@@barguttobed medieval mongolian? Khalkhas are those mongols who were always in homeland under uguedei and tului families. Its just a term name which appeared in 15th century. Dayan khan gave this name to central mongols, which khalkha means "to cover-to shield" so they will defend the homeland forever.
@@barguttobed so you wanna say that khalkha mongols forgot their original archaic traits yet buryats has it all like before? you must be joking.... i have tons of buriyat firends, most of them cant speak buriyat only few older ones speak, but barely not that good with so litlle vocabulary base. tbh russian buryats lost their own language due to switching to mainland russian language so the mongol language among russian buiyats already lost and stuck at some point and haven't developed since 1990s. today 90% of russian buriyats dont even know their language. meanwhile, on the other hand, khalkha still uses ancient traditional core and in combination with new without touching archaic traits
The pronouncer is a Chinese person learning Turkish (according to his comment on bilibili), so for this reason it’s may make this language sounds a bit like Turkish
“评论区有人提到应该照蒙古语读法念，这种说法大概率是不对的，因为目前学术界一般认为早期蒙古语言的音系类似突厥语而非现代蒙古语。” He emphasized that the academia believes the phonetics are closer to turkic than to modern mongolian languages.
most ancient countires in Northern China was created by Xianbei. Royal families of Sui and Tang dynasties were half Xianbei. Most Northern Chinese should have varying degree of Xianbei Ancestry. Xianbei is ancestor of mongolic, and also appears to have close connection to proto Turkic people. If you think about it, the map is huge for this Turkic-Mongolic-Xianbei related people
@@heaven.123 Ruling class from the Northern Wei all the way to Tang dynasties were almost exclusively sinacized Xianbei. They originated in Inner Mongolia. The Gokturks were eventually conquered by these dynasties and drafted into their armies to fight their wars (particularly in Manchuria), according the ancient Turkic scripture in the Orkhon Valley.
I am Inner Mongolian, I can tell that this language is very close to ancient Mongolian. A lot of words here are same as ancient Mongolian but no longer spoken by us.
@@johnthiam2446Khalkha itself has various tribes from different parts of Mongolia . I’m from Olkhonud tribe and we mostly inhabited in north western part of Mongolia . Some others are from east Mongolia . You’re mistaken if you thought Khalkha Mongols only live in Mongolia . There are also some in Inner Mongolia and Xinjiang.
It's commonly accepted that both Xianbei and Khitan were Mongols. Some scholars argue Xiongnu were pre-dominantly Turkic based on Chinese sources. However, they need more archaeological evidence to prove it.
Nobody really can be certain how the Xianbei (鮮卑) spoke in the 4th century. (Xianbei phonetics can be reconstructed using what we know of various surviving Mongolian dialects.) Historical accounts indicate Xianbei are from present-day Inner Mongolia and eventually ruled most of China. In other words, ruling class of Northern Wei (北魏), Northern Zhou (北周), all way to the Tang dynasty were sinacized Mongols. This also explains why Tang dynasty had so many foreigners working in their court.
@@Weeping-Angel many of the words are now synonyms or near definition words. Ex: nair in xianbei is peace but nair in mongolian means cooperation, or agiyl means house in xianbei but in Mongolian ayil means household
@@borgilbatbaatar4949 It's true though. Inner Mongolia has been and probably always will be Chinese-Mongol. Mongolia gained freedom due to Soviet pressure on China and became slavicized. I'm not pro-China but Mongolia's history in itself is very odd, Soviets wanted a buffer state between it and the weakening Chinese government at the time and pressured China into allowing Mongolia to break free with some violence happening. Inner-Mongolia was safely within Chinese rule during the period. Once Mongolia became independent Soviets began killing off Mongolian clergy and nobility and enforced Russian onto the Mongols living there. (China isn't any better, not cherishing the Mongols living in Inner-Mongolia by not teaching them the script or language due to state mandated single language schools in Mandarin). Thus, he is correct it's Inner-Mongolia.
@@cqn6052 Back then Proto-Turkic and Proto-Mongolic were intertwined and many Khaganates and entities had both languages within. It's pretty dubious to say one is safely "Mongolic" or "Turkic" until those entities formed within the years 1000-1200 ish. Take a look at the Yugurs, the arguable successors to the ancient Uyghur Khaganate in the 6th century, they have the Western Yugur language which is a Turkic language and closely related to the far older Yeneseian languages and Eastern Yugur which is Mongolic in origin. Likely thing is, like all Turkic Khaganates at the time and before, they were split into East and West and therefore had 2+ languages they'd use commonly. Mind you, the Yugurs descend from Uyghur Khaganate nobility, with their name literally being derived from "western uyghur". These people fled the Islamization of the Turks and kept their Buddhist and Tengrist roots and kept their language alive.
Obviously Turkic language originated in South Siberia and Mongolia. Most of ancient runic Turkic alphabet is found in Mongolia and later the Yenisei river region. (Mongols on the otherhand were more concentrated in Inner Mongolia. Most Turkic tribes were purged from Outer Mongolia during the Mongol expansion, but some minority Turkic groups still reside in present-day Mongolia.) The close proximity and contact over thousands of years is why Turkic and Mongolian share common vocabulary, grammar, music, culture, religion, clothing, etc.
@@yo2trader539 No Mongols ancestors always lived in Outer Mongolia and Baikal region as well, turkic groups in Mongolia are recent migrants except for Tsaatan
@@yo2trader539tsaatan are actually immigrants. They were given land in Mongolia to live in the 1940-50s just like the Kazakhs were allowed to live in bayan ulgiy
@@barguttobed That's not true. None of them has Mongolian roots that explain their root and suffix relations. But Turkic has verbal roots for each of them. If a word in Turkic cannot be explained by its root, it is not Turkic. All the words above can be explained by Turkic roots. Mongolian cannot explain the word roots. 1)Miñ, Bi - or Mi - To get on, to be added on 2) Tümen, A Tocharian word Tmane borrowd by Turkic and then passed to Mongolian. 3) Altun, Al- Red, Reddish 4) Emig, Em- To suck 5) Bitig, Biti- To write, to draw, (especially with a sharp thing) > bi- to sharpen 6) Boz, bo- to destroy, to make unusable, to change main characteristics, to distort, to mix different things 7) Tor, to- to collect 8) Qır- Qı- to stab, to bleed with a knife. Another related Turkic word qılıç (sword) 9-Qural, Qur- To found, to arrange, to make 10-Quzı, Qu- to breed, to cub 11-Qapaqçı, qapa- to close, to shut, to cover, to block 12- Tağ, ta- to raise, to add on, to attach 13- Toğan, Toğ- To rise up, to arise, to ascend 14- Üren, Ür- To engage in, To produce, To increase, to widen (clouds increase and cover the sky) 15-Yıltırgan , yıltır- to be bright, brighten 16-Yükseg, Yük, Load burden, yüküz- to add loads, add loads on, burden up 17-Beg, An Iranian word related to Bhagha ( Lord, God) 18-Erkin, er- to ripe, to grow, to reach. erk, growth, reaching, reaching the power, power and erkin, potent, powerful
@@nadirhikmetkuleli7335 You don't speak any Mongolian and trying to give some explanation about our language? What a joke. It is clear that Mongolic and Turkic languages are related because share the same roots. But for Xianbei it is obvious more related to Mongolic than Turkic.
