Google Maps vs Apple Maps!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 พ.ค. 2023
- 🖼️ // My Wallpapers
www.buymeacoffee.com/joshuach...
Let's settle the debate. Which maps app is king? Google Maps or Apple Maps?
Related video: • Is Waze Dying?
🎥 // Gear I Use
www.amazon.com/shop/joshuachang/
🎵 // Music I Use
30 day free trial
share.epidemicsound.com/jvrsb4
⚠️ // Disclaimers
Description contains affiliate links.
--
/ joshuachang
I think you have to take this with a grain of salt. Apple Maps may be better in the US/Canada, but in Europe is another whole story. I live in Spain and G. Maps is way better, IMO
Apple has the majority of their tech grasp in the USA so they do most of there fancy stuff, like images for apple maps, in the USA. Google has hundreds of advertisements and videos showing how they try to cover as much land as possible for google maps.
@@djplonghead5403 Still, Apple is not a tech Startup and even has more money to invest into it.. At least they are improving. Still more potential.
I live in France and i use Apple Maps daily. It’s more than enough for me but it lacks key features still, like bike navigation….
I live in Germany and we got Lookaround with Apple Maps last year. And it is insanely good. They have mapped every little road even really remote ones in forrests. Most of the images in Google Street View in Germany are from 2011 or 2012 so they are really old. And navigation is basically the same between the two.
So I switched to Apple Maps last year and I'm really happy with it.
I’d say Apple is pretty good in uk tbh, especially for walks with its AR feature
I actually prefer the design of Apple Maps, but what I love so much about google is the amount of reviews compared to apple which is often lacking
Nobody uses garbage apple apps
Agreed. I like the design and minimalism of Apple Maps. I do wish the reviews were better, but I honestly finding myself just looking it up on Google for that and just getting place to place, the UI is good enough for me
@@alter112 time for you to use your brain and instead of saying 'nobody' say 'many people don't'
There must be a specific generation that cares about reviews. I need to go from point A to point B. Thats it. Reviews is a place for unsatisfied people (mostly unjustified)to rage. Sorry. Fact.
@@jamesnyers1721 Not really a fact since not all people leave reviews that are negative or unsatisfied. It’s helpful to know what peoples experiences were from a business good or bad. Saves you a trip and money.
I used to use Google Maps, but since I bought my Apple Watch I use Apple Maps. I love how how it vibrates when it’s time to turn, and shows the direction of the turn. Handy when it’s bright and my screen is hard to see. Also giving me details like driving thru a light and turning at the next light. Those two alone makes Apple Maps better for me.
Same. Although I also use Maps for informations because in France it is more reliable for opening hours.
Same here. I love how my Apple Watch is integrated with Apple Maps.
I use Apple Maps on my iPad to check if there is a new place
Just to add a couple new things for Apple Maps with iOS 17: Find My is now kind of integrated, people don’t show up directly on the map but they do show up in search so you can easily get directions to them. Offline maps are also now available
I thought the offline maps was a standard feature but it turns out it’s just iOS 17.
@@lebedsam1357 Apple maps offered the offline maps the last few years
@@lebedsam1357it is a standard feature. Why would it being in an iOS update make it anything but?
I definitly think Google Maps actually takes the win for Street View just because of the ability to go through time and contribute to it yourself. And, Google Maps can also split-screen like you showed with Apple Maps. :)
If Google maps used the data from Waze (which they also own) and incorporated warnings I think they would win. Or even if they added lanes considering they have street views of the actual roads they have no excuse in my opinion lol
@@damnimloominI don't get how having different lanes in street view is actually helpful, it takes more space in their servers, needs more cars to capture every lane, Google being that serious about ecology wouldn't add such futile feature I think
I think apple maps are amazing it really feels like your‘re in a game...
Doesn’t apple have street view?
@@bapoTV they could just have someone use their eyes and look at current street views lol or use an ai to fill in the blanks since we know they love that. Also that’s fine if one of the largest tech monopolies can’t find some server space I’ll just keep using apple 😂
I spent a week with my brother and he only uses Apple Maps ... I think it has come a long way and was very useful. I do agree that the detail on lanes and landmarks (trees, etc) are better on Apple Maps. But I can switch to satellite view on Google Maps if I need to see things like that. I use Google Maps every day for my commute and love it (especially when it shows speed traps). It will also give me a notification to let me know how long my commute will be, just in case there's an accident. Great comparison video
Apple Maps also warns about speed checks and notifies about accidents, it even recommends a faster route if there’s a last minute accident reported on your route
@@mr.infante Tell us something we don't know and that isn't on Google Maps😅👍
Apple advises of speed traps too as well as how long my commute will plus alternate roots. Google has had a definitive head start though does a few things better.
@@Murillos1 Apple Maps is my primary navigation app and is underrated, however google maps is better to explore around, and it’s constantly getting updated, so new buildings and addresses sometimes don’t show up in Apple Maps, or the location is not precise, in those instances I use Google maps. I like to take the best of them both
@@Murillos1 the sharing of ETA with contacts!
I really enjoyed this comparison. I’d love to see more like this (comparing popular but similar apps). Great stuff! Wish we could blend both of the apps!
