Don't comparison. It's your wish or choice... Both [S.Janaki Amma and Lata Ji] are Pillars of Music... Two legendary singers have sung this same tune. This video is only to inform it👈...
If Janaki Amma Ji is the right eye of Indian Music then Lata Ji is the left eye... WHO dares comparing them??? I am Bangladeshi but I know that they are LEGENDS and can't they be compared ever...
இருவரின் குரலிலும் ஒரு ஒற்றுமை இருக்கிறது. லதா மங்கேஷ்கர் பாடும் போது எஸ்.ஜானகி பாடுவதைப் போல இருக்கும். ரெண்டு பேருமே சரஸ்வதி ஆதாரங்கள் என்பதில் ஐயமில்வை
S Janaki amma dynamic range and singing style very high pitch perfect voice female play back singer no one can replace her voice range and singing style
S.janaki is the India's no.1 singer..... What a amazing voice.... Multi talented women.... ! All time my favourite singer one and only .janaki amma....!
Lata Mangeshkar is 10 years older than S. janaki and she sang this song when she was 69 years old. But you can see her clear pronounciation, power in her voice and at the same time melody. She is goddess.
@@kareach Yes only self obsessed south indian will think like that, not whole India, Good for you. Lataji is already 9 year older than S janaki. Here lataji is 69 year old and janakiji is 60 years old and you were telling me about feminity and alaaps. Go and listen this two songs when lataji was 62 years old and then tell me about this feminity and alaaps. Kesariya balam th-cam.com/video/Mh0sQPQs6x0/w-d-xo.html Chitthiye th-cam.com/video/W_nPXRsNiyI/w-d-xo.html
Our South India's boon we have great singers like Suseelamma, S.Janakamma, Vani Jayaram, Chitra mam, Sailaja, Swarna Latha, Sujatha and our God Singers Ghantasala gaaru, PB Srinivas, Ramakrishna, Yesudas sir & our beloved SPB garu and so many .... we actually blessed to hear and enjoy their divine magic. Lata ji also one of the finest singers of our country. Please don't compare them. Just listen and enjoy their melodies. That's my opinion
@@kunaljangra6522 no, we appreciate talents irrespective of region. I have seen many lokgayaks and gayikas singing awadhi and bhojpuri folk songs. They are ossom
s.janaki amma world best singer no one can reach her place and very high pitch perfect voice moduletion and High pich perfect voice and dynamic and expression King
Its not battle between latha ji or janaki amma Both r unique and he is expressing his love on janaki amma becz he knows her legacy The thing is everyone r music kings and queen not just janaki amma Janaki amma is one of the gods of music
இருவருமே மிகச்சிறந்த பாடகர்கள். இருவரின் குரலும் இனிமையானது, ஆனால் இந்த பாடலுக்கு தேவையான காதல் உணர்வு ஜானகி அம்மாவின் குரலில் காணலாம். ஏற்ற இறக்கங்களுடன் அந்த பாடலுக்கு தேவையான காதலுடன் பாடியிருப்பார்.
@@AmitKumar-lv9ph That's Your Opinion Only... Then Take And Kept In Your Pocket Ok... Who Are You Judge To My Opinion...!? Lata, Asha Who Were Ever These Are Nothing Infront Of Janaki Amma Ok... That's My Opinion... Then Go To Hell... 👋👋👋
Dear friend all are human being only. But your latha mangeshkar is not down to earth. In term of singing only u should appreciate but not in personally. But s janaki personally also she is very kind. Every singer love her so much. Becoz of her simplicity. And latha mangeshkar did not allow others to grow in bollywood. Vani jayaram voice is better than latha mangeshkar
Jai Sri Yadhava SJanaki garu I wish u to get Bharat Ratna award as early as possible central government should recognise u ur in heart of all music lovers in South bharat LordSri Krishna bless you with good health take care
The real Nightingale of india S. Janaki amma, avre Hindi, Tamil, telugu, malayalam, kannada, odisha, bengali, sinhala languages പാടിയിട്ടുണ്ട്, but latha ji Hindi ille മാത്രം ആണ് many songs പാടിയിട്ടോളൂ, and small marathi, bengali songs
No comparison of two legends. Seniority as well as resources available for hindi films in bombay/mumbai were added attractions to lataji. Majority of her songs are either hindi or marathi. In Janakiamma's case it is little different. Tamil n telugu filmdom is not on par with bombay/mumbai filmdom. However Janakiamma is all comfort zone in telugu, tamil, kannada and especially in malayalm. In all the four states she is an household name and lot of memorable songs are to her credit which fact cannot be ignored. Hence she is equal to lataji.
