7 Items That Seriously Break Minecraft
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ก.ย. 2024
- My 100 days no totem stream is tomorrow!
- The Previous Video(8 Things WE NEED):
• 8 New Features Minecra...
- Think you've missed something? You might have, and you can check my most recent uploads here: / ibxtoycat
Update Adventures (My Let's Play):
• Update Adventures Let’...
- My Twitter: / ibxtoycat
- Follow for video updates and Early News!
This Video Was Edited By:
Random 7S
You can become a channel member by clicking here:
/ @toycat
The beauty of Minecraft is that you can play however you want, you can choose not to use these things if you think they are too powerful. Getting rid of/nerfing them eliminates that freedom.
Quite the opposite for a few reasons
1. Smps if your not the owner you can’t just not remove them from your game and if you want to be able to be comparable to other players power level you will definitely need totems and mending
2. These things are like junk food it’s mentally hard to stop using them even if you know they ruining some things someone may have to intervene for you to stop
3. When something is harder to get but is the same power level as something easy to get your brain may subconsciously choose the easier option and completely ignore the other so making something less powerful creates more of a choice not removes a choice
No
@@kipy_mudkip 1. SMP’s shouldn’t be what we balance Minecraft around due to the fact that players can drop the most powerful items for any newbie to grab up, therefor those servers are just areas where balance has no importance unless we make Minecraft impossibly difficult for solo players.
2. You cannot genuinely have a addiction to using a powerful item in a video game.
3. You can just consciously choose not to use something instead of playing Minecraft on full autopilot.
@@sud1881
1. On normal smps ppl usually start around the same time and a lot of smps aren’t just friendly no kill, no steal kinda smps
2. Yes, yes you can
3. You kinda have a point
@@kipy_mudkip this!
Nerf mending... By giving us other options than mending.
Quite frankly the fact that I have to choose between Put mending on my tools or inevitably replace them is annoying. I don't want to have to make the EXACT SAME super pickaxe over and over again when mine breaks. That's not fun, that's annoying
Exactly!
Edit: and when you think about it, most of minecraft overpowered stuff can be ignored if you don't play multiplayer
Don't like shields making survive easy? Don't use
Don't like how fast elytra is? You can completly ignore it
kind of like mending and infinity.
I feel like putting a cap on repair XP would be enough to nerf mending. It wouldn't make it useless, but having the ability to repair a tool forever (even if it costs 20-30 levels to do so) would make it so that it's not a required enchantment for players that get attached to their tools.
You know what's really OP? Beds, you can just sleep in them and bypass the entire night. It's like a cheat that turns on peaceful mode on the surface.
That's like saying that torches are op because they stop mobs from spawning
@@nickorlando86 Aren't they? Think about how much harder the game is when you can't use light sources to block spawning. (If you're playing normally that is, if you're just rushing to see the credits, it wouldn't be a notable problem.)
Meanwhile a sword is an active solution that does make surviving easier, but takes active use, loses durability, costs food, and puts you into harm's way. It is similar to torches, but is far less powerful.
You can nerf everything to force players to play the game the way you want. However, you will likely lose a large portion of your player base in the process. Check out 7 Days 2 Die and the problems concerning the constant nerfing of that game.
If the devs of minecraft have left these things in their game, I'm sure that it is to make the game more enjoyable for everyone. You as a player can choose what tools you would like to use that the game provides for you. That's kinda the idea of a sandbox game. You always have the option to choose not to use a bed or a torch or anything besides your fists really
@@nickorlando86 I wasn't concerned about nerfing any of these, I was just commenting on how beds are similarly OP to any of the items mentioned in the video.
@@nickorlando86 agreed, just look at 1.9 and youll see as much
I seen a suggestion as how to somewhat nerf totems on twitter that I thought was pretty good: They should remove Evokers from Raids and replace them with Illusioners. This could not only give the illusioner a role in the game, but also make totems exclusive to mansions giving you a reason to visit them again
I think that is a great idea.
That's good but the spawn rate of the illusioners should be lowered a bit since they are more powerful than evokers.
U saw not seen
I say make evokers much stronger and rarer in raids. Make them more of a threat than ravengers.
No because how will Hardcore work? Totems are farmable so it’s easier for long term players like me.
My thing is why nerf them at all, if you really want a challenge just dont use them at all, it really isnt necessary to change them
100%. Leave it alone for players who are casual and don't want to endlessly search and graft for rare items. Or have an option on world creation settings that can disable them. But I prefer your advice...don't use them.
agreed
I think its better to remove iron and raid farms and villager manipulation.@user-yu8ge5li5j , a casual players does not need hundreds of iron (I am a casual player, I dont have time to be technical) , they can just mine for 30 minutes. what if minecraft survivial had this item that could instakill and you could get it by mining dirt, would people just say, "dont use it"? its all about game balancing , most of these are exploits and werent even meant to exist anyway, iron is meant to be mined, villagers are meant to not be manipulated and instead traded with.
