ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.พ. 2024
- The US, UK and EU have announced new sanctions on Russia, two years after its invasion of Ukraine.
The measures also marked a week since the death in custody of opposition leader Alexei Navalny.
President Vladimir Putin has claimed European sanctions have done Russia no harm, saying: "We have growth, and they have decline."
The International Energy Agency says Russia is still exporting 8.3 million barrels of oil a day - having increased supplies to India and China.
Subscribe here: bit.ly/1rbfUog
For more news, analysis and features visit: www.bbc.com/news
#Russia #Ukraine #BBCNews
![[FULL EP.14] เซียนหรั่ง สอน มาร์ชจุ จับปูนา ฮากระจาย | เฮ็ดอย่างเซียนหรั่ง | One Playground](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M8mPjd_T2lo/mqdefault.jpg)
but according to the Western media, Russia is running out of ammo and only fighting with dull shovels
Yes and this since 1,5 years 😂
😂
India is re exporting Russia oil. Oil is refined in I Dua and reshipped to UK, EU etc..
Kkkkkkkkkkkkkk... fuck filers propaganda
We still import Russian oil even if it is refined in a 3rd country like India. We break our own sanctions. Ridiculous.
If you don't import then you will be doomed.
USA will sell you same oil at 3 times more price.
Because there's no way around it. It's just giving oil companies like BP and Shell an excuse to hike up prices. The margin they put on per litre is practically double of what they put on prior to the war, that's why they're making record profits. But our government are the Tories, they'd rather give the rich an excuse to make more money than just go "fuck it, we can't do anything, so let's help our people" and just resume purchasing oil from Russia directly so that regular people can at least not suffer from oil companies' ridiculous margins.
That’s exactly how British & American mindset works
Because there's no way around it. It's just giving oil companies like BP and Shell an excuse to hike up prices. The margin they put on per litre is practically double of what they put on prior to the war, that's why they're making record profits. But our government are the Tories, they'd rather give the rich an excuse to make more money than just go "screw it, we can't do anything, so let's help our people" and just resume purchasing oil from Russia directly so that regular people can at least not suffer from oil companies' ridiculous margins.
@@Agmhd Oh right, thanks for letting us know. 🙄
Europe is not the world
Ounsubscribe
In this wast world you ( Russian) having a few friends whom are supporting you.pity wake up from dream world
Good point.
Tells you about the Western mindset, and why we are the enemies to the majority of the world
Who said Europe was the entire world? lol At least it ain't a s-hole that Russia, North Korea, Iran and China is..I know where I will stay living..
The way propaganda spinned will make us laugh 😅
Russia must stop the war.
It's comical.
Having thoroughly studied Russia's Central Banks releases the following is clear.
in 2023 and to date in 2024 Russia achieved 14 months of multi billion dollar deficits, following a multi billion dollar deficit in December 2022 (Source : Russia Central Bank data) leading to a 156 billion dollar reduction in revenue.
The deficits are a continual worsening trend caused by western sanctions decreasing Russia's revenues by 62% from oil and gas, which according to Russia Bank's data is over 156 billion dollars down on the same period in 2021/ 2022.
On top of this Russia's currency, the Ruble, has decreased in value by 52%, making it one of the 3 worst performing currencies in 2023, even after Russia's Bank doubled interest rate from 7.5% to 15% in 5 months at the end of 2023, in an attempt to stop it declining in value even further.
Russia has stopped fuel exports to prevent shortages, has food queues for the first time since Soviet times and spare parts availability for cars, planes, agricultural machinery, industry, etc has gone from 2 days to 18 months, if available at all.
Russia has been robbing its 'reserve funds' to pay for the economy, which means the growth may look good, but it's not from new revenues! You understand that differention, yes?
Lastly, Russians are freezing all across Russia due to heating and electrical power infrastructure failures due to poor maintenance.
These are easily researched facts and yet you will hear every day that Russia is doing well! why? because people believe Russian propaganda and don't understand statistics!
Let me give you an example.
Let's say Russia earned $100 and due to sanctions lost half (50%), the level of Russia's value at the start of the next year is now $50. in the next 12 months Russia achieves a growth of $10 giving them a total of $60.(which, if taken from the lower $50 starting point calculates as 20% growth). That for some and in particular the IMF forcasters, indicates a growth of 20%, rather than a deficit of 40% from the Original $100 starting point the previous year.
The bigger picture (wider the historical data spread) gives you the real picture, and not the snap shot taken that included the lower figures to support the narrative that Russia is doing OK.
Think about that for a while.
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DSa7eOEeNhLk&ved=2ahUKEwixg46dyJmEAxX8a0EAHRzFAYQQwqsBegQIEhAF&usg=AOvVaw3NJ0m03s0osA-Yo9_jUexJ
Russia is not North Korea or Iran, its too big to be alienated. You need to learn to coexist with Russia.
Absolute nonsense and here's why i say so.
Having thoroughly studied Russia's Central Banks releases thie following is clear.
in 2023 and to date in 2024 Russia achieved 14 months of multi billion dollar deficits, following a multi billion dollar deficit in December 2022 (Source : Russia Central Bank data) leading to a 156 billion dollar reduction in revenue.
