All Quiet on the Western Front (2022) REACTION
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ย. 2024
- ✔ Viki - linktr.ee/viki...
✔ Lia - linktr.ee/liav...
✔ Michelle - linktr.ee/Mich...
✔ Ellie - / ellielandgo
✔ Larry - / larrymoorebg
The Homies TikTok - / thehomiesshorts
The Homies Instagram - / thehomiesshorts
Check out our Full Movie/TV Shows Reactions on Patreon :)
✔ PATREON - / thehomiesreact
✔ For early reactions you can join as a member:
/ @thehomiesreact
✔ Twitch - / the_homiestv
✔ Twitter - / the_homiestv
✔ Discord - / discord
Thats no romanticize, no Hollywood!!! Shows the hell on earth! One of the best anti war movies ever!!!
The book was written by a man who was a German soldier. The main character was inspired by him specifically and if I recall correctly the scene with Paul in the hole with the Frenchman was a real thing that happened
Also due to this book the autor needed to scape Germany before the WW2 started
I think the soldier who wrote the book was Erik Maria Remarque.
Yes everything was real except he’s death!
Probably happened many times
the movie is loosely based on the book
Was lucky enough to catch this in a great cinema, and it was a very intense experience. And people were almost quiet walking out afterwards - everyone were in shock it seemed like. Truly one of the best anti-war movies made in a long time!
Now, I'm not a fan of war movies in general. This all changed when I saw this movie. Never have I been able to experience such happiness, pain, sadness, regret, nor fear through someone else's eyes, and I think I would purely consider it to be beautiful. I truly believe that this is one of the best, 10/10 films that I have ever seen.
That's because this is not a war movie, but an anti-war movie
@@tilltronje1623Every good war movie is an anti-war movie. Think Apocalypse Now, Full Metal Jacket, Das Boot.
@@ropeburn6684 so Saving Private Ryan is a bad war movie? Got it
@@tilltronje1623 It's a good war movie because the best parts of it are actually anti-war.
Like the whole premise. A whole bunch of guys need to risk life and limb just to save one other guy, because that's what you do in a war. Everyone suffers because war sucks big time, but you still gotta beat your buddy out.
A rather strong anti-war message, don't you think?
@@ropeburn6684 I really don't think, no.
The whole thing is nothing more than a heroic adventure mission. Saving a life because it's "the right thing to do"! Against all the oods! Against the backdrop pf the heroic allies saving the world from evil.
Don't pretend that is anti war. Any suffering that occurs is literally just a plot device that makes the characters even more heroic by braving the cruelty and carrying on regardless. It's not final, nothing that stays with them. Tom Hanks doesn't even die against the tank ffs. And crucially: they succeed. That is not anti war at all
Greetings from Germany, thank you for reacting to this heavy piece of cinema... actually, in German with English subtitles it feels a bit more authentic, but they did quite well here, with the dubbing, so it doesn't take much from the experience... A very tough movie to watch, indeed.. read the book and watched both movies of it before this, both great in their own style. In case you are up for an even more accurate despiction in a war movie, I'd recoomend you watching the (imo) best German movie of all times, "Das Boot" ... but if you go for that, please make sure to watch the German version with English subtitles, because there, they really fucked up the dubbing ;) take care and stay the same!
I agree with this statement. I’m more of a dubbed movie watcher because I have dyslexia and hate reading. But they really messed up the dubbed version of Das Boot.
YES,much better with sub-titles , Das Boot is fantastic, claustrophobic ,tense, good characters,well worth seeing.
And when you have watched "Das Boot" continue with watching "Stalingrad" from 1993 and "Generation War" from 2013.
I remember reading this book in high school, written by a German soldier, I saw this in a cinema , excellent anti war movie. I knew this would tear Vicki up.
I'm German and My Great Grandfather (born 1889) was lucky to have been gassed during Verdun in 1916 because that made him unable to continue fighting and therefor he not only survived WWI but also managed to survive WWII without having to serve because of his French Gas Disabilities.
