The comment on the production of spectacle was fascinating. Now the moment you hear spectacle you think debord and ofc this part of the literature is extremely difficult to wrap your mind around theoretically. As important as it is id love to hear what these changes in consumerism and turnover rate mean with respect to marxist economy, valorization, rate of profit, that sort of thing. This is my favorite podcast atm pls keep up the good work
@@clarestucki5151 , what do you mean no one ever has? It's not difficult to have a viable economic system. The problem is putting it in place. We've known for a very long time what works and what doesn't work. You don't need capitalism in order to have a business, to have a market, to have people producing things, selling in trading with one another, Etc. Capitalism is the economic system of parasites. You can't have an economic system where most of the wealth ends up going to the non producer.
@@michaelmappin1830 and religion is untaxed even though it brings in billions of dollars every year so what's your point? The problem is you ppl are being sold a steaming pile of grade A horse shit by thinking that an economy that requires capital (finance) can thrive on merely nothing but feelings. The truth is capitalism will be apart of every economic system because ppl want to be paid for their products and services otherwise it'll be literally slavery.
43 degrees celcius and overcast, the sun isnt even out its like waliking into an oven when you go outside....today in melbourne....the environment has been very evident this summer
It's true that all those parts of the totality are equally important, but they all point to a single social cause, which is the property rights uniquely associated with capital. Culture, technology, social relations etc are reproduced whenever these property rights are successfully enforced in the interest of capital against the rest of society. Whenever the pushback is beaten down and opposition quiets down, capitalist power is (re)established and life (or what's left of it) reorganizes itself around the new state of affairs, technology is nudged in a specific direction instead of another, and culture is put to work to make things acceptable or even desirable again for the conquered.
Great podcast. I am very grateful for such lectures. Many thanks to DaW and to David Harvey. And, actually, I have a question: can you please answer which tome and pages of Capital exactly are mentioned in podcast? Can't find this part in the book myself, and, right now, asking you, great people, for help.
@@antediluvianatheist5262 Cheap plentiful and doesn't require solar panels. On the other hand, if you could power your car with a $400 solar panel I'm all for it.
I've examined the realities you've mentioned in regards to technology and the products of such investments and creations are a look into the degradation of culture & economy.
I agree that all those aspects of society (education conception of nature, technology even religions ) are connected and evolve let's say in a tandem, sort of synchronizing way.. however, I am still prefer the Marx distinction between Economic Structure, let's say de basements, and Social/political/Tech/Science/Religion/Nature conceptions as the Superstructure.. both form the Society and feedback between them but in a different way...And grouping them is this way helps how we can transform one thing AND the relation with the others...
The problem with unfettered capitalism - an abstract entity - is that, at its root, the value structure inherent to the price formation of commodities that monetize social relations elevates the priority of property over people. The concept of property ownership supersedes human interest.
I hate it when people unpack bullshit, and think outside the box, you know, these university phrases that they try to spread like a virus? I realize that it's a reverse psychological trick that calls the listener an idiot by stealth.
Kapitalisme murni yang tanpa pengaman keadilan hanya lahirkan kesenjangan global, anti kemanusia dan hak dasar, penguasaan aset ekonomi global oleh segelintir orang, PDB yang tidak merata, krisis, penyakit dan perang yang ngak jelas.
This speaker never introduces the listener to the concept of CURRENCY. I find that amazing considering his sensitivity to the creativity and productivity of human beings and their relationship with Nature. The first step to organizing the creativity and productivity of the human race starts with the GOVT of any society. Govt is the ONLY source of sociey's currency - anyone else who creates it is a counterfeiter. Think about that. Govt is the ONLY naturally lawful source of national currency. If the govt doesn't create it, you've got NO currency in your hands. The problem with how the world is currently designed and why the world is confused, suffering deprivation, and remains in ignorance is that govt handed it's currency creation duty and responsibility over to a private banking cartel who decides who, what and when will receive currency. Instead of the govt of people deciding how to distribute currency, govt permits the private banking cartel to control and direct the world. I guarantee you that NO society will EVER enjoy peace, prosperity, full expression of personal and social creativity and productivity until the private banking cartel is DESTROYED and BANNED forever.
