Is the Elgato Prompter Really the Best?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ก.ย. 2024
- The @elgato Prompter has been hailed as a huge success, and called the best teleprompter ever... the teleprompter for everyone... the perfect prompter... and many more overwhelmingly positive things by all of the creators who have reviewed it.
Does it really live up to the hype though? I'm not so sure... Join me in this livestream where I share my experience of using a range of teleprompters and where Elgato's propter excels and where it stumbles.
Full details of Prompter on the Elgato Website: www.elgato.com...
Support the channel and purchase your Prompter using my affiliate link: amzn.to/4dJMx9t
Here are the components of my 12.5" teleprompter:
ILOKNZI i7 Teleprompter amzn.to/3Uwh7bP
Lilliput A12 12.5" Field Monitor amzn.to/3EW3WeH
Here are the components of my 7" teleprompter:
Desview T3 Teleprompter: amzn.to/2UWkXSM
Lilliput A7S: amzn.to/3xZ0Xxl
Download the latest version of Elgato Camera Hub Here: www.elgato.com...
The Teleprompter App I use on my Mac with other Teleprompters is Teleprompter Pro+ : apps.apple.com...
Got a feature request for Elgato? Submit it to Elgato here: app.smartsheet...
#elgato #livestreaming #prompter
===‼️ CHECKOUT MY COURSES & AFFILIATE PROGRAM
🎬 Take One Tech Academy 👉 www.takeonetec...
📘 Stream Deck Masterclass - www.streamdeckm...
📕 Rodecaster Pro 2 Masterclass 👉 www.rodecasterm...
📙 Ecamm Live Masterclass 👉 www.ecammlivema...
💰 Become a Take One Tech Affiliate & EARN 30% COMMISSION on referrals to my courses! takeonetech.io/...
===💫 CONNECT WITH ME & THE COMMUNITY
🎬 Join the Take One Tech family to learn, share and grow with me and others (it’s free!) www.takeonetec...
🎫 Discover the added benefits of becoming a channel member: / @takeonetech
☎️ Need some 1 on 1 time with me? Book a consultation! www.takeonetec...
❤️ ‘Buy Me A Coffee’ allows you to make a single one off donation ☕️ www.buymeacoff...
📦 I’d really appreciate a follow on Amazon Live! www.amazon.com...
👕 Checkout My Merch Store! : merch.takeonet...
🎯 My Website: www.takeonetec...
🔳 Checkout Stream Deck icon packs in my store: www.takeonetec...
👍 Follow me on the other socials…
🕊 / takeonetech_
🔵 / takeonetech
📸 / takeonetech_
🎵 / takeonetech
===🌟 I RECOMMEND THE FOLLOWING SERVICES
🌟 Ecamm Live: takeonetech.io...
🌟 TubeBuddy: takeonetech.io...
🌟 Epidemic Sound: takeonetech.io...
🌟 Setapp: takeonetech.io...
🌟 Kajabi: takeonetech.io...
🌟 Restream: takeonetech.io...
