And then the Barefoot Princess came along... And you start thinking about your words. Three days ago Angelina Jordan released her wonderful, soulful Jazz redition with Toby on the piano. (I'd be interested if BC is smiling. I guess she does)
BC Jean is absolutely very extremely the original. BC Jean should retain her rights to this song and protect her work from others trying to defame her.
ik and they chose beyonce to sing it cause her voice is more powerful,but I like it more at her....it's relaxing and it helps with my breakup from 2 months ago....do I still cry with this song...
agreed with out a question .. i agree sorry for your breakup .. god breaks it all to show you where your path needs to be .. better things will come.. I promise
"They" did not chose Beyonce to sing it. Beyoncé happen to hear this song performed by B.C. Jean and liked it so she contacted her and just bought it from her for a large sum of money. That is how it went honey........ There was no need to get jealous for one of them
I like beyonces version but this one is just so raw and amazing! You can just hear all of the emotion in her voice and I think it fits the song so perfectly!
+Like50BlackGuys I think the point is that the lyrics, the melody - that's BC Jean's actual guts spilling out and that's why it fits so perfectly. Both versions are amazing - but when you hear BC Jean's, you can picture the little fuck that made her write the incredible song...and all involved made millions so both are winners!
I wouldn’t say Beyoncé’s version lacks emotion; rather that her emotions are different because she is at a different point in the relationship than BC Jean sang from in the original. I see and hear a tired, frustrated BEYOND tears and anger, resigned form of acceptance in Beyoncé’s version. By acceptance, I do NOT mean to imply that it’s okay to treat anyone that way OR that the woman is letting things continue as if the relationship were healthy. Having been through this scenario myself, I can easily imagine this song sung from several different viewpoints all held by the same woman, just at different points in time. In my own experience with this kind of pain,, I did eventually accept that I couldn’t change him, and from that point on, I made decisions for myself that were no longer based on the future I once hoped for with him. On on the way to that resigned acceptance, you can bet I felt everything in BC Jean’s version, too ... and now I am somewhere else entirely and feeling strong and much more myself than I ever felt when I was still with the cad. Of course, I might simply be reading into this because I have unfortunately been there. ;-)
I had the honor of playing guitar for BC at a festival on Kauai some years ago and what a powerhouse artist she is! Loved every minute of it and had a great time hearing her stories around the song. Had to come back for another listen!
@@JhonatanZati technically someone else stole the song and gave it to beyonce but they did slap beyonce's name on it. I bet the financial settlement stipulated no backchat
I just discovered this artist today! FML I did not know this is the original and she sounds so amazing......what a shame the label didn't push this as it's better than the cover. Real rasp and grit, loved it!!!
Listen to Angelina Jordan performance. Emotional and jazzy. I think DC would be proud of this performance. th-cam.com/video/eJr-BfUQ2jE/w-d-xo.htmlsi=oYbBNTtQ1cWFdUja
This is great... Great lyrics... .. Angelina Jordan brought me here... Glad I know the history of the song .. Angelina is smooth...THIS IS SO GRITTY❤❤❤❤
Angelina Jordan's 2024 version with co-writer of the song Toby Gad brought me here. Well done to BC Jean & Toby for writing this hit song. Compared to Beyonce's version, it's interesting to see the raw emotional aspects of the song so evident here, of course with Angelina's vocals they're taken to a whole other level.
Hello fellow Angel. Toby's story about BC and the 🍕 brought me here too. Curious. Agree, BCs original is very emotional, her break up feelings fresh. How 18 year old Angelina Jordan pars or exceeds the emotional impact with her rendition stays a miracle... like she did the last 10 years.
BC Jean's version is more raw, Beyoncé's version is more..I don't really know how to explain it. More pop, I guess? Both versions are great and both voices are completely different, so no need to compare. Just saying that you like one version better is good enough.
I like both of them singing it but respect to her for writing it :) They give such different feelings!!! But I'm tired of everyone here bashing Beyonce. She is talented in her own right and so is this girl. They're differently talented. Please stop with the negative comments. :(
I agree with you. You are so right. Why do people/half of society have to be so mean to BC and Beyonce. They are both talented. And the people are just jealous fools who want attention.
Beyonce is like Led Zeppelin. taking everything she wants, sometimes not paying, sometimes giving few dollars for a song. I bet Beyonce cannot write any melodies. She probably had 9 people working on the album artwork of her self-titled album because it is so hard to put pink "Beyonce" on a black bottom. Her father is rich. I get it. She gets lots of grammy awards and so does her husband Jay-Z. Beyonce's father gave her lots of golden spoon inside her mouth.
girl she makes her harmonies. that is why she is credited in most of her songs. And woah! Youre a closeted fan boo, with all that insider information yoy just spewed. LMAO.
Your vocals are true perfection. You deserve full credit for this song because the raspiness in your voice matches the song perfectly. With the emotion you give off in this song is beautiful. You darling are True Perfection.
@@SeanEvans2 Omg can't you hear the weakness in the voice of bc jean , I've heard several covers which are far better . you're either deaf or have no love for Beyonce .? Jean and gad imo did a great job in producing the Beyonce cover .
