I have listened to this for 3 days straight (every day at least a few times) - I will tell you how INCREDIBLE and inspired i am about these individuals: 1) They have PASSION. It is one of the most beautiful passions i could witness. Very well made by the team, well done. 2) The SINGER is actually reading and PERFECTLY pronounced all the words CORRECTLY. My sincere applause and salutes.
What beautiful music!!! I admire you all. I don't speak read nor write Mandarin Chinese but I love listening to it. Not to take away from Steve Chou's talent but you guys have made this song even better with so much soul and emotions in your angelic voice. Its like you made a new version of this beautiful love song. All of you have incredible voices but I have to say Security Guard is my favorite. Sorry I don't know your names yet. I will soon. But Securty Guard voice reminds me of an very popular RB artist named Babyface. He's like a Mandarin Babyface. Keep up this great work!
It's a beautiful thing to see African and Chinese Culture integrated with each other. BaoAn has a wonderful voice and his voice is more suitable with Chinese Songs than English songs.
I don't understand Mandarin, but I'm here to listen to this beautiful masterpiece. Can you guys do an interview on where you learned Chinese and how you got into singing it, in English so those of us who do not speak Chinese can learn more about your group. Amazing!
If you want to sing Chinese songs, you need only take one week learn pinyin, Mandarin has a total of 23 initial consonants and 24 finals. When you can pronounce these 47 sounds correctly, you can sing all Chinese songs. Don't worry about the difficulty of pinyin, because it is composed of Roman letters just like English.
@tobe1368 1.5 billion people understand Mandarin 120 million people understand Sichuan dialect 85 million people understand Cantonese 50 million people understand Hokkien
Hokkian is a one of the hundreds of dialects in China, mainly spoken in Fujian Prov. as well as Taiwan, and it sounds so distinctive that is like a foreign language to most Chinese who don't live in Fujian Prov. @tobe1368
一個非洲朋友能把中文歌唱得這麼標準這麼生動感人!! 真的是非常不簡單!! 由衷地佩服讚賞!!
音樂是不分國界的
有没有可能歌词不是他写的
@@TimiOfDaVoid這裡沒在講歌詞誰寫，是說他唱得好
一堆非州黑鬼在中國留學呢 而且福利比自家人好千萬倍
？？？？？？人家有说歌词是他写的了吗@@TimiOfDaVoid
這聲線，這情感，絕對是一絕，他比時下很多歌手都棒，服了。
我觉得对外国人而言，最难的不是发音标准，大家之所以认为他唱的非常好，很重要的原因是，他完全理解了歌词内容，所有的技巧都为表达的情感服务，一点不感觉炫技，这是优秀歌手的特征
你又懂了！
看神情确实有点这个意味
中國在非洲開發很久了,很多非洲人會講流利中文, 他們如果知道歌詞內容並不奇怪
你说的没错。一个歌如果要把那个情感发展出来，一定要先懂歌词在讲什么。他肯定是做很多年的功课，做很多年的读书，才会唱得那么顺利。要当一个很好的歌手，一定要先当一个很好的学生
声卡音响很重要，肤色又有优势
Not only he can sing in Chinese, the emotions he brought into the performance is amazing! ❤👍
Music is one of the few things along with food that can easily transcend barriers
音樂無國界、無時空。
@@changsue8215 Yes, music is an universal language, no boundarty
They make me crying
His singing is better than the original, the original female is kinda not too clear in pronunciation
保安把這首黃昏的意境表達的淋漓盡致，甚至於讓聽者進入到更深的世界裡面。很厲害👍
他的聲線就是那麼的獨特有磁性，聽他唱歌，絕對是聽視最頂級的享受。
她能找到你吗
這保全不去當歌星，真是太屈才了。😊😊👍👍
现在就是民间歌手啊哈哈
我的天， 这可以出唱片了吧！ 这种水平比专业还专业。
有一種特別的韻味，屬於這位保安小哥的歌聲中的特色，他把這首歌曲，詮釋得非常到味，很耐聽的聲線，渾厚、深情、傷感又浪漫。
我是香港人，唱這歌， 演繹好幾次，無一次都跟不上曲詞表達方式，我身為華人，有點慚愧😅 謝謝你們努力演出，歌聲無國界🤝 願世界表現和平❤
面對現實吧，很少中國人能唱到這個水平.
