በሬ Honest person. I really always love your lesson.💙 And Dr. Yonatan you are over my Expectation keep going man. ብፍላይ ኣብ'ዛ ኣርእስቲ እዚኣ ብዘየዳግም ጌርኩም ብኣብነት ኣሰኒኹም ኣኾሊስኩምና ። የቐንየልና🎩
Dr Yonatan, Is nationalism only bad (as you have explained) ? Or is there a positive or constructive type of nationalism which people/nations can benefit from?
It is defined as "Identification with one's own nation and support for its interests, especially to the exclusion or detriment of the interests of other nations." If this is the case, then nationalism works only for dictators to promote their influence across nations and consolidate power.
Miriam Webster definition of Nationalism “ : loyalty and devotion to a nation especially : a sense of national consciousness, exalting one nation above all others and placing primary emphasis on promotion of its culture and interests as opposed to those of other nations or supranational groups”. Everyone exalt its family , sport club etc , what is wrong with it? Americans, Chinese, Russians, English, Italians, Turkish, Ethiopians, Eritreans, every country etc does, why bother about it?
Very powerful speech Every Ethiopian MUST watch this speech so most of the Ethiopian people who living in tribalism (namely ethnic federalism) can finally choose to be the citizen NOT the idiots and tribalist or ethnocentric There are three kinds of people 1) The idiots 2) The tribalist 3) The citizens Both of from idiot people 😂😂
It seems there's some confusion here. If you're well-educated, you should have done your homework. I haven't heard any evidence or basis for your claim.
You can not have the sense of belongingness to a society if you don't have a national feeling. True, extreme ሕሉፍ nationalism is dangerous. But, come on man! Nationalism is a healthy feeling of love to who you are where you originated!! You are twisting this to fit the Tigray politicians narrative.
Your deep seated hatred of Tigray is clouding your sense of right and wrong. Your nationalism is based the hatred of the people of Tigray. We want to have a country at peace with itself and and its neighbors. We want our country to be like Switzerland. The german , Italian, and French speaking Swiss never deny their identity. We are proud Tegaru from Eritrea. The era of denying our natural identity is over . Just take it easy.
do we have a healthy Nationlism in Eritrea?? The answer is WE DO NOT!!! In fact in Eritrea, it’s ultranationalism right now. You personally could feel of having a “healthy Nationalism” but assuming everyone else is the same is WRONG especially when Eritreans are subjected to ultra nationalism 24/7. Eritrea is under ultra nationalism force today.
ክሳብ እንመውት ክንመሃር ኢና።
ኣነ ድኣ ናተይ ትርጉም እንድየ ዝህቦ ነይረ። ናሽናሊዝም ሃልዩስ: ሕሉፍ ሃገራውነት እዩ እቲ ጌጋ ይብሎ ነይረ።
እስከ ቀጽሉ ….
Thank you guys
Memharan ❤
Yes
Yes Yt kournal
Betami xebuk Temerty yehwatey kexelwo.
Thanks
Thank you Mussie
What a refreshing podcast! The topics you cover and the way you present them are truly engaging. Keep up the fantastic work, guys
ጽቡቅ መደብ ክቡራት ኣሕዋት፡ በሬ my always favourite analyst, smart & humbel. Thanx Dr Yonatan for bringing him❤❤
ናይ ብሓቂ መሃሪ መደብ። ኩላትና ንዚ መደብ ንከታተል ዘለና ኩላትና ሳብስክራይብ ንግበር ሸር ድማ ንበላ ።
ጽቡቕ ኣገላልጻ ምስ ብሩህ ኣብነታት❤❤❤ ንበረኸት ተወሳኺ ግዜ ኣምጻኣልና!
Great analysis guys thanks 💙🤝✅
Thank you guys
We really appreciate you guys 💙💙💙
ሰላም ፣selamt Dr Jonathan.../. thank you. ሰላም ሓዊይ በርከት ።።።✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿🌿⚖️✔️
ጽቡቅ ኢልና አለና ክቡራት አሕዋት ! ህድአትን ፍልጠትን ዘሳነየ ልዝብ ! ንአና ከአ ርጉእ ትምህርቲ ዝረከብናሉ መደብ
Thank you Dr. Yonatan and Bereket. Very interesting topic and very good analysis.