@@Sheepybearry i feel like this just a personal thing, also its not an item that insta kills things itd just an iron farm, you have to go through a whole process to create. Again if you dont want to use it then don't. And honestly who cares if it "wasnt meant to be used that way" its not hurting anyone and if anything stuff like this is a benefit. You have to remember this is also a sandbox game based on creativity and the fact the community were able to create an exploit out of this shows how far it can be taken.
@@Sheepybearry
It's a game it's supposed to be fun not a chore.
There is nothing exciting about mining.
Though i understand your perspective i don't agree with taking away methods of taking away game's tedium.
The game is a sandbox.
Play the way you want to play don't push it on others.
I personally would stop playing the game than mine for hours.
The problem with mending is that it doesn't feel like a powerful bonus. It feels like a necessity. It is practically mandatory to get first before thinking about getting any other powerful enchantments, or many enchantments on the same item. Not having mending necessitates getting other enchantments in unlimited quantities, or otherwise devalues them. That efficiency V book i found in a treasure chest is not very exciting when its gonna last literally a couple of minutes cuz my tool breaks.
And I tried to not use librarians! I actually made an effort to find Mending as intended, in treasure chests! Spent hours on it, no luck, that wasn't fun at all.
I dont know why not many people think of it, but they could reduce the need for mending in the first place. How many people even remember that you can repair things on the anvil using copy of the same tool, or even raw materials, without losing enchantments? Unfortunately, that can only be used a couple of times before the cost skyrockets and the repair becomes impossible. My thoughts are... why not just allow this to be the default way of repairing things? Smooth out the repair cost growth (or even remove it, why is it even a thing?) and, most importantly, give it a hard cap, so that repairing your stuff is possible indefinitely. Now it is just Mending, but consumes materials, costs more levels, and requires taking some more actions. This will make mending still desirable rare enchantment, but in no way mandatory.
edit: okay i actually watched later into the video. Yeah, that's the problem with nerfing such necessary things as mending, and arguably iron farms, removing them would not provide more choices, but rather detract from the gameplay. If you make getting enchantments difficult again, most players, _especially_ new ones, would just not get to experience them. Because unless you specifically enjoy mining for hours or otherwise grinding, that will just take away from playing the game the way you want to.
Repairing shouldn't increase the cost of combining in the anvil: it should be a fixed price, maybe 10 levels? Then there would be an alternative for mending in a challenge mode.
Stfu with ur mc personality
It's true they should reduce costs of repairing tools because right now you can only really do it a few times
Also maybe make the anvil not break randomly... or not break at all.
@@criss3656 It doesn't though. You see cracks forming on it the more you use it and it'll break. Plus, Iron isn't hard to stack up on anyways.
I think it would be better to just add alternatives to these items so that there is a choice that has to be made
That's also a valid way to nerf things! It's exactly what I suggest, too :)
One would be remove mending from hardcore, that simple change would completely change the hardcore series, or add emerald armour that can't be enchanted, as emeralds can become chest fillers, with a good raid and villager trade setups
@@hubertradford3799 removing mending from hardcore makes no sense.
it doesn't make the game harder, just infinitely more annoying
@@dudeofdudovia try doing trips to the nether fortress and a bastion with armour that doesn't regen and see how long you last
@@hubertradford3799 You could just.. leave when your armor gets low, as they said; not harder, just horribly annoying
If any of these items were nerfed, I would just not update
Omg let's GOO! I don't wanna see you anyway
@@crunchywashere3513 ?
@@JackieJKENVtuber LMAO get out
@@crunchywashere3513 you confuse me, mate
@@JackieJKENVtuber hassam the pain, watch the twain and let me know if the rain gets to your wayne
1. About Totems. Not everybody wants to make complex farms. I, for instance, only do crop farms and a dungeon xp farms, nothing more. It's just a different style of play - to not be bothered with a 2+ hour build just to get a "try again" button. And, with all of this in mind, Totems only work if you're holding them. So you'll miss out on a shield, or on a secondary block to place in your offhand when building. However, I wouldn't mind if Totems become more harder to find. I could even use one for a change. Totems are not really overpowered and do not need a nerf.
2. About iron. I genuinely don't understand this one. Firstly, you, again, need to make a iron farm, and it's far cry from a basic thing to construct. Second, you don't need that much iron anyway unless you're up to a mega project like a huge railway. I always found it more tedious to make an iron farm rather to go mining when I needed to make my railways, and it never failed me. Iron farms do not need to be nerfed.
3. About Mending. It definitely needs to be more rare. They should make all villagers have a cache of their trades to never change them, like when after you traded with them. That way it would take an insane amount of luck or a giant man-mane village (which is pretty cool) to obtain the trade you need. Plus, the librarians should only have basic level enchantments at first and gradually transition to the best ones. Mending, or more rather villager trade refreshment is in desperate need of a nerf.
4. About duplication. I would like it to keep being patched out from the game; they can't really be irradiated for good, though. But if the TNT duplication will be patched, it would leave players without the means of creating devices like World Eaters. Before you nerf TNT dupes, you should suggest an alternative, like a mob that consumes blocks down to the bedrock for example, with going through the Deep Dark portal for a requirement of getting such mob for yourself. Duplication has to be nerfed or, which is better, patched out completely.