before I tackle this thorny problem seemingly unsolvable by most people, Marx included, I want to say that it is not out of arrogance or reckless disregard for any of the so called economist who tried their hand at undoing this Gordian knot, but a keen sense of ~wanting to know~ what a proper humane system looks like and how exactly it'll function. This attitude rests on the Socratean idea that I don't know anything, only that I'm an ignorant fool. This is a very advantages start because it keeps dogmas & ideologies at bay. From this simplistic take on how to solve ANY problem we arrive at the conviction that there HAS to be an answer that's universally acceptable to all people because we are all the same in our human ignorance/needs etc ; we do not understand the complexity of what faces us. But here, we need some help. From who ? Well people choose to follow other people who seem to know the answer, and many halve baked solutions have only added to the general chaos dished up by 'experts' leaving us in a steadily worsening anti social quagmire. Now the Person to turn to for answers is no less than God Himself, but more specific the Bible, preferably the oldest translation you can get. Now immediately I have to point out that I'm NOT a religious pundit, stay away from church ! But please read this Book if you seek wisdom to understand HOW to deal with these convoluted matters. Someone who DID this in a way far above contemporary intellectual levels, was a man called Rudolf Steiner, who incidentally was murder for exactly this reason ; he proposed a REAL alternative and the Nazis took him out for that...... why kill a fool with another thumbsuck solution unless it threatens the PTB ? Hopefully this essay will show why. Suppose the system is a table on which we are preparing a meal for everyone.... now because the floor on which the table stands is very uneven, we found that a three legged table is perfectly stable on such a floor, provided the three legs are separate and equally spaced. These three legs are Liberty, Equality and Fraternity. But WHAT does that mean in terms of culture, law & economy ? Simply this : In our respective cultures we are free/liberty. Before the law we are equal, and in economy we are brothers & sisters. But note, that if you move the table's legs so that govt and economy become one, the table falls over and there goes our meal, or when you coincide law & culture the same thing happens.... These three legs MUST be apart and sovereign to keep the table steady... Today our table has ONE leg no wonder only chaos comes out of our so-called educated erudite opinions of fools posing as leaders. They know fokall to put it mildly, but those that do, get nailed to trees by the jews/the raw capitalists/banksters who has no grain of humanity to spare. Now I don't want to bore you any further but thanks for reading this and if you have questions, let's get into it.
What you just described is the settled-upon scientific consensus about how the planet's climate works. The science of humanity's effect on the planet's climate is also settled.
The science of your IQ is settled though. We have determined it's below zero. You're like a black hole for intelligence, everyone that's exposed to you gets dumber.
@@antediluvianatheist5262 yes I understand. You want to deliver the message not click away from it. I'm sure he very educated what he has to say. But again you want to draw it more viewers. I wish he did a podcast of his own. Have 1hr or so. I learn a lot from Richard Wolff.
The comment on the production of spectacle was fascinating. Now the moment you hear spectacle you think debord and ofc this part of the literature is extremely difficult to wrap your mind around theoretically. As important as it is id love to hear what these changes in consumerism and turnover rate mean with respect to marxist economy, valorization, rate of profit, that sort of thing.
This is my favorite podcast atm pls keep up the good work
*We can do better than capitalism.*
One might think so, but so far no one ever has.
No you can't it's economically impossible.
@@ECisvotersuppression , what do you mean it's impossible? Capitalism is religion. Technically it's an anti economic system.
@@clarestucki5151 , what do you mean no one ever has? It's not difficult to have a viable economic system. The problem is putting it in place. We've known for a very long time what works and what doesn't work. You don't need capitalism in order to have a business, to have a market, to have people producing things, selling in trading with one another, Etc. Capitalism is the economic system of parasites. You can't have an economic system where most of the wealth ends up going to the non producer.
@@michaelmappin1830 and religion is untaxed even though it brings in billions of dollars every year so what's your point? The problem is you ppl are being sold a steaming pile of grade A horse shit by thinking that an economy that requires capital (finance) can thrive on merely nothing but feelings. The truth is capitalism will be apart of every economic system because ppl want to be paid for their products and services otherwise it'll be literally slavery.
Marvelous..... a Nobel prize would not be nearly good enough for his contribution to clear thinking. Thank you sir.
I think Heidegger does this too using the term enframing to describe the reveal that technology has on our relationship to nature.