One nice thing about Google Maps is that you can actually put emojis on your bookmarks lists. I find it to be very helpful when trying to find one list by having that visual aspect to it beyond just the text when in the bookmark list. Needless to say, that if you decide to have your bookmarks show up on your main page the emoji makes it exceptionally easy to find the category you're looking for.
I swear ppl be saying the most useless reasons as to why its better😂😂😂
I feel like the main drawback to using apple maps in Europe - in german speaking countries at least has to be the fact that almost no one uses yelp. So you just can‘t find a big chunk of restaurants or companies you‘d like to navigate to on apple maps- everyone has a google business profile tho so you‘ll always get an Adress using google maps - I personally like the clearer instructions on when to turn and the nicer layout of the actual map on apple maps a lot more so I‘ve been using that a lot.
Apple Maps uses TripAdvisor in France, that’s nice here, better since the open contributions, but sure thing there is room to improve .
This is the first time I'm seeing why Yelp is still used. I always thought who uses yelps? Google a restaurant and read or add reviews right on the search result, no need for a separate app for that. Now I see why, Apple keeping them on a lifeline.
It would be really nice if you would talk about how they compare for transit, biking, walking, etc. Not everyone gets around by car.
Yeah Google is really bad for that while Apple displays transit and cycling directions much better. It’s cleaner and more simple, easy to use ect. Also the graphics and guides are great.
@@greek9244 However Google Maps has transit, walking, and biking coverage in so many more places than Apple Maps. Apple Maps is mostly good in the U.S. and Google Maps easily wins out outside of America. Once Google Maps adds Live Activities their transit directions will be absolutely amazing though…
@@OEverything I agree that google maps has better biking coverage outside the us, however I live in Germany and Apple Maps has covered every small bus route of every shitty town I know
@@OEverything nah google maps transit doesn’t really work at all in my country or city but Apple Maps has better transit coverage in Western Europe than google, but Eastern Europe google maps is a lot better. Just depends on where you live I guess
Good one.
I’ve started to use Apple Maps for navigation and Google Maps for everything else (research, Timeline, lists, etc.) It’s working out pretty well for me!
Apple maps is invaluable to me when driving in new cities because of it's spoken lane warnings. "Stay in the left two lanes", stuff like that has saved me so many times. For some reason my google directions are almost delayed, like the spoken directions did a poor job anticipating where i'd be. Those last second directions can be hectic and even dangerous
I work for a public water utility and sometimes we have to assess damages from water leaks to sidewalks, roads, etc. I’ll use google street view to find out if the damage was there before our leak or if a meter box was covered up by landscaping or pavement. Being able to time travel in street view has helped us a lot.
One nice thing you didn’t mention about Apple Maps is that you can share your ETA with your friend. So if you two are meeting up by a certain time, you can rest assured they won’t be late and you two can arrive around the same time to eliminate waiting.
I use google maps for 99% of my directions in my area. I’ve noticed that G Maps is more accurate than Apple Maps when it comes down to traffic and arrival times. Google will have you take certain side streets to avoid traffic where Apple will have you stay on main roads and avoid neighborhoods.
One thing I really do like about google maps is the ability to start and cancel a route with just one button. That is very important to me, especially when this app is designed to be used while in motion, such as driving a car. That means I can tap the phone or infotainment screen on Apple CarPlay one time whereas I have to press the screens two times on Apple Maps which costs so much time and attention away from the road.
On Google you can share your trip location with anyone
@@b0wking119it’s not live though
@@rehatbir. It's live! In fact, I can track your every move using Google maps.
@@rehatbir. there is a way to make it live
@@rehatbir.its live! Goofy
I think the main thing going for google maps is that it works mostly everywhere in the world. I live in South Africa and google maps is great for suggesting safer route options whereas Apple maps does not do that. That may also be why Google maps suggests you to go past your slipway turn of to make a u turn, because most of the world drive on the left side of the road. Letting you go past the slipway and making you do a u turn. I might be wrong though.
You are 100% on that. Google maps is amazing in South Africa.
What do you mean by "most of the world driving on the left"? Surface-wise or population-wise?
Wow I did not know they suggest safer driving options. I’d really like this for the U.S. especially in cities like Chicago and Atlanta
Google dominates in Africa. It's like they just care. I have directions for even really remote locations in Uganda
All countries that have left-hand traffic combined make up about 30% of the earth's population, I wouldn't call that "most of the world".
Not sure if Apple Maps does this but one cool feature I love is the intergration between google maps and photos. So it overlays the photos that you've taken in a particular location on the maps and you can zoom out to show more pics in other locations.
I found this very helpful when I'm looking for pictures that I took years back in a particular location.
Just navigate to that area and I see all the pics that were taken there
Yeah. Apple OS Photos apps uses Apple Maps to overlay photos that have location data. Photos without location data are not displayed on the Maps, but you can easily add locations to the Photos to see them in Maps view. I like it better this way.
YESS!!!!! I really like that feature as well
How do I enable this?