Both Turkic and Mongolic people are related and have the same roots originated from the Hongshan culture in the area of modern Inner Mongolia. Ancient Turkic were indistinguishable from Mongolic people.
@@Paxia you have an identity problem because you are a greek hittite anatolian who try to connect himself to steppe empires. Do a dna test and you will see. Don't try to steal mongol history to resolve your weak identity problem. Mongols are close to ancient Xianbei and Xiongnu, and Khitans. Just look at illustrative dna lol
@@Secular_Turkishthere is no proof that some of this words has turkic origin, for example word Bar(means “take” in all turkic languages, and turks are trying to prove that word “bar” has turkic origin But there is mongolian ancient word “barih” which means also take or hold. Since the Xiongu empire was confederation of all nomadic people (mongolic, turkic and tungusic), you should say that this words are common words
@@buryat-mongol_2000The state was founded by Turks, its army was Turks, their language was Turkish and their rulers were Turks. In Chinese sources, Huns and Xiongnu are mentioned as Turks.
the sample text belongs to Huis Tolgoi.his stone text was found in Mongolia. it i its date is 580. this time there was GökTürk Khaganate in Central asia and Mongolia. (that is why text says Türk kağan(khan).) The Inscription of Hüis Tolgoi (HT) is a monolingual inscription in a Mongolian language[1] found in Bulgan Province, Mongolia in 1975 by D. Navaan. The 11-line text is written in vertical Brahmi script running right to left with horizontal marks separating words. The language of the inscription was unknown until the joint expedition of Alexander Vovin, Étienne de la Vaissière, Dieter Maue and Mehmet Ölmez to Mongolia in 2014 for closer imaging of the stele. Due to certain morphological peculiarities the language of the inscription was hypothesized to be Mongolic rather than Turkic. The language, "which can be conditionally termed as a variety of Para-Mongolic," is "much closer to the mainstream Mongolic languages, such as Middle Mongolian and modern extant Mongolic languages than to Serbi-Khitan,"[2] and is beyond reasonable doubt some form of Mongolic, close to the mainstream Mongolic language
The Xianbei completely defeated the Xiongnu and drove the Xiongnu from the Mongolian plateau to Central Asia.If you read Shiji, the Xiongnu were originally surrendered to the Donghu (ancestor of the Xianbei people)
Xianbei were Monoglic clans from Inner Mongolia, but Chinese records say the Yuwen clan of Northern Zhou ruling family had Xiongnu heritage. Xiongnu was a collection of dozens of clans, so I don't think they were completely defeated or pushed out. It's more like musical chairs with different clans becoming top dog depending on the era.
Podemos conversar , fui rourana en vida pasada.. quienes eran los rourana? Investigué y mencionan que posiblemente eran de xianbei. Amo mucho todo lo asiático soy de América central. Agradezco tu información.
@@yo2trader539 Xiongnu were Proto-Turkic the Donghu were Proto-Mongolic. Both had intermarriage, with Chinese and each other. Modun Chanyu defeated the Donghu and absorbed them if I can remember correctly.
The origin of the earliest Turkish monarchs are Armenian servants ruled by real Turk, and then these Armenian influenced by Turkic language invaded Eastern Rome/Greece, now the majority of modern Turkish people after Ottoman empire are mostly white Greek people and ancient Armenian (Middle East white people), while real Turk(already had extinction before modern era) are the most common kind of Asian people like Mongol.
It's Mongolic, the way does it sounds doesnt matter + its reconstruction i dont think that it sounded like this. All thing is matter that structure and vocabulary of this language show that its definitely Mongolic
There are very few information on Xianbei language. Two inscriptions belong to the Proto-Turkic. Proto-Turkic sounds closer to Proto-mongolic. Therefore, the ancient Turkic people were closer to Mongolians instead of Central Asian and Turkeys from the genetic perspective(Except for Kazakh/Tuvas).
Thats probably not entirely true. Kipchaks and Cumans (Present day Qazaqstan and Kyrgyzstan) can trace their origins all the way back to the yellow river basin in Eastern Asia. Mongolians originate from Inner Mongolia ironically (I know I know) and Turks especially ancient ones were from Manchuria and Mongolia/Siberia. It was only with Mongolian expansion and the hostilities between Kipchaks and Uyghurs + Mongols became unbearable is when the Kipchaks left for Central Asia nd consequently kicked out the Oghuz turks to Anatolia and Western Asia.
Due to my knowledge of Mongolian, I can understand some Xianbei which is surreal. Миний Монгол хэл чадвар учраас, зарим Xianbei ойлгодог чаддаг байна, Xianbei хэл Моннол хэлын өвөг зэрэг гэж юм шиг байна.
Xianbei And Turkish Tümen - Tümen Altun - Altın Bor - boz(gray) Qağan - Kaan/kağan Qağtun - Kadın/hatun Tağ - Dağ(mountain) Min - Bin Aqa - Aga Eben - Çimen Mağtun - Hatun
So that's where jebe's name comes from. Commander of Genghis Khan army. And Names like temucin must be 'person who temu' even though I don't know what temu is.
@@Orjinadam1189 the rouran are Mongols. There are no Chinese or other sources talking of the Turkmen at the time suggesting they either were of no Importance or still lived in Yakutai Siberia
@@Orjinadam1189rourans are xianbei descendant and u turks are just slave and xiongnu is mongolic because slab grave culture is mongolic its the makurs descendant even xiongnu words like tegri , tarqan, meheer, delu, nuruugun,niru,uul,arhad Even i dont want to even fight on history with turkic and mongol History and we are descendant of donghu to
@@dakidaki5703 not really. Quite the opposite. Turks were always the majority in the steppes. Mongols werent that populated. There are tens of different Turkic countries all around the world and there is just one Mongolia. Even under the genghis khans rule,many soldiers of the mongolian empire were Turks.
Türküm kelimelerin önemli bir kısmı harf değişimleriyle Türk dilinde bulunan kelimeler örneğin koyun anlamına gelen "kuraqa" Türk dilinde koyun yavrusu "Kuzu" R Z değişimi
So, the oldest attested form of "qaghan", "qaghatun", "altun" etc. is Xianbei and it's thought Turkic and other Mongolic languages borrowed these words from Xianbei, right?
