If you're interested in our evangelical scholar's analysis of this moment, read below: Could Jesus Pray for Judas Iscariot? SHORT ANSWER: Yes, Jesus could pray for Judas Iscariot. There is no logical contradiction in the idea of Jesus praying for Judas, and there is no indication in Scripture that Jesus would somehow have been prevented from praying for Judas (or any other sinner). LONG ANSWER: Treating several questions related to this main question. Did Jesus pray for others? We know that Jesus prayed while on earth (e.g., Matt. 14:23; 26:36-44; Mark 1:35; 6:46; 14:32-39; Luke 3:21; 5:16; 6:12; 9:18, 28-29; 11:1; 22:39-45; John 17:1-26; Heb. 5:7). Furthermore, it seems clear enough that Jesus prayed for other people, with examples that include him praying for children (Matt. 19:13-15); apparently for a demon-possessed person (Mark 9:14-29); for Peter (Luke 22:31-34); for his immediate followers (John 17:6-26), for the people who were crucifying him (Luke 23:34), and even for those of us who would become his followers later on (John 17:20-26). Moreover, Jesus is currently praying for believers (Rom. 8:34; Heb. 7:25). Significant here is that Luke reports that Jesus spent the night in prayer before selecting the men who would be apostles (Luke 6:12-16); it would be odd to suggest that Jesus prayed about eleven of the twelve but did not pray about Judas. If Jesus and the Father are the same, they share the same will, so how could Jesus pray for Judas? This question has three difficulties, each worth treating on its own. a) First, the question begins by accidentally sliding into heretical thinking, that is, assuming that Jesus and the Father are "the same." While Jesus and the Father are one and the same God, they are not the same person. This is the mystery of the Trinity. The Father is God, and Jesus is God, and the Holy Spirit is God. But the Father is not the Son, and the Son is not the Spirit, and the Spirit is not the Father. The three persons of the one God are distinct. The Father did not die for our sins; Jesus did. The Holy Spirit did not become incarnate; Jesus did. b) Second and similarly, the question does not recognize that it is equivocating (i.e., subtly changing the meaning) on the definition of the word "will." While Jesus and the Father share the same "will" in one sense of that word, it is evident that they don't have the same "will" in another sense of that word. This becomes clear when Jesus himself makes a distinction between his will and the Father’s will, which he does in the Garden of Gethsemane while praying(!) (see Matt. 26:36-44; Mark 14:32-39; and Luke 22:39-45). Apparently it is entirely possible for the sinless human will of Jesus to give expression in prayer about a sinless natural desire (like health and safety), and this will of Jesus must ultimately be sacrificed for a greater purpose (i.e., providing salvation for humanity). Perhaps this kind of distinction is behind Jesus's own comment in John 5:30, "I do not seek my own will, but the will of him who sent me." The important christological discussion regarding the two natures of Jesus is not the only distinction. This also surfaces the important theological topic of differentiations of “God’s will” in Scripture. Note for example, that "God our Savior ... desires [i.e., one word for "wills"] all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth” (1 Timothy 2:3-4) and that “the Lord ... is patient toward you, not wishing [i.e., another word for "willing"] that any should perish, but that all should reach repentance” (2 Peter 3:9). But God “wishing/desiring/willing” that no one will perish does not guarantee that all will believe. While he certainly could if he wanted to, it is evident that God does not always override human free will to bring about what he "wants." c) This brings me to the third sub-point here: prayer is not magic words. Just like any of the rest of us, when Jesus prays, he is not casting a spell that makes things happen exactly as he prays. That is not what prayer is. It is a mistake for us to assume that “the prayer of a righteous person” (cf. James 5:16) gets whatever they ask for as if prayer were like speaking a magic spell; that’s not how the verse in James 5 reads. And the story about the seven sons of Sceva in Acts 19:11-20 warns against praying “in Jesus’s name” as if it were some formula for getting what we want. It is not necessary to suggest that Jesus could pray “about” Judas without praying “for” Judas, as if Judas’s free will would have been destroyed had Jesus prayed “for” him. If that were the case, why wouldn’t Jesus simply pray his magic words “for” every single person in the whole world so that everyone would be saved? Furthermore, we see Jesus expressly say that he had prayed for Peter (Luke 22:31-34), and it apparently was a prayer that did not prevent Peter from sinning but was nevertheless answered in Peter’s repentance. It would be odd to claim that Peter was the only one of his followers for whom Jesus prayed, or to press it further, to suggest that Jesus prayed for all his followers except Judas. That would again be suggesting that prayers-esp. Jesus’s prayers-are something like magic spells that overpoweringly make things happen. In other words, Jesus could pray for Judas without making it automatic that Judas be saved. Was Judas ever (or never) a believer? This is a good question, but I'm not sure it really matters to any of us now (!). Judas Iscariot was definitely numbered among the twelve apostles (Matt. 10:1-4; Mark 3:13-19; Luke 6:12-16; John 6:70-71), so he was clearly a "follower" of Jesus. Of course, we know that he was not always behaving in a forthright way during those years of following Jesus (e.g., John 12:4-6). Nevertheless, he apparently believed something about Jesus enough to follow him for a few years. But he most famously betrayed Jesus and was replaced as an apostle because he defected from the faith (Acts 1:12-26). Those of an Arminian theological bent might like to argue that Judas was a believer who then gave up his belief; those of Calvinistic theological convictions might like to argue that Judas never was a true believer. To me, it matters little. Perhaps Judas is the quintessential example of false belief, i.e., a person who poses as a disciple but is ultimately not one, and there are other false believers mentioned in the New Testament (e.g., like Simon Magus in Acts 8:9-24; and the people against Jesus in 1 John 2:18-19). But my point here is that there is no need to try to determine the eternal fate of Judas Iscariot as if that would somehow help us recognize any further that he is not a model for any of us to look up to. That is already clear enough. Was Jesus praying for Judas in John 17? Maybe not, but that is different than saying that Jesus never prayed for Judas. The prayer Jesus prayed in John 17 was not his only prayer, and his statement "I am not praying for the world" (v. 9) is certainly not a pledge to have never ever prayed for the world. After all, Jesus died for the world so that the world could be saved (John 3:16), for the world being saved is what God wants (1 Tim. 2:4; 2 Peter 3:9). So, John 17:9 is not proof that Jesus never ever prayed for Judas or anyone else in "the world"--it is simply a statement that Jesus was praying specifically for his followers in John 17. It seems odd to utilize John 17 to suggest that Jesus would never pray for unbelievers even though he was willing to die for unbelievers. Moreover, the New Testament gives us an example of Jesus praying for unbelievers while he was dying on the cross (Luke 23:34). If Jesus could pray for unbelievers while they were crucifying him it seems that Jesus could pray for Judas even while Judas was planning to betray him. Could Jesus pray to God the Father asking for Judas Iscariot to not betray him? Why not? In a sense, Jesus's prayer in the Garden of Gethsemane might be said to have entailed just such a wish. Notice what Jesus prayed: “My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from me" (Matt. 26:39a). Jesus's request to have "this cup" of suffering pass from him might well have included Judas's betrayal not happening. But Jesus submits to the bigger plan and prays, "Yet not as I will, but as you will” (Matt. 26:39b). And in God's way of doing things whereby he maintains sovereign control over all even while humans exercise free will, God allows Judas's free choice to betray Jesus, which moves ahead the means of salvation for humanity through Jesus's suffering and resurrection.
Well if judas would of changed his mind then who would of done the dirty deed second judas was never truly saved to begin with no different than many so called Christians today could judas of changed his mind after he betrayed jesus yes and jesus would of forgave him.
Judas may have had a last minute salvation, even then Jesus Y’Shua would still forgive Judas. YHVH’s plan had to be played out specifically according to prophecy.
For the record, I love The Chosen. My wife and I have been watching it every night and are now coming to the end of Season 3. I just want to say that nothing in this world is perfect, but you guys have done an amazing job. It’s as lifelike and brilliant as one could hope for. In my ministry, I face controversy daily-it’s to be expected. With over 47,000 denominations today, controversy is inevitable. I understand that you’ve added some creative elements to the show that aren’t explicitly in the Bible, aiming to bring out the humanity of the story. Personally, I think the show is heartfelt and worthy. In my opinion, it has the potential to renew many people’s faith and even bring people to Yeshua. I’m a heavy studier of the Scriptures. While I believe the Trinity is a concept influenced by pagan ideas and can be proven incorrect biblically, I understand your intent to remain true to the overarching message. For example, phrases like "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do" were not part of the original manuscripts. Still, you’ve done your best, and the message is strong, even if some errors exist. The King James Version, for instance, contains added texts that have caused confusion about concepts like the Trinity. As many know, 1 John 5:7 was not in the original manuscripts and has misled people about the chapter’s original meaning. Similarly, added texts can sometimes obscure the truth, such as the example where Yeshua didn’t actually say, "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do." Despite these issues, the central message is what truly matters: salvation is for all. It is a gift from our Heavenly Father, and we are called to repent and follow Yeshua’s example. Today, the confusion caused by so many differing interpretations has diluted the basic message. Even foundational truths, like the one true Sabbath, have been distorted and misunderstood, though I find them to be very clear in Scripture. The Chosen is amazing, but remember, we are called to work out our salvation with fear and trembling. Don’t be disheartened if some things in the show aren’t perfect. The overall message is incredible and a blessing to many.
I love that you address these issues that are brought up even tho you don’t have to. As you acknowledge, you have many learned folks who speak to these issues and give you additional guidance. The Chosen is a tv show that has blessed me immensely and brought me back to my Bible over and over! Thank you and I am praying for you and your family!
Peter was DESTINED to become the Rock on which Messiah would build His Church... (Matthew 16:18) and for that reason when Messiah prayed for Peter...it was according to the WILL of the FATHER... (Luke 22:32). Judas on the other hand was destined to become the Betrayer...(John 6:70) and Messiah will NEVER PRAY against the Father's Will...(John 17:12) You people really need to learn to join the right dots!!! This is leading people astray!
In the bible it literally says that Jesus prayed. End of story. Keep doing you, Dallas. The Chosen family is fantastic and your team is phenomenal! This show brings so much peace and love and happiness to multitudes.