UNTRUE...Lataji's Bengali, Oria, Assames, Nepali, Punjabi and even south songs etc. songs are in thousands (some of the biggest International Malaysian/Indonesian hits have been sung by didi under Rhoma Irama music), also unlike Janakiamma (who sang majority in her native Tamil/familiar Telgu languages), Lataji sang majorly in Urdu/Hindi which were alien language for her, which she had to learn hard way. To achieve perfection in Urdu syntax is very hard for even hindi speakers. Thats the reason South singers have had tough time in Bollywood, as its hard for them to pronounce Urdu properly (shuddh Hindi is much easier for singers like Yesudas as Malayalam has lot of sanskrit). To compare Lata with anyone is foolishness.
We don't have to compare or fight between these two Godesses. Both of them have heavenly voice. I love them both . Of course Janu Ma is and will be my Idol forever and ever. Januma's Hindi songs sounds like Lata Ji's singing... unless we really listen to the really tiny differences of their voice❤❤❤Januma loves Lata Ji's voice and she had said that before... just like SPB Sir loves Md.Rafi Sir's voice❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Please Don't compare them... they're Gods of Music🎶 🎵 😍
The tamil language makes perfect lyrics. The words, sweetness for listening with Janaki's voice, make perfect combination. That's why Janaki amma stands top for this song.
i am not from india..but since my childhood i know jiya jale only..didnt know tamil version.. i like the tamil version...but lata mangeshkar is my fav,no 1 for me..2nd for k.s chitra
Don't comparison. It's your wish or choice...
Both [S.Janaki Amma and Lata Ji] are Pillars of Music...
Two legendary singers have sung this same tune. This video is only to inform it👈...
If Janaki Amma Ji is the right eye of Indian Music then Lata Ji is the left eye... WHO dares comparing them??? I am Bangladeshi but I know that they are LEGENDS and can't they be compared ever...
இருவரின் குரலிலும் ஒரு ஒற்றுமை இருக்கிறது. லதா மங்கேஷ்கர் பாடும் போது எஸ்.ஜானகி பாடுவதைப் போல இருக்கும். ரெண்டு பேருமே சரஸ்வதி ஆதாரங்கள் என்பதில் ஐயமில்வை
I agree bro,l am from Bihar, tamizh one gave a feel of goosebumps. I love both of them.
@@billubhai5644 Thank you brother. Thanks for the message.
But ashaji voice and janaki amma voice similar
@@harini2802 ஒரு சில பாடல்கள் தானே.....அல்லது எல்லா பாடல்களுமா...
@@nramadurainarasihman7324 some songs both same voice
S. Janaki amma Indian Kohinoor Diamond and no one can beat her voice singing style
What a beautiful voice janakamma lovely voice melody Queen always my favorite singer janakkamma
S. Janaki amma universal singer and Melody queen humming king
S. Janaki amma world best singer and one and only very high pitch perfect voice
Sorrry sorry sorrry very pity....no body can sing like lata ji.i hear janki amma but sorry bro not like lata ji
@@AmitKumar-lv9ph no no
@@AmitKumar-lv9ph U know singaravelanay deva song not attempt lathaji because that is nadaswaram that song only singing janakamma only
@@raghavach6202 he is mad please don't reply to his nonsense messages
@@AmitKumar-lv9ph coz you've used to hear her voice alot..no comparison ,they both are legends in their own aspects its unfair to compare them
Why to compare?
You want to say one is best and other is not ?
Both are Legends ...have respect for both of them...
Both Are Legend
S Janaki amma dynamic range and singing style very high pitch perfect voice female play back singer no one can replace her voice range and singing style
S.janaki is the India's no.1 singer..... What a amazing voice.... Multi talented women.... ! All time my favourite singer one and only .janaki amma....!
Lata didi is Goddess Saraswathi.
S janakiamma is like Lord Krishna...who is multitalented versatile, universal.
👍
Correct 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🥰🥰🥰
In south no krishna only lord shiva...my janagi amma is siva and goddest Parwathi
@@aravind270 man Now You divide the gods too
@@pinrayi7909 you people divided Human the name of caste...
S.janaki honey voice 👍🥰
S. Janaki amma what a cutie voice and modulations and flock humming softly and sweet and classical and dynamic and husky
S. Janaki amma Bharat Rathana really
S Janaki amma sung above more than 50000 songs in all languages and state's and all versions
Lata didi is famous in other countries and she also sing more than 40 k songs
Lata jis singing is full of energy and emotions. And there is Lata ji who cares about other
ஜானகி அம்மாள் அவர்கள் பாடல்கள் மனித மனங்களை உயிரையே மயக்கும் மாயம் செய்யும் அழகிய குரல்
S. Janaki amma no one can replace her place
Both are legends! Legends can’t be compared! 🙏🏻 I love both Janaki ji and Lata ji 🤩😇🙏🏻
S Janaki amma indian number one female play back singer no one can reach her place
Yesssss
Lata Mangeshkar is 10 years older than S. janaki and she sang this song when she was 69 years old. But you can see her clear pronounciation, power in her voice and at the same time melody. She is goddess.