Anyway, He lived until 1996 so i got to know him because i'm born in the mid 1980s.
And he remained a Hunter but i remember one time during New Years Eve, one of our Neighbors went all out on Fireworks including using some questionable Polish or Czech "Böller" as we called them. And when that went off my then 105 year old Grandpa like 5 minutes after Midnight suddenly started shaking, threw up over our Table and then slowly get off his chair and very slowly move his old frail body under the Dinner Table, shaking uncontrollably and we were unable to talk to him until the next Morning.
Meaning he was 105 years old and sat under that Table shaking from around 00:10am to 6-7:00am in the Morning.
This experience was the Reason why i decided to become a Historian here in Germany and of course join the Military myself (having basic was mandatory when i turned 18) and i ended up serving 6 years including in Combat.
I now focus on PTSD and other combat-related Psychological Issues.
My other Relatives, especially my German WW2 Veteran Grandfathers and Granduncles helped me a lot with my Research as they mostly spent a ton of time in anti-partisan warfare and Eastern Front Combat.
Just thought i share that because to this day, having been to Afghanistan myself 2 times i can say that PTSD and Combat in both WWI and WWII was far worse on the Psychology of a Soldier than what us Soldiers experience nowadays.
Yet i would have never known with most WW2 Vets i met that they hat PTSD because it was such a Taboo when the War ended, they managed to put on a Mask and hide it very well.
Prost & Cheers from the Bavarian Alps
Omg, the story with your grandfather under the table is so sad!
I aint reading all dat
RIP to your grandfather🖤
@@Iamnodannie_YT skill.issue.
@@bubba418 epic
Not sure why people would watch a German movie in English? Completely ruins it.
Exactly!!! 🙄
It’s more convenient than having the tiny captions on the already-tiny screen share
It’s better in German I agree
Thank you ladies for your authentic reactions to a movie about one of the most shocking times in European history. Having seen this you will appreciate "1917" and "Passchendaele" - not suggesting you watch them unless you want to put yourselves through similar levels of distress.
I've been to Belgium where a lot of the combat on the Western Front took place and walked among original sections of trenches and marvelled at how much of the "iron harvest" (unexploded mines, bombs, shells, gas canisters, etc) is still being dug up over 100 years later.
If you ever get to go to Belgium take a look around Ypres. It's a lovely old town that was right on the front line in the war and had five distinct battles fought around it, the most notorious being 3rd Ypres (Passchendaele). A lot of Canadians, New Zealanders, British and Australians buried there.
This movie fucked me up for a WHILE after I watched it. Granted, I've read a lot about the first World War so I kinda knew what to expect going in, but how exactly the story movies and the acting and everything is just done so well that it still hits you right in the gut with the emotions. I'd recommend watching it in German with whatever subtitles you're most comfortable reading though, the dubbed voice acting doesn't compare imo.
it did so for me too I was f***ed for weeks after the film is a true anti war film show your de'at'h in war for your country is mean'ingless shows your just a cog in the ma'chine of wa'r that's why I will never join the military because America my country is a imp'eri'alist col'oni'al power and it's po'wer and influe'nce is slowly f'alli'ng apart and china is set to become the next super power and the ne'o co'lo'nial west rn is in d'ecli'ne and one day africa and their people and all the other pre col'oni'zed countries will be free from the western powers gr'asp and ex'port'ation.
The treaty that ended WW1 was a precursor and one of the things that set-in motion WW2.
The General sipping on expensive drinks and smoking expensive cigars in "All Quiet on the Western Front" is based on a real General from World War 1, General Erich Ludendorff. He was considered a "butcher" during the war because his strategies were often high risk/high reward and it always ended up being extremely costly for both sides involved.
I watched this the day after it dropped, I was excited to see a newer version of this movie and wasn’t disappointed. I recommend watching it in German, it gives it a more authentic feel.