I love you BC Jean - I was screwed over by the record industry too, in a different way - I always tell people your story and share this recording of YOUR song with them, the one true, deeply-felt, awesome, and authentic ORIGINAL version. As a songwriter, having a track taken away and given to an established star and done in a different style is my idea of SOUL AGONY and I just hope that in the quantum mechanics of artistry that this injustice makes BC come back stronger with more great songs. x
I love this girl's voice. She doesn't sound like the random American teenager singing with the same childish soprano voice. Finally, a different voice. This song always sounded rock to me, now I understand the orginal version was supposed to be more alternative rock, actually, and less rythm and blues.
Mouhamed Diallo that's a matter of personal taste. You might like Beyonce's version better but we like this one more because it has more soul and I personally enjoy rock a lot.
Mouhamed Diallo this IS the original version of this song, this girl BC Jean wrote it and sang it before Beyoncé, before you post you need to check facts,or else you may come off as a liar. NO I'm not calling you a liar, I'm just making sure that you understand that you are mistaken, Beyoncé's version is ,in fact, a cover of THIS girl's song.
Omar Khodr BC Jean didn't fully write this. Yes it was her idea but the mans voice you hear on this mainly wrote it and he also gave Beyoncé's dad permission to use it. Just BC Jean didn't know as she wanted to use it on her album... She said she was out eating one day and was offered pizza but refused it because she was on a diet. She then thought if I were a boy I'd eat it and not give a shit then she went on about all the things she would do different if she were a boy. Then the fella with her got a pen and wrote all this down and made it into a song and took her into the studio. Yes she did do it but not on her own he helped a lot. And B never stole it it's just BC Jean wasn't told
And now just put it into perspective of times when Heart, Tina etc have been big. These goose bumps when the rock part kicks in. Here like in alone like what ever… nice!
Beyonce did sing the hell out of this song, so i was interested to hear and compare the original. every time i heard this on the radio i would think to myself, this doesn't sound like something she would sing, but, whatever. now i know why. but this girl.... she has a funky Pink vibe to her. we need more singers like that because right now everyone is so autotuned and robotic. i hope this chick made some royalties off of this at least.
Connor Jerry yes you are You know it's a sign of a small mind to start attacking someone over nothing Don't get mad at me for spreading the truth, get mad at yourself for having an inferior intellect
Connor Jerry I love when people with limited vocabularies get owned by people with larger vocabularies because then the only thing they can think to say is "wow do you even know what you're saying?" It's like in their mind they think, "i no no big words dat mean dis person don't eider" lmao Sorry you didn't read enough when you were younger to broaden your mind Cause if you did that you would realize that Beyoncé has the technically better voice Bye Felicia
What a voice. Quite unique and raspy. It really fits. Though I can see why Beyonce's cover was more successful. Her version is smoother and flows better. This one here is a bit more edgy. I listen to all kind of music from jazz to rock, from metal to classic, from pop to progressive. Not everybody likes to listen to this "edginess", especially on the radio. Though credit where credit is due. This is still an awesome version and without the original and the writers there can not be a cover :P
I'm so happy I found the original - I adore this song - I don't think we should slam Beyonce' - her version is powerful and great in her own way but this IS the original and a lot more personal and rough witch I like more - I like both - but this is Jean's song - Thank you so much BC Jean - we know who the credit goes to :)
This is awesome. It's the original writer and singer of this song. So it's cool to like Beyoncé and her music, just know that she didn't write this song. Personally I feel if you didn't write your own shit then you're only a singer. The woman in this video is an artist.
Helen leona please don't make me go there. If you like Beyoncé, more power to you. We're in the Information Age, we all know what she is. And if you don't, inform yourself. If you continue to listen to her, and she makes you all warm and fuzzy, again it's a free country for now.
+420 420 lol, we do live in the information age. and everything I said is very accurate. the woman has 10 awards for songwriting alone. and she got most of them while she was still really young. some even made history. she was the first black woman and second woman ever to win an ASCAP songwriting award...14 years ago.. Google if u like
So... I often catch myself singing the chorus of this in my head. Then I get annoyed because I am not a fan of the other person who sang this. I will be singing this version in my head from now in and enjoying every minute of it. Thank you for this song, I love it and the way you sing it!!!
OMG! This is so much better than Beyonce version. I can't wait to learn how to play this song on Bass Guitar. I love BC Jean and her beautiful voice who perfectly fit's this song.
This is one of best songs of all time. It is shame that Beyonce takes all credit. This original version us much better. Raw emotions, unique vocals, she is hot!!!. BIG LIKE FROM ME!!!
Why are u mad at Beyoncé got getting credit when she sold it to Beyoncé. How about you give credit to Beyoncé for even liking the original song and decided to cover it and change certain words to fit her musically. Like y’all be so negative.
@@queefisafunnyword She didn't. BC label rejected it for.her and sold it to Beyonce without her permission or consent. She is credited as a writer however the dispute was over the fact that Beyonce had credits. And was getting a huge amount of royalty points. You listen to the song it's clear Beyonce changed a few words but contributed nothing to the actual creative process. However Beyonce was getting a higher percentage then both she and Colby combined. So she threatened to sue if this was not adjusted. Beyonce team didn't want the trouble so they settled with her. All was well until Beyonce continued to claim she wrote it which created some bad blood. But she had the last laugh when someone leaked the original. Proving that Beyonce was out right lying. That's when Beyonce changed her story and pretty much said she had no idea of the issues behind the song....then why did you claim to write it? And even have an origin story? Idc that she didn't write it I didn't like that she lied. This is when the songwriting issues began to come to light.
