Thinking back, I think Friendship is one of the biggest motifs in PBFB. It's one of the most powerful things that permeates though the project, and I think... it may be a big part of my personal obsession with it that I could never fully explain.
I don't think you should ever believe you aren't a great filmmaker. You just made a short day in real-life feel like the premise of an oscar-winning movie. I'm not even gonna lie that your perfect editing made me cry a little. I think if anything this week would have shown you that everyone can get somewhere in life with amazing friends and a little bit of comedy.
You would probably not believe how much these videos actually mean to a lot of people here on youtube around the world. Only heartless people would dislike this video and no one has disliked it. You are an amazing film maker. I also cried a little at this video. Bing you should be proud!
+Charlie Walker Every time I come back to these videos I say to myself "I shouln't do thiiisssss" because I know I'l just get upset and go into deep thought about how much I loved PBFB. I'll never forget it.
Seeing you with your friends, having a great time, always reminds me of how much I love my friends, and of all the amazing times we've had. Thanks Bing. RIP Edd.
This short film/vlog/video diary gave me such a bittersweet feeling, life sucks sometimes, but it can also be so beautiful. I think Past Bing / Future Bing will continue to inspire and affect people for a long time after it's finished. It's definitely one of those beautiful things!
This project just gets deeper and deeper, you know what I mean? It feels like we're getting to know Bing better than we ever did, little by little. Every day I look foward to watching PBFP and I love him even more with every video. Surely I'm not the only one who feels like this?
I'm so glad no-one disliked this, iut is so brilliantly moving and is just, in an alternative way, showing people mourning their lost friend, if anyone could possibly dislike this im sure they don't have a heart.
I can't describe how sorry I am for your loss. But I also can't describe how glad I am to see all of you holding up, and smiling, and getting together. It's truly, amazing.
Bing, You have a way of showing us things in a way that shows so much by saying so little. The times you do speak it makes us laugh and makes us think. It is poignant, like a omniscient narrator telling us all we wanted to know, but it is videos like this that makes me love what you do. Where we see not from your eyes, but from the world around you. We see you like others see you. You do not have a act, or a bit. You are who you are and you tell it how it is. You are an inspiration, thank you.
Thank you for this goodbye video, Bing. This is probably my favorite video you've ever filmed just because it is so real and true. Proper right job, mate. Good bye, Edd. We'll all see you soon. Keep a close watch up there for us.
I lost my mum recently, and I'm not really sure how to put this, but thank you, Bing. Really thank you, you've managed to create a video that strengthens how fantastic is it to have friends when you're a dealing with something so difficult. :)
i think this shows how everyone is feeling about edd. this is truly an amazing video with amazing people in it. it's good to see bing and everyone els still support each other through tis very difficult stage in their life. THANK YOU EDD FOR YOUR AMAZING VID'S AND FOR BEING YOURSELF!!!! I LOVE YOU!!!!
this made me teary. it must be an unreal week and I hope all gets better for you. you all say very little but we know what your thinking. love you bing! and everyone else too
this week edd has shown me that you can do whatever you love and not let anything get in your way. He created sketches he enjoyed, never once complained and showed us all that he had overcome his cancer, no matter what the doctors said. rip edd gould, you will be forever missed!
My goodness, I just don't have any words to describe how much I admire your friendships. My closest friends are ones I met through the internet so I can't hang out with them like this. You are very lucky
Bing is so good at making short, minutes long videos that make you feel like you've watched this amazing, [quote, unquote] feel good, summer, 80's, hipster movie. (y)
This is by far my favourite video you have ever done. The peacefulness and just atmosphere you created with a) the music and b) the choice in clips you shot compliment and portray your lives so perfectly. Watching this just makes me feel you are an amazing group of friends, so full of life and laughter. I am very jealous of you guys, but its nice to know I'm sort of half friends with some of you :) I look forward to seeing you again at MCM my friend. Any preference to cereal bar this time? XD
Im sobbing and Im not quite sure why. I have watched maybe 2 off Edds video, but this moves me so much. This makes me love my friends even more. RIP Edd.
Best wishes to you bing in the time to come. Just know that you're still making someone's day better by uploading your awesome videos. Wether they are about fun things, absurd things or things no one wishes to go through. I really enjoy your work. So.. Thanks for being you. :)
Having been through this myself I know that nothing I can say will take anything from this horrible moment, but nevertheless my thoughts and prayers are with you all in this tough time
This was seriously beautiful Bing. I actually started to choke up. I don't know if it was the song, or the emotion I was getting from the video or what. But this was amazing. Keep up the awesome work
I hope you mean that it's making us all feel sad again. With a lyric like: 'Crying out in anger at a life that had to end' describes what i've felt like recently.
