It's so weird seeing JV comment "wtf" to this, because it feels like a solved puzzle. The mix is so flawless it feels like Bon Iver intentionally meant their discography to be transformed like this. Never felt that way about a mix before. The visuals are also so pretty though like wtf.
spot on mate, I hate to admit that I now prefer these mixes to the originals, everything I hear re: stacks or Calgary I find myself trying to add the other songs
It's hard to comprehend the time, energy and sheer love that has gone into the project. The skill involved in knowing the songs so intimately and understanding their musical structures in a way that enables such beautiful and innovative mixing of rhythms and textures is mind boggling. And that's without even factoring in the time mixing the music, and then the skill in sourcing and editing video too. Maaaaaan. This is staggering. Seriously well done, and thank you, Calb. I suspect this is going to skyrocket into the millions, and rightly so.
Three of my favourite artists united in a single comment thread!! This is incredible!! Jonathan, you are inspiring - I went to your concert in London in August and absolutely loved it!! I told that awful joke during a mic malfunction 🙈. At any rate, I agree with Calb - Twenty Four is one of my favourite albums of all time!
the comfort this brings from sounding like the past 10 years of my life is something that can’t be matched. its so brilliant to hear the nostalgia of the early stuff dissolving into the new and encompassing present emotions. so wonderful
Going back to this mix after 2-3 years without it. It’s like the snake innagadden of Eden baby! He’s whispering that there’s a ceiling (forbidden knowledge)
Today marks the 10th anniversary of one of the best albums of all time: Bon Iver, Bon Iver. No better way to celebrate it than listening to this right after finishing listening to that monumental record.
It’s so poetic that restacks is mashed with 8 circle. 22, a million felt like Justin Vernon wanted to move on while still keeping his core principles that made him so special. And using restacks to convey the change from then to now is beautiful. The line “And I carry his guitar” put into the context of this mashup just makes so much sense, even more than it did before.
been a die hard JV/bon iver since 2008. this was seriously such a beautiful take on his discography. thanks for putting in the time and effort to get this to the finish line and releasing it
@@ferndells no mate, he mixes blindsided with shdiah towards the end of deathbreast I think its the best part. Though Ive only made it to 18 mins so far. Haha
I do not listen to Bon Iver, so I can say for sure that this is objectively a fantastic mix. You've inspired me to go out and listen to Bon Iver's discography so that I can come back to this and appreciate it to its fullest extent. Excellent work, loved this and loved the Blonde x Currents mix. Can't wait to see what you create in the future.
I'm 13 mins in, and I realize there's no point wiping the tears off my face now. I'm not even halfway done yet. Might as well just wait till this is over.
Honestly, I've listened to this almost daily since it was uploaded and I still can't put into words how immense this is. This will get me through another winter. Fuck.
I’m absolutely freaking out and my bf is just chilling because he doesn’t listen to bon iver and can’t appreciate what an ABSOLUTE fucking masterpiece this is. I’m gob smacked. Blown away. I can’t explain how this makes me feel. I’m hella hyped to see them in April
I can’t believe I’ve only just found this! Incredible work mate! It’s mad, I spent my younger years listening to the first Bon Iver album in a Ford KA…now I find myself driving a Ford KA again but this time I’m blasting your remixes. Thanks man❤
9 months after discovering this, I am at least 2,000 of these views. my favorite artist of all time. thank you for taking the time to make this piece of art
I've been listening to Bon Iver for over a decade and it's like hearing this music for the first time. Each time a new track started i was more and more blown away
Every time I listen to this, there's a moment when I'm like "wait, is this the right video? I don't remember this part" So I go and check and yeah, it's the right video. I mean, there are sooo many layers to it, it's so complex and beautiful and sad and there's always something new to aprehend.. A true true masterpiece. Thank you for sharing that with us. May all of this beauty finds its way back to you! ✨🙌🏻💜
ive been coming back to this video for years, these songs for each of these remixes are so perfectly chosen that whenever im listening to the originals i find myself singing the lines from the other Bon Iver songs they were mixed with. nothing musically will compare to the first time i listened to this video
As I sit here, Calb, experiencing this for the very first time, I must express my sheer astonishment. I find myself utterly captivated, both metaphorically and quite literally. Throughout the years, I've immersed myself in countless renditions of Justin's take on "I Can't Make You Love Me / Just in the Nick of Time." It had become an anthem that resonated with me on profound levels. This song embodied my love, my heartbreak, and the myriad of emotions I struggled to articulate. In recent times, the tears I once shed while listening to this melody had dried up, leaving a void I hadn't realized I missed. Yet, your rendition, "Faith Can't Make You Love Me," has rekindled those long-lost emotions within me. Listening to your composition felt like returning to a place of security and solace, akin to coming home after a long journey. For that, my dear friend, I am eternally grateful. Thank you from the depths of my heart.
