Watching this after clearing CA. Feeling amazing and very proud of this person who helped so many under confident students to clear their CA journey. The best part is that he converts your mindset from " CA is very tough" to "I can do this, it's easy for me". Thank you once again. Best of luck to all Nov 24 students.
I don't know how my paper went .. but i will not let it hamper my idt preparation.... Going to give my best .... And mere haath mein abhi bs meri mehnat and yeh 1.5 days hai...
Aapne bola tha q1 last me karna aur mene wesa hi kiya..aur reading time me b last read Kia..pehle read b Kiya hota to confidence low ho jaata.. Thanks for everything Sir ..
2500 pages wale sir se class li thi ek heart attack to course dekh k aa hi gya tha 😢, phir aapki 250 pages wali book li or revision video se exam preparation kari. Last year November mai clear ho gya 2nd group easily. Thankyou so much ❤
Thank you so much sir..... mera paper acha gaya hai rahi baat electoral trust ke question ki to wo aapne guidance video me specifically mark karwaya tha ki ye question kar ke jana...... Again thanks a lot for everything radhe radhe🙏🙏
You need to change your playlist order, so that old videos appear first. Currently new videos appear before old videos, causing viewer to go from lecture 2 to lecture 1 after lecture 2 finishes. आपको अपनी प्लेलिस्ट का क्रम बदलना होगा, ताकि पुराने वीडियो पहले दिखें। वर्तमान में, नए वीडियो पुराने वीडियो से पहले दिखाई देते हैं, जिससे chapter 2 समाप्त होने के बाद chapter 2 से chapter 1 हो जाता है।
Thanks sir, not sure what will be the result, but yes I didn't buy DT classes, prepared from your youtube revision videos only. They were really helpful. Thanks a lot ✨
Sir May 2025 ke liye ICAI ne naya module upload kiya hai kya aap dt ke changes ka analysis karoge, nov 24 ke syllabus se padhe hai pehle apke videos se
My exam is on May 25. Atul Sir, I understand that one cannot read 600-700 pages before exams, but aren't your notes enough to get 60-70 marks? Please reply, Atul Sir. You are undoubtedly brilliant, Sir. I am asking just to enhance my confidence.
Insider information - ICAI also sees AIR1CA's ABC analysis and then increases the level of questions😂😂. ICAI be like - Answer question mei dedo, bcho ko question ki information nikalne do (Reference AFM exam)😂😂
Sir, In the question on S 44C ADJUSTMENT, i have computed 5% number correctly. I have wrote ATI excludes b/f dep, loss, chapter VIA. But provisoon I have written wrong. Instead of whichever is higher, I have written lower. So entire answer gonw wrong B/f steps adjustments I have done correctly for 5% computation. How much marks will be awarded? And please tell the genuine truth.
Hi sir. In the TP ques, it only "mark up" was mentioned, and nothing was given wrt whether on sales or cost. Is it okay if i have assumed the mark up on sales price instead of cost?
Purchase price 60 cr Sun inc was the 3rd party (unrelated customer) So its comparable uncontrolled transaction method Sun ltd and surya ltd are associated as guarantee more than 10% of borrowings at 20% Its book illustration
Sir, jo screen pe MCQ ka answers tick kiya hai, unme toh kuch basic galtiya dikh rahi hai.. ye aapne solve kiya hai, ya phir aise hi kisi student ka paper hai?
Sir adjusted total income me aapne joh notes me point de rakhe he usko add krne k bad ATI income negative ni aa rhai he but ye baki sir toh pata ni bol rhe he ki avg krna tha 😢
I think nov 24 will be one of the hardest attempt in ca history Overall review Fr- avg AFM - tough lengthy Audit - above avg / lengthy Dt - above avg/lengthy
I have taken your book and taken your classes also, I was soo satisfied by your style of teaching but today I realized that The notes are not enough! There wese a few topics in exams which are not there in the book. Eg electoral trust
Iske alawa sb book mai h already Krwaya tha ye topic bhi marathon mai pura 500-700 page ki book mai bhi ni milega vese electoral trust wla pura topic toh
@@AtulAgarwal 100% Agree with you sir, Your book is much much much better than 400-500 pages book. Agar 5 marks ka nhi bi aata toh kya dikkat h baaki 113 marks ka toh aara h na, aur humko attempt 100 marks ka attempt krna h. Thats it. Why to focus on irrelevant topics which comes rarely upto 4-5 marks. Your book is truely best and suitable for 1st time and last day revision.