Mr Harvey you are a gift to this world. Thank you for influencing my mental conceptions. I carry these lessons with me in daily life.
43 degrees celcius and overcast, the sun isnt even out its like waliking into an oven when you go outside....today in melbourne....the environment has been very evident this summer
I love you Dr. Haaaavy. Thank you.
Thank you my Elder Marxian hero! ❤️
Great commentary. I've experienced this life.
I'm liking the colour coordination David.
I think what he's trying to say is "The further we fall into the digital, the faster the natural disappears."
Strong parallels here with Cockshott's new book, "How the World Works."
well said Dave!
Capitalism
I work for a dime, my boss makes a dollar or 5.
It's true that all those parts of the totality are equally important, but they all point to a single social cause, which is the property rights uniquely associated with capital. Culture, technology, social relations etc are reproduced whenever these property rights are successfully enforced in the interest of capital against the rest of society. Whenever the pushback is beaten down and opposition quiets down, capitalist power is (re)established and life (or what's left of it) reorganizes itself around the new state of affairs, technology is nudged in a specific direction instead of another, and culture is put to work to make things acceptable or even desirable again for the conquered.
I am a penny pincher and a minimalist lol. I believe in fixing my own stuff as well. And i like primative survival. And i much rather work in a union.
Thanks great listen
Really informative. Thank you professor!
Excellent
Great podcast. I am very grateful for such lectures. Many thanks to DaW and to David Harvey.
And, actually, I have a question:
can you please answer which tome and pages of Capital exactly are mentioned in podcast?
Can't find this part in the book myself, and, right now, asking you, great people, for help.
Thank you Marxist grandpa
Michael Brooks talked about Integral Theory in a recent video. It's a similar idea as these interrelated co-important parts of our worlds.
We need to discover a new energy source that is cheap and plentiful.
It's called 'The Sun.'
@@antediluvianatheist5262 Cheap plentiful and doesn't require solar panels. On the other hand, if you could power your car with a $400 solar panel I'm all for it.
@@tgifford4 only problem is your car won't move if the sun isn't shining😆😆😆😆
@Daniel Paul and how is that battery made and what's the process? I'll wait😁
@Daniel Paul this video doesn't answer my question and that is what's the process of MAKING the solar panels, wind turbines, and batteries?
I've examined the realities you've mentioned in regards to technology and the products of such investments and creations are a look into the degradation of culture & economy.
Good stuff!
If you're on a train, you're probably sleeping ... not looking out the window
I agree that all those aspects of society (education conception of nature, technology even religions ) are connected and evolve let's say in a tandem, sort of synchronizing way.. however, I am still prefer the Marx distinction between Economic Structure, let's say de basements, and Social/political/Tech/Science/Religion/Nature conceptions as the Superstructure.. both form the Society and feedback between them but in a different way...And grouping them is this way helps how we can transform one thing AND the relation with the others...
The problem with unfettered capitalism - an abstract entity - is that, at its root, the value structure inherent to the price formation of commodities that monetize social relations elevates the priority of property over people. The concept of property ownership supersedes human interest.
david harvey accidentally reveals he doesnt know how netflix works
How about we work on not trashing the planet? Or maybe we should trash it. That would certainly spark transformational change.
Subtitulen esto por favor
I hate it when people unpack bullshit, and think outside the box, you know, these university phrases that they try to spread like a virus? I realize that it's a reverse psychological trick that calls the listener an idiot by stealth.
capitalism will pass
We will pass with it
Kapitalisme murni yang tanpa pengaman keadilan hanya lahirkan kesenjangan global, anti kemanusia dan hak dasar, penguasaan aset ekonomi global oleh segelintir orang, PDB yang tidak merata, krisis, penyakit dan perang yang ngak jelas.
