When Johnny Cash played this for his daughter she said “It sounds like you’re saying goodbye”, and he told her “I am”. Such a beautiful, heartbreaking song.
He intentionally waited until his health was declining to record this. After the pneumonia that started his decline the amount of time he could sing was greatly curtailed. He waited until singing hurt would put a strain on him to convey it was the end to everyone who heard it. If you listen to other songs first you can hear him strain and struggle to make it through this.
Johnny Cash's father, in a drunken state, once told him that he wished Johnny had died instead of his brother Jack. That was probably one of the reasons he was so messed up for a large part of his life.
"Johnny Cash's father, in a drunken state, once told him that he wished Johnny had died instead of his brother Jack. That was probably one of the reasons he was so messed up for a large part of his life." Oh, you think?
@@AllenC1x "you know, you could've just said those three words without the whole quote bruh" I could have, but I chose not to because something could happen to that comment at anytime, for example, it could be edited or deleted (second option won't really matter in this case, since the whole section will get deleted along with it), so quoting the comment is my way of preserving it so that it doesn't get lost to time.
This song was made and written by Nine Inch Nails. The leader singer made this song about a middle aged mans life spiraling out of control and losing the ones around him due to death and drugs/ overdoses'. Johnny Cash took the song changed one word and made it about and old man looking back on his life losing those around him due to age and what year to year can do to a friendship. Nine Inch Nails lead singer wasn't happy about this because the song was soooo personal to him. Once he heard the song he said, "this is now cash's song". Cash is the ONLY person in the Country Hall of Fame, Rock N' Roll Hall of Fame, AND the Songwriters Hallo of Fame. You could literally write a Harry Potter 10 book story about this man's life and still have chapters left out... During this song his wife passed away. His daughter told him that this song sounds like he is saying goodbye... Johnny replied, "I am saying goodbye; I miss my June (wife June Carter)". Johnny passed away like 4 months after releasing this song.... RIP Legend.
Neither Johnny Cash nor Trent Reznor were keen to the idea, before recording it. Rick Rubin (who produced the album this cover is on) brought the idea to both of them. Cash was more receptive, taking less time/convincing (of course, since recording comes prior to hearing final product)
The interview with Trent Reznor (lead singer of Nine Inch Nails) was really interesting. He was against remaking it because he just didn't think it would work. But when he heard the final cut he equated it a girlfriend being happier with another man. He just had to let go. The song was Cash's now.
The fact that he continues to touch people, young, old, white, black, Christian, atheist, male or female, is a testament to the man as a Legend. ❤ I love that you all appreciate this.
Johnny was 74, but was in constant pain from illness for the last 10 years of his life, thats why he looked so old. This song is a Nine Inch Nails song written by Trent Reznor, the lead singer. When he wrote it, he didn't know that it would end up being prophetic of his own life. He wasn't a junkie when he wrote and recorded it, but within 2 years he was. Johnny recorded this song about 2 years after Reznor got out of rehab. It was produced by a friend of Reznor"s. He was flattered that Johnny wanted to do it, but he felt weird about it when he heard the recording, becuase it was someone else singing about something that was so personal to him. A few weeks later he saw the music video ( a video that won numerous awards BTW) and said that he finally understood, and that the song was no longer his. Also in the video was his wife June Cater Cash, standing on the steps behind him. She died very very soon after the video was made, and Johnny followed 4 months later.
He is a legendary performer but there's no way he can be considered one of the greatest musicians of all time. He was basically a 3-chord guitar strummer with a cool voice, a ton of charisma, a lot of attitude and a fabulous life story. But one of the greatest musicians of all time? Even he would laugh at that idea.
@Code 9 I absolutely love Johnny Cash and is one of my fav musicians but I 100% agree with you. He is no where close to the greatest but he is still made some damn good music
@@Code9 music isnt all about who is the best singer, or the best at playing. Its about the music, the charisma, the voice. You dont need to be the best at playing or singing, to be one considered of the best. He wasnt the most talented, but was damn well one of the best to ever do it.
FACT: This video was made 7 months before Johnny Cash died. After his wife of 35 years died (June Cash), Johnny said he had nothing to live for except music after his wife died. You can feel it in this song. A once powerful man reduced to a shadow of himself waiting for death. This song was Johnny making his peace with the end.
This is a cover of a Nine Inch Nails song. Trent Reznor had no idea Johnny Cash had done a rendition of his song, the first time he heard it was while he was watching television and it brought him to uncontrollable sobbing. He said it felt like someone took his song and did a better job than he ever could with it.
And it’s not like June was just some random lady who he met and married. June Carter…Carter Family = “the first family of country music”. Their version of “were you there” (the hymn) is the most incredible and eerie and beautiful version of it I’ve ever heard.
This rendition brings me to tears. Every. Time. When his wife June passed away he was devastated..4 months later he was gone; God Bless him. He will always be a part of the soundtrack of my life. Always.
One of the worst things about getting old is that you lose your friends to accidents, disease and other things. You get older and really regret some discissions you made and things you have said. Its really hard on you as you realize your in the last chapter of life. Being lonely, becoming disabled and have a really hard time doing stuff. I guess thats one of the reasons I enjoy these reaction videos as it reminds me of my days of glory and to see a young generation seeing what our lives and culture was like in the past makes you proud you were a part of it. Thanks guys!
Who says our young people are shallow and unaware of what's important in life. These young men will restore your faith our future will be prosperous! Cruzer In CT
this song is a testimony, even though it is a re-recording it shows the true feelings of a man who faced a difficult life regardless of the situation, johnny was a man who went through a lot and still did not abandon his beliefs and himself, he is a example of life
what about crying? it's an inherent characteristic of human beings, of caring about life.. whoever has the courage to laugh in happy moments and cry in sad moments is truly a hero.. "this world is a school" best way, all respect to him, and if you shed tears at that moment it's because you understand that, it's not a synonym of weakness but of emotional maturity
Same. I see it as a very egoic thing. It isn't about me. I can cry in private thinking, listening or seeing something. But I don't cry around people. That's something I overcome. In place of tears, I show composure.