Hi Doctoryie, it's great to see you again, i really appreciate today's video and analysis, great job
Big Respect to both of you 🙏.
ኣዝዩ ሃናጺ መደብ።
💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
My favorait jornalist yoni ❤❤❤❤
Brilliant 🤩👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Nice meeting thanks guys.❤❤❤❤
Sagm we write about this since 1990
በሬ Honest person. I really always love your lesson.💙 And Dr. Yonatan you are over my Expectation keep going man. ብፍላይ ኣብ'ዛ ኣርእስቲ እዚኣ ብዘየዳግም ጌርኩም ብኣብነት ኣሰኒኹም ኣኾሊስኩምና ። የቐንየልና🎩
Thank you guy’s
keep it up, I put my comment before I finished up the video anyways you guys are awesome 👍
Keep your teaching lovely brothers
ኢኒቆዒ ተጀሚረ ኽሊሳሐሳብ ሒጂ ጣዐና❤❤❤❤❤
ጽቡቅ ኣቃራርባ በርየ ሓውና ግርም ገርካዮም ኣለኻ በቲ ዝርዶኦም ቃንቃ ነዞም ጎዋኑ ናይ ሳሕል ዶጉቶር የናታን ብጣዕሚ ነመስግን 💙💙💙🌿🌿🌿✌✌✌💪💪💪💪
Interesting topic 👍
ቀጽልወ ጽቡቅ ኣቀራርባ❤
Great discussion, enlightening 🌿💙
Brilliant analysis!
Please እዛ Topic ቀጽልዋ ብጣዕሚ ኣገዳሲት ኢያ
Dr yonatal could u bring . as topic we should now our people What is the differences of ( nationalism ) (patriotism) ( despotism) and ( humanism)
🦋🦋🦋🌿🌿🌿
Nationalism, patriotism, national identity, citizenship .. . Confusing.
Anyways it is good probe . Continue ❤🎉
Please do a program of the difference of Nation vs. Nationality vs. Nationalism vs. Patriotism. these are the words everyone is confusing
Wawww the two educated ones
🎉.
Yoni and Bere my favourite activities 💙💚💙💚
Dr Yonatan, Is nationalism only bad (as you have explained) ? Or is there a positive or constructive type of nationalism which people/nations can benefit from?
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
ኣዝዩ መሃሪ መደብ።
Zfetwem sebat bflay nay berye agalaltsa blues eye zkatatelo ajokum zemhawatey bebezelonayo neberkit😊
በርየ ዓሻ ሙሁር ኤርትራዊዶ ክንብሎ ፍልጠቱ ዘይሓብእ ንጹህ ሙሁር::
ኣብ መጻኢት ኤርትራ ከም ብዓል በርየ ዮኖታን ምስ ክውንነት ዝሳማሙዑ ሙሁራት ክመሩሑና ኣለዎም::
ድሕሪ ሕጂ ዲግሪዶ ገለዶ ኣለኒ ዝብል ዘጥፍኣና ስነ ልቦና ዘለዎም ክመርሑና ከይነፍቅድ:: ሕጊ እዩ ዝመርሕ ግን ከምዞም ናይ ህግሓኤ ስነልቦና ዘለዎም ሙሁራት ማለተይ እየ::
ንሶም እንተደይቦም መንበር ባቃ ከምዘለናያ ኢና ክንጠፍእ::
ስለዚ ደጋጊምና ንባዕል በርየ ዮኒ ክንስዕቦም እዚ መደቦም ክዓቢ ንሓግዞም ብፍላይ መንእሰያ ::
Akrari hagerawi hmam u
Thanks! Just stand your ground and keep telling the truth about Eritrean toxic nationalism. Don’t cave in to our fellow HAGERAWYAN
Thank you Tesfazghi
ደ ቂ 😊አ😮ኒሲቲዬ ዳአ ዘየዐዱሚኮ ኢ
ውዲብ ሳጊም ውዮዳአ ሲማዒ ሲኢና ኢሚቢር ቂዲሚ ሰቢና ተቃሊሲናሎ❤❤❤❤❤
Bk 🎉
ከም ዝመስለኒ እቶም ኣብ ርድኢት ዝጋገዪ ዘለዉ ሰባት ቻነል እምበር ፍልጠት ዘይውንኑ ሰባት ኢዮም ወይ ከኣ ብሰንኪ ጌጋ ርድኢቶም ደገፍቲ ኔሮም ተቃወምቲ ከይኮኑ ( ብተቃወምቲ ዝወርር ኣታሓሳስባ ጌርካ ምርዳእ ) ዝፈርሑ ኢዮም ።
Eritrawunt Hasot eu !!