It's always nice to hang out with friends! I hope you're feeling a bit better than you did earlier this week:) also I liked your patch up for yesterday it worked nicely..you didn't catalogue your past bing videos?
I had an awesome day like this with my friends today after a rough patch... It was much needed so I can def understand why you would want to film this to save for later! It's currently almost 2:30 AM and I'm still a lil drunk... Aka perfect night!!!!
since i was older than 6 there have only been two things that have made me cry, in the first pokemon movie when ash turned to stone and this video. I didn't know Edd but regardless i would not be where i am today/ on the parth i am on without him. Wherever you are Edd you change lives.
If anything, the music is deliberate upon the subject. Presumably filmed a week after his passing, they were clearly all remembering him, especially at the end, and as bradboy98 said: 'crying out in anger at a life that had to end'. It shows they're all upset that Edd's life has been cut short. It's not supposed to be negative, it's put into contrast with their smiles and laughter that we see throughout the video.
somehow, it all settled down with you guys and this fire in the end. thank you, for being so honest. i miss edd and would try to to compensate in a similar way as you guys. brushfire fairytales, i like you guys a lot!
I took your awesome idea and started a blog where I post every other day and they'll be released in 10 years where I reply to them. I love your videos, they very meaningful!!
Let's sum up this week: Two very well-known Newgrounds animators died, one lesser known Newgrounds animator died, new video game consoles were rumored, and there is an astonishing lack of movies being shown in the theater. Oh, and my favorite band is recording new music. Really a weird week.
Randy Solem and Luccas Bode. Randy Solem set the trend of animating with video game sprites, Luccas Bode was some obscure 3D animator. Randy died of heart problems. Luccas died of multiple organ failures.
When I grow up i wanna find someone like Bing. You guys are all awesome. I don't have friends as good as that either. So brave, all of you. Sorry if this doesn't make much sense, blame Baileys and its beautiful creamy-ness. It's so creamy, 'n beige
It's called 'Giving In' - I wrote it, and I'm so honoured that it became a part of this.
there is really no emotion that can sum watching this other than sadness. :(
he will be missed...
Thinking back, I think Friendship is one of the biggest motifs in PBFB. It's one of the most powerful things that permeates though the project, and I think... it may be a big part of my personal obsession with it that I could never fully explain.
I love you Jamie for that incredible Woody Allen impression
I still come back to this and even though it was a sad time, it's still my most favourite PBFB. It's so real and just feel good for the most part.
I don't think you should ever believe you aren't a great filmmaker. You just made a short day in real-life feel like the premise of an oscar-winning movie. I'm not even gonna lie that your perfect editing made me cry a little. I think if anything this week would have shown you that everyone can get somewhere in life with amazing friends and a little bit of comedy.
You would probably not believe how much these videos actually mean to a lot of people here on youtube around the world. Only heartless people would dislike this video and no one has disliked it. You are an amazing film maker. I also cried a little at this video. Bing you should be proud!
I've come back from when I watched this 3 years ago and this is still my favourite video on TH-cam.
+Charlie Walker Every time I come back to these videos I say to myself "I shouln't do thiiisssss" because I know I'l just get upset and go into deep thought about how much I loved PBFB. I'll never forget it.
Seeing you with your friends, having a great time, always reminds me of how much I love my friends, and of all the amazing times we've had. Thanks Bing. RIP Edd.
Can't stop watching this. It's such a beautiful piece of recording, really gets to me every time.
This short film/vlog/video diary gave me such a bittersweet feeling, life sucks sometimes, but it can also be so beautiful. I think Past Bing / Future Bing will continue to inspire and affect people for a long time after it's finished. It's definitely one of those beautiful things!
This project just gets deeper and deeper, you know what I mean? It feels like we're getting to know Bing better than we ever did, little by little. Every day I look foward to watching PBFP and I love him even more with every video.
Surely I'm not the only one who feels like this?
I still come back to this video every now and then.
I'm so glad no-one disliked this, iut is so brilliantly moving and is just, in an alternative way, showing people mourning their lost friend, if anyone could possibly dislike this im sure they don't have a heart.
I can't describe how sorry I am for your loss. But I also can't describe how glad I am to see all of you holding up, and smiling, and getting together.
