Abu Bakr said if anyone who worship Muhammad let him know that Muhammed is dead, and those who worship Allah let him know Allaah is alive and can not Die.
Look how hurt people are when they’re precious sheikhs gets called out. That right there tells you everything. Whether bilal phillips and/or hamza yusuf dies today or tomorrow does not deprive the ummah of anything in anyway. The preservation of Islam lies solely in Allah’s power and authority.
They misunderstood him. He said making dua for the dead not to the dead. And when he said to ask someone for dua, he meant to ask righteous alive people to make dua for you. I'd suggest taking knowledge from reliable sources and the classical sources rather than taking it from a follower of the salaf movement.
@@fattestmanintheworld5081 sufi doesn't mean dancing and worshiping graves. Sufism is very vast. Just because one sect of Sufis are like that doesn't make every Sufis like that. For example, how would you feel of someone came and said all followers of the salaf movement are extremists? Yes, we have extremism in every sect but does it make everyone in that sect extremists?
@@MonicaSĪGÑofJõñãhYUNIS Beware he is Sufi. He was shanting with others a song calling deceased for help, may Allah protect us from shirk. "By Him in Whose Hand is my soul, my Ummah will split into 73 sects: one will enter Paradise and 72 will enter Hell' (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi)"
@Yahiya Kareem i did watch it. Followed by truly thinking about it. And my comment is the result of the process. I could be technically ignorant, but willful ignorance is an accusation I strongly deny.
Sending praise and and blessing upon the pious is practiced by the sahbah they used sing poetry and make also make praises. Praising Muhammad SAW you’ll receive 10 blessings and 10 sins will be removed
Provide a Sahih Hadith - We worhsip and call upon Allah only, it's Shirk, you've made a Claim provide a Sahih hadith - Dead people can't help. Even prophets.@@i-gotskillz-i8051
The title is instigating and divisive! Prophet Muhammad Peace be upon him never did this, instead he tried to unify his ummah and, what are we here for, for doing actions that hurt him? No right, then why so much of arrogance and hatred in the comments , dear brothers and sisters it's a humble request to get ourselves united we are not here to fight and quarrel amongst ourselves we are here for a greater purpose or if I can say greatest to spread peace and love,the Sunnah of our Beloved Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him.
Unite upon what??? Like when the Jews of Medina united against the Muslims. But their hearts were all disunited?? It is like you are asking the wolf to unite with the sheep. It cannot happen, We have to unite upon the truth. I will never unite with a Shia who believes that Aisha R.A was a fornicatress, Authubillahi Al-Adeem and people who curse the beloved companions of the prophet. Never!!! How can you expect me to unite with such people. We will be united if we come together but our hearts will be disunited and there will be many disagreement and fighting. So stop just saying "lets unite" like there is no problems. Rather say, *let us unite upon the Qur'an, the Sunnah, and the understanding of the companions and their students (Salaf-us-Saliheen).*
@@MrGW2fanboy Well Because it's a buzzword in your head and you are conditioned to put your guard up to what you hear about it because you have been listening to people who misunderstand it. Because you agreed with me up until that part. Salafiyyah is everything I wrote: To understand the Qur'an and the sunnah the way the prophet pbuh taught and with his companions understanding and the rightly guided generations that came after them. The salaf are the students and the students of the students of the sahabah. Salafiyyah it to go back to their understanding of the religion not to "modernise" Islam to suit us. Because Islam was made for all people for ALL TIMES and does not change with time. The people who say it is extreme are saying the sahabah and their students are extreme. The prophet made dua for them to have understanding of the religion so we must obey. Study more about Islam and the methodology of understanding it (salafiyyah). There was a need to specify our manhaj because there are so many sects claiming to be on the sunnah yet are far from it. In shaa Allah I am upon what the prophet and his companions were upon over 1440 years ago. May Allah guide us All.
This was the aqeedah of sahaba ... the belief system taught in Qur'an and Sunnah !!! woe to the worshipers of the dead and bid'ah lovers who ignorantly think that this was propagated by Shaikh Muhammad ibn Abdul wahhab.
kek, before him there is no..none of his believe system ever occurred..even ibn taymia will not gone far than what he has done. :D even his brother syaikh sulaiman write a letter on syaikh Muhammad wrong path..
Ibn e Taimyyah circumstances were different than those were in the time of Ibn Abdul Wahhab..!! Otherwise the former would have gone for the same...!! The later's manhaj was exactly that of the Prophet and his companions..!! 'Grave/pious-dead worship' has been pushed into islam by shitti first and then by sufis. Shaikh Sulaiman opinion's of zero value!
@@pariah2749 Shaykh Sulayman later retracted his statement. Also, Around 400 years before Muhammad Ibn Abd al Wahhab, Al-Maqrizi Al-Shafi’i (d. 845H) says Istighatha is Shirk and makes a distinction between shirk in Uluhiyyah and shirk Rububiyyah He says: “And people in this matter - I mean: visiting graves - are of three groups: A group that visits the dead and supplicates for them. And this is the legitimate visitation. And a group that visits them and supplicates through them, so these are the polytheists in Uluhiyyah and love. And a group that visits them and supplicates to them directly, and the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: "O Allah, do not let my grave become an idol that is worshipped," and these are the polytheists in Rububiyyah.” تجريد التوحيد المفيد i.imgur.com/QqqgSMy.png
People in the comments are ridiculous. This man is stating facts. Hamza Yusuf said he calls for Prophet Muhammad (SAW), and he also believes we shouldn't have a Kalifah. Those are Bidah. Sufi Bidah. What happened to Fearing Allah. The Prophet (SAW) always said to worship, and call to only Allah. What happened to the aquidah of the Muslims? These are signs of the end.
Xassan Daxir He said Islam doesnt need a khalifah, not we shouldn't have one. And don't forget he isnt some salafi Bedouin living in medina on his camel. He is restricted on what he can say.
Uneducated/Students who doesn’t know about Fiqh and neither know the names of books talking about Scholars is the sign of an Illiteracy and Qiyamah has many signs. Using (SAW) instead of SALALLAHU ALAYHI WASALLAM is the sign of uneducated person. Grow up and learn Islam first. Just listening and obeying Blindly is not a sign of a Muslim.
@@syedosman5848 really? Bizarre... I haven't come across that one... cause who among the companions ever wrote in English? Never mind abbreviate... could you please inform me ?
I really believe what Hamza Yusuf said about following a madhab is taken completely out of context by Bilal Philips. As a public figure, he should be more responsible of what he says. Generally speaking, it is beneficial to have a teacher when learning something new, including islam, thus following a madhab.
@@adamyoutube281 Imam Shafi learned arabic for 17 years! know your place . The prophet said that the generations closer to him will have truth and then lies will start spreading. All the great scholars and Salafs followed madhabs. and now you are watching new preachers and jumping here and there saying that follow quran and sunnah. do you really think our great scholars didn't think what you thought?
if you feel others are midguided, ask Allah Azzawajal to guide them on the straight path. If you feel you are misguided or guided, ask Allah Azzawajal to guide yourself on the same path. if you do not do that, then you are plain arrogant. but on this point, i have a lot to say, but no point :) السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
If you care about the Muslims you will warn them against deviants, just like you would warn them against listening to, hanging around with druggies, alcoholics etc Of course, if you don't care about the Ummah, you won't speak against deviants misleading the Ummah, you will just tell us... Make dua for them and not to speak against the evil.
Prophet s.a.w and the sahabaas used to address the deviants so are we better than him and his sahabaas naoodhubillah...no... so prophet s.a.w said if u see something wrong happening in ur sight u should proceed to stop it physically..if u can't..then verbally..if u can't...then atleast consider it(evil act)to be bad ...and if u can't even do that then ur imaan is in danger...
5 years ago, SubhanAllah. I did say there is a lot one can say on this point, however the key is firstly to understand that words can be interpreted in many different ways, especially text format, so I do apologise if my words were misunderstood. Secondly, the point I am making is the last point to the above hadith, also the above blessed hadith of our prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon Him) has a verh lengthy explanation as to what it actually means. However, since we are speaking about our Master, the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon Him), they naturally did everything with immense wisdom, we do should try to adopt this, and the Quran explains how to attain wisdom in many many different places 'the prophet of Allah (peace and blessings be upon Him) has been sent to teach religion, help purify (body mind heart and desires) and teach them wisdom and the book of Allah, the Exalted.' (62.2) also said in many many different places also. So when somebody is doing wrong. Then yes, we should stand up and speak, but wrong is that person who goes out of his way to just criticise others. We should know, we as muslims have been facibg criticism our whole lives for no aparent reason. Islam is supposed to be opposite to this.. and that is the beginning of wisdom. Give.. forgive.. and love. May Allah, the Exalted bless you all, and Allah, the Exalted knows best.
As for the point 'to stay away from sufis' That is simply because you have heard a complete one sided story and do not even know what a so called 'sufi' is. The funny thing is, a 'sufi' probably would not even use that term. So may Allah subhannahu wa ta'Alaa bless you all immensely and allow all to pass with the light of tawbah and imaan Insha'Allah عزوجل.
This is so oversimplified and generalised. Zaytuna is so big now and growing all the time. So many professors of islamic sciences part of that organisation. I feel more safe with all of their understanding than a lonely jelous wolf.
I 110+ agree. I believe shykh humza is gift to educated youth. I live in Pakistan, yet I can’t listen any scholar from Pakistan because they don’t make sense in their talks. But Every time I listen shykh humza, I can’t just move away from screen. Dude, I really love him. I appreciate what he is doing and May Allah give me taufeeq, I will support him in his cause. May Allah help him and bless him more.
calling dead is the same as calling to a statue. They both cannot hear you or see you or respond to you. So what makes calling to a statue shirk and makes you a non-Muslim but to a dead person not. I'm not saying he is a Kafir either, but calling to graves/ dead people is an act of Kufr.
Billal phillips is a true islamic scholar some grave worshipers may not like his speech because the bidat people don't like right path may Allah guide them
@@iimiboy your OPINION in singing about Muhammad is shirk - tawassul itself is actually not SHIRK - I personally disagree with it myself - but THERE ARE SAHIH HADITHS of things like this happening among the companions after he died - its not like their calling out to their grandpa, its strictly Muhammad (saw) ….based on INTERPRETATIONS of Hadith - AND I DISAGREE WITH THEIR INTERPRETATIONS TOO but im not a takfirist khwarjite like yourself - I think its haram yes, but thats it - they are not elevating Muhammad to the LEVEL OF ALLAH , like the Christians do with Jesus is just intellectually fallacious
@@TheGEOPOLITICIANGUY yea show us your evidence please. Why didn't the sahaba make dua to rasoolullah sallalahu alaihisalaam for rain but they instead went to the uncle of the prophet for him to make dua for rain.
Differences among Scholars are normal since the beginning (after the death of our beloved prophet) of Islam But it is Wahhabism to deal with opponents with a destructive attitude. So beware them.
I've never in my life met a person who worships graves. Nor have I met anyone who worships the person buried there. And I swear by Allah, you won't be able to find someone who does
Shame on you for accusing Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, this is the work of masih al dajjal and Shia to destroy muslim ummah. show me the proof that he asked to call Muhammad SAW, or any Shaykh for help beside Allah??? If you can't provide the proof delete the title and seek Allah forgiveness for spreading fitna. Otherwise you are no different than Shia kufr who worship Ali R.A and spread lies and allegation toward Sahaba,you'll answer to Allah in the hereafter.
How unfortunate to give circular arguments to discredit a scholar. How unfortunate that our enemies see us as one ummah. They kill us indiscriminately; while we are busy discrediting each other. Signs of end of times إنا لله وإنا إليه راجعون
Jazakallahu Khaira ya Sheikh! MashaAllah! Great lecture. May Allah protect us from these false aqeedah's and may He rid the sub continent and the rest of the world of all bid'ah and shirk! And may He guide us all to the right path!! Ameen!!!
Jazaka Allah khairan Ustad Bilal Phillips ... Sufism is a new thing that was not in the time of prophet Mohammed (salla Allahu alaihi wa sallam), or his Sahaba, or the Taabeen, our the Tabi Taabeen. if anyone can connect to Allah (subhanahu wataala) as Sufi claim, then shouldn't the Sahaba have had that? wake up guys and repent to Allah (subhanahu wataala) before you meet him in the day of judgment and he asks you why you changed the deen. May Allah (subhanahu wataala) guide us all, Ameen.
@Yasin Abdul Ameen, back to you brother. I am actually a hanafi with recent interest in tassawwuf, but that doesn't change much at all. I haven't received any requests, can you try again?
You are so wrong. You are saying what i use to say 20 years ago. That is such a short cited argument. May Allah show you the truth and not let shaitaan use one of his million tricks to keep you away from something that is good.
