Hey, I wanted to ask if it’s OK if I use a brief clip of this excellent oscilloscope rendition of Marble Garden, in a series of videos I’m doing, it’s an educational/fun series of videos focusing on the music theory of beloved songs from Sonic games. When I use someone’s footage in my videos, I always attribute credit for the footage to that person - When the footage appears on screen during the video there is always a notation at the corner of the screen that says “Footage by TH-cam User (Name of Person).” I also include it in the list of citations in the description of the video, which also includes a link to the originating video itself. This will also appear in the list of citations on-screen at the end of the video. If you want to get a sense of the kind of videos I make and how I attribute sources, my recent video “Sonic 3’s Endless Mine: Music Theory” is a good example. Hope to hear from you! Also, thank you so much for doing these videos - they are so fantastic/interesting/helpful! Thanks! -Alex
- grassy theme - probably fastest running in the game - bouncy slappy AF bass - 12/8 swing time This might be the most Sonic-y music in the game I think
@@NinjaCacodemon_IsSus you may be right, and I freakin love that tune (and level). Both acts. I think when I say "Sonic-y" I mean something else though.
5:07 really showcases how quintessential that delay effect is to this piece. It's baffling to hear how out of place the melody sounds with just the on-beat channel playing. Really makes you appreciate the finer details the composers put into their work!
I like how channel 1 and 4 echo with each other to represent how sonic is actually on a mountain. Makes it a lot more natural. Well done SEGA. Well done.
One year later and you're 100% wrong. Just talking out of your behind. It is now confirmed thanks to Sonic origins. The tracks that were composed by Michael Jackson and Brad buckster. This song remained in the final release meaning it was not composed by those two. Ice cap zone carnival night and the mini boss music was, however.
Tbh even if it isn't official When the Sun Goes Down - Jetzons is honestly really close to a non-16Bit Marble Garden, even if it isnt actually related.
I remember having an mp3 player where i loaded the sonic 3 ost to listen to and sometimes i liked to unplug the jack a lil bit so i could hear stuff like this...
Wow! All tracks that do not include Micheal Jackson's 16 bit remixes still remain untouched especially if this current beta build was 4 months from release which is a lot, enough to edit out or have placeholders for pending music tracks
What type of synthesis is that? Sounds like fm And also the tracks have instrument interrupts, that’s awesome And also using two channels for a delay effect is genius. So full
Hey if I could make a suggestion, you should consider adding a frame of the level you're deconstructing as your video's thumbnail background. I think it'd help differentiate each one a little clearer, and it'd be helpful to people who aren't as diehard a sonic fan and can't always tell the levels apart from title alone Keep up the good work though, I'm really happy this channel's been more active recently:)
For sega, they really did their music well for sonic 3, its what i like for an echo in the game when all the other tracks are playing, always the simplest things to make an echo for the classic sonic generation 😀
I think marble garden and ice cap easily have the least interesting music in sonic 3 & knuckles. Both are just kinda bland- with the latter also having little variety in it...
Channel 0 is really what ties this song all together as one of my favorite songs on S3&K’s BEYOND fantastic soundtrack!
All Sonic soundtracks are really about DA BASS. Seems like bass is the inner soul of these songs.
Marble Garden Zone for the win!!!!😃
Act 2: Am I a joke to you?
I thought it was DAC?
@@koolaidflavas8701 nah it's channel 0
Hey, I wanted to ask if it’s OK if I use a brief clip of this excellent oscilloscope rendition of Marble Garden, in a series of videos I’m doing, it’s an educational/fun series of videos focusing on the music theory of beloved songs from Sonic games. When I use someone’s footage in my videos, I always attribute credit for the footage to that person - When the footage appears on screen during the video there is always a notation at the corner of the screen that says “Footage by TH-cam User (Name of Person).” I also include it in the list of citations in the description of the video, which also includes a link to the originating video itself. This will also appear in the list of citations on-screen at the end of the video. If you want to get a sense of the kind of videos I make and how I attribute sources, my recent video “Sonic 3’s Endless Mine: Music Theory” is a good example. Hope to hear from you!
Also, thank you so much for doing these videos - they are so fantastic/interesting/helpful!
Thanks!
-Alex
bro nice music theory
I feel like if anyone it should be Sega that you worry about for copyright reasons, sense this video is really Sega content
@@DRpotatoYT I think the content would mostly fall under fair use, but in this case it's polite to ask permission
I got into this channel thanks to you, hope you keep doing that stuff because it's great, interesting and i learn a lot of that. You are great
Ohhh snap! Love yo content
- grassy theme
- probably fastest running in the game
- bouncy slappy AF bass
- 12/8 swing time
This might be the most Sonic-y music in the game I think
Oh yeah!