@@FabExoN Open your photos app, go to the “albums” tab, scroll down to the “people and places” section, and then click on the box called “places” - should bring up a map that shows where all your pictures were taken, as described above
I'm from Malaysia and I have Apple Maps, Google Maps and Waze for different use cases. For daily navigation and restaurants research, I use Google Maps, when I drive on highway, I use Waze to check the road reports and toll fare. Whenever to travel to Singapore (or any Apple Maps supported countries), I will switch to Apple Maps as the navigation/public transport arrival time is clearer and more accurate.
I always use both. Google maps for discovery and Apple Maps for literally everything else
Another bonus feature for Apple Maps that I use heavily is it’s integration with the Apple Watch. When you have navigation active, you can just look to your wrist for the next instruction, and it gives different haptic notifications depending on which direction you have to turn. The same thing applies to CarPlay, if you have navigation active it will seamlessly work across all three at once, whereas Google Maps needs a bit more user attention to make work.
I've turned off vocal instructions using haptics and looking at my watch.
If you use a WearOS watch you get the same integration that apple gives you with their watch.
Everything you mentioned fully automated with Android devices too ;) That said, historically and till this day, apple=more steps+more user input required while Androids=less steps, more automation. His video once again showed proof of that too. Too many hidden stuff is a headache for many people.
Apple Watch navigation alerts are awesome. The haptics are directional.
Got to figure out how to disable notifications on Apple Watch while using navigation with CarPlay. Having this haptics on the wrist while driving is annoying as hell.
Apple use to have a single tap END button however it caused screen burn in, which is now also why it's a lot less cluttered with stagnant coloured buttons. It makes sense as when youre using it to navigate your outside in direct sunlight which is when the screen is at its brightest point.
Apple Maps also does support offline maps.
Also another feature that might be useful for other users is the Terrain map layer in G. Maps, which shows the topographic map instead of the default one.
Very useful in San Fran. As there are some difficult walks for the elderly!
Apple kind of has an equivalent for that, don’t know why he didn’t compare the different layers (driving, satellite, etc.) in the video
Nice review but it would have been cool to have included a comparison of Transit directions convenience and accuracy on both apps as well. Important use-case for many.
Exactly. The comparison is good but where I come from 80% of the people are using navigation apps just for public transit.
Android user here with Google maps, here in NYC Google maps actually tracks the live position of subways and I believe it does the same for bus. So you can plan on which train you want to take. It does this either through a transit API or more accurately crowd sourced data. It also shows you how crowded the trains are and calculates which train route is faster through transfer based on the real time positions of the trains. Also it mixes transit options, so you can take a train to a ferry to a train. or if the place you are going is in a transit desert, it gives you transit options as close as possible and estimates the Lyft price for each route so you can pick the best one for your wallet from whichever transit station Can someone who commutes with public transit with apple tell me how it works
The thing holding back Apple Maps is their lack of reviews. If they cut Yelp and came out with their own review system, it could easily overtake Google Maps imo
Overtake?! Hmm... Doubtful. Considering more people use Android and Google globally that isn't going to sprout as much data as Google has already amassed. iOS pocket has 27% global market share.
@@DSarDarkstar ok
@@DSarDarkstar but in the US they have 50% market share so if you live there it’s not nearly as one sided
@@Ferrichrome I live in the USA... And yet Morrissey sang it best "America is not the world". Blame American teens for this trend in iOS. They like their grandparents, seek simple tech with very little function.... They just want green bubbles or blue bubbles or whatever bubble they think is the bad one. It's electronic racism I tell ya!)
it's so much more nuanced than that. Apple Maps has at least 2 or 3 more generations to go before they can catch up
I have both apps on my phone. I recently started using apple map because it shows which direction I’m facing. I find it to be very helpful when I go hiking. I do appreciate the offline map feature of google map though because you know sometimes there’s no signal in the wilderness.
My take on this. I’m from the Caribbean and we mostly use google maps or Waze as the road networks are simple. When I was in Miami in June, google maps had us taking the wrong turns at the wrong times. Apple Maps have so much context we never missed a turn off and it was able to show complex roadways as opposed to google maps. I know what to use strictly for my USA trips going forward.
Great video. Thanks Josh 😊
In Malaysia Google Maps is the only usable map navigation app, even Waze uses Google map data. I love Google Maps where it gives me rewards when I write reviews, upload pictures videos, help them improve the map.
I tried using Apple Maps, I love the interface but the data is either inaccurate or just filled with spam businesses which takes several days for the system to take down upon reporting, and no street view on Apple Maps.
❤
agree, Google maps works well here in southeast asia
Very informative. Thank you for sharing this information 😊
The one feature that always takes me back to Apple Maps is the destination location when navigating. Google places it in relation to where you are (i.e. north if the destination is north of you). Apple Maps always places it at the top of the screen so your arrow/location is always at the bottom of the screen. Being able to switch between route overview and focused view is also easier on Apple Maps.
I HATED this about Google Maps. However, I checked and you can change this in Google Maps to have the destination always at the top. (However I still far prefer Apple Maps for two main reasons. Context directions ie. "The second left after the stop sign" vs Googles 100 ft type of directions. Apple's is far superior. Directions: SOOOOOO many time Google maps tries to be too smart, only to be extremely stupid. It will take you on side streets and back ways because in theory it is a shorter distance, however, there are so many turns and stops and it is usually through neighborhoods with speed limits and bumps that ends up being far slower and convoluted. This has happened for myself and when I'm in Rideshare ALOT. Many times it takes you through parking lots instead of streets. It is beyond stupid.