Thank you for posting this and thanks for the CLEAR TITLE. I would like to point out that whenever I am searching for Islamic lectures on line, the algorithm always suggests Hamza Yusuf videos, even if the video they're promoting does not match with what I typed in the search. Also, TH-cam & Google seem to be making it difficult to find the Islamic topics that one searches for. Be ware that they may eventually purposely misguide people to the wrong path...
Dr Bilal must practice surah Hujurat on the following ayat(verses) and repent to Allah and apologize for his erring. Allah loves good conduct in relations and speech: “Oh you who have believed let not a people ridicule another people; perhaps they may be better than them, Nor let women ridicule other women, perhaps they may be better than them. And do not insult one another, and do not call each other by offensive nick names. Wretched is the name of disobedience after ones faith, and whoever does not repent then it is those who are the wrong doers. Oh you who have believed avoid negative assumption. Indeed some assumption is sin, And do not spy or back bite each other. Would one of you would like to eat the flesh of his brother when dead. You would detest it. And fear Allah for Allah is accepting of repentance and merciful”.
Perhaps are you misusing the Quran ?...🤔 He is only making an argument that you could try to reject with knowledge. I think what he said is clear and simple.
Non has the right to be worshipped but Allah,bilal Phillips is right.The prophet (pbuh) is dead ,he can't hear nothing of this world and doesn't know what's going on in this world .He was a human being just like everyone else but a messenger and a slave of Allah just like the rest of the previous prophets.
Allahu Akbar non has the right to be worshipped but Allah (do not exaggerate in worshiping me like the Christians worshipped Isa son of Maryam).That is what the prophet Mohammed said (pbuh).So we shouldn't worship him ,he's not Allah or the creator but a messenger and slave of Allah .
“The Messenger of Allah spoke to the People (buried) in the Well saying: “Have you found out that what your Lord had promised you is true?” then someone exclaimed: “Are you calling out to the dead!” The Prophet replied: “You do not hear better than they do, except they do not respond.” Sahih Bukhari, Volume 2, Book 23, Number 452 Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) let the dead bodies of the unbelievers who fought in Badr (lie unburied) for three days. He then came to them and sat by their side and called them and said: O Abu Jahl b. Hisham, O Umayya b. Khalaf, O Utba b. Rab’ila, O Shaiba b. Rabi’a, have you not found what your Lord had promised with you to be correct? As for me, I have found the promises of my Lord to be (perfectly) correct. Umar listened to the words of Allah’s Apostle (may peace be upon him) and said: Allah’s Messenger, how do they listen and respond to you? They are dead and their bodies have decayed. Thereupon he (the Holy Prophet) said: By Him in Whose Hand is my life, what I am saying to them, even you cannot hear more distinctly than they, but they lack the power to reply. Then’he commanded that they should be buried in the well of Badr. Sahih Muslim, Book 040, Number 6869 and a lot more even in qur'an. even ordinary death people can hear, how come prophet, the most beloved and revered by Allah, can't? you believe there is afterlife and everything unseen but easily dismissed and judge..
SubhanaLlah, this is what you believe?. What abut this hadith? "My life is a great good for you, you will relate about me and it will be related to you, and my death is a great good for you, your actions will be exhibited to me, and if I see goodness I will praise Allah, and if I see evil I will ask forgiveness of Him for you." Nabi Muhammad Am not gonna post the source. Help yourself, unless you want to daef the hadith
Really?? So, you know more??? Are you a scholar? Which institute did you get your islamic knowledge? Yea, that's what I thought. You're just a mindless blabber.
Sending salawat is ok asking allah to bless muhammed , but praying to muhammed for help is obviously shirk. Only allah hears and answers calls, this is in the quran and sunnah clearly
This man is certainly trying to misguide people. As a Muslim I don't like the way he is addressing our beloved Prophet Muhammad (SA), his attempt is to divide the Muslim Ummah rather than uniting them. I have always heard Shaykh Hamza Yusuf praising our Peophet Muhammad (SA) wholeheartedly, he have immense love in his heart for our Prophet Muhammad (SA) and this man Bilal Philips haven't understood the status of the greatest Nabi e Kareem (SA) otherwise he wouldn't have uttered such words. I love and respect Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, he is dear to me, he is showing the right way, teaching the right Islam. Mashallah, may Allah (SWT) give him long and healthy life and elevate his status. Aameen!
+Faiz Sheikh He didn't criticize Hamza Yusif, he merely pointed an aspect of his faith out, i.e. his belief in isnad and you're here crying. So is Hamza Yusif now for you a perfect human being? if you're so heartbroken about this I suggest you verify this with the sheik H.
+Faiz Sheikh " he is dear to me, he is showing the right way, teaching the right Islam" that is what I am careful not to say in regards to people. Are you a scholar to know which Islam is right or wrong?
+nazirdjon I don't have to be a scholar to judge a scholar, no one needs to. You should know that during the reign of Amir ul Momineen Hazrat Umar Farooque (RA) common people were free to intervene in political & religious matters, except that they weren't allowed any abuse. There are several other evidence I can give. So don't tell me that Islam doesn't give me right to judge a scholar. Bilal Philips is uttering the words that I haven't heard before. I am not here to debate, I just watched this video and thought of expressing myself.
+YmnTree Sheikh Hamza Yusuf is not the only scholar I admire. I listen to many scholars and I am free to express my view about each of them. Brother, you should not get so much offended by my comment. I listen to Sheikh Hamza and he never ever care to criticize or blame any other scholar for anything (their Aquidah their Madhab etc.). There is no need AT ALL to add another scholar into any speech which is meant to educate about Islam, Quran & Sunnah.
@@abdulhamidmohammed6738 No Tasawwuf is a science of Islam. The science of ihsan. People that are known to be people who heavily focused on purification of the heart and ihsan are called sufis. It is not a sect. There is a lot of bid'ah that some sufis have injected into the science, but you don't reject the entirety of the science. You can be a Maliki and be a Sufi. You can be a Hanbali and a Sufi. You can be a simple Muslim and not know all that much about fiqh and be a Sufi. But Sufism by itself is not a jurisprudence, it's not a sect, and it's not bid'ah. It's a technical term like fiqh, aqeedah, etc. Without Tasawwuf I'd argue everything else becomes pointless. Your iman becomes pointless, your worship etc becomes pointless without purification of the heart.
Alhamdulilah for sheikh bilal phillips people of ahlul bidah should not be followed it leads to shirk ul akbar. 100% in agreement with his stance on his issue.
Subhanallah alhamdelliah allah answered my dua about this, i met a woman who follows hamza yusuf and she was forcing on me having to follow madhab, or else i will be misguided, like following the quran and authentic sunnah is not enough subhanallah she was the one misguided , and she was insuliting me even though i said nothing mean or act badly with her
YOU FEAR SHIRK? "there is no god but allahand muhammad pbuh is his messenger" ...its simple its in the title..how can you do shirk after saying that? islam is easy but people make it ugly
The problem with our Ummah is we don't read nowhere nearly as much as we used to. For example it's basic understanding that in the physical world, Sayidna Muhammad (saw) was a descendant of Sayidna Ishmael (pbuh), and that righteous bloodline continued without blemish all the way to his tribe, the Bani Hashim, who were the best of people within the Quraish . That's Sayidna Muhammad's proof of lineage and existence in the physical world, but what about Prophet Muhammad's timeline in the spiritual world? ARE WE NOT AWARE OF A STRONG HADITH, NARRATED BY UMAR BIN AL KHATTAB: Allah's Messenger (Peace Be Upon Him) said: When Adam committed the error, he submitted (to Allah): O Lord, I beg You to forgive me through the mediation of Muhammad. Then Allah said: O Adam! How did you recognize Muhammad as I have not created him yet? He replied: O Lord, when You created me with Your divine hand and breathed Your soul into me, I raised my head and saw 'la ilaha illallahu Muhammad-ur-rasulullah ("There is no god but Allah, Muhammad is Allah's Messenger")' inscribed on each pillar of the Throne. I discovered that with Your name, the name of only such a person can be associated who is Your most beloved of all the creatures. At this Allah said: O Adam, you have said it correctly. Of all the creatures I love him the most. Now when you offered your prayer through his mediation, I forgave you. And if Muhammad were not there, I would not have created even you. SOURCES: Al-Hakim narrated it in al-Mustadrak al Sahihayn (Volume No. 2, Page No. 651, Hadith No. 4228) Tabarani Mu'jam Al-Ausat Volume 006, Page No. 313-314, Hadith Number 6502 This was the first instance of a human being (Adam, pbuh) using the name of someone else; Muhammad pbuh, who was not even created yet, as a means of mediation, to secure for himself the mercy of Allah. Chew on that...
Hamza Yussuf is not a sufi, he's a suni that follows the fiqh of Imam Malik. Also we all have teachers that lead us to the prophet may peace be upon him, Dr Bilal studied at Medina, his teacher learnt Islam from his teacher , who learnt it from his/her teacher , who learnt it from his/her teacher until the generations of the tabi, sahaba then prophet himself saw
Scholars should not criticise other scholars. It is not a muslim's place to judge another muslim. As Muslims we are a brotherhood, one Ummah. Let us not be split apart.
So if the scholars don't refute the people and the "scholars" of misguidance, how can we know which path is the true path to follow? Refutation is a part of the deen.
Hamza Yusuf is totally devoted ehli sunne sunni Muslim , he can't go out from that circle . There is great tradition of İslam . Once you read , you will see what is allowed and what is not.
Hamza Yusuf is a pious person of high stature. Whatever you call him a sufi or non sufi, he talks about unity, he attends all the big events with every scholars and tries to bridge the coflicts. If you try to unite Muslims on the basis of Allah, Prophet Mohammad s.a.w an Quran then forget about everything else. Every scholar says there should be unity but only at his terms. Why?
not true. Yusuf is not a pious person of high stature. He's a confused person sometimes mixing in the Jews or other beliefs with Muslim beliefs. Listen to some of his audio tapes. he's hilarious at best. The problem is that he is misguiding people knowingly.
@@user-vp6bf1nm5u th-cam.com/video/7YCl1S-DfiQ/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=IslamRewards he is not. he talks about Muslim and sectarianism,, that is why they hate him. culture and tradition is not islam
@@brasstow3209 oh, you haven’t heard him long enough nor listened to all his audio tapes. People don’t hate him or dislike him just because. He’s not intellectually consistent. Listen to all his talks long enough with an open mind and you’ll see.
Its astounded me of how many people here discredited Dr. Philips. What he say is make sense. Don't go the path of the christian my brothers and sisters.
This guy called Imam Husayn a “rebel”. Astaghfurillah...What a bad statement. Husayn is is sayyid ahl Shabbab aj jannah.....Master of the youth of paradise is Hassan and Husayn.
@@zahinelahi2655 inshallah they are exposed. And he said the prophet is dead in a very dreary voice, indicating that he isn’t even alive in the next world. He’s foolish
Qur'an teaches that those who die in the path of Allah aren't dead but alive in His Divine presence and taken care of, also our Noble Rasul Swallalah Aleyhih wa Salam interceded on behalf of his Ummah, and his presence ministry is Rahma , and he also taught whoever see's him in a dream is real, he'll intercede for his Ummah on the day of judgement. He further taught us that Ulamahs are vicagrant to the prophets.
But not alive on earth right? Not intervening in our affairs nor able to do so, right ? If the Messenger of Allah sallallaahu aleyhi wa sallama was alive do you think he'd let all those scholars be humiliated, incarcerated, threatened by the guy in charge today ? That Jewish and American acolyte in the neom plan for greater Israel and the building of the third temple for the coming of the dajjaal ? Hum? Anyway calling on anyone but Allah is plain shirk... even if it is the Messenger of Allah sallallaahu aleyhi wa sallama. Agree?
Put your emotions to a side. Some people love isis and Al qaeda and they won’t look at things with an open mind. Shaykh hamza Yusuf says seeking help from the prophet peace be upon him is allowed. He allows such evil. It’s there on the internet so do your research brother and look at things with an open mind. May Allah guide us all
@@sovu9399 you are doing wrong by saying this. Talk in a decent and polite manner. Refuting and exposing people of misguidance should be done without swearing or cussing.
@@weshouldsaveourselves6780 Sure brother! The thing is, he turned away after hearing the truth by brother Bilal. these sufi/shia are the enemies of Islam, damn corrupters. Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala CURCED those who bring something new to Islam.
I agree with Billal but I must admit that I never heard Hamza Yusuf encouraging grave worshipping. He grow up 70/70s California , Catholic convert, one of our best scholar of our time. And Rational . Allah give us knowledge so we listen both and take only good deed from their teaching Amen.