The deficits are a continual worsening trend caused by western sanctions decreasing Russia's revenues by 62% from oil and gas, which according to Russia Bank's data is over 156 billion dollars down on the same period in 2021/ 2022.
On top of this Russia's currency, the Ruble, has decreased in value by 52%, making it one of the 3 worst performing currencies in 2023, even after Russia's Bank doubled interest rate from 7.5% to 15% in 5 months at the end of 2023, in an attempt to stop it declining in value even further.
Russia has stopped fuel exports to prevent shortages, has food queues for the first time since Soviet times and spare parts availability for cars, planes, agricultural machinery, industry, etc has gone from 2 days to 18 months, if available at all.
Russia has been robbing its 'reserve funds' to pay for the economy, which means the growth may look good, but it's not from new revenues! You understand that differention, yes?
Lastly, Russians are freezing all across Russia due to heating and electrical power infrastructure failures due to poor maintenance.
These are easily researched facts and yet you will hear every day that Russia is doing well! why? because people believe Russian propaganda and don't understand statistics!
Let me give you an example.
Let's say Russia earned $100 and due to sanctions lost half (50%), the level of Russia's value at the start of the next year is now $50. in the next 12 months Russia achieves a growth of $10 giving them a total of $60.(which, if taken from the lower $50 starting point calculates as 20% growth). That for some and in particular the IMF forcasters, indicates a growth of 20%, rather than a deficit of 40% from the Original $100 starting point the previous year.
The bigger picture (wider the historical data spread) gives you the real picture, and not the snap shot taken that included the lower figures to support the narrative that Russia is doing OK.
Think about that for a while.
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DSa7eOEeNhLk&ved=2ahUKEwixg46dyJmEAxX8a0EAHRzFAYQQwqsBegQIEhAF&usg=AOvVaw3NJ0m03s0osA-Yo9_jUexJ
Russia needs to learn to coexist with its neighbors.
@@matthewb.7172 it did coexist with neighbours fine, but as the saying goes (again not even Russian, Irish or Indian) - if a family started quarelling and fighting each other, this means a Brit has been there recently.
@@Notyourbusiness266”it did coexist with its neighbor” untill it decided to invade. Russians have to reconcile with their history of oppression begining with Stalin. All supporters of dictatorships direct blame outwards and it seems you drink the coolaide
@@Notyourbusiness266 Or Brit's love child, USA.
Russia has surpassed expectations and still the west cannot get over it 😂😂😂😂
By getting bogged down in a war.
RuZZia hide the truth. Simples, compare the Meerkat
Not if you understand economics. Looking at a few indicators can provide a false picture. The Russian economy is slowly being destroyed. Basically they are spending their savings and using monies meant for non-war purposes to build tanks etc. This will create long-term economic problems.
Surpassing expectations would actually mean Russia took over the majority of Ukraine in less than 2 days and then started considering invading Moldova. So no they're not surpassing expectations, but they are spending away 100ks of Russian lives and billions of dollars to prop up their trillion dollar economy, so in that way they sort of surpassed expectations (but not really because we all knew supreme leader Putin doesn't value the average Russians lives). Hope Xi is ready to help Putin last another year or 2 after Europe uses $300 billion in Russian assets to build Ukrainian wartime factories in Romania and Poland. Perhaps we could even employ the Chinese to do it since they're the best at building them in under a year and Evergrande (which builds 1 in 6 Chinese houses) just went bankrupt in a Hong Kong court.
@@Matt1975ism The real number of how many Russians have died in Ukraine is classified. We wouldn't want the world to know what the Kremlin and Russian military Generals' incompetence actually looks like.
TALK ABOUT AARON BUSHNELL... WHY BBC IS HIDING IT?
fear
They aren’t a news network, they just spread the propaganda of their donors and politicians.
did you expect BBC to talk about him?
Do you also want to talk about Irina Slavina?
The sanctions actually work. It made Russia's economy grow by 3.6% instead of the target goal of 4.9% but it also affect some European countries like Germany almost close to 0. It works on enemies and allies.
germany isn't at zero GDP growth, it's below.
Germany is in an economic recession currently.
They do work ..Germany 2:21 is in recession.....the power house of EI 😂
Russia must stop the war.
This is nonsense. Russia's goal was around 1.7%. They themselves were surprized by the high IMF prediction, and still held a lower prediction afterward.
GDP is a measure of the value of all goods and services produced in a country. A 3.6% growth means that Russia now produces 3.6% more stuff in terms of dollar value.
Lots of exports to Russia were banned. Lots of Western brands left Russia willingly. This left a big demand for those goods and services in Russia...this demand was filled by new local producers that sprang up in Russia during the first year (and they didnt have to worry about being outcompeted by western industries). This is why Russia now produces more goods and services (which requires the employment of people, increase demand for labor, which increases wages and salaries.
The other factor is the increase in value of certain goods and services. Attempting to block imports of oil and gas from one of the largest producers is going to increase the dollar value of these goods and services...because of market volatility.
