It's not "sad" that we can't understand everything they say. To the Hmong in China, they say everyone is still family regardless of where they come from. Our differences shouldn't separate us, they bring us together.
Not completely true. The Hmong were affected during the Cultural Revolution as well, but it was already in trouble during the 1600's when the Manchurian's of the Qing Dynasty began banning practices and limiting rights for the minority groups. Those who migrated downwards towards the South maintained a lot of the original traditions, customs, and language, while those in the north began assimilating into Manchu and Han culture, as there's were banned. This goes for the majority of Han-Chinese people as well, those who fled the North due to invasions from Mongol tribes and Jurchen clans.
@@johnnythao post cultural revolution, their culture is coming back. No more repression , in fact they are given special priveleges , more paid holidays,lower passing score to go to uni, can have as many children as they want
Living in the United States, I can understand the guy's dialect perfectly, but I can't pick up the dialect from these Chinese Hmong at all. Such a beautiful world we live in, thanks for the video.
It’s so sad that Hmong people has dispersed so much that it’s so difficult to understand one another now. Nevertheless, we are all apples from the same tree.
Yes it is, but I find it kind of beautiful in a way, that we have created so many dialects and varieties. Most have to speak Mandarin in order to understand each other. :0(
I like how he's just casually speaking Hmong dawb like they would understand 😂 no sir, they don't understand the dialect just like how you cant understand theirs. You can clearly see how uncomfortable and clueless they are to our dialect.
@Jacky Phantom yes, each color represents the type of clothing for which each sub group of hmong distinguishes themselves. Why we do, I have no idea, but we are all hmong in essence and culture
@@level__level There are plenty of White Hmong in China too, there is no signal Chinese Hmong dialect, they have many dialects, actually many many, maybe hundreds of dialects more than us. The standard is actually something somewhat in-between our White and Green Hmong dialects, so it's incorrect to say White Hmong isn't the "original" dialect, because Green Hmong isn't either. For example Laotian Green Hmong call themselves Moob, but in Standard Miao, the standard Hmong dialect used in China for TV and news pronounces it Hmoob, like in White Hmong, but Standard Miao also pronounces the color white as Dlawb, so Standard Miao is neither White or Green, which makes sense because our dialects evolved and separated from them
I would've appreciated it if you interviewed some elders. It's clear that even though the girls do speak Mong they're not comfortable with it. And we would've gotten a better example of their dialects and how it's similar and different then ours. It kinda seems like showcasing maidens instead of our culture which most young girls don't know. It's just disappointing.
@@hujyajtv8976 Koj has yuamkev ua luaj le mas. Puab nyob Suav teb ces tsimnyog puab paub yaam lug Moob suav. Ntshe puab yuav rov has rua peb cov Moob nyob tim Mekas teb, nplog teb, thaib teb has tas, "Peb Moob aw, ruam dlhau lawm tag tag le tsi paub has lug le peb." Koj tsi xob has lug thuam rua puab es koj yuavtsum paub has tas tsi muaj tuab tuab yaam lug zoo xwb, tabsis txhua yaam lug yeej zoo lawm mas. Xob ua sab phem.
They probably don't understand him because Hmong Americans from Laos have such a new mixed language. There's a lot of Laotian and thai words that are embedded in the Hmong language from that area of the world. Every time Hmong people migrate, their language keep changing.
wow hmoob suav cov dress thiab jewerly mas zoo nkauj heev li lau..lawv siv sijhawm ntev npaum cas los ua tau ib lub ib ce lau?...lawv mas muaj tswv yim heev li os...
@@hughujkbkilhhhfbhgyre6436 Lol! You mean Siberia. That's were our distant ancestors brought over our people, but unfortunately that blood linage is no longer in us, we've completely assimilated into East Asians. Very much like how the Turks are mainly Europeans now, due to migrating west.
Obviously wherever you live you will speak that dialect. Hmong Laos and Thai speak the Lao/Thai dialect which we can still understand. Hmong Vietnamese will speak the Vietnamese Disney. It’s just where you live.
peb xav Kom peb sawv daws txhob siv lo lus hais tias Hmoob ua ntees no mas. .tus tij laug uas tab Tom hais hais lus no nas hais li ntawv nas. .ntees yog rau cov tuag xwb nas nawb. .
I feel sad that we can't clearly understand each other. I have a big question. Why Hmong in many countries can understand each other except Hmong in China?