Did our Rasool not spend time alone in the cave meditating or contemplating in the praises of Allah (internalizing it with his very essence of being) freeing himself from any external disturbance? It was a time early in Islam. He may have been disturbed by those around him, or from the cacophony that emanates within a city. Do the rest only utter Allah's praises and do actions with lips saying praises. And that is good. Or do some go to the extent of saying Allah's name with the same breath as they are taking deeply into their bodies, and also whilst exhaling and concentrating in desiring a connection with the creator and immersing only in the thought of the creator? Oh if any regards this as a bad act act, then surely you must be deranged. The Quran as even declared by Ali (RA), is for all time, so not all of the understanding could have been derived at the time of our Rasool. So when anyone speak of an "innovation" (and surely Bilal Philips uses a cell-phone and travels by plane) he needs to ponder on the essence of the "innovation" of whether it is suggestive of positive or of negative effect. Once again our Rasool immersed himself in a private affair contemplating Allah subhanahu wata ala in that cave. An "innovation"? I think not.
Dear brother, calm down and humbly seek knowledge. Put your emotions aside. The definition of bid'ah is exclusively pertaining to acts of 'ibaada. Not dunya issues. Otherwise we'd still be going around in camel caravans and getting light from camp fires and candles.
Philip sir is lack of knowledge ....No Sunni worship other than Allha ...He have to learn more about thawassul and isthigasa .... Don't follow this talk ...he is lack of knowledge...May Allha guide him in right ...Hamza Yusuf is best Sunni scholor no one can overtake him
It is the way of RasoolUllah (S.A.W) to enjoin in the good and *forbid the evil* whether it is a person or an act or belief. So to inform the people of a bid'ah belief or ideology is not only allowed but it is wajib (mandatory).
@@seekerofknowledge6595 please don't attribute qualities to Rasoolullah (SAW) of which you have no knowledge. The fact is he did not name and shame anyone, not even the Munaafiqeen. The funny thing is that the sufis have much more dirt on these so called scholars but they don't bring it out in the open
You are dividing people in the name of different sufis and scholars ..As a Muslim you should unite people not divide....And how can u say about sheikh Hamza yusuf who is a role model for youth today....U are a Saudi paid salafi scholar who can only divide people that is what the enemies of Islam want and u are doing it for them
The real Bid'ah is the Wahhabi movement. Bilal Philips studied in Madinah so it explains his extreme views that are alien to true Islam. How dare he discredit Shaykh Nuh Ha Mim Keller like that. "The Blessed Prophet [Peace and Blessings be Upon him] said, "Whoever bears malice towards Allah’s Walī, Allah will declare war upon him" (Sahih Bukhari). And it is without a doubt that Shaykh Nuh is of the true Awliya' of Allah. Anyone can realize this even as soon as they lay eyes on him.
8:20 If this was true, that abu bakr only gave a secret knowledge to someone, everyone who hides this knowledge is sinful, Allah says in the Qur'an: Surah Al-Baqarah 2:42 وَلَا تَلْبِسُوا۟ ٱلْحَقَّ بِٱلْبَـٰطِلِ وَتَكْتُمُوا۟ ٱلْحَقَّ وَأَنتُمْ تَعْلَمُونَ ٤٢ Do not mix truth with falsehood or hide the truth knowingly. - Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran and again in Surah Al-Baqarah: 2:76 وَإِذَا لَقُوا۟ ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ قَالُوٓا۟ ءَامَنَّا وَإِذَا خَلَا بَعْضُهُمْ إِلَىٰ بَعْضٍۢ قَالُوٓا۟ أَتُحَدِّثُونَهُم بِمَا فَتَحَ ٱللَّهُ عَلَيْكُمْ لِيُحَآجُّوكُم بِهِۦ عِندَ رَبِّكُمْ ۚ أَفَلَا تَعْقِلُونَ ٧٦ When they meet the believers they say, “We believe.” But in private they say ˹to each other˺, “Will you disclose to the believers the knowledge Allah has revealed to you, so that they may use it against you before your Lord? Do you not understand?” - Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran 2:77 أَوَلَا يَعْلَمُونَ أَنَّ ٱللَّهَ يَعْلَمُ مَا يُسِرُّونَ وَمَا يُعْلِنُونَ ٧٧ Do they not know that Allah is aware of what they conceal and what they reveal? - Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran Of course, abu bakr (ra) did not do this sin and what they say is lies.
He's not tearing the community apart.He is trying to show people the truth and part of that is rejecting the falsehood and misguidance others are spreading those who claim to be following the prophet(pbuh) but are doing the opposite!
He is taking to us from the path of salaf indeed we can directly call to Allah swt no need for anyone between even in some cases Allah says it's about me and my servant servant doesn't need any intermediary in this dunia after life indeed we some of us need the intermediary of prophet Muhammad pbuh
Ahmed Ali 0 seconds ago 6:24 Allah states in the Quran the martyrs are alive and people bury them? Hamza Radiyallahu anhu and many more shuhada were buried by Nabi Sallallhu alayhi wasallam was he committing sin by burying the dead? Tahir Al Qadri was not putting Nabi Sallallhu alayhi wasallam’s in the rank of Isa alayhissalaam he’s clearly talking about istighatha This man is mixing chain of Hadith knowledge to something else so the average Muslim thinks he can have knowledge without chain. So why do the Muhaddithun have a chain? He’s giving green light to those who self study this is their methodology then they say they’re upon the methodology of the Sahabah Radiyallahu anhum. I went into to so called salafiyyah circles in my early days and all I saw was miniature abu jahls and firouans waiting to question, anttack, and reticule everyone and everything. All I heard in them circles was Ahlul id’ah, shirk billah, istiwa, daleel, sahih and minhaj lol. Not one could pronounce a single word from above list in actual Arabic and they’re asking for daleel. The salafiyyah of Indian sub continent study hanafi fiqh books because they don’t have any nor are their self studied so called ulama are able to formulate any. Some UK Salafi study in Morocco and Muritania the fiqh of Imam of Darul Hijra Imam Malik rahmatullah alayhi then attack the madhahib. Bunch of clowns. Little knowledge is dangerous. Your character shows you up even before your ignorant knowledge. Ask the so called Salafiyyah wives about their husbands characters at home and you’ll see the real minhaj in their behaviour. No name calling then comes up the name of Shaykh Hamzah Yusuf lol The speakers brushes all Sufies with one brush lol
Wow. This man is extremely misguided regarding this. While certain things he said seem correct at face value, they are utterly incorrect. For example, the Prophet (SAW) is not dead. Allah says that about the martyrs, so what is the status of Rasoolullah (SAW). "And do not say ofthose who are killed in the way of Allah "they are dead". Nay, they are living but you perceive it not". We are ordered not to say that the martyrs are dead and this man is saying Rasoolullah (SAW) is dead. A'udhubillah. Secondly, he says we are allowed to ask people for help, but are not allowed to ask Allah through the waseela of Rasoolullah (SAW). Something doesn't make sense here. Also in an authentic Hadith Rasoolullah (SAW) told a sahabi to say Ya Allah, ya Rasoolullah to cure his illness even though Rasoolullah (SAW) was not there
@@PlayazXI According to the Quran yes. 2:154 "And do not say about those who are killed in the way of Allah, "They are dead." Rather, they are alive, but you perceive [it] not." The word yuqatalu is used, ie slain. The Muhammad peace be upon him did not die in battle but on his bed. Therefore that ayah cannot be applied to the rasool.
@@SonoftheFortunate in Islam rulings are made wholistically, and not based on the fact that Rasoolullah (SAW) was omitted from the verse. There are many many proofs of the Prophet (SAW) being alive. Many have seen him in dreams, some have seen him in an awakened state and Imam Busiri (RA) was even visited by him (SAW). Aside from this there are many other proofs that he (SAW) is alive
@@PlayazXI What? Did you just claim the Prophet peace be upon him is alive?? By what evidence? Dreams?! Dreams are not evidence of life. He is clearly not on earth, his soul is not in his body. He will be resurrected just like us. Isa peace be upon him on the other hand is alive because Allah tells us that he himself raised him to the heavens and he is alive. So claiming that Prophet is alive in a physical form requires great evidence. I have an open mind, but a dream is not evidence. And Al Busiri was A SUFI!
yeah ,because your interpretation is the right one every one else is misguided?Specially those who u dont like! U should say this too. Let Allah be the judge my friend.
@@ishmaelm1932 If he disagrees with Shaykh Hamza, he should debate with him face-to-face. I have never heard Shaykh Hamza criticize anyone by name in his lectures.
@@raheelshafi882 he criticizes the Muslims and praises those who war with Muslims. Listen to all of his lectures. Then decide. Please don’t follow blindly. Don’t let his charm misguide you. This speaker (Dr.Bilaal) is a well known educator. It is his job to point out falsehood or the misguided ones.
May Allah destroy the Saudis and Najdis who want to dig out the blessed grave, destroy the green dome and disrespect muslim heritage! Wake up brothers!!
actually a muslim should beware of wahhabism/salafism at all. because your ideology is not what islam was or will be. all of you have no respect for the ulama except of your ulama. all of you have the arrogance to tell people that all of them are wrong except of you and everything which has been taught over the last 1300 years would be wrong and all of them would practise shirk and bida'a. but look, there was no one who ever called himself a salafi except of you. but even you are taking from our scholars which where all sufis even ibn taymiyyah who was in the qadiri tareeqah. imam ashari or imam maturidi teachings have also sufi aqeeda and still you are all taking their teachings. your silsila is broken no proofs no scholars after the salaf. you should be the one who should be bewared of. the methods of muhammad ibn adbul wahhab are the same as they are practicing now in Iraq or Syria by ISIS. May Allah bless you with Hidayah. At the moment all of you are on the wrong path. You are NOT uniting, you are DESPARATING the Ummah of Rassulullah (Alaihi Salatu wa Salam)
you are doing the same: disparting. there is difference between salafi and teachings of muhammad ibn abdul wahab. Allah forbids to talk about things you don't have knowledge about. think about it and recognize, that there is no need for response or keep going. and before you start judging me, without knowing me, i respect all madhab and also sufi that don't fall into shirk. as salamu aleykum.
Sometimes here (@Muslim platforms ) you will see a muslim name or some usernames imitating or labeling themselves being "Muslim" And some of you who heartily committed their Islamic faith will fall on that schemes, and what is that scheme? To misguide you, misinform you, avert you from your creed and not least but last " To divide you in order & then to exploit your weakness. "Watch out" your enemies are licensed for your disperity and your destruction. Leave all accounts to the lord, Guard yourself -----something you disagree leave it--don't quarrel to another human being. Finally, anybody who says *there is no God But Allah" is your brother or sister. Guard your tongue, please
السلام عليكم Thats definitely not right. With respect i tell you, that you dont even know what sufi is. Sufi is a other Word for Tasawwuf or tazzkiyah and is the science how to cleanse your heart. The Word comes from the name of a group of People living to the time of our beloved Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) They were poor people fed by our Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) every day and they were known as people who were really strong in their Prayers. Was Imam Shafi (رحمه الله) on a road to Hell too? (Aoouthu Billah) He said: “Be a Faqih and a Sufi” You can look this statement up. There are similar from other Big Schoolars and Salafs. You cant Judge a term you dont know, only because today a few crazy people miss use it... You know who was the Teacher of Sheikh Hamza yusuf (صاحب دامت بركاته)? It was one of the Big Schoolars of our time. Especially in the Usool (princibles) of Fiqh, Aqidah and Kalam. You simply complete miss interprete his statements. May Allah guide you all السلام عليكم
كان ابن المنكدر (التابعي) يجلس مع اصحابه فكان يصيبه صمات فكان يقوم كماهو حتى يضع خده على قبر النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم ثم يرجع فعوتب فى ذلك: إنه ليصيبني خطر فإذا وجدت ذلك إستعنت بقبر النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم (سير أعلام النبلاء للذهبي :3/3724)، إشتشفيت بقبر النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم (وفاء الوفا للحافظ السمهودي :2/444) Even the inn munkadhir(Ra)Asked the help of prophet!!!;what about this mr.philips???
He is being rather symplistic. Intercessant dead or alive is not worship of the person but asking them to interceed with God. Now I would not do that i would just asked god. i have never seen in hamza yusuf say that. I know he has his faults but not that one i think.