Normally, when left alone, the market will settle into the most efficient trade routes, but if you stir that up, things become expensive.
E.g. here's a hypothetical, If Europe stops importing from Russia, and starts importing from Saudi and Qatar and bids a higher price to get it due to demand, Saudi and Qatar now have less available for it's current customers. Their current customers now have their supply disrupted and have a bigger demand for oil and gas, and when they search for supply they find that Russia just so happens to have additional supply available and are willing to pay more than usual due to circumstances.
All this caused the Russian Government to collect more tax revenue. Increased business activity, increased employment and salaries, increased value of exports that are directly taxed, etc. means more money in the coffers of a government (oil and gas exports have a large export tax slapped in those in Russia). Governments get revenue from tax (this obvious even to the most simple minded person).
This guy is complaining and don’t have solutions
Human life is cheap. Talk is even cheaper.
This is journalism not simple talk
In Russia it is anyway
@@matthewb.7172 lol west killing machine look at history
@@yourass7934 When did the west ever kill?
PRECISELY 😂😂
350000 casualties 😂
Country off 40 milion people lose 31000 and they running out off men, what is logic there
Joke of the year.Yet I hear that Ukraine has lost 25,000 soldiers according to Westerners
This Russian man feels sad because his country economy grow up 😂😂
Честно говоря он не русккий. Скажем так, он сейчас в Израиле
He looks intoxicated and has a drug problem
😂😂😂 that's how you know who he is working for
@@piuswanyaga8361 That’s just how RuZZians look, not enough sunlight, poor diets and too much vodka
hes russian so will be @@piuswanyaga8361
“Russia leader has a palace!” Haha how many palaces does royal family in UK have?
0:50... How dare you?... For British and American life is cheap too... Palestinian lives . Hypocrite.
Arab life is cheap because of the way strong Arab men, in many places, fight for dominance. Problem has deep historical roots. West can't fix this. All Jews voluntarily leaving the region wouldn't fix it.
After 7 years, Brexit turns out to be an intelligent move. Europe is a sinking ship.
You think it was just s lucky move ?
Your sanctions are total BS!
The whole world is laughing loudly.
😂😂😂
Every country want friend with russia
So why is Russia upset about the sanction?
Except EU lol
@@captainchaoscow we dont care lol eu sanctioned its self
Says by a man who we don’t know who he is and full of hatred towards Russia 😂😂😂
So many Russians don't like Putin and that is why Naval y is dead. To send them a message. So no it is not Russia that people hate and many people in the west have admired Russia, including myself. Putin however is someone that does not value Russians lives and is willing to sacrifice 300k of Russians for a small peninsula, and even more stil for years to come. So even though Tucker Carlson admires him, the rest of the west does not.
I am Russian, i know who he is. Where does he say something bad about Russia as a country? Why do self-indulged idiots like you think that saying things that can help overthrow the inhumane regime is considered to be a hatred? I wish you to find yourself in the conditions that I live in.
Maxim Katz, unfortunately, is not a reliable source of information. His videos are not popular in Russia, as he often makes mistakes and does not always tell the truth. When he reads his texts, he usually does not understand their meaning and utters complete nonsense. When asked about what he said, he cannot remember his words. None of Maxim Katz's predictions have come true, and his company does not have sufficient competence in this area.
@@nobody_dudeу него два миллиона подписчиков 😃
Сколько там интервью пыпы всего просмотрело?
@@mind-blowing_tumbleweed неважно сколько подписчиков, важно сколько смотрит, а каца накручивают на всяких сомнительных сайтах, рекламой идет перед фильмом или роликом. Плюс авторитета ноль, как я и писал, его никто всерьез не воспринимает, может только горстка либерах, потому что не один его прогноз не сбылся, он ошибается абсолютно во всем. Проблема либералов в России, в том, что слишком слабые лидеры мнения, как духовно так и умственно, по сути один Навальный был и то умер, а то что остались, это просто курам на смех. А сколько там просмотров интервью я не знаю, вам виднее.
Total absolute BS
"Im a russian politician that wants my country to do really bad so i can overthrow my goverment and rise to power myself". Nice dude xD
At last someone noticed that!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
dude it's democracy vs autocracy, of course he wants to defeat them. Autocracy sucks.
@@A1lexander so, he wants to ruin the economy and people's lives for the sake of democracy! How democratic is that
He is a traitor 🤣 No wonder why Russian opposition is irrelevant. You love want to lead a country yet you ask for sanctions for your country
love how the russian opposition wants his country to have a brain drain he truly loves his country
Katz is not Russian, he comes from Israel.
They are paid propagandist.
You are correct, a man will support another country, to his own country, he had been brain washed by the west
Absolute nonsense and here's why i say so.
Having thoroughly studied Russia's Central Banks releases thie following is clear.
in 2023 and to date in 2024 Russia achieved 14 months of multi billion dollar deficits, following a multi billion dollar deficit in December 2022 (Source : Russia Central Bank data) leading to a 156 billion dollar reduction in revenue.