Yes fool people never accept..they jus arguement.leav them
Oh please the feminity, alaap and expressive melodic trances are way beyond Mangeshkar
@@kareach same for amma
@@kareach Yes only self obsessed south indian will think like that, not whole India, Good for you. Lataji is already 9 year older than S janaki. Here lataji is 69 year old and janakiji is 60 years old and you were telling me about feminity and alaaps. Go and listen this two songs when lataji was 62 years old and then tell me about this feminity and alaaps.
Kesariya balam
th-cam.com/video/Mh0sQPQs6x0/w-d-xo.html
Chitthiye
th-cam.com/video/W_nPXRsNiyI/w-d-xo.html
S Janaki is inmatchable. Stop using words like South Indian etc. I might say something unpleasant
S. Janaki amma my darling
Our South India's boon we have great singers like Suseelamma, S.Janakamma, Vani Jayaram, Chitra mam, Sailaja, Swarna Latha, Sujatha and our God Singers Ghantasala gaaru, PB Srinivas, Ramakrishna, Yesudas sir & our beloved SPB garu and so many .... we actually blessed to hear and enjoy their divine magic. Lata ji also one of the finest singers of our country. Please don't compare them. Just listen and enjoy their melodies. That's my opinion
Well said.....👍
S. Janaki amma Indian number one female play back singer in this Universe also excited talented singer
Yes, absolutely
Janaki amma is my life..
Janaki amma is the most deserving recipient of Bharat ratna award
She has the womanness oozing in the voice
@@janakiammastatus that's only for lata mam
@KKR Media 🤣
@@sanam5513 😂nice joke
Both are great singers. But for us southies, we are more used to Janaki Amma. She deserves Bharata Ratna.
She must be conferred Bharat ratna
You like janki becouse you are sothise but I like lata di because she is world famous
@@kunaljangra6522 no, we appreciate talents irrespective of region. I have seen many lokgayaks and gayikas singing awadhi and bhojpuri folk songs. They are ossom
S. Janaki amma Indian Kohinoor Diamond
S. Janaki amma beautiful and best voice
S. Janaki amma what a cutie voice
S. Janaki amma Morley better than Indian all female singers and husky king and queen of hearts and queen humming king and queen of music
ஜானகி அம்மா குரலில் என்ன ஒரு காதல் உணர்வு அருமை❤❤❤
s.janaki amma world best singer no one can reach her place and very high pitch perfect voice moduletion and High pich perfect voice and dynamic and expression King
both singers r da best n cant compare laths is thinner than janaki amma voice sweetness r good in rrsprctive plsces
எஸ். ஜானகி அம்மா உலக அளவில் மிக சிறந்த பிண்ணனி பாடகர்🎤 ஜானகி அம்மா இசையின் கடவுள்
Lata didi sung 36000 songs
Its not battle between latha ji or janaki amma
Both r unique and he is expressing his love on janaki amma becz he knows her legacy
The thing is everyone r music kings and queen not just janaki amma
Janaki amma is one of the gods of music
Janu amma has come to my 3 times and to my working place when she pass my office I'm blessed
Janu amma is down to earth she visited my home 3 times including my sons first bday I'm blessed
Janu amma has song 47000
இருவருமே மிகச்சிறந்த பாடகர்கள். இருவரின் குரலும் இனிமையானது, ஆனால் இந்த பாடலுக்கு தேவையான காதல் உணர்வு ஜானகி அம்மாவின் குரலில் காணலாம். ஏற்ற இறக்கங்களுடன் அந்த பாடலுக்கு தேவையான காதலுடன் பாடியிருப்பார்.
Yes yes true
உண்மை... S. ஜானகி அம்மா உணர்ச்சிகளின் நாயகி..!
Janki Amma voice mind blowing out standing super it's best in world
ONE SUN,ONE MOON,ONE LATA MANGESHKAR (Daughter of Nation)
Both are talented Bharatiya singers....Awesome voice and pitch.
See the age when both singers attempted the song :)
S. Janaki amma my mom
Both are legends but I have enjoyed Janaki’s performance.