No, the words kağan, hatun, and Altın are of turkic origin, but turks and mongols lived with each other for so long, so its actually loan words of turkic to Mongolian
1) Kagan is Mongolized Iranic title *hwa-kama- (self-ruler), the lexeme was in Sogdian language as xutkame- *hwá "self" < *swé "self" *káHmah "wish" < *kóh₂-mo-s "wish" 2) Altun "red copper" can be a Turkic calque from Chinese 火銅 (literally: fiery copper/bronze), if the word *āl "red" is cognate to root *yal- "fire" (Turkish: alev "fire" from root *yal-) *tun ~ *tunç "bronze/copper" < 銅 [tūŋ]
So sweet, simply an old dialect of our modern Mongolian languages. Amazing, given that the Xianbi people spoke it about 2000 years ago! They were part of The Hunnu/Xiongnu Empire and succeeded the latter. That means I am speaking indeed a "long-living", old language.
Bro:- can you tell about da Yuezhi tribe origin They are indo Iranian tribe? Hephthalite or Yuezhi are same/ different tribes? I belong to Jat's tribe y haplogroup L-m11 36% , R-m207 28%, Q-m242 15% (northern Pakistan and India)
@@heliumboi8309 Yep and you totally right 👍🏼 Actually from reading in comments I found that the speaker is originally Chinese who learned Turkish, so that’s why he is forcing on Turkish accent to read this. Btw I’m sure Xianbei didn’t had that weird accent
@noble crow No, look at the Chinese sources, there are tabgaç Turkish communities if you accept the Mongols as Turks, if you join, there were no Mongols in the past, there were Turks in the Chinese source. 🐺🏹🇹🇷🐺🏹🇹🇷🐺🇹🇷👍👍👍
for the next video content, discuss the ancient languages of Nanyuei and Baiyuei, these languages have become extinct, possibly in the South China region 🙏 Source : id.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanyue en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baiyue
there's also Minyue, an ancient kingdom in what is now Fujian province in southern China, and was later annexed by the Han empire as they expanded, many Chinese people moved south and intermarried with the locals there
İt is strange for me The words don't seem foreign to my ears, but As a Turkish feels like i understand worlds but same time i dont understand. The ending shape of words is like the endings in Turkics languages.(,den,tan,ten,çin,rçin,kin,tin ,ran,uğra,dü,gü,etc)
Xiangnu were the ancestors of turk while xiagbei are the ancestors of khitan and mongol. Turk and khitan were converted to Buddhism while tatar and mongol remain tengrist at that time.
@@t3ngristtt all confederacies and empires were multi ethnic. But there’s literally no reason to deny the fact that the xiongnu was a Turkish empire. And I have the evidence that it was a Turkish empire lmao
I think "The Xianbei Language" is not just a proto-Mongolic language. It's between Turkic and Mongolic. Actually Turkic and Mongolic languages are close relatives. So, this language is in between.
Turkic and Mongolic arent "genetically" (in the linguistic sense) related. No serious linguist still holds to the Altaic theory. The early forms of Turkic and Mongolic were essentially part of a sprachbund though, and that's the reason for the similarities
@@barguttobed don’t bother arguing with this retard bro, this guy is one of those Turkish nationalists think that everything was turkic. I’ve even seen him claim that the donghu,xianbei,Liao dynasty,Mongol empire were Turkic 😂
Whoa! One more historical minority language from China.Sound very interesting! I can spot some loanwods such as "min" from Chinese 万 ("maan" in Cantonese pronunciation) although here it means "thousand" not "ten thousand" like in Chinese, and "kir" I guess it's an Indo-European loanword since it sounds similar to English "kill".
![ไข้ขึ้นเลย! เมื่อแฝดโดนจัดเต็มวัคซีนครบ2เดือน🤒 [cc] แดนแพทตี้ SS2 | EP.54 |](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/z2VHItnyyvY/mqdefault.jpg)
Xianbei - Buryat (khori dialect)
3 - gur - gurben
7 - dolu - doloon
30 - gurcin - gushan
1000 - min - myangan
10000 - tumen - tumen
Gold - altun - altan
Brother - aqa - akhai
Take - bar - barikha
Inscriptions - bitig - besheg
Official - bitigcin - besheeshe
Grey - bor - boro
You - ci - shi
Wolf - cirno - shono
Knife - hir - eri (blade) - ir (Mongolian khakh dialect)
Cultivate - hurgay - urguulkha
Official - irgin - erkheten - irgen (Mongolian khalkh dialect
Arrow - jebe - zebseg (weapon)
Hymn - magtal - magtaal
Bald - muquli - mukhar
Dog - naqan - nokhoi
Peace - nayra - nayr (celebration, feast)
Sheep - quriqa - khurigan (lamb)
Khan - qagan - khaan
Khatun - qagtun - khatan
Cloud - ulen - uulen
well because buryats are mongol tribesmen
@@t3ngristtt Yes Buryad is more achaic and closer to medieval Mongolian than Khalkha
@@barguttobed medieval mongolian? Khalkhas are those mongols who were always in homeland under uguedei and tului families. Its just a term name which appeared in 15th century. Dayan khan gave this name to central mongols, which khalkha means "to cover-to shield" so they will defend the homeland forever.
@@t3ngristtt I mean linguistically, Khalkha mongolian evoluate more than Buryad, and some phonetics changed. Buryad preserved more achaic traits.
@@barguttobed so you wanna say that khalkha mongols forgot their original archaic traits yet buryats has it all like before? you must be joking.... i have tons of buriyat firends, most of them cant speak buriyat only few older ones speak, but barely not that good with so litlle vocabulary base. tbh russian buryats lost their own language due to switching to mainland russian language so the mongol language among russian buiyats already lost and stuck at some point and haven't developed since 1990s. today 90% of russian buriyats dont even know their language. meanwhile, on the other hand, khalkha still uses ancient traditional core and in combination with new without touching archaic traits
The pronouncer is a Chinese person learning Turkish (according to his comment on bilibili), so for this reason it’s may make this language sounds a bit like Turkish
“评论区有人提到应该照蒙古语读法念，这种说法大概率是不对的，因为目前学术界一般认为早期蒙古语言的音系类似突厥语而非现代蒙古语。”
He emphasized that the academia believes the phonetics are closer to turkic than to modern mongolian languages.
in wikipedia say The Xianbei are thought to have spoken Mongolic or para-Mongolic languages, with early and substantial Turkic influences
Yes, the accent (which we would have no way of knowing anyways) is distinctly Turkish
I can recognize 30-40% words especially numbers. But sentences are impossible to understand. I’m Mongolian.