The deficits are a continual worsening trend caused by western sanctions decreasing Russia's revenues by 62% from oil and gas, which according to Russia Bank's data is over 156 billion dollars down on the same period in 2021/ 2022.
On top of this Russia's currency, the Ruble, has decreased in value by 52%, making it one of the 3 worst performing currencies in 2023, even after Russia's Bank doubled interest rate from 7.5% to 15% in 5 months at the end of 2023, in an attempt to stop it declining in value even further.
Russia has stopped fuel exports to prevent shortages, has food queues for the first time since Soviet times and spare parts availability for cars, planes, agricultural machinery, industry, etc has gone from 2 days to 18 months, if available at all.
Russia has been robbing its 'reserve funds' to pay for the economy, which means the growth may look good, but it's not from new revenues! You understand that differention, yes?
Lastly, Russians are freezing all across Russia due to heating and electrical power infrastructure failures due to poor maintenance.
These are easily researched facts and yet you will hear every day that Russia is doing well! why? because people believe Russian propaganda and don't understand statistics!
Let me give you an example.
Let's say Russia earned $100 and due to sanctions lost half (50%), the level of Russia's value at the start of the next year is now $50. in the next 12 months Russia achieves a growth of $10 giving them a total of $60.(which, if taken from the lower $50 starting point calculates as 20% growth). That for some and in particular the IMF forcasters, indicates a growth of 20%, rather than a deficit of 40% from the Original $100 starting point the previous year.
The bigger picture (wider the historical data spread) gives you the real picture, and not the snap shot taken that included the lower figures to support the narrative that Russia is doing OK.
Think about that for a while.
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DSa7eOEeNhLk&ved=2ahUKEwixg46dyJmEAxX8a0EAHRzFAYQQwqsBegQIEhAF&usg=AOvVaw3NJ0m03s0osA-Yo9_jUexJ
it's really strange to hear even for me (I hate Putin and what he's done to my country)
So; the story has changed. 180 about turn. No wonder people don’t trust the press anymore…
How many soldiers have Ukraine lost??. Stop spinning. Russia is winning the war despite the so called suntions.
The Putin shrugs his shoulders at every new sanction.
War is far from over. Even if Russia 'wins' it's going to have to deal with counter insurgency attacks for decades.
5..
Russia is not ‘winning’.
Sounds like you're the one trying to falsely spin the narrative.
Why didn't MSM report on how these sanctions affect EU economy??
No one cares about Navalny. Even many doesn't know who is this navalny.my 😂 question is where the BBC find these kind of Specialists.
Macron said that they will consider boots on ground!! He needs to be careful.. He might end up in a casket...
Nikakva šteta!!!Bolje i to nego treći svjetski rat!!!
@@duskokukolj5571 English please
You can't threaten the whole world.
Turks approached the USA and EU side. If there is no entry into Turkish investment funds, it will go to the other side again... I think we have to ensure foreign currency inflow by keeping the Turks in this composition!!!
I'm not Russian but i can tell that this man is a real traitor
А потом они удивляются почему в России не популярны западные ценности
@@kostik26 hahaha so true..🤣🙌 I translate "And then they wonder why Western values are not popular in Russia"
I'd say he's legit and Putin & co. are the traitors.
Based on?
@tesfayenguise: I am not a Russian but I think you are a moron. Since you are entitled to your opinion and I am entitled to mine
that guy is an emigrant not opposition
The earth doesn't revolve around Europe faster you understand faster we progress
Western companies assets in Russia have an estimate from $700 bil. to $1 trillion of value. I am pretty sure that Moscow will gladly trade these for the $300 bil. in question.
That's so dumb
U r underestimated the whole Russian intelligence and governance system! What u r suggesting is what lowborn Mafias action!
I cannot help but continue to be amazed that BBC, continues to draw supporters,------
I cannot help but be amazed that you've been outwitted by the comma.
@@MrTravelWriter well well arent you the smart one here
There are lots of people who don think much out there. Imagine just looking for news that would tell you what to think and what not to think.
Borat reincarnation, straight from the choral synagogue in Ashdod...
😂😂😂
Perhaps some other "experts" on Russia?
He was rather good expert on urban infrastructure, until he has decided to become an opposition. It spoiled him a lot.
I have never seen a man so disappointed that his own country's economy has not been destroyed by its enemies but instead has thrived.....
He is even offering advise on how to crush his home country and disappointed in its enemies for failing to destroy it.
Honestly western managed opposition in the diaspora is always such a weird people.
Even us in African countries we have them.
What have you expected from a jew?
@@1Know1tHurts you must be Jew hater Nazi sympathizer or a Muslim who hates Jew because of Palestine . In India and Africa too they have such people guess what none of them are Jew . Pakistan Army has ruined their own country for west and their own greed guess what it's an Islamic nation .
Human life is cheap in Palestine 🇵🇸
Alexei and MI6 🤫 CIA🤔
More than 12 000 sanctions did not work.❌
Giving Ukraine 100s billions of dollars did not work.❌.
Ever tried negotiating maybe?🤔🤷 Seems cheap and more practical to me 🤷
But Russia doesn’t have 35$ trillion dollars in debt 🤷♂️
still you believe Europe is represent the whole world altogether.