@@MsTrueTy that’s literally not what happened and that was debunked by BC herself. Do y’all just make up scenarios in your head and run with it? BC said she wrote the song and kept it for herself but when her label rejected the song BC BEGAN TO OFFER THE SONG. Beyoncé heard her demo and wanted it so after calling her and BC deciding that it would be better exposure to have Beyoncé sing it, she gave the song to Beyoncé. I implore you to use google. It’s free.
Im kinda dissapointed in Beyoncé tbh..... This poor girl put her heart and soul into this piece of art and then B just comes along and makes it her own 😪🙁. This girl sings it so much better(probs cuz it's hers) and it just feels so *RAW*
Beyoncé bought the song from BC and gave her the writing credits. Beyoncé only credited herself for the production. So don’t speak if you don’t know anything. And as for the vocals, maybe YOU think BC sings better, but objectively that is not true. Beyoncé has much better technique and a much stronger voice.
@@hannahlove8949 Actually BC was only informed about Beyonce releasing her song after the single was due to be released. She wasn't even informed that her song had been sold. The co-writer went behind her back and sold it to Beyonce. Only after it came to light did BC and Beyonce reach a deal about the writing credits etc... BC Jean never intended to sell this song. That's why people are a bit salty about it.
damnnn she killed this song!! omg i loveee it...i will definately put this in my ipod!! :) i love beyonce but i think beyonce get too loud as if she tries to hard in her songs
I saw Alexander Jean last night.. they went on before Lindsey Stirling... I was absolutely BLOWN away. BC Jean has an INCREDIBLE voice. What a beautiful soul
I talked to BC and her parents and asked them flat out what the story was. On Beyonce's album, this is the only song that has BC 100% credit for writing this song. This has so much soul and passion. Love this version
WhiteEmerald1991 not really because the record label dropped her before she released it meaning the label had all rights to it and Beyoncè bought the song
Yeah.... But like in Nashville... There's a writer's culture so people almost always say the name of a writer when the perform in smaller arenas or other performances... Just not always big awards shows. But it's a thing there... Like manners to give props to song writers. I thought it was weird when I first moved there... Like who cares???? Ohhhhhhh because a good song is GOLD and someone let you wear their good!!!! Yup.
You don’t know how many songs aren’t written by the people who sing then do you? This is normal practice in the music industry. Some artists wrote songs and for various reasons give/ sell them to other artists.
+Connor Jerry u people just hate Beyonce... coz this girls couldn't even sing the first chorus without going off key.. just because somebody writes a song doesn't mean their version of it is the best...let's just be honest.. this girl has almost zero vocal ability. any good vocalist will notice that she is telling on the texture of her voice and being emotional to further her performance. she has horrible breathe control and I rely tiny range. she is struggling so much vocally and anybody who really knows vocals can hear that. I'm telling u all this because I'm an artist too. singer and songwriter. I'm mature enough to understand that not everything I write is best sang by me. that would be a huge lie
Connor Jerry lol, thats the worst excuse for bad singing i ever heard. im pretty sure she herself noticed that she made a mistake too.. the backup singer also followed her in hopes of covering it but but it didnt work. u could still hear it. well, if u understand how music works. see instruments play the music in a certain key, and the singer is supposed to sing in accordance with that key in order for it to be music.. if not then its just noise. music is all about organizing sound. and thats the aim of every musician. thats why she doesnt make the same mistake the second time the chorus came around. coz she knows too that that aint how its supposed to sound. whether its her song or not, the rules of music are what they are. ur argument is something that only somebody with no real knowledge of music would say ... going off key has nothing to do with who wrote what...going off key is what helps distinguish a good singer and a bad one... if u dont understand what going off key is, ill make it easier for u. it means ur voice is not in sync with the music...
Toby Gad Co wrote this song with her it didn't fare well in the label and Beyonce asked for it Now 15 years later Toby Gad is re releasing this with the artist Angelina Jordan This was beautiful as the original and Angelina Jordan the 18 year old phenomenal singer and songwriter sings this better than Beyonce and if you don't agree first take a listen and get back to me
Isn't it is nice to hear the rawness from someone who actually wrote the song? Instead of the plain interpretation of the original like a school kid giving a synopsis of a book they read.
This is way better than the Beyonce cover. I listen to metal and hardy ever this type of music but the emotions in her voice really show that sometimes when you hear a song it's more than worth the effort to seek out the original.
I personally like both versions, I think this one is more.... naked and raw. But they're both really good. Rachel Crow does a really amazing version of it too.
I definitely prefer this version. In my opinion this song always sounded too alternative for Beyonce. This girls voice is so distinctive, beautifully raw and sincere.
@marquis actually she claimed she Co wrote it before this girl went after her for rights. Beyonce didn't want to be sued so she credited her and made a settlement to make the attention go away.
Beyonce has always claimed she has co-written every song she has ever recorded. Most of Beyonce's songs has 4 or more writers. She has the whole arsenal of writers, producers and so on. I bet even her self-titled album artwork was planned by nine people - a rip off from AC/DC Back in Black - but AC/DC won't sue Beyonce because it would be ridiculous to claim own the right for black background and basic font.
Well written. Great style as well. Amazing talent you got there Ms Carlson. I hope you got what you truly deserve from writing this amazing song. Pls keep on writing and singing.. Another fan here from the 💕 Much love and power..😍
guys this is not a "version" this is the original!