Sir aapke aur Ajay sir ke review bahut he genuine rehte Baaki log to bss mere ye book se itna aaya maine ye solve kra ya tha wahi bolte Student ke wo exam hall me point of view se baaat he nhi krte
Sir your concept book is just awesome....market k teachers sirf anxiety dilate hain.
Watching this after clearing CA. Feeling amazing and very proud of this person who helped so many under confident students to clear their CA journey.
The best part is that he converts your mindset from " CA is very tough" to "I can do this, it's easy for me".
Thank you once again.
Best of luck to all Nov 24 students.
CA exams are just memory testing.... 🤢🤢🤢Who will focus that much on penalties...
True it is all about memory testing who can memorise it better
Absolutely
Or baad me industry wale rattu tota bolkr paise nahi dete 😂
@manikantayeswanth3458 sharam aani chaiye icai ko
Apnr aap ko cbse samjh rhe hai
Thoda toh lihaaj rkhe ye log
Honest Review of paper❤. Thank you sir 😊
Very tough......covered all chapters all topics ..penalty direct mcq 😮
Thank you Atul sir for your concept notes and question bank.
Became CA in May 2024 exams.
I don't know how my paper went .. but i will not let it hamper my idt preparation.... Going to give my best .... And mere haath mein abhi bs meri mehnat and yeh 1.5 days hai...
Good Attitude Bas Jitna Aajtak Padha hai Try to Revise as much as you can uske baad new dekhna kuch you will score for sure
Thats the right approach well done
All the best for idt exam u will rock ❤
Apna gyaan yaha mat ***d
Jaake padh chup chap
Beewakoof
Thankyou so much sir i was able to cover category A chps due to your notes and revision videos in 7 days.
Paper prima facie looked easy
But in every Q there were 1-2 new/unique points
Bhai jb result maintain krna hota icai ko toh aisa hi paper aata😂
Thanks for the most valuable gift for me "Shree Madbhagwat Geeta"
🙏 Radhe Radhe !
14:36 IDT
The DT concept book was extremely useful for efficient revision in a short amount of time.❤
Aapne bola tha q1 last me karna aur mene wesa hi kiya..aur reading time me b last read Kia..pehle read b Kiya hota to confidence low ho jaata.. Thanks for everything Sir ..
Bahuti helpful dt concept book otherwise in 1.5 days all syllabus cover too difficult
Kanha sab sambhal lenge ❤ Ab aage focus karo
बोलो वृंदावन बिहारी लाल की जय 🧡🧡 राधे राधे 🎉🎉🙏🙏💛💛
Thank you so much sir. All the books and revision lectures were very useful.
Sir bhle paper thoda hard lga lekin aapke level ka concept book aur khi nhi hai, its best❤
Thankuu so mch sir...Nov. 23 me sirf rev. Video dkh k or thda bht ee pd k gya tha bs...55 aa gye the or 2nd gp. Nikal gya tha
Group 2 be like: Group 1 tumhara hogya ho toh hum bi thode mje lele inke ?🤣😭
Thanks for honest review...baki sb log easy paper bta rhe nonsense log
Sir, just read from your concept book, and can say that ab DT tough nahi rahi.❤❤
Radhe Radhe💕
2500 pages wale sir se class li thi ek heart attack to course dekh k aa hi gya tha 😢, phir aapki 250 pages wali book li or revision video se exam preparation kari. Last year November mai clear ho gya 2nd group easily. Thankyou so much ❤
2500 page mei kon padha raha hai?
@@devanshgupta3685😂😂
Bhai kon he vo 2500 page wala sir bata 😢
Ur notes helped a lot brooo..... Thanku sooooo much.... ❤❤❤
Thank you so much sir..... mera paper acha gaya hai rahi baat electoral trust ke question ki to wo aapne guidance video me specifically mark karwaya tha ki ye question kar ke jana...... Again thanks a lot for everything radhe radhe🙏🙏
You need to change your playlist order, so that old videos appear first. Currently new videos appear before old videos, causing viewer to go from lecture 2 to lecture 1 after lecture 2 finishes.