The end of this video shows a definite finality to his career and eventually his life. The way he closed the lid to the piano and then ran his hands along the lid was his good-bye to music and the world. RIP Mr Cash... goat
This song (both versions) astonished me. How the same lyrics can have vastly different messages. Kudos to Trent. He wrote a song that made a legend notice it.
It was so absolutely perfect when Reznor made it that I got my panties in a bunch when Cash came in. Now I've learned to accept Cash's version too, and even love it. But it took a while. I credit both artists absolutely fully.
When his eldest daughter heard him sing this song she said "It sounds like you're saying goodbye" and Johnny Cash said "I am". He died less then a year later.
That is because he done this song shortly after his wife passed away. He passed shortly after his wife. Can't remember how long exactly after she passed.
Johnny Cash was iconic as a country singer, not acting. He is one of the most important artists in music history. Much of his music contained themes of sorrow, moral tribulation, and redemption, and also included gospel . His wife June Carter Cash was a five-time Grammy award-winner, and was a member of the famous gospel-singing Carter family. Johnny Cash's music genre spanned across country, rock and roll, rockabilly, blues, folk, and gospel. His crossover appeal earned him the rare honor of being inducted into the Country Music, Rock and Roll, and Gospel Music Halls of Fame. There's so much on Johnny Cash. This doesn't even scratch the surface. I've never been a big C&W music fan, but my generation grew up with Johnny Cash one way or another. He was a household name and was bigger than life. Thanks for this reaction guys! ✌💙✌
He's also in the Rockabilly, Memphis Music, and Nashville Song Writer's halls of fame. He's received the Kennedy Center honors, National Medal of Arts, along with CMA, VMA, Grammy's, and many other awards. All well deserved.
It's that moment when Cash is pouring the wine out from the glass, combined with the lyrics and him looking at the camera that gets me every time. "You want fame and fortune, huh? Here, take it. See me now? See all the good it's done me? Here, take it! TAKE IT!"
I love this song. Trent Reznor wrote a beautiful song but Johnny made it epic! After watching Walk The Line, I just wept for the life he lived. He was truly an artist. May he rest in peace.
The change in your faces once he started singing was so noticeable. And I think that is the power that Johnny Cash always possessed, but he didn't realize the gravity of it until old age.
The part when he says "You could have it all. My empire of dirt." brings me to tears every time. They show his awards, his records, all of his achievements and accomplishments, he sits at a table in a throne with a feast in front of him, representing all of the things he accomplished in his life, the wealth he accumulated, and he's literally saying, mostly to his late wife, that he would give it all up if he could just have more time with her. He struggled heavily with alchohol addiction throughout his life, so it hits even harder as you see his trembling hand pour the wine out across the table. He's acknowledging all the people he hurt in his life, the way his alchoholism destroyed his life and the lives of everyone around him, and in the end he says "If I could start again, a million miles away. I would keep myself, I would find a way." Everything he's done, all the art he's made, all the awards, the movies, the records, the fame, the fortune, it's all dirt. It's meaningless. He would give it all away if he could just do it all over again, but he can't.
Cool story IF HE WROTE THIS SONG. Werid wonder why a COVER turns out to be all this epic retelling his life. Why couldn’t he just write his own song waxing lyrical about the 💩his life was. He had a hard life but was a damn superstar legend. I had a HARDER life then him, all I get is JUDGEMENTS from most people….but hey his life was sooooooo hard, poor him….boo hooo…..all that money praise and all else….. Why does everyone act like his life was destroyed cuz of it? How? His wife was with him to the end, his kids etc…. PLEASE give me his hard life….😂🤣🤧
@@franjamison77 Yea but the original writer and singer said it was his song now . And the fact it was a super personal song says even more . Don't think he sang the song since
He made you have a conversation. That in and of itself is how powerful he was as a entertainer. Johnny took his rendition of this song and made it about his life. Not many can do something so powerful. You guys are a treasure. Thank you for objectively listening to music and offering your honest feelings about it. It’s refreshing
There will never be anyone compared to 'The Man in Black,' Mr Cash. He lived a life like no other. My Dad, who I lost 13 years ago, was a great fan of Johnny, so I grew up listening to him. My Dad was not a musician, but he was rugged, lived through a horrific childhood, survived the Korean War, and was my hero. Johnny's songs bring back so many great memories, and at the same time, sooths my soul. I'm so happy you chose to listen to him!
This song was originally written by and performed by Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails it was biographical and dealt with his struggles-namely drug addiction. But it is so relatable and could be applied to anyone who struggles with a life of regret. Johnny did a cover of it. This was his last release before he passed away. He was a Christian and he performed the song exactly as written except one verse. He changed it from "crown of s***" to "crown of thorns". P. S. As Christians we believe we will be united with our loved ones after death so we would not want to live forever in this life but forever in the life to come, absolutely!
Trent wasn't an addict when he wrote it actually. it was a prophetic song, rather than biographical, because with 2 years after writing it, he was an addict.
After Trent heard Johnny's cover. He officially said the song belongs to Johnny now. That it was no longer a cover of his song and that if he (Trent) were to perform it, that, would be the cover.
Was never a Cash fan but the passion he put into this song was amazing. I felt his life, his pains, i felt him slipping away. He truly made this his song and Trent Reznor, who wrote it, gave it to him with grace
After Trent Reznor (nine inch nails) heard Cash's rendition of his song, he remarked, "that's not my song any more." It fits Cash in that he struggled endlessly with heroin addiction, and his wife June stood by him through all of it.
This was his goodbye. Johnny Cash is a member of the Country Music Hall of Fame, Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Gospel Music Hall of Fame. His wife passed shortly after recording this and he passed away about 6 months later. To know more about him, check out his song, The Man in Black
The Nine Inch Nails song was done in the 90's and is totally different. When Trent Reznor, who is NIN lead singer and writer of the song, heard Johnny's version he said it's Cash's song now. He embodied the lyrics in a completely different way. Great interview about how Rick Rubin had Johnny perform many other modern artists. I recommend Johnny's version of Personal Jesus originally written & performed by Depeche Mode. Thanks for all your videos.