Hold up Mr. Bilal Phillips... on the day of judgement pbuh will be risen and he will give shifa'at for Muslim ummah. He will say ummatti ummatti to almighty Allaah swt for our forgiveness. Because almighty loves him so much he will pardon us and we shall enter heaven... So what's wrong with the waseela of pbuh.. In this world.... As he will return as Isa (as) will also return... So not sure of your point..... I think you need to understand... No shaheed /martyr of Lord almighty dies... In reality..... They live on... Peace love respect
So do you have a doctorate in Islam? The speaker was not randomly talking. He is well versed in Islamic knowledge. He is educating the people not saying uneducated things like what you wrote above. Amazing how people with such little knowledge think they know better than an 'Alim. Islam teaches us to respect those who have knowledge.
If I got no money and ask for you is it shirk or ask my boss to increase my salary is it haram or ask Dr zakir naik about anything is it haram coz for me I never follow anyone that can I trust accept Qur'an and hadhist
*TAWHEED = ONENESS* _They have certainly disbelieved who say, " Allah is the Messiah, the son of Mary" while the Messiah has said, "O Children of Israel, worship Allah , my Lord and your Lord." Indeed, he who associates others with Allah - Allah has forbidden him Paradise, and his refuge is the Fire. And there are not for the wrongdoers any helpers._ _They have certainly disbelieved who say, " Allah is the third of three." And there is no god except one God. And if they do not desist from what they are saying, there will surely afflict the disbelievers among them a painful punishment._ _The Messiah, son of Mary, was not but a messenger; [other] messengers have passed on before him. And his mother was a supporter of truth. They both used to eat food. Look how We make clear to them the signs; then look how they are deluded._ _Say, "O People of the Scripture, do not exceed limits in your religion beyond the truth and do not follow the inclinations of a people who had gone astray before and misled many and have strayed from the soundness of the way."_ _So will they not repent to Allah and seek His forgiveness? And Allah is Forgiving and Merciful._ *☾★*
@@mohammadsayed6373 I want to know what you know about sufism without researching now. I want to know if you've spoken to sufi Shuyookh and what they've said. And I want to know why you say it is a parallel religion
The reason I'm asking these questions is because we both know that your knowledge on sufism is virtually none and if you won't admit it to me then at least admit it to yourself. My apologies if that sounded rude or harsh but that's the reality. Sufism has changed my life in indescribable ways. It's the first time in my life that I have true love for the deen and for the Prophet (SAW). Am I right in saying you haven't even tried the sufi path but are making such claims? It's like saying pizza tastes disgusting when you haven't even tried it
@@PlayazXI اسلام علیکم Brother, it is an immensely huge topic. In short only way acceptable in the way of Allah-swt is that of our beloved Prophet Muhammad-saw & his-saw companion's. All other ways/interpretations/thoughts (even with minor differences) are rejected. Sufism was not known to Suhabas-ra. Hope I answered your query.
Imamat continue Prophet Muhammad (SW) told the names of his 12 Khalifas to Jabir bin Abdullah (RE): Ali bin Abu Talib, Hassan bin Ali, Hussain bin Ali, Ali bin Hussain, Muhammad bin Ali, Jaffer bin Muhammad, Mussa bin Jaffer, Ali bin Mussa, Muhammad bin Ali, Ali bin Muhammad, Hassan bin Ali and Muhammad bin Hassan and instructed him to covey His Slaam to the 5th Vicegerent Muhammad Baqar (ES) which he conveyed. "Iblees misguided everybody except a small group of the true believers (momineen)" (Surah Saba Verse-20). As such, a small group among the believers is infallible (masoom). ". . . Then We made the inheritors of Quran the chosen (mustafa) servants . . ." (Surah Faatir Verse-32). Allah bestows Slaam on the chosen (mustafa) servants (Surah an-Namal Verse-59). Therefore, the names of the chosen personalities are honored with the suffix title of Elayh Slaam and every Muslim pays Slaam on the Salayheen (pious people) during prayers. "On that day (day of resurrection), we shall call all human beings with their respective Imams. . ." (Surah al-Isra Verse-71). Therefore, so long a person exists in this world the presence of an Imam is essential! On the night of Power the angles descend therein, by the permission of their Lord with all the decrees (Surah al-Qadar Verse-4). Hence the presence of a Competent Authority (Sahib-e-Amar) is essential to whom the decrees are handed over. "Are they waiting to see if the angels come to them, or thy Lord (Himself), or certain of the signs of thy Lord! On that day when some of the signs of your Lord shall come, its faith shall not profit a soul which didn’t believe before, or earn good through its faith. Say: Wait; We too are waiting" (Surah al-An’aam Verse-158). Prophet Muhammad (SW) said, “When my 12th Khalifa will show up, Khazir and Ilyas from this world and Idrees and Eysa from the heavens will come to testify the Imamat of Muhammad al-Mehdi and Eysa will pray behind Muhammad al-Mehdi. "O you who believe! Obey Allah and obey the messenger and the Ulil Amr . . . " (Surah an-Nisaa Verse-59). Therefore, obedience of Ulil Amr is essential just like obedience of Allah and the Prophet. Ulil Amr are those vested with authority in all matters. Iblees accepted Allah but didn’t accept the superiority of His vicegerent (khalifa) then what would be the status of the person who has faith in Allah but does not accept the Imam of his time!
Yes sir true to that May Allah protect all humans from the errors of this man or any other man Ameen, and make more and more Little Hamza yusuf and Abdullah bin Bayya and Tariq
What the hell is this guy talking about? always negative. The wahabis are a minority in the Muslim community. None of the Muslim Khalifates were wahabi- they fought against the Ottoman Khalifate.
yes before ww1 they rebelled against ottoman, and then the chain of even is extend until 1948 by the help of british thus the birth of israel.. do you know how the allied can fight in the dessert?by the help of saudi's lending their base to fight german
Sufism is not correctly followed today. The correct Sufism is that of the Great Imam Junayd and the Great Shaykh Abdul Qadir Jilani (May Allah's Mercy be on Them)
just reading these comments tells me how much I need to know about hamza yusuf, his teachings and how they've rubbed off his followers in these comments.
+Quasim Ali There is absolutely nothing wrong with what Bilal Phillips says here. Unfortunately, many people take this faith that was meant to liberate the individual from the Ahbar (monastic order) and try to recreate such an order of intermediaries in Islam. This then leads to people worshipping people
Allahu Akbar ! Remember, This Umm shall split into 73 Sects and the only successful group Shall be those who source their way of life from The Qur'an and The Sunnah Only. To Allah we shall return for His Judgement and we won't be wronged. Br Bilal Philips said nothing wrong. Allah knows best !
*☾★* _You will surely find the most intense of the people in animosity toward the believers [to be] the Jews and those who associate others with Allah ; and you will find the nearest of them in affection to the believers those who say, "We are Christians." That is because among them are priests and monks and because they are not arrogant._ *☾★* *☾★* _Indeed, those who have believed [in Prophet Muhammad] and those [before Him] who were Jews or Sabeans or Christians - those [among them] who believed in Allah and the Last Day and did righteousness - no fear will there be concerning them, nor will they grieve._ *☾★* *☾★* _Say, "O People of the Scripture, you are [standing] on nothing until you uphold [the law of] the Torah, the Gospel, and what has been revealed to you from your Lord." And that which has been revealed to you from your Lord will surely increase many of them in transgression and disbelief. So do not grieve over the disbelieving people._ *☾★* *☾★* _O you who have believed, upon you is [responsibility for] yourselves. Those who have gone astray will not harm you when you have been guided. To Allah is you return all together; then He will inform you of what you used to do._ *☾★*
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D5 | Fall | พลาดวันนี้ จะต้องเสียใจ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A5-Cuo12p6A/mqdefault.jpg)
I would never call on a man, jinn, or angel. Allah is sufficient enough for me to call on for all of my needs, Alhumdallah .
Then you shouldn't be using doctors either
@@PlayazXI oh, can the doctors control the world?
@@user-vp6bf1nm5u Allah has given us the means. Whether it be medicines, tools, food, etc. And He has Power over everything
@@PlayazXI I think you mean to direct this @D Smith
@@PlayazXI We know Doctors fail when Allah decides & we know Doctors are only successfull when Allah allows them to be .
Abu Bakr said if anyone who worship Muhammad let him know that Muhammed is dead, and those who worship Allah let him know Allaah is alive and can not Die.
no body worship prophet muhammad..love him yes, worship him no..
For Wahhabis, love is worship, therefore you have to hate everyone, even the Prophet! What a shame!
The QURAN SAYS those who "die" in the way of Allah are NOT dead.
also noeone worships Muhammad saw. youve been sold propaganda.
🤣 tell the chapter number hadees number zakir naik
there is no secret knowledge in Islam (Islam is Clear)
Worship only Allah (Call only Allah)
True.
True
Look how hurt people are when they’re precious sheikhs gets called out. That right there tells you everything. Whether bilal phillips and/or hamza yusuf dies today or tomorrow does not deprive the ummah of anything in anyway. The preservation of Islam lies solely in Allah’s power and authority.
No matter what Hamza Yusuf is always going to be our favourite scholar. He never encouraged grave worshipping in any of the videos
Please don't accuse any one that he warship other than Allah cos if you say something wrong you are troubled
@@luluah1198 mr khawla please you dont know anything
They misunderstood him. He said making dua for the dead not to the dead. And when he said to ask someone for dua, he meant to ask righteous alive people to make dua for you. I'd suggest taking knowledge from reliable sources and the classical sources rather than taking it from a follower of the salaf movement.
Even if he’s Sufi ?
@@fattestmanintheworld5081 sufi doesn't mean dancing and worshiping graves. Sufism is very vast. Just because one sect of Sufis are like that doesn't make every Sufis like that. For example, how would you feel of someone came and said all followers of the salaf movement are extremists? Yes, we have extremism in every sect but does it make everyone in that sect extremists?
May Allah give a long life full of imaan and mercy to our dear Sheikh Hamza Yusuf. Aameen.
Ameen 🤲🏻✨
@@MonicaSĪGÑofJõñãhYUNIS Beware he is Sufi. He was shanting with others a song calling deceased for help, may Allah protect us from shirk.
"By Him in Whose Hand is my soul, my Ummah will split into 73 sects: one will enter Paradise and 72 will enter Hell' (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi)"
@Yahiya Kareem i did watch it. Followed by truly thinking about it. And my comment is the result of the process. I could be technically ignorant, but willful ignorance is an accusation I strongly deny.
Sending praise and and blessing upon the pious is practiced by the sahbah they used sing poetry and make also make praises. Praising Muhammad SAW you’ll receive 10 blessings and 10 sins will be removed
Provide a Sahih Hadith - We worhsip and call upon Allah only, it's Shirk, you've made a Claim provide a Sahih hadith - Dead people can't help. Even prophets.@@i-gotskillz-i8051
We should not call upon anyone unseen except Allah swt.
The title is instigating and divisive! Prophet Muhammad Peace be upon him never did this, instead he tried to unify his ummah and, what are we here for, for doing actions that hurt him? No right, then why so much of arrogance and hatred in the comments , dear brothers and sisters it's a humble request to get ourselves united we are not here to fight and quarrel amongst ourselves we are here for a greater purpose or if I can say greatest to spread peace and love,the Sunnah of our Beloved Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him.
Unite upon what???
Like when the Jews of Medina united against the Muslims. But their hearts were all disunited??
It is like you are asking the wolf to unite with the sheep. It cannot happen,
We have to unite upon the truth. I will never unite with a Shia who believes that Aisha R.A was a fornicatress, Authubillahi Al-Adeem and people who curse the beloved companions of the prophet. Never!!! How can you expect me to unite with such people. We will be united if we come together but our hearts will be disunited and there will be many disagreement and fighting. So stop just saying "lets unite" like there is no problems.
Rather say, *let us unite upon the Qur'an, the Sunnah, and the understanding of the companions and their students (Salaf-us-Saliheen).*
We are Muslim. I follow Quran and Sunnah but I don't call myself Sunni.
Student of Knowledge طالب العلم you had me until the salafi quote
@@MrGW2fanboy
Well Because it's a buzzword in your head and you are conditioned to put your guard up to what you hear about it because you have been listening to people who misunderstand it. Because you agreed with me up until that part. Salafiyyah is everything I wrote:
To understand the Qur'an and the sunnah the way the prophet pbuh taught and with his companions understanding and the rightly guided generations that came after them.
The salaf are the students and the students of the students of the sahabah.
Salafiyyah it to go back to their understanding of the religion not to "modernise" Islam to suit us. Because Islam was made for all people for ALL TIMES and does not change with time. The people who say it is extreme are saying the sahabah and their students are extreme. The prophet made dua for them to have understanding of the religion so we must obey.
Study more about Islam and the methodology of understanding it (salafiyyah). There was a need to specify our manhaj because there are so many sects claiming to be on the sunnah yet are far from it. In shaa Allah I am upon what the prophet and his companions were upon over 1440 years ago.
