I do a tier list for Pink Floyd albums, because that’s fun Music (In Order Of Use): Crime Pays (Instrumental) - Madlib, Freddie Gibbs All Spice - MF DOOM Licorice - MF DOOM
damn, a person that acknowledges shit i said in the vid (or that i say anything tbh), lately been thinking people just skip to the end, so hearing this is gratifying
Nothing like hearing other people’s take on their discography. I personally have always had a real love for piper, their earlier sound is just so whimsical and fun. Great video man
Good tier list, I also think WYWH is their peak. Though, IMO, Animals > DSOTM. The Wall is their second best in my opinion, but honestly I can see why people don't like it. You should listen to the '90 Berlin Live version of The Wall, though. Trust me when I say it has no boring parts. Good video.
animals over dark side is a take i don’t agree with but understand W for understanding the wall hate, not for everyone from what it seems like might tune into the vid, idk though, I’d have to be in the mood for it really thanks
The thing about The Wall is that Roger's voice is not everyone's cup of tea, and there was balance before because Gilmour sings most of the songs. That's why some people HATE, no, DESPISE The Wall. So if you listen to Roger's waters for... the hour and half that The Wall is, you start to realize how his voice is so moan-ey. "One of My Turns" and "Don't Leave me Now" can be a pain in the ass to listen to because sometimes his voice is just... ahh. You can't put it into words. Definetly not in a good way though, LMAO. The Berlin show however, has many other singers, so you don't have to suck up Roger's voice... for some time. The Wall's D side is in my opinion the best (The Show Must go On, In the Flesh, etc...) and it's awesome in the Berlin show. His voice is still not exactly the best there, still, but it's much more tolerable than the album version. There's also a whole ass orchestra on the background. Also, about DSOTM, I don't know. Never liked it too much. Speak to Me is really bland and just a boring ass song. Breathe is beautiful, though. On the Run is garbage. The rest of the album is pretty good, it's just that Animals is ... Animals. Dogs has some bland parts, but the ending is chef's kiss. Pigs is not only groovy, but the lyrics are also awesome. Sheep was never much of a pushover for me, but I guess it's there. Pigs on the Wings are alright. But I prefer Dogs, Pigs, and Sheep. Always.
The Wall IS two large pieces put together though. There is no separation between songs aside the tracklist. Also the only song I’d consider “filler” would be BTBBH. Every other song has a stablished purpose. It’s a beautiful album, and a masterpiece.
Yes, The Wall is the most overrated of the so-called "Big Four" in my opinion (the big four being Dark Side, Wish You, Animals and The Wall). My favourite songs from it are Comfortably Numb, Nobody Home, The Thin Ice, Is There Anybody Out There? and One Of My Turns... but the rest of the album is like whatever, like nobody ever called for the Pink Floyd song called Stop. At 30 seconds, Stop from The Wall is the shortest Pink Floyd song in existence. My ranking would be: 1 - The Dark Side Of The Moon 2 - Wish You Were Here 3 - Atom Heart Mother 4 - Animals 5 - More (I absolutely adore this album, i don't give a sh** what anyone else thinks, its a beautiful album, i listen to this album often) 6 - Ummagumma (I realise you ranked Ummagumma going by new material only, but i'm ranking ummagumma as a whole, live stuff included, i love it, i listen to this album a lot). 7 - Meddle 8 - The Wall 9 - A Saucerful Of Secrets 10 - The Piper At The Gates of Dawn 11 - Obscured by Clouds 12 - The Final Cut 13 - The Division Bell 14 - The Endless River 15 - A Momentary Lapse of Reason
@@IolZ555 maybe I just love Gilmour’s voice. Roger maybe a lyrical genius but I love the soft gentle sound of Gilmour’s vocals, I highly recommend you listen to his solo album called Rattle That Lock if you haven’t already, it’s so good.