Eritrawi zibehal meninet yelen 😮
ንስኩም ክንደይ ጊዘን ገንዘብን ሂብኩም መጻሕፍቲ ኣንብብኩም! ኣነ ከኣ ብ 30 ደቂቅ gymይ እዳ ሰራሕኩ ክመሃር ዝገበርኩም thanks
ሖሎፍ ውን
It is defined as "Identification with one's own nation and support for its interests, especially to the exclusion or detriment of the interests of other nations." If this is the case, then nationalism works only for dictators to promote their influence across nations and consolidate power.
ዮኒ & በሬ ጽቡቕ ኣቐራርባ እዚ ሃግራውነት ዝብሃል መርዚ ጸረ ኣህዛብ ክሳብ ኣብ ህዝብና ዓምዩቕ ርድኢት ዘየሕደረ ህዝብና ጸረ ነብሱ ኮይኑ ካብ መስረሕ ምጽናት ኣይክጋላገልን እዩ!!!
ጊሪሜ አሲቲሚሂ
Thanks kuberti ahwet koxelwo
ዮኒ እዛ ዛዕባ ደጋጊምኩም እንተተብስልዋ ጹቡቅ ኔሩ
ቲሚካሒቲን ጺቢቲን ጸረ ሒዝካ ሠላም አይሪኪባን ኢያ
የሕዋት ኣይትተሃመሉ ኣብ ዉሽጢ ሃገር ተመስሪቱ እዩ :: ደቂስኩም ኣለኩም : የሕዋት :: ብዝሰፍሔ ክገልጽልኩም እዮም :: ፈላስፋታት ኣሎው ::
ዕቱባት ኣያታተይ ሙሁራት ዓድና ከምዚ ኢልኩም ተቢዕኩም ክትሙጉቱን ክትምህሩን ከተስተምሁሩን እንተበቂዕኩም እቲ ንደልዮ ሓርነት፡ ቆጦባ፡ ዕብየት ከነምጽኦ ንኽእል ኢና ሓሰብት ብዘይ ነግ ፈረግ ሓሳቦም እንተገሊጾም እቶም ሓረስቶት ነቲ ሓሳብ ኣብ ግብሪ ክልውጥዎ ወላ ሓደ ኣይጽግገምን። ጎዲሎምና ዘለዉ እቶም ሓሰብቲ እምበር ዓየይቲ ኣይኮኑን። ስለዚ ብዘይ ነግ ፈረግ ሓሳብ ልብኹም ግለጹ። ን ሓረስቶት (ዓየይቲ) እንተ ኣእሚንካዮም እሞ ብ ሓሳብ ዘዊርካዮም እቲ ንደልያ ህዝብናን ዓድናን ከነድሕን ኢና።
መግለጺኹም እሰማማዓሉ ብዝያዳ ክትንጽር ጸቢብ ሃገራውነት Narrow Nationalism ከም ፍልሰፍናን ሳዕቤናቱን ብፍላይ ኣብ ትሑት ፖሎቲካዊ ንቅሓት ዘሎዎ ሕብረተሰብ
ማዕረ ማዕርኡ ኣብ ኣነነትን ትምክሕትን የውድቀካ መጨረሻ ንሓድነትካ ውን ይብትን የቀንየለይ
Hagerawnet aikonen xegem kulu behageru eu zikorie natna xegem ab sdet koina kindzi mizrabna eu gudlet nixhna eu
እዚ ኣርእስቲ(ኤርትራዊ ሃገራውነት) ንነዊሕ ግዜ ከም ኣካታዕን ኣዳናጋርን ገይርዎ ዘሎ፣ ሃገርካ ኣብሊጽካ ንናይ ካልኦት ምንእኣስ፣ ንካልኦት ኣንኢስካ ንነብኻ ምልዓል ወይ ሓቢርካ ናይ ምንባር ራኢ ዘይምህላው እምበር ልክዕ እቲ ትርጉም ዘካትዕ ኣይመስለንን። ጽቡቕ ምምኽኻርዩ ብዝኾነ ዶር
ብሱል ትንተና ኣሕዋት ቀጸልዎ!!!