It's truly, amazing.
Bing,
You have a way of showing us things in a way that shows so much by saying so little. The times you do speak it makes us laugh and makes us think. It is poignant, like a omniscient narrator telling us all we wanted to know, but it is videos like this that makes me love what you do. Where we see not from your eyes, but from the world around you. We see you like others see you. You do not have a act, or a bit. You are who you are and you tell it how it is. You are an inspiration, thank you.
Thank you for this goodbye video, Bing. This is probably my favorite video you've ever filmed just because it is so real and true. Proper right job, mate. Good bye, Edd. We'll all see you soon. Keep a close watch up there for us.
Such a beautiful video. The song just captures the mood so well.
This is my favorite PBFB video. I've watched it again nearly every year since it came out. Rest in peace, Edd.
I lost my mum recently, and I'm not really sure how to put this, but thank you, Bing. Really thank you, you've managed to create a video that strengthens how fantastic is it to have friends when you're a dealing with something so difficult. :)
Beautiful. This is why I love this series. Liked and faved.
fell in love with the song used in this video and searched everywhere until I found it. such a beautiful song.
Its good to see everyone smiling and having fun after recent events, awesome vid
Sometimes I forget Bing is a real person and not just some guy on youtube. This was a good reminder.
me too i felt the same way, like there was some sort of sadness in the air but seeing them all smile made me happy
i think this shows how everyone is feeling about edd. this is truly an amazing video with amazing people in it. it's good to see bing and everyone els still support each other through tis very difficult stage in their life. THANK YOU EDD FOR YOUR AMAZING VID'S AND FOR BEING YOURSELF!!!! I LOVE YOU!!!!
this made me teary. it must be an unreal week and I hope all gets better for you. you all say very little but we know what your thinking. love you bing! and everyone else too
i really enjoyed this video. it reminds me of all my friends and me. i need to get them all together again. thanks bing.
Its nice to see you are all dealing with it with a smile as like the description says it has been a weird week. Take it easy Bing and gang :)
I have a million things I want to say but not a single way to say them. Just know that you, and these videos you make, mean so much to me.
this week edd has shown me that you can do whatever you love and not let anything get in your way. He created sketches he enjoyed, never once complained and showed us all that he had overcome his cancer, no matter what the doctors said. rip edd gould, you will be forever missed!
this is a pbfb video that I always come back to.
So nice.
Without the music it wouldn't be as emotional.
This made me feel a lot of emotions that I didn't know existed let alone had words for.
That was really sweet. Made me weirdly happy and teary at the same time
Because TH-cam has that light switch now, I flipped it on when I watched this. I've never felt a more poetic ending to a great man's life ever before.
My goodness, I just don't have any words to describe how much I admire your friendships. My closest friends are ones I met through the internet so I can't hang out with them like this. You are very lucky
Bing is so good at making short, minutes long videos that make you feel like you've watched this amazing, [quote, unquote] feel good, summer, 80's, hipster movie. (y)
you guys have so much fun together
i wish i had friends like you
@QWERTYCommander Who are the other 2 ? :/
Thank you for this. I can't really find the words to say what I'm feeling after seeing it, and I wish I could, but all the same, thank you for this.
This video made me miss summers spent with my friends. Looks like you have some quality people in your life.
That end was a moment of such raw emotion caught on film. It was beautiful. My thoughts are with you all. R.I.P Edd
You guys are wonderful.
it was so nice to see edds closest friends together to celebrate moving on and truly embracing their feelings
I wish I had friends and fun times like this.
This is by far my favourite video you have ever done. The peacefulness and just atmosphere you created with a) the music and b) the choice in clips you shot compliment and portray your lives so perfectly. Watching this just makes me feel you are an amazing group of friends, so full of life and laughter. I am very jealous of you guys, but its nice to know I'm sort of half friends with some of you :) I look forward to seeing you again at MCM my friend. Any preference to cereal bar this time? XD
Beautiful friendships, right there.
Im sobbing and Im not quite sure why. I have watched maybe 2 off Edds video, but this moves me so much. This makes me love my friends even more. RIP Edd.
I've decided that this is my favourite future bing video. It is good...
I wish my roof was that nice. And I'm glad to see y'all smiling and laughing. But it's a bittersweet gathering.
Best wishes to you bing in the time to come. Just know that you're still making someone's day better by uploading your awesome videos. Wether they are about fun things, absurd things or things no one wishes to go through. I really enjoy your work.