I'm pretty sure it can be both...
this is the original version
No it's the original
It's the original version
@@Flashbax7 Erm, no
This actually gave me goosebumps. That's insane. She deserves a TONNE of recognition. Just discovered this in 2023.
Me too. Soulful!
Moi aussi ❤️ merci à @PopsPlay
@@sebastienlemouzy84 Oh bordel j'en pleure...
Songwriters get a very healthy cut, plus she gets to go to the shops without being bothered. One of the best jobs in music.
no one sings a song like the songwriter- its full of the emotion they wrote it with. plain and simple
Couldn't be more true
And then the Barefoot Princess came along... And you start thinking about your words.
Three days ago Angelina Jordan released her wonderful, soulful Jazz redition with Toby on the piano. (I'd be interested if BC is smiling. I guess she does)
BC Jean is absolutely very extremely the original. BC Jean should retain her rights to this song and protect her work from others trying to defame her.
This (the original) is my personal favourite because you can feel the emotion and plus I’m in love with her raspy voice.
Me too
Exactly my thoughts too
for anyone wondering this is the original version, it was her song first but her label rejected it
+Justine Devitt whoever her label was, was completely deaf.
Yeah we've all seen the watch mojo video
ik and they chose beyonce to sing it cause her voice is more powerful,but I like it more at her....it's relaxing and it helps with my breakup from 2 months ago....do I still cry with this song...
agreed with out a question .. i agree sorry for your breakup .. god breaks it all to show you where your path needs to be .. better things will come..
I promise
"They" did not chose Beyonce to sing it. Beyoncé happen to hear this song performed by B.C. Jean and liked it so she contacted her and just bought it from her for a large sum of money. That is how it went honey........ There was no need to get jealous for one of them
This gave me chills down my spine the whole song through... jesus christ she's got a great voice. New fan, right here!
I think you’re on crack. I have 0 respect for you if you think this sounds good.
BC Jean bought and owns this song. She’s legally able to protect her work through courthouse means. Team BC Jean always!
What
She wrote the song with Toby Gad.
@@dougcampbell7898 and?
She didn’t just buy and own it. She WROTE it.
I never knew this was the original song...
syeanne stella me neither...till i saw it on mojo top 10 count down...lol
hahaha me either!
***** yea your right but her song was stolen from her by Beyonce
didn;t beyonce pay for her copyright?
she stole it first then when confronted she decided to pay off what she did not to mention she stole it and she gave no credit to BC Jean.
I like beyonces version but this one is just so raw and amazing! You can just hear all of the emotion in her voice and I think it fits the song so perfectly!
I have 2 agree. I like both versions. They both r amazing!!!!
+Like50BlackGuys this is the original
Chessa S Yeah I know... what's your point?
+Like50BlackGuys I think the point is that the lyrics, the melody - that's BC Jean's actual guts spilling out and that's why it fits so perfectly. Both versions are amazing - but when you hear BC Jean's, you can picture the little fuck that made her write the incredible song...and all involved made millions so both are winners!
+Pete Adams exactly :)
I just found this in 2018 and I feel cheated not knowing this.
lol you better I just found out in 2019
Found out now
Found out 20today
Found out today
Found out today
Her voice is like Sia and P!nk combined
Júlia *plays waterfall*
tbh I think it sounds like a mix of elle king and jewel
omg that's true!! both comments are true btw hehe
her voice is so raspy... which is one quality I love to hear in a female vocalist.
Are you sure? Maybe Pink, but Sia... ☺
I feellike she put way more emotion in this song then Beyonce did...which I guess makes sense since she wrote it.
i love it
+Rogenia Ngwayah (Rococopuff_5sosfam) Beyonce's version is prettier but this version has more emotion without a doubt
I wouldn’t say Beyoncé’s version lacks emotion; rather that her emotions are different because she is at a different point in the relationship than BC Jean sang from in the original. I see and hear a tired, frustrated BEYOND tears and anger, resigned form of acceptance in Beyoncé’s version. By acceptance, I do NOT mean to imply that it’s okay to treat anyone that way OR that the woman is letting things continue as if the relationship were healthy. Having been through this scenario myself, I can easily imagine this song sung from several different viewpoints all held by the same woman, just at different points in time. In my own experience with this kind of pain,, I did eventually accept that I couldn’t change him, and from that point on, I made decisions for myself that were no longer based on the future I once hoped for with him. On on the way to that resigned acceptance, you can bet I felt everything in BC Jean’s version, too ... and now I am somewhere else entirely and feeling strong and much more myself than I ever felt when I was still with the cad.
Of course, I might simply be reading into this because I have unfortunately been there. ;-)
Rogenia Ngwayah yea
Nope sweet heart I wrote that song I heard it in my dream but this bastard by the name of ash Amin was recording me in my car and sold it as his own
Wow, I'd love to hear Pink tear into this one.
+Dianna Marie Wow, me too!
+Dianna Marie That probably would say amazing!!!!
me too😅😍
pink would ruin this song B C JEAN DOES IT THE BEST
@@harveybrooks1580 It is impossible for P!nk to ruin any song. It is ridiculous
I too didn't know this was the original version. Man this one really strikes straight into your heart
the honesty in her voice gives me goosebumps.. love it . .
Beyonce's sounds refined and kind on the ears...
2:12 That is hurt right there, she really feels the lyrics as she sings them! I love it, real music real feels.
Love this song! And this powerful version! Fantastic Job! 🤩
I had the honor of playing guitar for BC at a festival on Kauai some years ago and what a powerhouse artist she is! Loved every minute of it and had a great time hearing her stories around the song. Had to come back for another listen!
did she bad mouth beyonce?