Whaaaaaat is this. Christmas is when Christ was born in Bethlehem. Guys I get your Santa Claus. But this is just something. We don’t have any Santa Claus, we have little baby Jesus that brings gifts to our children in December. Heloooooo? Christmas has none to do? Bro. Set your records straight
I'm just shaking my head and rolling my eyes. People are looking for reasons to try and discredit the show and will make things up in an attempt to achieve their goal. It's sad how so many people have lost the ability to think, reason, and discern. A majority of the issues people have with the show fall into this category. The "problem" with the show is it challenges peoples pre-conceived ideas and beliefs. They do not and refuse to think outside the box, outside of their beliefs. Dallas & Co, PLEASE keep doing what you're doing. God is using it to truly change lives.
JESUS did live between the lines, not every second of HIS life is recorded!!! Go with God Dallas, that's the only approval you need. 🙏 Do not be discouraged 🙏. Millions have found JESUS through your GOD inspired series! Don't stop! 🙏
Exactly I saw Twitter posts saying "we warned you about this show" and then when I watched the scene I was ???? warned about what!? That they would portray Jesus' unshakeable love and compassion for others even when they plan to betray or hurt Him? Because that's exactly what Jesus's nature is and the Father desires for no one to perish. So I was so confused, they did a perfect job and I am annoyed by how many people just want to pick at the show and ruin its reputation for no reason. What does it say about their spirits that they want to destroy a show that has been converting tens of thousands to Christ? So weird...
This makes me so sad. That scene was so beautiful. It made me realize I am Judas coming to Jesus with my unmet expectations. They are focusing on the wrong things.
Dallas, you absolutely did not get this wrong! Remember our role…loaves and fishes…keep doing what you’re doing! May God continue to bless you and The Chosen 🙏
He definitely got it wrong. It is an unbiblical scene. The derision here is why this series is so dangerous. The Word of God is all we need. Not made up scenes for the benefit of Hollywood. This scene and its dialogue are not found in Scripture. WAKE UP Christians.
I actually loved that Jesus said He would pray for Judas. He was Jesus, Son of God. He loved Judas. Even though He knew what Judas was going to do, He still loved Him. Thank you, Dallas and your whole team, for all the hard work and for helping me to understand the Holy Bible. It was such a heavy scene for me to watch with Judas, but it helped me see and realize all the suffering Jesus went through even before the cross. That scene you showed was so powerful and heavy, and Im so thankful I got to watch it. The Lord wants us to pray for all. That doesn't mean only certain people or don't pray for people who upset you. Pray for All. I want to have faith like my Jesus. Where I pray for all, even those who hate me, call me names. Thank you and May the Lord Bless you all.
amy_loves_the_chosen, I agree with you! And I believe the devil has reared his ugly head to try to discourage people from the Gospel! Love "The Chosen"!!! ❤❤❤
I can believe that Jesus could pray for Judas to have God's peace over him, for about what the choice was that he was considering making & would do, in, actually, God's service, to fulfill what Jesus came to be with us, to do, for our salvation. 🤲🙏🫶
@@nickma71 judas was not a devil as he first followed Jesus. The devil did temp him an he was sorry afterwards. Don't think a devil would hang himself.
@@andrewjoyce7374 I can. I recommend you study scripture. Or repent if you think this is a "gotcha", which doesn't work with those who rightly divide. Jesus came as the messiah of Israel. He will unite the divided kingdom, take away the sin of the nation, rule from Jerusalem, and restore them. This is prophecy. It was in the open. Dying for sin was hidden in scripture. God says it in the Bible, through his spokesmen (prophets again). When Jesus told them he was going to be delivered up, the meaning was hidden from them by God. It had to be hidden. Are you following along? I will continue.
I like the conversation in the controversy. The struggle is real and a conversation about Jesus the Son and God the Father is always good. I will never understand everything written in the Bible, but the discussion draws me closer to my Creator. Thank you for the conversation starter Dallas. God will use it all. God is in control and I trust God. Amen
I'm using The Chosen and controversies to further study and understand Jesus and His work on earth. But I don't appreciate the over-reaction of some to the point that they call Dallas a heretic?
Fortunately God is more merciful than most Christians (and I’m including myself in that). He sent Jesus to save everyone and not one of us fully understands every nuance of free will vs God’s foreknowledge, fulfilling His purpose etc….and that includes Dallas and the writers of this show. I thank God for the work all involved in The Chosen are doing. ❤
@@NEChristo Perfectly stated. The Chosen draws me to Jesus, I can feel the Spirit instructing and calming my soul with the loving, merciful Jesus who died for everyone. Every one. The show draws me to Jesus, these arguments make me want to run for the hills away from “ Christians”.
@ I totally understand yet Jesus teaches us that loving God and others are the foundation of all the commandments-all the law is summed up in loving and forgiving one another. It’s not easy to do, impossible without His grace really, but we’ve got to remember we’re all messed up in this world 😂 that’s why we need Him. 🤍 love to you!
@@NEChristo This is not my experience with Christians today but I still am drawn to Jesus. If he would die a brutal, tortuous death for Judas, who he loved, why wouldn’t he pray for him? If my son committed some terrible crime I would be heart broken but I would pray for him. How can this possibly be a bone of contention among people who call themselves followers of Christ.
@NEChristo in your initial comment you mention not understanding every nuance of free will and God's foreknowledge and I think I can help you out. When you say "free will" are you importing that idea from culture or getting it explicitly from Scripture? You'll recall that The Bible often refers to our will as being enslaved to sin. Regarding God's foreknowledge, how are you defining that word? Do you mean that God looks down the corridors of time and sees events and therefore knows events? The Biblical understanding of foreknowledge is to "know" beforehand; "know" in the intimate sense of the word (ginosko), whereas you may be using "know" in the general sense (oidas, to know of).
Dallas, I thought that scene between Jesus and Judas was awesome. I believe Jesus prays for us all. Jesus created us all. I am so looking forward to Season Five of The Chosen. I keep re- watching The Chosen seasons 1-4 over and over. I Love The Chosen! Merry Christmas and a Blessed New Yeat.
I dont see many other TV series creators having to explain thier decisions as much as you do. Peopl need be thankful for all you and everyone involed put into this. Thank you
Thanks for once again going the extra mile, Dallas. I found it completely plausible that in his frustration and sorrow over Judas, Jesus would pray for him. Continued prayers as you finish editing Season 5 and writing Season 6.
To all those so critical of this scene, I would suggest putting all this energy into this: Love the Lord with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind, and love your neighbor as yourself.
Or how about the scene opened up a discussion when people could have been talking about the Kardashians etc. This guy has ruined this show with his ego, period. Rolling his eyes at questions? wow
@@croqsieur Try harder, I aint here to splain it to ya Lucy. If ya don't get it, don't let people know; it is a sign of weakness. If ya think "what" is a clever resonse, you carry on sport.
@@christinetuttle8975, Dallas works very, very hard, I believe his motives in this show are God honouring, we the viewers all come from different walks of life. There is ONE thing that Jesus makes, perfectly perfectly clear in the Bible, His wish is for us believers to get along, and pursue unity!!, did YOU get that??. Despite your differences in opinion, JESUS has a mandate for you. Do your part in seeking unity not division!, this is not big enough to squabble over. This is NOT a core doctrine or belief, you are allowed to have a different opinion, but not to sow seeds of division that May harm other viewers. Rolling eyes??. Come on who cares. Pls, for the sake of the gospel keep your thots and opinions to yourself, pls, y thank you,
@christinetuttle8975 find Jesus. You clearly don’t have Him. If Jesus weeping or having any sort of emotion offends you, you haven’t read the Bible. One of the most famous verses is “Jesus wept” (John 11:35). If you lived during Jesus’ time, you would’ve been one of the people who demanded His death because He didn’t fit your version of what the Messiah should be.
Because they were all ordain to sacrifice the most holy sacrificed. He is a true Passover lamb . He takes away the sin of the world., he did not come to rub our sins in , he came to rub it out, never to feel guilty again when we give our life to him , we become a new creation in Christ Born Again , he gave us the right to become and a child of God, don’t you religious he did not come for us to be religious he came for us to be born again to give us a second chance in life not to be catholic not to be Protestant, or Baptist but Born Again spiritually . He came to fulfil Judaism., the nations will go up to Jerusalem to celebrate the feast of the Tabernacle, the Catholic Church was the first religion that was created and through their teaching they denied the world from celebrating God’s feast. Days The Jews CELEBRATE , his feast days ! but here is the kicker ! if our father in heaven is Jewish, and we are grafted as a believer we are adopted we are Jewish, it’s not the circumcision of the foreskin but circumcision of the heart . Jesus said to Nicodemus, you are Israel’s teacher how it is you don’t know these things ? he was referring to Eze 37:24-38 . Salvation belong to the Jew first then to the Gentiles. Paul said there is no difference between Jew or Gentile we worship the same God.
Thank you. I agree it’s good to think about, talk about, and study these topics. We can never get to the bottom of biblical insight. There’s always more to God. Grace and peace to you.
Jesus prays for us…He came for sinners. What an inspiring show! Thank you Dallas. I am grateful for your work. God bless you and your family, the cast and crew of The Chosen. Christmas Blessings! You are in my prayer..
You wont please everyone but this LDS guy adores the chosen and what youre doing. We await the new season with great anticipation and wear our Chosen hoodies all over Nashville.
I look at it this way, this show has intrigued millions and has brought people back to God and new people to God. This show has persuaded people to open their bibles and actually read them. It's great if people are seeing things that are not quite in the scripture and asking questions, but it is a TV show, and the Lord is definitely behind it. All to the Glory of God ❤
God has used pagans to bring people to the truth of the Gospel. We don’t assume paganism is right because of it. I love the chosen, despite its sometimes poor theology. Just wanted to he fair here
@@ScribeAlicious he also used false prophets and pastors . Boy are they shaking in their boots atm as Jesus is exposing them all for their deeds . Daystar is the latest ..
@@ScribeAlicious I have to disagree with "poor theology". Rare instances yes, but the vast majority is on target with God's Word. I use The Chosen as a way to study and think more deeply about many things in God's Word.