Super
@@behappy3496 hi sai how are you
@@behappy3496 purila bro
I never listened S Janaki ji but she sounds so like Lata ji..Legends..
No can beat Janaki amma in expression. Expression Queen Janaki amma
S. Janaki amma Indian number one play back singer no one can beat her voice
Lata ji can beat any bollywood tollywood female singers ok
@@AmitKumar-lv9ph but not janaki amma
Both have same voice
s.janaki amma universal singer no one can beet her singing style and voice moduletion
S Janaki amma melody queen 👑👑👑🌍🌍🌎🌍👑👑👑👑🌍🌍🌎🌍🌍🌎
s.janaki amma my darling and mom and dreams
Nobody Can Sing Like Janaki Amma... She Is One Piece In This World... ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Sorry bro..no body sing like lata ji in whole world.like janki amma asha can ditto sing
@@AmitKumar-lv9ph That's Your Opinion Only... Then Take And Kept In Your Pocket Ok... Who Are You Judge To My Opinion...!? Lata, Asha Who Were Ever These Are Nothing Infront Of Janaki Amma Ok... That's My Opinion... Then Go To Hell... 👋👋👋
@@shaikirfan2648 bro coool........goddess singing is only lata mangeshkar ok chill....i am just giving u gyan
Dear friend all are human being only. But your latha mangeshkar is not down to earth. In term of singing only u should appreciate but not in personally. But s janaki personally also she is very kind. Every singer love her so much. Becoz of her simplicity. And latha mangeshkar did not allow others to grow in bollywood. Vani jayaram voice is better than latha mangeshkar
@@madhusudhanac3746 stop who u are.governent not maide.they know who is best female singer in this country ok.dont dare to reply
Janaki Amma
Lata ji voice is more sweet and sharper if compared. Theirs younger sung songs difference is seen. S. Janaki Amma is also awesome.
S Janaki amma humming Bird 🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️🕊️ King of music 🎶🎶🎶🎶🎵🎵🎵
Lata ji .. the greatest of all
Jai Sri Yadhava SJanaki garu I wish u to get Bharat Ratna award as early as possible central government should recognise u ur in heart of all music lovers in South bharat LordSri Krishna bless you with good health take care
s.janaki amma indian number one female play back singer no one can beet her singing style and voice moduletion and High pich perfect voice moduletion
సూపర్ S జానకి అమ్మ ❤️❤️🙏🙏❤️❤️
Apart from Comparison, For this Particular Song, S.Janaki Amma Scores 💯
Janaki amma🌹🌹🌹🌹
இருவரும் மிகச்சிறந்த பாடகர்கள் ❤️
No comparison. Every one is unique in their own way. Janaki amma always on the upper hand
😂😂 why because she is a South Indian??
@@sauravkumarnanda3193 so what, like s janaki, in male singers yesudas no 1 in india
Both are great. Cannot compare or question talents. Who are we!??
S. Janaki amma my life
The real Nightingale of india S. Janaki amma, avre Hindi, Tamil, telugu, malayalam, kannada, odisha, bengali, sinhala languages പാടിയിട്ടുണ്ട്, but latha ji Hindi ille മാത്രം ആണ് many songs പാടിയിട്ടോളൂ, and small marathi, bengali songs
No No, S.Janaki is a grt singer... Her voice becomes high pitched at many places which makes it unpleasant to hear sometimes... Accept the truth...
No comparison of two legends. Seniority as well as resources available for hindi films in bombay/mumbai were added attractions to lataji. Majority of her songs are either hindi or marathi. In Janakiamma's case it is little different. Tamil n telugu filmdom is not on par with bombay/mumbai filmdom. However Janakiamma is all comfort zone in telugu, tamil, kannada and especially in malayalm. In all the four states she is an household name and lot of memorable songs are to her credit which fact cannot be ignored. Hence she is equal to lataji.
UNTRUE...Lataji's Bengali, Oria, Assames, Nepali, Punjabi and even south songs etc. songs are in thousands (some of the biggest International Malaysian/Indonesian hits have been sung by didi under Rhoma Irama music), also unlike Janakiamma (who sang majority in her native Tamil/familiar Telgu languages), Lataji sang majorly in Urdu/Hindi which were alien language for her, which she had to learn hard way. To achieve perfection in Urdu syntax is very hard for even hindi speakers. Thats the reason South singers have had tough time in Bollywood, as its hard for them to pronounce Urdu properly (shuddh Hindi is much easier for singers like Yesudas as Malayalam has lot of sanskrit). To compare Lata with anyone is foolishness.
Lata ji also sang in English and Dutch.
Rafi did same but also Surinamese.