@@JhonatanZati not at all, she was very grateful and respectful.
@@JhonatanZati technically someone else stole the song and gave it to beyonce but they did slap beyonce's name on it. I bet the financial settlement stipulated no backchat
just learned that BC Jean's was the original. so much better! i love this song now!
This song could have been a hit from her nowadays in the internet age. Don't need a label behind you now.
I love BC Jean´s original version it has SOUL.
I just discovered this artist today! FML I did not know this is the original and she sounds so amazing......what a shame the label didn't push this as it's better than the cover. Real rasp and grit, loved it!!!
Listen to Angelina Jordan performance.
Emotional and jazzy.
I think DC would be proud of this performance.
th-cam.com/video/eJr-BfUQ2jE/w-d-xo.htmlsi=oYbBNTtQ1cWFdUja
This is sublime. This is the voice and tempo and atmosphere that matches the words and melody.
Way more sincere. Much better.
I hope she got paid some major cash for this.
I was thinking the same
She probably gets tonnes of recurring royalty checks.
She is in a gaining popular band with her husband called Alexander Jean! Check them out!:)
@@wearetheiam4720 this is original
Of course not. Beyonce is a greedy son of a bitch.
So much passion! I’m so grateful I found this original version.
i actually understand the lyrics a lot more because of this version
Not Carlie yea..beyonce yells
R. Todd Beyonce doesnt yell she sings with support. Yelling is straining and beyonce isnt straining
Yea, KP in Firework is yelling, Beyonce has power for sure
But some of them are different.
Its not a version its the Original!
Her raw vocals and the original lyrics are so powerful. I relate a little better to the original but I like both.
This is the original version Beyoncé's is a cover
I know. That's the point.
Man-D Sakizzie there's 3 versions, Reba Beyoncé and her
OMG, what an energy. The best version. ❤
I like this version better. Her voice is raspy it fits perfectly. Honestly she should have kept the song.
But her record label rejected it so...
+Jazzy Le so they proved again human stupidity is infinity
SapereAude exactly
I don't get it just cause Beyoncé is more famous than her doesn't earn it should get rejected
+Jazzy Le That is the sad thing about the music industry. Some people still try to get their music out but the big labels still control a lot.
Yeah, like neyo is basically her ghost song writer since he's wrote most of her songs and she takes credit for it lol
I'm obsessed with her unique voice.
This is great...
Great lyrics...
..
Angelina Jordan brought me here...
Glad I know the history of the song ..
Angelina is smooth...THIS IS SO GRITTY❤❤❤❤
Angelina Jordan's 2024 version with co-writer of the song Toby Gad brought me here. Well done to BC Jean & Toby for writing this hit song. Compared to Beyonce's version, it's interesting to see the raw emotional aspects of the song so evident here, of course with Angelina's vocals they're taken to a whole other level.
Hello fellow Angel. Toby's story about BC and the 🍕 brought me here too. Curious. Agree, BCs original is very emotional, her break up feelings fresh. How 18 year old Angelina Jordan pars or exceeds the emotional impact with her rendition stays a miracle... like she did the last 10 years.
I love this version
You rock... BC Jean.....
I really like this A LOT more then Beyonce's COVER.
BC sings it with more feeling and hurt in her voice.
Beautiful song.🤘🤘
BC Jean's version is more raw, Beyoncé's version is more..I don't really know how to explain it. More pop, I guess? Both versions are great and both voices are completely different, so no need to compare. Just saying that you like one version better is good enough.
Yeah but this is the original and she wrote the song, so maybe she has the experience she sings about and that makes is so much more real.....
I like both of them singing it but respect to her for writing it :) They give such different feelings!!!
But I'm tired of everyone here bashing Beyonce. She is talented in her own right and so is this girl. They're differently talented. Please stop with the negative comments. :(
I agree with you. You are so right. Why do people/half of society have to be so mean to BC and Beyonce. They are both talented. And the people are just jealous fools who want attention.
Correction: Why do people have to be mean to BC and Beyonce!?
Beyonce acquired the song the wrong way.
Beyonce is like Led Zeppelin. taking everything she wants, sometimes not paying, sometimes giving few dollars for a song. I bet Beyonce cannot write any melodies. She probably had 9 people working on the album artwork of her self-titled album because it is so hard to put pink "Beyonce" on a black bottom. Her father is rich. I get it. She gets lots of grammy awards and so does her husband Jay-Z. Beyonce's father gave her lots of golden spoon inside her mouth.
girl she makes her harmonies. that is why she is credited in most of her songs. And woah! Youre a closeted fan boo, with all that insider information yoy just spewed. LMAO.
Your vocals are true perfection. You deserve full credit for this song because the raspiness in your voice matches the song perfectly. With the emotion you give off in this song is beautiful. You darling are True Perfection.
Wow! Brilliant! The originals are always best. Never liked Beyoncé versions tbh but i've heard Reba sing this too and blows it out of the park!!
If you think this is better than the Beyonce cover , not only do you need a hearing test but your out your mind .
@@tomwhite4736 Nope. I can hear perfect. An opinion I'm entitled to have. You don't like my opinion then that's fine. Your also welcome to yours.
@@SeanEvans2 Omg can't you hear the weakness in the voice of bc jean , I've heard several covers which are far better . you're either deaf or have no love for Beyonce .? Jean and gad imo did a great job in producing the Beyonce cover .