This speaker never introduces the listener to the concept of CURRENCY. I find that amazing considering his sensitivity to the creativity and productivity of human beings and their relationship with Nature. The first step to organizing the creativity and productivity of the human race starts with the GOVT of any society. Govt is the ONLY source of sociey's currency - anyone else who creates it is a counterfeiter. Think about that. Govt is the ONLY naturally lawful source of national currency. If the govt doesn't create it, you've got NO currency in your hands. The problem with how the world is currently designed and why the world is confused, suffering deprivation, and remains in ignorance is that govt handed it's currency creation duty and responsibility over to a private banking cartel who decides who, what and when will receive currency. Instead of the govt of people deciding how to distribute currency, govt permits the private banking cartel to control and direct the world. I guarantee you that NO society will EVER enjoy peace, prosperity, full expression of personal and social creativity and productivity until the private banking cartel is DESTROYED and BANNED forever.
before I tackle this thorny problem seemingly unsolvable by most people, Marx included, I want to say that it is not out of arrogance or reckless disregard for any of the so called economist who tried their hand at undoing this Gordian knot, but a keen sense of ~wanting to know~ what a proper humane system looks like and how exactly it'll function. This attitude rests on the Socratean idea that I don't know anything, only that I'm an ignorant fool. This is a very advantages start because it keeps dogmas & ideologies at bay.
From this simplistic take on how to solve ANY problem we arrive at the conviction that there HAS to be an answer that's universally acceptable to all people because we are all the same in our human ignorance/needs etc ; we do not understand the complexity of what faces us. But here, we need some help. From who ? Well people choose to follow other people who seem to know the answer, and many halve baked solutions have only added to the general chaos dished up by 'experts' leaving us in a steadily worsening anti social quagmire.
Now the Person to turn to for answers is no less than God Himself, but more specific the Bible, preferably the oldest translation you can get. Now immediately I have to point out that I'm NOT a religious pundit, stay away from church ! But please read this Book if you seek wisdom to understand HOW to deal with these convoluted matters.
Someone who DID this in a way far above contemporary intellectual levels, was a man called Rudolf Steiner, who incidentally was murder for exactly this reason ; he proposed a REAL alternative and the Nazis took him out for that...... why kill a fool with another thumbsuck solution unless it threatens the PTB ? Hopefully this essay will show why.
Suppose the system is a table on which we are preparing a meal for everyone.... now because the floor on which the table stands is very uneven, we found that a three legged table is perfectly stable on such a floor, provided the three legs are separate and equally spaced. These three legs are Liberty, Equality and Fraternity. But WHAT does that mean in terms of culture, law & economy ? Simply this : In our respective cultures we are free/liberty. Before the law we are equal, and in economy we are brothers & sisters.
But note, that if you move the table's legs so that govt and economy become one, the table falls over and there goes our meal, or when you coincide law & culture the same thing happens.... These three legs MUST be apart and sovereign to keep the table steady... Today our table has ONE leg no wonder only chaos comes out of our so-called educated erudite opinions of fools posing as leaders. They know fokall to put it mildly, but those that do, get nailed to trees by the jews/the raw capitalists/banksters who has no grain of humanity to spare.
Now I don't want to bore you any further but thanks for reading this and if you have questions, let's get into it.
Rudolf Steiner wasn't murdered.
@@AlexDeLarge1 expand if you please will.
N.E. Campmore
He died of an illness at 64. He wasn’t murdered.
@@AlexDeLarge1 Not officially, but in reality he was. There were several attempts on his life but he died after they poisoned him.
@@johannesbekker1970
No evidence for this.
Kinda nebulous and esoteric.
Climate is changing but it’s always been in flux. The models are complex & incomplete. The science is definitely not “settled.”
What you just described is the settled-upon scientific consensus about how the planet's climate works. The science of humanity's effect on the planet's climate is also settled.
The science of your IQ is settled though. We have determined it's below zero. You're like a black hole for intelligence, everyone that's exposed to you gets dumber.
@@krs-two4329 sorry, I really didn't intent to be ableist or intrude on his safe space.
@@krs-two4329 then why do so many ppl still live in Africa, india, and the middle east?
@@Apodeipnon get a clue moron if the msm is talking about climate change that means there's profit involved.
Jesus making me fall asleep. Get someone with a passion while trying to talk about anti capitalism
He has passion.
He just has a dry delivery.
Next time he will get someone with interest while trying to listen about anti capitalism.
@@antediluvianatheist5262 yes I understand. You want to deliver the message not click away from it. I'm sure he very educated what he has to say. But again you want to draw it more viewers. I wish he did a podcast of his own. Have 1hr or so. I learn a lot from Richard Wolff.
Sad and pathetic that you a grown adult is more interested in the theatrics than the actual message. Lol typical brain dead zombie.😆