What matters is that they felt comfortable of singing in other languages 🙏👏
Well said dear.. Both have sung in most of the Indian languages both brightened at their specific prime part..
@@music4seva187 of course it's is a foolishness ...... your so called politician 😂😂 cannot be compared with any singer
Actually janaki is better than latha because janaki is unique. So talented. No one is equal to janaki in all languages.
S Janaki amma melody queen 👑👑👑💖💖💖💖👑
S Janaki amma indian kohinoor Diamond and gold 🪙🪙🪙🪙🪙🪙🥇🥇🥇🥇🪙🪙🥇🥇🪙🪙
Always S. Janakiji The Best of all Bests
Yes 10000%
இது பாடகிகளுக்கு மட்டும் அல்ல. தமிழின் வரிகளா ஹிந்தியின் வரிகளா என்றும் தான். தமிழின் அழகே அழகு. ஜானகி அம்மா குரலும் தான்..
Lata ji so sweet unke takkar ye kbhi nhi de paingi 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
We don't have to compare or fight between these two Godesses. Both of them have heavenly voice. I love them both . Of course Janu Ma is and will be my Idol forever and ever. Januma's Hindi songs sounds like Lata Ji's singing... unless we really listen to the really tiny differences of their voice❤❤❤Januma loves Lata Ji's voice and she had said that before... just like SPB Sir loves Md.Rafi Sir's voice❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤Please Don't compare them... they're Gods of Music🎶 🎵 😍
ஜானகி அம்மா உலகின் உச்சம்
I guess, S Janaki Amma is better than others play back singers. Because of South She hasn't achieved great heights
Yes
She has an edge over other singers , not just voice , expression in voice
Sorry bro.you need some sweetness.regular listen lata jee....get well soon
@@AmitKumar-lv9ph You listen Janaki Amma songs you will feel heaven. Yesudas songs also. Come out well.
@@JessyAleppy listen lata jee pure sweet honey voice..get well soon
S. Janaki amma and Latha ji to legendary singers are indian Nightingales
S Janaki amma ♾️ universal singer
S janki amma supar (maa saraswati lata didi mangeshkar) 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
U r right sir 💯
Both are too good and having so sweet voice .......Lata didi sung 36000 songs
But s Janaki Amma sings 48000 morethan
The tamil language makes perfect lyrics. The words, sweetness for listening with Janaki's voice, make perfect combination. That's why Janaki amma stands top for this song.
Janakamma voice expression is super..
Janaki Amma is the best singer in the world..😍
Lata Ji Saraswati.
Best Singer .
S Janaki amma husky rock star ✨✨✨✨⭐⭐⭐⭐
both are legendary.. latha ji at that has clear perfection is really greatest thing..
Lata jee world.s best singer.her voice far far batter than other singers
Avaribbaru nanna tumba ishtavada singer's 💞
Sensational ,absolutely beautiful. no words to express the comparison. All the best darling.
My favourite s.janaki Amma🙏
Janaki Amma mother of evry singer
Lata ji ek hi paida hoti haaaaa 🔥🙏🙏🙏🙏
S Janaki amma daughter of any language
Both are legends 🙏🏻, Lata maa I miss you, plz come back 🙏🏻🙏🏻😭😭😭😭
S Janaki amma Bharat Ratna
i am not from india..but since my childhood i know jiya jale only..didnt know tamil version.. i like the tamil version...but lata mangeshkar is my fav,no 1 for me..2nd for k.s chitra
S Janaki amma expression King 👑👑👑👑👑👑👑🌍🌍🌎🌍🌍👑👑👑👑👑🌍🌍🌎🌍🌍👑👑👑👑👑🌍🌍🌎🌍🌍🌎🌍👑👑👑👑👑👑👑
S Janaki amma daughter of music world
They are gems of India
jaanaki Amma & Lata ji
Love from 🇱🇰
I will always vote for nenjinile ❤❤❤.. S. Janaki ma'am what a voice ❤
S Janaki amma daughter of Nation
One can't sing like Lataji and Janki Amma. The magic of voice and expressions are with both voices.They both deserves same place.
I crazy of Janaki amma voice..
No words of Lata ji voice too
There is hardly any difference in this clip; it is like mirror image. Hats off to the singers and A R Rehman.
S Janaki amma humming King 👑👑👑🌍👑🌍🌍🌎👑👑
S Janaki amma is best singer
Lata ji no need any body oppinon
Janaki amma is southern lata ji.
No one equal to Janaki amma
She is equal to ten thousand Bharat Ratna awards only
She is not even close to lata ji sorry.she can campare with asha ji
@@AmitKumar-lv9ph I think u didn't know about S janaki