Click on the compass, that "red and white arrow" and the map display is changed to the way you like
It would be a dream come true, if google and apple collaborated to create a common standard/interface (wouldn't be the first time) for map data and reviews. Imo such things should be platform independent and also it would allow google and apple (and other competitors) to capitalize more on the integration in their platforms rather than the information provided
Super useful video! Thanks :)
One thing to not about Apple’s street view is that it’s actually more advanced. It actually treat things with depth meaning that you can tap a side of a building in the distance and it will take you to the point closest to it. It also makes movements seem more natural. I think this was done using a combination of LiDAR installed on the street view car and some computational depth calculation which I find really cool.
Here in the UK Google Maps still has way more POI data but that's about it. Apple Maps is more accurate when it comes to lane guidance, speed limits, toll zones, road layouts, road closures etc. It has improved so much over here
Yea, it’s quite a lot better here, especially in public transport
Not a huge fan of how Apple Maps looks after using Google Maps for so long, but I might need to give it another try after all these years. Seems like it would be very useful for just when Im driving around town and need to get from Point A to Point B. Google Maps will most likely stay as my primary maps app though.
Also, Google Maps was super useful for when I was in NYC using the subway system. Gave me step by step directions on when I what lines I should take, when/if I would need to change lines. It made it so simple.
apple does that too
@@ianferneepr5648 Yes I just noticed that after reinstalling and looking at all the settings. Apple Maps looks better than I remembered. Also nice how it syncs with an Apple Watch and youll get a vibration on the wrist when youre nearing a turn. Will be using Apple Maps for Point A to B like I said, but sticking to Google when looking for places to eat and such.
Honestly Google Maps are better overall in my experience. I use car play and I still prefer Google maps. Google maps user interface is better imo .
@@CU-Later yeah this is basically what I do. I use Google Maps for search and discovering things for the most part but Apple Maps for car, transit, biking, and pedestrian navigation. I think it just destroys G Maps for the navigation piece - the experience is way nicer, better sounds, better Apple Watch integrations, and the UX is significantly better & more detailed imo. Also the AR walking directions is much smoother than G Maps AR walking directions
I think you should have included walking directions/functionality as well. As someone who travels weekly, I find Apple Maps to be superior when walking. A great feature is Look Around, by pointing your camera at the buildings around you, will refine your location when in dense cities. As well as give augmented reality directions when needed.
You can actually also do that in Google maps
@@Alvin_ketchup omg how to do that pls
Google Maps do that even before Apple Maps released
I use all three. I have a shortcut that gives me options for where I want to go. If I select somewhere known (like home or the grocery store) it takes me to Apple Maps for the better directions and navigation. If I select “other” it takes me to google maps since it’s better for discovering new places. And it also opens Waze in the background so I get the little sound effect when I go over the speed limit.
oh wait, thats actually really cool, can u tell me how u did it
Apple Maps looks really nice, but when you can’t find opening hours, updated locations for stores or get accurate travel times ,it just doesn’t matter.
every store has opening times and the travel times and directions are more accurate,. at least here in Australia
An extremely well-balanced and fair review. I work from home, I don't travel that much and when I get in the car there's 90% chance I know where I'm going or how to get there with little to no assistance from a maps app. Apple Maps is my default but I'll venture into Google Maps from time to time (probably less than a dozen times in a year). Of course it's not surprising that Google was the winner as their entire business model is based on getting every scrap of information they can to keep their advertising business model afloat.
As much as I love Apple products and services I don't think Apple Maps can ever catch up to Google Maps simply because it's not a core function of Apple's business. I'm sure Apple has a crack team of talented engineers and marketing experts working daily to improve the experience but it's never going to be as robust as Google's because unlike Google they don't rely on the maps app to be a primary profit center compared to Google.
I see these (and Waze) more as complementary apps. For me:
- Waze is for my commute and driving into heavily congested areas like downtown
- Google Maps has a better interface for looking up directions at a starting location other than where you currently are
- Apple Maps is what I’ll use for walking/public transit due to its tight integration with my Apple Watch - allowing me to leave my phone in my pocket. That same feature is also great when I’m going someplace new because the haptic taps on my wrist will alert me to an upcoming turn or stop (I intensely dislike audible directions, so don’t use them).
TL;DR use the app for the use-case you need in the moment
Excellent review. Just used both on an extended driving trip through Scotland; timeline is so cool for this. In fact, we had switched to iphones in oct, and I didn't realize google had defaulted to *not* tracking me, so I missed the first few days. When our friends joined us, and we shared locations through Google, then it started capturing. Hope apple adds this soon. One other benefit of apple maps are the cues on my watch. Nice to have haptic heads-up and a quick glance at the watch while driving.
If you have an apple watch, apple maps is the way to go. Don't even have to look at your phone. The watch pulses and let's you know both what and when.