Thank you Dallas for your patience in describing and caring for others perceptions. I'll be praying for you and everyone involved in the show to have GOD's strength , wisdom , and courage as you bring this message to the world. Armor Up!
All I have to say is thank you for bringing us this beautiful, powerful show that's brought so many people closer to Jesus and their faith. Thank YOU & God Bless!
So because you hope Jesus prays for you and it feels good hes correct? I'm not saying he's not right but when you use emotions instead of logic, your part of the problem we battle against with the atheist
That's one of the greatest things about reading the book of John. When you get to Jesus' prayer in the Garden of Gethsemane in Chapter 17, you realize as you're reading it that Jesus specifically prayed for you AND me in that moment that we would believe and be committed to the Father. When I first realized that, I was moved to tears.
Thank you so much Chosen Team for taking the time to carefully share your thoughts, opinions and reasons for your scene choices! You guys are so busy and still take the time to explain with biblical backing your choices. This just shows how much you love others and the sincerity of the shows goal to bring people to Jesus. Love you guys and so appreciate you!
Glad you spoke of Gethsemane. Your will not mine is the human side of Jesus. Love the scene with Judas. So powerfully showed Jesus's sadness and love for Judas.
Dallas, I continue to pray for God's blessing upon The Chosen to reach people throughout this world🙏❤️👍‼️ I also pray for those that are trying to come against this work. May God break through the veneer, crust, or stone hearts to the blessed truth of Jesus' death, resurrection and ascension to the Father's throne. I believe that God's Hand is truly upon this "show" , so as many of my elders have said; "Don't sweat the small stuff" . May you continue to walk in the truth and light of the love of Jesus Christ. Leave the rest of it in the hands of the Holy Spirit 😘👍🙏❤️‼️
God has used your show to bring people closer to His Son. This showed is blessed by the King of the Universe! Don’t listen to the hissing snakes. The Devil has been trying to tear down God’s work. God bless you and your cast and families!! I can’t wait for Season 5 and I just bought the first 4 seasons. I had no clue the home base was in E Texas. I’m just across the line in Shreveport. I’m praying for this show and thank you.
Some of these things that people have issues with I find to be very annoying, but what I do love about it is when Dallas gets the opportunity to address the issues and how he handles it. He’s always clear about not trying to satisfy people‘s opinions or getting into debates, but providing clarity and in the clarity, he always shows the intent behind the scene and how they already prepared for things like that with the team that he has of scholars reviewing the scripts. That’s what I love!Because everything he said made sense and truly is the way that I view Jesus based on the Scriptures and based on what I know, Jesus heart to be. Bravo!
And for every episode, every season, there is a Bible roundtable. Incredible and informative discussions there. More people should watch those rather than complain online before their understanding is complete.
Hi Dallas: I am a practicing Catholic and you nailed it. It's too bad you have to defend yourself a lot of times, but you do it w grace and dignity. Keep up the GREAT work that you All do. My husband and I pray for the cast and crew, you and your beautiful wife Amanda, (inside and out), every single day. 🙏
You are not wrong. This series has been a true miracle for my spiritual life . From the first season every episode has drawn me closer to growing closer to the Saviour. It opened my eyes to reality and wanting to understand that even back then His disciples were human and nothing has changed. The way they are portrayed allows me to recognize myself in each of them. Blessings to you and the Chosen family. Thank you for igniting fire innmy soul. Also I have gone to the Word and I have found nothing not found in the scriptures.
Dude my wife and I loved The Best Christmas pageant ever. Thank you for your hard work to Jesus in the Chosen and the Christmas pageant movie. I believe it will be a classic in the long run.
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever was absolutely incredible! It was funny, entertaining, touching, poignant and inspiring! Thank you, Dallas! The Chosen is magnificent. I have gained so much watching these episodes knowing it’s a human presentation of God’s Word. Again, thank you.
Was it as good as the first film? I would like to see it, but my wife is a HUGE fan of the original film, and thinks it would be an insult to watch the new one. 😢😢😢
I didn't watch the scene nor will I until the new season I try to stay away from spoilers especially when I know I am going to watch regardless. I am here to say Thank you for everything you and the team has done. Great breakdown and I agree with the views.
He definitely got it wrong. It is an unbiblical scene. The derision here is why this series is so dangerous. The Word of God is all we need. Not made up scenes for the benefit of Hollywood. This scene and its dialogue are not found in Scripture. WAKE UP Christians.
Oh Dallas...as usual you answer with such grace and humility! Thank you for showing us Jesus in your actions and words! May The Father continue to bless you and yours and all your efforts!
Dallas, I trust and believe that you will continue to do what you feel is right according to God's will for the Chosen show. I feel that any little discrepancy that may occur doesn't matter because in the bigger scheme of things you are leading so, so many people to come to Jesus. So try not to let others discourage you. Keep up the great work❣
I think you got it right, Dallas. Having two natures [human and Divine] can only be half understood by us [humans]. The Divine part of His nature is not fully comprehendible. With that being said, of course he would want to pray for someone he loved, it's the human thing to do. Attempting to explain his Divine nature is a slippery slope and best left to God [the Trinity]. Phenomenal work by the entire cast and crew, I can't wait for season 5.
Since Jesus was human I believe any human would be affected by the fact that their friend is about to betray them. I think you got it exactly right. I was moved by that scene.
Foreknowledge does not equal causation. Probably the hardest thing for human beings confined to space and time is to comprehend our God is outside of space and time. Sorry, but movies like back to the future, when mere humans can change the outcome of actual history is NOT realistic. What we know is that Jesus is God. JESUS EXISTED in heaven with God before he condescended to become human for our sakes, pleading with the Father that if there is any other way for humans to be saved, let this cup pass, but if there is no other way, I submit to your (our) will... yes I know I took some creative license, but it actually shows that Jesus is the only way, and as gruesome as the crucifixion was, it was the only way to provide for our salvation!! Just because Judas's acts were prophesied does NOT mean they were caused by God.
@@jackmommiesg is this the right verse? said, “While I was with them in the world, I kept them in Your name. Those whom You gave Me I have kept; and none of them is lost except the son of perdition” (Judas) (John 17:12).
Jesus still prays for us Dallas !! God the Father prays for us , and the Holy Spirit prays for us when words fail , says He groans … can you imagine 🥹🥹🥹
“In the same way the Spirit also comes to help us, weak as we are. For we do not know how we ought to pray; the Spirit himself pleads with God for us in groans that words cannot express.” Romans 8:26
Oh Dallas! I am still on your side! I found the scene to be very moving, and PLAUSIBLE. I don't understand why all these people are so proud as to believe that they have solved 2000 years of debate, nor do I agree that you are heretical. As believers, we choose our theological camps, based on our FLAWED understanding of the Bible. That same pride has caused the many schisms in the Church. May you not be wounded by such landmines. God bless you for sticking your neck out for the Chosen. I love it.
I am SO THANKFUL for your wonderful work in creating and producing The Chosen. Jesus came and He KNEW He would be betrayed and that He would die on the cross, dying for us all. Could it be that Jesus prayed for Judas and how Judas would feel after he would betray Him? I feel that The Chosen is such an amazing work. I hope it will encourage those who are naysayers to open their Bibles and agree to disagree with those who disagree with their view on such a topic as this. The Bible is all about John 3:16.
That is a great point. Jesus was so loving that also think he could have been referring to praying for Judas to deal with betraying him after the fact!! 🙏🏻
One can watch and enjoy it and simultaneously acknowledge when something is just not biblical. They're not mutually exclusive. I enjoy the series, but some of the choices are a reach.
This is an age old topic of inquiry. This issue was going to come up no matter how you portrayed it!. I remember my grandfather, born in the 1880s, talking about this. He was a farmer not a scholar. But he rolled the whole thing around in his mind and asked questions. You did a good and thorough job of explaining this as best anyone could. Enjoy your family this holiday season.
The Chosen is an amazing television drama. It's made me appreciate my own faith, the struggles my ancestors went through from every corner of the world it gave me curiosity watching about "life in the first century" architectural sites, foods, teachings, political atmosphere.
I loved the scene and couldn’t think of another way our Lord would feel after realizing that this soul would be lost. In His infinite mercy how else would he see one of us ?
In the story of 'The name of the Rose' there was a huge barney over whether Jesus owned the clothes he wore. There was nearly a fist fight among high ranking clerics over this question. Dallas, you're doing fantastic work and are loved for the wonderful thing you've done with 'The Chosen'. My church is showing an interest and we're having wonderful discussions about it. We're loving it, as it is, and whatever arguments arise they can't harm this work you're doing. Jesus will give you the answers you need, you can rely on that. God bless. 🌹
The scene was powerful. It showed how we can have a different agenda from God, and think we know best because we have certain skills, or outlook. Forgetting that our ways and thoughts are not His. The scene was played excellently. When Judas stood up, his offense had taken its final root. His words and actions after that spoke volumes. May none of us get to the place that we think we know more than God. May we always practice humility even when we don’t understand. Praise the Name of Jesus for all prayers and intercession He does on our behalf. And may we always side with His will.
Jesus loves each of us. What you have started is conversation which is very important. There is always controversy in everything. Important point. People are watching. 🙏Deborah. North Carolina ❤
You in the show have got me to rekindle my faith and to take a long hard look at myself. Keep doing what you’re doing, man. Your job is just to bring them in. That’s his job to sort us out.