100% agree with most of this, farms should still exist for the technical players, more effort=more reward, and would like to see them make mining more fun for adventure type players.
Villagers can't just be changed by putting the trades at the end and the like, as players will still do the same thing, breed hundreds of villagers/materials to get the perfect villager, this just makes it more tedious and time-consuming which is not fun. I would like to see them add more complex mechanics to it such as gifting the villager a diamond to reset the trades, still means some investment but removes the tedious nature of moving villagers around (this is still not a great idea but haven't put a lot of thought into it tbh, just needs to be fun instead of tedious somehow like a mini-game).
For the duplication, when they remove it, they just need to add a renewable way to get sand then TNT can just be crafted without destroying whole deserts to build these types of machines, would be great for concrete etc too.
agreed
Like these ideas more less,introduce negative exp to remove durability when using mending would be interesting. Automatic farm building is a play style more then a core problem, I play with my friend on his realm and he doesn’t use auto farms but that’s because its his choice to keep the game balanced. When it come down to it Minecraft the game is one that lets make it as hard or as easy as you want depending on your personal play style and that what makes a amazing game.
Even if villagers can’t change their trades , players can simply kill the villager that doesn’t have the item they are looking for , just have a zombie spawner be connected to the trading hall , wait for a zombie villager and cure it to replace the villagers lost, that’s how I got my villagers to my trading hall
I don't carry totems most the time anyways. The off hand slot is quite useful in java and there's a big opportunity cost giving it up to a totem
To be clear: as I said in the video, most of these would be best served by having viable alternatives, like how the Elytra shouldn't be nerfed but horses and minecarts buffed. These are the biggest points where one thing is better than the rest.
Btw My Record Breaking 100 Day Live Stream Is starting early tomorrow, here:
th-cam.com/video/oq8FiKsGZ90/w-d-xo.html
I have never gotten a totem except for once and then my friend (we have a multimplayer server waited till I logged off killed me once i got back on and took the totem.
Don't TH-cam live streams top out at 12 hours? Or did they increase the maximum amount of time a single live stream can run?
I was afk while going down a water stream
And used up my totem.
That I just spent an hour getting ):
I will be honest, I don’t actually agree with you on most of these items because grinding for items is truly something I enjoy. If anything they should add a harder difficulty that removes the ability to obtain these items. BUT HEY, that’s just my opinion and it’s ok when people disagree on things especially when it’s a just a video game.
19:27 can we get an f?
When totems came only from Woodland Mansions, they were so rare that I never wanted to use them. Now with raid farms, they've become so common that they are no longer special. There's a really hard balance to find for the totem because they are invaluable in Hardcore where death is everything, but cheap in survival where death is rarely all that punishing.
20:38 A biome filled with endermen and witches would actually be really interesting
Having farms makes massive survival projects possible that would not be achievable otherwise
100%. I can easily go through a stack or two of iron for projects that aren't even that big. As a matter of fact, I wouldn't even use an iron farm if it wasn't for the ore distribution changes. Before 1.18 I could go mining for diamonds and come back with multiple stacks of iron, but now if I go mining for diamonds I'll only get a fraction of the iron. You pretty much have to make two mines at different Y levels for diamonds and iron and that increases the amount of time you're spending just walking in a line and breaking blocks. I get that mining is a huge part of MINEcraft, but when I'm already spending an hour trying to get diamonds the last thing I wanna do is go to a different mine to spend an additional hour getting iron. Even though fortune works on iron ore now, it still just feels like a waste of time mining for it (at least in my experience). Mining for diamonds and ancient debris at least makes you feel like you're achieving a goal, mining for iron just feels like a chore.
Farms don't need a nerf so much as mining needs a buff. I think there's a way to solve multiple of these issues with one stone.
If you nerf farms you also damage other types of play, such as skyblock.
no, I wouldent think so
@@Sheepybearry I'm guessing you've never gone for a big build then
@@onemoreweirdo207 I hope you are not the type to flex on constructions when you use creative mode
It’s Minecraft not a multiplayer pvp game. items don’t need to be balanced.
So actively make Minecraft less fun? Yeah no. This isn’t the kind of game that constantly needs buffs and nerfs because it’s not intended to be competitive. It’s a sandbox ffs
It is intended to be "competitive" in the form of "competitive" servers
@@WillowaffleANTIGD the servers can set their own rules
These are all optional and you are forgetting most players do not even finish the “game”. My own kids don’t build farms, they go into creative and just create enchanted items.
Maybe Mojang realized that people do not enjoy spending hours to get the best tools only to have them break. Having lost two sets of gear to the end, there is still risk and pain possible in losing gear.
Exactly this, I hate it when people complain about an entirely skippable feature like farms being too OP on a single player, non'competitive game. Like, then don't make one and let the rest of us have fun?
@@onemoreweirdo207 and you are the type to say "raid farms are useful for long term hardcore world people like me" bro what are you thinking
@@crunchywashere3513 Ah, here wego:
1) I personally don't like hardcore, I prefere being able to die. However, totem farms ARE useful for a long term hardcore player unless that person doesn't like using totems, which is completely their choice.
