate her hard work and persistence in trying to be the Cantonese opera actress. Too bad she really doesn't have the voices nor the training. Cantonese opera is an art that needs the training and practice.
這是阿姐代表作，激反那場叫反正那個關目甚佳，夠凌厲！❤🎉🥰😍🤩😘
羅家英，汪明荃夫妻檔及幾位大佬倌。這套戲劇，聲藝俱佳，我是戲迷，這套戲劇本好，我很欣賞汪亞姐粵唱粵好。👍👏👏👏👏
全劇都做得好好睇，故事感人正氣。難得見到羅家英大佬官唱做念打，一絲不苟的功架，阿姐扮相超驚艷，老實講，好少花旦有佢咁靚，這次唱子喉都非常好，應該哪個那個時候還年青吧。阿姐的確好難得，明知粵劇不是自己的強項 ，也欠缺天份，但還是醉心粵劇，利用自己的知名度提攜後輩，延續粵劇文化 ，佢對粵劇的貢獻、使命，與白雪仙不相伯仲，都值得學習，值得敬佩🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍
半途出家不要要求太高加上她是外省人添!🤩👍🤔🤭
好戲連場，好好好👍各位演得非常之成功，好戲連場，汪明荃令我大開眼界，任冰兒阮兆輝是無可自疑的大老官，功力深厚，羅家英無用置疑功㗎一流，好好好👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏，真係拍爛手掌，好精彩啊。
罗家英功架利落，身段好。演戏或粤剧一样精彩。
汪阿姐古裝扮相真係好靚
出色！出色！
.汪明荃唱得好，真係唔錯呀，人又靚
.
亞姐表情100分👍🏻
非常好謝謝
非常精彩！家英哥寶刀未老，功底扎實，贊贊赞！
亚姐声色艺只欠声，不然就真係very good, 但整體性可观，對普哥真係五體投地！就係中意睇呢D大戏，真係好大戏。
多谢回复，是否所有粤剧粤曲都可在此要求放送呢？
有一视频只可听声的，是梁汉威与黄伟坤的易水送荆軻
你们有吗？数年前曾在youtube上載過，後来片主收回了。謝謝你！
@@rosacatwong4948 l0
谢谢你发布精彩的节目。 2023 年新年快乐
辉哥無得顶.不愧一代宗師.祝福身體健康.幸福美滿.
阿姐很美。
覺得汪小姐和羅生，裝束、聲缐都好襯，有啲上氣唔接下氣咁🤭 又似睇佢兩公婆打情罵俏⋯
多谢上載!!好正!
(萬世流芳張玉喬)家英哥好小做戲,原來他武功重好熟練,功架了得偑服家英哥,汪亞姐唱功好咗好多,對上次(德龄
慈禧)亞姐做得很入戲,欣賞。
汪明荃唱得幾好。出乎我意料。相信她好努力練習,才達成今日成績。劇情又好。
非常落力值得贊
汪大媽出場影響了水准／幾個知明名伶也被拉低，二幫比她好，縣劇團水平，香港好多有實力的新秀要擔起重担。
福陞粵劇團，真是流芳百世，粵劇之光。看汪姐家英哥合作，我每場多年，抽空空間看全部，甚之神功戲，都捧場。当年靈感心願，祝願他倆們，天赐良緣，珠聯璧合，佳偶天成。兩人性格配合，以柔制剛，以退為進，互相包容體諒，尊重，明事理。是家英哥，最適合。患難見真情，才是最珍貴。晚年夫妻，更難得，珍惜，相敬如賓，永結同心。粵劇界更發揮，發揚光大。何時重看福陞劇團呢，期望渴求👍👍💪💪❤️❤️😄😄👌
好好看,感謝分享
👌❤
初演時不似粵曲，現在好得多了，行哥演一哥戲當然好啦。
這 套戲如果不翻做，不知有 張玉喬這嗰咁貞烈女子，可以為國 犧牲，結二次婚，然後自殺，讓後夫再投回明朝，真 令人欽敬😌😌😌👏👏👏
i never see yuen siew fai do a performance with chiang mun duan and Youll sing poll
❤💝👍✌❤💝😍
張玉喬歷史有沒此人？😙😙😙
應該是以陳圓圓為原型
好!好到意料之外。👍👍👍👍👍👏👏👏👏👏
:::
對於我哋睇慣大戲嘅人來講，汪亞姐做粵戲還可以勉強，但唱就不敢恭維喇🥴🥴🥴
亜姐未畢業只是早有名声！
香港粤剧著名剧目,唐滌生譜曲、填詞。講述明末清初乱世佳人張玉喬忍辱偷生,自刎感召後夫、投清將领李成棟起義反正,歸顺南明的悲壯故事。阮兆輝飾演抗清官員陳子壯,剛直不阿,兵敗殉國;声腔高昂、沉郁、悲壯,意态激烈奔放。羅家英李成棟形象威武雄伟;声量大、音質硬,行腔高亢激越,旋步英風,动作舒眉亮眼,做表气势磅礡;難以忠或奸評論其人格;由明軍变節投清,抱得美人歸,為報答紅颜之死,又再度回歸南明,情緒变化發展自然。雙生一旦戏,把兒女之情中的貞烈,对家國的盡忠細緻演繹。剧情高潮迭起,配樂豐富,大鑼大鼓与唱腔互為輝映
,使舞台气息变化無窮,震撼人心!
