BONSAI SOIL vs POTTING MIX: Does it make a difference?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มี.ค. 2023
- The results of my 18 month experiment to determine what difference, if any, a good quality bonsai mix makes in comparison to a commercial potting mix. For trees I'm just growing on, I usually use a commercial cactus potting soil, mixed with about one third perlite, while for my more developed bonsai I use my own bonsai soil recipe. I wanted to find out if it made any difference, so I planted two cloned trident maple cuttings in two pots with each of the mixes. I also give my recipe for bonsai soil, which contains akadama, pumice, lava rock and composted pine bark. If you have a different recipe that works for you, congratulations! Despite my experimenting, I continue to believe that a lot of soil types will work for bonsai, and the most important elements are particle size and how much water it retains in your particular environment. Don't @ me.
Music: On Shore - Sergey Cheremisinov
Many places in South Asia grow bonsai in simple garden soil with rice husk and sand and they can make amazing bonsais.
Rice husk is filled with vitamins for the bonsai tree. Using rice water after boiling is also great to water orchids with.
One of the most dedicated and informative videos on bonsai I've ever watched. Congrats on your nice maples and thank you!
That is an extraordinarily nice comment. Thank you so much, I'm glad you enjoyed it.
Awesome video! This video answered all my questions. I believe this video should be a 1 million viewed video due to comparison and information. Other videos sound persuasive and deviate from the objective. Keep up the great work!
What a nice comment! Not many bonsai videos get 1 million views, unfortunately. Glad it helped you, though - I don't like to just repeat things I've heard if I haven't tested it myself.
I like your video style! I learned quite a bit 😊
Great video as usual. I think the higher levels of fertilizer in the potting mix is responsible for all the difference you noticed. I grow most of my trees in big pots with quite heavy organic soils the first few years. When I put them in shallow bonsai pots I add more inorganic substrates, but are still using more organics than most people. Works good for me in my climate and care. The biggest benefit is that I don't have to water that often.🙂👍
Right, I think the 100% inorganic mixes are great if you have a bonsai nursery with three or four watering sessions a day - for most of us humans, some organic material provides a margin of safety!
This was really interesting, thank you!
Great video mate, I’ve just subbed 😊
A really great, informative video. Thank you for the experiment and results. I'm the same to be honest, if it's young and growing on then I used a compost and perlite mix which works fine.
Great unbiased video. I cant afford expensive bonsai soil. So i mix my store bought potting mix with some perlite and small pebbles. Seems to work for me. And during raininh season its a good time for my cheap soil to clean and drain from the natural rain water that comes down
Akadama is £32 a bag of Japanese dirt ✔️👍
So effective information. Good share 🎉❤🎉❤
Great info in this video-thank you. Sub
I'll show this video to anyone who doesn't understand bonsai and why you would basically use what looks to be "gravel" as soil for a tree. Which for me, is everyone in my family 😆
I don't usually bareroot and cut the roots of my temperate trees during the growing season where I live, maybe you have success with it in Australia. Sometimes when it's my only option I will do it and I loosely cover my newly potted tree with a white plastic bag in some shade. It seems to help them recover.
I've been planning a root over rock as well and with a Trident, I hear they make great ror.
Thanks for the comment. I agree that it's not ideal, but I had four weeks in Australia to do everything. No choice :) Fortunately tridents are basically weeds, one day I'll do a video showing how they grow in all the vacant lots where I live in Korea.
@@growingwithbonsai Awesome, a bonsai growers dream, free tridents!
Compost pine bark?
You can't draw conclusions based on just two small and young examples! We would need dozens of examples and a multi-year period: at least three years. 18 months is not enough to make any definitive conclusion.
You seem to think I owe you something. The plants are genetically identical and I found out what I wanted to know. But feel free to conduct the experiment you describe yourself.