I’m only a few minutes and I’m feeling so emotional. This is the music that raised me, formed me, comforted me during the dark times and warmed me during the beautiful ones. To experience these songs wrapped up in each other like this is incredible.
Oh my God, the Faith one is phenomenal. Not only is Justin's version of I Can't Make You Love Me one of my favorite tracks of all time, but Faith is also my favorite off of i,i. Chills throughout this whole video. Now if you give me a mashup using For Emma, I can die peacefully lol
Listening to this mix inspired me to write this message to my cousin.... "going to put on the bon iver mix you sent me while i attempt to journal. Im a few minutes in and its so beautiful. Thank you for the kind words about me today cuz. You mean so much to me. Brings me to tears thinking about it. I feel like ive always had such a hard hard time feeling understood by anyone. Its happened here and there but ive always had such a hard time making intimate friends. This is something i can except but it seems i missed the opportunity to turn inward to family for many years. Glad thats here now. Love you!!" Think this message is fitting to the emotions the music pulls out of you...
dude, what the FUCK.
do you know our music better than us???????? this is insane. I dont know what to say.
im beyond touched, man. wtf.
Much love JV.
Can't wait to get these cassettes made, gents!
Amazing mix from amazing music
now this is podracing
👏
Like discovering Bon Iver for the first time
it really is
Just want to say a big yes
that's the feeling, absolutely
yesss
totally!
are you okay
Not now
It's so weird seeing JV comment "wtf" to this, because it feels like a solved puzzle. The mix is so flawless it feels like Bon Iver intentionally meant their discography to be transformed like this. Never felt that way about a mix before. The visuals are also so pretty though like wtf.
They meant that in a good way
spot on mate, I hate to admit that I now prefer these mixes to the originals, everything I hear re: stacks or Calgary I find myself trying to add the other songs
you know you did the best job when the creator of all this music comments
That's awesome -- I am curious to know where JV has commented.
@@kristenjackson713 here www.reddit.com/r/boniver/comments/l1z0dz/ceiling_in_our_garden_the_full_bi_mix_is_out_now/gk7irl0/
@@papermaniacs, thanks!
It's hard to comprehend the time, energy and sheer love that has gone into the project. The skill involved in knowing the songs so intimately and understanding their musical structures in a way that enables such beautiful and innovative mixing of rhythms and textures is mind boggling. And that's without even factoring in the time mixing the music, and then the skill in sourcing and editing video too. Maaaaaan. This is staggering. Seriously well done, and thank you, Calb. I suspect this is going to skyrocket into the millions, and rightly so.
This is giving me the same feeling as Live at Pioneer works
That is the highest compliment I know how to give
I nominate this mix to be the soundtrack of Life™
This shows such an appreciation for the whole discography. Beautiful!!
Fun fact: I own your Twenty Four CD and t-shirt, it was one of my favorite albums of 2020. Thank you for your music. I'm glad you liked the mix!
🔥🔥🔥
Three of my favourite artists united in a single comment thread!! This is incredible!! Jonathan, you are inspiring - I went to your concert in London in August and absolutely loved it!! I told that awful joke during a mic malfunction 🙈. At any rate, I agree with Calb - Twenty Four is one of my favourite albums of all time!
bloody hell i'm in bits. great work, friend - seriously x
oi oi , fancy seeing you here ! ;)
good to see you here :)
@@kitholdridge Actual non-surprised, surprised chuckle at seeing this little comment thread.
Just as impressed with the spot on visuals that maintain the same design language bon iver uses
the comfort this brings from sounding like the past 10 years of my life is something that can’t be matched. its so brilliant to hear the nostalgia of the early stuff dissolving into the new and encompassing present emotions. so wonderful
Bro I've got to go to work and people are going to think I've been smoking weed
This is an overload of all the feelings I've had in the last decade
22 (Holocene) knocked me in my feels...... oh wow
I come back here every month or so.
3 years and couting!
Going back to this mix after 2-3 years without it. It’s like the snake innagadden of Eden baby! He’s whispering that there’s a ceiling (forbidden knowledge)
Bon Iver has meant so much to me for so long that I almost forgot what it was like to hear it for the first time... until I heard this. Masterpiece
Today marks the 10th anniversary of one of the best albums of all time: Bon Iver, Bon Iver. No better way to celebrate it than listening to this right after finishing listening to that monumental record.
Life changing record!