我更惭愧。。。 我唱歌都跑调
音准是一种天赋，很多人经过专门的训练，能达到一定的准确度
無一次不，双重否定表肯定，等价于每一次都，此处应该改成每一次都跟不上曲詞表達方式
true
保安唱什麼歌都好聽，因為他很認真，且音樂天分很高，其它2位伙伴也很優，天熱了，較擔心他曬黑皮膚久老化病變及眼晴的傷害，在空內唱也不錯
這位小姐，他們皮膚黑是因為人種基因，是天生的，不是太陽曬黑的啦！😂😂😂😂😂
這位小姐，他們不是在外太空唱，是在地球的另一隅.
無知才是最可怕的
比无知更可怕的是无知而不自知。
這一看就是反串的啦😂😂😂
唱得非常好聽，咬字很清晰，重點是情感很到位，最難能可貴的是 您們知道並能理解 每一句歌詞在表達什麼，聽完整首歌後，超感動！😭😭😭
这哥们在中国是很红的，少说也有数百万粉丝，所有平台加起来估计能过千万
他們不懂歌詞啦
@@彭大鵰 Nonsense
@@彭大鵰 除了炫技，我也聽不出其中有感情，可能就是不完全懂歌詞的關係，跟這位女孩子比差多了 !
th-cam.com/video/fSjAyvVu4A4/w-d-xo.html
@@alpa1287我聽不出這兩個白人女孩唱歌有什麼感情，就是美聲二人組而已，沒結婚數十年，不會知道身為「家後」的付出與犧牲的。
th-cam.com/video/fSjAyvVu4A4/w-d-xo.html
反之，這個頻道的保安和他的同伴們，唱歌有靈魂。
生活順遂的人唱歌很難唱出真感情。
保安的歌唱技巧非常一流，懂得在歌曲的适当部份加上R&B 唱技，使原曲变得更加生动和感性。
異鄉的國度,熟悉的語言,豪邁的歌聲,簡單的電子琴,詮釋一首經典歌曲~~
聽保安唱歌太感動了， 眼淚都要掉下來❤ 加油！
保安年輕輕輕就能唱出滄桑感十足的黃昏不是每個會唱歌的人都能辦到只可以說他是天生唱歌的好材料..加油!
太幸運了，願望成真，保安超會唱，把黃昏唱成自己的歌了，超好聽！感謝波波團隊！
被你说点子上了，我听过保安再去听原唱（以前没听过）觉得肯定是翻唱🤣
@@fotosapient 這是翻唱的沒錯，但這首歌，他唱出和原唱不同的感覺，就像是他自己的歌一樣。
渾然天成的天份和持續的努力，很棒的表演❤❤❤
Pure and clear. How I wish the river being the same.
@@equalrights9091yellow river flowing slowly matches the music well
我深深地喜歡這首歌。
聽到我眼水都出來了。唱得好有感情。好好聽！Sang with feelings!!! My tears came out… 😮😮😮🥲😭😭😭👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
不急不缓，声声深深出自心屝。
好一首与众不同的黄昏，听着保安的歌声一起消失在黄昏的地平线，回味无穷！
這也太好聽了吧愛了愛了 願看到這條評論的人身材變瘦，痘痘會慢慢消下去，皮膚會變白，吃多不長肥肉，你/妳喜歡的人會向你/妳表白，身邊在乎的人健康平安，而你/妳會人想事成，還會暴富變美💙💙❤❤
千言万语汇成一个字：赞
I'm Chinese and I love your understanding of the emotion, your amazing singing skills and your great sense of musicality ❤
I have listened to this for 3 days straight (every day at least a few times) - I will tell you how INCREDIBLE and inspired i am about these individuals: 1) They have PASSION. It is one of the most beautiful passions i could witness. Very well made by the team, well done. 2) The SINGER is actually reading and PERFECTLY pronounced all the words CORRECTLY. My sincere applause and salutes.