I cannot listen to it without bawling my eyes out, I love Cash! If you can tell the story and us and make people feel it. That's an artist to make someone else feel your pain or someone can relate to it. He's a great storyteller and a loving caring man. He was a sinner his whole life like as we are. And of course in the end he became closer to god. It's a beautiful thing
"Walk the the Line" was one his signature songs as well as title for biography movie. Movie had Reese Weatherspoon & Joaquin Phoenix in it. Definitely worth checking both out
Was ONLY into hip-hop when the movie came out and saw it with a fam member in theater. That movie was such a success, it's what started the "High Budget Biopic" trend in the past decade or so... Before that, Biopics were made for TV movies but that movie basically created a new genre for the box office (IMO) It was so popular they made that comedy parody "Walk Hard" with John C Reilly.
I love seeing how Johnny Cash affects people. He crosses genre's, age groups and will forever live on! The Stephanie wasn't his last song though he recorded 72 songs after his wife passed away before his own death. Thanks for this video!
I am 40 years old. I watched 100s of reactors watch this video and everytime I watch because this song is amazing. This song makes me cry everytime. I cried this time aswell. Life relections and reflections on regret is this song wrapped in a bow. Trent really did an amazing job writing this song and Johnny killed singing it. Both different versions are amazing.
Johnny Cash had a distinct sound. He was one of the first country music artists that broke many barriers. He performed with Ray Charles, unheard of at the time. His life was on a downward spiral until he met June Carter. She was the love of his life. He had so many hits over the course of his life. He was a legend.
This video hits like a punch to the gut. It hits even harder when you know the man's music and life story. I love what you guys do. Seeing young men of today being moved emotionally by the music of my youth is a great pleasure. You bring a lot of good sense to the table. All the best to you.
Makes me cry every time. I’m half way there. Just a handful of folks left. Thanks for sharing you lives with us. Strong, handsome, intelligent young men. Makes me happy to see you every time. I’m pulling for your success and pray for you often.
Cash took this song and transformed it into a song of regret... he was strong enough to say "I am not who you thought I was" he is singing his own dispair.
Not sure anyone will read because I’m late but… THIS SONG IS INCREDIBLE!! The way he presents the internal struggle of having it all at one point in time and reflecting about how he would give it ALL away to never lose himself. Lots of people have made songs about this but Johnny’s hits different because of how old he was when he performed it. He ACTUALLY had the ability to reflect and really felt deep in a hole because he knows IF he could go back and “keep myself” he would find a way. But the hard truth is he cannot, you cannot, I cannot, NOBODY can. So it’s best we take advantage of life and the opportunity God has given us before it’s too late and all we have is ourselves and our regrets!
Johnny Cash ‘The Man In Black’ is one of the most gifted and celebrated country music artists of all time. He and the legendary Glen Campbell are my personal absolute favorite country music artists. … Johnny Cash’s wife, June Carter, wrote a love song for/about him called Ring of Fire 🔥 and Johnny Cash sang it. It is widely considered one of the greatest country songs ever. … it’s worth a listen. 📻🎶🎵🖤
They would really like that one, too. Totally agree! Have been subscribed to this group of excellent young men for just a few months, but have watched dozens of past reactions that they've done & they simply comprise one of the best reaction sources on TH-cam - which says a lot, because the entire "reaction" concept has ballooned over the past 3+ years & spawned hundreds of channels. I rank these gentlemen somewhere in my Top 5, & I estimate that I've checked out, AT LEAST, 150 reactors over the last couple of years. And so being in my Top 5 amongst 150+, who I gave a sincere effort to like, says it all. Appreciate you guys! I'm 65, an Army vet, an amputee (entire right leg) - amongst other serious health conditions - and you are a part of almost each day that I live. Bless you guys & keep kicking ass. ✌&❤4🌏
This song is about regret. Johnny Cash was one of the "wild men" in country music. He wore black for those who were in prison. So many of his early songs were great "Walk the Line", "Ring of Fire. I love his video (later one) "God's gonna cut you down". Keep up the great work! You guys do a great job!
Ya'll make me proud as retired educator. I love watching your reactions and your interactions with each other as topics are discussed and debated. It has given me a great deal of pleasure to witness the broadening of genres that are being investigated. The greatest joy, is the maturation of each one of you, as you try to put everything into context; in terms of history, styles and influences. School is not about grades or degrees, it is about about developing a lifetime of curiosity and the ability to keep learning throughout life. Keep up the great work!
Johnny's life started off very tragic and ended tragic. I highly suggest truly digging into this man's life. You could spend years still uncovering even more aspects of his life. Even his friendship with Elvis (which is how he stumbled across drugs himself and had a huge battle beating that addiction). You can't hear this song and not hear the pain and cry for him.
Johnny was THE MAN. Not afraid to try different musical styles. He had a bad problem with drinking and pills, his 2nd wife June Carter and her family helped him get clean and gk on for many more decades sober. Listen to his beautuful duet "I Miss Someone" with his daughter Roseanne Cash...fantastic.
I'll never forget the first time I heard this song. The t.v. was on in another room while I was doing my hair in the bathroom. I was actually late for work, but when Johnny started singing this song, I ran into the other room to watch this video. I was absolutely mesmerized 😮 I really didn't have time to be standing there, but it was like I couldn't move until Johnny was finished singing
When Johnny showed this video to his daughter, he asked her what she thought. She said "Dad, it sounds like you're saying goodbye" He said "I am" RIP Johnny Cash A True Legend 🤘
As a young girl I remember seeing my parents dancing to Johnny Cash music in our living room. My husband and I both loved Johnny Cash music. He's legend, for sure.