I agree with the poster just below you " lost monster " bc jean needs vocal training .
Listen to Angelina Jordan performance.
For me it is the best. Emotional and jazzy.
Greetings from Detroit.
Now I am a fan. I love your original version and thank you for the raw grit that it deserves.
I love you BC Jean - I was screwed over by the record industry too, in a different way - I always tell people your story and share this recording of YOUR song with them, the one true, deeply-felt, awesome, and authentic ORIGINAL version. As a songwriter, having a track taken away and given to an established star and done in a different style is my idea of SOUL AGONY and I just hope that in the quantum mechanics of artistry that this injustice makes BC come back stronger with more great songs. x
I love this girl's voice. She doesn't sound like the random American teenager singing with the same childish soprano voice. Finally, a different voice. This song always sounded rock to me, now I understand the orginal version was supposed to be more alternative rock, actually, and less rythm and blues.
***** beyonce'version is better and no cover!
Mouhamed Diallo
that's a matter of personal taste. You might like Beyonce's version better but we like this one more because it has more soul and I personally enjoy rock a lot.
Mouhamed Diallo this IS the original version of this song, this girl BC Jean wrote it and sang it before Beyoncé, before you post you need to check facts,or else you may come off as a liar. NO I'm not calling you a liar, I'm just making sure that you understand that you are mistaken, Beyoncé's version is ,in fact, a cover of THIS girl's song.
Omar Khodr
BC Jean didn't fully write this. Yes it was her idea but the mans voice you hear on this mainly wrote it and he also gave Beyoncé's dad permission to use it. Just BC Jean didn't know as she wanted to use it on her album... She said she was out eating one day and was offered pizza but refused it because she was on a diet. She then thought if I were a boy I'd eat it and not give a shit then she went on about all the things she would do different if she were a boy. Then the fella with her got a pen and wrote all this down and made it into a song and took her into the studio. Yes she did do it but not on her own he helped a lot. And B never stole it it's just BC Jean wasn't told
And now just put it into perspective of times when Heart, Tina etc have been big. These goose bumps when the rock part kicks in. Here like in alone like what ever… nice!
her voice can make me cry. so beautiful
this original is so soul felt and is so emotion felt. love this original alot better!!!!!!
Beyonce did sing the hell out of this song, so i was interested to hear and compare the original. every time i heard this on the radio i would think to myself, this doesn't sound like something she would sing, but, whatever. now i know why. but this girl.... she has a funky Pink vibe to her. we need more singers like that because right now everyone is so autotuned and robotic. i hope this chick made some royalties off of this at least.
PLUM THUM the singer here actually wrote the song 🎤
She is doing well on the royalties...
I can't believe producers dropped this and told her it wouldn't do well.
WHOA !! That's deep Way better than beyonce !! She's feeling it all into the song !!
Why would her record label reject the song? I call bullshit. They probably just wanted to sell it to Beyonce. Cuz u can tell this is a hit.
Either way Beyonce did it better lol. Like always
Connor Jerry not really Beyoncé's voice is amazing, she gets the praise she deserves
this chick is good but not better than beyonce
Connor Jerry exactly Beyonce is way better thanks for finally understanding
Connor Jerry yes you are
You know it's a sign of a small mind to start attacking someone over nothing
Don't get mad at me for spreading the truth, get mad at yourself for having an inferior intellect
Connor Jerry I love when people with limited vocabularies get owned by people with larger vocabularies because then the only thing they can think to say is "wow do you even know what you're saying?" It's like in their mind they think, "i no no big words dat mean dis person don't eider" lmao
Sorry you didn't read enough when you were younger to broaden your mind
Cause if you did that you would realize that Beyoncé has the technically better voice
Bye Felicia
Yoooooo.😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍 she’s everything.. I’m about 15 years late but I’m obsessed with her voice
Watchmojo brought me here, I much prefer this to beyonce, the vocals are so raw
Jaz It feels so much more real.
Sameeee
Its more strained
I just discovered this version and I love it so much ❤
I also love her duo with Mark Ballas 😊
This "version" is the original:D
3 words. This. Is. Amazing.
She put her heart and soul into that song
What a voice. Quite unique and raspy. It really fits. Though I can see why Beyonce's cover was more successful. Her version is smoother and flows better. This one here is a bit more edgy. I listen to all kind of music from jazz to rock, from metal to classic, from pop to progressive. Not everybody likes to listen to this "edginess", especially on the radio. Though credit where credit is due. This is still an awesome version and without the original and the writers there can not be a cover :P
I'm so happy I found the original - I adore this song - I don't think we should slam Beyonce' - her version is powerful and great in her own way but this IS the original and a lot more personal and rough witch I like more - I like both - but this is Jean's song - Thank you so much BC Jean - we know who the credit goes to :)
"Wait, Beyonce didn't write this song?" "Beyonce write a song? Hahaha😂😂😂😂"
@truthteller truth hurts but Whitney Houston never took credit for the song and always acknowledged and gave credit where it was due.
There's something so much more meaningful listening to a song being sung by its writer... You can feel the story in her voice.
This is awesome. It's the original writer and singer of this song. So it's cool to like Beyoncé and her music, just know that she didn't write this song. Personally I feel if you didn't write your own shit then you're only a singer. The woman in this video is an artist.