“Kropp on the other hand is a thinker. He proposes that a declaration of war should be a kind of popular festival with entrance-tickets and bands, like a bull fight. Then in the arena the ministers and generals of the two countries, dressed in bathing-drawers and armed with clubs, can have it out on themselves. Whoever survives the country wins. That would be much simpler and more than just this arrangement, where the wrong people do the fighting”
― Erich Maria Remarque, All Quiet on the Western Front
I've seen a couple of reactions to this movie and everyone cuts out, after paul got the bullet in his helmet, his disbelieving and complaining the guys from the other side shoot at him.
Perhaps it in english it doesn't come out like it but in german he delivers his confusion.
In my opinion very important because he still hadn't realized that this isn't a game, that it is deadly serious.
This Saturday is the 105th anniversary of the Armistice... The 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month...
Two words:
"Das Boot"
Directors Cut in German with subtitles!
actually this movie captures the moment that created ww2. The surrender of germany and the conditions france demanded destroyed germany litterly. This bad conditions are the moment that Hitler used to gain power and the trust of germany and austria for his idea. Funfact the director switched the end of the movie. In reality after the surrender of germany france did a last attack before the war ended.
Germany invaded Poland for lost land for ww1 The fact Germans in Poland weren’t treated well and obviously the Jewish part that the nazis played in :(
Give Vicki some lighter comedies to watch and react too. You're tearing her up with all this death and sadness.
Honestly, I think Vicki may be akin to my 83 yr old mother, in that seeing death, grief, evil, sadness is almost literally painful to them. I've always thought my mother is such a pure and sweet soul, the type of person who when she smiles the world is a brighter place around her, that to watch people doing violence or other ugliness, almost physically hurts her. She will cry and it's just painful to her. I wish the world was full of more "pure souls," like Vicki and my mother. It would be a better place.
Man's inhumanity to man is boundless
If this makes you cry you really don't wanna know about what happened in the eastern front
Yes! My 2 favorite Homies! I never miss your reactions. I knew this one would be particularly rough on Viki. Lia is a rock. We love you both for these qualities.
Remember, when you feel the sadness and pain of these kinds of brutal historical movies, those lows will make your highs much more meaningful.
One cannot enjoy the sunlight having never experienced the rain.
Damn this have to be the most emotional reaction video ive ever seen
WW1 movies are always a horror story. Just countries competing to send more men into the meat grinder.
Watch the movie "COME AND SEE" (1985) I think there tears will flow not only from Vicky but from Lia and Michelle
I remember suggesting that me and my mom should watch that movie. Biggest mistake of my life but I can't deny how great of a movie it is
The guy in the end didn't even collect his tag which means he'll be just missing at war. His family wont even know what happened to him...
The young lady should no longer watch films like this, made in Germany!
The reason: When Germans make films, there is no hero who runs and the bullets fall into the sand behind him!
Heroes are dead, in Germany you only become a hero when you are dead!
Films in Germany are not made according to the American model, there is no happy ending.....
The naked, cruel truth is shown!
The young lady is never allowed to watch a film like that again, she can't handle it psychologically!
Greets from Germany
From an Afghanistan Veteran
IT should be called WOKE Western 3.gen.feminist trying to give war a reason😂.
Most fun Part the First sentence: WE Love war movies and WE are exited to learn what the Stories behind that movie IS all about🎉
"Girls If you hadnt sleept in school you might know allready"😢
Something that almost everyone fails to notice is the sad fact the young soldier who collects the dog tags at the end forgets to pick Paul´s tag when he takes the scarf instead..
I agree with Viki. If I watch a military movie like this, I'd be crying. I'm emotional so I don't watch military movies.
Haven't seen. I know it's world classic. Remake. I saw you reaction on pic. I know it's sad. War,tragedy,even personal tragedies. Glad you enjoyed it :)
Thanks for your reaction to a realistic war film. The film, as well as the book on which it is based, relentlessly shows the pointlessness of war and is a warning for those of us alive today. The film offers viewers no heroes, only victims; even the survivors continue to suffer. So do the viewers!
it shows the reality of war
The book from the 1920's as well as the first film from the late 30's (i think? ) are absolute masterpieces as well. There's another anti war film with a somewhat similar theme (WWI): Johnny got his gun. Check it out if you liked this one.