May Allah guide us All.
@@MrGW2fanboy Salafism is a poison
This was the aqeedah of sahaba ... the belief system taught in Qur'an and Sunnah !!!
woe to the worshipers of the dead and bid'ah lovers who ignorantly think that this was propagated by Shaikh Muhammad ibn Abdul wahhab.
kek, before him there is no..none of his believe system ever occurred..even ibn taymia will not gone far than what he has done. :D even his brother syaikh sulaiman write a letter on syaikh Muhammad wrong path..
Ibn e Taimyyah circumstances were different than those were in the time of Ibn Abdul Wahhab..!! Otherwise the former would have gone for the same...!! The later's manhaj was exactly that of the Prophet and his companions..!!
'Grave/pious-dead worship' has been pushed into islam by shitti first and then by sufis.
Shaikh Sulaiman opinion's of zero value!
Worshippers of the dead? Bring me one person who worships the dead and I promise you I will change my name
@@PlayazXI dua is ibadah/worship when you direct dua to other than Allah this is shirk and worship of the dead
@@pariah2749 Shaykh Sulayman later retracted his statement. Also, Around 400 years before Muhammad Ibn Abd al Wahhab, Al-Maqrizi Al-Shafi’i (d. 845H) says Istighatha is Shirk and makes a distinction between shirk in Uluhiyyah and shirk Rububiyyah
He says:
“And people in this matter - I mean: visiting graves - are of three groups:
A group that visits the dead and supplicates for them. And this is the legitimate visitation.
And a group that visits them and supplicates through them, so these are the polytheists in Uluhiyyah and love.
And a group that visits them and supplicates to them directly, and the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: "O Allah, do not let my grave become an idol that is worshipped," and these are the polytheists in Rububiyyah.”
تجريد التوحيد المفيد
i.imgur.com/QqqgSMy.png
dr. Philips speak the truth, worship only Allah!!...(swt) may Allah (swt) protect you and us from the fals aqiedah. amien
People in the comments are ridiculous. This man is stating facts. Hamza Yusuf said he calls for Prophet Muhammad (SAW), and he also believes we shouldn't have a Kalifah. Those are Bidah. Sufi Bidah. What happened to Fearing Allah. The Prophet (SAW) always said to worship, and call to only Allah. What happened to the aquidah of the Muslims? These are signs of the end.
Xassan Daxir He said Islam doesnt need a khalifah, not we shouldn't have one. And don't forget he isnt some salafi Bedouin living in medina on his camel. He is restricted on what he can say.
Uneducated/Students who doesn’t know about Fiqh and neither know the names of books talking about Scholars is the sign of an Illiteracy and Qiyamah has many signs. Using (SAW) instead of SALALLAHU ALAYHI WASALLAM is the sign of uneducated person. Grow up and learn Islam first. Just listening and obeying Blindly is not a sign of a Muslim.
@@syedosman5848 really? Bizarre... I haven't come across that one... cause who among the companions ever wrote in English? Never mind abbreviate... could you please inform me ?
I really believe what Hamza Yusuf said about following a madhab is taken completely out of context by Bilal Philips. As a public figure, he should be more responsible of what he says.
Generally speaking, it is beneficial to have a teacher when learning something new, including islam, thus following a madhab.
Follow Quran and Sunnah not a madhab
@@adamyoutube281 Madhab is the interpretation of the Quran and Sunnah. If you don't have that, you will misinterpret it as a common Muslim individual.
@@adamyoutube281 do you know arabic? can you interpret quran and hadith better than the jurists?
@@adamyoutube281 Imam Shafi learned arabic for 17 years! know your place . The prophet said that the generations closer to him will have truth and then lies will start spreading. All the great scholars and Salafs followed madhabs. and now you are watching new preachers and jumping here and there saying that follow quran and sunnah. do you really think our great scholars didn't think what you thought?
@@asifrana232 The true Salaf are the 4 Imams. the neo salafis are khawarij.
if you feel others are midguided, ask Allah Azzawajal to guide them on the straight path. If you feel you are misguided or guided, ask Allah Azzawajal to guide yourself on the same path. if you do not do that, then you are plain arrogant.
but on this point, i have a lot to say, but no point :)
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
If you care about the Muslims you will warn them against deviants, just like you would warn them against listening to, hanging around with druggies, alcoholics etc
Of course, if you don't care about the Ummah, you won't speak against deviants misleading the Ummah, you will just tell us... Make dua for them and not to speak against the evil.
Prophet s.a.w and the sahabaas used to address the deviants so are we better than him and his sahabaas naoodhubillah...no... so prophet s.a.w said if u see something wrong happening in ur sight u should proceed to stop it physically..if u can't..then verbally..if u can't...then atleast consider it(evil act)to be bad ...and if u can't even do that then ur imaan is in danger...
5 years ago, SubhanAllah. I did say there is a lot one can say on this point, however the key is firstly to understand that words can be interpreted in many different ways, especially text format, so I do apologise if my words were misunderstood. Secondly, the point I am making is the last point to the above hadith, also the above blessed hadith of our prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon Him) has a verh lengthy explanation as to what it actually means. However, since we are speaking about our Master, the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon Him), they naturally did everything with immense wisdom, we do should try to adopt this, and the Quran explains how to attain wisdom in many many different places 'the prophet of Allah (peace and blessings be upon Him) has been sent to teach religion, help purify (body mind heart and desires) and teach them wisdom and the book of Allah, the Exalted.' (62.2) also said in many many different places also.
So when somebody is doing wrong. Then yes, we should stand up and speak, but wrong is that person who goes out of his way to just criticise others. We should know, we as muslims have been facibg criticism our whole lives for no aparent reason. Islam is supposed to be opposite to this.. and that is the beginning of wisdom.
Give.. forgive.. and love.
May Allah, the Exalted bless you all, and Allah, the Exalted knows best.
As for the point 'to stay away from sufis'
That is simply because you have heard a complete one sided story and do not even know what a so called 'sufi' is. The funny thing is, a 'sufi' probably would not even use that term. So may Allah subhannahu wa ta'Alaa bless you all immensely and allow all to pass with the light of tawbah and imaan Insha'Allah عزوجل.
@@Saif0412 ignore these blind pacifists
Going to visit a shrine and saying salaam and making dua for them is COMPLETELY separate from 'worshipping' graves and asking from them
👌
Why you need to Salam them and pray for them
Invoking other than ALLAH is SHIRK
This is sahih hadith. Invoking others is shirk.
This is so oversimplified and generalised. Zaytuna is so big now and growing all the time. So many professors of islamic sciences part of that organisation. I feel more safe with all of their understanding than a lonely jelous wolf.
I 110+ agree. I believe shykh humza is gift to educated youth. I live in Pakistan, yet I can’t listen any scholar from Pakistan because they don’t make sense in their talks. But Every time I listen shykh humza, I can’t just move away from screen. Dude, I really love him. I appreciate what he is doing and May Allah give me taufeeq, I will support him in his cause. May Allah help him and bless him more.
@@muhammadusmanarif5338 Asalam Alaikum, Research Shiekh Omar Baloch
@@MonicaSĪGÑofJõñãhYUNIS sure.
I’ll do tawasul on the Prophet SAW any day, any time!
I will Pray to Allah any day any time inshallah..
Prophet a.s is not in our world
Hamza Yusuf never said there is secret knowledge. I do not support calling dead people but to say they are nonbeliever is too much for me
calling dead is the same as calling to a statue. They both cannot hear you or see you or respond to you. So what makes calling to a statue shirk and makes you a non-Muslim but to a dead person not. I'm not saying he is a Kafir either, but calling to graves/ dead people is an act of Kufr.
CALLING A DEAD PERSON IS SHIRK AND A MUSHRIK AINT A MUSLIM RIGHT.
Don't claim out of ur knowledge. Do research
من كان يعبد محمد فإن محمد قد مات ، و من كان يعبد الله فإن الله حي لا يموت.
Billal phillips is a true islamic scholar some grave worshipers may not like his speech because the bidat people don't like right path may Allah guide them
Did Bilal Philips call Hamza Yusuf for debate or conversation face to face? because that's what he should do instead of make a video like this
@@ceoaman3044 oh really? As an educator, he shouldn’t warn ppl about imam hamza’s misguidance?
Beware of Bilal Philips & the Wahhabiyyah in general..
Comparing this to Hamza Yusuf”s depth and sincere knowledge is mind blowing
Hu Hu Hu Hu Hu Hu Hu Hu Hu Hu Hu, do you like the shirk Hamza Yusuf sings in the kasida burda?
What knowledge?
@@iimiboy your OPINION in singing about Muhammad is shirk - tawassul itself is actually not SHIRK - I personally disagree with it myself - but THERE ARE SAHIH HADITHS of things like this happening among the companions after he died - its not like their calling out to their grandpa, its strictly Muhammad (saw) ….based on INTERPRETATIONS of Hadith - AND I DISAGREE WITH THEIR INTERPRETATIONS TOO but im not a takfirist khwarjite like yourself - I think its haram yes, but thats it - they are not elevating Muhammad to the LEVEL OF ALLAH , like the Christians do with Jesus is just intellectually fallacious
@@TheGEOPOLITICIANGUY yea show us your evidence please.
Why didn't the sahaba make dua to rasoolullah sallalahu alaihisalaam for rain but they instead went to the uncle of the prophet for him to make dua for rain.
@@iimiboy How is that Shirk?
Differences among Scholars are normal since the beginning (after the death of our beloved prophet) of Islam
But it is Wahhabism to deal with opponents with a destructive attitude.
So beware them.
Sh hamza yusuf is a beautiful knowledgable Muslim. I still listen to him
Me too. Bit confused. I never I heard him saying ask prophet SAW to give us something
The grave worshippers Sufis shouldn't get offended by this video but get educated by it. Believe me it's for your own good.
you must inform other about deviant suffi
A grave worshiper is a quburi, not a sufi.
IS THE SAME
I've never in my life met a person who worships graves. Nor have I met anyone who worships the person buried there. And I swear by Allah, you won't be able to find someone who does
@@PlayazXI not all sufis are extremists
Shame on you for accusing Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, this is the work of masih al dajjal and Shia to destroy muslim ummah. show me the proof that he asked to call Muhammad SAW, or any Shaykh for help beside Allah??? If you can't provide the proof delete the title and seek Allah forgiveness for spreading fitna. Otherwise you are no different than Shia kufr who worship Ali R.A and spread lies and allegation toward Sahaba,you'll answer to Allah in the hereafter.
How unfortunate to give circular arguments to discredit a scholar. How unfortunate that our enemies see us as one ummah. They kill us indiscriminately; while we are busy discrediting each other. Signs of end of times إنا لله وإنا إليه راجعون
Jazakallahu Khaira ya Sheikh! MashaAllah! Great lecture. May Allah protect us from these false aqeedah's and may He rid the sub continent and the rest of the world of all bid'ah and shirk! And may He guide us all to the right path!! Ameen!!!
L E T T E R WRITING ✍ WOULD ANSARI,-H E L P!
Jazaka Allah khairan Ustad Bilal Phillips ...
Sufism is a new thing that was not in the time of prophet Mohammed (salla Allahu alaihi wa sallam), or his Sahaba, or the Taabeen, our the Tabi Taabeen.
if anyone can connect to Allah (subhanahu wataala) as Sufi claim, then shouldn't the Sahaba have had that?
wake up guys and repent to Allah (subhanahu wataala) before you meet him in the day of judgment and he asks you why you changed the deen.
May Allah (subhanahu wataala) guide us all, Ameen.
@Yasin Abdul Exactly, not to mention other big names and their opinions on tasawwuf, for example that of Shafi'i's.
@Yasin Abdul Ameen, back to you brother. I am actually a hanafi with recent interest in tassawwuf, but that doesn't change much at all. I haven't received any requests, can you try again?
You are so wrong. You are saying what i use to say 20 years ago. That is such a short cited argument. May Allah show you the truth and not let shaitaan use one of his million tricks to keep you away from something that is good.
Thank you for posting this and thanks for the CLEAR TITLE. I would like to point out that whenever I am searching for Islamic lectures on line, the algorithm always suggests Hamza Yusuf videos, even if the video they're promoting does not match with what I typed in the search. Also, TH-cam & Google seem to be making it difficult to find the Islamic topics that one searches for. Be ware that they may eventually purposely misguide people to the wrong path...
so true! I've been facing the same problem during my research.
I have had a different outcome...