In Kalmyk and Buryat dialects it is easier to understand, because our dialects are more archaic and didn't change as much as central Mongolian
@@afasdfas Тийм
I understand 70-80 percent
Only 40 percent?
@@afasdfaswhat words you understand?
most ancient countires in Northern China was created by Xianbei. Royal families of Sui and Tang dynasties were half Xianbei. Most Northern Chinese should have varying degree of Xianbei Ancestry.
Xianbei is ancestor of mongolic, and also appears to have close connection to proto Turkic people. If you think about it, the map is huge for this Turkic-Mongolic-Xianbei related people
Tang dynasty was turk alliance and turk are highly respected not xiagbei
@@heaven.123 Turks was occupied by Tang dynasty . They are not turkic people at all
Xianbei was Proto-Mongolic people not turkic . Have no match with turkic people
@@heaven.123 Ruling class from the Northern Wei all the way to Tang dynasties were almost exclusively sinacized Xianbei. They originated in Inner Mongolia. The Gokturks were eventually conquered by these dynasties and drafted into their armies to fight their wars (particularly in Manchuria), according the ancient Turkic scripture in the Orkhon Valley.
@@heaven.123 Ru saying they don't respect themselves?
I am Inner Mongolian, I can tell that this language is very close to ancient Mongolian. A lot of words here are same as ancient Mongolian but no longer spoken by us.
Many words still in use
80 хувь нь бүгд ойлгогдож байна, хэрэглэдэг үгнүүд байна
because most modern mongols are khalkha and khalkha were from the very northern tip of mongolia.
You clearly know nothing about the history
@@johnthiam2446
@@johnthiam2446Khalkha itself has various tribes from different parts of Mongolia . I’m from Olkhonud tribe and we mostly inhabited in north western part of Mongolia . Some others are from east Mongolia . You’re mistaken if you thought Khalkha Mongols only live in Mongolia . There are also some in Inner Mongolia and Xinjiang.
we call elder brother "aga" in Hokkien and we call dad "Aba" like Xianbi and Buriyats :)
Similarities between turkidh and xianbei
min-bin(1000)
ağyil-ahıl(animal house,house)
altun-altın(gold)
qağan-kağan(khan)
qağtun-hatun(women,khatun)
tağman-dağ(mountain)
Bor-Boz/gri(grey)
As Native Mongolian i understand almost 50%
Сайн уншвал 70-80 хувь байна л даа
Xianbei and Xiongnu are the ancestors of both Mongolic and Turkic peoples I think and it is there common origin thus.
It's commonly accepted that both Xianbei and Khitan were Mongols. Some scholars argue Xiongnu were pre-dominantly Turkic based on Chinese sources. However, they need more archaeological evidence to prove it.
Yes half of Xiognu Turkic half we’re oirad buryat kalka and the Turks left Mongolic Asia and Turkic spreaded
@@RandomBestEdits there’s no evidence any of them were Turkic, or who Turkic people even were at the time
@@yo2trader539 How u can thinking that XIanbei is turkic? The language on video is clearly Mongolic
@@Fkindo-europeanarechaotic even how can this video tell there is lot of historical proof of xiongnu or xianbe and khitan in east side of mongolia
Bir çok eski Türkçe kelime duydum bu sesli okunan metinlerde...
As a Mongolian, i almost understand everything.❤️
As a Turkish, i understand like 40%
You must be one smart Mongolian
Me from Kazakhstan and yes! I understand this! :)
Nobody really can be certain how the Xianbei (鮮卑) spoke in the 4th century. (Xianbei phonetics can be reconstructed using what we know of various surviving Mongolian dialects.) Historical accounts indicate Xianbei are from present-day Inner Mongolia and eventually ruled most of China. In other words, ruling class of Northern Wei (北魏), Northern Zhou (北周), all way to the Tang dynasty were sinacized Mongols. This also explains why Tang dynasty had so many foreigners working in their court.
@@Weeping-Angel many of the words are now synonyms or near definition words. Ex: nair in xianbei is peace but nair in mongolian means cooperation, or agiyl means house in xianbei but in Mongolian ayil means household
I'm impressed you've got this very very EARLY language!
As a inner Mongolian I can only understand 60%
Hey bro
No no not inner. Its highly propagandist word
@@borgilbatbaatar4949 It's true though. Inner Mongolia has been and probably always will be Chinese-Mongol. Mongolia gained freedom due to Soviet pressure on China and became slavicized. I'm not pro-China but Mongolia's history in itself is very odd, Soviets wanted a buffer state between it and the weakening Chinese government at the time and pressured China into allowing Mongolia to break free with some violence happening. Inner-Mongolia was safely within Chinese rule during the period. Once Mongolia became independent Soviets began killing off Mongolian clergy and nobility and enforced Russian onto the Mongols living there. (China isn't any better, not cherishing the Mongols living in Inner-Mongolia by not teaching them the script or language due to state mandated single language schools in Mandarin). Thus, he is correct it's Inner-Mongolia.
Xianbei belongs to Xibe and Xubu and says Turkic khan founded
@@cqn6052 Back then Proto-Turkic and Proto-Mongolic were intertwined and many Khaganates and entities had both languages within. It's pretty dubious to say one is safely "Mongolic" or "Turkic" until those entities formed within the years 1000-1200 ish. Take a look at the Yugurs, the arguable successors to the ancient Uyghur Khaganate in the 6th century, they have the Western Yugur language which is a Turkic language and closely related to the far older Yeneseian languages and Eastern Yugur which is Mongolic in origin. Likely thing is, like all Turkic Khaganates at the time and before, they were split into East and West and therefore had 2+ languages they'd use commonly. Mind you, the Yugurs descend from Uyghur Khaganate nobility, with their name literally being derived from "western uyghur". These people fled the Islamization of the Turks and kept their Buddhist and Tengrist roots and kept their language alive.
Idk how but I could understand so many words as a Turkish.
Obviously Turkic language originated in South Siberia and Mongolia. Most of ancient runic Turkic alphabet is found in Mongolia and later the Yenisei river region. (Mongols on the otherhand were more concentrated in Inner Mongolia. Most Turkic tribes were purged from Outer Mongolia during the Mongol expansion, but some minority Turkic groups still reside in present-day Mongolia.) The close proximity and contact over thousands of years is why Turkic and Mongolian share common vocabulary, grammar, music, culture, religion, clothing, etc.