Johnny got his gun is far superior to this.
I had hopes you would "get it", after feeling so much for the main characters...
Then you said, "So many lives...."
"One life or a billion! It's all the same!" - Ambassador Delenn, "Babylon 5"
Each of those lives was a living breathing human. Each had hopes and fears and loved ones. Each was unique and irreplaceable. Each of the men suffered the fear and pain and horror of that war; on both sides. Millions... each one experiencing that hell as did the main characters of this movie.
How can a society that cherishes each individual send waves of their young men into that hell, to die in pain and dirt and fear and suffering?
It can't. And that's why it's necessary to raise a generation that does cherish each individual member of society, for the unique being each of us is.
No society where all of us is more important than each of us can avoid this waste, this destruction of life. Sooner or later the "needs of the many" will come to dominate the "needs of the few... or the one". And once you step through that threshold... no atrocity is unimaginable. The individuals add up, and become just numbers.
"Holy State or Holy King-
Or Holy People’s Will-
Have no truck with the senseless thing."
- Rudyard Kipling, "MacDonough's Song"
www.kiplingsociety.co.uk/poem/poems_macdonough.htm
Probably the saddest thing is that we never learn.
The father from my great grandfather fought in Verdun, my great grandfather in Wehrmacht (Poland, Africa, Eastern Front), my grandfather joined after ww2 the french foreign legion and fought in indochina, my father was in Iraq, i was in army too but no war to join
I think it depicts one of the the first use of armoured tanks in warfare. truly gripping and so relevant to our times.
I'm pretty sure you are correct and iirc those tanks were horrible to drive because while the armor plating protected you once you ran out of ammo or became unable to continue you would have soldiers rushing you and throwing grenades inside
No this is 1918: the first use of tanks was by the British in 1916, two years earlier. The French St.Chamond tanks shown in the film first saw combat in 1917.
While the Shock value was there at first, these Tanks did not do much. and once the first shock was over, they where dispatched rather easy, the English called them Steel Coffins. The French, even 20 years later, did not know how to properly use Tanks, a harsh lesson they got taught by the Wehrmacht then.
@@1Ashram Yes, the key advantage of them wasn't "shock value" it was mobility: they could get a couple of six-pounder guns and four machine-guns through no-man's-land and across the enemy trenches with out getting stuck in the mud or bogged down fighting infantry battle in those trenches. When used properly (i.e. en masse), they enabled the attack to maintain momentum, which was always the problem before they arrived on the scene.
They certainly couldn't stand up to any kind of direct artillery fire though. There's a picture of a British tank that penetrated the German front line only to get hit in the face by a German field gun. There's just two track frames lying on either side of the road, an engine block sitting on the ground in the middle of the road, and _nothing else_ : the entire hull and all the crew in it are just _gone_ ....😮
The fact men didn’t realize gun bullets did nothing is just scary
You may have watched war movies before. Now you have watched an anti-war movie.
Yep and this is the biggest anti war film since saving private Ryan because saving private Ryan also showed a lot of deaths and and other bad shit
the symbolism of the final scene is breathtaking: 'the STAB IN THE BACK'
on full display and the passing on of the 'panties' to the next generation.
this phrase 'stab in the back' would go on to spawn Adolf H.
Both of my grandfathers were in the trenches in France....they were both shot and gassed...but survived. However they passed away in their forties.......I never knew my grandfathers.
I still prefer the original 1930 version. Bulgaria itself ( same side as the one shown in this film - Central powers, lost 187,500+ killed and 152,390+ wounded in world war one.) The cost of one life is meaningless in a conflict, hence why people are, have been, and will always be used as meatbags / expendable in war.