No matter how many times I hear that song, in combination with this awesome video, I'll always get at least the wet eyes at. It's sad and beatiful at the same time. Johnny Cash is a true legend. RIP Man In Black.
So cool to see these young men moved by Cash. Life goes by fast, I am in my mid 50s and feel like I as a kid a few years ago. Go after your dreams everyone. There does come a time we all get older and have regrets.
I found this song probably 12 yrs ago. I used to listen to this over and over when i going through some really hard times and i dont know why this song resonated with me sooo much. Been a big fan ever since.
His wife June on the stairs, she wasn't supposed to be in this video but came downstairs out of concern for him as he was terminally ill, that look on her face is genuine so they left it in. Cash is beyond legend, 100 lifetimes of pain shown on that face, none of us could survive 10% of what he went through but he was his own worst enemy but found redemption anyway. He was an original rock and roll artist from the 50's and he's right up there with Elvis, Chuck Berry and the rest. It's my good fortune I saw him and his wife perform close up back in 1980 and I still remember being so awestruck I couldn't believe it. For a look in how this song happened on here, do a search for HURT-BEHIND THE SCENE.
Trent Reznor talks about the fact that while he wrote this song, it really belongs to Johnny Cash now. An all-time baller move by Reznor to respect a legend like that. Still, Reznor's version is a classic in its own right. Give the live version a listen if you get a chance.
As you get old the people that you know and love disappear, they go away. I don’t think is good to live forever…this song is an incredible way to put life in perspective. Hits me every time I listen to it.
This "Nine Inch Nails" song is heartbreaking. When Johnny Cash sang this, I reminded me how hard life can be for everyone of every age. Thanks for doing this one, Cartier Family!
When Johnny Cash played this for his daughter she said “It sounds like you’re saying goodbye”, and he told her “I am”. Such a beautiful, heartbreaking song.
He intentionally waited until his health was declining to record this. After the pneumonia that started his decline the amount of time he could sing was greatly curtailed. He waited until singing hurt would put a strain on him to convey it was the end to everyone who heard it. If you listen to other songs first you can hear him strain and struggle to make it through this.
@@thenecessaryevil2634bro it’s not even his song. He covered nine inch nails.
@@jamezxh Yes, and?
@jamezxh when Trent Reznor heard this he said to cash that's you're song"
@@jamezxh “I wasn’t prepared for what I saw, and it really then, wasn’t my song anymore.” - Trent Reznor
Johnny Cash's father, in a drunken state, once told him that he wished Johnny had died instead of his brother Jack. That was probably one of the reasons he was so messed up for a large part of his life.
"Johnny Cash's father, in a drunken state, once told him that he wished Johnny had died instead of his brother Jack. That was probably one of the reasons he was so messed up for a large part of his life."
Oh, you think?
@@codyeaster290 you know, you could've just said those three words without the whole quote bruh
@@AllenC1x "you know, you could've just said those three words without the whole quote bruh"
I could have, but I chose not to because something could happen to that comment at anytime, for example, it could be edited or deleted (second option won't really matter in this case, since the whole section will get deleted along with it), so quoting the comment is my way of preserving it so that it doesn't get lost to time.
@@codyeaster290 Good grief. You must be tiring for the people who have to put up with you.
@@moralityisnotsubjective5 Seriously. What a slog.
This song was made and written by Nine Inch Nails. The leader singer made this song about a middle aged mans life spiraling out of control and losing the ones around him due to death and drugs/ overdoses'. Johnny Cash took the song changed one word and made it about and old man looking back on his life losing those around him due to age and what year to year can do to a friendship. Nine Inch Nails lead singer wasn't happy about this because the song was soooo personal to him. Once he heard the song he said, "this is now cash's song". Cash is the ONLY person in the Country Hall of Fame, Rock N' Roll Hall of Fame, AND the Songwriters Hallo of Fame. You could literally write a Harry Potter 10 book story about this man's life and still have chapters left out... During this song his wife passed away. His daughter told him that this song sounds like he is saying goodbye... Johnny replied, "I am saying goodbye; I miss my June (wife June Carter)". Johnny passed away like 4 months after releasing this song.... RIP Legend.
Great comment. Pretty much sums it all up.
Thank you for your comment, we learn something new everyday, cheers 🙌🏻
Neither Johnny Cash nor Trent Reznor were keen to the idea, before recording it. Rick Rubin (who produced the album this cover is on) brought the idea to both of them. Cash was more receptive, taking less time/convincing (of course, since recording comes prior to hearing final product)
The interview with Trent Reznor (lead singer of Nine Inch Nails) was really interesting. He was against remaking it because he just didn't think it would work. But when he heard the final cut he equated it a girlfriend being happier with another man. He just had to let go. The song was Cash's now.
@@Mim795 I love music and history can add impact. Wish you the best!
The fact that he continues to touch people, young, old, white, black, Christian, atheist, male or female, is a testament to the man as a Legend. ❤ I love that you all appreciate this.
He continues to touch people INCLUDING his wife, if you know what I mean.
Johnny was 74, but was in constant pain from illness for the last 10 years of his life, thats why he looked so old. This song is a Nine Inch Nails song written by Trent Reznor, the lead singer. When he wrote it, he didn't know that it would end up being prophetic of his own life. He wasn't a junkie when he wrote and recorded it, but within 2 years he was. Johnny recorded this song about 2 years after Reznor got out of rehab. It was produced by a friend of Reznor"s. He was flattered that Johnny wanted to do it, but he felt weird about it when he heard the recording, becuase it was someone else singing about something that was so personal to him. A few weeks later he saw the music video ( a video that won numerous awards BTW) and said that he finally understood, and that the song was no longer his.
Also in the video was his wife June Cater Cash, standing on the steps behind him. She died very very soon after the video was made, and Johnny followed 4 months later.
What he suffered from? Thank you.
@@costealucia5357 he was old. And I’m sure he had issues with body pain. Knees and back. Don’t know of any illness. You’d have to look it up.
Thank you for giving us the history of the song. I knew most of it years ago, but I had forgotten.