8/4 …?
Actually I think Hydrocity is faster
@@DanKop2 time sig is subjective, but 8/4 doesn't make sense here. (I could be wrong)
@@NinjaCacodemon_IsSus you may be right, and I freakin love that tune (and level). Both acts.
I think when I say "Sonic-y" I mean something else though.
2:17
Look at how they do echo in the early days.
With a whole entire channel for echo
I like that little screech channels 2 and 3 do. No seriously it's IMMACULATE
so fucking true champ
I LOVE THAT LITTLE SCREECH TOO!!!!
I always love the DAC in every song
@Wishful Thinker Yeah.
@Wishful Thinker Is that a problem?
we all love DAC and CH1 Combo
@Techful I don't see how that's a problem
2:32 This little marimba melody makes me love this song even more
My heart melted when I heard Channel 1 by itself 1:42
It kinda sounds like the level into on Aladdin.
@@JOEY22445 sorta
The treeeeng
@@alcumezuke4949 literally
Literally my favorite part
5:07 really showcases how quintessential that delay effect is to this piece. It's baffling to hear how out of place the melody sounds with just the on-beat channel playing. Really makes you appreciate the finer details the composers put into their work!
6:42 - 6:57 i can not put into words how much i love this part of the song
Same
It'd be great if you added a timer that shows when the music loops
Without that echo it just sounds so lifeless.
1:32 2:32 5:31 6:31
A song that is so simple became so iconic, such is the basis for most of Sonic's early music. Because simple gets the job done.
It's so simple yet it ties up one of my FAVOURITE zones in Sonic 3 and possibly my top 3 favourite zones of all time
THIS ZONE IS YOUR FAVORITE?!?! I mean, it's fine but, favorite?
@@jordancooney6817 You say that as if it’s not one of the best in the game lol. Shits underrated af
@@CoalWurld When I think favorite, I think Hydrocity, Mushroom Hill, Ice Cap, and Flying Battery.
@@jordancooney6817 Marble Garden is at least top 5 imo
@@CoalWurld Well, you do you.
The DAC channel is so 😩👌
1:43 it's so cool how it starts off square and morphs into a sine wave. such a cool effect!
Sega was like “Nah We Going With No PSG’s” and still made it a banger!
Nobody:
Bass drum: Tri-puh-let-ta
Played Sonic 3 on my stream today and played this for a while during intermission. Thanks carp
These videos are seriously satisfying to listen to, especially when one-by-one each track comes in until the whole song is complete. Love your work!
I was humming the bassline through the whole song
Channels 2 and 3 remind me of the GEMS twang sound
bruh wat it does sound like spinball
I like how channel 1 and 4 echo with each other to represent how sonic is actually on a mountain. Makes it a lot more natural. Well done SEGA. Well done.
2:58 aww yeah
0:42 I love this part so much
0:42 my favorite part
Só cool
LoL
I think this is the only song in the classic Sonic games that doesn’t use the PSG channels.
Flying Battery 1 and 2 both don't use PSG
0:06 i got chills at the WOOAARRWWRGGG
Cause this is THRILLER!
THRILLER GARDEN! V1
5:58 EVERYBODY NOW!
Everyone can't hold it back whenever anyone hears these songs and can't stop singing
Love how the bass seems to be the same as the Rusty Ruin, Gene Gadget and other but with a different shape at the note's "activation" time
I do like how there's an extra bit at the end of Channels 2 and 3 after the first part.
So it turns out by making a good song, all you need is drums and bass....
Ok
Marble Garden is my fav zone is S3 its just so epic
2:58 this is where it Gets serious 😁
This track is a bit of an outlier really. It's a different style to all of the other songs in the game
One of my fave songs
Is that a harmonica on channel 1? Cool, huh? Some instruments seem to hold better on their own than along with the other ones.
Everyone gangsta when the DAC and Channel 0 comes in.
(Notice how I didn't use "until".)
That was funny 💀
sorry, you just lost your like
oh god
You don't like it?
it wouldve been funny if you said until.
Bro, this song just screams Michael Jackson
sadly it probably wasn't Jackson
One year later and you're 100% wrong. Just talking out of your behind. It is now confirmed thanks to Sonic origins. The tracks that were composed by Michael Jackson and Brad buckster. This song remained in the final release meaning it was not composed by those two. Ice cap zone carnival night and the mini boss music was, however.
Tbh even if it isn't official When the Sun Goes Down - Jetzons is honestly really close to a non-16Bit Marble Garden, even if it isnt actually related.
Lets be honest DAC and CH1 combined is the best
But in the Marble Garden's case, Channel 1 isn't the bassline.