ሃገራውነት ብሃገራውያን እንተ ተሰሪሑ ሓደገይና ኢዩ!! ሃገራውነት ብዜጋታት እንተ ተሰሪሑ ግን ሂወት ኢዩ!!
Nationalism ብትግርኛ ካብ ሃገራዉነት ብ ብሄርተንንት ተርጉምኩን ተትጥቀሙላ ነቲ ሰብ ን ምርዱኡ ጽቡቅ ሙከነት።
ኣብ ኤርትራውያን እሸጊሩ ዘሎ ሕጂ ሃገራዊ ብሄርተኝንት አዩ።
ሃይመናትዊ ብሄርትንንት
ዓሌታዊ ብሄርትኝንት
መንነታዊ ብሄርትኝንት
ወዘተ
በምዚ ተትገልጽዎ ጽቡቅ ኔሩ ነቲ nationalism 👍🏼🙏🏽
ብሄራውነት √√√√√ ብሄርተኝነት××××××××
@@semharkahsay1946 ብሄራዉነት ጽቡቅ ንገር ብሄርተኝነት ጊን ጽንፊ ዝሓዘ ኣታሓሳስባ አዩ ካባይ ወጻኢ ካሊአ ባዕሉ ይፈልጥ ዓይነት ዝብል አዮ።
እብ ኤርትራ ካኣ ሃገራዊ ብሄራዉነት ዘይኮነ ሃገራዊ ብሄርትኝነት አዩ ኣሸጊሩ ዘሎ።
ኣብዚ ቅሩብ ካኣ ግዜ ካኣ ኣውራጃዊ ብሄርትኝነት ዝምዕብል ዘሎ ይመስል❤️👍🏼
@@zerom498 ብኣምሓርኛ ኢዩ ብሄርተኝነት ትግረኛ ከኣ ብሄራውነት ይበሃል ።ብሄራውነት ማለት ከኣ ንቢሄርካ ኣብሊጽካ ምርኣይ ዓብላሊ ክተከውን ምድላዩ ስለዚ።ብሄርተኝነት ትብል ቃል ኣምሓርኛ ኢያ ኢየ ዝብለካ ዘለኹ ።
@@zerom498 ኣውራጃ ሞ ወላ ተደለየ ናብ ብሄር ክቅየር ኣይክእልን ዩ መፈላለይ ተሃሊካ ኮ ኢኻ ብሄር ዝፍጠር እምበር ስለዝደለኻዩ ብሄር ትፈጥር ማለት ኣይኮነን።ኣይኮነን ኣውራጃ ብሄር ክፈጥር ሲ እቲ ብዓቢኡ ብሄረ ትግርኛ ኢሎም ሰይሞምና ዘለው ከማን ቅርጺ ናይ ቢሄር የብሉ ምኽንያቱ ትግርኛ ቋንቋ እምበር ብሄር ኣይኮነን ካልኣይ ከም ትግርኛ ሕብረተሰብ ኣብ ትግራይ ኣሎ ሓደ መበቆል ዘለዎ ሰለዚ ብሄር ስለዝደለኻዩ ስቅ ኢልካ ዝምስረት ኣይኮነን ሚኢቲ ዓመት ብብረት ተቃሊስካ ውን ዝመጽእ ኣይኮነን ምኽንያቱ ቢሄር ,ዓሚቅ መበቆል ,ናይ ገዛእ ርእስኻ ቋንቃ ,ልምዲ ብሂል ,ኣለባብሳ ኣቋንና ጸጉሪ ኣመጋግባ ,ባህላዊ ጸወታታት ክውንን ኣለዎ ብሄር ክተቅውም ተኾንካ።
@@semharkahsay1946 ብሄርትኝነትን ፡ ብሄራዉነትን፡ ኩሉ ትግርኛ አዩ ትርጉሙ አዩ ዝፈላለ ። Off course ኣብ ኣምሓርኛ ዉን ይጥቀምሉ አዮም ክልቲኡ፡ አዚ ማለት ግን ናይ ትግርኛ ቃል ኣይኮነን ማለት ኣይኮነን።
ኣቱም ሰባት ኣነስ ንበረየ ክፍትዎ፡ ክገርመኩም ብ ዳኒ ወዲ መምህር እየ ፈሊጠዮ እሞ ኣጋላልጹኡ ኣፍልጡኡ በቃ wwww
ቲሚካሒታዊ ሀጊራውኒት
ሳጊም ሒቢረ
ዮኒ ኣብ ቀጻሊ ግን ንበርየ ክዛረብ ዕድል ሃቦ ኢኻ😅ንስኻ ትምህሮ ዘለኻ ውን ኣዝዩ መሳጢ ኢዩ፣ ግዳ ጋሻ ስለ ዝኾነ ኣደንጊጹኒ😂😂
Miriam Webster definition of Nationalism “
: loyalty and devotion to a nation
especially : a sense of national consciousness, exalting one nation above all others and placing primary emphasis on promotion of its culture and interests as opposed to those of other nations or supranational groups”. Everyone exalt its family , sport club etc , what is wrong with it? Americans, Chinese, Russians, English, Italians, Turkish, Ethiopians, Eritreans, every country etc does, why bother about it?
ሃገራዊ ምጽናቲዝም ጌሩ ዛሃነጾ ሻዕብያ እዩ ናትና።
ጸረ ሒዚባዎኒት
Very powerful speech