===🧰 GEAR THAT I ACTUALLY USE
🎙 AUDIO
Rodecaster Pro 2 amzn.to/3bkaade
Shure MV7 amzn.to/3orJc5R
Shure RK345 windscreen amzn.to/2RlQRXk
KZ ZS10 Pro amzn.to/3x5Edee
KZ ZSN in-Ear Monitor Cables amzn.to/2Sdo8EI
Elgato Wave LP Mic Boom amzn.to/3IukA6n
Avermedia Livestreamer Arm amzn.to/3PgTC4C
🎛 PERIPHERALS
Stream Deck XL: amzn.to/3huECm6
Stream Dec+: amzn.to/3nI0tvn
Stream Deck Pedal: amzn.to/3AeqqHe
Logitech MX Master 3: amzn.to/3hugkso
Logitech MX Mouse Case: amzn.to/3uV43kk
Logitech Wireless Presenter: amzn.to/2TuXqYq
📷 CAMERA
Sony ZV1 amzn.to/3OSAaMt
Sony ZV-E10 amzn.to/3B06xTG
Sigma 30mm Lens amzn.to/3EU051D
💡 LIGHTING
2 x Nanlite Forza 60 amzn.to/3EZRdYm
1 x Nanlite Forza 60 Softbox amzn.to/3XPoBK3
1 x Nanlite 60 Grid amzn.to/3FijLhd
1 x Nanlite Para 90 Softbox amzn.to/3gYyl3V
1 x Nanlite 90 Grid
1 x Nanlite Forza Bowens Mount Adapter amzn.to/3Fkg7TP
1 x Nanlite MixPad II 11C amzn.to/3VtbxIA
4 x Nanlite Pavotube II 6C amzn.to/3EZLjq8
2 x Nanlite Pavotube II6C Fabric Grid amzn.to/3FkgtK9
4 x Nanlite LitoLite 5C: amzn.to/3OSelwA
⚙️ OTHER RANDOM GEAR
Peak Design Tech Pouch: amzn.to/3omICqc
4K Virtual Monitor: amzn.to/3ojdAPI
iClever Folding Keyboard: amzn.to/3gQKqom
The large digital clock above my monitor! amzn.to/3uEbw9u
Some links are affiliate links which means I earn a commission from qualifying purchases. Using my links helps support my channel at no additional cost to you. Thanks for your support!🙏😊
It would have definitely been so much better if they released a 12 inch screen on top of their 9 inch. I am sure the second version will be better, but we'll never know when it will arrive. Those waiting for a StreamDeck+ with more buttons are still waiting. So Im getting this now
I really appreciate your perspectives and insights. You have a great Channel. Thank You 🙏🏾 and yes, thanks for unmuting 😅. Cheers and Thanks 😊
Thank you! Glad you like it :-)
Caught replay. Awesome detail. Thanks Alec
You're welcome Florence! Glad it was helpful :-)
When Elgato addes the voice control feature I have with the Prompt Smart Pro software I’ll consider getting one.
Elgatos Promter software feels a bit like Beta software to me really.... certainly lacking a lot of features at the moment!
@@TakeOneTech I fully agree. As you pointed out some features seem very awkward and unfinished. You’d think with all the professionals they work with they’d be farther along with the software.
Another top notch live, Alec - bravo! 👏 Very informative.
I use a 16” teleprompter mounted on a tripod with the Sony ZVE10, and I use a reconditioned iPad Pro 12.9” for the monitor (flipped using the Duet app).
There were some teething problems to start with, but it now runs perfectly with my M3 Max MBP; so, apart from dusting the iPad occasionally, everything stays exactly where it is! 😬
I agree with your point about a larger screen being important for Zoom calls; an Elgato Prompter XL with improved software would sweep the board…
Thanks Jesse! It's definitely worth the extra effort to setup a larger teleprompter over the Elgato Prompter. Having been used to the 12.5" screen on my teleprompter, the Elgato prompter suddenly felt more toy like!
Just found your channel - fantastic content! Can I ask for your vote on my teleprompter purchase - I'm looking to invest in a teleprompter for language education content. I am filming with iPhone 12 and have good lights and audio. What do you vote for: 1.) Elgato prompter or 2.) bigger iPad + amazon teleprompter (neewer, glide gear, desview etc). Talking head style vids, maybe sometimes stepping back a wee bit to teach using white board...many thanks!
This is amazing because you are talking about my situation. I have had the Desview T2 then the Desview T3 with the A7 Lilliput for the last 4 years. I recently purchased the larger 10 in Lilliput but I had to get a tablet stand to hold it and position it under the Desview. This for me to to cumbersome and not as clean as using the smaller A7. I have been looking into the Elgato promoter even before it was released. After reading the resolution I thought that I wouldn’t be as clear as the Lilliput. Is the picture on the Elgato just as clear and the Lilliput? Thanks
Technically the screen quality on the lilliputs will be superior to the Elgato prompter.... they are after all intended as precision field monitors and are both 4K, while the Elgato is 1024 x 600.
however Even on my 12" Lilliput I set my resolution to 720p because I want the interface elements to be larger on the screen. So in that respect I believe Elgato made the right choice with resolution.