2) Why would making something in creative not be impressive? Do you have ANY idea how people design megabases or redstone contraptions? Most people go into creative, figuere out a good design and then proceed to make it in survival, as randomly placing blocks until it works out tends to not work out.
3) There are people who make AMASZING stuff in creatve. In fact, most profesional minecraft builders and youtubers do that.They use building mods like worldedit too. Does that make it any less impressive? Should they not be proud of their builds?
4) Why does how one choses to play the game so much matter to you? Why do you mind people being happy over what they achieved in the game?
@@onemoreweirdo207 Totems should be nerfed in Hardcore, I liked the cooldown idea. I didn't say creative content was trash, I said what's the point of having it easy on survival when you can go to creative?
@@crunchywashere3513 What;s the point of complaining when you can just not use totems in your world?
Let's be clear here, exploration is a lot of fun, but for the smaller portion of the playerbase on Java, it increases the world's file size quite significantly, since it saves every chunk that has been loaded. It's easy to gain several GBs of world size just doing some End City raiding. Now for things like iron this won't typically be a problem, but exploring to find just the right villager absolutely would be.
For me anyway this is a problem with Java's world saving system, but it has also lead to me trimming out large chunks of the End so I don't have 6GB of End saved with nothing built or done with them.
If something is too powerful and that is bad just do not use. Mojang is not forcing u to use item.
Mojang does not just place a totem in your off hand
@@citricmantis_543 I guess that's true but that isn't good game design the player shouldn't have to force themselves to not use a beneficial item
That's kinda like if there's a duplication bug and you just say oh well don't use that bug well that bug should be in the game in the first place
@Normalman18 Yes but people not accepting it is better than removing a feature which people like. There are lot of people that do not like when things are limited because if they use them up you cannot get any in the world. Also some people’s play style is build as many auto farms as possible and collect things form there. Most autofarms are not that easy to build and are not early game and are more mid game. Finally the wood land mansion has 3 totems compared to raids on, loot chests, and more illagers for loot. Raids have one totem and you have to get the bad omen so woodland mansion have a use they just are not as good a before.
I relish the grammar was horible sorry for that
Yeah auto correct is putting the wrong words
DO NOT COME FOR MY LIBRARIANS!!!!!
So you want to nerf most of the things that makes Minecraft playable and punish those of us that invest the time to make farms and learn elements of the game beyond running throught caves with an unenchanted pickaxe. Interesting.
Happy Thanksgiving toycat. Also technically there is no such thing as black Friday anymore. We used to see Wal-Mart turn into a gladiatorial arena in which stressed to the max moms beat eachother over the head with tickle me elmo.
Following up on your suggestion, make enchanted books a level 3-5 trade,
Or, keep it as it is, and(this was an idea I once thought of) a villager, by birth, will have a pre-determined trade list of every profession. So, replacing a jobsite will not replace a trade. You need to breed up villagers to get mending. Better than the previous way of exploring the world for mending villagers, and less overpowered than recycling trades.
Mending and Totems should stay in normal modes and be nerfed/removed in hardcore since it's meant to be a challenge, if you are not worrying about death or cannot die in hardcore there is something fundamentally wrong with it
P.s love the idea of removing Totems from raids in hardcore
totems maybe, mending no.
mending makes the game fun because i don't have to create 52 sets of the same tools because it says "Too Expensive!"
After all these years it took me till11:46 to realize the librarian has a book on there head for a hat
Very well edited video, absolutely loved it Toycat! I’ve always enjoyed the top 5 style videos (:
Disagree. The background footage chosen was quite distracting.
Edit: STupid 2Nd LEtter TYpo!!
14:02 I really disagree with this one as a person that doesn't have all day to mine huge areas and even if I did I wouldn't spend it on something so boring. Having a way in survival to do mine huge areas for cool builds is really good. The best option here is to allow players in the late game to create a tnt that acts a a limit infinite tnt or better yet make title entities push-able
The philza reference honestly made my day :]
Maybe there should be an incentive for getting some items more traditionally. A cooldown for totems being used would make them more complex to use
An Enchanter mob being added to the Raids might make fights harder
Hardcore players would afk till the totem cooldown is up
Ok - so explain to me why Minecraft is more fun if you nerf all of these things?
While I understand removal of duplication machines, many of these things help make the game playable to those who are not very good at it, and/or don't have the time to spend hours grinding for stuff. I can also understand moving enchanted books up the librarian tech tree; that feels like a fair balance.
I know nobody asked, but I was just working at my skeleton farm while watching your video because farming is boring and a FULL DIAMOND skeleton just popped into the killing chamber! I too play on bedrock. I love how it was at the exact same time you were talking about the raid farms!
No don’t do this to us
Hot take? They don’t need to nerf these things. Not everyone wants to have to deal with a harder game because this one part wants a challenge that they can easily self impose; if someone wants to have large supplies of totems, why not let them? Too overpowered? Well simple solution, don’t use it. Nobody’s forcing you to use your massive supplies.