It's not "sad" that we can't understand everything they say. To the Hmong in China, they say everyone is still family regardless of where they come from. Our differences shouldn't separate us, they bring us together.
Hmong in China are our original tribe. They kept most of our original culture and traditions. Time to go to China.
Not completely true. The Hmong were affected during the Cultural Revolution as well, but it was already in trouble during the 1600's when the Manchurian's of the Qing Dynasty began banning practices and limiting rights for the minority groups. Those who migrated downwards towards the South maintained a lot of the original traditions, customs, and language, while those in the north began assimilating into Manchu and Han culture, as there's were banned. This goes for the majority of Han-Chinese people as well, those who fled the North due to invasions from Mongol tribes and Jurchen clans.
@@johnnythao 傻逼 这也能扯到文革
@@johnnythao post cultural revolution, their culture is coming back. No more repression , in fact they are given special priveleges , more paid holidays,lower passing score to go to uni, can have as many children as they want
It's so weird, I understood them but I also had doubts, their dialects are so unique
Looks like the Hmong and Miao people are the most artistic people specially with their clothing embroideries!
Living in the United States, I can understand the guy's dialect perfectly, but I can't pick up the dialect from these Chinese Hmong at all. Such a beautiful world we live in, thanks for the video.
because they use many Chinese words. Chinese have big culture influence .even Hmong in Vietnam listen to Chinese songs more than Vietnamese songs.
@Jacky Phantom 怎么到处都是你
It’s so sad that Hmong people has dispersed so much that it’s so difficult to understand one another now. Nevertheless, we are all apples from the same tree.
Yes it is, but I find it kind of beautiful in a way, that we have created so many dialects and varieties. Most have to speak Mandarin in order to understand each other. :0(
I think its pretty darn cool!
I wonder why though. Americans and British has been separated for longer, 400 + years and they understand each other fine. Same with Spanish.
Yeah it's called dialect
@@Timothee_Chalamet_CMBYN Might have to do with that Hmong language is a oral language. There are no rules set to keep it coherent.
My dream is to see all Asian people United as One
I like how he's just casually speaking Hmong dawb like they would understand 😂 no sir, they don't understand the dialect just like how you cant understand theirs. You can clearly see how uncomfortable and clueless they are to our dialect.
yes LOL
not to mention, that hmong people who speaks only the white dialect doesnt understand every single word from the green dialect lol.
@Jacky Phantom yes, each color represents the type of clothing for which each sub group of hmong distinguishes themselves. Why we do, I have no idea, but we are all hmong in essence and culture
Because Hmong white is NOT the original dialect. Hmong Green is because it is the closest to hmong Chinese dialect.
@@level__level There are plenty of White Hmong in China too, there is no signal Chinese Hmong dialect, they have many dialects, actually many many, maybe hundreds of dialects more than us. The standard is actually something somewhat in-between our White and Green Hmong dialects, so it's incorrect to say White Hmong isn't the "original" dialect, because Green Hmong isn't either. For example Laotian Green Hmong call themselves Moob, but in Standard Miao, the standard Hmong dialect used in China for TV and news pronounces it Hmoob, like in White Hmong, but Standard Miao also pronounces the color white as Dlawb, so Standard Miao is neither White or Green, which makes sense because our dialects evolved and separated from them
Hmong Też Ma Piękne Stroje i Też Piękne Dziewczyny ❤ Pozdrawiam Serdecznie Hmong z Poland ❤ .
i understand but then i dont. I wish we could all reconnect.
Zoo heev lis og 💗💗💗
Oke zoo heev li os tij laug
Zoo siab heev li qhov peb yog hmoob os tij laug
Zoo heev li os
2คนแรกนี่แซ่จ๊ะเหมือนผมเลย
Zoo heev li og 👍👍🙏❤️🌹🌹
I would've appreciated it if you interviewed some elders. It's clear that even though the girls do speak Mong they're not comfortable with it. And we would've gotten a better example of their dialects and how it's similar and different then ours. It kinda seems like showcasing maidens instead of our culture which most young girls don't know. It's just disappointing.