@@yo2trader539 No Mongols ancestors always lived in Outer Mongolia and Baikal region as well, turkic groups in Mongolia are recent migrants except for Tsaatan
@@barguttobed and buryats barga
@@RandomBestEdits Yes, buryats and Barga got same origins
@@yo2trader539tsaatan are actually immigrants. They were given land in Mongolia to live in the 1940-50s just like the Kazakhs were allowed to live in bayan ulgiy
I'm dhzungar mongol i understand 70percent
Mendee Brother! I'm Buryad, are you from Xinjan?
As a Korean person, it sound like Mongolian + Turkish.
It is clearly seen that as all Mongols, this Mongolic language is also highly influeced by Turkic language and culture.
Turkic Words > Xianbei Words
Miñ > Miñ ( A thousand)
Tümen > Tümen (Ten thousands)
Altun > Altun (Gold)
Emig > Amğa (Breast)
Bitig > Bitig (Inscription, Writ, Letter)
Bitigçi > Bitigçin (Official, Correspondent, Writer)
Boz (Bulgaric version: Bor ) > Bor (grey)
Tor (Bulgaric version: Çor) > Çur (stone)
Qır- (to massacre) > Kir- ( to kill)
Qırğuçı (massacrist) > Kirğayçin (assassin)
Qural (tool, weapon) > Qurağ (weapons)
Quralçı (weapon maker, weapon user, armed person) > Qurağçin (armed person)
Quzı (sheep) Quzığan ( plural sheep in old Turkic, Bulgaric version: Qurığan) > Quriqa (sheep)
Qapaqçı (gatekeeper, guard, qapaq: gate) > Qapaqçin (guard)
Qağan (Khagan) > Qağan (Khan)
Xatun/Qatun (Sogdian Xwatwen, xwa : self-, + auto, -taw (powerful, ruling) + en , feminine noun maker) > Qağtun
Tağlar ( mountains, tağ: mountain) > tağnar (mountain)
Toğan (hawk, falcon, from the verb toğ - : to rise, arise ) > Toyğon (eagle)
Üreñ ( white, cloud white) > Ülen (cloud)
Yıltırğan (brilliant, bright, from the verb yıltır- to be bright, brighten, shine, from the same root, yıltız, star) > Yiltuqan (bright)
Yükseg (high, from the verb yüküze - to heighten, Bulgaric version: yükrüg) > jiru
Beg (Bey, Chieftain) > Begeynar
Erkin (Freeman, noble, from the erk, power) > Hergin
Those words are originally Mongolian and not borrowed from Turkic languages
@@barguttobed That's not true. None of them has Mongolian roots that explain their root and suffix relations. But Turkic has verbal roots for each of them. If a word in Turkic cannot be explained by its root, it is not Turkic. All the words above can be explained by Turkic roots. Mongolian cannot explain the word roots.
1)Miñ, Bi - or Mi - To get on, to be added on
2) Tümen, A Tocharian word Tmane borrowd by Turkic and then passed to Mongolian.
3) Altun, Al- Red, Reddish
4) Emig, Em- To suck
5) Bitig, Biti- To write, to draw, (especially with a sharp thing) > bi- to sharpen
6) Boz, bo- to destroy, to make unusable, to change main characteristics, to distort, to mix different things
7) Tor, to- to collect
8) Qır- Qı- to stab, to bleed with a knife. Another related Turkic word qılıç (sword)
9-Qural, Qur- To found, to arrange, to make
10-Quzı, Qu- to breed, to cub
11-Qapaqçı, qapa- to close, to shut, to cover, to block
12- Tağ, ta- to raise, to add on, to attach
13- Toğan, Toğ- To rise up, to arise, to ascend
14- Üren, Ür- To engage in, To produce, To increase, to widen (clouds increase and cover the sky)
15-Yıltırgan , yıltır- to be bright, brighten
16-Yükseg, Yük, Load burden, yüküz- to add loads, add loads on, burden up
17-Beg, An Iranian word related to Bhagha ( Lord, God)
18-Erkin, er- to ripe, to grow, to reach. erk, growth, reaching, reaching the power, power and erkin, potent, powerful
@@nadirhikmetkuleli7335 You don't speak any Mongolian and trying to give some explanation about our language? What a joke. It is clear that Mongolic and Turkic languages are related because share the same roots. But for Xianbei it is obvious more related to Mongolic than Turkic.
Both Turkic and Mongolic people are related and have the same roots originated from the Hongshan culture in the area of modern Inner Mongolia. Ancient Turkic were indistinguishable from Mongolic people.
@@afasdfas Yeah that is true. Xianbei/Donghu is Proto Mongol, Xiongnu is Turkic. But they are too similar because both sons of Altai.
as a Khalkha Mongol i can understand a lot, 70 percent
Don’t try to connect yourself to nomadic East Asian warriors that were indeed of para mongolic descent khalkha. You khalkhas are Buddhist foreigners
@@Paxia you have an identity problem because you are a greek hittite anatolian who try to connect himself to steppe empires. Do a dna test and you will see. Don't try to steal mongol history to resolve your weak identity problem. Mongols are close to ancient Xianbei and Xiongnu, and Khitans. Just look at illustrative dna lol
It means mongol people just conquered china over and over again
@@이재명각하만세what you mean?
Xianbei belongs to Xibe and Xubu and says Turkic khan founded
Xinabey and Kalmyk-Mongol language
carguycin-zarguyci
Ci-Ci
Cirno-cino
derbel-debel
diga-degter
eben-ebesun
hacin-hoto
Irgin-irgin
horay-garh
Irgindiga-irginta
gur-gurvn
Dolu-dolan
gurcin-gucin
Tumen-tumen
altun-altin
aqa-aha
Bitig-bicig
Bitigein-biciqcin
Bor-bor
Jebe-zebe
Kile-kele
Magtal-magtal
noqan-noha
qow-qaha
quriqa-quriqin
Tag-teg
Ulen-ulen
The Xianbei language is absolutely an ancestor of the Mongolian languages. Almost every word has its Mongolian equivalent.
Some of these words are in Turkish.
@@Secular_Turkishthere is no proof that some of this words has turkic origin, for example word
Bar(means “take” in all turkic languages, and turks are trying to prove that word “bar” has turkic origin
But there is mongolian ancient word “barih” which means also take or hold. Since the Xiongu empire was confederation of all nomadic people (mongolic, turkic and tungusic), you should say that this words are common words
Xiongnu and Huns ruled the Mongols, but they were not Mongols, they were Turks@@buryat-mongol_2000
@@buryat-mongol_2000The state was founded by Turks, its army was Turks, their language was Turkish and their rulers were Turks. In Chinese sources, Huns and Xiongnu are mentioned as Turks.
Maybe it depends on the pronunciation but this sounds mot Turkic than Mongolic
Brilliant piece work, may I ask how did you come to know this is how Xianbei sounded like,
Sorta to how scholars know what PIE sounded like
Absolutely great video! May I ask where did you find the vocabulary about Serbi language? Thanks!