US hegemony almost coming to an end.
Does a planet increasingly run by reckless gangster regimes offer your family and friends a better future?
@@cliodyncycwatch924USA military is biggest mafia since 1945
@@cliodyncycwatch924by invading other countries 😂
@@joexavier4070.
By stopping coup in Ukraine. 2014 😂😂😂😂.
By invading Iraq 😂😂😂
Almost ?
What a Russian opposition! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
It's like when the UK or US pretends to hand over over power to non conservatives , while holding actual power over/ relationship with decision making frameworks and every other function of state and private interest.
Doesn’t exist, Dictator VP has them all bumped off!
@@Matt1975ism You don't understand Russians. We had enough reforms with Gorby and Yeltsin 😅😅😅😅Thanks but no, thanks🤓
@@StPiter111all slavs love soft authorities
They only matter in west.
Санкции работают! Не отменяйте пожалуйста! Мы начали делать все сами!
Ukrainians are modern-day "MacGyvers." 🌻 U.S. aid may be delayed, but it WILL be delivered. Americans are *demanding* action. Slava 🇺🇦!
Like what? Like bukhanka? 😂
@@kugeliszudikasнапример все. А вот на чем летает Америка в космос и Маск? На русских двигателях РД, а на чем живут АЭС в штататах? На продуктах Росатом 😁 а может топливо, металл европа и США используют свое? Нет опять из России😂
@@user-xn5mf7ps9r take away your fossil fuel what else you got?😃😃 Apple? Samsung? Tesla? Audi? Starlink, spaceX, microchips, Microsoft, Medical equipment? medicine? 😃 you braggint about things that was for millions years in the ground, but still i can not see anything you created yourself 😃 except chaoes and poverty 😃
@@kugeliszudikasа еще мы производим мебель,строительные материалы выращиваем крупный рогатый скот птицу шьем одежду кстати качественную
The United Kingdom's economy grew by 0.1 percent in 2023😅
Most of russia is 10 years behind the UK.
@@Richoright lol where we behind uk
Budanov of Ukraine: in fact Navalny is dead because of blood clots
EU Sanctions no one but itself. Economy sanctions against enemies is not a new strategy, but a rather old one with a new name. Surrounding the enemy during siege, preventing resources and reinforcements to get in were always a war strategy. On the other hand if anyone has ever saw a map about Russia, then there is no question about that surrounding it or preventing resources to come and go by applying sanctions are never was going to work. But hey, maybe 13th time it is going to have an effect, right? Nope, nothing is going to change.
Is it true Olaf Scholz has claimed british troops are in the Ukraine aiding in the use of long range misssles against Russia.
Putin murdered Navalni 😂 ...what a BS LOL
Provide evidence, don't just post
@@torubbrown4779 Evidence for what. It takes common sense ....little thinking . You should try 😉
@ronjones8696 Navalny...... Imaginary Western Super hero. Like Spiderman and The Ghost Of Kiev lol
Even the us said russia hasn't done it
@@user-hs6xs7zl6k 2 mounts after the Accusations.....I guess it served the purpose ..to Rally more Support $. Definitely helped. Congress to pass the supplemental bill 😂 Scammers
😂😂😂😂😂.. Laughable how the conversations have changed recently so 😂😂😅😅. When the missiles works properly is western tech but they downplayed Russia 🇷🇺 might 😂😂😂😅.. A bunch of comedians try to understand the reality 😂😅😅.. Putin is sipping his Vodka while laughing at the west 😂😂😂
Uraaah 🇷🇺
❤❤I love Russia more than myself ❤❤
✨✨Dear Putin is my inspiration ✨✨✨
Эм я хотел послушать про санкции а максимка занимает про смерть Навального..
As Russian who lives in Russia I can definitely say that we're more than fine these days and truly independent. We have our own payment system and have no need for VISA or MC. We have a full house of resources, all kinds, while USA and EU is still dependent on some of our resources. Shelves are full of groceries, all other shops and markets are full of everything you need. Sanctions not only "not working", but actually hurting USA and EU more than us. Guys, come on... a country that is trying to control the world by putting sanctions on everything is sees will eventually go under. That worked foe some time when China wasn't that strong, but USSR was strong. Now both Russia and China are strong. And Iran, and even North Korea, which is sending shells to Russia and USA can't do much about. USA and EU (read NATO) is weaker than ever. The world will eventually abandon the use of dollar like it was couple of decades ago and the debt of USA will play its destroying game towards the owner of that debt.
The UK applied sanctions on Russia then its economy shrunk by 0.1% last year ...That shows just how effective sanctions are...Russian economy performed poorly because its economy only registered 4.9% growth and not 3.6%
the sanctions is effective if russia were using the dollar currency but it was not artillery shells in russia is cheaper than in western countries despite the sanction. GDP was not the only way to describe an economy but GDP PPP also defines how expensive the domestic products which russia is pushing to derailed itself from western reliance.
In some metrics Russian economy is now the largest economy in Europe and not Germany...That must be really bad for Russia
@@haeveen8255get help bro!