I use both apps because of the watch l now use apple maps constantly.
Google maps is way better though for longer trips cause of the crowd sourced info on speed traps and traffic health. Once Apple get those, I’ll switch because I already prefer Safari over Chrome and etc.
Sorry, that is feature useless. I’m not sure what function it was but it vibrated like seven times annoyingly.
Hey! Love the content but I did want to update you on the fact that as of right now, Apple Maps will support offline maps with iOS 17. I am on iOS Public Beta 3, have downloaded offline maps for two trips I've taken (one where there was very little cell service at all) and it has been super simple to use. This comes with Automatic updates (toggleable in settings) as well as being optimized for iPhone storage (toggleable in settings), taking up less space than when I tried it with Google Maps. Also, Apple Maps introduced a feature recently where you can use Look Around (street view) when walking and actually see directional elements implemented with AR. I, again, used it on a trip when exploring a new city and was able to easily locate shops, restaurants and more with this feature. I understand that this video can't be constantly updated but maybe a pinned comment or something in the description could disclose these new addons.
This was a really good comparative review video. I just switched to Apple from android and was wondering about their maps. Thank you!
Your video style and accent make me feel comfortable! Come on man, hope to see more videos from you❤!
I’ve been using Apple maps exclusively for the past 4 years. I love the UI and what it actually displays on the screen, I use the directions box on the top left primarily rather than the blue line for guidance which is so much clean compared to google maps which is always cluttered. Also, Google Maps never displays what street you’re on which is annoying, It’s like you know where you’re going or you know where you are but not both.
Yeah apple always has better UI google has more functions always been that way even though I mainly use android luckily u can use both on iOS
I (Germany) personally like Apple Maps more. I really love the more detailed map, especially in vacation its easier to discover placed that you could visit. Since i'm a Beta user, i can use offline maps in Apple Maps. I think its easier to select the region you want to download on Apple Maps. In google maps the selection marker felt a little buggy. I also think that Apple Maps is loading the online map faster than google maps when you have bad internet connection (germany in a nutshell lol).
An interesting comparison between the two! Another issue is the amount of data that is used, if your contract with the network provider charges on that basis. There are things that can be done to minimise it, such as pre-loading the planned route via a cheaper to use router at home etc. There are lots of sites that can advise on this topic.
The other matter is that both of them are dependent on the availability of communications where you start from. There are parts of the world where it has no access to the map in use. Looking on the bright side, apps like this CAN access up to date maps (when there is a network connection), compared with sat nav systems that carry local copies of maps on board - but we do not actually know how accurate the updates are either. I use Google maps to browse around planned routes on my desktop, and the maps are often out of date, and often their street view output is not compatible with the overhead view - in effect when zooming in, the version changes; weird. The accuracy of this probably depends a lot on their interface with various highway authorities globally, of course.
Great content, thanks for the explanation.
I mostly use Apple Maps in the UK where I am based, however, I like the way it navigates, but some features aren't available in the UK like the cycling option, and unfortunately, this is the biggest one I wanted.
When you already know which app will win, you still find yourself watching. Lol. Love this!
I’ve had some pretty bad experiences with Google Maps navigation. The first incident was probably the worst. I was driving down the interstate and decided to add a stop to a Sam’s Club to get some gas (had been in the area once before, so I was sort of familiar with how to get there already). Google had me get off the interstate one exit early even though Sam’s was very close to the next exit’s interchange. It had me go down some back road through the woods with a low speed limit. At one point, it told me to turn down a grassy path (not even a gravel/dirt road). I couldn’t even go that way because a tree was down, showing how infrequent that path gets used. I kept going straight passed more sketchy woods houses until I got to the back of the Sam’s parking lot. I was so blown away that that was the PREFERRED route Google Maps wanted to use. I could’ve just waited one more exit, turned left, immediately turned left again, and been where I wanted much quicker and so much easier. After a few more bad (but not quite so horrible) experiences with Google Maps navigation, I’ve swapped to using Apple Maps. However, I still search Google Maps if I want to find new places like restaurants since Apple Maps doesn’t always have everything on the map (like the places don’t show up in search, and scrolling over the location on the map doesn’t reveal anything there).
I was driving in Germany and using Appel map was quite intuitive in its introduction and often time it happened to miss leading me, but on the other hand google maps I had also experienced some confusion, miss leading and disoriented but it was quite better compared with apple map. There is one feature in apple map that like it is warning about traffic lights and the speed limits that associated with it. However, my personal experience suggests that both maps are very useful tool to navigate in the road but it important for the driver to read and follow the road instructions signs and directions of distention.
Great video - on point
The main reason why I like Apple Maps over Google Maps is navigation on interstates or big highways because Apple Maps tells you based on your location in which lane you should be to avoid right/left turn only lanes or which is the recommended lane if you are approaching an exit. Something that Google Maps similarly does, but it is somewhat confusing for me when I am driving since it tells you for example " in 1.2mi be in this lane". It is a small thing, but I find it the compelling argument for me choosing Apple vs Google.