@@costealucia5357Pneumonia and diabetes I think
In an interview, Trent was asked how he responded to Johnny Cash asking to use his song. His reply, "How would YOU respond? He's Johnny effing Cash."
Johnny Cash is one of the greatest musicians of all time. He is a legend.
He is a beloved legend.
He is a legendary performer but there's no way he can be considered one of the greatest musicians of all time. He was basically a 3-chord guitar strummer with a cool voice, a ton of charisma, a lot of attitude and a fabulous life story. But one of the greatest musicians of all time? Even he would laugh at that idea.
he s'not the greatest musician but the best storyteller a real Legend
@Code 9 I absolutely love Johnny Cash and is one of my fav musicians but I 100% agree with you. He is no where close to the greatest but he is still made some damn good music
@@Code9 music isnt all about who is the best singer, or the best at playing. Its about the music, the charisma, the voice. You dont need to be the best at playing or singing, to be one considered of the best. He wasnt the most talented, but was damn well one of the best to ever do it.
FACT: This video was made 7 months before Johnny Cash died. After his wife of 35 years died (June Cash), Johnny said he had nothing to live for except music after his wife died. You can feel it in this song. A once powerful man reduced to a shadow of himself waiting for death. This song was Johnny making his peace with the end.
His close friend Waylon Jennings had just died also.
@@marckrenek4147 Struggle Jennings is his grandson. ❤ his music.
@@donnahighley2940 waylon jennings is the dad of shooter.
This is a cover of a Nine Inch Nails song. Trent Reznor had no idea Johnny Cash had done a rendition of his song, the first time he heard it was while he was watching television and it brought him to uncontrollable sobbing. He said it felt like someone took his song and did a better job than he ever could with it.
And it’s not like June was just some random lady who he met and married. June Carter…Carter Family = “the first family of country music”. Their version of “were you there” (the hymn) is the most incredible and eerie and beautiful version of it I’ve ever heard.
This rendition brings me to tears. Every. Time.
When his wife June passed away he was devastated..4 months later he was gone; God Bless him. He will always be a part of the soundtrack of my life. Always.
Me too. I don't think I ever watch this video without tears falling.
Every time !😟😥
One of the worst things about getting old is that you lose your friends to accidents, disease and other things. You get older and really regret some discissions you made and things you have said. Its really hard on you as you realize your in the last chapter of life. Being lonely, becoming disabled and have a really hard time doing stuff. I guess thats one of the reasons I enjoy these reaction videos as it reminds me of my days of glory and to see a young generation seeing what our lives and culture was like in the past makes you proud you were a part of it. Thanks guys!
Nuff said---truth. Be safe.
❤
Who says our young people are shallow and unaware of what's important in life.
These young men will restore your faith our future will be prosperous!
Cruzer
In
CT
Only heard this song about a thousand times. Still gives me goosebumps
I'm not a crier. Period. But this song always makes me bawl like a baby. This is a true testimony to how powerful Mr. Cash was
this song is a testimony, even though it is a re-recording it shows the true feelings of a man who faced a difficult life regardless of the situation, johnny was a man who went through a lot and still did not abandon his beliefs and himself, he is a example of life
what about crying? it's an inherent characteristic of human beings, of caring about life.. whoever has the courage to laugh in happy moments and cry in sad moments is truly a hero.. "this world is a school" best way, all respect to him, and if you shed tears at that moment it's because you understand that, it's not a synonym of weakness but of emotional maturity
It's this last part from 6:15 that gets me every single time!
When Hurt comes on EVERYBODY HURTS.
Same. I see it as a very egoic thing. It isn't about me. I can cry in private thinking, listening or seeing something. But I don't cry around people. That's something I overcome. In place of tears, I show composure.
The end of this video shows a definite finality to his career and eventually his life. The way he closed the lid to the piano and then ran his hands along the lid was his good-bye to music and the world. RIP Mr Cash... goat
I get tears in my eyes every single time I hear this. Love Johnny Cash. I grew up with him and I'm 70. He was a legend.
This song (both versions) astonished me.
How the same lyrics can have vastly different messages.
Kudos to Trent. He wrote a song that made a legend notice it.
It was so absolutely perfect when Reznor made it that I got my panties in a bunch when Cash came in. Now I've learned to accept Cash's version too, and even love it. But it took a while. I credit both artists absolutely fully.
Johnny Cash definitely had a lot going on in his life.... he even made a live album at Folsom Prison
He has a song about folsom to. He did have a 'live at San Quentin' album to. A show he did for the prisoners there.
I hear that train a coming, Coming round the bend. I ain't seen my baby since I don't know when.
the movie Walk the Line with Joaquin Phoenix, did the Folsom prison scene justice. Got 82% on Rotten Tomatoes.
you're...saying that...like its not... very common knowledge....
CARTIERA FAMILA😊 0:17
When his eldest daughter heard him sing this song she said "It sounds like you're saying goodbye" and Johnny Cash said "I am". He died less then a year later.
I bet it was Rosanne Cash. She had a hit in the 1980’s Playing with the queen of hearts
That is because he done this song shortly after his wife passed away. He passed shortly after his wife. Can't remember how long exactly after she passed.
@@garyedgington9020 that’s his wife, June Carter in the video looking at him concerned. Yes, she did pass away before he did of heart failure.
Johnny Cash was iconic as a country singer, not acting. He is one of the most important artists in music history. Much of his music contained themes of sorrow, moral tribulation, and redemption, and also included gospel . His wife June Carter Cash was a five-time Grammy award-winner, and was a member of the famous gospel-singing Carter family. Johnny Cash's music genre spanned across country, rock and roll, rockabilly, blues, folk, and gospel. His crossover appeal earned him the rare honor of being inducted into the Country Music, Rock and Roll, and Gospel Music Halls of Fame. There's so much on Johnny Cash. This doesn't even scratch the surface. I've never been a big C&W music fan, but my generation grew up with Johnny Cash one way or another. He was a household name and was bigger than life. Thanks for this reaction guys! ✌💙✌
He's also in the Rockabilly, Memphis Music, and Nashville Song Writer's halls of fame. He's received the Kennedy Center honors, National Medal of Arts, along with CMA, VMA, Grammy's, and many other awards.