@@IolZ555 Your top 2 favorite songs are purple rain and uneven compromise? Purple rain is a W take but idk bout UC Well my top 5 favorite songs are 1:Siberian breaks 2:Beach life in death 3:Sing about me I'm dying of thirst 4:Gone gone/thank you 5:While my guitar gently weeps HM:Long season live
@@dsw-2898 I was just talking about music that duckworth fw, cause i know he like uneven compromise and fw prince, so i was like: over these songs?? That being said purple rain, uneven compromise, 1989 (Michelle’s song), and Heroes are my definitive favorite songs oat, can’t think of a 5th
@@IolZ555 Those are sum W picks Purple rain and Heroes are both in my top 10 And I just listened to 1989 and Uneven compromise Really liked 1989(9 or 10/10 song) Ughh can't really say the same for Uneven compromise(it's like a 7 /10)
I thought I was the only one with that wall take. There’s just too much crap on it for me to want to play it start to finish. The good songs are amazing but the bad ones are god awful
@@IolZ555 the songs that ruin it for me are “don’t leave me now” “empty spaces” (may be a hot take) “don’t leave me now” (god awful) “is there anybody out there” “bring the boys back home” “the trial” (never understood peoples love for that song)
@@michaelopal9549 see those songs are just boring as shit to me. I actually like the trial kinda, Roger’s voice is weird but i think it’s one of the most memorable moments off the record, and is so off the wall i kinda have to just respect it
![[UNCUT] “อภิสิทธิ์” ครม.อุ๊งอิ๊ง แย่งเก้าอี้กันฝุ่นตลบ “ทักษิณ” บงการเอง Iคนดังนั่งเคลียร์I 21ส.ค.67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/a_b-kItw2jY/mqdefault.jpg)
youre the kinda guy who listened to the wall once and then listened to the single
okay
That the wall take broke my heart 😔 respect for WYWH in S tho
I might not agree with all the takes you made, but I like how they were all supported by solid reasoning that made me wanna believe you
Solid list
damn, a person that acknowledges shit i said in the vid (or that i say anything tbh), lately been thinking people just skip to the end, so hearing this is gratifying
Nothing like hearing other people’s take on their discography. I personally have always had a real love for piper, their earlier sound is just so whimsical and fun. Great video man
piper is still a good record ofc, just not exactly my cup of tea all the time
thank you 🙏
Wrongggg, do it again!!
Wrongggg, do it again!!
obnoxious ahh comment
@@IolZ555 little one can’t have any pudding 😔😔🙏🙏
@@IolZ555aww he was making a reference
Good tier list, I also think WYWH is their peak. Though, IMO, Animals > DSOTM. The Wall is their second best in my opinion, but honestly I can see why people don't like it. You should listen to the '90 Berlin Live version of The Wall, though. Trust me when I say it has no boring parts. Good video.
animals over dark side is a take i don’t agree with but understand
W for understanding the wall hate, not for everyone from what it seems like
might tune into the vid, idk though, I’d have to be in the mood for it really
thanks
The thing about The Wall is that Roger's voice is not everyone's cup of tea, and there was balance before because Gilmour sings most of the songs.
That's why some people HATE, no, DESPISE The Wall. So if you listen to Roger's waters for... the hour and half that The Wall is, you start to realize how his voice is so moan-ey. "One of My Turns" and "Don't Leave me Now" can be a pain in the ass to listen to because sometimes his voice is just... ahh. You can't put it into words. Definetly not in a good way though, LMAO.
The Berlin show however, has many other singers, so you don't have to suck up Roger's voice... for some time. The Wall's D side is in my opinion the best (The Show Must go On, In the Flesh, etc...) and it's awesome in the Berlin show. His voice is still not exactly the best there, still, but it's much more tolerable than the album version. There's also a whole ass orchestra on the background.
Also, about DSOTM, I don't know. Never liked it too much. Speak to Me is really bland and just a boring ass song. Breathe is beautiful, though. On the Run is garbage. The rest of the album is pretty good, it's just that Animals is ... Animals. Dogs has some bland parts, but the ending is chef's kiss. Pigs is not only groovy, but the lyrics are also awesome. Sheep was never much of a pushover for me, but I guess it's there. Pigs on the Wings are alright. But I prefer Dogs, Pigs, and Sheep. Always.
