மிக அற்புதமாக விளக்கியிருக்கிறீர்கள். மிக்க நன்றி . As you remarked, we all think about whether the composer thought so deeply, or it just happened. You have a very good explanation that God chooses the vehicle... Like wand chooses the wizard...
An eye opener! Such a wealth of information! The next time we listen to these kritis, it will be so much more meaningful! If only this kind of background...were available behind every kriti in Carnatic music! We would enjoy it even more! Vijay Siva sir, thanks so much for making this available to us!
Excellent. Please upload more. World is waiting to learn more hidden treasures. Understanding the meaning at this level enhances the experience for singers as well as listeners. Special thanks..
Such a good lecture sir. Thank you. I do have one observation: the compositions on Thiruvanaikaval are both in North Indian ragas ( for lack of a better word) - Yamuna and Joojayavanthi/ Dwijavanthi.
As we all know Tyagaraja had his students documenting all his compositions but in the case of Deekshitar who was a traveller too who was documenting these songs ?? Deekshitar himself or his students??
You could have added that at Arunachala Amba did penance with Gautama Maharshi as Guru and attained Oneness with Him to become Ardhanarisvara. More than sringara the aspect of Shivasakti aikyam is more apt here.
Great lecture - unravelling lot of hidden meanings :) - "Chodyam" in Ananda natana prakasam - Chodyam means question or inquisitiveness both in Sanskrit and Malayalam :). Utharam is the answer if I'm not mistaken , Sir
@@satheeshiyer it's basically a Sanskrit word which means wonder, there's a method called artha viparinamam. One word's meaning becomes other in other language, so the change, pramadam in Tamil is fantastic but in Telugu it's danger, likewise sneham in Telugu Kannada Tamil is friendship but in Malayalam it's love, having said that Malayalam has a less vocabulary.
Sir nice lecdem. But it is only viable for people who know telugu/tamil. English is a universal language. But please next time in english. Or please add English subtitles
Sir - many many thanks to you for posting . . . it enables us to listen these Krithis in their pure form . . . We request you to post more such demonstrations on Dikshithar's krithis and keep up this wonderful work . . . _/\__/\__/\_
It is not Ekambra Nathar....it is Ekamra Nathar...Amara is mango...Ambaram is clothe...perhaps we can call Palani Murgan as Ekambara nathar as he has a single cloth, Koupeenam....so it is Ekamra and not Ekambra....Sanskrit words should be properly pronounced
As prr maharishies words, ava padi adaya villai, sfanjathai padi irrukka. So need for one by one yatra panninala or pona podhu padinala an all. Mumukshu ku everything a open book
விஜய் சிங்கிற்கு என்னுடைய மனமார்ந்த வாழ்த்துக்கள். இம்மாதிரியான முயற்சி கள் தொடர வேண்டும் என வேண்டுகிறேன்.
Superb presentation sir. the last response is about what happens when you sing internalizing the meaning..... provides the original objective of life!
Sir, Kindly add subtitles in English so non-Tamil speaking rasikas can understand and learn from this masterpiece led dem. thanks in advance
மிக அற்புதமாக விளக்கியிருக்கிறீர்கள். மிக்க நன்றி . As you remarked, we all think about whether the composer thought so deeply, or it just happened. You have a very good explanation that God chooses the vehicle... Like wand chooses the wizard...
An eye opener! Such a wealth of information! The next time we listen to these kritis, it will be so much more meaningful! If only this kind of background...were available behind every kriti in Carnatic music! We would enjoy it even more! Vijay Siva sir, thanks so much for making this available to us!
Excellent. Please upload more. World is waiting to learn more hidden treasures. Understanding the meaning at this level enhances the experience for singers as well as listeners. Special thanks..
गौरवपूर्वक प्रणाम दीक्षित और विजय शिवन जी को।
अद्भुत कार्यक्रम।
Wonderful effort to explain these immortal Krithis..DKJ mama's singing adds lustre to this brilliant effort..thanks for the upload..
Best one .
So many thanks for uploading.
Thanks to technology.
No words to say tks. Just divine that's all
Such a good lecture sir. Thank you. I do have one observation: the compositions on Thiruvanaikaval are both in North Indian ragas ( for lack of a better word) - Yamuna and Joojayavanthi/ Dwijavanthi.
Listening today, I am transported to meditative DKJ mama's music times.
Superb demo cum lecture.of Pancha Linga krithies of sri Muthuswami. Dikshithar. Thanx.
Typing error...it is Aamra , the mango .....
Thank you so much for uploading this valuable lecture
Wonderful effort by the dedicated musical genius but bit more effort could have gone into the spiritual aspects of the lyrical splendor.
As we all know Tyagaraja had his students documenting all his compositions but in the case of Deekshitar who was a traveller too who was documenting these songs ?? Deekshitar himself or his students??
Thank you very much sir for sharing this video. I found it very educative.
Ram Ram🙏
You could have added that at Arunachala Amba did penance with Gautama Maharshi as Guru and attained Oneness with Him to become Ardhanarisvara. More than sringara the aspect of Shivasakti aikyam is more apt here.
Great lecture - unravelling lot of hidden meanings :) - "Chodyam" in Ananda natana prakasam - Chodyam means question or inquisitiveness both in Sanskrit and Malayalam :). Utharam is the answer if I'm not mistaken , Sir
Satheesh H Carnatic music
Chodyam is a wonderful object, not malayalam word which means a question.
@@tyagarajakinkara well chodyam is indeed a malayalam word - maybe it means wonderful object in another language
@@satheeshiyer it's basically a Sanskrit word which means wonder, there's a method called artha viparinamam. One word's meaning becomes other in other language, so the change, pramadam in Tamil is fantastic but in Telugu it's danger, likewise sneham in Telugu Kannada Tamil is friendship but in Malayalam it's love, having said that Malayalam has a less vocabulary.
Sir please explain in English also
Good presentation
Sir nice lecdem. But it is only viable for people who know telugu/tamil. English is a universal language. But please next time in english.
Or please add English subtitles
Wow 🙏🏻
Sir - many many thanks to you for posting . . . it enables us to listen these Krithis in their pure form . . .
We request you to post more such demonstrations on Dikshithar's krithis and keep up this wonderful work . . .
_/\__/\__/\_
Excellent and Educative
It is not Ekambra Nathar....it is Ekamra Nathar...Amara is mango...Ambaram is clothe...perhaps we can call Palani Murgan as Ekambara nathar as he has a single cloth, Koupeenam....so it is Ekamra and not Ekambra....Sanskrit words should be properly pronounced
Aprākrita doesn't mean beyond prakriti- this material world?
Superb
Many vidwans sing Advaitha as Dwaitha in Aananda Natana Prakaasham. Even dancers show their abhinaya as dwaitha when dancing for this song.
Actually its advaitha
Muthuswami dikshitar says this tn kamalambam bhajare pallavi. And in maye twam yahi composition
Not dvaitha
As prr maharishies words, ava padi adaya villai, sfanjathai padi irrukka.
So need for one by one yatra panninala or pona podhu padinala an all.
Mumukshu ku everything a open book