I mentioned in the livestream that I did notice some issues with the Elgato when I have anything light coloured on the screen... it seems to give a 'misty' glow in the camera output. I can only think that this is related to the glass they have used in reflector. People have said "just turn down the monitor brightness' but it is not something I have ever experiences with any of my other teleprompters, so it does seem specific to the Elgato Prompter.
I ultimately upgraded my 7" lilliput & Desview T3 combo to a lager teleprompter with a 12.5" liilliput. I prefer the larger size as I find it much better on Zoom calls which is my primary use case. Therefore I will not be switching to the Elgato prompter as it feels like a distinct downgrade in screen size.
However since you have said that you found the larger screen setup more cumbersome, then you will definitely like the Prompter... it is a significant upgrade on the 7" lilliput in terms of screen real estate without adding much more bulk. In fact, given that it is all in one, it almost feels less bulky than the Desview/Lilliput combo.
Hope that helps! :-)
How are you getting the monitor with zoom to auto reverse so it looks right in teleprompter and not upside down?
I'm using a field monitor in my Teleprompter whcih has biuilt in function to flip the screen vertically and/or horizontally.
Here are the components of my 12.5" teleprompter:
ILOKNZI i7 Teleprompter amzn.to/3Uwh7bP
Lilliput A12 12.5" Field Monitor amzn.to/3EW3WeH
Here are the components of my 7" teleprompter:
Desview T3 Teleprompter: amzn.to/2UWkXSM
Lilliput A7S: amzn.to/3xZ0Xxl
Although costly compared to regular monitors, I use field monitors precisely because they have the ability to flip the image, something not possible natively on the Mac.
The Elgato Prompter does the flipping automatically.
@@TakeOneTech Thank you for letting me know. I purchased the Prompter People Pocket Cue V2 thinking I would use an iPad. Didn’t realize that iPad doesn’t flip for Zoom calls etc. I wanted to get a monitor for it but the one they sell is $270.
Q: thank you Alec great info as always. Does the prompter accept an iPhone as the web cam?
There is not a custom iPhone mount, as such, however you can use any generic iphone mount (such as this: amzn.to/3V1bki5 ) and then use screw that to the same plate I had my ZV1 mounted on in the video. (The plate and screw are provided with the prompter).
@@TakeOneTech thank you again Alec. Truly enjoying your great videos. And the Ecamm training I bought from you. Alec I know a technique to remove filler words (ums, errs etc) and would gladly share it with you on a quick zoom at some time). Peter
@@peterthomson5155 Thank you Peter, that is very kind of you and I'm always open to improving and learning! Happy to chat any time and you are welcome to book a Zoom call here: www.takeonetech.io/discovery-call
Thank you 🙏😊
Will do Alec
Would you say that the Elgato is an updated from the Lilliputian A7s. I use it for zoom calls and work calls. Is the picture just as clear as the Lilliput or is the Elgato a clearer image? Thank you.
Does Elgato prompter work with the Lumix G7 camera with 25MM micro four thirds lens?
An 1.5 video to review a prompter?
You obviously didn’t watch it all and listen properly, chief.
Six words and two numbers to say some senseless?
With my weekly livestreams I tend to take a deep dive into a particular topic and thats what I did here....
I felt that in order for people to really understand all of the hype around Prompter, there needed to be context given in terms of exactly what a teleprompter is (many people don't know the full use cases for such a a device) and then the other offerings and my experience of using them and thus where the Prompter excelled and where it stumbled.
The of course it was a livestream so took audience comments and questions which was the final half hour.
With that in mind, it was not intended to be a concise review... I'll be posting a separate shorter (sub 30 min) recorded video with that in the coming days .... I'll also be posting a separate step by step setup tutorial as well....
Fortunately TH-cam displays the video length on the thumbnails so folks know what they are getting into before they click through! They also indicate if it was a live stream, as I know some folks prefer pre-recorded/edited content to live streams