I could listen to just the rhythm section of this song for hours
Channel 0 (or 1) and DAC are the life of the party.
i swear this is the most underrated song in 3K’s soundtrack.
Not really. It's the weakest track in s3&k.
Strangely, the pc port actually makes marble garden... Better.
I remember having an mp3 player where i loaded the sonic 3 ost to listen to and sometimes i liked to unplug the jack a lil bit so i could hear stuff like this...
Also I think this is the only game where the music loops completely with the intro. There were only a few songs from the first 2 games that did this.
Wow! All tracks that do not include Micheal Jackson's 16 bit remixes still remain untouched especially if this current beta build was 4 months from release which is a lot, enough to edit out or have placeholders for pending music tracks
I don't think this video is a deconstruction of a music track from the prototype, though.
This is from the final version though.
Joan Cruz exactly
Naean Howlett-Foster then why u here
I think they put in the Michael Jackson music at the last minute because they were like "well we have this music, might as well use it"
0:01 Ch2, Ch3
1:07 Ch1
2:08 Ch1, Ch4
2:58 Ch0, DAC
3:58 Ch2, Ch3, Ch0, DAC
5:07 Ch1, Ch2, Ch3, Ch0, DAC
5:58 EVERYTHING
What's your favourite part? Mine: I don't really have a favourite part
What type of synthesis is that? Sounds like fm
And also the tracks have instrument interrupts, that’s awesome
And also using two channels for a delay effect is genius. So full
The Genesis/Mega Drive uses FM synthesis.
Khairi Hamed fm is amazing, it’s my fave tied with additive
@@KhairiHamedYM2612: I’ll Wait
0:05 Something about how the soundwaves transform here
Hey if I could make a suggestion, you should consider adding a frame of the level you're deconstructing as your video's thumbnail background. I think it'd help differentiate each one a little clearer, and it'd be helpful to people who aren't as diehard a sonic fan and can't always tell the levels apart from title alone
Keep up the good work though, I'm really happy this channel's been more active recently:)
For sega, they really did their music well for sonic 3, its what i like for an echo in the game when all the other tracks are playing, always the simplest things to make an echo for the classic sonic generation 😀
is it my impression or does the music change the tone between the cell phone and the computer?
I believe it's due to the speakers being different, sorry i'm a year late
Channel 2 and 3 going crazy
I like this zone
Jurassic Park 3 (2001) Marble Garden Zone
Channel 4 is like that annoying kid that says and does everything you do just to be like “yeah I was already gonna do that, uh huh” lol 😆
Cool
🌄 When the sun goes down...
One of my favs thanks bro 😁
thank you...
Channel 0 and DAC are the best
ah i remember when i was young and I couldn't beat the level, now I can just fly with ease with hyper sonic c;
Chanel 0 is my favorite AND 3 AND 4
I GOTTA KNOW
WHO TAKES A LIIIIIFE FOR FREEEEE
what r u refrencing
Some kind of man.
I know would tell her openly
echoes? in all s3&k zones?
2:58 the breakdown
First 100th like cuz I like marble garden zone 👌
What is channel 0 instrument
It's supposed to be the bass
@@Mimiiii_VEV0 well the song hits hard with it
3:41
Welcome to perfect 4ths: the song
2 and 3 always get in this song
How you deconstruct advance music?
Wait this song doesn't use the 4 Channels in the Master System audio chip?
act 2 please
DAC? You mean "PCM (sampled) track," right? The DAC is just a component to the system.
Everyone refers to it as DAC for some reason. Knowing the difference between pcm and dac would be interesting for me though
20:34
19K
nice...!!
Yoo u should do an oscilloscope of this but with reverse frequencies lol
Da best
🤗👍👏
708
I kind of like the echo of channel 1
The echo completes it for me
The echo of channel 1 is channel 4
what the hell is an oscilloscope deconstruction
just watch the video, it's hella self explanatory
Is it even remotely possible to deconstruct Undertale music?
Probably not, unless Toby released the original midi file and samples that he used. Kinda unlikely tho.
No, because its not a file with coded music, its just mp3, not vgm
@@AskYourStupidQuestions huh. Ok
I think marble garden and ice cap easily have the least interesting music in sonic 3 & knuckles. Both are just kinda bland- with the latter also having little variety in it...
Second to come
I hate marble gardens it's so boring the only thing I'm interested is channel 1 and channel 4
Behold, the weakest track in s3&k.
First dislike cuz I hate marble garden
No u
Have fun in robotnikland
Wow rude go to hell marble garden may suck but Micheal Jaxon doesn't.
Go to hell everybody likes marble garden's song. But when you say the zone layout is trash, then youre true.
@@eidisa dude this was a year ago and I hate the layout