Personally, I like Apple Maps more. Although I'm from Germany and a lot of these features you've got in the US aren't available here, I love it for it's easiness to use. One thing I especially like is how good and reliable it works with CarPlay. Voice commands just work well and thanks to the intuitive design I'm able to navigate quick and simple when driving
My favorite feature for Apple Maps and the reason I use it primarily is the compatibility with my Apple Watch. Not only do I have a quick and easy view of what’s coming up with that in addition to my phone, it also will vibrate when a turn is coming up, with different vibrations for left and right.
Definitely more of a niche use case since it requires an Apple Watch, but a really cool and useful feature if you have one.
Thanks for this review, just a comment for algorithm :D
I prefer Apple Maps for actual navigation, both driving and walking. It happened so many times that i was super confused about the walking directions on Google Maps. But for discovering new places, Google Maps is a must!! Regarding transit navigation, i dont have a favorite, even though Google probably does a slightly better job there. It’s a bit annoying switching between the apps though 😃
I agree, Apple Maps when driving/navigation. Google maps when not
The UI for transit is pretty bad on Google though. The lines do not exactly follow the real life subway lines and their colors are not always correct
my tady máme v CZ Mapy.cz, které jsou nejvíce detailnější mapovou appkou. A co se týče Apple Maps na navigaci v autě, byla by užitečná kdyby měla databázi popisných čísel domů.
Lol. Apple maps doesn’t work in Middle East yet, it’s only a Satellite image, No Directions, Nothing at all!
Middle East is desert
Middle East poor
Great video, thanks!
I just had to point out, at “Voice Commands” you give a point to Apple Maps for context clues. For example in some countries (not giving names) there are people who steal signs for fun. At least in smaller areas. I know, its a silly example but I still think giving aproximate distance is way better (also on highways)
Edit: another example is city management change signs when there are major changes/repairs coming on some roads/areas
I've started using Apple Maps in Portugal when driving because it's surprisingly more accurate and safer. Google Maps has taken me on a number of routes in the past year that are actually dead ends. Switching to Apple Maps gave me a corrected and simplified route. But I use a mixture of the two, for all the reasons you cited.
Same here in The Netherlands, Google has sent me to some closed private roads and almost tried sending me on a bike lane with a car! For navigation, Apple Maps it is. but for finding my way around a city or finding a restaurant, Google it is.
The reason there were undue U-turns in the navigation was probably due to either lane change route safety (feeling you may get into an accident ) or the fuel efficiency setting... As in it probably felt you wasted more fuel idling at a light than just making a u-turn. That's how i interpreted it when it happened to me on occasion.
Fuel efficiency? You burn more fuel driving the car than staying still. Officers will keep their cars on while on parking because turning the car off and on will burn more fuel. So no, that’s not the reason.
The real reason is that it may “think” that there’s no way to turn, or that it’s under construction which usually will show but idk, who knows.
@@jaerg91usually there's several routes for these cases, idk why it didn't show here but I have this exact "issue" almost everytime for x or y reason, you just need to click on the other route
Yes, safety is most important. Apple has tried sending me down the wrong way in a one-way street. Apple has been dead to me ever since.
I love Apple for biking navigation in NYC and London -- the Siri alerts blend well with music/podcasts, & the pop-ups on Apple Watch are a nice touch
with the 14 pro, having the directions on the dynamic island is amazing
One of the big things that keeps me using Google Maps is the ability to choose routes that are optimized for non-gas-exclusive cars, such as hybrids and EVs. Since they optimize their mileage differently than gas cars do, Google Maps offers different routes depending on the car you drive. Really neat, and currently a dealbreaker.
Less people use electric cars so Apple Maps is better
And google map has trash route like the guy showed in thevid so it doesn’t matter
Fair enough
@@bloxblox51not in his specific use cases, plus neither are really better than the other, they have their own upsides and downsides, though I do prefer apple maps
One thing I think should be emphazised is just how much data google collects when you use their services..
Apple actually annonymizes location services information like routing, traffic or nearby points of interest. They also have something called fuzzing which I didn't look into very much tho it's supposed to hide where you want to go I think. Apple Maps also stores the information where you have been locally on your phone and any info that is going out to a server is disassociated from your appleID and annonymized.
It sure isn't the most private App out there but it beats google by miles! Just imagine all the data they collect from google maps users...
Excellent comparison of both the maps.
Great video! Only thing I'd say is that I'd have preferred a better weighted points system to show more the more important features. For instance, actual navigation instructions is not as important to a MAPS app as discovering new Chinese restaurants around me.
However, I understand that this would probably have added a bit too much complication to the video.
King posted
You forgot cycling. Google is great but Apple can't even do it (here in Copenhagen at least)
As someone who did delivery for about 4 years, I used both. Both had their pros and cons, both made mistakes. But as an iPhone user, I used Apple Maps more because I tell Siri to give me directions so wherever I needed to go without having to unlock my phone and physically typed in the address. I’m sure that if I had an android phone I’d do the same but with google maps. In conclusion, both are mostly good at what they do but depending on what phone I used determined which app I would use more
Very good video. I use Apple Maps for actual navigation in my car. The context you mentioned is really important to me that mentions stops signs and traffic lights etc
I use Google maps for everything else like discovery etc. timeline is really cool too
This was really interesting. And I can give a perspective on what it's like managing business profiles on both platforms. While apple was the easiest to deal with in proving ownership and being able to access the profile to keep the business location up to date. Apple has this invisible grid thay is hard to move a business. Especially when it comes to fixing seo of a business. Google had hands down been the best and most accurate and crucial for business hits. They still dominate with hit results. The reporting from google about customer feedback and features are way better. Apple may be simple here but they were the hardest to get this up and running. So far Google has this one in the bag as the clear winner in the business management space.