I always loved the negotiation scene between the German and French delegations because it really highlights how shrewd and cunning these people are. The French delegation leader refuses at first to accept any kind of ceasefire and demands that the German delegation leader formally requests one - which he then uses as confirmation that the Germans are negotiating from a position of weakness. It's very subtle but the maneuvering is compelling to watch.
It's not difficlt to understand the French position here, Germany attacked France more than 4 years earlier, and the fights destroyed about 20% of the French land and almost 50% of its industry. And at that time, the germans were beaten on all Front after the Armistice reached by Austria-Hungary, Bulgaria and the Ottoman Empire. The last one to fight was Germany on the Western Front, and it didn't go well for them at that time, being beaten on almost all the front. So France wanted tu push their advantage, the thing that the Germans did 50 years prior during the Franco-Prussian War.
The French gave the German the exact medicine they received from them by the treaty of Frankfurt, 1871.
Ofc the Entente wouldn't go easy on Germany, it was the last Central power to surrender and in an obvious position of weakness since end of 1917.
@@slawaboga1433 nope, the French weren't "much harsher" than what did the Germans to the French in the Frankfurt treaty on 1871.
Youre uneduc(ated and clearly igno(rant.
Austro Hungarian empire is another empire, and was mostly falling appart itself.
This movie is a masterpiece. One of my favourite movies, but you have to watch it in the original German to get the real emotion in the actors’ voices. The English dub does not do the actors Justice.
This movie only shows some of the brutalities of war though. Real war is much more graphic. If you want to see the real truth of war, you need to watch “Come and See”, but I will warn you, it is the most horrifying movie I’ve ever seen. Not because it tries to be scary, but because it simply shows you the true atrocities that human beings are capable of committing.
There is plenty real brutalities of war on telegram
Die Synchro ist sehr gut. Eben weil die meisten Schauspieler sich selbst synchronisiert haben.😉
Worst part that the last attack is not fiction or movie drama. There are many written accounts from soldiers describing how men were killed in the literal last minute before the ceasefire.
The whole point of the book, and the movie, is to show how terrible and often meaningless war can be, and to show how it is the soldiers who suffer and not the military leaders or the politicians.
It’s sad to watch, but it is good to be sad about war. At least your heart is in the right place then.
In the scene with the little boy in the forest shooting the soldier. The egg is just an excuse. Tell you that in the east of France everything was almost destroyed. As a Frenchman, I was even surprised to see civilians so close to the front. Already imagined that barely 40 years ago there was the Franco-Prussian War which gave birth to Germany as a country. . The French civilians had a hatred against the Germans that had been barbaric towards the population in the war of 1870. In just 40 years, hatred is still presen
Watching this, I can only say, the French deserved all they got 20 years later, you do not make peace by humiliating, and disrespecting a defeated enemy, taking everything, as thousands of people starved to death. while the french military occupying the rhineland was harrasing and laughing about the starving and poor german people. It says a lot that the British and Americans where disgusted by the french " peace " deal.
bien sur les anglais sont des gentlemans, tout le nord de la france a été rasé a cause de cette guerre alors pas de romantisme svp !
Watch the original version of this remake
You know, for us French, the 14/18 war was one of the most terrible. Yet France has known no century without war from the time of Julius Caesar to now. Suffice it to say that the population is accustomed, so to speak, to war. But that of 1914 was really a shock of dread and horror. imagine that for a small country like France. It has lost more than a million and a half of men
you should definitely watch the movie in german. the english version is good, but the german actors give an amazing performance when speaking their native language.
Faut il rappeler les massacres des allemands contre les civiles belge en 1914?
Im Westen nichts Neues.
Erich Maria Remarque.
My grandpa fought in
WWI in the Bavarian
Army as a machine gunner on the
Western Front.
Good reaction! Sadly you saw it in dubbed english....so you never have the chance to watch it the first time again in german....that would have been the best choice....it is gone sadly....