All well deserved.
He was also an actor!😊
@@I_give_up_already - Yes, but that was not what he was famous for.
@@faithnyou1732 show me where I said it was🤦🏻♀️🤦🏻♀️
This is one of the most real, sad and intense songs ever written. 🙌
Reznor does a good tune.
It truly is
Original song is by nine inch nails
Johnny is about the only artist that no matter what genre/ playlist I have on, if he sneaks in I'm okay with it. He belongs everywhere.
He's been everywhere, Man. ;)
I never skip him when he plays. 😢
he would've made a great MC
It's that moment when Cash is pouring the wine out from the glass, combined with the lyrics and him looking at the camera that gets me every time. "You want fame and fortune, huh? Here, take it. See me now? See all the good it's done me? Here, take it! TAKE IT!"
I love this explanation. Hands down the best I've heard
*takes it.*
aight chill bruh
So many want to be rich and famous without knowing the costs.
Thank you guys so much for showing this man the respect he deserves
I love this song. Trent Reznor wrote a beautiful song but Johnny made it epic! After watching Walk The Line, I just wept for the life he lived. He was truly an artist. May he rest in peace.
The change in your faces once he started singing was so noticeable. And I think that is the power that Johnny Cash always possessed, but he didn't realize the gravity of it until old age.
When he said “I never heard of Johnny Cash” I almost cried…how did you grow to adulthood without hearing Johnny Cash??
Me too! I laughed then cried cuz Johnny cash IS music
This song is not originally his, but he definitely made it its own, in a big way. Such a legend.
Once Trent Rezner heard Johnny's version he admitted the song was his (Johnny's) song.
@@rwxstudio7173 I swear y'all just repeat the same thing over and over
@@nachocheez9690 are you resistant to learning?
I don't know Trent said it Wasn't he is anymore after this
@@rwxstudio7173he didn’t actually say it in that way but ok
Thank ya'll for liking and respecting this song. It's meaningful to a lot of people.
A good mix of different reactions. These guys have good chemistry
The part when he says "You could have it all. My empire of dirt." brings me to tears every time. They show his awards, his records, all of his achievements and accomplishments, he sits at a table in a throne with a feast in front of him, representing all of the things he accomplished in his life, the wealth he accumulated, and he's literally saying, mostly to his late wife, that he would give it all up if he could just have more time with her. He struggled heavily with alchohol addiction throughout his life, so it hits even harder as you see his trembling hand pour the wine out across the table. He's acknowledging all the people he hurt in his life, the way his alchoholism destroyed his life and the lives of everyone around him, and in the end he says "If I could start again, a million miles away. I would keep myself, I would find a way." Everything he's done, all the art he's made, all the awards, the movies, the records, the fame, the fortune, it's all dirt. It's meaningless. He would give it all away if he could just do it all over again, but he can't.
Cool story IF HE WROTE THIS SONG. Werid wonder why a COVER turns out to be all this epic retelling his life. Why couldn’t he just write his own song waxing lyrical about the 💩his life was. He had a hard life but was a damn superstar legend. I had a HARDER life then him, all I get is JUDGEMENTS from most people….but hey his life was sooooooo hard, poor him….boo hooo…..all that money praise and all else…..
Why does everyone act like his life was destroyed cuz of it? How? His wife was with him to the end, his kids etc….
PLEASE give me his hard life….😂🤣🤧
@@6Haunted-Days The song could reflect your life as well.
I never get enough of you guys. I would like to give you a collective hug. You restore my faith in the youth.
After all this time I still can't listen to this song without shedding at least one tear
Far and away the absolute best cover version of any song. Ever.
Rod Stewart's cover of First Cut is the Deepest by Cat Stevens is pretty good....
????? Research
@@franjamison77 Yea but the original writer and singer said it was his song now . And the fact it was a super personal song says even more . Don't think he sang the song since
He made you have a conversation. That in and of itself is how powerful he was as a entertainer. Johnny took his rendition of this song and made it about his life. Not many can do something so powerful.
You guys are a treasure. Thank you for objectively listening to music and offering your honest feelings about it. It’s refreshing
❤❤❤
This song never fails to choke me up - the absolute look of heartbreak on his face is devastating.
This song always makes me just bawl with emotion. Heartbreaking 💔
There will never be anyone compared to 'The Man in Black,' Mr
Cash. He lived a life like no other.
My Dad, who I lost 13 years ago, was a great fan of Johnny, so I grew up listening to him. My Dad was not a musician, but he was rugged, lived through a horrific childhood, survived the Korean War, and was my hero. Johnny's songs bring back so many great memories, and at the same time, sooths my soul. I'm so happy you chose to listen to him!
This song was originally written by and performed by Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails it was biographical and dealt with his struggles-namely drug addiction. But it is so relatable and could be applied to anyone who struggles with a life of regret. Johnny did a cover of it. This was his last release before he passed away. He was a Christian and he performed the song exactly as written except one verse. He changed it from "crown of s***" to "crown of thorns". P. S. As Christians we believe we will be united with our loved ones after death so we would not want to live forever in this life but forever in the life to come, absolutely!
Trent 100%
Trent wasn't an addict when he wrote it actually. it was a prophetic song, rather than biographical, because with 2 years after writing it, he was an addict.
After Trent heard Johnny's cover. He officially said the song belongs to Johnny now. That it was no longer a cover of his song and that if he (Trent) were to perform it, that, would be the cover.
The video makes this song. The interspersion of Cash’s video “Gospel Road” changes the author’s belief entirely.
Was never a Cash fan but the passion he put into this song was amazing. I felt his life, his pains, i felt him slipping away. He truly made this his song and Trent Reznor, who wrote it, gave it to him with grace
I am so touched by your emotion as you watch this. I can never watch him sing "Hurt" without crying.