Good songs on the wall: Hey You, In The Flesh, Another Brick In The Wall, Comfortably Numb, Young Lust, Run Like Hell.
run like hell and young lust are bangers but the rest is a mixed bag
Blud is saying atom heart mother is equal to the dark side of the moon😂😂😂😂
it’s lowkey better now that i think about it
solid tier list
insanely based
The Wall IS two large pieces put together though. There is no separation between songs aside the tracklist. Also the only song I’d consider “filler” would be BTBBH. Every other song has a stablished purpose. It’s a beautiful album, and a masterpiece.
Also I can listen to The Wall fully in my head. Not forgettable at all for me
i was just saying you were being agreeable af today
Based
the wall at D? 😔
yeah 😔
Yes, The Wall is the most overrated of the so-called "Big Four" in my opinion (the big four being Dark Side, Wish You, Animals and The Wall). My favourite songs from it are Comfortably Numb, Nobody Home, The Thin Ice, Is There Anybody Out There? and One Of My Turns... but the rest of the album is like whatever, like nobody ever called for the Pink Floyd song called Stop. At 30 seconds, Stop from The Wall is the shortest Pink Floyd song in existence.
My ranking would be:
1 - The Dark Side Of The Moon
2 - Wish You Were Here
3 - Atom Heart Mother
4 - Animals
5 - More (I absolutely adore this album, i don't give a sh** what anyone else thinks, its a beautiful album, i listen to this album often)
6 - Ummagumma (I realise you ranked Ummagumma going by new material only, but i'm ranking ummagumma as a whole, live stuff included, i love it, i listen to this album a lot).
7 - Meddle
8 - The Wall
9 - A Saucerful Of Secrets
10 - The Piper At The Gates of Dawn
11 - Obscured by Clouds
12 - The Final Cut
13 - The Division Bell
14 - The Endless River
15 - A Momentary Lapse of Reason
more placement is based lowkey
@@IolZ555 maybe I just love Gilmour’s voice. Roger maybe a lyrical genius but I love the soft gentle sound of Gilmour’s vocals, I highly recommend you listen to his solo album called Rattle That Lock if you haven’t already, it’s so good.
@@jagdeepkaul1261 noted, thanks
dogs is the best song of all time, if the album was only that song 7 times it would still be s+
over purple rain and uneven compromise is insane
i respect it tho
@@IolZ555 Your top 2 favorite songs are purple rain and uneven compromise?
Purple rain is a W take but idk bout UC
Well my top 5 favorite songs are
1:Siberian breaks
2:Beach life in death
3:Sing about me I'm dying of thirst
4:Gone gone/thank you
5:While my guitar gently weeps
HM:Long season live
@@dsw-2898 I was just talking about music that duckworth fw, cause i know he like uneven compromise and fw prince, so i was like: over these songs??
That being said purple rain, uneven compromise, 1989 (Michelle’s song), and Heroes are my definitive favorite songs oat, can’t think of a 5th
@@IolZ555 Those are sum W picks
Purple rain and Heroes are both in my top 10
And I just listened to 1989 and Uneven compromise
Really liked 1989(9 or 10/10 song)
Ughh can't really say the same for Uneven compromise(it's like a 7 /10)
@@dsw-2898 i used to think that uneven compromise was a 7, then i became based
The mind is so complex when you’re based
I thought I was the only one with that wall take. There’s just too much crap on it for me to want to play it start to finish. The good songs are amazing but the bad ones are god awful
there aren’t even that many awful moments, just a bunch of boring filller
basically 6 great tracks surrounded by slop
@@IolZ555 the songs that ruin it for me are “don’t leave me now” “empty spaces” (may be a hot take) “don’t leave me now” (god awful) “is there anybody out there” “bring the boys back home” “the trial” (never understood peoples love for that song)
@@michaelopal9549 see those songs are just boring as shit to me.
I actually like the trial kinda, Roger’s voice is weird but i think it’s one of the most memorable moments off the record, and is so off the wall i kinda have to just respect it
I think Dark Side of The Moon should be S, I love the concept and the heavy presence of synths and sax ( I am a slut for synths and sax)
yeah i get why one might like it, i just feel like this band in general doesn’t hit me like it does with everyone else, idk why
L wall take
it’s true tho lowkey
Almost identical to mine. The wall is a sleeping simulator
true facts
The wall in D is horrible
it is honorable for sure