आपको अपनी प्लेलिस्ट का क्रम बदलना होगा, ताकि पुराने वीडियो पहले दिखें। वर्तमान में, नए वीडियो पुराने वीडियो से पहले दिखाई देते हैं, जिससे chapter 2 समाप्त होने के बाद chapter 2 से chapter 1 हो जाता है।
Radhe Radhe ❤
Radhe radhe sir 🙏 aapke notes and question bank se group 2 cleared🙏
Radhe radhe sir aap ajay sir surendra sir aur sachin sir ne bht help kri h fulll end tk support thank u so much sir😊😊❤
Radhe Radhe bhaiya🙏
paper kaisa gya pta nhi.... lekin 6 marks ka ek silly mistake ki vjh se glt kia to dimag me bs vhi ghum rha hai kahi vo mistake attempt na lga de bss
Bhai mere kahani bhe same he hai small mistake aur gaye number 😢😢
Your concept book was amazing
Thank you so much sir...
Because of you people only I became a CA in the May 24 attempt ...❤❤❤❤
Thanks for all the efforts you make for all of us. ❤
Thank you Sir🙏
Radhe radhe ❤
The G.O.A.T. of CA Fraternity
Thankyou sir ❤
Ab yaato IDT exempt hoga yaato me
Ek aur teacher ki concept book li thi phle.. but usko dekha hi nahi gya.. thanks to krishn ji ki aapki concept book dekhi Maine..🫰😍
Abki baar paper ache level pr rhe h
Sir is paper me jo MCQ K answers tick h vo aapne solve kiya h?? Plss reply??
Bhaiya audit may 25 ki concept book kb order ke liye available honge
Atul sir dt 250 pages concept book> 2500 pages dt book radhe radhe sir❤❤
Aap kiñke bare me bat kr rhe ho it will be helpful for me to take my Dt classes wisely
@niraj_kashyup blindly follow Ajay sir, atul sir and surender sir definitely you will do good in exam surely 😃
Thanks sir, not sure what will be the result, but yes I didn't buy DT classes, prepared from your youtube revision videos only. They were really helpful. Thanks a lot ✨
Sir
May 2025 ke liye ICAI ne naya module upload kiya hai
kya aap dt ke changes ka analysis karoge, nov 24 ke syllabus se padhe hai pehle apke videos se
❤
Sir app ca inter ka dt start karne wale ho plz bata dijeye
Mcq answer.. I checked it... I m quiet low 😔not getting even 15
My exam is on May 25. Atul Sir, I understand that one cannot read 600-700 pages before exams, but aren't your notes enough to get 60-70 marks? Please reply, Atul Sir. You are undoubtedly brilliant, Sir. I am asking just to enhance my confidence.
More than sufficient
Question 2 part b kya rha...pareshan kar diya
Dt notes bhout acche h.
Institute always plays cleverly
Sir your concept book MAY 2025 KI KAB AAYEGI SITE PE
Transfer pricing is mark up question and not profit margin
Question kaa level Tod fodd thaa ...
Har baar paper syllabus se retaa hai lekin level faad k rakh deta hai
Sir transfer pricing me sili mistake ho gayi 😢😢
Insider information - ICAI also sees AIR1CA's ABC analysis and then increases the level of questions😂😂. ICAI be like - Answer question mei dedo, bcho ko question ki information nikalne do (Reference AFM exam)😂😂
Idt 14:36
MCQ 24/30 😌
Sir pls give answerrs to descriptive
Dt above avg + lengthy
Sir please MCQ ke answer discuss karo please. I think a lot of mcqs marked by the student in this pdf are incorrect.
I wanna know the correct answer
Sir, In the question on S 44C ADJUSTMENT, i have computed 5% number correctly. I have wrote ATI excludes b/f dep, loss, chapter VIA. But provisoon I have written wrong. Instead of whichever is higher, I have written lower. So entire answer gonw wrong
B/f steps adjustments I have done correctly for 5% computation. How much marks will be awarded?