Looks like mostly mongolian words, but I can pick up a few Turkic words (I am Kazakh)
This video has too many Turkic orginal words.
My hasag pisda yah geji baitag bogdiir darhan
it is not stealing bro :) think about it same religion same lifestyle almost same names ?(chagatai-batu...)
the sample text belongs to Huis Tolgoi.his stone text was found in Mongolia. it i its date is 580. this time there was GökTürk Khaganate in Central asia and Mongolia. (that is why text says Türk kağan(khan).)
The Inscription of Hüis Tolgoi (HT) is a monolingual inscription in a Mongolian language[1] found in Bulgan Province, Mongolia in 1975 by D. Navaan. The 11-line text is written in vertical Brahmi script running right to left with horizontal marks separating words. The language of the inscription was unknown until the joint expedition of Alexander Vovin, Étienne de la Vaissière, Dieter Maue and Mehmet Ölmez to Mongolia in 2014 for closer imaging of the stele. Due to certain morphological peculiarities the language of the inscription was hypothesized to be Mongolic rather than Turkic. The language, "which can be conditionally termed as a variety of Para-Mongolic," is "much closer to the mainstream Mongolic languages, such as Middle Mongolian and modern extant Mongolic languages than to Serbi-Khitan,"[2] and is beyond reasonable doubt some form of Mongolic, close to the mainstream Mongolic language
@@PimsleurTurkishLessons Not hypothesized but proved, its clearly Mongol man, not turkic
The Xianbei completely defeated the Xiongnu and drove the Xiongnu from the Mongolian plateau to Central Asia.If you read Shiji, the Xiongnu were originally surrendered to the Donghu (ancestor of the Xianbei people)
Xianbei were Monoglic clans from Inner Mongolia, but Chinese records say the Yuwen clan of Northern Zhou ruling family had Xiongnu heritage. Xiongnu was a collection of dozens of clans, so I don't think they were completely defeated or pushed out. It's more like musical chairs with different clans becoming top dog depending on the era.
Podemos conversar , fui rourana en vida pasada.. quienes eran los rourana? Investigué y mencionan que posiblemente eran de xianbei. Amo mucho todo lo asiático soy de América central. Agradezco tu información.
No originally Donghu were subjects of Xiongnu, thanks to Modu Chanyu.
@@yo2trader539 Xiongnu were Proto-Turkic the Donghu were Proto-Mongolic. Both had intermarriage, with Chinese and each other. Modun Chanyu defeated the Donghu and absorbed them if I can remember correctly.
@@salvatorenostrade3331There isn’t any specific point to prove that Xiongnu was Turkic
Монгол Халимаг Буриад Тува Өвөр Монгол
Can you do one on the mandinka language or Krio from Sierra Leone or Temne.
I need a volunteer. :D
@@ilovelanguages0124 can u do Xiong I please I am ur number one fan
This language sounds more turkish than turkish itself
Because Turkish it self is not really soo Turkic
The origin of the earliest Turkish monarchs are Armenian servants ruled by real Turk, and then these Armenian influenced by Turkic language invaded Eastern Rome/Greece, now the majority of modern Turkish people after Ottoman empire are mostly white Greek people and ancient Armenian (Middle East white people), while real Turk(already had extinction before modern era) are the most common kind of Asian people like Mongol.
Ironically, these Armenians believing them self as Turkic massacred Armenians, their own people.
@@riza-2396 Meanwhile 84% of Turkish is Turkic.
It's Mongolic, the way does it sounds doesnt matter + its reconstruction i dont think that it sounded like this. All thing is matter that structure and vocabulary of this language show that its definitely Mongolic
Xianbei: aqa(brother) / / / Turkish: ağa(brother)
Xianbei: baç(patron) / / / Turkish: baş(head, leader)
Xianbei: bor(grey) / / / Turkish: boz(grey)
Xianbei: tağ(land) / / / Turkish: dağ(mountain)
Buryad land tag gazar
Xianbe grey bor buryat boro
Bac buryat patron
Aqa aha buryat aha xianbe aqa
All those words are Mongolic
There are very few information on Xianbei language. Two inscriptions belong to the Proto-Turkic.
Proto-Turkic sounds closer to Proto-mongolic. Therefore, the ancient Turkic people were closer to Mongolians instead of Central Asian and Turkeys from the genetic perspective(Except for Kazakh/Tuvas).
No, the words I present in the first part of the video are reconstructed basing on the Chinese transliteration during 3-6 century
your turk ?
Thats probably not entirely true. Kipchaks and Cumans (Present day Qazaqstan and Kyrgyzstan) can trace their origins all the way back to the yellow river basin in Eastern Asia. Mongolians originate from Inner Mongolia ironically (I know I know) and Turks especially ancient ones were from Manchuria and Mongolia/Siberia. It was only with Mongolian expansion and the hostilities between Kipchaks and Uyghurs + Mongols became unbearable is when the Kipchaks left for Central Asia nd consequently kicked out the Oghuz turks to Anatolia and Western Asia.
Most Kyrgyz are an accurate depiction of how Turkic people would havr looked long ago.
Maybe with a bit of Chinese blood due to Yenesei Kyrgyz intermarrying with Tang dynasty.
Due to my knowledge of Mongolian, I can understand some Xianbei which is surreal.
Миний Монгол хэл чадвар учраас, зарим Xianbei ойлгодог чаддаг байна, Xianbei хэл Моннол хэлын өвөг зэрэг гэж юм шиг байна.
As a Khalkha Mongol i understood 50%
Not good it would be 70-80 percent to me
As a Turkish we use 'aqa' (aga,abi,brother), 'altun' (altın, gold), 'min' (bin, 1000), 'qağtun' (hatun, woman), 'qağan' (Kağan, Khan) 'tağnar' ( dağ, dağlar, mountain)
It's like Old Turkic between Old Mongolian
Cool is an understatement. Is there anything you haven’t covered yet?!?
Probably like this sounded also the Avar language. I read that the name mongol comes from the name of a khan of the ruanruan empire
Xianbei And Turkish
Tümen - Tümen
Altun - Altın
Bor - boz(gray)
Qağan - Kaan/kağan
Qağtun - Kadın/hatun
Tağ - Dağ(mountain)
Min - Bin
Aqa - Aga
Eben - Çimen
Mağtun - Hatun
Even hear, they talk about Niri Qagan, Qagan of the Turks. Also many turkic words.
So that's where jebe's name comes from. Commander of Genghis Khan army. And Names like temucin must be 'person who temu' even though I don't know what temu is.