Zero. Russia is now the 5th biggest economy in the world in PPP. in a year or two theyll be fourth. The sanction have backfired and helped the Russian economy
MSM has portrayed navalny as a hero. In reality he's a villain.
Exactly! Stop crying navalny…He’s ..Nothing!
I wouldn’t mind seeing the evidence that Putin was responsible for the death of Navalny. The journalists and guests on this report seem very sure of their views but any evidence seems circumstantial at best
He was an NED funded puppet. If a US presidential candidate received substantial campaign donations and support from any other foreign government, they would be called a traitor.
He’s a traitor and NED puppet
Why do you skip the information about where the growth came from? It's military spending. Not from household consumption. I wonder why are skipping that fact? Are you trying to push an agenda?
Exactly. Who does the BBC serve by choosing not to get analysis on that
He BBC no longer knows what analysis is. Also, when a country switches to a war-time economy the common metrics are no loger relevant to it, or at least not directly comparable to those of countries with peace-time economies.
Every Russian sector is experiencing growth.
Spoken as only a bot called Joke1239 could. USE A REAL NAME COWARDS.
Actually, the growth is due to sanctions. My country has signed contracts to replace all passenger aircraft by 2030. All of them will be produced in Russia. All trains, all ships will be replaced. Literally, many shipyards are being built right now. China is helping to build them, but they are all on the territory of Russia. Many computer manufacturing plants have been built. Russia is even changing the windows operating system to its own. Your media is deceiving you. We in Russia now, like the Soviet Union, produce everything ourselves. Everything except cars. The cars are now Chinese, but they are manufactured in factories in Russia.
As long as you sell stuff to Armenia, Kazakhstan and other satellites is just a short drive.
The Russian economy in 2023 outpaced both the United States and Europe in terms of growth, increasing in size by 3.6% despite being subject to a wide array of powerful economic sanctions😅
Absolute nonsense and here's why i say so.
Having thoroughly studied Russia's Central Banks releases thie following is clear.
in 2023 and to date in 2024 Russia achieved 14 months of multi billion dollar deficits, following a multi billion dollar deficit in December 2022 (Source : Russia Central Bank data) leading to a 156 billion dollar reduction in revenue.
The deficits are a continual worsening trend caused by western sanctions decreasing Russia's revenues by 62% from oil and gas, which according to Russia Bank's data is over 156 billion dollars down on the same period in 2021/ 2022.
On top of this Russia's currency, the Ruble, has decreased in value by 52%, making it one of the 3 worst performing currencies in 2023, even after Russia's Bank doubled interest rate from 7.5% to 15% in 5 months at the end of 2023, in an attempt to stop it declining in value even further.
Russia has stopped fuel exports to prevent shortages, has food queues for the first time since Soviet times and spare parts availability for cars, planes, agricultural machinery, industry, etc has gone from 2 days to 18 months, if available at all.
Russia has been robbing its 'reserve funds' to pay for the economy, which means the growth may look good, but it's not from new revenues! You understand that differention, yes?
Lastly, Russians are freezing all across Russia due to heating and electrical power infrastructure failures due to poor maintenance.
These are easily researched facts and yet you will hear every day that Russia is doing well! why? because people believe Russian propaganda and don't understand statistics!
Let me give you an example.
Let's say Russia earned $100 and due to sanctions lost half (50%), the level of Russia's value at the start of the next year is now $50. in the next 12 months Russia achieves a growth of $10 giving them a total of $60.(which, if taken from the lower $50 starting point calculates as 20% growth). That for some and in particular the IMF forcasters, indicates a growth of 20%, rather than a deficit of 40% from the Original $100 starting point the previous year.
The bigger picture (wider the historical data spread) gives you the real picture, and not the snap shot taken that included the lower figures to support the narrative that Russia is doing OK.
Think about that for a while.
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DSa7eOEeNhLk&ved=2ahUKEwixg46dyJmEAxX8a0EAHRzFAYQQwqsBegQIEhAF&usg=AOvVaw3NJ0m03s0osA-Yo9_jUexJ
And yet the Russian people are poorer. Spending 40% on military does nothing for the benefit of the Russian people, as the equipment is produced and then destroyed in Ukraine. The Russian people see no benefit, whereas if it was invested in education or healthcare they would see growth and the benefits.
@@Richoright Show proof that the Russian people are poor. Give link a video of a Russian slum and an American or British slum to show that Russia is much worse than the west for people. You can't just say wild statements without proof that's the problem with the internet. I can easily regurgitate my made up stats and say Russia is the greatest or worst country in the world which is what you're doing
@@Richoright Why are you talking about poverty in a country you've never been to?
@@user-sq2uy1rc8y I’ve not been to Germany but I know they speak German. I don’t need to visit a country to understand facts. Do you want me to travel around Russia counting poor people? Over 13 million Russians live below the poverty line and in rural areas they don’t even have basic facilities.
A very wise and charismatic leader ❤
Because big Asian countries and BRICKS helping to Russian economy and Russia is independent almost
If it true sanctions are neccessary
0:46 - ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. Julian Assange once posted a video about this. They say that then "freedom of speech" failed him.