Youa V Xiong dabneeg
Tuaj koom koj dua os.
zoo heev .tab sis tu siab kawg uas peb puav leej yog hmoob tiamsis ib leeg tsi paub ib leeg tej lus le
Hmong Thailand
yog kawg lawv ruam dhau lawm tsis paub lus hmoob
@@hujyajtv8976 Koj has yuamkev ua luaj le mas. Puab nyob Suav teb ces tsimnyog puab paub yaam lug Moob suav. Ntshe puab yuav rov has rua peb cov Moob nyob tim Mekas teb, nplog teb, thaib teb has tas, "Peb Moob aw, ruam dlhau lawm tag tag le tsi paub has lug le peb." Koj tsi xob has lug thuam rua puab es koj yuavtsum paub has tas tsi muaj tuab tuab yaam lug zoo xwb, tabsis txhua yaam lug yeej zoo lawm mas. Xob ua sab phem.
pom hmoob sawv tsheej phiaj tag ib tiaj lo yg Hmoob zoo siab heev li os Hmoob cas peb g koom siab es sau los nyb ua ke xb os Hmoob....
Nyob li no thiaj li sib hlub sib hwm Coob nyob ua ke laj dob plaub dhau...
They probably don't understand him because Hmong Americans from Laos have such a new mixed language. There's a lot of Laotian and thai words that are embedded in the Hmong language from that area of the world. Every time Hmong people migrate, their language keep changing.
The dialect is very unique
So interesting. I’m hmong American myself
yog kawg lawm jk yam hmoob ngias muaj ngias lus
Hmong traddition fashion is great.
Tuaj saib koj dua os py zoo
hmoob yog ib hom ng zoo nkj zoo nraug hv
wow hmoob suav cov dress thiab jewerly mas zoo nkauj heev li lau..lawv siv sijhawm ntev npaum cas los ua tau ib lub ib ce lau?...lawv mas muaj tswv yim heev li os...
Lo zem heev li os
Why so many dislikes? Yall dont appreciate where yall came from lol
Ikiguy
We hmong didn’t come from China, we came from Persia. China was only a pathway for us to get to America.
Hughujkb Kilhhhfbhgyre 数典忘祖之辈，你族在中国古代传说中就已经在中国繁衍生息上千年了。早已经融入华夏文明。 按你的那个说法，怎么不说所有人都来自非洲呢？ 毕竟非洲是人类发源地不是吗？
@@hughujkbkilhhhfbhgyre6436 Lol! You mean Siberia. That's were our distant ancestors brought over our people, but unfortunately that blood linage is no longer in us, we've completely assimilated into East Asians. Very much like how the Turks are mainly Europeans now, due to migrating west.
@@skey8809 yup 蚩尤是中华三祖！大家都是中华/中国人
@@skey8809 别说什么数典忘祖，因为苗族本来和我们没什么关系，都不是汉藏语系，但这人说他们来自波斯就纯粹是臆想了，苗族基因可是几千年的南方土著，和南亚语系还有关系
Hluag nkj hmob suav zoo nkj kawg li tug tij laug .
So beautiful!!
hmoob nyob suav teb. yeej muaj ntau. Zoo li .Hmoob peg
แลดูน่ารักๆ
Zoo siab koj tau yees duab rau peb tau saib ua tsaug ntau.
Zoo laug dhau lawm os
Nej hailus peb tsipaub lios hmoob suav ‘aw!
Zoo heev li
Hluas nkauj hmoob suav zoo nkauj ntxim hlub kaws
相隔千里，却有血脉相连的感觉。
Wow hluas nkauj hmoob SUAV zoo nkauj laiv yom
hmoob aws tsis paub lus li lawm tu siab kawg...
hmoob suav hais lus txawv dua hmoob nyob lwm teb chaws lawm pom tau tias sib txawv heev lawm
posvangvieng vang Hmoob suav yog tas nro peb haiv neeg Hmoob lub keeb kwm.
Hmoob tiam sig hais nyuab heev li os ypm hmoob Suab aw
8
.
tu siab hmoob suav tsis txawj hais lus hmoob lawm
Ntxim hlub kawg
zoo nkauj heev sig tsi lo ua pâum hom hí hí
chứ mong việt nam thì
jong gâx hênhv lê sis tsi lo uô paiv hí hí
Nyob coob lom zem xauv npo xwb zoo heev os kwv tij hmoob
Happy for watching hmoob origines.