I can tell homie in the red hat wasn’t just listening but he actually heard Johnny.. a true message for all of us.
Their faces as they were trying not to cry. It's hard to breathe when you first hear this song.
Johnny Cash has such an incredible catalog of music. My personal favorites are God's Gonna Cut You Down and Folsom Prison Blues.
I love:
I'll Never Pick Cotton
When the Man Comes Around
Ring of Fire
Tears in the Holston River
And the two mentioned above.
After Trent Reznor (nine inch nails) heard Cash's rendition of his song, he remarked, "that's not my song any more." It fits Cash in that he struggled endlessly with heroin addiction, and his wife June stood by him through all of it.
This.
Beautiful, heart breaking song written by Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails. Johnny Cash was a legend. This song says so much about Johnny's life. 💔
This was his goodbye. Johnny Cash is a member of the Country Music Hall of Fame, Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Gospel Music Hall of Fame. His wife passed shortly after recording this and he passed away about 6 months later. To know more about him, check out his song, The Man in Black
The Nine Inch Nails song was done in the 90's and is totally different. When Trent Reznor, who is NIN lead singer and writer of the song, heard Johnny's version he said it's Cash's song now. He embodied the lyrics in a completely different way. Great interview about how Rick Rubin had Johnny perform many other modern artists. I recommend Johnny's version of Personal Jesus originally written & performed by Depeche Mode. Thanks for all your videos.
Rusty Cage by Soundgarden too!!
"A song is something that walks by itself" - Bob Dylan
Definitely agree, some covers are just made into something completely new.
I cannot listen to it without bawling my eyes out, I love Cash! If you can tell the story and us and make people feel it. That's an artist to make someone else feel your pain or someone can relate to it. He's a great storyteller and a loving caring man. He was a sinner his whole life like as we are. And of course in the end he became closer to god. It's a beautiful thing
I love both versions of this song. Hurt at different stages of life.
I love this version immensely but Trent at the Katrina fundraiser is pretty good too.
One is a young man speaking of his struggles the other is an old man with his regrets😢...both great though❤
@@staceyparks5717amen!
"Walk the the Line" was one his signature songs as well as title for biography movie. Movie had Reese Weatherspoon & Joaquin Phoenix in it. Definitely worth checking both out
Yep. Great song! Great movie! Walk the Line, Folsom Prison and Ring of Fire are my favorites!
Was ONLY into hip-hop when the movie came out and saw it with a fam member in theater. That movie was such a success, it's what started the "High Budget Biopic" trend in the past decade or so... Before that, Biopics were made for TV movies but that movie basically created a new genre for the box office (IMO)
It was so popular they made that comedy parody "Walk Hard" with John C Reilly.
Awesome movie, and it's parody spoof Walk Hard is hilarious!
There is only one Johnny Cash. He’s one of the most important performers of our lifetime.
Yes.
Johnny Cash is a legend.
I love seeing how Johnny Cash affects people. He crosses genre's, age groups and will forever live on! The Stephanie wasn't his last song though he recorded 72 songs after his wife passed away before his own death. Thanks for this video!
I am 40 years old. I watched 100s of reactors watch this video and everytime I watch because this song is amazing. This song makes me cry everytime. I cried this time aswell. Life relections and reflections on regret is this song wrapped in a bow. Trent really did an amazing job writing this song and Johnny killed singing it. Both different versions are amazing.
Johnny Cash had a distinct sound. He was one of the first country music artists that broke many barriers. He performed with Ray Charles, unheard of at the time. His life was on a downward spiral until he met June Carter. She was the love of his life. He had so many hits over the course of his life. He was a legend.
This video hits like a punch to the gut. It hits even harder when you know the man's music and life story. I love what you guys do. Seeing young men of today being moved emotionally by the music of my youth is a great pleasure. You bring a lot of good sense to the table. All the best to you.
Makes me cry every time. I’m half way there. Just a handful of folks left. Thanks for sharing you lives with us. Strong, handsome, intelligent young men. Makes me happy to see you every time. I’m pulling for your success and pray for you often.
Yup, still can't listen to his version of this song without tearing up 😭
Cash took this song and transformed it into a song of regret... he was strong enough to say "I am not who you thought I was" he is singing his own dispair.
Cash is a Legend. One of the greatest music artists of all time.
Not sure anyone will read because I’m late but…
THIS SONG IS INCREDIBLE!! The way he presents the internal struggle of having it all at one point in time and reflecting about how he would give it ALL away to never lose himself. Lots of people have made songs about this but Johnny’s hits different because of how old he was when he performed it. He ACTUALLY had the ability to reflect and really felt deep in a hole because he knows IF he could go back and “keep myself” he would find a way. But the hard truth is he cannot, you cannot, I cannot, NOBODY can. So it’s best we take advantage of life and the opportunity God has given us before it’s too late and all we have is ourselves and our regrets!
When death invites me in, I'll leave my regrets at the door.
This is a cover of a nine inch nails song btw
@@colby8181 yes.
Love your reaction to this legendary performer. I became a fan years ago mostly due to my Dad’s influence.
Johnny Cash ‘The Man In Black’ is one of the most gifted and celebrated country music artists of all time. He and the legendary Glen Campbell are my personal absolute favorite country music artists. … Johnny Cash’s wife, June Carter, wrote a love song for/about him called Ring of Fire 🔥 and Johnny Cash sang it. It is widely considered one of the greatest country songs ever. … it’s worth a listen. 📻🎶🎵🖤
I highly recommend his song "God's Gonna Cut You Down"! The music video is amazing also!
100% this.