I think the instances where Google has you go further, you would probably get to your destination in the same time but you would be idle less. They seem to favor easy turnbacks so you have access to easy right turns. Just my guess
Time is more valuable than distance travelled.
I just last week had a nightmare Google Maps experience where they really did tell me to take UTurns and it dumped me off location-wise in a way I didn't understand. It is also why I missed the exit and had to turn around. Mostly, the exit number had changed recently and where Apple would have said this exit, Google just gave the number. It was horrible. Siri voice is much less confusing to me personally than any of the ones I have ever used. I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE the "not this light, take a right next light" concepts. So much less confusing.
-I have been using both recently and give the advantage to Google Maps from a accuracy standpoint. There have been many time where Apple Maps will take you to the wrong location and plain get lost. Im not positive if this could be caused by a network issue or Apple Maps issue but it is frequent around the Atlanta metro area especially anywhere near the airport. I have never noticed a issue like this on Google maps where it gets lost and isn’t sure how to route you.
Another great feature of Apple Maps is if you have an Apple Watch, the navigation will show up on your watch when you start the trip. Also, a bit before you have to turn, and when you have to turn, the watch will vibrate a few times letting you know about the turn, I love that feature.
I found that really annoying. It is constantly buzzing my wrist when I use Apple maps
@@mkevin88SAME HERE! If it’s a long drive, I want to throw it out of the window 🫤🫤🫤 But it was too expansive 🫠🫠
Same for Google maps and wearos watches axtually
Apple Maps has sucked for far too long, but last Fall I made the full switch because the experience was way better than Google Maps and Waze. Where Waze relies heavily on user reports to know that roads are closed, Apple pulls from sources to automatically know or detect that roads are closed. It got to the point that Apple Maps was getting me to my destination faster than Waze every single time.
When I went to Japan with my family we relied heavily on Google Maps for transit directions. It was fine but after 5 days we were tired of it underestimating transfer times and the alternate options weren’t great. The rest of the trip we used Apple Maps and we have no issues navigating Japan’s rail networks. We were even able to set preferences to use our Japan Rail Pass on the JR lines which saved us money over the metro lines often recommended by default on Google Maps. The Apple Maps experiences is also great here in NYC.
The addition perk of having my Apple Watch buzz me before turns when using Apple Maps on my iPhone is also nice.
Apple Maps has better driving directions in Japan. I can’t use google at all.
Dont forget about the far less bugs
Thank you for coming up with the topic of navigation apps, which we all use almost on a daily basis. Other TH-camrs are not giving enough attention to day to day essential apps which we all use. They are only showing products which their sponsors are paying them.
Thx Joshua! Is there any other map app that is superior to either of these two? That you could recommend?
I have an iPhone but I’m team Google Maps all the way. I could literally make this comment thousands of words long, just about Google Maps lol. I live in Scotland and a lot of the Apple Maps features you mentioned don’t exist here - I didn’t even know Apple Maps had street view until right now. I mostly use Maps for looking up places before going there so things like street view, reviews, and house/building numbers are really useful. I also use it on the satellite setting because I prefer how it looks over the default and Google Maps’ satellite images are really good and clear. Apple Maps’ satellite images of my city are blurry and you can’t make out many details, although, they do seem to be more recent than Google’s satellite images so a point to them there. I don’t think Apple Maps will be winning me over any time soon unless they get as much street view coverage as Google and integrate reviews and photos within the app. The latter might well happen soon but unfortunately I don’t think they’ll be catching up to Google street view any time soon hahah
For my use case, if Apple Maps did offline maps I’d be 100% sold. I’ve found them incredibly handy, but I’m regularly out of service, which offline maps helps with immensely
Well that’s great they just announced it yesterday with iOS 17 😂😄
@@4zv4l38 heheh yep. I immediately thought of my comment lol
It’s out now !
I saw the apple maps street view camera car in Scranton PA yesterday !!! Pretty neat !!
After Parking, you have to walk to your destination, how do you switch from driving to walking within the same route?
Great video! Personally I tend to use Apple Maps 100% in my day to day life but when ever I travel I will use some combination of the two apps.
Also as a few other people mentioned outside of the US things do change significantly. Some countries I’ve been to just are not well supported by either Apple or google. For example I was recently in Bali and I found google did a great job when searching for where to go and finding restaurants but when I would try to get walking directions it would just give me a straight line like across the city, however Apple was terrible for watching but gave great directions.
I think it's all about the area. The "level of detail" where Apple Maps tells you about all the crosswalks and lights signals to give you the context of where you have to turn. Or mapping out 3D models trees. Things like these are only available in like 40 - 50 cities, I imagine. Same goes to Google maps though like "immersive view" and all.