I was talking to my family about this scene last night and I actually told them "If anything, I would find it MORE strange if Jesus just watched Judas fall away and didn't care at all about him" and they said "Same! It would be unlike His nature to not care or want the best for Judas" It just makes no sense. Scripture says God desires for NO one to perish, and Jesus did pray for everyone, John 17 is dedicated to Jesus' prayer to the Father. Yes in John 17:12 He did say Judas was the only one who He lost as Scripture prophesied but it's not because He wanted him to or made him fall away, it's because Jesus knows the beginning from the end and knew what kind of decision Judas would ultimately make. In the way that I saw it, this section from the Bible doesn't refute that Jesus could have prayed for Judas before he got to that point.. He could've prayed for him earlier on but knew what choice he would ultimately make, and that's why in John 17 He said He lost Judas. So my family and I were scratching our heads at what was so controversial, it was a perfectly well made scene that showed Jesus' compassion for Judas, unlike other movies that made it seem like He didn't love him, which always made me sad, because Jesus' nature is to love, so it's not like He loved Peter who denied Him 3 times, but hated Judas, He loved both. He loved Judas despite knowing that he would betray Him. He even added "do what you came for, friend" in Matthew 26:50, a cutting remark to show Judas that they had a good relationship and he betrayed him just like that. And just because something isn't explicitly written in the Bible, it doesn't mean that it couldn't have happened. The Gospels are more of a summary than a word-for-word recording of everything that happened, John said if he wrote everything that Jesus did, there would never be enough space. So it wouldn't surprise me at all if in that unwritten part, Jesus prayed for Judas. In fact, the opposite would surprise me more. You guys did a perfect job portraying Jesus' loving nature that is not contingent on how the recipient acts. HE loves. And yes of course, Judas is still condemned because of his choice and for removing the chance to ask for forgiveness, but Jesus still loved him
@JDog2656 I mean his suicide is a sign that he felt very bad about what he'd done and regretted it. But he ruined his chance of forgiveness. He should've gone to Jesus and asked for forgiveness 😢 Jesus would've forgiven him. But I imagine he didn't think that was possible because of what he did
I’m surprised by the controversy. But, you did a very good job explaining your thoughts behind the scene. Very good. Love the work you are doing, and love the Chosen.
God creates everyone. Some for a dark purpose. When I read that Jesus ministered to the dead while in the grave I think hey Judas was there. He could have comforted him. He now fully Knowing exactly why he was “there”. To fulfill the scriptures.
This Jewish woman has so deeply appreciated the sensitivity of your series. I think this is the first Jesus show that shows the deep Jewish roots of Jesus and the disciples well told. It’s also wonderful to see the dark skinned Middle East Jesus after just seeing Bonhoeffer and recalling the Nazi’s aryan Jesus. I’ve learned a lot and I’m deeply moved and grateful for this series. Thank you Dallas. It’s healing and uplifting to watch this. I think you have done a phenomenal job.
Dallas, I see pain. I am heartbroken. You, your creative team and your consultants are doing a marvelous job. We love you all and trust your desire to combine the Bible and needed creative together to make God proud.
“Trust your desire to combine the Bible ‘and needed creative together to “make God proud”. What? I don’t understand your comment. This show was needed “to make God proud”. Have you read or studied any of The Bible? Are you aware that The script for The Chosen ONLY uses GOD’S Word 5% of the time? This means that the show is a 95% imagination! How is this show that is 95% of the writer’s imagination going to make God proud? Just trying to understand.
Dallas, just KNOW, I trust you and your choices, as I'm sure 99.9% of us all do. You brought me back to reading the Bible EVERYDAY! God Bless you. ❤ Praise Jesus 🙏
I think people/critics just try to nitpick entirely too much. Misery loves company. The Chosen is designed to motivate people to dive into The Word. While it is based on Biblical truths and scripture, people need to open their Bible and find answers themselves. My 11 year old daughter LOVES this show sooo much and it was a catalyst that inspired her to dive into her Bible, to seek a close relationship with our Father and she professed her faith through baptism! We own all 4 seasons on blu-ray and we often rewatch them. New questions arise every time and we always refer to scripture. Thank you, Dallas, for your dedication & commitment to getting it right! The hard work that you & your team put into this is absolutely amazing. Your heart is true! We have shared The Chosen with our pastor and many members of our church family. It really helps to see people from our Bible “come to life” and to see that they were real people with real feelings and situations. I am a visual person and I am so thankful for The Chosen! God bless you, your family, & all of the cast & crew of The Chosen!
I loved that scene. The love and compassion Jesus had was so real. Jesus even prayed in the garden of Gethsemane to let that cup pass, but God's will be done. Jesus is our intercessor who prays for us to the Father even now.
The controversial Judas scene left me weeping as I confessed the many times I, like Judas, have broken Jesus's heart & made Him cry. Watching others react w/animosity caused more tears as I realize they prefer to strain at gnats rather than humbling themselves before God. So, like Jesus, I pray for them to be moved by the Holy Spirit and believe on Him.
The only issue I see is Judas and the predestination question. We, me and family, watched the trailer and end up having a very long theological discussion about Judas, human agency, salvation and freewill. Thank you Dallas for providing feedback.
An all powerful god that predestines some to succeed and some to fail is not a benevolent being. The only way to logically justify the existence of a loving God is to accept that everyone is impacted by their choices and the choices of others. God allows us to choose to follow him or not and his arms are always outstretched with the invitation to come follow me. The adversarial forces of this world will continue to try to influence us to make choices to limit the ability to choose. Goodness leads to greater agency, wickedness seeks to control and bind. Predestination is the phylosophical encapsulation of humankind's attempt to understand the complexity of life. As the saying goes we can't "see the forest for the trees". It's not possible for us to comprehend the effects of all the choices people make or why things happen. An all-knowing Father in heaven does hold the power to comprehend in realtime the precise future that will unfold based on the choices being made by every person in this world. Like an awesome GPS, you make a wrong turn, and God "recalculates" the path forward.
When Jesus asked Judas "Who has your heart? I want it" it broke me in pieces. I mean, Jesus gave us free will, we're allowed to choose what we want to do, the problem here isn't that Judas betrayed Him, because this was God's plan, but the problem is that he decided to take his own life bc he regretted what he did. For me, I saw Jesus's question not as he didn't want Judas to hand Him over to the Romans, bc this what Judas needed to do, but Jesus didn't want Judas to give his life and soul to the evil. I think you did a great job in Judas and Jesus relationship, bc with The Chosen we can understand a bit what was Judas motivations
Jesus would have known Judas was going to kill himself. I can imagine, if nothing else, Jesus was pleading for Judas' life. If Judas had lived long enough for the resurrection, it's possible he could have been reconciled to Christ. Why are the critics so stirred up about Jesus praying for any of humanity??
@@cynthiabush1784Judas died before the resurrection, thus salvation, so he will have a chance to be eternally saved, just as others who died before Jesus was crucified; I cannot believe Judas is the one man in history with no chance of salvation because he died before Jesus was crucified.
Not that I feel you needed to explain, because I thought the scene between Jesus and Judas was beautifully done.. Thank you for explaining your thoughts and reason why.. BIG HUGE FAN!!
And how many of us have wondered if God really knows what He is doing? How many of us have challenged or even been angry or disappointed with God? How many of us have betrayed or denied our Lord? We are all Judas. We are all Thomas. We are all Simon Peter.
He definitely got it wrong. It is an unbiblical scene. The derision here is why this series is so dangerous. The Word of God is all we need. Not made up scenes for the benefit of Hollywood. This scene and its dialogue are not found in Scripture. WAKE UP Christians.
@@enterprisecreations1492 We don't really know what George Washington said in the boat when crossing the Delaware, either; it's called artistic license, and as long as the facts are right, I'm okay with it.
I took as Jesus saying that he will pray for Judas so that after he does what he's supposed to do, that way judas will repent and be saved even after he betrayed Jesus. Jesus wouldn't have prayed for Judas to change his mind bc the betrayal had to happen, but he could've prayed sp that Judas repented AFTER
Great scene. People have to stop picking everything apart. Jesus prayed for many people, even His enemies. Keep doing what you are doing. It is AWESOME❤️🙏🏻✝️
Remember always what you and all the support cast, workers, and staff have accomplished, in being obedient to God’s purpose for this present day. We are so close to our eternal home, when we look at the souls being reached with the Gospel of Christ, the other Countries, the translations that I or any one of us could not have done. I thank God for all you have done. From its beginnings until now you have spoken to and reached out the hand of Gods love and truth to faces I’ll never see. During the pandemic when so many churches, pastors, and Christians effort’s were muffled, thru you answering God’s call on your life, “Hope “was shed abroad. So remember there will always be the doughtier, the naysayer, ad skeptic. I loved the scene and felt it made me think of Christ, the man of sorrows. Your series has been such a blessing to me, my family. I pray God give you peace, strength , and joy. When God said Go into all the world, you continue to respond in such beautiful and careful ways the urgent message of God’s love. Thank you again. God bless you always. ( sorry it’s so long. ❤)
From my perspective, I don't know that Judas ever stopped believing. It seems to me that his betrayal wasn't driven, necessarily, by unbelief but by a misguided belief that he was, in some way, helping the "revolution" that he (and many others) were expecting to take place at the coming of the Messiah. I don't think he believed Jesus would be killed. I think he believed Jesus would, ultimately, take "his rightful place" as King. But that's just my speculation, especially given his obvious regret of that betrayal afterwards.
That is a very plausible thought. The man who walks on water and raises the dead should be able to defeat the Romans with a wave of his hand. What Judas didn't get was that that was not the mission. Whatever was in Judas's mind, he was chosen for this task.
That makes sense, Judas even went back to the temple to ask for Jesus' release, and threw away his coins, when he realized what a big mistake he made. He was very regretful and hated himself enough to end his life 😢 what a terrible outcome.
If you're interested in our evangelical scholar's analysis of this moment, read below:
Could Jesus Pray for Judas Iscariot?
SHORT ANSWER: Yes, Jesus could pray for Judas Iscariot. There is no logical contradiction in the idea of Jesus praying for Judas, and there is no indication in Scripture that Jesus would somehow have been prevented from praying for Judas (or any other sinner).
LONG ANSWER: Treating several questions related to this main question.
Did Jesus pray for others? We know that Jesus prayed while on earth (e.g., Matt. 14:23; 26:36-44; Mark 1:35; 6:46; 14:32-39; Luke 3:21; 5:16; 6:12; 9:18, 28-29; 11:1; 22:39-45; John 17:1-26; Heb. 5:7). Furthermore, it seems clear enough that Jesus prayed for other people, with examples that include him praying for children (Matt. 19:13-15); apparently for a demon-possessed person (Mark 9:14-29); for Peter (Luke 22:31-34); for his immediate followers (John 17:6-26), for the people who were crucifying him (Luke 23:34), and even for those of us who would become his followers later on (John 17:20-26). Moreover, Jesus is currently praying for believers (Rom. 8:34; Heb. 7:25). Significant here is that Luke reports that Jesus spent the night in prayer before selecting the men who would be apostles (Luke 6:12-16); it would be odd to suggest that Jesus prayed about eleven of the twelve but did not pray about Judas.