This is Minecraft, a game where you can play however you want. And that includes the people who want large supplies of stuff, and wants the game to be harder. Regarding the latter, if you want the game to be harder just self impose it. No need to ruin other people’s fun because you want something else
A good option would be to have mending or such books to be only be a relatively rare treasure item and you have sell the books to a specific villager who will take them so they could "study" them so once you sell him 3 or some arbitrary number he will be able to sell you some so you actually have to go find mending a few times adding some hardship but after that you have "infinite" mending when your world moves on to bigger and better things rather than just hunting for books all day . That way the power level in your world proguess as you play unlike current system where you could quite easily get mending villager day one
Edit: this could also add to the lore that enchanted books were a lost technology that was created by the old builders who built all the structure and that we are bringing that knowledge back which would be super cool a sort of restoring the greatness of an older Minecraft civ.
that would be a really neat mechanic!
I would like that to be a feature of library villagers in general, that you can teach them enchants to sell to you
Aside from the fact that I don't think I've ever seen a mending book in any chest ever, I think this is an interesting mechanic that should honestly apply to all villagers.
Got a mason who's selling purple terracotta but you want him to sell white? Just give him three white ones. I love this idea.
@@imperfectimp the point is to make them a chest only or maybe low fishing chance book
The only problem with nerfing different things is that, for the casual player, they don't have time to spend extra hours mining or exploring. Only the small minority who are extremely committed to Minecraft and play all the time are the ones who complain about these features.
While I really like the idea of the totem being nerfed, I really only see this as a divide in the playerbase. Because Minecraft allows you to play on earlier versions(which is a good thing),nerfing features that people use a lot, especially hardcore players will only mean they play on an earlier version or maybe just make a mod that reverts functionality to the totem(totem functionality is probably way easier to revert than combat?).
Also, you can just skip using totems alltogether if you want to. Nobody is forcing anyone to use them.
@@onemoreweirdo207 I dont think thats a fair argument. If something is implemented in the game ,then most people(who at least know of the feature) will use it. By then it becomes more of a "challenge" of sorts like "playing hardcore without totems" or something like that, without being the keyword. There's no easy answer to any of these problems and it's even harder for Minecraft because of it's massive integration in the community (plus the snapshot system)
@@TheSonicVEVO That's the thing, they are not problems, they are FEATURES. You are the one not liking them, therefore you are the one who doesn't have to use them. It's really a fair arguement, you don't need to see not making a farm or not starting a raid as a challenge, because it isn't.
Why should the game become more boring for thousands of people to please the ones who dislike avoidable features?
@@onemoreweirdo207 fair enough then your argument makes sense
What if Mending books were one-time use items that reset a tool's repair cost? If your tool says "Too Expensive!", just use a Mending book on it and you can repair it with materials again.
This is how the Unmending mod works.
6:00 I think I have a pretty cool way to counter Iron Farms that makes actual sense (not really...). My Idea is it to add the Furnace Golem from Minecraft Earth to Minecraft. It wouldnt take damage from lava and it could have its own sonic boom attack with the difference from the warden being that it shoots fire which would burn the player rather than soul energy. Once an Iron Golem has been killed, the village will begin to spawn Furnace Golems. This also prevents the 3 blocks stacking up method since with the sonic boom or fire boom he has a ranged attack. You could also get a Furnace Golem by repairing Iron Golems with Blast Furnaces.
12:00 To make villager trading less organized and harder to get good trades I have an Idea. Enchanted Items are normally the best trades. I would make it so you cant see what enchantments are on the books/tools/armor you buy and that it would be randomized again every single time you buy another item. That way not every librarian that doesnt have mending has to die. The only thing you see is the enchantment glint in the trade Gui. Lets say you buy an enchanted book for 24 emeralds or something and you get bane of arthropods II. Then you buy another one and get Sharpness V and after that you get trash again with fire protection I. This would also introduce little kids to gambling which is obviously a very good idea jk.
16:00 Mending could become the second signature enchantment of ancient cities since it works similar to sculk making it rarer than before.
They shouldn’t take away the totems from raid it should be low probability like %5 or %10 drop chance. So you can farm but it is so much slower
Still if you grind enough that type of nerf is irrelevant just like how people get insane amounts of wither skulls with farms despite it being just a 5% chance with looting. If anything doing that would just encourage more raid farms because assuming that the average mansion has 3 evokers the chance of getting at least one totem is only about 14%. One cannot underestimate how much players will grind to get truly massive storage systems that can collect thousands of these unstackable items.
@@theidiot3731 oh I thought I said only one evoked per raid. Yea it would be some what irrelevant, but they would have to afk for sooooo long if 1 per raid
That's not a good change because the nerf is to just increase the grind. Minecraft is already super grindy.
I'm a technical player turned builder and the iron veins are so powerful I have no intention of building an iron farm and don't need one.
Great video! I love this editing!
Personally, I don't really spend a lot of time with villagers but when I do and I usually only get a few villagers and use an enchantment table for the rest. I agree with making enchantment books a higher-tier trade though. That's what it should be.
Honestly, just make one or two enchantments that are unique to the table.
well i dont care cause all my villagers are top tier. probably cause i have like 3 tho lol
That would make villagers even worse, having to spend hours to get what you need is already bad enough, not even knowing whjat it is after spending lots of emeralds is even worse.