So.. Thanks for being you. :)
Having been through this myself I know that nothing I can say will take anything from this horrible moment, but nevertheless my thoughts and prayers are with you all in this tough time
This was seriously beautiful Bing. I actually started to choke up. I don't know if it was the song, or the emotion I was getting from the video or what. But this was amazing. Keep up the awesome work
Bing, you're a fantastic film-maker. Honestly, don't ever stop ^^
you, bing, just made me cry.
I hope you mean that it's making us all feel sad again. With a lyric like: 'Crying out in anger at a life that had to end' describes what i've felt like recently.
Such an amazing song
this video was really beautiful and touching in a way i didnt expect, i love it(:
It's always nice to hang out with friends! I hope you're feeling a bit better than you did earlier this week:) also I liked your patch up for yesterday it worked nicely..you didn't catalogue your past bing videos?
One of the most beautiful PFBF so far in my opinion.
I had an awesome day like this with my friends today after a rough patch... It was much needed so I can def understand why you would want to film this to save for later! It's currently almost 2:30 AM and I'm still a lil drunk... Aka perfect night!!!!
What a nice way to give tribute to edd ... we all miss you xxx
since i was older than 6 there have only been two things that have made me cry, in the first pokemon movie when ash turned to stone and this video. I didn't know Edd but regardless i would not be where i am today/ on the parth i am on without him. Wherever you are Edd you change lives.
I just.. this is perfect and strangely moving
This is now another favourite of mine :)
I wish i could have a day like this.
One of the best groups of friends ever. :)
I think Bing's the most humanistic youtuber. He's definitely the one I'd like to meet the most.
This was lovely.
This video is perfect and brilliant. I'd like to know where a bouts the rooftop is... Beautiful. This video made me cry. :')
If anything, the music is deliberate upon the subject. Presumably filmed a week after his passing, they were clearly all remembering him, especially at the end, and as bradboy98 said: 'crying out in anger at a life that had to end'. It shows they're all upset that Edd's life has been cut short. It's not supposed to be negative, it's put into contrast with their smiles and laughter that we see throughout the video.
Yes I didn't know him, but edd still got me through a lot of tough time. He videos always made me smile. And for that edd, I thank you. PIP EDD.
this is really beautiful, i hope you're all okay
i hope me and my friends get to do something like this when we are older XD looks fun
seems like a group of people who experienced a lot together
somehow, it all settled down with you guys and this fire in the end. thank you, for being so honest. i miss edd and would try to to compensate in a similar way as you guys. brushfire fairytales, i like you guys a lot!
I took your awesome idea and started a blog where I post every other day and they'll be released
in 10 years where I reply to them. I love your videos, they very meaningful!!
Only Comedians can still make jokes and smiles at a time like that
I need better friends, closer friends, so we can do stuff like this and im open to be myself and we can all hang out and have fun..
i cried at the end
i cant find the song anywhere. i love it, its amazing, and so is this video :)
The most beautiful ending song ever
That seems like such an awesome atmosphere :) you guys are awesome
Randy Solem, one of the first ever people who animated with video game sprites, thus starting a huge trend.
Nice to see them smiling instead of crying. RIP Edd
I need to hug you all now ;u; I cried at this...
This is my favorite
Let's sum up this week:
Two very well-known Newgrounds animators died, one lesser known Newgrounds animator died, new video game consoles were rumored, and there is an astonishing lack of movies being shown in the theater.
Oh, and my favorite band is recording new music.
Really a weird week.
i gald to see you guys are copeing well.but the end shows that you still are shocked by how massive the situation is.
That was....wow. It was beautiful man. Really striking. I don't know what else to say really...
Damnit bing...making me cry...
At least you all got to cry together and around people you love. I've been crying alone. I'm sure Edd's spirit was there with all of you.
Dear Friends, I'm so grateful for you. Every single day.
Randy Solem and Luccas Bode. Randy Solem set the trend of animating with video game sprites, Luccas Bode was some obscure 3D animator. Randy died of heart problems. Luccas died of multiple organ failures.
When I grow up i wanna find someone like Bing. You guys are all awesome. I don't have friends as good as that either. So brave, all of you. Sorry if this doesn't make much sense, blame Baileys and its beautiful creamy-ness. It's so creamy, 'n beige
I didn't want this video to end :)
My face lit up as soon as I saw Richard :)
I would love to hang out with all you guys! :) Seems like such a relaxing and nice time. :)
Great video
Beautiful :')