If Jesus and the Father are the same, they share the same will, so how could Jesus pray for Judas? This question has three difficulties, each worth treating on its own.
a) First, the question begins by accidentally sliding into heretical thinking, that is, assuming that Jesus and the Father are "the same." While Jesus and the Father are one and the same God, they are not the same person. This is the mystery of the Trinity. The Father is God, and Jesus is God, and the Holy Spirit is God. But the Father is not the Son, and the Son is not the Spirit, and the Spirit is not the Father. The three persons of the one God are distinct. The Father did not die for our sins; Jesus did. The Holy Spirit did not become incarnate; Jesus did.
b) Second and similarly, the question does not recognize that it is equivocating (i.e., subtly changing the meaning) on the definition of the word "will." While Jesus and the Father share the same "will" in one sense of that word, it is evident that they don't have the same "will" in another sense of that word. This becomes clear when Jesus himself makes a distinction between his will and the Father’s will, which he does in the Garden of Gethsemane while praying(!) (see Matt. 26:36-44; Mark 14:32-39; and Luke 22:39-45). Apparently it is entirely possible for the sinless human will of Jesus to give expression in prayer about a sinless natural desire (like health and safety), and this will of Jesus must ultimately be sacrificed for a greater purpose (i.e., providing salvation for humanity). Perhaps this kind of distinction is behind Jesus's own comment in John 5:30, "I do not seek my own will, but the will of him who sent me." The important christological discussion regarding the two natures of Jesus is not the only distinction. This also surfaces the important theological topic of differentiations of “God’s will” in Scripture. Note for example, that "God our Savior ... desires [i.e., one word for "wills"] all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth” (1 Timothy 2:3-4) and that “the Lord ... is patient toward you, not wishing [i.e., another word for "willing"] that any should perish, but that all should reach repentance” (2 Peter 3:9). But God “wishing/desiring/willing” that no one will perish does not guarantee that all will believe. While he certainly could if he wanted to, it is evident that God does not always override human free will to bring about what he "wants."
c) This brings me to the third sub-point here: prayer is not magic words. Just like any of the rest of us, when Jesus prays, he is not casting a spell that makes things happen exactly as he prays. That is not what prayer is. It is a mistake for us to assume that “the prayer of a righteous person” (cf. James 5:16) gets whatever they ask for as if prayer were like speaking a magic spell; that’s not how the verse in James 5 reads. And the story about the seven sons of Sceva in Acts 19:11-20 warns against praying “in Jesus’s name” as if it were some formula for getting what we want. It is not necessary to suggest that Jesus could pray “about” Judas without praying “for” Judas, as if Judas’s free will would have been destroyed had Jesus prayed “for” him. If that were the case, why wouldn’t Jesus simply pray his magic words “for” every single person in the whole world so that everyone would be saved? Furthermore, we see Jesus expressly say that he had prayed for Peter (Luke 22:31-34), and it apparently was a prayer that did not prevent Peter from sinning but was nevertheless answered in Peter’s repentance. It would be odd to claim that Peter was the only one of his followers for whom Jesus prayed, or to press it further, to suggest that Jesus prayed for all his followers except Judas. That would again be suggesting that prayers-esp. Jesus’s prayers-are something like magic spells that overpoweringly make things happen. In other words, Jesus could pray for Judas without making it automatic that Judas be saved.
Was Judas ever (or never) a believer? This is a good question, but I'm not sure it really matters to any of us now (!). Judas Iscariot was definitely numbered among the twelve apostles (Matt. 10:1-4; Mark 3:13-19; Luke 6:12-16; John 6:70-71), so he was clearly a "follower" of Jesus. Of course, we know that he was not always behaving in a forthright way during those years of following Jesus (e.g., John 12:4-6). Nevertheless, he apparently believed something about Jesus enough to follow him for a few years. But he most famously betrayed Jesus and was replaced as an apostle because he defected from the faith (Acts 1:12-26). Those of an Arminian theological bent might like to argue that Judas was a believer who then gave up his belief; those of Calvinistic theological convictions might like to argue that Judas never was a true believer. To me, it matters little. Perhaps Judas is the quintessential example of false belief, i.e., a person who poses as a disciple but is ultimately not one, and there are other false believers mentioned in the New Testament (e.g., like Simon Magus in Acts 8:9-24; and the people against Jesus in 1 John 2:18-19). But my point here is that there is no need to try to determine the eternal fate of Judas Iscariot as if that would somehow help us recognize any further that he is not a model for any of us to look up to. That is already clear enough.
Was Jesus praying for Judas in John 17? Maybe not, but that is different than saying that Jesus never prayed for Judas. The prayer Jesus prayed in John 17 was not his only prayer, and his statement "I am not praying for the world" (v. 9) is certainly not a pledge to have never ever prayed for the world. After all, Jesus died for the world so that the world could be saved (John 3:16), for the world being saved is what God wants (1 Tim. 2:4; 2 Peter 3:9). So, John 17:9 is not proof that Jesus never ever prayed for Judas or anyone else in "the world"--it is simply a statement that Jesus was praying specifically for his followers in John 17. It seems odd to utilize John 17 to suggest that Jesus would never pray for unbelievers even though he was willing to die for unbelievers. Moreover, the New Testament gives us an example of Jesus praying for unbelievers while he was dying on the cross (Luke 23:34). If Jesus could pray for unbelievers while they were crucifying him it seems that Jesus could pray for Judas even while Judas was planning to betray him.
Could Jesus pray to God the Father asking for Judas Iscariot to not betray him? Why not? In a sense, Jesus's prayer in the Garden of Gethsemane might be said to have entailed just such a wish. Notice what Jesus prayed: “My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from me" (Matt. 26:39a). Jesus's request to have "this cup" of suffering pass from him might well have included Judas's betrayal not happening. But Jesus submits to the bigger plan and prays, "Yet not as I will, but as you will” (Matt. 26:39b). And in God's way of doing things whereby he maintains sovereign control over all even while humans exercise free will, God allows Judas's free choice to betray Jesus, which moves ahead the means of salvation for humanity through Jesus's suffering and resurrection.
@@TheChosenSeries Yes, Jesus
Well if judas would of changed his mind then who would of done the dirty deed second judas was never truly saved to begin with no different than many so called Christians today could judas of changed his mind after he betrayed jesus yes and jesus would of forgave him.
Judas may have had a last minute salvation, even then Jesus Y’Shua would still forgive Judas.
YHVH’s plan had to be played out specifically according to prophecy.
For the record, I love The Chosen. My wife and I have been watching it every night and are now coming to the end of Season 3. I just want to say that nothing in this world is perfect, but you guys have done an amazing job. It’s as lifelike and brilliant as one could hope for.
In my ministry, I face controversy daily-it’s to be expected. With over 47,000 denominations today, controversy is inevitable. I understand that you’ve added some creative elements to the show that aren’t explicitly in the Bible, aiming to bring out the humanity of the story. Personally, I think the show is heartfelt and worthy. In my opinion, it has the potential to renew many people’s faith and even bring people to Yeshua.
I’m a heavy studier of the Scriptures. While I believe the Trinity is a concept influenced by pagan ideas and can be proven incorrect biblically, I understand your intent to remain true to the overarching message. For example, phrases like "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do" were not part of the original manuscripts. Still, you’ve done your best, and the message is strong, even if some errors exist.
The King James Version, for instance, contains added texts that have caused confusion about concepts like the Trinity. As many know, 1 John 5:7 was not in the original manuscripts and has misled people about the chapter’s original meaning. Similarly, added texts can sometimes obscure the truth, such as the example where Yeshua didn’t actually say, "Father, forgive them, for they know not what they do."
Despite these issues, the central message is what truly matters: salvation is for all. It is a gift from our Heavenly Father, and we are called to repent and follow Yeshua’s example. Today, the confusion caused by so many differing interpretations has diluted the basic message. Even foundational truths, like the one true Sabbath, have been distorted and misunderstood, though I find them to be very clear in Scripture.
The Chosen is amazing, but remember, we are called to work out our salvation with fear and trembling. Don’t be disheartened if some things in the show aren’t perfect. The overall message is incredible and a blessing to many.
Don't mind them Dallas , people can't live without drama. Everyone is an expert all of the sudden 😅. Keep up the great work, love the show!
Christ said we need to pray for our enemies. Nuff said.
That's a GREAT point.
Amazing point
Exactly
Thank you
Exactly why people twisting trying to cause confusion
I love that you address these issues that are brought up even tho you don’t have to. As you acknowledge, you have many learned folks who speak to these issues and give you additional guidance. The Chosen is a tv show that has blessed me immensely and brought me back to my Bible over and over! Thank you and I am praying for you and your family!
Peter was DESTINED to become the Rock on which Messiah would build His Church... (Matthew 16:18) and for that reason when Messiah prayed for Peter...it was according to the WILL of the FATHER... (Luke 22:32).
Judas on the other hand was destined to become the Betrayer...(John 6:70) and Messiah will NEVER PRAY against the Father's Will...(John 17:12) You people really need to learn to join the right dots!!! This is leading people astray!
Perhaps jesus was praying that judas would be able to repent afterwards and not hang himself.
@@XatreneDid Judas have the option to repent or didn't he have free will? Perhaps Jesus was praying for Judas to repent.
@@XatrenePerhaps perhaps jesus was praying that judas would be able to repent .
@@Xatrene.. after Judas had betrayed Him.
In the bible it literally says that Jesus prayed. End of story. Keep doing you, Dallas. The Chosen family is fantastic and your team is phenomenal! This show brings so much peace and love and happiness to multitudes.
Here here! Have a great Christmas everyone!
@@ReginaldStaples Christmas has none to do with the jesus
Whaaaaaat is this.
Christmas is when Christ was born in Bethlehem.
Guys I get your Santa Claus. But this is just something.
We don’t have any Santa Claus, we have little baby Jesus that brings gifts to our children in December. Heloooooo?
Christmas has none to do?