They would really like that one, too. Totally agree! Have been subscribed to this group of excellent young men for just a few months, but have watched dozens of past reactions that they've done & they simply comprise one of the best reaction sources on TH-cam - which says a lot, because the entire "reaction" concept has ballooned over the past 3+ years & spawned hundreds of channels. I rank these gentlemen somewhere in my Top 5, & I estimate that I've checked out, AT LEAST, 150 reactors over the last couple of years. And so being in my Top 5 amongst 150+, who I gave a sincere effort to like, says it all. Appreciate you guys! I'm 65, an Army vet, an amputee (entire right leg) - amongst other serious health conditions - and you are a part of almost each day that I live. Bless you guys & keep kicking ass.
✌&❤4🌏
When the Man Comes Around
Most of the people in that video are narcissitic morons.
This song is about regret. Johnny Cash was one of the "wild men" in country music. He wore black for those who were in prison. So many of his early songs were great "Walk the Line", "Ring of Fire. I love his video (later one) "God's gonna cut you down".
Keep up the great work! You guys do a great job!
Ya'll make me proud as retired educator. I love watching your reactions and your interactions with each other as topics are discussed and debated. It has given me a great deal of pleasure to witness the broadening of genres that are being investigated. The greatest joy, is the maturation of each one of you, as you try to put everything into context; in terms of history, styles and influences. School is not about grades or degrees, it is about about developing a lifetime of curiosity and the ability to keep learning throughout life. Keep up the great work!
The hairs on my arms just stood straight. Such an emotional song 😢
This song hits you in the chest. RIP Mr. Cash.!!! Never forgotten.
So many Johnny Cash songs you can react to. Great talent!
I love Johnny Cash!!! 💗 His version of this song gives me chills n tears to my eyes, hurts a lil close to home... 🥺
Johnny was a true legend…. The man in black 🖤 RIP King
Johnny's life started off very tragic and ended tragic. I highly suggest truly digging into this man's life. You could spend years still uncovering even more aspects of his life. Even his friendship with Elvis (which is how he stumbled across drugs himself and had a huge battle beating that addiction). You can't hear this song and not hear the pain and cry for him.
Johnny was THE MAN. Not afraid to try different musical styles. He had a bad problem with drinking and pills, his 2nd wife June Carter and her family helped him get clean and gk on for many more decades sober. Listen to his beautuful duet "I Miss Someone" with his daughter Roseanne Cash...fantastic.
Even near the end Cash had the "it" factor - there will NEVER be another Johnny Cash. RIP.
This song always gets to me. It's like his eulogy. The movie Walk the Like was a wonderful movie. The actor who played him did it justice
Joaquin Phoenix is the actor, and he did all his own singing (as did actress Reese Witherspoon).
I'll never forget the first time I heard this song. The t.v. was on in another room while I was doing my hair in the bathroom. I was actually late for work, but when Johnny started singing this song, I ran into the other room to watch this video. I was absolutely mesmerized 😮 I really didn't have time to be standing there, but it was like I couldn't move until Johnny was finished singing
Glad to see you youngin's listening to and appreciating the music of my young days.
When Johnny showed this video to his daughter, he asked her what she thought. She said "Dad, it sounds like you're saying goodbye"
He said "I am"
RIP Johnny Cash
A True Legend 🤘
You dudes crack me up... so much love. It's people like you all that keep us connected, great job guys
As a young girl I remember seeing my parents dancing to Johnny Cash music in our living room. My husband and I both loved Johnny Cash music. He's legend, for sure.
No matter how many times I hear that song, in combination with this awesome video, I'll always get at least the wet eyes at. It's sad and beatiful at the same time. Johnny Cash is a true legend. RIP Man In Black.
So cool to see these young men moved by Cash. Life goes by fast, I am in my mid 50s and feel like I as a kid a few years ago. Go after your dreams everyone. There does come a time we all get older and have regrets.
I love watching you guys. Thanks for checking out Johnny Cash.
Johnny sang some great gospel songs. His faith was important to him.
This song gives me goosebumps every time I listen to it 😢
I'm a grown man and I still cry every time I see this video. God bless all of you.
This songs gets me everytime. Phew. Great stuff.
One of deepest songs , shakes me to the core having cash sing it. Looking back at his life knowing it’s led him to the end.
As someone who has outlived people I wish were still here this song is emotional damage made into musical art. 😢
Do his "A boy named sue ". Absolute classic.
I found this song probably 12 yrs ago. I used to listen to this over and over when i going through some really hard times and i dont know why this song resonated with me sooo much. Been a big fan ever since.
That piano at the end...builds the tension and breaks my heart.
His wife June on the stairs, she wasn't supposed to be in this video but came downstairs out of concern for him as he was terminally ill, that look on her face is genuine so they left it in. Cash is beyond legend, 100 lifetimes of pain shown on that face, none of us could survive 10% of what he went through but he was his own worst enemy but found redemption anyway. He was an original rock and roll artist from the 50's and he's right up there with Elvis, Chuck Berry and the rest. It's my good fortune I saw him and his wife perform close up back in 1980 and I still remember being so awestruck I couldn't believe it. For a look in how this song happened on here, do a search for HURT-BEHIND THE SCENE.
One of the best songs I ever heard!
Y’all definitely need to do more hits by cash. He’s a legend.
Such a heartbreaking loss. 😢 He will forever be missed. 😢❤
I love seeing brothers respecting great music.
Trent Reznor talks about the fact that while he wrote this song, it really belongs to Johnny Cash now. An all-time baller move by Reznor to respect a legend like that. Still, Reznor's version is a classic in its own right. Give the live version a listen if you get a chance.
When his daughter heard this , she said “dad, it sounds like you are saying goodbye “ he just smiled and said “ yes” 🐐
I'm a huge fan of Johnny Cash. I grew up listening to his songs. He's one of the greatest singer/songwriter of all time.
When I first heard this song I broke down and cried. So powerful and reminded me of my southern family and how they are all seemed to "go away"
As you get old the people that you know and love disappear, they go away. I don’t think is good to live forever…this song is an incredible way to put life in perspective. Hits me every time I listen to it.
This "Nine Inch Nails" song is heartbreaking. When Johnny Cash sang this, I reminded me how hard life can be for everyone of every age. Thanks for doing this one, Cartier Family!