I like getting some free enchantments from the table and finishing off my gear via villagers. It costs less xp than just villagers alone, allowing me to put more stuff on
@@glassofwater281 Exactly! That's how I always do it!
Harder-core = no totems.
No do t nerf these just don't use them
Lots of ppl actually love this game for the farms and quirks that make things attainable
Most of the issues he have sounded like they could've been solved with buffs to other items or alternatives. Minecraft is a super time consuming game and I'm not down for making it harder just because some people like late game stuff too much.
Totems aren't even as OP as he says. You can pop a totem and then just get spanked by some mob/lava/whatever immediately afterwards.
Rite and mending isn't op either you literally eat exp in order to keep good gear I find it more op that you can buy diamond gear from villagers but at the same time I got kids and when they play they dint have the patience to go strip mine and I'm not about to reach into my end chest to give them new gear everytime they die to fall damage and don't know where they were
@@Apparentlygaming1 villager enchanting is also nuts. I have literally dozens of sets of fully enchanted diamond armor and gear, and more than enough netherite to upgrade it. Honestly that'd be much more important if I had kids on my server
The thing is, the point of Monecraft is to enjoy the game however you like. Not wanting to deal with "OP items" is simply a choice you can make as a challenge to yourself. Nobody is forcing you to make farms.
True, but still some people do love the overpowered items because it saved them so many times
Specially if you only play in single player and don't care about balancing *cough*
@@brunoreis4455 true
Instead they should add more hard bosses like the Warden so we have an excuse to use these items.
Bedrock players already have one in the Wither. As a player of both Bedrock and Java, Java’s wither is a joke and Bedrock’s is as hard as the Warden.
@@ASH4Ix they nerfed the bedrock wither lol
tbh minecraft is bad for hard bosses, look at terraria calamity mod, all the hard bosses are fought mid air, elytra sucks for dodging projectiles
@@xenird and for aiming.
also minecraft can be great for bosses, terraria is 2d so ground movement is not really viable, minecraft is 3d and it has WAAAAY more ground movements
@@xenird you shouldn’t bring up mods of other games to compare to vanilla Minecraft I’m sure there are a lot of extremely hard Minecraft boss mods that are hard and not just 1000 health 80 damage
Lots of interesting ideas here, and I understand that they're top-of-the-head suggestions, but if they removed Mending from Netherite gear, I wouldn't bother with Netherite at all. It wouldn't be worth it.
Oh my Lord, funny video toycat 'pls don't put me on a list' lmao keep making great videos thx 🙏
It would make more sense to make librarians more akin to toolsmiths etc: on lvl one he sells bookshelves and buys leather or st, lvl 2 he sells worse enchantments like efficiency II or protection I, and then only on the last trade you get stuff like fortune III and mending
That would make it hell to get good enchants
@@thelurker1330 but a better system
@@biel405 you put in more work for gradually better books, rather then lecturn resetting for 1 book
yes, but it would be cooler if the chances of those good enchants (like mending) appearing in the librarians trades would be higher.
@@chrimity in higher tier professions, yes entirely agree with that.
I would be annoyed of they changed the current method of mending. I like the building aspect of the game more than grafting continuously and searching. I also don't like playing in creative. Maybe they can just introduce an extra hard option in the game which makes it harder to get. That way leaves the experience the same for players like myself.
If mending was nerfed my intrest in playing would probably go down a bit.
Having to spend a bunch of time just to enchant a single tool every time my tool breaks isint very fun
0:39
that's pretty clever, personally i brought a cow with me on a boat, and milked it every time i got mining fatigue.
I thought the idea of a sandbox game was that the developers give you stuff, and you do what you want with that stuff. Sure, the devs can try to make things balanced. But the players will always find a way to exploit something or another. Check out what is happening/ happened to 7Days2Die. The devs for that game constantly are nerfing their sandbox game to force players to play differently. It would be a shame if that happened here
I disagree with a lot of this I really don't feel that any of these things need to be nerfed and I am really not sure why people think these are so bad.
I totally support buffing other option to make them more viable (mining over farms for example) and item duping is technically an exploit, but I'm with you otherwise. These additions made Minecraft better in my opinion, like how mending made it so I could use diamond tools without feeling like I had to conserve them.
All these features don't have to be used to find enjoyment (ie if you don't like totems don't use them) but if you take them away you leave those of us who like them in a position where we have to adapt to how they want to play.
they think there bad because they remove the point of different parts of the game, and are exploits
@@Sheepybearry I mean I know that much but respectfully I disagree
@@Sheepybearry Then don't remove anything, these other parts are still there, if you care so much about them, feel free to use them. Nobody is focring you to use anything shown in this video.
They agree because their favourite youtuber said so. The truth is, we are humans, we are impressionable. If someone we generally agree with says something and backs it up with logical points, we are likely to agree with them. Especially since (I'd assume) the majorit of people here (including me) are impressionable kids and yoing adults.
I know for a fact that if mojang actually came up tomorrow with a list of new features that adressed these issues and made the changes people are recommnding, the community would protest and many would stop playing.
totems should have a cooldown like chorus fruit but maybe around 10 seconds or more
it's already bad with one totem, and here you tell us to expect to use multiple?