Bro. Set your records straight
I'm just shaking my head and rolling my eyes. People are looking for reasons to try and discredit the show and will make things up in an attempt to achieve their goal. It's sad how so many people have lost the ability to think, reason, and discern. A majority of the issues people have with the show fall into this category. The "problem" with the show is it challenges peoples pre-conceived ideas and beliefs. They do not and refuse to think outside the box, outside of their beliefs. Dallas & Co, PLEASE keep doing what you're doing. God is using it to truly change lives.
My thoughts exactly! 💜✝️
JESUS did live between the lines, not every second of HIS life is recorded!!! Go with God Dallas, that's the only approval you need. 🙏 Do not be discouraged 🙏. Millions have found JESUS through your GOD inspired series! Don't stop! 🙏
Exactly I saw Twitter posts saying "we warned you about this show" and then when I watched the scene I was ???? warned about what!? That they would portray Jesus' unshakeable love and compassion for others even when they plan to betray or hurt Him? Because that's exactly what Jesus's nature is and the Father desires for no one to perish. So I was so confused, they did a perfect job and I am annoyed by how many people just want to pick at the show and ruin its reputation for no reason. What does it say about their spirits that they want to destroy a show that has been converting tens of thousands to Christ? So weird...
I totally agree. After all this is kust a TV show. I habe enjoyed it so much.
AMEN!!!
This makes me so sad. That scene was so beautiful. It made me realize I am Judas coming to Jesus with my unmet expectations. They are focusing on the wrong things.
Exactly this
Funny....they are focusing on the wrong things - just like Judas!
This is my view as well
This part right here
I missed the scene
Keep exploring, keep searching,keep asking ,keep talking Jesus. I believe you got it right. 🙌🙏🙌
I’m 1 of hundreds of millions that find no problem with that scene , it was very powerful .
I AGREE! Very POWERFUL!!!
And the majority of the people also crucified Jesus. Majority approval does not equal innocence. Try again.
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼@@isaaccooper9258
Jesus already knew what Judas was going to do. Jesus prayed for everyone
True. I think of it until now.
Dallas, you absolutely did not get this wrong! Remember our role…loaves and fishes…keep doing what you’re doing! May God continue to bless you and The Chosen 🙏
"But even if we, or an angel from heaven, should preach to you a gospel contrary to what we have preached to you, he is to be accursed!"
To paraphrase an animated tropical fish "Just keep praying. Just keep praying."
Dallas, you had everything wrong. The Jesus from your show is a false Jesus.
@@user-te3gl1dh3c Exactly! The person posting the snippet from the bible (out of context) is just trying to act holier than thou.
He definitely got it wrong. It is an unbiblical scene. The derision here is why this series is so dangerous. The Word of God is all we need. Not made up scenes for the benefit of Hollywood. This scene and its dialogue are not found in Scripture. WAKE UP Christians.
Dallas is so humble, reasonable, and wise. We don’t completely share the same theology, but I look up to him and respect him.
I actually loved that Jesus said He would pray for Judas. He was Jesus, Son of God. He loved Judas. Even though He knew what Judas was going to do, He still loved Him. Thank you, Dallas and your whole team, for all the hard work and for helping me to understand the Holy Bible. It was such a heavy scene for me to watch with Judas, but it helped me see and realize all the suffering Jesus went through even before the cross. That scene you showed was so powerful and heavy, and Im so thankful I got to watch it. The Lord wants us to pray for all. That doesn't mean only certain people or don't pray for people who upset you. Pray for All. I want to have faith like my Jesus. Where I pray for all, even those who hate me, call me names. Thank you and May the Lord Bless you all.
amy_loves_the_chosen, I agree with you! And I believe the devil has reared his ugly head to try to discourage people from the Gospel! Love "The Chosen"!!! ❤❤❤
Agree! Now, if only the holier than thou crowd could get it too.
Thats what I said too . That its very plausible even though he knew he still prayed for him
That's what I said too its very plausible that even though he knew he still prayed for him
I can believe that Jesus could pray for Judas to have God's peace over him, for about what the choice was that he was considering making & would do, in, actually, God's service, to fulfill what Jesus came to be with us, to do, for our salvation. 🤲🙏🫶
Jesus wanted Judas to change. He wanted to save all souls . Don't believe people are so picky. It's a great show. Keep up the good work.
Judas was chosen because he was a devil. He came to die for the sin of the world, to take our punishment. Don’t call the Lord Jesus Christ a liar.
@@nickma71i dont understand your statements. Can u please elaborate??
@@nickma71 judas was not a devil as he first followed Jesus. The devil did temp him an he was sorry afterwards. Don't think a devil would hang himself.
@@andrewjoyce7374 I can. I recommend you study scripture. Or repent if you think this is a "gotcha", which doesn't work with those who rightly divide.
Jesus came as the messiah of Israel. He will unite the divided kingdom, take away the sin of the nation, rule from Jerusalem, and restore them. This is prophecy. It was in the open. Dying for sin was hidden in scripture. God says it in the Bible, through his spokesmen (prophets again). When Jesus told them he was going to be delivered up, the meaning was hidden from them by God. It had to be hidden. Are you following along? I will continue.
Show being the operative word.
I like the conversation in the controversy. The struggle is real and a conversation about Jesus the Son and God the Father is always good. I will never understand everything written in the Bible, but the discussion draws me closer to my Creator. Thank you for the conversation starter Dallas. God will use it all. God is in control and I trust God. Amen
I'm using The Chosen and controversies to further study and understand Jesus and His work on earth. But I don't appreciate the over-reaction of some to the point that they call Dallas a heretic?
@bettebeane536 I try to remember that God uses it all and be thankful for the difficulties that I need to find Him in.
Scripture tells us that someday we will know even as we are known. Until then, "live justly, love mercy, and walk humbly with your God."
Fortunately God is more merciful than most Christians (and I’m including myself in that). He sent Jesus to save everyone and not one of us fully understands every nuance of free will vs God’s foreknowledge, fulfilling His purpose etc….and that includes Dallas and the writers of this show. I thank God for the work all involved in The Chosen are doing. ❤
@@NEChristo Perfectly stated. The Chosen draws me to Jesus, I can feel the Spirit instructing and calming my soul with the loving, merciful Jesus who died for everyone. Every one. The show draws me to Jesus, these arguments make me want to run for the hills away from “ Christians”.
@ I totally understand yet Jesus teaches us that loving God and others are the foundation of all the commandments-all the law is summed up in loving and forgiving one another. It’s not easy to do, impossible without His grace really, but we’ve got to remember we’re all messed up in this world 😂 that’s why we need Him. 🤍 love to you!
@@NEChristo This is not my experience with Christians today but I still am drawn to Jesus. If he would die a brutal, tortuous death for Judas, who he loved, why wouldn’t he pray for him? If my son committed some terrible crime I would be heart broken but I would pray for him. How can this possibly be a bone of contention among people who call themselves followers of Christ.
Well said.
@NEChristo in your initial comment you mention not understanding every nuance of free will and God's foreknowledge and I think I can help you out.
When you say "free will" are you importing that idea from culture or getting it explicitly from Scripture? You'll recall that The Bible often refers to our will as being enslaved to sin.
Regarding God's foreknowledge, how are you defining that word? Do you mean that God looks down the corridors of time and sees events and therefore knows events?
The Biblical understanding of foreknowledge is to "know" beforehand; "know" in the intimate sense of the word (ginosko), whereas you may be using "know" in the general sense (oidas, to know of).
Dallas,
I thought that scene between Jesus and Judas was awesome. I believe Jesus prays for us all. Jesus created us all.
I am so looking forward to Season Five of The Chosen. I keep re- watching The Chosen seasons 1-4 over and over. I Love The Chosen!
Merry Christmas and a Blessed New Yeat.
Thanks for helping us reach 1 billion people with the authentic Jesus.
Me too
Jesus says specifically in John that He DOES NOT pray for the world but only His sheep
@@ScribeAlicious That is one specific prayer. Read the rest of the Bible.
@@TheChosenSeries as trevas odeiam a luz...lembrem-se disso! Toda sorte de impedimento e de dissabores virão. Apenas continuem caminhando.❤
I dont see many other TV series creators having to explain thier decisions as much as you do. Peopl need be thankful for all you and everyone involed put into this. Thank you
Thank you. For those who believe there needs no explanation. For those who do not there is no explanation possible. Thank you for your show.❤
Perfectly said ❤
Thanks for once again going the extra mile, Dallas. I found it completely plausible that in his frustration and sorrow over Judas, Jesus would pray for him. Continued prayers as you finish editing Season 5 and writing Season 6.
Praise Jesus for controversy I hope more people find Jesus Christ
People are reacting, therefore, thinking about these things!
To all those so critical of this scene, I would suggest putting all this energy into this: Love the Lord with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind, and love your neighbor as yourself.
Or how about the scene opened up a discussion when people could have been talking about the Kardashians etc. This guy has ruined this show with his ego, period. Rolling his eyes at questions? wow
@@christinetuttle8975what? 💀
@@croqsieur Try harder, I aint here to splain it to ya Lucy. If ya don't get it, don't let people know; it is a sign of weakness.
If ya think "what" is a clever resonse, you carry on sport.
@@christinetuttle8975, Dallas works very, very hard, I believe his motives in this show are God honouring, we the viewers all come from different walks of life. There is ONE thing that Jesus makes, perfectly perfectly clear in the Bible, His wish is for us believers to get along, and pursue unity!!, did YOU get that??. Despite your differences in opinion, JESUS has a mandate for you. Do your part in seeking unity not division!, this is not big enough to squabble over. This is NOT a core doctrine or belief, you are allowed to have a different opinion, but not to sow seeds of division that May harm other viewers. Rolling eyes??. Come on who cares. Pls, for the sake of the gospel keep your thots and opinions to yourself, pls, y thank you,
@christinetuttle8975 find Jesus. You clearly don’t have Him. If Jesus weeping or having any sort of emotion offends you, you haven’t read the Bible. One of the most famous verses is “Jesus wept” (John 11:35). If you lived during Jesus’ time, you would’ve been one of the people who demanded His death because He didn’t fit your version of what the Messiah should be.
Jesus prayed to the Father to forgive those who were nailng him to the cross! Amen from a Catholic
Amen!
If you believe in Christ for your salvation is all that matters, not our denomination. God bless.