Andy please do rouran next and xiongnu
rouran and bumin khan 🐺🏹🦾🇹🇷
@@Orjinadam1189 the rouran are Mongols. There are no Chinese or other sources talking of the Turkmen at the time suggesting they either were of no Importance or still lived in Yakutai Siberia
@@Orjinadam1189 Turkish npc thinks that the rourans were Turkish 😂
@@Orjinadam1189dude who said rouran is turkish
@@Orjinadam1189rourans are xianbei descendant and u turks are just slave and xiongnu is mongolic because slab grave culture is mongolic its the makurs descendant even xiongnu words like tegri , tarqan, meheer, delu, nuruugun,niru,uul,arhad
Even i dont want to even fight on history with turkic and mongol
History and we are descendant of donghu to
Mongolian and turkish languages sound so same.
Really?
Not turkish
Mongolian language
Guhtureg not turkish
Түрэг бол эртний Монгол аймаг
@@dakidaki5703 until Cengiz Han named your tribes mongols there wasnt anything as mongols you were bunch of yellow tribes worthless russian vassal
@@dakidaki5703copium
@@dakidaki5703 not really. Quite the opposite. Turks were always the majority in the steppes. Mongols werent that populated. There are tens of different Turkic countries all around the world and there is just one Mongolia.
Even under the genghis khans rule,many soldiers of the mongolian empire were Turks.
Türküm kelimelerin önemli bir kısmı harf değişimleriyle Türk dilinde bulunan kelimeler örneğin koyun anlamına gelen "kuraqa" Türk dilinde koyun yavrusu "Kuzu" R Z değişimi
So, the oldest attested form of "qaghan", "qaghatun", "altun" etc. is Xianbei and it's thought Turkic and other Mongolic languages borrowed these words from Xianbei, right?
@noble crow how can you be so sure?
Xianbei is mostly Para-Mongolic. Their language has some Turkic loanwords. We don't really know those words' origin, we can't be sure.
No, the words kağan, hatun, and Altın are of turkic origin, but turks and mongols lived with each other for so long, so its actually loan words of turkic to Mongolian
1) Kagan is Mongolized Iranic title *hwa-kama- (self-ruler), the lexeme was in Sogdian language as xutkame-
*hwá "self" < *swé "self"
*káHmah "wish" < *kóh₂-mo-s "wish"
2) Altun "red copper" can be a Turkic calque from Chinese 火銅 (literally: fiery copper/bronze), if the word *āl "red" is cognate to root *yal- "fire" (Turkish: alev "fire" from root *yal-)
*tun ~ *tunç "bronze/copper" < 銅 [tūŋ]
@@aboba5995 lol keep dreaming
I appreciate your work and content. Keep it up
miñ, tümen, altun, amğa, baç, bitig, bitigçin, bor, çarğuyçin (and the suffix -çin) are of Turkic origin.
It is very similar to old turkic language, I am half mongol
I love mongol people❤️🇲🇳
Hail to our cousins
Turks And Mongol Language wooww
Thank you
As an Indian I understood exactly one word and that is bodhisattva 😂
Love the language though
😅
So sweet, simply an old dialect of our modern Mongolian languages. Amazing, given that the Xianbi people spoke it about 2000 years ago! They were part of The Hunnu/Xiongnu Empire and succeeded the latter. That means I am speaking indeed a "long-living", old language.
Xiongnu next?
Bro:- can you tell about da Yuezhi tribe origin They are indo Iranian tribe? Hephthalite or Yuezhi are same/ different tribes? I belong to Jat's tribe y haplogroup L-m11 36% , R-m207 28%, Q-m242 15% (northern Pakistan and India)
@@indo.iranian.Jat.007The Hephthalites and Yuezhi are Turkic peoples. The enemies of the Turks distorted the history of the Turks
Min (OldTurkic: Min)(Turkish: Bin).
Tümen (OldTurkic: Tümen)(Turkish: Tümen, on bin).
Altun (OldTurkic: Altun)(Turkish: Altın).
Agyil (OldTurkic: Agıl{house of animals})(Turkish: Ağıl).
Baç (OldTurkic: Baş)(Turkish: Baş{head, leader, first}).
Bitig (OldTurkic: Bitig)(Turkish: Biti, Kitap).
Bitigçin (OldTurkic: Bitigçi)(Turkish: Bitici, kitapçı).
Bor (OldTurkic: Boz) (Turkish: Boz).
Eben (OldTurkic: Çimgen)(Turkish(çim, çimen).
Hirçe (OldTurkic: Eçü Apa)(Turkish: Amca).
Mağa (OldTurkic: Baka{title:hard enough to break})(Turkish: Bağa{crustacean}.
Pari (OldTurkic: Bark)(Turkish: Bark{house}, yapı).
Qağan (OldTurkic: Qagan)(Turkish: Kağan).
Qağtun (OldTurkic: Qatun)(Turkish: Kadın).
Serbi (OldTurkic: Sarp{Hard})(Turkish: Sarp{hard place to pass}).
Tağ (OldTurkic: Tag{mountain})(Turkish: Dağ).
Tabgaç (Title of KaraKhaganete Khans).
Toyğon (OldTurkic: Torgay)(Turkish: Toygar{lark}).
Tümen (OldTurkic: Tümen{ten thousand, numerous)(Turkish: Tümen{big cluster, ten thousand troops}).
Jiru (OldTurkic: Yukaru{above})(Turkish: yukarı).
Xianbe is mongol old mongol min tumenshuud
Old mongol time in buurah tumen
Old buurah mongol grey bori
Arrow old buurah mongol zev
Altun old buurah mongol altu
So this is the language the huns probably spoke.
As a Mongolian I can say that Xianbei are Mongllians.Not turckik
80%тай ойлгож байна.
As an khalkha mongol i understand 90%
Yes it’s just the guy pronounce it with weird accent but all the words are same
@@barguttobed reader is turkish
@@barguttobed if i read this all of mongol audience will understand this
@@heliumboi8309 Yep and you totally right 👍🏼 Actually from reading in comments I found that the speaker is originally Chinese who learned Turkish, so that’s why he is forcing on Turkish accent to read this. Btw I’m sure Xianbei didn’t had that weird accent
@@barguttobed well as my estimate this would have medieval mongolic accent
Sounds very Turkic, although word roots are not recognizable...
@@PimsleurTurkishLessons turktard
Doesnt matter its mongolic. If u spell modern mongolian with Turkish accent it will sound turkic too
@@barguttobed it’s para mongolic not mongolic.
@@Paxia lol it’s still Mongolic language family dumb
@@Paxia "it’s para mongolic not mongolic" brother, say the sentence you wrote again, but slower and really think about your logic.
The Tagbach descendants moved to Byzantine territory which are today called Serbia (Xianbei=Serbi)
tabgach =turks 🤟
@noble crow NOO TURK 🐺🐺🐺🐺🏹🏹🇹🇷🇰🇿🇰🇿😑🇹🇷🇰🇿🇹🇷
What? No.