🙌🏽 true
I write songs but can't sing at all, I wish I could. :(
but she does both. sometimes she writes, sometimes she pays people to write, and sometimes she buys whats already written, so what is she?
Helen leona please don't make me go there. If you like Beyoncé, more power to you. We're in the Information Age, we all know what she is. And if you don't, inform yourself. If you continue to listen to her, and she makes you all warm and fuzzy, again it's a free country for now.
+420 420 lol, we do live in the information age. and everything I said is very accurate. the woman has 10 awards for songwriting alone. and she got most of them while she was still really young. some even made history. she was the first black woman and second woman ever to win an ASCAP songwriting award...14 years ago.. Google if u like
So... I often catch myself singing the chorus of this in my head. Then I get annoyed because I am not a fan of the other person who sang this. I will be singing this version in my head from now in and enjoying every minute of it. Thank you for this song, I love it and the way you sing it!!!
I'm a man and her emotions put into this performance make me cry.
her voice is beautiful and the song is filled with emotion love it
This girls voice is amazing
OMG! This is so much better than Beyonce version. I can't wait to learn how to play this song on Bass Guitar. I love BC Jean and her beautiful voice who perfectly fit's this song.
Stunning
I'm so happy for finding this!!!
just found out that this is the original version in 2019 ....😢
Same here
And I'm here in 2020 because of a video about originals and their covers...
@@Cassely94 same here
2020 😭
I love that raspy, raw voice!!!
This is one of best songs of all time. It is shame that Beyonce takes all credit. This original version us much better. Raw emotions, unique vocals, she is hot!!!. BIG LIKE FROM ME!!!
Why are u mad at Beyoncé got getting credit when she sold it to Beyoncé. How about you give credit to Beyoncé for even liking the original song and decided to cover it and change certain words to fit her musically. Like y’all be so negative.
Uhh BC is on the credits
But I do wonder why she gave it to Beyonce tho
@@queefisafunnyword She didn't. BC label rejected it for.her and sold it to Beyonce without her permission or consent. She is credited as a writer however the dispute was over the fact that Beyonce had credits. And was getting a huge amount of royalty points. You listen to the song it's clear Beyonce changed a few words but contributed nothing to the actual creative process. However Beyonce was getting a higher percentage then both she and Colby combined. So she threatened to sue if this was not adjusted. Beyonce team didn't want the trouble so they settled with her. All was well until Beyonce continued to claim she wrote it which created some bad blood. But she had the last laugh when someone leaked the original. Proving that Beyonce was out right lying. That's when Beyonce changed her story and pretty much said she had no idea of the issues behind the song....then why did you claim to write it? And even have an origin story? Idc that she didn't write it I didn't like that she lied. This is when the songwriting issues began to come to light.
@@MsTrueTy that’s literally not what happened and that was debunked by BC herself. Do y’all just make up scenarios in your head and run with it? BC said she wrote the song and kept it for herself but when her label rejected the song BC BEGAN TO OFFER THE SONG. Beyoncé heard her demo and wanted it so after calling her and BC deciding that it would be better exposure to have Beyoncé sing it, she gave the song to Beyoncé. I implore you to use google. It’s free.
I’m not crying you’re crying! Man this hit way harder
The little shake she does building up to the chorus has got to be the most adorable thing ever!
Her voice is something! I like it! It's like Cyndi Lauper x Pink
Im kinda dissapointed in Beyoncé tbh.....
This poor girl put her heart and soul into this piece of art and then B just comes along and makes it her own 😪🙁. This girl sings it so much better(probs cuz it's hers) and it just feels so *RAW*
Beyoncé bought the song from BC and gave her the writing credits. Beyoncé only credited herself for the production. So don’t speak if you don’t know anything. And as for the vocals, maybe YOU think BC sings better, but objectively that is not true. Beyoncé has much better technique and a much stronger voice.
@@hannahlove8949 What about her every other song?
@@urim_l. She writes or co-writes almost all of her songs. So whats your point?
@@hannahlove8949 Actually BC was only informed about Beyonce releasing her song after the single was due to be released. She wasn't even informed that her song had been sold. The co-writer went behind her back and sold it to Beyonce. Only after it came to light did BC and Beyonce reach a deal about the writing credits etc... BC Jean never intended to sell this song. That's why people are a bit salty about it.
damnnn she killed this song!! omg i loveee it...i will definately put this in my ipod!! :) i love beyonce but i think beyonce get too loud as if she tries to hard in her songs
This is this girls song
@Penderyn Lewsyn y'all had no business responding to a 12 year old comment 😂
@@guinnmyahslaysstaymad why not?
I saw Alexander Jean last night.. they went on before Lindsey Stirling... I was absolutely BLOWN away. BC Jean has an INCREDIBLE voice. What a beautiful soul
When I heard this song for the first time today ... it was the first really big emotion of the year 2019 for me. A crazy start to the new year.
I like this version better than Beyonces! This girls voice fits the song well!
This is the original.
Soulful Ginger thats because Beyance and her father stole it
keli james she dose sound great i almost cried listening to her
camryn lloyd it's the original
+camryn lloyd i agree completely. BC Jean's version is WAY better than Beyonce's version.
It sucks her label rejected this.....Beyonce made so much from this song
She still got quite a bit of that money though
Good thing. She would’ve gotten embarrassed. The world ain’t bias like y’all let’s be real this sounded horrible.
@@firethoughts5193 True lmao. They act like this would've been a hit with her singing like this.