More like 2 hours then
Iron farms are fine! If you are building them most likely you have big plans, definitely an endgame player. Don't forget some updates break them too, so if the creator doesn't make a follow up vid you're screwed or move on to another one. (Hits home, Gnembon's a developer now and idk how to fix his iron farm) Anyways iron farms allow survival players to be more creative cuz not only do you have iron blocks but also have access to more raw iron blocks and ores in their builds, instead of wasting time smelting. Same goes for copper and gold.
Yesssssssss, I agree so hard with not nerfing mending, but making other options more appealing instead
Totem of undying is literrally a get out of jail free card. Thats their gimmick. What you described is a regeneration potion. It shouldn't be nerfed because someone doesnt like it. It doesn't deserve that. It's like saying diamonds shouldnt be strong because they're too popular, make them as weak as gold or something crappy like that. Minecraft is a sandbox game, not a shitty mmorpg.
Iron golems, villagers, and mending are just fine already, don’t nerf it
Maybe an addition of Impossible mode? Where you'd have half the health and mobs with enchants similar to Dungeons spawn
Just make it so the level 5 trade of the librarian villager is guaranteed to be a treasure enchantment (frost walker 40%, or mending 40%, or curses 20%)
I personally feel like these overpowered features are perfectly fine the way they are. I feel like, even in normal survival or hardcore, Minecraft is a sandbox game. That's why I bought it, so these features just make the gameplay more fun for me. If I want a true survival game, I would just buy another game.
I don’t want survival to be just a more annoying creative mode. Even if it’s a sandbox game if you want survival elements in it at least make those elements good.
I don’t want survival to be just a more annoying creative mode. Even if it’s a sandbox game if you want survival elements in it at least make those elements good.
@@NoName-yd9fi create your own challenges and stop trying to ruin the game for the rest of us.
@@devil8975 Challenges require incentives. This is game design 101. Minecraft is supposed to have hard modes that cater to players who want an actual survival experience as opposed to "creative but more annoying". If you want that, play easy or peaceful. This game is supposed to have a place for everyone - and not be a compromise that is bad for everyone.
@@NoName-yd9fi If you want an actual survival experience, get an actual survival game. Even the Wikipedia page describes minecraft as a sandbox game, which it is. Why do you think almost all Minecraft survival youtubers have such insane worlds with so many crazy builds? Because it's fun. It's definitely not "creative but more annoying".
Hell no my guy.
They could add a little bit of of coding and make totem not accessible in hardcore
Minecraft is extremely time consuming. A nerf to strong items that one has to work for to acquire would just be a horrible idea. A buff to alternatives, as you suggest, is a better alternative. Some things could use a nerf, like totem farming should be reduced, but aside from that I think that mending is fine as is. We should just be able to have a set cost for repair on items. Like maybe a hard max of 10-15 levels to repair a netherite gear.
if you don't like a feature don't use it, don't ask for it to be ruined for the rest of us who enjoy the game as is
To be fair while these changes could be good I still think these don't really need nerfs just an opinion.
I don't think librarians need to be nerfed. When setting up the trading hall, I usually get frustrated after an hour or two of villager cycling and still not having mending. Then I'll just say to myself: alright, I've put in the effort, so I can reap the reward. And I'll put mending on my stuff with cheats.
I do think diamond and netherite gear should always be able to have mending, since it's not renewable. (OK, diamond gear is technically renewable through villager trading, but as you might have noticed I don't like villager trading).
As for iron farms, I never really use them, so I can't judge that. I don't do a lot of restone, don't need more than 10 hoppers on any world and don't make big minecart rollercoasters.
My guess to why none of this has happened yet, is because it would absolutely burn the players out. I would not play minecraft if i had to spend EVEN MORE hours trying to find the best enchantments for gear. Also there are things that I have built that i never would have done if i had to mine the iron manually, simply because it costs a toooonnn of iron and i would be spending more time mining than actually building.
I would argue that totems aren't always the best thing to have in your offhand now. Torches, blocks and shields are all options.
While I sort of like the idea of books being higher up in villager trade levels, I do feel like it would encourage the large scale murder of villagers that don't end up with useful ones, though I'm not sure how important that is considering what people do already with zombification.
1:23 that’s nice but you can get from doing a raid on hard difficulty. I had like a half a dozen after one raid. (It’s been awhile so that number might be wrong point is their not difficult to get if you just get gud and play hard)
P.S this was on bedrock
P.P.S 1:55 well nevermind you got me.
No one is forcing you to use Mending. If you think it’s so OP just don’t get a librarian with the trade. Play the game your way 😊
Bro, this isn't how we as humans work. Even if we don't like it, we will go to the easiest thing because it is accessible
@Biel Exactly, good god
Might as well remove the elytra as it's impossible to do so in the real world and remove the end and the nether to. The things you listed are like that for a reason and the thing is the person that is playing can choose the easy way or the hard way. It's a sandbox game for a reason. If they start nerfing to much it'll might as well be an rpg game
I disagree with a lot of stuff in your video. Many people, especially people who played since Alpha, never even really use things like an Iron Farm or even Totems. If people dont want this, they can make rules for it, especially on servers :)
I don’t agree with some of the takes in this video, but I definitely think the elytra and totems are super overpowered with no downside. Elytra is even worse, that item cuts off the various different modes of transportation Mojang could’ve potentially added .