He did not pray for Satan
Because they were all ordain to sacrifice the most holy sacrificed. He is a true Passover lamb . He takes away the sin of the world., he did not come to rub our sins in , he came to rub it out, never to feel guilty again when we give our life to him , we become a new creation in Christ Born Again , he gave us the right to become and a child of God, don’t you religious he did not come for us to be religious he came for us to be born again to give us a second chance in life not to be catholic not to be Protestant, or Baptist but Born Again spiritually . He came to fulfil Judaism., the nations will go up to Jerusalem to celebrate the feast of the Tabernacle, the Catholic Church was the first religion that was created and through their teaching they denied the world from celebrating God’s feast. Days
The Jews CELEBRATE , his feast days ! but here is the kicker ! if our father in heaven is Jewish, and we are grafted as a believer we are adopted we are Jewish, it’s not the circumcision of the foreskin but circumcision of the heart .
Jesus said to Nicodemus, you are Israel’s teacher how it is you don’t know these things ? he was referring to Eze 37:24-38 . Salvation belong to the Jew first then to the Gentiles. Paul said there is no difference between Jew or Gentile we worship the same God.
Yes !
Thank you. I agree it’s good to think about, talk about, and study these topics. We can never get to the bottom of biblical insight. There’s always more to God. Grace and peace to you.
Jesus prays for us…He came for sinners. What an inspiring show! Thank you Dallas. I am grateful for your work. God bless you and your family, the cast and crew of The Chosen. Christmas Blessings! You are in my prayer..
Thanks for keeping us in your prayers.
Praying for you Dallas. May God strengthen you and all involved as you bring this before the masses. Fear not. God is with you.
You wont please everyone but this LDS guy adores the chosen and what youre doing. We await the new season with great anticipation and wear our Chosen hoodies all over Nashville.
I look at it this way, this show has intrigued millions and has brought people back to God and new people to God. This show has persuaded people to open their bibles and actually read them. It's great if people are seeing things that are not quite in the scripture and asking questions, but it is a TV show, and the Lord is definitely behind it.
All to the Glory of God ❤
God has used pagans to bring people to the truth of the Gospel. We don’t assume paganism is right because of it.
I love the chosen, despite its sometimes poor theology. Just wanted to he fair here
@@ScribeAlicious he also used false prophets and pastors . Boy are they shaking in their boots atm as Jesus is exposing them all for their deeds . Daystar is the latest ..
@@ScribeAlicious I have to disagree with "poor theology". Rare instances yes, but the vast majority is on target with God's Word. I use The Chosen as a way to study and think more deeply about many things in God's Word.
Thank you Dallas for your patience in describing and caring for others perceptions. I'll be praying for you and everyone involved in the show to have GOD's strength , wisdom , and courage as you bring this message to the world. Armor Up!
All I have to say is thank you for bringing us this beautiful, powerful show that's brought so many people closer to Jesus and their faith. Thank YOU & God Bless!
I hope Jesus prays for me!!!! Don’t let it worry you! We understand!!!! You got it 100% right!!!!
So because you hope Jesus prays for you and it feels good hes correct? I'm not saying he's not right but when you use emotions instead of logic, your part of the problem we battle against with the atheist
Luke 22:32-34
King James Version
32 But I have prayed for thee, that thy faith fail not: and when thou art converted, strengthen thy brethren.
He did and He does!
That's one of the greatest things about reading the book of John. When you get to Jesus' prayer in the Garden of Gethsemane in Chapter 17, you realize as you're reading it that Jesus specifically prayed for you AND me in that moment that we would believe and be committed to the Father. When I first realized that, I was moved to tears.
Ronda Jesus actually is in Heaven now does pray for you nonStop FACT
Thank you so much Chosen Team for taking the time to carefully share your thoughts, opinions and reasons for your scene choices! You guys are so busy and still take the time to explain with biblical backing your choices. This just shows how much you love others and the sincerity of the shows goal to bring people to Jesus. Love you guys and so appreciate you!
Thank you, Dallas, thank you for clarification and most of all thank you for The Chosen series! Love it 😍
Glad you spoke of Gethsemane. Your will not mine is the human side of Jesus. Love the scene with Judas. So powerfully showed Jesus's sadness and love for Judas.
You’re doing a wonderful job with this series!!
Thank you for bringing it to life for us!!
✝️💖🙏
Dallas, I continue to pray for God's blessing upon The Chosen to reach people throughout this world🙏❤️👍‼️ I also pray for those that are trying to come against this work. May God break through the veneer, crust, or stone hearts to the blessed truth of Jesus' death, resurrection and ascension to the Father's throne. I believe that God's Hand is truly upon this "show" , so as many of my elders have said; "Don't sweat the small stuff" . May you continue to walk in the truth and light of the love of Jesus Christ. Leave the rest of it in the hands of the Holy Spirit 😘👍🙏❤️‼️
God has used your show to bring people closer to His Son. This showed is blessed by the King of the Universe! Don’t listen to the hissing snakes. The Devil has been trying to tear down God’s work. God bless you and your cast and families!! I can’t wait for Season 5 and I just bought the first 4 seasons. I had no clue the home base was in E Texas. I’m just across the line in Shreveport. I’m praying for this show and thank you.
Some of these things that people have issues with I find to be very annoying, but what I do love about it is when Dallas gets the opportunity to address the issues and how he handles it. He’s always clear about not trying to satisfy people‘s opinions or getting into debates, but providing clarity and in the clarity, he always shows the intent behind the scene and how they already prepared for things like that with the team that he has of scholars reviewing the scripts. That’s what I love!Because everything he said made sense and truly is the way that I view Jesus based on the Scriptures and based on what I know, Jesus heart to be. Bravo!
Appreciate your continued support, Anfani.
@ 🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽🫶🏽
And for every episode, every season, there is a Bible roundtable. Incredible and informative discussions there. More people should watch those rather than complain online before their understanding is complete.
@ exactly
Hi Dallas: I am a practicing Catholic and you nailed it. It's too bad you have to defend yourself a lot of times, but you do it w grace and dignity. Keep up the GREAT work that you All do.
My husband and I pray for the cast and crew, you and your beautiful wife Amanda, (inside and out), every single day. 🙏
Why is your denominational tag needed? Declaring to be a 'follower of Jesus' is more impt.
We truly feel your prayers. Thank you.
You are not wrong. This series has been a true miracle for my spiritual life . From the first season every episode has drawn me closer to growing closer to the Saviour. It opened my eyes to reality and wanting to understand that even back then His disciples were human and nothing has changed. The way they are portrayed allows me to recognize myself in each of them. Blessings to you and the Chosen family. Thank you for igniting fire innmy soul. Also I have gone to the Word and I have found nothing not found in the scriptures.
Some people really don't understand the whole TV show artistic license thing, do they.
The Chosen is awesome. ♥️🕊️🔥
Dude my wife and I loved The Best Christmas pageant ever. Thank you for your hard work to Jesus in the Chosen and the Christmas pageant movie.
I believe it will be a classic in the long run.
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever was absolutely incredible! It was funny, entertaining, touching, poignant and inspiring! Thank you, Dallas! The Chosen is magnificent. I have gained so much watching these episodes knowing it’s a human presentation of God’s Word. Again, thank you.
Was it as good as the first film? I would like to see it, but my wife is a HUGE fan of the original film, and thinks it would be an insult to watch the new one. 😢😢😢
@@chrisblanc663 personally I like the new one better!
I didn't watch the scene nor will I until the new season I try to stay away from spoilers especially when I know I am going to watch regardless. I am here to say Thank you for everything you and the team has done. Great breakdown and I agree with the views.
I will not watch anything about season 5 no teasers until the entire season is released.
@@barbaragalliera9846 agreed
Even the demons believe who Jesus is. That is scriptural. Good explaination! ❤ Love The Chosen!
Jesus did not die for demons. That verse was to encourage the church to start walking as the Saints they already are positionally before God.
Absolutely right madam..❤
Short but very well said.
He definitely got it wrong. It is an unbiblical scene. The derision here is why this series is so dangerous. The Word of God is all we need. Not made up scenes for the benefit of Hollywood. This scene and its dialogue are not found in Scripture. WAKE UP Christians.
Oh Dallas...as usual you answer with such grace and humility! Thank you for showing us Jesus in your actions and words! May The Father continue to bless you and yours and all your efforts!
Dallas, I trust and believe that you will continue to do what you feel is right according to God's will for the Chosen show. I feel that any little discrepancy that may occur doesn't matter because in the bigger scheme of things you are leading so, so many people to come to Jesus. So try not to let others discourage you. Keep up the great work❣
I think you got it right, Dallas. Having two natures [human and Divine] can only be half understood by us [humans]. The Divine part of His nature is not fully comprehendible. With that being said, of course he would want to pray for someone he loved, it's the human thing to do. Attempting to explain his Divine nature is a slippery slope and best left to God [the Trinity]. Phenomenal work by the entire cast and crew, I can't wait for season 5.
Since Jesus was human I believe any human would be affected by the fact that their friend is about to betray them. I think you got it exactly right. I was moved by that scene.
You don't have to explain yourself, Dallas. Ignore the haters.
Foreknowledge does not equal causation. Probably the hardest thing for human beings confined to space and time is to comprehend our God is outside of space and time. Sorry, but movies like back to the future, when mere humans can change the outcome of actual history is NOT realistic.
What we know is that Jesus is God. JESUS EXISTED in heaven with God before he condescended to become human for our sakes, pleading with the Father that if there is any other way for humans to be saved, let this cup pass, but if there is no other way, I submit to your (our) will... yes I know I took some creative license, but it actually shows that Jesus is the only way, and as gruesome as the crucifixion was, it was the only way to provide for our salvation!!
Just because Judas's acts were prophesied does NOT mean they were caused by God.
Luke 22:32-34
King James Version
32 But I have prayed for thee, that thy faith fail not: and when thou art converted, strengthen thy brethren.
Amene!! Thank you my Jesus ❤
But he is saying this to Simon Peter,not Judas,don't use verses out of context. This is lying.
