"In my 'humble' Opinion", (and if we were voting; or, even, if we were gambling), I would say this 'iz' definitely *not* Johann Sebastian (1685-1750) BACH. After spending the last 52 years focused, almost solely, on JS Bach in listening, reading & playing [via piano, organ, violin & viola] "all-things-JS-Bach", ...no way is this JS Bach {once again, this is "my humble opinion"}. The first movement sounds close to C.P.E. Bach, however the 2nd mvt. comes 'strongly' across as G.F. Handel. The third mvt. 'did' trick me up "a bit", but finally presented itself as too 'Italian' in nature (somewhere in the Corelli-Vivaldi genre`), while the Finale sounded, once again, more like C.P.E. Bach, ...(if a Bach, at all). ~ Sorry, that is the way I hear this in my well-seasoned JS Bachian aural templates. - IMHO
3:40 Part II 7:44 Part III 10:49 Part IV Very good played, thank you
Beautiful!
Bravo, Penelope! Beyond words!!!
Wow. Amazing performance! Hauntingly beautiful.
Yes mamma ❤
Unmistakably Bach! So beautiful
Some scholars supposed that this sonata is by Pisendel, the Vivaldi's pupil and Bach's friend.
"Finale with its hint of Polonaise" - rather of Passepied.
"In my 'humble' Opinion", (and if we were voting; or, even, if we were gambling), I would say this 'iz' definitely *not* Johann Sebastian (1685-1750) BACH.
After spending the last 52 years focused, almost solely, on JS Bach in listening, reading & playing [via piano, organ, violin & viola] "all-things-JS-Bach", ...no way is this JS Bach {once again, this is "my humble opinion"}.
The first movement sounds close to C.P.E. Bach, however the 2nd mvt. comes 'strongly' across as G.F. Handel. The third mvt. 'did' trick me up "a bit", but finally presented itself as too 'Italian' in nature (somewhere in the Corelli-Vivaldi genre`), while the Finale sounded, once again, more like C.P.E. Bach, ...(if a Bach, at all). ~ Sorry, that is the way I hear this in my well-seasoned JS Bachian aural templates. - IMHO
Nevertheless, it's absolutely stunning music, tho.
You were certainly right. It's thought to be a Bach's friend Johann Georg Pisendel (according to imslp).
No way this is Bach.