❤️👍🔔
Hmmoob pom tau nej nyob tau lom zeem kawm ua rau kv kho siab heev li
Hluag nkauj hmoob suab zoo nkauj heev li, tiam sis tsi paub lus hmoob li os.
hì không có ai biết chữ mong việt nam thật rồi
pux mongz jong gâux nyoz tsôngl quôv têz
peb cov hmoob yuav ploj zuj zus mu li lm lau
ntuj aw hmoob os hmoob aw hmoob suav aw mu uasuav tas lawm lis tiag lawv tsis paub hais lu hmoob lis lawm os
hlinra hlub yog lawm tiag og. tu siab kawg tij laug
hlinra hlub zajnkaujtswimuobtsis
hlinra hluสb
Thanks for sharing.
hmoob muaj ntau hom heev.hmoob dawb.hmoob leeg.hmoob dub.hmoob puas.hmoob liab.hmoob ntsuab.hmoob tshiab.hmoob sib. thiab tseem tshuav ib hom hmoob nyob suav teb hais lus txawv txawv kuv tsis paub lawm
Zoo.Hv.Li.O.Py
Hais lus hmoob kom heev heev nawb hais lus hmoob tsis tau lawm nawb
💓💓💓💓💓
ชอบมากอยากไปเที่ยว
Zoo heev
Like
Yus yog Hmoob los twb tsis paub ib lo lus Hmoob li es pheej hais tias yog Hmong pab tu siab.
Lom zem kawg kiag suav teb log,tuaj kv tshooj thiab os p y hmoob aw.
Hmoob puas yog peb cov kwv tig hmoob uas hu txiv hu uas vaim no nej
sib paub tsis sib tau yeej tu siab mad,kuv nplooj sb zoo.
Hmoob cov lug mas poob tag lawm lau, haig lug tshig sib to taub hlo
Moob ni Moob Gimtxaj kawgle ncuJoov taspeb YogMoobsib nb
Obviously wherever you live you will speak that dialect. Hmong Laos and Thai speak the Lao/Thai dialect which we can still understand. Hmong Vietnamese will speak the Vietnamese Disney. It’s just where you live.
ฟังได้นิดหน่อย
kuv tho sai koj
Hay
ntxim lom zem them
พูดสำเนียงภาษาจีน
Cas hais lus txawv ua luaj li hmoob
Kev hais lus hmoob kom meej ces swb kiag hmoob nplog los tsuas teb lawm
cov kwv tij hmoob nyob suav teb g paub lus hmoob lawm tiag lau
peb xav Kom peb sawv daws txhob siv lo lus hais tias Hmoob ua ntees no mas. .tus tij laug uas tab Tom hais hais lus no nas hais li ntawv nas. .ntees yog rau cov tuag xwb nas nawb. .
tsis paub hais lus Hmoob ces peb Hmoob tag li no li lawm os
Cheng Xiong tsi yog tsi pauv og yog ib leeg nyob ib leeg ib lub teb chaw xwb
haa laj mhoog lug kawg yom
8
Zoo le zoo Moobsib Moobland thov sibhlub sibpaab thoojxeeb koomtxoog ua ibgob neeg xํobxyum lawvkua Gizoo giyog Moobsib txhajyog lubnoob Moob
moo qua nyob npuas ciam nyab laj xa
tu siab tias hai lus tsis tshua sib paub zoo lawm es peb cov lus hmoob tiag2 yg hmoob suav li lo yg hmoob nplog li
Tij laus. Koj puas mus txog Honhe naj. Koj mug txos no tseg muab ib zaj video rau kuv saib yom. Ua tsaug.
Z li lawv ts pb lus hmoob as hihi cov hluas nkj no yuav tham no ts nkag siab yus li os
I feel sad that we can't clearly understand each other. I have a big question. Why Hmong in many countries can understand each other except Hmong in China?
Which china province is the flower explosion city
Kho siab zim xwb os, ib tsoos phooj ywg sawv daws os
zoo heev os tij laug . pab kuv thiab os
看起来很好玩
Vg,OK
Cac bai mua khao mang mua bai ban là nơi em ở học sinh khối 7
So r there any hmong people in Xijiang Guizhou?
tug tij laus cas .koj cov video sau no .tsi pom peb hmoob vietnam li sub no.
Hmoob DakLak yog lawm. kuv ngob xeev Điện Biên
Hmoob DakLak y
Very strong Chinese accent, can barely make out what they are saying.
Hahaha z luag qhov uas lawv ts pb lo lus lom zem yg dab tsi os
Hmoob puas tseg yog hmoob dub maj.
Zoo xaib heev tab si khuv sim ua koj tsi noog cov luas nkauj los si có phooj ywg ntuwm tub xov tooj los Facebook na tij laug....
lawv hmoob xuav teb ces yeej ib yam lj ntaw peb nyob nrog lawv ua ke yus twb nug tsis txaug li os
kuv ha tri tau lud Hmông lở
eg nej nyob teb cxawg twg na