May Allah have Mercy on Shiekh Hamza Yusuf and guide him 🤲🏻✨
Dr Bilal must practice surah Hujurat on the following ayat(verses) and repent to Allah and apologize for his erring. Allah loves good conduct in relations and speech:
“Oh you who have believed let not a people ridicule another people; perhaps they may be better than them, Nor let women ridicule other women, perhaps they may be better than them. And do not insult one another, and do not call each other by offensive nick names. Wretched is the name of disobedience after ones faith, and whoever does not repent then it is those who are the wrong doers.
Oh you who have believed avoid negative assumption. Indeed some assumption is sin, And do not spy or back bite each other. Would one of you would like to eat the flesh of his brother when dead. You would detest it. And fear Allah for Allah is accepting of repentance and merciful”.
Perhaps are you misusing the Quran ?...🤔
He is only making an argument that you could try to reject with knowledge. I think what he said is clear and simple.
Don't attribute to sheikh hamza what you have no clear proof of.
Non has the right to be worshipped but Allah,bilal Phillips is right.The prophet (pbuh) is dead ,he can't hear nothing of this world and doesn't know what's going on in this world .He was a human being just like everyone else but a messenger and a slave of Allah just like the rest of the previous prophets.
Allahu Akbar non has the right to be worshipped but Allah (do not exaggerate in worshiping me like the Christians worshipped Isa son of Maryam).That is what the prophet Mohammed said (pbuh).So we shouldn't worship him ,he's not Allah or the creator but a messenger and slave of Allah .
“The Messenger of Allah spoke to the People (buried) in the
Well saying: “Have you found out that what your Lord had promised you is
true?” then someone exclaimed: “Are you calling out to the dead!” The
Prophet replied: “You do not hear better than they do, except they do
not respond.”
Sahih Bukhari, Volume 2, Book 23, Number 452
Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) let the dead bodies
of the unbelievers who fought in Badr (lie unburied) for three days. He
then came to them and sat by their side and called them and said: O Abu
Jahl b. Hisham, O Umayya b. Khalaf, O Utba b. Rab’ila, O Shaiba b.
Rabi’a, have you not found what your Lord had promised with you to be
correct? As for me, I have found the promises of my Lord to be
(perfectly) correct. Umar listened to the words of Allah’s Apostle (may
peace be upon him) and said: Allah’s Messenger, how do they listen and
respond to you? They are dead and their bodies have decayed. Thereupon
he (the Holy Prophet) said: By Him in Whose Hand is my life, what I am
saying to them, even you cannot hear more distinctly than they, but they
lack the power to reply. Then’he commanded that they should be buried
in the well of Badr.
Sahih Muslim, Book 040, Number 6869
and a lot more even in qur'an.
even ordinary death people can hear, how come prophet, the most beloved and revered by Allah, can't? you believe there is afterlife and everything unseen but easily dismissed and judge..
The creed of the sunni muslims is that our Prophet (peace be upon him) is ALIVE in his grave.
SubhanaLlah, this is what you believe?. What abut this hadith?
"My life is a great good for you, you will relate about me and it will be related to you, and my death is a great good for you, your actions will be exhibited to me, and if I see goodness I will praise Allah, and if I see evil I will ask forgiveness of Him for you." Nabi Muhammad
Am not gonna post the source. Help yourself, unless you want to daef the hadith
Calling on the Prophet Muhammad pbuh isn't worship , this is dirty whahabi tactics to change the meaning.
Really?? So, you know more??? Are you a scholar? Which institute did you get your islamic knowledge? Yea, that's what I thought. You're just a mindless blabber.
Stfu grave worshipper quburi
Sending salawat is ok asking allah to bless muhammed , but praying to muhammed for help is obviously shirk. Only allah hears and answers calls, this is in the quran and sunnah clearly
This man is certainly trying to misguide people. As a Muslim I don't like the way he is addressing our beloved Prophet Muhammad (SA), his attempt is to divide the Muslim Ummah rather than uniting them.
I have always heard Shaykh Hamza Yusuf praising our Peophet Muhammad (SA) wholeheartedly, he have immense love in his heart for our Prophet Muhammad (SA) and this man Bilal Philips haven't understood the status of the greatest Nabi e Kareem (SA) otherwise he wouldn't have uttered such words.
I love and respect Shaykh Hamza Yusuf, he is dear to me, he is showing the right way, teaching the right Islam. Mashallah, may Allah (SWT) give him long and healthy life and elevate his status. Aameen!
+Faiz Sheikh He didn't criticize Hamza Yusif, he merely pointed an aspect of his faith out, i.e. his belief in isnad and you're here crying. So is Hamza Yusif now for you a perfect human being? if you're so heartbroken about this I suggest you verify this with the sheik H.
+Faiz Sheikh " he is dear to me, he is showing the right way, teaching the right Islam" that is what I am careful not to say in regards to people. Are you a scholar to know which Islam is right or wrong?
+nazirdjon
I don't have to be a scholar to judge a scholar, no one needs to.
You should know that during the reign of Amir ul Momineen Hazrat Umar Farooque (RA) common people were free to intervene in political & religious matters, except that they weren't allowed any abuse. There are several other evidence I can give. So don't tell me that Islam doesn't give me right to judge a scholar.
Bilal Philips is uttering the words that I haven't heard before. I am not here to debate, I just watched this video and thought of expressing myself.
+YmnTree Sheikh Hamza Yusuf is not the only scholar I admire. I listen to many scholars and I am free to express my view about each of them.
Brother, you should not get so much offended by my comment.
I listen to Sheikh Hamza and he never ever care to criticize or blame any other scholar for anything (their Aquidah their Madhab etc.). There is no need AT ALL to add another scholar into any speech which is meant to educate about Islam, Quran & Sunnah.
Jazakallah Khair Brother Bilal Philips (true teaching of Islam)
Islam was really that clear we would not need scholars.
@@Mulberry2000 Brother, even own language study need a Teacher to explain
Jazaak Allahu Khayr Dr. Bilal! May Allah swt increase your rank! Aameen.
Ameen!
why use Hamza Yusefs name in the title. He is not Sufi. He follows malaki school of thought. This is defamatory
MOST SUFI SAY THEY ARE SUNNIS... BECAUSE HE IS MALIKI DOESNT MEAN HE IS NOT A SUFI.
SUFI IS A WAY OF LIFE. NOT A SECT, WHAT IS THE PROBLEM
@@Evethedive ISLAM is a way of life.... SUFISM IS A SECT.
Sufi is about defeating your ego, nefis.
So what is the problem
@@abdulhamidmohammed6738 No Tasawwuf is a science of Islam. The science of ihsan. People that are known to be people who heavily focused on purification of the heart and ihsan are called sufis. It is not a sect. There is a lot of bid'ah that some sufis have injected into the science, but you don't reject the entirety of the science. You can be a Maliki and be a Sufi. You can be a Hanbali and a Sufi. You can be a simple Muslim and not know all that much about fiqh and be a Sufi. But Sufism by itself is not a jurisprudence, it's not a sect, and it's not bid'ah. It's a technical term like fiqh, aqeedah, etc. Without Tasawwuf I'd argue everything else becomes pointless. Your iman becomes pointless, your worship etc becomes pointless without purification of the heart.
Alhamdulilah for sheikh bilal phillips people of ahlul bidah should not be followed it leads to shirk ul akbar. 100% in agreement with his stance on his issue.
Subhanallah alhamdelliah allah answered my dua about this, i met a woman who follows hamza yusuf and she was forcing on me having to follow madhab, or else i will be misguided, like following the quran and authentic sunnah is not enough subhanallah she was the one misguided , and she was insuliting me even though i said nothing mean or act badly with her
There is a distinct difference between Bilal and Hamza Yousuf. Bilal scratches the surface all the time ..
This guy is severely misguided, I don't necessarily agree with either but the way he talks about our beloved Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) is disgusting.
How does he talk about him?
disgusting? how so?
Sheikh hamza Yusaf is a Sunni, studied 11 years in Algeria. he is Maliki. Not suffi
YOU FEAR SHIRK? "there is no god but allahand muhammad pbuh is his messenger" ...its simple its in the title..how can you do shirk after saying that? islam is easy but people make it ugly
The problem with our Ummah is we don't read nowhere nearly as much as we used to. For example it's basic understanding that in the physical world, Sayidna Muhammad (saw) was a descendant of Sayidna Ishmael (pbuh), and that righteous bloodline continued without blemish all the way to his tribe, the Bani Hashim, who were the best of people within the Quraish . That's Sayidna Muhammad's proof of lineage and existence in the physical world, but what about Prophet Muhammad's timeline in the spiritual world?
ARE WE NOT AWARE OF A STRONG HADITH, NARRATED BY UMAR BIN AL KHATTAB:
Allah's Messenger (Peace Be Upon Him) said: When Adam committed the error, he submitted (to Allah): O Lord, I beg You to forgive me through the mediation of Muhammad. Then Allah said: O Adam! How did you recognize Muhammad as I have not created him yet? He replied: O Lord, when You created me with Your divine hand and breathed Your soul into me, I raised my head and saw 'la ilaha illallahu Muhammad-ur-rasulullah ("There is no god but Allah, Muhammad is Allah's Messenger")' inscribed on each pillar of the Throne. I discovered that with Your name, the name of only such a person can be associated who is Your most beloved of all the creatures. At this Allah said: O Adam, you have said it correctly. Of all the creatures I love him the most. Now when you offered your prayer through his mediation, I forgave you. And if Muhammad were not there, I would not have created even you.
SOURCES:
Al-Hakim narrated it in al-Mustadrak al Sahihayn (Volume No. 2, Page No. 651, Hadith No. 4228)
Tabarani Mu'jam Al-Ausat Volume 006, Page No. 313-314, Hadith Number 6502
This was the first instance of a human being (Adam, pbuh) using the name of someone else; Muhammad pbuh, who was not even created yet, as a means of mediation, to secure for himself the mercy of Allah.
Chew on that...
Hamza Yussuf is not a sufi, he's a suni that follows the fiqh of Imam Malik. Also we all have teachers that lead us to the prophet may peace be upon him, Dr Bilal studied at Medina, his teacher learnt Islam from his teacher , who learnt it from his/her teacher , who learnt it from his/her teacher until the generations of the tabi, sahaba then prophet himself saw
What are you trying to say then
Bruh he is sufi even maliki fiqh doesn't allow
Scholars should not criticise other scholars. It is not a muslim's place to judge another muslim. As Muslims we are a brotherhood, one Ummah. Let us not be split apart.
As Muslims, we should not even try to expose the sins of others, or our own. Only Allah knows what is in someone's heart.
Except if they spread practices that the Messenger never taught, hm?😏
@@amantubillahi9628 indeed
So if the scholars don't refute the people and the "scholars" of misguidance, how can we know which path is the true path to follow? Refutation is a part of the deen.
Hamza Yusuf is totally devoted ehli sunne sunni Muslim , he can't go out from that circle . There is great tradition of İslam . Once you read , you will see what is allowed and what is not.
He's ash'ari and he speaks nothing but misguidance.
Hamza Yusuf is a pious person of high stature. Whatever you call him a sufi or non sufi, he talks about unity, he attends all the big events with every scholars and tries to bridge the coflicts. If you try to unite Muslims on the basis of Allah, Prophet Mohammad s.a.w an Quran then forget about everything else. Every scholar says there should be unity but only at his terms. Why?
not true. Yusuf is not a pious person of high stature. He's a confused person sometimes mixing in the Jews or other beliefs with Muslim beliefs. Listen to some of his audio tapes. he's hilarious at best. The problem is that he is misguiding people knowingly.
@@user-vp6bf1nm5u th-cam.com/video/7YCl1S-DfiQ/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=IslamRewards
he is not. he talks about Muslim and sectarianism,, that is why they hate him. culture and tradition is not islam
@@brasstow3209 oh, you haven’t heard him long enough nor listened to all his audio tapes. People don’t hate him or dislike him just because. He’s not intellectually consistent. Listen to all his talks long enough with an open mind and you’ll see.
He speaks against shari'a law. He doesn't think it should be established.
@@safwanshahriar4108 What? Where'd you get this info.?
I listened to a video of his promoting SHARIA LAW'S!
Its astounded me of how many people here discredited Dr. Philips. What he say is make sense. Don't go the path of the christian my brothers and sisters.
+Saqib Raheel 😂 ? OK... strange...
Makes sense at face value only. If you have true knowledge you will see in how many places he is completely incorrect
@@PlayazXI Sounds like you're talking about Hamza Yusuf.
He does seems to be right!
May Allah guide us and may we not be misguided like the Christians!
This guy called Imam Husayn a “rebel”. Astaghfurillah...What a bad statement. Husayn is is sayyid ahl Shabbab aj jannah.....Master of the youth of paradise is Hassan and Husayn.