lol same i keep repeating this song
保安真係唱得太好了！他学中文咁短時間都可以字正腔圓，太棒了👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
保安如唱一下廣東話歌必定多几万個以上subscribers and even more fans. He should be able to do as he is so talented.
音乐，可以是美丽的音符，也可以是奋斗的号角。向那些唱着歌、负着重前行的人们致敬！
觉得保安唱每首歌时都很享受，被自己唱的歌曲所打动。我被他的这种歌声感动，所以不时回顾，百听不厌。
這歌曲真的很棒！聽了感覺心靈全被滋養，心情也舒心了起來…快樂的時候 聽的是歌曲。
唱不完的一首歌~~~那尾音,唱得太棒了! 實力派歌手才這種技巧!
保安唱中文歌曲真的很到位、控制 力度一樣到位、唱英文歌曲一定紅半天、如果來台灣一定紅、沒人能比、聽他的歌 是一種享受、也很感動、真希望他能來台灣
我也希望他能來
千万别。我们好不容易有个非洲朋友会唱歌， 是宝贝！去了台湾，万一支持台独。被政府禁了。那就苦了歌迷聊
@@DrLove-v1v 也是😂
本来就是
唱中文歌就已很棒很紅了，為何唱英文才會紅？
靜聽這歌，好好享受著不同的唱法，真是感謝了
Beautiful song beautiful ohhhhhhhhhhhhh beautiful 😊simple a great performance.... beautiful, BR Pernambuco 🎉
Thank you TH-cam for introducing these wonderful artistes. Love from South East Asia.
歌聲十分有磁性，咬字清楚，真厲害。
The last sentence was repeated several times it shows he is not able to make up his love .
好喜歡保安
保安保安....1級棒....
保安嗓音穿透力太强了！必须来中国巡演兄弟！😍
Good job guys! Didn't expect you to sing in Chinese, simply a great performance. Respect!
Thanks! You all have amazing voices. This is one of my most favourite mandarin songs.
很久沒有聽到這麼特別嗓音，會讓人想要一直聽下去
不同國籍，卻能唱進心裡
真的超厲害😊
聽來聽去還是台灣的歌最對味
@@buffetonly93 臺灣就是中國的省，中國歌曲沒錯。
@@myriamfelix5798 建議中國人回家做夢吧，夢裡什麼都有。
打開電視接受洗腦教育吧！可憐的國家啊
@@myriamfelix5798 對，中華民國
@@geminiming0524 沒錯!
這歌保安唱得太棒了，为你点赞👍👍👍👍👍
保安，你好。作为一名在国外打拼的中国人， 我很为你的歌声感动。向你们的团队致敬。你很有天赋，希望你能像波波说的那样，好好学习中文，用自己的才能改变命运。说实话，很多现在看似不可能的事情将来也许都会出现。我都能想象哪天你会和波波的团队一起被邀请到中国的哪家卫视电视台参加演出。中国人尊敬努力奋斗的人，但是也鄙视飞黄腾达后骄傲自满的人。希望你不忘初心，努力为你和你的家人创造美好的生活。
多唱点大陆的歌，或者参加汉语桥比赛啥的
你的评论很中肯 赞同
什麼時候是中國人了？
@@EddieHsu-o6p Jay 君是在说他自己是个在外打拼的中国人！😂
不愧是力宏，閱讀能力真的非常奇葩
一聽就著迷，保安的歌聲太有感覺，厲害！
Omg WOW!!! Even though I'm not Chinese, but I can definitely feel this.