Every Ethiopian MUST watch this speech so most of the Ethiopian people who living in tribalism (namely ethnic federalism) can finally choose to be the citizen NOT the idiots and tribalist or ethnocentric
There are three kinds of people
1) The idiots
2) The tribalist
3) The citizens
Both of from idiot people 😂😂
Then talk about right wing nationalism.
It seems there's some confusion here. If you're well-educated, you should have done your homework. I haven't heard any evidence or basis for your claim.
ፍ ቂሪ ሀገር ህዛቢ 😅አብ ጊዛእ ሀገሮ ሂፖሊቲካዊ ኢኮኖሚያዊ ባሂላዊ ሰቢአዊን መሲላት ዘሊው ማሊት ኢዮ። ሀጊራዊኒት አጊላሊ አቢራሲ ጪኾኒ ወራሪ ሀቢቲ ሀጊር አብ ራቢሐታት ወሊቀ ሰባት ዚዊዒ አብነት ህገደፍ
You can not have the sense of belongingness to a society if you don't have a national feeling. True, extreme ሕሉፍ nationalism is dangerous. But, come on man! Nationalism is a healthy feeling of love to who you are where you originated!! You are twisting this to fit the Tigray politicians narrative.
Your deep seated hatred of Tigray is clouding your sense of right and wrong. Your nationalism is based the hatred of the people of Tigray. We want to have a country at peace with itself and and its neighbors. We want our country to be like Switzerland. The german , Italian, and French speaking Swiss never deny their identity.
We are proud Tegaru from Eritrea. The era of denying our natural identity is over . Just take it easy.
do we have a healthy Nationlism in Eritrea?? The answer is WE DO NOT!!! In fact in Eritrea, it’s ultranationalism right now. You personally could feel of having a “healthy Nationalism” but assuming everyone else is the same is WRONG especially when Eritreans are subjected to ultra nationalism 24/7. Eritrea is under ultra nationalism force today.
Lease do not confuse young people. Mossolini was a fascist, right wing nationalist. ነቶ ብዝሕ ትምህርት ዘይብሎም ተደናግርዎም ኣለኹ።
They are enlightening the young generation. Your toxic nationalism has no place in the young generation.
Sagm. Invite we can talk about this
Thank you guys