These people shall be raised with Yazeed on judgment day
@@zahinelahi2655 inshallah they are exposed. And he said the prophet is dead in a very dreary voice, indicating that he isn’t even alive in the next world. He’s foolish
YA RASOOL ALLAH HI UNZUR HALANA
YA HABIB ALLAH HI ISMAQALANA 🌹
Wheres is hes proof?
Be aware of bilal philips
Qur'an teaches that those who die in the path of Allah aren't dead but alive in His Divine presence and taken care of, also our Noble Rasul Swallalah Aleyhih wa Salam interceded on behalf of his Ummah, and his presence ministry is Rahma , and he also taught whoever see's him in a dream is real, he'll intercede for his Ummah on the day of judgement. He further taught us that Ulamahs are vicagrant to the prophets.
But not alive on earth right? Not intervening in our affairs nor able to do so, right ?
If the Messenger of Allah sallallaahu aleyhi wa sallama was alive do you think he'd let all those scholars be humiliated, incarcerated, threatened by the guy in charge today ? That Jewish and American acolyte in the neom plan for greater Israel and the building of the third temple for the coming of the dajjaal ? Hum?
Anyway calling on anyone but Allah is plain shirk... even if it is the Messenger of Allah sallallaahu aleyhi wa sallama. Agree?
I agree with him.
Still in love with sheikh hamza yusuf
Put your emotions to a side. Some people love isis and Al qaeda and they won’t look at things with an open mind. Shaykh hamza Yusuf says seeking help from the prophet peace be upon him is allowed. He allows such evil. It’s there on the internet so do your research brother and look at things with an open mind. May Allah guide us all
then go and kiss his sufi ass.
@@sovu9399 you are doing wrong by saying this. Talk in a decent and polite manner. Refuting and exposing people of misguidance should be done without swearing or cussing.
@@weshouldsaveourselves6780 Sure brother!
The thing is, he turned away after hearing the truth by brother Bilal.
these sufi/shia are the enemies of Islam, damn corrupters. Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala CURCED those who bring something new to Islam.
@@sovu9399 super sufis and shias are indeed transgressors
I agree with Billal but I must admit that I never heard Hamza Yusuf encouraging grave worshipping. He grow up 70/70s California , Catholic convert, one of our best scholar of our time. And Rational .
Allah give us knowledge so we listen both and take only good deed from their teaching Amen.
He's rational??? He thinks he's more pious than the early generation scholars! smh
@@user-vp6bf1nm5u Show me where he said this
😂Mulla is angry 😂😂...u r clearly in the error
Did our Rasool not spend time alone in the cave meditating or contemplating in the praises of Allah (internalizing it with his very essence of being) freeing himself from any external disturbance? It was a time early in Islam. He may have been disturbed by those around him, or from the cacophony that emanates within a city. Do the rest only utter Allah's praises and do actions with lips saying praises. And that is good. Or do some go to the extent of saying Allah's name with the same breath as they are taking deeply into their bodies, and also whilst exhaling and concentrating in desiring a connection with the creator and immersing only in the thought of the creator? Oh if any regards this as a bad act act, then surely you must be deranged. The Quran as even declared by Ali (RA), is for all time, so not all of the understanding could have been derived at the time of our Rasool. So when anyone speak of an "innovation" (and surely Bilal Philips uses a cell-phone and travels by plane) he needs to ponder on the essence of the "innovation" of whether it is suggestive of positive or of negative effect. Once again our Rasool immersed himself in a private affair contemplating Allah subhanahu wata ala in that cave. An "innovation"? I think not.
Dear brother, calm down and humbly seek knowledge. Put your emotions aside. The definition of bid'ah is exclusively pertaining to acts of 'ibaada. Not dunya issues. Otherwise we'd still be going around in camel caravans and getting light from camp fires and candles.
Calm down ya 3alawi
Philip sir is lack of knowledge ....No Sunni worship other than Allha ...He have to learn more about thawassul and isthigasa .... Don't follow this talk ...he is lack of knowledge...May Allha guide him in right ...Hamza Yusuf is best Sunni scholor no one can overtake him
The biggest tell tale sign of a false scholar is the way they discredit others. This is not the way of Islam and Rasoolullah (SAW)
It is the way of RasoolUllah (S.A.W) to enjoin in the good and *forbid the evil* whether it is a person or an act or belief.
So to inform the people of a bid'ah belief or ideology is not only allowed but it is wajib (mandatory).
@@seekerofknowledge6595 please don't attribute qualities to Rasoolullah (SAW) of which you have no knowledge. The fact is he did not name and shame anyone, not even the Munaafiqeen. The funny thing is that the sufis have much more dirt on these so called scholars but they don't bring it out in the open
You are dividing people in the name of different sufis and scholars ..As a Muslim you should unite people not divide....And how can u say about sheikh Hamza yusuf who is a role model for youth today....U are a Saudi paid salafi scholar who can only divide people that is what the enemies of Islam want and u are doing it for them
You don't judge matters my sister do research
Hamza Yusuf is not a role model for the Youth. This is coming from the youth.
@@ankaldally2734
You yourself should do research on this matter..
The real Bid'ah is the Wahhabi movement. Bilal Philips studied in Madinah so it explains his extreme views that are alien to true Islam. How dare he discredit Shaykh Nuh Ha Mim Keller like that. "The Blessed Prophet [Peace and Blessings be Upon him] said, "Whoever bears malice towards Allah’s Walī, Allah will declare war upon him" (Sahih Bukhari). And it is without a doubt that Shaykh Nuh is of the true Awliya' of Allah. Anyone can realize this even as soon as they lay eyes on him.
Typical sufi talks.. Just by face colour you can spot Wali of Allah azzawajal.. 😂😂😂
Ya Rasool Allah
Lol
Uploader should first learn the Hadith about Backbiting and Saying Bad to a Muslim. Shame on you
He’s not backbiting. He’s educating. He is an educator. It is incumbent upon him to point out the wrong and state the truth.
very true what he says ....Islam is straight but people started their own beliefs from sheikhs who corrupted the faith. ..
8:20 If this was true, that abu bakr only gave a secret knowledge to someone, everyone who hides this knowledge is sinful, Allah says in the Qur'an:
Surah Al-Baqarah 2:42
وَلَا تَلْبِسُوا۟ ٱلْحَقَّ بِٱلْبَـٰطِلِ وَتَكْتُمُوا۟ ٱلْحَقَّ وَأَنتُمْ تَعْلَمُونَ ٤٢
Do not mix truth with falsehood or hide the truth knowingly.
- Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran
and again in Surah Al-Baqarah:
2:76
وَإِذَا لَقُوا۟ ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ قَالُوٓا۟ ءَامَنَّا وَإِذَا خَلَا بَعْضُهُمْ إِلَىٰ بَعْضٍۢ قَالُوٓا۟ أَتُحَدِّثُونَهُم بِمَا فَتَحَ ٱللَّهُ عَلَيْكُمْ لِيُحَآجُّوكُم بِهِۦ عِندَ رَبِّكُمْ ۚ أَفَلَا تَعْقِلُونَ ٧٦
When they meet the believers they say, “We believe.” But in private they say ˹to each other˺, “Will you disclose to the believers the knowledge Allah has revealed to you, so that they may use it against you before your Lord? Do you not understand?”
- Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran
2:77
أَوَلَا يَعْلَمُونَ أَنَّ ٱللَّهَ يَعْلَمُ مَا يُسِرُّونَ وَمَا يُعْلِنُونَ ٧٧
Do they not know that Allah is aware of what they conceal and what they reveal?
- Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran
Of course, abu bakr (ra) did not do this sin and what they say is lies.
This video is extremely troubling. With a catchy title I feel like it was uploaded only for views
i think the person who we need to be Beware of is you Bilal Phillips. You're evidently tearing the Muslim community apart, shame on you.
He's not tearing the community apart.He is trying to show people the truth and part of that is rejecting the falsehood and misguidance others are spreading those who claim to be following the prophet(pbuh) but are doing the opposite!
telling people not to worship graves sounds like he is trying to regroup the ummah actually
What wrong did Br Bilal said 🤔
He is taking to us from the path of salaf indeed we can directly call to Allah swt no need for anyone between even in some cases Allah says it's about me and my servant servant doesn't need any intermediary in this dunia after life indeed we some of us need the intermediary of prophet Muhammad pbuh
Mahfuz Ahmed How he tearing muslim community... i don't understand why you hate him.
I'm hoping bilal philips has taken this back just like yasir qadhi
My sheikh of all the time. Bilal
Be careful..
Ahmed Ali
0 seconds ago
6:24 Allah states in the Quran the martyrs are alive and people bury them? Hamza Radiyallahu anhu and many more shuhada were buried by Nabi Sallallhu alayhi wasallam was he committing sin by burying the dead?
Tahir Al Qadri was not putting Nabi Sallallhu alayhi wasallam’s in the rank of Isa alayhissalaam he’s clearly talking about istighatha
This man is mixing chain of Hadith knowledge to something else so the average Muslim thinks he can have knowledge without chain. So why do the Muhaddithun have a chain?
He’s giving green light to those who self study this is their methodology then they say they’re upon the methodology of the Sahabah Radiyallahu anhum.
I went into to so called salafiyyah circles in my early days and all I saw was miniature abu jahls and firouans waiting to question, anttack, and reticule everyone and everything.
All I heard in them circles was Ahlul id’ah, shirk billah, istiwa, daleel, sahih and minhaj lol. Not one could pronounce a single word from above list in actual Arabic and they’re asking for daleel.
The salafiyyah of Indian sub continent study hanafi fiqh books because they don’t have any nor are their self studied so called ulama are able to formulate any.
Some UK Salafi study in Morocco and Muritania the fiqh of Imam of Darul Hijra Imam Malik rahmatullah alayhi then attack the madhahib.
Bunch of clowns. Little knowledge is dangerous.
Your character shows you up even before your ignorant knowledge.
Ask the so called Salafiyyah wives about their husbands characters at home and you’ll see the real minhaj in their behaviour.
No name calling then comes up the name of Shaykh Hamzah Yusuf lol
The speakers brushes all Sufies with one brush lol
Wow. This man is extremely misguided regarding this. While certain things he said seem correct at face value, they are utterly incorrect. For example, the Prophet (SAW) is not dead. Allah says that about the martyrs, so what is the status of Rasoolullah (SAW). "And do not say ofthose who are killed in the way of Allah "they are dead". Nay, they are living but you perceive it not". We are ordered not to say that the martyrs are dead and this man is saying Rasoolullah (SAW) is dead. A'udhubillah. Secondly, he says we are allowed to ask people for help, but are not allowed to ask Allah through the waseela of Rasoolullah (SAW). Something doesn't make sense here. Also in an authentic Hadith Rasoolullah (SAW) told a sahabi to say Ya Allah, ya Rasoolullah to cure his illness even though Rasoolullah (SAW) was not there
The Prophet peace be upon him did not die in battle.
@@SonoftheFortunate oh so you believe this applies ONLY to martyrs?
@@PlayazXI
According to the Quran yes.
2:154
"And do not say about those who are killed in the way of Allah, "They are dead." Rather, they are alive, but you perceive [it] not."
The word yuqatalu is used, ie slain.
The Muhammad peace be upon him did not die in battle but on his bed. Therefore that ayah cannot be applied to the rasool.
@@SonoftheFortunate in Islam rulings are made wholistically, and not based on the fact that Rasoolullah (SAW) was omitted from the verse. There are many many proofs of the Prophet (SAW) being alive. Many have seen him in dreams, some have seen him in an awakened state and Imam Busiri (RA) was even visited by him (SAW). Aside from this there are many other proofs that he (SAW) is alive
@@PlayazXI
What? Did you just claim the Prophet peace be upon him is alive?? By what evidence? Dreams?!
Dreams are not evidence of life. He is clearly not on earth, his soul is not in his body. He will be resurrected just like us.
Isa peace be upon him on the other hand is alive because Allah tells us that he himself raised him to the heavens and he is alive.
So claiming that Prophet is alive in a physical form requires great evidence.
I have an open mind, but a dream is not evidence.
And Al Busiri was A SUFI!
yeah ,because your interpretation is the right one every one else is misguided?Specially those who u dont like!
U should say this too.
Let Allah be the judge my friend.
Hold on for a second. He has some good points. I listen to hamza Yusuf a lot I love his lectures. But come on, tawassul is so muddy
@@ishmaelm1932
If he disagrees with Shaykh Hamza, he should debate with him face-to-face. I have never heard Shaykh Hamza criticize anyone by name in his lectures.
@@raheelshafi882 he criticizes the Muslims and praises those who war with Muslims. Listen to all of his lectures. Then decide. Please don’t follow blindly. Don’t let his charm misguide you. This speaker (Dr.Bilaal) is a well known educator. It is his job to point out falsehood or the misguided ones.