Literally watched this movie yesterday in dubbed English , Regretting it now🫠
The allies were very shitty in the first world war. Not to compare with the second world war. The British blockade killed many more civilians than the German submarines. The Germans even warned in public newspapers that they will attack certain civilian ships and that the US people should beware as they will attack this ship. Initially, the Germans even gave the ships plenty of time to evacuate. But they had to stop that later as it made them very vulnerable to consistently saying where they were attacking to protect civilians. The Germans attacked civilians in Belgium because the Belgian soldiers disguised themselves as civilians to surprise the Germans. The Germans didn't just invade Belgium. They asked beforehand if they could go through peacefully. You have to see this war from every side as there was no good or bad. Just like before the war. The Germans felt attacked from all sides. Just as Russia was rearming, it was over. The USA was not "neutral" either, as is often said in American schools. Most American settlers were German, yet the US consistently supplied the Allies and broke their neutrality. They tried to ban German language and culture. Every piece of German was removed. Although the settlers had nothing to do with the country politically. For the fact that the Germans made the USA more or less great by producing the largest families in the USA or inventions like jeans or the beginning of the gold rush, they were hated and sometimes even chased away. Not a single president stood up for this group of Americans, who really did something for the country with their working-class mentality. Allied propaganda made everyone in the world hate the Germans. All the great powers allied against the Germans and yet the Germans almost won. It was a period of weeks. If the usa had entered the war a few weeks later.. it would have been dark for the allies. Despite the British blockade, which left the Germans without supplies and one planet against them, the Germans almost won. Shows how overpowered they are. After the war they were held responsible for everything. But we're talking about the bad bad Germans. Don't get me wrong, the Germans screwed up too. But they also had to fight against a planet. That doesn't justify the actions, but makes it more understandable.
Watch the Russian film of '85 called Go and see. You will see the real horror of war
There are English subtitles and I didn't spell the title correctly. Come and see
you should watch stalingrade (1998)
Mögen sie in Frieden ruh'n ❤🩹🙏
Man! Am I the only one here who doesn’t want the girls to watch theses kind of war movies???
because I don’t want them to break their hearts ♥️ 😢😢💔💔💔
It’s true always. War never changes.
Did you see "Das Boot" as well? Its another very good movie based on true events.
Hey everyone.
My name is Patrick and I come from Germany.
First of all, respect for watching the film.
But to be honest, we were shown this and other films like it in history class at school.
We were in grades 7-10 (12-15 years old) so that we would never forget our guilt in the war.
Don't you watch films like this in schools in America?
Only Germans were guilty ! ! ! ! !
They're not Americans I think they're Bulgarian or somewhere in the Balkans
They clearly are not Americans, Americans don’t have that accent.
They are both gorgeous… but the woman on the left is beyond gorgeos… she is beautiful without bounds
15:54 when looking this movie think how feminists "claim to be always being opressed and have the worst live and men has such a privilege"
You’re a very weird individual
I recommend for you this mouvies, a Shadow in the eye
"les sentiers de la gloire" de Stanley Kubrick avec Kirk Douglas.
War and war movies don't inapt to women and ladies (unless they are also soldiers). Sadly, wars include very much pain, kill, tears, blood, brutality, these belong to them as naturality.
In the West we have forgotten what really it means the war; hopefully we will not have to learn it again (to someone already happening unfortunately).
war is not fair at all
Tot cei mai greu plus sa vada ce trag sold fii pt ele ele po ap las sa dee
first war with tanks...imagine seeing one on the other side
They are not showing most of the scenes bro
Love the movie! you should have the others react too
press 0 and 9 on your keyboard
Why you saying not moving wher they ar going in the wall under the tank they are safest
I realize that neither the Homies nor their main audience would have a lot of interest in a 90 year old movie but - the original All Quiet is so much better than this version. It was made less than a generation after WWI so basically everyone involved in its making had been touched by the horrors of those years. There is a burning anger in it that this version lacks.
personaly, after watching all 3 adaptations, I think the second version from 79 is the best.