What if your a peaceful player and it’s not as easy to gain resources
Instead of removing the Totem in HardCore, Make it so each time you die, you come back with one less heart.
I agree with some of your points but as for some one that doesn't have lots of time to play the game everyday (because of work and other responsibilities). I think everyone can play the game their way. You don't want totems from raids then you don't have to use them. You don't want villager trades they way they are then you don't have to play that way. Minecraft is a sandbox game you can play your way
*Thinking about continuing to read in my book*
Toycat: "you will never learn anything if you don't read books"
I: "yeah I think I am going to read now
False. I died in my hardcore mode last night. 69,000 points. God damn tragedy. I didn’t play it for a long time. Went back to it. Played but didn’t do a whole lot. Was fishing for treasure and lvling up at my mob farm. Mined a bit. Until I finally found a zombie villager. Got him into my house and caught him in a boat. Flew around the entire map looking for a brown mushroom. Found a couple more villages. Found one finally. Every other game they are all over the place. So I go back home and make a potion of weakness. Try to throw it at him and I hop in the boat with the zombie. I panic. Trying to jump out. And die. With a totem and die again instantly almost. Hahahahaha. I hadn’t played in MONTHS. I played a bit on the Nintendo. Turns out to get out of a boat on Java is LEFT f-ing SHIFT. Ahhh yes. Let me just crouch out of this boat real quick.
I was just thinking about this the other day when I died to the warden only because I forgot to put anther totem on, that they are ridiculously overpowered, and I wouldn't even consider putting something else in my off-hand.
See the issue with iron is mining is still boring in fact mining in general is boring even with a cave update the only solution is to add stuff like drills and machines honestly
“…asking if they have the McRib this time.”
Well, I mean, if you wait long enough…
What is this guy trying to be the minecraft marshal , the enchantment enforcer , the afk farm officer , the villager vigilante?
Novice librarians having *any* enchanted book available makes no sense. I would be OK with them making enchanted books stage 3+ and changing the final stage to 2 enchantments (3 total) instead of 1 + (whatever options are available now). I spend most of my time either landscaping or upgrading villages, and even I don't mess with villager-acquired enchantments because they just suck the fun out of the game. I want to actually *earn* my end-game gear, not have it handed to me from a simply game exploit.
Note: I do not use any type of mob farm, nor do I reset villager trades. If I want mob loot, I stay up at night and fight them. If I want a different villager trade, I expand the village and make a new occupation block. I am a weird one like that.
You forget that the time invested into gathering these things is why they're so useful and it's worth it
Mending II being a mutually exclusive enchantment would be an interesting idea, maybe it could slowly repair gear over time as a passive effect
my take on the whole mending thing is they should just buff anvils and make it so items don't get more and more expensive
real
No pls don't nerf them lmao
21:01 A missed opportunity to make a joke about streak being called cooked beef in Bedrock
Going through the villager tech tree for books sounds worse than it is. Had to do it with my masons for all the terracotta variants. Sure, hundreds of villagers lost their lives in the process. But they probably deserved it
I loved how hard minecraft was back then, having full diamond with the rarest enchantments was crazy today it’s easy done
Alternative Title: I Don't Like the Way Some People Play the Game, so These Things Should Be Nerfed.
I'm thinking from a design perspective, wouldn't you want sharpness to be nerfed if it gave you +100 damage, even though you could just not use it?
@@toycat That's a false equivalency. There are no swords that do +100 damage. Sure, you can farm totems and put mending on tools, but you can choose not to. If you do choose to farm them, you have to go through the time sink of building the farm and sitting on it to get the items you want. Some players enjoy automating everything in the game and it doesn't mean things should be nerfed just because you don't like to play that way.
I agree with the totem being usable in the main hand only as well as removing duplication. I think that getting good enchantments and prices take long enough as it is and villagers don’t need to be changed
There's also already a choice between mending and another enchantment. Infinity. Infinite arrows or infinite bows?
I think on Hardcore there should be a limit to how many totems you can use. Like you can use at the max two totems then they become entirely useless for the rest of the time in your hardcore world.
Maybe, idk, a difficulty scaled cooldown?
Peaceful - no cooldown
Easy - 5 minutes
Normal - 30 minutes
Hard(core) - 2 hours? Seems a little long but it’s not arbitrarily adding a cap to it, just a cooldown on how many you can use.
@@nathan_thorn6906 Adding a cooldown doesn’t really get rid of the problem. Most players don’t pop multiple totems in the span of two hours. Some times it happens but not usually.
I think, the librarians should be able to give you higher enchants, once there are a certain amount of villagers in the village to. Also think that villagers should not trust you until you save them from a raid, before this they wont let you choose jobs for them and golems will attack if you damage villager structures. Though zombie villagers will trust you for saving them and you can start your own village.
gonna have to disagree with the mending villagers rec, dude :/
.