But in your case apple maps is better in UX and LoD because you live where they have taken time to individually analyse building and area and surroundings and reconstruct their models in the app, therefore; the handsfree voice commands and directions.
Otherwise where I live, I sometimes cannot even trust apple maps.
Google maps despite having less details, still is better in like 2-3 million cities. That's why it must be very reliable for many many users compared to 40 - 50 cities.
So Google Maps is better IMO if you're not in the big cities, navigating through them, or travelling across.
Thank you very much!
The features should be weighted. Accuracy in reaching at the right destination and avoiding unnecessary turns should be weighted much higher than finding friends nearby. So providing just 1 point in accuracy doesn’t give justice to the most important feature which is reaching to right destination using best possible route
I use Apple Maps in Pune, India and for the most part it is actually very good. It isn’t as detailed or functionality packed as Google in India but I love the UI and CarPlay. Apple partners with a different provider in India but it’s getting better every time I use it. We need competition as Googles monopoly will enslave us therefore, I use lesser of the two evils for the most part. I totally agree with the feature request you suggested from Apple.
Couple of things to note as well, with G. Maps, I love the satellite view. So much detail there. Also with voice commands, Google also gets pretty specific. (Eg. Turn right after the McDonald's and then turn left) But I turn off voice (except for alerts) so it doesn't interrupt my music.
What’s wrong with apple‘s satellite view?
I always use Google maps and I like using the satellite view. With it's state view, you can get an idea on how the place looks like before starting your journey. I also like it's street view. I went to Africa and traveled from Kenya to uganda on Google maps. It was very accurate, even the street view. During my visit, I TH-cam vlogger who told me that he used Google maps from South Africa to Uganda.
You can also change the map from default to satellite for a more detailed map
Google maps is useful
Apple maps is beautiful
I use Apple Maps for driving around town, google maps for 1hr+ trips, and Waze for long roadtrips
Its interesting to see how other people from another country use things. I use mine the other way around; Google maps for long trips and waze around the city. hahaha
Funny thing is that Google now owns Waze and integrates their data in Google Maps
My mom is terrible with directions and we used to use google maps for everything.
But since both Siri and Apple Maps have improved.
I told her Siri on her phone give us directions from home to a place in central California. Her phone is attached to her Bluetooth setup on her car. So she came back and said “that was the easiest way for her to get her directions and it took me to the exact location without having to ask Siri for any corrections.”
That’s 600 miles traveled and she didn’t need anyone or anything else to know where she was going.
This is someone that doesn’t have a clue what north to eastbound is.
So I was glad I helped her with that. I also told her that she needs to get the directions for her other destination. So just reset Siri and say “hey siri I need directions to address 123 abc from my current location.
Now the one issue I can see with this is if you get a throwaway phone. Usually they don’t have 100% accurate location data from the satellites depending on the carrier like tracphone for example.
But from the mouth of a senroy citizen to your own channel Apple was a smooth choice.
for me, living in europe, I frequently enjoy using the public transport feature of apple maps. it's helped me a lot to get around places I don't know by bus/train/tram. on the other hand car navigation with google maps is in europe a lot better. streetview quality on apple maps is insanely better and they even have this quite amazing 3d-like effect when you look around.
ah and they just added offline maps in the new update they announced yesterday.
Here in Canada, Apple Maps remains behind. Even after so many promised updates. While the aesthetics of Apple Maps are to my preference, Google Maps is more on the ball. Apple Maps also has a beautiful drop down when it's time to change lanes. But I find that Apple Maps tells me to take turns as I'm passing the exit, whereas Google Maps tells me a bit before the turn so I don't end up going through an intersection haha
I’ve had the exact opposite experience, Google Maps has brought be to the incorrect location several times. Perhaps in rural parts of Canada might be different I guess.
I live in Poland and Gmaps is better
I live in Germany, apple is better
@@bradIeyyy Wo wohnst du? Apple Maps ist scheisse in SH und Hamburg.
I wish either app would allow you to open another tap when navigating on a current one: I often use both at the same time to see a final destination then another to look at a detour without having to end my current navigation. This is handy on road trips.
mega video congrats
Tbh I always LOVE the style and presence of apple map, but google map has one feature that I can’t refuse: keep north up while routing. If Apple map can issue the new version with this feature, I will definitely use Apple map instead of google map. I think this feature helpful and reliable because keep north up is always the main character of map when map is initially invented. Keeping the north up makes me feel secured, since I’m aware of where I am (in terms of which part of city etc). I love this feature maybe because I’m learning geology in school and I always look the map that way, and once they turn to keep your direction up, I feel confused and uncomfortable.
Besides, for the saved places, I’d say google map is much better, not because of the view, but because that one is able to make comment to his/her saved places. For example, if you really like a restaurant, you can not only save the restaurant, but also make comment on what is the best food in the restaurant.
For the street view, I confirm that in major cities like LA New York or Chicago, it is much better. However I lived in Minneapolis but no street view is found in Apple map. I remembered that Apple map already took the pictures of these medium cities or small towns, but Idk why they still not public them.