In the voice of Hagrid: “you’re a wizard Calb”
This will go down in history
It’s so poetic that restacks is mashed with 8 circle. 22, a million felt like Justin Vernon wanted to move on while still keeping his core principles that made him so special. And using restacks to convey the change from then to now is beautiful. The line “And I carry his guitar” put into the context of this mashup just makes so much sense, even more than it did before.
Re: stacks, 8 circle and Perth you legit took my favourite song out of each album to make one of the best pieces of music to ever exist
crying at this
You should put this on spotify as a podcast. Please and Thank you.
been a die hard JV/bon iver since 2008. this was seriously such a beautiful take on his discography. thanks for putting in the time and effort to get this to the finish line and releasing it
I never expect much out of mixes like this but this is a work of art in its own right. Did not stop smiling the entire time. Incredible work.
every single person who loves bon iver NEEDS to hear this😭ALGORITHM DO YOUR THING PLSS
Blindsided and RABi together sound absolutely breathtaking.
do you mean death breast?
@@ferndells no mate, he mixes blindsided with shdiah towards the end of deathbreast I think its the best part. Though Ive only made it to 18 mins so far. Haha
Omg what a ride
@@saugatrj I think he got it wrong in the description tho, isn't that RABi?
Hey, he fixed it!
I still listen to this like once a week
Don't forget to listen to the real albums too
@@Calbmusic always!
You know you did something very right when Justin himself is fawning over your work! Kudos my friend, you sure deserve it.
This project is the highest compliment I've ever seen from one artist to another. This is beyond beautiful. Thank you Calb and thank you Bon Iver.
*Words cannot express how articulate I feel*
I do not listen to Bon Iver, so I can say for sure that this is objectively a fantastic mix. You've inspired me to go out and listen to Bon Iver's discography so that I can come back to this and appreciate it to its fullest extent. Excellent work, loved this and loved the Blonde x Currents mix. Can't wait to see what you create in the future.
That is the absolute best thing this mix could accomplish. Thank you! More stuff coming soon.
How'd you go Sam? Did you listen to the discog and come back to appreciate the sublime nature of Calb's mix? :O
HoLEY shit. I'm thrilled to be alive at the same time something like this is created.
the transition from faith to blindsided was unreal 😭
i’ve never commented on a youtube video but this is genuinely, without fail the best video i’ve ever seen on the internet
I want to like this but it’s at 111 😂
OMG WHAT IS THIS!? HEAVEN?
I'm 13 mins in, and I realize there's no point wiping the tears off my face now. I'm not even halfway done yet. Might as well just wait till this is over.
🥲
The combination of stacks and circle haunts me, it’s so ethereal. You made something truly beautiful here
fire! 8 stacks perth was so dope
'I was here since the Bon Iver Mix' is gonna be a thing
The fact that the VERN responded to this. A1 man A1
The sheer talent and attention to detail this took. Simply amazing.
Crying in the club 😭👌🏻🤟🏻
Honestly, I've listened to this almost daily since it was uploaded and I still can't put into words how immense this is.
This will get me through another winter. Fuck.
Only a person so tasteful as to mix Frank Ocean and Tame Impala would be able to create this. Well done.
Flaeem wow
Yesss
I am very grateful that you exist and I exist and we all exist together feeling these beautiful sounds
22 and Holocene work together so well it's unreal. Ugh I'm not equipped to handle this right now
Right now I can feel the universe
The smile on my face right now. Crazy how music can elicit such a thing
Ooohh Minnesota, WI, We, 666 ʇ back to back?? This is making my day!
That might be my favorite part!
Just stumbled upon this, unbelievable. Gave me chills over and over
I didn't know I needed this until I needed it. Familiar but new, this soothes the soul when very little in the world does that right now. Thanks.
I’m absolutely freaking out and my bf is just chilling because he doesn’t listen to bon iver and can’t appreciate what an ABSOLUTE fucking masterpiece this is. I’m gob smacked. Blown away. I can’t explain how this makes me feel. I’m hella hyped to see them in April
The goosebumps this gave me. Wow
MASTERPIECE
Welp, might as well wish the next few days a goodbye gonna be listening to this all day
Yesss ! I’ll never be the same
Stunningly euphoric and refreshing !!!!!
So very well put!
i- ...... speechless. had to come here to say THANK YOU
here I am. blown away. blown all the way away.
GOAT work
This mixtape is perfect for my life current state.
Now this... THIS is the mixtape we've been wanting.
I can’t believe I’ve only just found this! Incredible work mate!