此劇開山應是武狀元陳锦堂芳艷芳两位前輩。😍🥰🤩
謝謝分享。認識了這也是唐滌生的作品。
汪明荃巔峰之作，唱做俱佳，好！好！好！
入
若有李宝莹的片段上载就好了！
此劇省略了最好看及最好聽的那場花旦唱主題曲:芳艶芬唱淚洒翡翠樓, 在芳姐原㓺第六場, 佟養甲總督進府前唱。汪明荃, 南鳳及青苗的年青花旦的版本, 都冇這場, 不知是否珠玉在前, 不敢效颦? 浪費了我三個晚上去睇, 都失望而回。
」1
得三個鐘咋，重唱主題曲？🤔
睇過芳姐，其餘後軰當過戲癮算啦，芳姐無人能及。
而家粵劇重缩到兩個鐘。😢
王昀浚
行哥本是我欣賞的前輩，可惜他改编外國劇：英雄叛國，李爾王走火入魔，竟然在中國文化節中國戲曲改编外國歌劇成大鼻子情聖，令我非常失望，他承傳的志向去了那處！😢
汪阿姐可借唔唱得!😜
亞姐色系靚、藝系有好，但系講到声真系重有九條街咁遠😢
越聴越覺得阿姐唱得未夠班
她不是紅褲子出身，半途出身，是咁上下喇，最慘就係她唱粵曲有震音先攞命，好似唱粵語流行曲咁來唱粵曲🥴🥴🥴
亞姐半途出家，能夠做到今時一成績已經係非常了不起，應該多以鼓勵不應該雞蛋裏挑骨頭，我佩服佢嘅毅力同精神所以比足一百分好好好阿姐好嘢
阿姐應該學上海妹腔，上海妹肺病冇氣，但好識用聲。
此劇本身就編得很好，開合有度，情節細膩，引人入勝，各佬倌表演亦佳，實在是一齣值得廣為介紹的文戲粵劇。可惜就是擔綱的正印花旦喉底太差，影響了整齣戲。要知文戲最重唱功，唱功不成，整齣戲就失色。
汪明荃是個學習勤力的演員，奈何她沒有好聲線的天賦，若論唱曲，此劇二幫任冰兒就比她好得多，更何況汪明荃不是以粵劇為其主要職業，踏台板的機會少，練習的機會自然就少。
我以上所論，全然站在藝術角度，並非有意對汪阿姐不敬。話說回來，若她演此劇另有目的，例如要和夫婿共做一塲戲，作為什麼什麼的紀念等等，這當別論。
十分同意，此劇為芳姐首本，單係唱功就冇得比。
H
好似再翻做，張玉喬，除了 汪明荃，冇人再做過
有，陳咏儀做過。
汪阿姐做花旦唱子喉唱到咁樣，獨白及唱曲都沙啞，亦欠粤劇唱功韻味，聲藝不存！
汪阿者貴为八和主席，还在门外。
Ken Yan said that Pi
Ken Yan l，
一語中的！
The fact is that Ms Lisa Wang cannot perform Cantonese opera....she has neither the voice not the basic skills to carry off any role...she might have wormed herself into the top post of the Pat Woh Association but she is still considered an outsider by most...she thinks that by pairing herself with the top Man Mou Sangs of the day like Ting Fan etc will enhance her image n standing...but sad to say it only exposes herself to ridicule n showcase to viewers n the audience her deficiencies...neither can Law Kar Ying help her...he was only a so so Sang during his heydays...not at all outstanding... his rise to prominence is largely due to his association n the time he was performing opposite the great one n only Ms Lee PY....she might think it an easy passage to transform herself from a small box series actress into a stage performer....but she neither had the stature, presence,voice not skills to impress....I think she might fit into the Mui Heong roles like those Lor San Lui etc...pls stop torturing us n know yr own limitations...
Liew Kai Sun
I am no fan of Lisa but i admire her passion and hardwork.
Agreed. But we do have to appreciate her hard work and persistence in trying to be the Cantonese opera actress. Too bad she really doesn't have the voices nor the training. Cantonese opera is an art that needs the training and practice.
←
難聽之極
汪亞姐轉唱平喉可能討好些和無咁辛苦。
Aaaaaaa