Bey gets the money as a producer and singer. This one gets the money as a writer
@@willlima8524 y’all obviously have no taste or sense of musicality. Just like her record label
You can really hear the emotion in her voice! Love this version much better than the cover
I talked to BC and her parents and asked them flat out what the story was. On Beyonce's album, this is the only song that has BC 100% credit for writing this song. This has so much soul and passion. Love this version
Loooove this version so much more!! So much raw emotion! Wish BC Jean could have released it instead
wow so much better... it's real, it's full of emotions, it's raw, it's very good.
I do think that Beyonce version of this song SHOULD SAY "COVER." not saying cover is rude
Plenty of people sing songs other people wrote and sang the original for. But because its beyonce she needs to call it a cover. Y'all be reaching
WhiteEmerald1991 not really because the record label dropped her before she released it meaning the label had all rights to it and Beyoncè bought the song
She bought it. It's Beyonce's now.
Yeah.... But like in Nashville... There's a writer's culture so people almost always say the name of a writer when the perform in smaller arenas or other performances... Just not always big awards shows. But it's a thing there... Like manners to give props to song writers. I thought it was weird when I first moved there... Like who cares???? Ohhhhhhh because a good song is GOLD and someone let you wear their good!!!! Yup.
You don’t know how many songs aren’t written by the people who sing then do you?
This is normal practice in the music industry. Some artists wrote songs and for various reasons give/ sell them to other artists.
Holy shit this is so much better then yonce
carly rohling no
how? she actually goes off key at the end of the chorus...
+Connor Jerry u people just hate Beyonce... coz this girls couldn't even sing the first chorus without going off key.. just because somebody writes a song doesn't mean their version of it is the best...let's just be honest.. this girl has almost zero vocal ability. any good vocalist will notice that she is telling on the texture of her voice and being emotional to further her performance. she has horrible breathe control and I rely tiny range. she is struggling so much vocally and anybody who really knows vocals can hear that. I'm telling u all this because I'm an artist too. singer and songwriter. I'm mature enough to understand that not everything I write is best sang by me. that would be a huge lie
Connor Jerry lol, thats the worst excuse for bad singing i ever heard. im pretty sure she herself noticed that she made a mistake too.. the backup singer also followed her in hopes of covering it but but it didnt work. u could still hear it. well, if u understand how music works. see instruments play the music in a certain key, and the singer is supposed to sing in accordance with that key in order for it to be music.. if not then its just noise. music is all about organizing sound. and thats the aim of every musician. thats why she doesnt make the same mistake the second time the chorus came around. coz she knows too that that aint how its supposed to sound. whether its her song or not, the rules of music are what they are. ur argument is something that only somebody with no real knowledge of music would say ... going off key has nothing to do with who wrote what...going off key is what helps distinguish a good singer and a bad one... if u dont understand what going off key is, ill make it easier for u. it means ur voice is not in sync with the music...
Connor Jerry You're* who's dumb now?
Never been a fan of the "hit" version. Those munchkin sustained vibratos crack me up when she sings BOY! BCJ is amazing
OMG ! ❤️ the two popular renditions, BUT the emotion in the chorus can only come from writing from current pain. Playlist: ADDED !!!!!
No one can beat this original
Beyoncé did
I actually like this version better than the Beyonce version; probably because of the rawness in her voice.
Toby Gad Co wrote this song with her it didn't fare well in the label and Beyonce asked for it Now 15 years later Toby Gad is re releasing this with the artist Angelina Jordan This was beautiful as the original and Angelina Jordan the 18 year old phenomenal singer and songwriter sings this better than Beyonce and if you don't agree first take a listen and get back to me
I like this version
Yeah erm wow. Never knew this was the original and I’m very happy to have heard it coz it’s iconic just like this!!!!
Isn't it is nice to hear the rawness from someone who actually wrote the song? Instead of the plain interpretation of the original like a school kid giving a synopsis of a book they read.
The song makes much more sense now. I feel her.
she has an astounding voice
This is way better than the Beyonce cover. I listen to metal and hardy ever this type of music but the emotions in her voice really show that sometimes when you hear a song it's more than worth the effort to seek out the original.
It took me a while to like this song but after hearing the original and Reba versions, I can see thr genius of it.
I personally like both versions, I think this one is more.... naked and raw. But they're both really good. Rachel Crow does a really amazing version of it too.
I definitely prefer this version. In my opinion this song always sounded too alternative for Beyonce. This girls voice is so distinctive, beautifully raw and sincere.
The RIGHTFUL owner!!
if u look at the i am sasha firece booklet u will know she got all credit and a check
I have the platinum version but not the original release which was a 2-CD. I believe they added her later.
@marquis actually she claimed she Co wrote it before this girl went after her for rights. Beyonce didn't want to be sued so she credited her and made a settlement to make the attention go away.
Beyonce has always claimed she has co-written every song she has ever recorded. Most of Beyonce's songs has 4 or more writers. She has the whole arsenal of writers, producers and so on. I bet even her self-titled album artwork was planned by nine people - a rip off from AC/DC Back in Black - but AC/DC won't sue Beyonce because it would be ridiculous to claim own the right for black background and basic font.
Lucky to found this, better version of the song. Much more emotional.
Well written. Great style as well. Amazing talent you got there Ms Carlson. I hope you got what you truly deserve from writing this amazing song. Pls keep on writing and singing..
Another fan here from the 💕
Much love and power..😍