It’s mad, I spent my younger years listening to the first Bon Iver album in a Ford KA…now I find myself driving a Ford KA again but this time I’m blasting your remixes. Thanks man❤
9 months after discovering this, I am at least 2,000 of these views. my favorite artist of all time. thank you for taking the time to make this piece of art
this is a religion to me
I’m so happy I listened to this with my AirPod pros. Holy mother of Bon this is glorious
Mother of Bon 🤣
everybody is talking about blonded currents, but this is fucking precious man, i love it so much
This is like our community's Kanye West - 2049. This is really creative work.
man, I’ve been listening to this for the past 2 weeks and it’s been a seriously contemplative experience - i think you changed my life with this dude
everything's so smooth, basically kept it on repeat for an hour or 2
I'm gonna be honest, I haven't dove into Bon Iver's whole discography yet. This is making me do it, so great job. Excellent mix.
This is the best possible thing that this mix could achieve 👍
Was thinking the exact same!
Oh my god!
I've been listening to Bon Iver for over a decade and it's like hearing this music for the first time. Each time a new track started i was more and more blown away
This guy can MIX ! I'm very thankfull for this!
Matilda profile picture?
@@stanmorris5108 Fitzpleasure :)
@@VoOrT3xX bon Iver and alt J. You have good taste
Every time I listen to this, there's a moment when I'm like "wait, is this the right video? I don't remember this part" So I go and check and yeah, it's the right video.
I mean, there are sooo many layers to it, it's so complex and beautiful and sad and there's always something new to aprehend..
A true true masterpiece.
Thank you for sharing that with us.
May all of this beauty finds its way back to you!
✨🙌🏻💜
This is still my favorite of anything on all of the utubes.
dude this is seriously starting 2021 off SO GOOD.
this is an incredibly artistic interpretation of an incredible artist and the result is something else entirely and its extraordinary
This should be officially released through the Chigliak records or seomthing like that. You did so so good man. Deathsided is sick!
this shattered me. i am so thankful . hearing “it might be over soon” in the beginning literally just. oh my god
Man you are a 10 thousand years ahead of our time
ive been coming back to this video for years, these songs for each of these remixes are so perfectly chosen that whenever im listening to the originals i find myself singing the lines from the other Bon Iver songs they were mixed with.
nothing musically will compare to the first time i listened to this video
need this on spotify in my heart in my soul
SOOOOOO DAMN GOOD!!! Thank you for sharing your labor of love with us all!
Deathsided is a song I didn't know I needed until now
What a celebration of incredible music. This has to be the best highlight of how incredible Justin and co. are.
As I sit here, Calb, experiencing this for the very first time, I must express my sheer astonishment. I find myself utterly captivated, both metaphorically and quite literally.
Throughout the years, I've immersed myself in countless renditions of Justin's take on "I Can't Make You Love Me / Just in the Nick of Time." It had become an anthem that resonated with me on profound levels. This song embodied my love, my heartbreak, and the myriad of emotions I struggled to articulate.
In recent times, the tears I once shed while listening to this melody had dried up, leaving a void I hadn't realized I missed. Yet, your rendition, "Faith Can't Make You Love Me," has rekindled those long-lost emotions within me.
Listening to your composition felt like returning to a place of security and solace, akin to coming home after a long journey. For that, my dear friend, I am eternally grateful. Thank you from the depths of my heart.
I can’t even believe how fucking bonkers this mix was. Outstanding job.
This creates world peace. I'm crying.
This immediately brought tears to my eyes...wth
Thank you for spending the time to give this to the world. This is awesome and I will be coming back for it often.
as like an all time die hard bon iver fan, youve literally blown my fucking mind. this feels like i’m hearing an entirely new discography
I’m only a few minutes and I’m feeling so emotional. This is the music that raised me, formed me, comforted me during the dark times and warmed me during the beautiful ones. To experience these songs wrapped up in each other like this is incredible.
THE MOST BEAUTIFUL THING IVE EVER HEARD
Oh my God, the Faith one is phenomenal. Not only is Justin's version of I Can't Make You Love Me one of my favorite tracks of all time, but Faith is also my favorite off of i,i. Chills throughout this whole video. Now if you give me a mashup using For Emma, I can die peacefully lol
Also, this just shows the RANGE that man has, wow
Listening to this mix inspired me to write this message to my cousin....
"going to put on the bon iver mix you sent me while i attempt to journal. Im a few minutes in and its so beautiful. Thank you for the kind words about me today cuz. You mean so much to me. Brings me to tears thinking about it. I feel like ive always had such a hard hard time feeling understood by anyone. Its happened here and there but ive always had such a hard time making intimate friends. This is something i can except but it seems i missed the opportunity to turn inward to family for many years. Glad thats here now. Love you!!"
Think this message is fitting to the emotions the music pulls out of you...
This is a very perfect thing you did
10/10. Absolutely breathtaking. Seamless.