the modern versions have to many new things included, like the last charge of the germans, what didnt even happen, as well as all the diplomacy stuff. it is not bad in itself and the film definatly shows in the most brutal way how war happens, it is very different to the original
the first version is great and ofc very true to the book, but it suffers from the horrible acting of that time. the lack of expressing emotion and instead monologing them to the audience as well as the theatralic, almost comlicly death scences while charging the trenches realy kills it for me
the 79 version already had good effects and acting but is also very true to the book. best of both words basicly. and while it doesn't have the brutal scences from the modern version, they still nail how war changes each man involved. it also hasthe best depiction of gas attacks from all 3 movies and Kat explaining the new recruits to get rid of the serrated bajonett and use a shovel instead is more chilling than most fight scences from the modern film
@@calronkeltaran493 That's funny, I didn't mention the 79 version because it was my least favourite of the three. Your criticisms of the original are all valid. I guess I've watched enough movies from that time to be very forgiving of the artforms that were very much still finding their way. Plus stunts in movies back then were insane. WWI made lives a cheap commodity 🤷🏼♂️
@@WhatHaveIMadeLife has historically always been very cheap.
y know all obout war
and the oscar goes to...
Dont watched dubbed movies they take away a lot of immersion. You already had the subtitles on in english then watch it in german as the creators intended it.
This brings to mind the poem 'Dulce et Decocorum Est', which also examines the question of patriotism retrospective to the First World War.
Wtf! You should have watched it in german. Voice actors cannot to justice to the real actors.
the french had help of the americans during the time and germany was losing the fight
à verdun aussi ?
Actually they had help of the British. The Americans entered war in April 1917.
This movie is a fine remake of the original 1930 movie. That was based on the book of the same title, which was banned in a number of countries precisely because it showed the horrible futility of war and what it does to mankind. Those wars, like the ones started by Hitler & now Putin, are based on ego-driven maniacal thoughts of madmen grasping for power.
I'm so sorry for your suffering this movie, but it is precisely why women are absolutely necessary as a moderating influence in men's lives. The ego-driven men who start these wars are NEVER happy men at home.
Thank you, ladies.
Stalingrad 1993, recommend and interesting film
I cannot believe people have been watching this movie with English dubs.
I think it's a generational thing, but I preferred the way previous adaptations depicted Paul's death. For me, showing the cruel banality and indifference of death and war was more effective than showing his death a big extravagant spectacle. The previous depictions were also more in line with final words in the book.
I took Paul's death in this adaptation as a way to show the hopelessness of being so close to going home but yet being unable to continue. Another way to look at Paul's death is that the director wanted to show another sad thing about WW1 is that sometimes dog tags don't get collected which gives the families no closure because they could either be dead in a trench somewhere or taken prisoner or just straight up left the country.
das Buch hat mit dem Film kaum etwas zutun es ist angelehnt mehr aber auch nicht was an Characktern fehlt hat man mit Acktion und Brutalität aufgefüllt
This movie is an anti-war movie that talks about the stupidity of war rather than one that glorifies it.
a movie on the life of men
Evoloing
зачем убирать фильм с экрана? не видно же что там происходит
copyright i think !
This movie was based on Germany book and been adapted so many times this is most recent and probably the best depiction of how it cruel it was during the world war 1 and 2 in the frontlines
Why do humans such things to each other....I will never understand..😢
What year are you two living in that yiu refer to handicapped people as "invalids"
Die weint ja schon in der ersten Minute XD
Whenever someone calls for going to war, please keep this movie in mind !!! That's the whole idea of it. Never again this cruelty ! But unfortunately, ...
I hope us men get a little more respect around here
Next time a Feminist sympathizer dares to talk about "Male privilege", remember what those soldiers had to face.
You should have reacted in germán with inglish subtitles
sie wollten halt nicht lesen, sondern schauen.
you should have saw it in german but still nice
What is this. Why is the scenee cut all the time ? BS
I always believed that the germans were considered beasts in America. Your clip changed my idea.
Would be better if the movie was larger so we can see wat you're watching
yeahhh i watch the orginal german version its better