保安唱的每一首歌 一聽在聽都不會膩
天籟！保安小哥 百年難得一見的歌聲 ❤保安的鐵粉 Greetings from Germany 🙌
妙！和周传雄的完全不同。没有那种颓废的感觉，但是又保留了淡淡的忧伤，然后还有些异域风味。保安这个控制力度很到位👍
+1
+3
😅😅
+7
不少人唱這首歌，除了小剛就只有保安哥最觸動人心...
嘩一聲 ! 以翻唱嚟講, 保安哥真系唱得非常好 ! 幾乎要超越原唱 ! 再加上取景, 拍攝等都系一流 ! 偑服 !!! 👍👍👍👍👍👍
Excellent performance. His voice carried the emotion of the lyric, he truly understands the sadness of the words. 佩服!
保安的唱歌技巧超棒!❤👍😃
太強大了!! 不同味道的黃昏~~有種在黃昏夕陽中吹薩克斯風的感覺
才一天多就已經4.5萬點閱了，相信這首很快可以成為頻道最夯的歌，保安太棒了
What beautiful music!!! I admire you all. I don't speak read nor write Mandarin Chinese but I love listening to it. Not to take away from Steve Chou's talent but you guys have made this song even better with so much soul and emotions in your angelic voice. Its like you made a new version of this beautiful love song. All of you have incredible voices but I have to say Security Guard is my favorite. Sorry I don't know your names yet. I will soon. But Securty Guard voice reminds me of an very popular RB artist named Babyface. He's like a Mandarin Babyface. Keep up this great work!
特别喜欢保安唱歌，人朴实表情丰富支持点赞👍
有一天 波波的 歌唱團 到台灣 我在美國一定回台灣 去看他們 一定要給他們親一口 太努力的太努力了 有前途的遺傳 謝謝你們 thank you for SharePoint love
保安唱的真好聽真有天分。
黃昏R&B版，真是新奇👍😘
我的天，唱得真好，听我一身鸡皮疙瘩！
音色属于典型的黑人厚嗓型，而周传雄的声音更像典型中国流行乐的轻薄型，各有千秋，不觉得哪一种一定更优。另外，后面的R&B类似的转音不太适合一首伤痛流行歌曲，因为这样会显得演唱有点“油”。伤痛情绪容易出戏。当然保安的歌声在其他地方都充满感情，深得原唱精髓，仍是我最喜欢的翻唱之一。
保安哥唱的很好，只是缺了一個好的經紀人，能讓他上舞台，登台唱是大不同的，願上帝給他個好機會吧！
滄桑感十足的黑人保安唱黃昏非常好聽！！！加油！！
Wow! Voice of angel!
So much soul, extraordinary especially in a foreign language. Love love love, bravo! Strength, tenderness, roundedness, absolutely superb!
哇塞是黃昏😮😮😮
我最愛的一首歌😊😊😊
拜託保安趕快去參加選秀比賽！！！
无意间听见就停不下来了，好听！
这个保安歌绝了！唱出与小刚完全不同的感觉，而且更好听！
比原唱更好听！
The accent still there but it makes this song unique in a different way, very nice.
感同身受，用心倾听..
I was waiting to see if this song will be covered. Yay! 保安哥好正！
終於唱了黃昏這首超級經典老歌了！
很喜歡保安的歌聲❤️❤️❤️
great singing, some blues vibe and jazz style. fabulous
最喜欢的这首歌曲。赞👍🎉
Amazing voice. I was listening to you but watching the lady I was not sure what she was doing.
nobody knows,
Wahahaha 😂🤣 I was thinking the same 😂
非常好听!
你的聲音已經完勝大多台灣歌手 你們就像台灣原住民 你們的聲線 深不可測 耐聽 好聽 持續聽
😅😅😅
人家用的是简中
win！❤
？？？
尴尬不。。。
已經很久沒有聽到這麼好的歌聲了，
Bravo,👏👏👍👍thanks for your singing and sharing your music with us. Keep up the amazing singing.