Initially they said Ukraine will win. They advised against the 2022 peace talks and armed Ukraine. In the end, they will accept reality and acknowledge the fact that Russia can't be beaten.
“All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as self-evident."
For a few days we all thought Kiev was going to be conquered.
@@cliodyncycwatch924 Russians hoped for a negotiated settlement. Unfortunately the negotiations failed. Who didn't want peace?
Who advised against the 2022 peace talks in April? Hint: someone visited Zelensky in Kiev at that time.
@@cliodyncycwatch924 If Russia wants Kiev, Russia will take Kiev.
@@PerceivedREALITY999 Does a planet increasingly run by reckless gangster regimes offer your family and friends a better future?
@@cliodyncycwatch924 “Operation Iraqi freedom” was the saintly title for the brutal invasion of Iraq. “Operation unified protector” was the angelic name for the destruction of Libya. “Operation enduring freedom” was the virtuous name given to the unjust invasion of Afghanistan. All in the name of democracy
As a British citizen married and resident in Russia, my British pension has been stopped. The UK pension states that Citibank refuses to do cash transactions to Russia. They are discriminating British pensioners in Russia
*How sanctions affect the Russian economy*
The manufacturing business activity index (PMI Manufacturing) from S&P Global was 54.7 points in February (52.4 in January). The average index value over the past 12 months increased to 53.4 points (53.3 a month earlier). This is the best value since 2008 (for 16 years).
According to Rosstat, in January the output of basic industries increased by 5.3%. If we talk about the physical volume of production, then the past month was the best January in history. Thus, the previous record of January 2021 was broken.
The growth of industrial production by January 2023 was 4.6%. The growth of industrial production is accelerating.
Russia's GDP growth rate in January 2024 increased compared to the previous month. The Ministry of Economic Development reported this on February 28 in its review “On the current situation in the Russian economy.” It reports that in January the country's GDP grew by 4.6% in annual terms after 4.4% in December.
The manufacturing industry accelerated its output growth rate to 7.5% after 5.1% in December. Thus, the engineering complex showed growth of 28.3% year-on-year after 9.5% in December. The metallurgical industry increased its growth rate by 4.9% against 2.8% in December, and the food industry by 7.3% after December’s 1.9%!!!
Can you rely on the bbc to report 'facts'?
"Britain to get six inches of snow next week".
Russia is the first country that has quality, decency,and dignity to lead the world
No longer. Russia is a communist state where the citizens are too afraid to protest or say anything bad about the government. Nice progress guys!
😂 ok bot
Absolute nonsense and here's why i say so.
Having thoroughly studied Russia's Central Banks releases thie following is clear.
in 2023 and to date in 2024 Russia achieved 14 months of multi billion dollar deficits, following a multi billion dollar deficit in December 2022 (Source : Russia Central Bank data) leading to a 156 billion dollar reduction in revenue.
The deficits are a continual worsening trend caused by western sanctions decreasing Russia's revenues by 62% from oil and gas, which according to Russia Bank's data is over 156 billion dollars down on the same period in 2021/ 2022.
On top of this Russia's currency, the Ruble, has decreased in value by 52%, making it one of the 3 worst performing currencies in 2023, even after Russia's Bank doubled interest rate from 7.5% to 15% in 5 months at the end of 2023, in an attempt to stop it declining in value even further.
Russia has stopped fuel exports to prevent shortages, has food queues for the first time since Soviet times and spare parts availability for cars, planes, agricultural machinery, industry, etc has gone from 2 days to 18 months, if available at all.
Russia has been robbing its 'reserve funds' to pay for the economy, which means the growth may look good, but it's not from new revenues! You understand that differention, yes?
Lastly, Russians are freezing all across Russia due to heating and electrical power infrastructure failures due to poor maintenance.
These are easily researched facts and yet you will hear every day that Russia is doing well! why? because people believe Russian propaganda and don't understand statistics!
Let me give you an example.
Let's say Russia earned $100 and due to sanctions lost half (50%), the level of Russia's value at the start of the next year is now $50. in the next 12 months Russia achieves a growth of $10 giving them a total of $60.(which, if taken from the lower $50 starting point calculates as 20% growth). That for some and in particular the IMF forcasters, indicates a growth of 20%, rather than a deficit of 40% from the Original $100 starting point the previous year.
The bigger picture (wider the historical data spread) gives you the real picture, and not the snap shot taken that included the lower figures to support the narrative that Russia is doing OK.
Think about that for a while.