Hamza Yusuf is aristocracy related to government officials. Also anti-black
May Allah destroy the Saudis and Najdis who want to dig out the blessed grave, destroy the green dome and disrespect muslim heritage!
Wake up brothers!!
actually a muslim should beware of wahhabism/salafism at all. because your ideology is not what islam was or will be. all of you have no respect for the ulama except of your ulama.
all of you have the arrogance to tell people that all of them are wrong except of you and everything which has been taught over the last 1300 years would be wrong and all of them would practise shirk and bida'a.
but look, there was no one who ever called himself a salafi except of you.
but even you are taking from our scholars which where all sufis even ibn taymiyyah who was in the qadiri tareeqah. imam ashari or imam maturidi teachings have also sufi aqeeda and still you are all taking their teachings.
your silsila is broken no proofs no scholars after the salaf.
you should be the one who should be bewared of.
the methods of muhammad ibn adbul wahhab are the same as they are practicing now in Iraq or Syria by ISIS.
May Allah bless you with Hidayah. At the moment all of you are on the wrong path. You are NOT uniting, you are DESPARATING the Ummah of Rassulullah (Alaihi Salatu wa Salam)
you are doing the same: disparting. there is difference between salafi and teachings of muhammad ibn abdul wahab. Allah forbids to talk about things you don't have knowledge about. think about it and recognize, that there is no need for response or keep going. and before you start judging me, without knowing me, i respect all madhab and also sufi that don't fall into shirk. as salamu aleykum.
durani1987
Did you read any book about the biography of any sufi and the history of reformative movement of muhammad bin abdul wahab/
Sometimes here (@Muslim platforms ) you will see a muslim name or some usernames imitating or labeling themselves being "Muslim"
And some of you who heartily committed their Islamic faith will fall on that schemes, and what is that scheme? To misguide you, misinform you, avert you from your creed and not least but last " To divide you in order & then to exploit your weakness. "Watch out" your enemies are licensed for your disperity and your destruction.
Leave all accounts to the lord, Guard yourself -----something you disagree leave it--don't quarrel to another human being.
Finally, anybody who says *there is no God But Allah" is your brother or sister.
Guard your tongue, please
durani1987
Come on dude , are you blinded by bid’ah
السلام عليكم
Thats definitely not right.
With respect i tell you, that you dont even know what sufi is. Sufi is a other Word for Tasawwuf or tazzkiyah and is the science how to cleanse your heart. The Word comes from the name of a group of People living to the time of our beloved Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) They were poor people fed by our Prophet (صلى الله عليه وسلم) every day and they were known as people who were really strong in their Prayers.
Was Imam Shafi (رحمه الله) on a road to Hell too? (Aoouthu Billah)
He said:
“Be a Faqih and a Sufi”
You can look this statement up. There are similar from other Big Schoolars and Salafs.
You cant Judge a term you dont know, only because today a few crazy people miss use it...
You know who was the Teacher of Sheikh Hamza yusuf (صاحب دامت بركاته)? It was one of the Big Schoolars of our time. Especially in the Usool (princibles) of Fiqh, Aqidah and Kalam.
You simply complete miss interprete his statements.
May Allah guide you all
السلام عليكم
exactly
كان ابن المنكدر (التابعي) يجلس مع اصحابه فكان يصيبه صمات فكان يقوم كماهو حتى يضع خده على قبر النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم ثم يرجع فعوتب فى ذلك: إنه ليصيبني خطر فإذا وجدت ذلك إستعنت بقبر النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم (سير أعلام النبلاء للذهبي :3/3724)،
إشتشفيت بقبر النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم (وفاء الوفا للحافظ السمهودي :2/444)
Even the inn munkadhir(Ra)Asked the help of prophet!!!;what about this mr.philips???
Nice video calling out the deviants
He is being rather symplistic. Intercessant dead or alive is not worship of the person but asking them to interceed with God. Now I would not do that i would just asked god. i have never seen in hamza yusuf say that. I know he has his faults but not that one i think.
Hold up Mr. Bilal Phillips... on the day of judgement pbuh will be risen and he will give shifa'at for Muslim ummah. He will say ummatti ummatti to almighty Allaah swt for our forgiveness. Because almighty loves him so much he will pardon us and we shall enter heaven... So what's wrong with the waseela of pbuh.. In this world.... As he will return as Isa (as) will also return... So not sure of your point..... I think you need to understand... No shaheed /martyr of Lord almighty dies... In reality..... They live on...
Peace love respect
So do you have a doctorate in Islam? The speaker was not randomly talking. He is well versed in Islamic knowledge. He is educating the people not saying uneducated things like what you wrote above. Amazing how people with such little knowledge think they know better than an 'Alim. Islam teaches us to respect those who have knowledge.
You wahabis are always attacking people who is not doing anuthing wrong with you! Shame on you mr. Philips
If I got no money and ask for you is it shirk or ask my boss to increase my salary is it haram or ask Dr zakir naik about anything is it haram coz for me I never follow anyone that can I trust accept Qur'an and hadhist
He's talking about the dead or someone who isn't present man use your brain
Bilal Philips - please make new short videos like this
*TAWHEED = ONENESS*
_They have certainly disbelieved who say, " Allah is the Messiah, the son of Mary" while the Messiah has said, "O Children of Israel, worship Allah , my Lord and your Lord." Indeed, he who associates others with Allah - Allah has forbidden him Paradise, and his refuge is the Fire. And there are not for the wrongdoers any helpers._
_They have certainly disbelieved who say, " Allah is the third of three." And there is no god except one God. And if they do not desist from what they are saying, there will surely afflict the disbelievers among them a painful punishment._
_The Messiah, son of Mary, was not but a messenger; [other] messengers have passed on before him. And his mother was a supporter of truth. They both used to eat food. Look how We make clear to them the signs; then look how they are deluded._
_Say, "O People of the Scripture, do not exceed limits in your religion beyond the truth and do not follow the inclinations of a people who had gone astray before and misled many and have strayed from the soundness of the way."_
_So will they not repent to Allah and seek His forgiveness? And Allah is Forgiving and Merciful._
*☾★*
Eye Opener for Sufism
And what do you know about sufism?
@@PlayazXI
اسلام علیکم
Brother, Sufism is a parallel religion and has nothing to do with Islam.
@@mohammadsayed6373 I want to know what you know about sufism without researching now. I want to know if you've spoken to sufi Shuyookh and what they've said. And I want to know why you say it is a parallel religion
The reason I'm asking these questions is because we both know that your knowledge on sufism is virtually none and if you won't admit it to me then at least admit it to yourself. My apologies if that sounded rude or harsh but that's the reality. Sufism has changed my life in indescribable ways. It's the first time in my life that I have true love for the deen and for the Prophet (SAW). Am I right in saying you haven't even tried the sufi path but are making such claims? It's like saying pizza tastes disgusting when you haven't even tried it
@@PlayazXI
اسلام علیکم
Brother, it is an immensely huge topic. In short only way acceptable in the way of Allah-swt is that of our beloved Prophet Muhammad-saw & his-saw companion's.
All other ways/interpretations/thoughts (even with minor differences) are rejected.
Sufism was not known to Suhabas-ra.
Hope I answered your query.
Imamat continue
Prophet Muhammad (SW) told the names of his 12 Khalifas to Jabir bin Abdullah (RE): Ali bin Abu Talib, Hassan bin Ali, Hussain bin Ali, Ali bin Hussain, Muhammad bin Ali, Jaffer bin Muhammad, Mussa bin Jaffer, Ali bin Mussa, Muhammad bin Ali, Ali bin Muhammad, Hassan bin Ali and Muhammad bin Hassan and instructed him to covey His Slaam to the 5th Vicegerent Muhammad Baqar (ES) which he conveyed. "Iblees misguided everybody except a small group of the true believers (momineen)" (Surah Saba Verse-20). As such, a small group among the believers is infallible (masoom). ". . . Then We made the inheritors of Quran the chosen (mustafa) servants . . ." (Surah Faatir Verse-32). Allah bestows Slaam on the chosen (mustafa) servants (Surah an-Namal Verse-59). Therefore, the names of the chosen personalities are honored with the suffix title of Elayh Slaam and every Muslim pays Slaam on the Salayheen (pious people) during prayers. "On that day (day of resurrection), we shall call all human beings with their respective Imams. . ." (Surah al-Isra Verse-71). Therefore, so long a person exists in this world the presence of an Imam is essential! On the night of Power the angles descend therein, by the permission of their Lord with all the decrees (Surah al-Qadar Verse-4). Hence the presence of a Competent Authority (Sahib-e-Amar) is essential to whom the decrees are handed over. "Are they waiting to see if the angels come to them, or thy Lord (Himself), or certain of the signs of thy Lord! On that day when some of the signs of your Lord shall come, its faith shall not profit a soul which didn’t believe before, or earn good through its faith. Say: Wait; We too are waiting" (Surah al-An’aam Verse-158). Prophet Muhammad (SW) said, “When my 12th Khalifa will show up, Khazir and Ilyas from this world and Idrees and Eysa from the heavens will come to testify the Imamat of Muhammad al-Mehdi and Eysa will pray behind Muhammad al-Mehdi. "O you who believe! Obey Allah and obey the messenger and the Ulil Amr . . . " (Surah an-Nisaa Verse-59). Therefore, obedience of Ulil Amr is essential just like obedience of Allah and the Prophet. Ulil Amr are those vested with authority in all matters. Iblees accepted Allah but didn’t accept the superiority of His vicegerent (khalifa) then what would be the status of the person who has faith in Allah but does not accept the Imam of his time!
Alot of your information is not even true. Where are your sources. Because anyone can go around saying anything but why should anyone believe you.
Yes sir true to that May Allah protect all humans from the errors of this man or any other man Ameen, and make more and more Little Hamza yusuf and Abdullah bin Bayya and Tariq
What the hell is this guy talking about? always negative. The wahabis are a minority in the Muslim community. None of the Muslim Khalifates were wahabi- they fought against the Ottoman Khalifate.
Are you serious!? The Ottomans did not exist till hundreds of years after them?.
+Ibrahim Alwarthan he's saying the wahhabis fought the ottomans, because they did
yes before ww1 they rebelled against ottoman, and then the chain of even is extend until 1948 by the help of british thus the birth of israel.. do you know how the allied can fight in the dessert?by the help of saudi's lending their base to fight german
news flash for you wahhabies, Sultan Muhammad Al-Fatih the conqueror of Constantinople was a sufi.
So called wahabi is a British sponsored conspiracy
Sufism is not correctly followed today. The correct Sufism is that of the Great Imam Junayd and the Great Shaykh Abdul Qadir Jilani (May Allah's Mercy be on Them)
There were errors with him too. I came to know this recently
Dr.bilal Philips right
just reading these comments tells me how much I need to know about hamza yusuf, his teachings and how they've rubbed off his followers in these comments.
Tahir ul Qaadri is wrong
Why can't this guy try to teach good about Islam???? Please stop this nonsense
+Quasim Ali Brother I agree with you, this man is trying to divide us
+Quasim Ali There is absolutely nothing wrong with what Bilal Phillips says here. Unfortunately, many people take this faith that was meant to liberate the individual from the Ahbar (monastic order) and try to recreate such an order of intermediaries in Islam.
This then leads to people worshipping people
Allahu Akbar !
Remember, This Umm shall split into 73 Sects and the only successful group Shall be those who source their way of life from The Qur'an and The Sunnah Only.
To Allah we shall return for His Judgement and we won't be wronged.
Br Bilal Philips said nothing wrong.
Allah knows best !
Best scholar
*☾★* _You will surely find the most intense of the people in animosity toward the believers [to be] the Jews and those who associate others with Allah ; and you will find the nearest of them in affection to the believers those who say, "We are Christians." That is because among them are priests and monks and because they are not arrogant._ *☾★*
*☾★* _Indeed, those who have believed [in Prophet Muhammad] and those [before Him] who were Jews or Sabeans or Christians - those [among them] who believed in Allah and the Last Day and did righteousness - no fear will there be concerning them, nor will they grieve._ *☾★*
*☾★* _Say, "O People of the Scripture, you are [standing] on nothing until you uphold [the law of] the Torah, the Gospel, and what has been revealed to you from your Lord." And that which has been revealed to you from your Lord will surely increase many of them in transgression and disbelief. So do not grieve over the disbelieving people._ *☾★*
*☾★* _O you who have believed, upon you is [responsibility for] yourselves. Those who have gone astray will not harm you when you have been guided. To Allah is you return all together; then He will inform you of what you used to do._ *☾★*
Wear video NO w time