咬音不准完全不是問題，因為我是中國人，我完全知道歌詞，完全知道歌詞的意涵，驚艷和癡醉的是你們的聲線和演繹，完全撕裂了我封閉的回憶和穿透了我的心，竟然會聽哭了
歌聲有種感動人靈魂的力量，非洲小哥，天生的歌者
天賦美聲的保安、歌唱前途無限量、若也用心唱英文歌曲、不得了、會成明日巨星啊！❤👍👍👍🌟🌟🌟👏👏👏
真的厲害。連情感都很到位。周是快天黑的傷。小哥是剛黃昏的單單思念
excellent guy，excellent job.
💯👍Wow… What a beautiful cover. Just amazing!❤👍
唱的真好聽，繼續聽歌中
在非洲土生土長，只練幾個月中文的保安，竟然能把中文歌曲 唱到這個程度.... 這可讓華人歌手 聽了都汗顏.... 👍👍😀😀😎
这是天生的天赋，天生就是一副好嗓子，不仅唱国语歌，英文也很好，那有什么好羞耻的，国内的词曲作者应该请他来教歌更好
在山口洋，有很多会说客家话的民族，但在中华人民共和国的原籍国，很多人可能已经不会说客家话了，这就是为什么文化生活在不断变化的原因。
老天赏他吃这碗饭，天生的歌者👍
@@borneoman7729 是的，除了你这憨逼不变
保安小哥是非洲歌神。
天生的歌手啊，尾音交代的很清楚，轉音自然優美，中文咬字也很清晰👍
天才的歌手。
That's a Man singing..... Why are you calling him...... A her....!!!
Bravo !! Bravo !!! You successfully & emotionally interpreted this beautiful song !! Very well done !!
無論旋律和歌詞都非常美 , 唱的太好听了。歌词太有意思了，这个思念真的好感动啊。加上動人心魄的歌聲 , 循環了不知多少次 。加上背景制作精美 , 真的是視聽一流享受！👍
这位老外唱中文歌好听,唱腔歌词他掌控很好👍
用心用感情在唱歌並不是在賣弄技巧，這樣的歌聽來格外感動人！❤🎉👍
黃昏這首歌你唱得到，就是你什麼歌都唱的到👍👍
It's a beautiful thing to see African and Chinese Culture integrated with each other. BaoAn has a wonderful voice and his voice is more suitable with Chinese Songs than English songs.
Pure musical talent and linguistic aptitude on display. Bravo. I am jealous! Love from Canada!
好听，唱的很有感情
歌聲渾厚，超強穿透力！
Very pretty songs
You all 3 people did very good job…😃👏👏❤️❤️
Thank you so much
比我唱得好
唱出真感情。。👍👍👍
I don't understand Mandarin, but I'm here to listen to this beautiful masterpiece. Can you guys do an interview on where you learned Chinese and how you got into singing it, in English so those of us who do not speak Chinese can learn more about your group. Amazing!
If you want to sing Chinese songs, you need only take one week learn pinyin, Mandarin has a total of 23 initial consonants and 24 finals. When you can pronounce these 47 sounds correctly, you can sing all Chinese songs. Don't worry about the difficulty of pinyin, because it is composed of Roman letters just like English.
@tobe1368 1.5 billion people understand Mandarin
120 million people understand Sichuan dialect
85 million people understand Cantonese
50 million people understand Hokkien
Hokkian is a one of the hundreds of dialects in China, mainly spoken in Fujian Prov. as well as Taiwan, and it sounds so distinctive that is like a foreign language to most Chinese who don't live in Fujian Prov. @tobe1368
I learned that they had studied Mandarin in Confucius Institute in their own country, the Chinese equivalent to British Council. 😂
用真诚来歌唱，那一定是能打动人心的！