And please tell the genuine truth.
Mera to GRP2 pass he no tension
Hi sir. In the TP ques, it only "mark up" was mentioned, and nothing was given wrt whether on sales or cost. Is it okay if i have assumed the mark up on sales price instead of cost?
Maine Cost pe Assume Kiya. Can someone clarify this ?
Purchase price 60 cr
Sun inc was the 3rd party (unrelated customer)
So its comparable uncontrolled transaction method
Sun ltd and surya ltd are associated as guarantee more than 10% of borrowings at 20%
Its book illustration
Markup means always on cost only basic costing hai
@@shreya.8255 yes
GP is always assumed to be on sales but there are questions where it has been taken on cost. Hence clarifying. Thanks anyways.@@shreya.8255
Sir ap iss paper pr I am sure 88-93 le aate bcz you are air 1 ❤
Arm length prive kya h
Sir, what if I took book value of Land (instead of SDV) in slump sale wala question? Will I get zero?
😂 yes
Sir isme MCQ ke jo answers tick hain kya wo aapne kiye hain ya kisi bache ke hain please reply
Student k h vo
@AtulAgarwal thanks sir
GRP2 tough this time
Above average to tha
Are these mcqs answer correct which are marked in this paper??
No
Tough laga sir mujhe..bahut dukh horahe sir..kya kare aabbb😢😢
Abhi idt pe focus kro
Ok sir@@AtulAgarwal
Sir, jo screen pe MCQ ka answers tick kiya hai, unme toh kuch basic galtiya dikh rahi hai.. ye aapne solve kiya hai, ya phir aise hi kisi student ka paper hai?
Student ka h paper
Muje to easy lga paper....
Sir adjusted total income me aapne joh notes me point de rakhe he usko add krne k bad ATI income negative ni aa rhai he but ye baki sir toh pata ni bol rhe he ki avg krna tha 😢
Glt bol rhe
Jo isme MCQ ke answer mark kar rakhe h , wo saare shi h kya 😅 ?
Arm length price kya thi
59.08
Extra gyan wale😂😂
I think nov 24 will be one of the hardest attempt in ca history
Overall review
Fr- avg
AFM - tough lengthy
Audit - above avg / lengthy
Dt - above avg/lengthy
😂
Aapne Audit Kaha se kia Tha?
@@adityasoni4617 self
@@adityasoni4617 self
@@adityasoni4617 self
Namaste sir
Bhai ratta maarne ka exam hai🙄☠️
I have taken your book and taken your classes also, I was soo satisfied by your style of teaching but today I realized that The notes are not enough! There wese a few topics in exams which are not there in the book.
Eg electoral trust
Iske alawa sb book mai h already
Krwaya tha ye topic bhi marathon mai pura
500-700 page ki book mai bhi ni milega vese electoral trust wla pura topic toh
@AtulAgarwal UN model Para 6 se jo question aaya wo bhi nahi hai book mai.
This is not to disrespect you but an observation.
@@AtulAgarwal 100% Agree with you sir, Your book is much much much better than 400-500 pages book. Agar 5 marks ka nhi bi aata toh kya dikkat h baaki 113 marks ka toh aara h na, aur humko attempt 100 marks ka attempt krna h. Thats it. Why to focus on irrelevant topics which comes rarely upto 4-5 marks. Your book is truely best and suitable for 1st time and last day revision.
@@Nishamalviya00 shi se dkho ap
Same to same question h vo
Sir notes me he electoral trust concept notes me@@AtulAgarwal
Sir aapke aur Ajay sir ke review bahut he genuine rehte
Baaki log to bss mere ye book se itna aaya maine ye solve kra ya tha wahi bolte
Student ke wo exam hall me point of view se baaat he nhi krte
Mcq k ans dedo ja
Is br 5 se 7% both Grup result ho ga
G1 9%
G2 15% approx
MCQ answers Wo hi hai ? Exam ka ?
I don’t think so
@user-so3ii6zj8u Its not i almost got demotivated
Radhe Radhe Sir Ji🙏
Radhe Radhe🙏