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&opi=89978449&url=m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3DSa7eOEeNhLk&ved=2ahUKEwixg46dyJmEAxX8a0EAHRzFAYQQwqsBegQIEhAF&usg=AOvVaw3NJ0m03s0osA-Yo9_jUexJ
keep telling that to yourself....Don't said no to WAR outloud ....keep your mouth shut like a dog slave to Putin regime
the only country to take new land since 1945....Gerogia land , /crimea, East Ukraine....USA FOUGHT SEVERAL wars with no land grab...Russia killed 300,000 men in 2 years.....double the USA lost in vietnam in almost 20 years ...Russia completelly distrouyed every city it took from Ukrtaine.....complete FOREGIN PLANET SCIENCE FICTION distruction level...the most pathetic army in the world.....rapes tortures and dozens aof thousands of children kidnaped in Ukraine.....horrible medieval countrry...the same country that was colonial until 1989....subjugating 14 other countries under the so called USSR...the same country that forced ALL Ukrainians and Belarussians and Moldovians to learn Russian....USSR tried but it could not force all muslim colonies of the Soviert empire to learn Russian...and now.....they threw 5 million artilery shells...completely dsitroyed the land to SAVE RUSSIAN SPEAKERS....WOW...WOW....after 702years of forcing people to learn Russian...
We the majority support Vladimir Putin and Russia. Russia rules.
Most Ukraine are killed by artillery shell from miles away. Ukrainian soldiers mostly never see their enemy. Russia casualties is way less then Ukrainian.
A half-kilo of ground meat in St. Petersburg costs less than the life of a Russian conscript.
Putin:🤣
Is a Russian opposition leader or any member, who recommends brain drain? This is just a traitor.
He was not very successful as an opposition leader, couldn't win an election even to Moscow (not federal) parliament. He was much better as an urbanist, promoting bike paths and such stuff in Moscow.
Putin is not using the money to build more palaces then???. 😂😂😂
Buying gas, buying oil..." saying: like its like buying Gucci. Not a choice baby.
Remember that Europe and West have adopted an economic model based on injustice. Incentivating to privileged and depriving the lesser has caused austerity. Super rich people gathered huge capital, and common people struggle for daily meeting both end has made the economy stagnant. BRICS countries have kept their capital rationally distributed, which is in circulation, thus, their economies are flourishing. American dream and European dream is doomed with empowering corporates over consumers. The result is clear.
Your analysis fails to notice or explain the sources and preferred destinations of massive flow of migrants.
@cliodyncycwatch924 Migrants are only helping several Western economies to afloat. otherwise, depopulation would have caused serious problems. Post 2nd World War, political correctness resulted in laws supporting migrant workers. The moment BRICS offers migration, a real serious problem in Western economies may start. However, population growth among BRICS is preventing them immigration momentarily.
Russia is one of the most unequal countries on the planet in terms of wealth distribution!
How to ship oil from Russian to Europe. 1. Set up a company on 3rd world country by ur friends or relatives
2. Use the company to purchase oil from Russian
3. Purchase oil from the company that u set up for ur friends / relative from the 3rd world country.
4. Claims that u purchase oil from other country not from Russian😅
That how u avoid sanction
I never understood these sanctions. Sanction no. 1 should be: no trade, no travel except on diplomatic level, no visas to Russians except diplomats.
Yes, to help Ukraine, help the Russians leave Russia.
Give the Russian smart people a choice.
Katz spent the whole of 2022 saying that right now Russia's planes would stop flying, a complete collapse of the economy, and in 2024 this same great economist suddenly forgot what he had said earlier and says that sanctions are useless and ineffective
R.I.P Aaron Bushnell
No to Genocide in Gaza ✊🏿
Now most countries think of economy than sanctions on Russia. It is not in great trouble than what was thought. It has more friends than usa have.
ATTENTION!!
Benny Hill considered funnier than Monty Python by two TV stations --WOR and WLVI!
Katz has huge connections around the world and Israeli government. Invite him more often
Yep, especially when he behaves like today and looks a bit intoxicated.
So a dictatorship is unable to force a quiet funeral? Must be a failed tyranny that one 😅😂
How can I receive a British pension in Russia, when Citibank (pension office's bank) has stopped paying pensions in Russia? They are discriminating pensioners resident in Russia while they continue paying to the rest of the world.
3% growth is a big number
Where did they find the guy? The fact that he is in Russia doesn't make him an expert)
Russia: our economy is better than all other countries combined
We’ve known since the beginning that the Russian philosophy was going to be their classic, quantity is a quality
Russia is geographically in Europe, this is a thing European find it hard to accept.Russia is a superpower and the solution is Europe to accept that live and employ mondus vivendi
The Empire falls
350 casualties? Surely he means 350,000?
What is the BBC, and does it provide factual information or padded out opinion? ]BBC NEWS
Britain actually sanctioning themselves 😂
They got quit a nerve to acuse other people !
Love how he didn’t comment on things he admitted he knew nothing about. Takes some integrity that
Is better for USA and collective west to beg and negotiate with Russia because you cant do with Russia all but talk talk talk for citizens to say they are doing something.
Half of Aeroflot's fleet is grounded. Maybe that's not the effect of sanctions.
What use of that have Ukranians when fleet of SU's flying at 300℅
India is re exporting Russia oil. Oil is refined in I Dua and reshipped to UK, EU etc..
When doesn't the world block all the sea traffic than they wouldn't be able to trade with other countries.
This is self sanctioning tbh if you still get the same oil but at a premium.
And all of a sudden the foreign minister is now an economic analyst of great abilities?
Don't be too playful.
This is NOT working! Please think of something different!