@noble crow No, look at the Chinese sources, there are tabgaç Turkish communities if you accept the Mongols as Turks, if you join, there were no Mongols in the past, there were Turks in the Chinese source. 🐺🏹🇹🇷🐺🏹🇹🇷🐺🇹🇷👍👍👍
Wait what!?
feels similar to Kazakh language
Sure turkic person reading this words and sentences. If mongolic person read this sounds different.
Very cool!
mostly interesting that im volga tatar and i understand half of words
Türkçeye çok benziyor
Türk ve moğol devleti
Çünkü bir sürü Türkçe alıntı kelime var ama dilin aslı para Moğolca
Please boss, make video about mongol language.
Can you do Faroese/Greenlandic next?
Brazil loves this people but this language is Impossible to understand.
*We Mongols call these proto-Mongols as the Sümbe nation: ᠰᠦᠮᠪᠦ Сүмбэ*
This is really unexpected , many thanks to this channel !
so it’s related to mongol language?
Xianbei is the ancestors of mongols
It's like mongolian with bit of accent
What script did xianbei use in history?
汉字啊 ，鲜卑人没有自己的文字 后来创制了自己的文字 使用范围比较小 在孝文帝改革之后就不怎么用了 看以后的考古了
I think xianbei language is what the huns speak litterly.
Im mongolia and somehow i can fully understanding our ancestor language😂
Perfect
Lol I understand every single word
As an mongol
Moghol language please
no mongol yes turkic
@@Orjinadam1189Not turkic yes mongolian
nice
xianbei and 汉language
土 = tu (land)
笔 =bi (pen)
新=sing (new)
In fact，汉 people is most lovely for xianbei😊😊😊
hun = turks ?
it's actually xin for new
like mongolian language
They were related to the mongols
Xianbei ancestor of Da Shiwei,Donghu,Tatar and Khitan
wow，xianbei is so much different then the xibe language, thats a surprise, it is so much so the father of turkic language
Waiting for comment "as a Mongolian native speaker......"
No wonder there's a famous Serbian quote: From Serbia to Tokyo 😁😉
Эн келн йир сәәхн !
As a Turkish, I understand quite a few words.
miñ, tümen, altun, amğa, baç, bitig, bitigçin, bor, çarğuyçin (and the suffix -çin) are of Turkic origin.
for the next video content, discuss the ancient languages of Nanyuei and Baiyuei, these languages have become extinct, possibly in the South China region 🙏
Source :
id.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanyue
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baiyue
Nanyue language would likely to be proto-Vietic or some Tai-Kadai language.
@@ToLeNam they austroasia and austronesia nation
there's also Minyue, an ancient kingdom in what is now Fujian province in southern China, and was later annexed by the Han empire as they expanded, many Chinese people moved south and intermarried with the locals there
What is the source for the vocabulary part?
100% PURE MONGOLIAN LANGUAGE !!! ❤
İt is strange for me The words don't seem foreign to my ears, but As a Turkish feels like i understand worlds but same time i dont understand. The ending shape of words is like the endings in Turkics languages.(,den,tan,ten,çin,rçin,kin,tin ,ran,uğra,dü,gü,etc)
aga and altyn turkic words!
Many other words too. Min, amğa, bor, bitig, bitigçin etc.
Aga and altyn is used in mongolian too
@@Munkhbayarkhavtgai моңғолдар түркілерден сөздерді және дәстүрлерді ұрлаған славяндар сияқты 🤦🤦🤦
I understand most of them, there are many Turkish words🇹🇷
Nasıl most of them kanka, birkaç kelime anca vardır Türkçe. Çoğu Moğolca kelimeler
Tamam abarttım birkaç kelimeden fazlası var ama genel olarak Türkçe-Moğolca karışımı
Xiangnu were the ancestors of turk while xiagbei are the ancestors of khitan and mongol. Turk and khitan were converted to Buddhism while tatar and mongol remain tengrist at that time.
dont lie xiongnu were a confederation of all following people. it contained everyone starting from mongolic, turkic, kyrgiz, and uighurs.
@@t3ngristtt Yenisei Kyrgyz were conquered by Xioungu, but ok
@@t3ngristtt kyrgyz and Uyghurs are literally all Turkic 😂
@@t3ngristtt all confederacies and empires were multi ethnic. But there’s literally no reason to deny the fact that the xiongnu was a Turkish empire. And I have the evidence that it was a Turkish empire lmao
@@Paxia They are para turkic😹 they don’t descends but parallel to Gokturks
So many turkic words. Almost like something between turkic and mongolic
Aramic please
Sounds very turkic
Dude how?
i'm mongol and half the words in this are in mongol language
Because turkic person is reading this
Some words are Turkic origin but main words are Mongolic
I think "The Xianbei Language" is not just a proto-Mongolic language. It's between Turkic and Mongolic. Actually Turkic and Mongolic languages are close relatives. So, this language is in between.
They're not related, but they've been in close contact for a long time so they converged
Xianbei are Donghu (Mongol), Xiognu are Turks
many indoeuropean words.
this is much earlier then turkic and mongolic, its their father~~
Turkic and Mongolic arent "genetically" (in the linguistic sense) related. No serious linguist still holds to the Altaic theory. The early forms of Turkic and Mongolic were essentially part of a sprachbund though, and that's the reason for the similarities
Proto mongolic has proto trukic influence
No you have proto-mongolic influence
@@barguttobed don’t bother arguing with this retard bro, this guy is one of those Turkish nationalists think that everything was turkic. I’ve even seen him claim that the donghu,xianbei,Liao dynasty,Mongol empire were Turkic 😂
@@barguttobed btw are you from Mongolia?
@@Str1ker793 Bro, i'm Buryad-mongol from Buryatia but i love all mongol people, e are one nation!
@@barguttobed I love my buryat brothers. You guys truly have a special place in my heart.
Very similar to mongolia
Whoa! One more historical minority language from China.Sound very interesting! I can spot some loanwods such as "min" from Chinese 万 ("maan" in Cantonese pronunciation) although here it means "thousand" not "ten thousand" like in Chinese, and "kir" I guess it's an Indo-European loanword since it sounds similar to English "kill".
it is Mongolia
Turkic and mongols
Xiongnu is ancestors of Turkic people.
Xiongbei is ancestors of Mongolic people.
I felt like I understood everything, but I just understood some words...😅😅
I definitely understood Tağbaç. Tağ maybe means mountain i think
It s like hungarian
@wratch it’s a joke. Because Hungarians came from asia
Sounds like a mix of Arabic, Manchurian, and Mongolian