@ read John 14 through 17 … where Jesus prays not only for His deciples , but for us
@@jackmommiesg is this the right verse? said,
“While I was with them in the world, I kept them in Your name. Those whom You gave Me I have kept; and none of them is lost except the son of perdition” (Judas) (John 17:12).
@@jackmommiesg John 17:9 I pray for them. I am not praying for the world, but for those you have given me, for they are yours.
Jesus still prays for us Dallas !! God the Father prays for us , and the Holy Spirit prays for us when words fail , says He groans … can you imagine 🥹🥹🥹
“In the same way the Spirit also comes to help us, weak as we are. For we do not know how we ought to pray; the Spirit himself pleads with God for us in groans that words cannot express.”
Romans 8:26
I thought the scene was beautiful. It actually made me cry! 😢❤
Dallas, thank you for making this beautiful show. I struggle from severe complex PTSD and I can’t tell you how much it has helped me❤
It means so much to us knowing that the show has been an encouragement to you.
Oh Dallas! I am still on your side! I found the scene to be very moving, and PLAUSIBLE. I don't understand why all these people are so proud as to believe that they have solved 2000 years of debate, nor do I agree that you are heretical. As believers, we choose our theological camps, based on our FLAWED understanding of the Bible. That same pride has caused the many schisms in the Church. May you not be wounded by such landmines. God bless you for sticking your neck out for the Chosen. I love it.
I am SO THANKFUL for your wonderful work in creating and producing The Chosen. Jesus came and He KNEW He would be betrayed and that He would die on the cross, dying for us all. Could it be that Jesus prayed for Judas and how Judas would feel after he would betray Him? I feel that The Chosen is such an amazing work. I hope it will encourage those who are naysayers to open their Bibles and agree to disagree with those who disagree with their view on such a topic as this. The Bible is all about John 3:16.
That is a great point. Jesus was so loving that also think he could have been referring to praying for Judas to deal with betraying him after the fact!! 🙏🏻
We love you Dallas and the whole Chosen Team! Please keep doing what you all are doing. The Chosen is changing lives🩵
So true, it's changed my life and I've come back to a more spiritual life, prayers and reading my Bible. That is because of watching the Chosen.
Folks just need to enjoy this beautiful series. ❤
Amen!
One can watch and enjoy it and simultaneously acknowledge when something is just not biblical. They're not mutually exclusive. I enjoy the series, but some of the choices are a reach.
Folks need to stay grounded in truth, which is Gods word through scripture.
Amen ❤️ 🙏
No, my enjoyment was BECAUSE it was Biblically Correct!
No matter…The Chosen helps human SEE JESUS. Great work. Keep going. The Chosen helped bring ME to Jesus, 100%
Another Jesus
This is an age old topic of inquiry. This issue was going to come up no matter how you portrayed it!. I remember my grandfather, born in the 1880s, talking about this. He was a farmer not a scholar. But he rolled the whole thing around in his mind and asked questions. You did a good and thorough job of explaining this as best anyone could. Enjoy your family this holiday season.
The Chosen is an amazing television drama. It's made me appreciate my own faith, the struggles my ancestors went through from every corner of the world it gave me curiosity watching about "life in the first century" architectural sites, foods, teachings, political atmosphere.
It is absolutely plausible that Jesus is praying for Judas' Heart.
Yes, I believe He would pray for his change of heart. He did pray to His Father in the garden to have this cup taken from Him.
Plausible is one thing. Actually written in scripture is another
I loved the scene and couldn’t think of another way our Lord would feel after realizing that this soul would be lost. In His infinite mercy how else would he see one of us ?
Your doing awesome. Best series ever. You've given food for thought and have sparked conversations. Keep up the good work.
I pray all works for good! I’m very happy this show promotes me to study more. Seek and you shall find.
Thank you so very much for your love and commitment for spreading the Word. May the Lord bless you always. Merry Christmas.
In the story of 'The name of the Rose' there was a huge barney over whether Jesus owned the clothes he wore.
There was nearly a fist fight among high ranking clerics over this question.
Dallas, you're doing fantastic work and are loved for the wonderful thing you've done with 'The Chosen'. My church is showing an interest and we're having wonderful discussions about it. We're loving it, as it is, and whatever arguments arise they can't harm this work you're doing. Jesus will give you the answers you need, you can rely on that.
God bless.
🌹
The scene was powerful. It showed how we can have a different agenda from God, and think we know best because we have certain skills, or outlook. Forgetting that our ways and thoughts are not His. The scene was played excellently. When Judas stood up, his offense had taken its final root. His words and actions after that spoke volumes. May none of us get to the place that we think we know more than God. May we always practice humility even when we don’t understand. Praise the Name of Jesus for all prayers and intercession He does on our behalf. And may we always side with His will.
Jesus loves each of us. What you have started is conversation which is very important. There is always controversy in everything. Important point. People are watching. 🙏Deborah. North Carolina ❤
You in the show have got me to rekindle my faith and to take a long hard look at myself. Keep doing what you’re doing, man. Your job is just to bring them in. That’s his job to sort us out.
It wouldn't be a season of The Chosen without a controversy due to certain people over reacting.
The heart of Jesus was that all should be saved. But reality and direction is already in play.
We pray for our enemies. The Lord’s Prayer needs to be something we live. Jesus prayed as he lived.❤
Jesus loves you all!
Hang in there brother - keep doing the good work that you are doing. :-)
I was talking to my family about this scene last night and I actually told them "If anything, I would find it MORE strange if Jesus just watched Judas fall away and didn't care at all about him" and they said "Same! It would be unlike His nature to not care or want the best for Judas" It just makes no sense. Scripture says God desires for NO one to perish, and Jesus did pray for everyone, John 17 is dedicated to Jesus' prayer to the Father. Yes in John 17:12 He did say Judas was the only one who He lost as Scripture prophesied but it's not because He wanted him to or made him fall away, it's because Jesus knows the beginning from the end and knew what kind of decision Judas would ultimately make. In the way that I saw it, this section from the Bible doesn't refute that Jesus could have prayed for Judas before he got to that point.. He could've prayed for him earlier on but knew what choice he would ultimately make, and that's why in John 17 He said He lost Judas. So my family and I were scratching our heads at what was so controversial, it was a perfectly well made scene that showed Jesus' compassion for Judas, unlike other movies that made it seem like He didn't love him, which always made me sad, because Jesus' nature is to love, so it's not like He loved Peter who denied Him 3 times, but hated Judas, He loved both. He loved Judas despite knowing that he would betray Him. He even added "do what you came for, friend" in Matthew 26:50, a cutting remark to show Judas that they had a good relationship and he betrayed him just like that. And just because something isn't explicitly written in the Bible, it doesn't mean that it couldn't have happened. The Gospels are more of a summary than a word-for-word recording of everything that happened, John said if he wrote everything that Jesus did, there would never be enough space. So it wouldn't surprise me at all if in that unwritten part, Jesus prayed for Judas. In fact, the opposite would surprise me more. You guys did a perfect job portraying Jesus' loving nature that is not contingent on how the recipient acts. HE loves. And yes of course, Judas is still condemned because of his choice and for removing the chance to ask for forgiveness, but Jesus still loved him
Beautifully said!
I think it’s not the betrayal he was concerned for, but the fact that Judas never repented and committed suicide. He didn’t believe the way Peter did
Well said!!
@JDog2656 I mean his suicide is a sign that he felt very bad about what he'd done and regretted it. But he ruined his chance of forgiveness. He should've gone to Jesus and asked for forgiveness 😢 Jesus would've forgiven him. But I imagine he didn't think that was possible because of what he did
@@cynthiat6505 Thank you!
I’m surprised by the controversy. But, you did a very good job explaining your thoughts behind the scene. Very good. Love the work you are doing, and love the Chosen.
You all did it just fine! Thanks to all of you, for Your very hard work! Gods continued Blessings for all! 🙏🕊️🙏
I took it that Jesus was praying for Judas soul because he knew what he was going to do, not to try to stop it as it was the cup he had to drink from.
Yes.
God creates everyone. Some for a dark purpose. When I read that Jesus ministered to the dead while in the grave I think hey Judas was there. He could have comforted him. He now fully Knowing exactly why he was “there”. To fulfill the scriptures.
This Jewish woman has so deeply appreciated the sensitivity of your series. I think this is the first Jesus show that shows the deep Jewish roots of Jesus and the disciples well told.
It’s also wonderful to see the dark skinned Middle East Jesus after just seeing Bonhoeffer and recalling the Nazi’s aryan Jesus.
I’ve learned a lot and I’m deeply moved and grateful for this series. Thank you Dallas. It’s healing and uplifting to watch this. I think you have done a phenomenal job.
Thank you for sharing, Rachel. We appreciate your kind words.
Hallelujah sister!
Dallas, I see pain. I am heartbroken. You, your creative team and your consultants are doing a marvelous job. We love you all and trust your desire to combine the Bible and needed creative together to make God proud.
🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾
Agreed
“Trust your desire to combine the Bible ‘and needed creative together to “make God proud”. What? I don’t understand your comment. This show was needed “to make God proud”. Have you read or studied any of The Bible? Are you aware that The script for The Chosen ONLY uses GOD’S Word 5% of the time? This means that the show is a 95% imagination! How is this show that is 95% of the writer’s imagination going to make God proud? Just trying to understand.
Dallas, just KNOW, I trust you and your choices, as I'm sure 99.9% of us all do. You brought me back to reading the Bible EVERYDAY! God Bless you. ❤ Praise Jesus 🙏
I think people/critics just try to nitpick entirely too much. Misery loves company. The Chosen is designed to motivate people to dive into The Word. While it is based on Biblical truths and scripture, people need to open their Bible and find answers themselves. My 11 year old daughter LOVES this show sooo much and it was a catalyst that inspired her to dive into her Bible, to seek a close relationship with our Father and she professed her faith through baptism! We own all 4 seasons on blu-ray and we often rewatch them. New questions arise every time and we always refer to scripture. Thank you, Dallas, for your dedication & commitment to getting it right! The hard work that you & your team put into this is absolutely amazing. Your heart is true! We have shared The Chosen with our pastor and many members of our church family. It really helps to see people from our Bible “come to life” and to see that they were real people with real feelings and situations. I am a visual person and I am so thankful for The Chosen! God bless you, your family, & all of the cast & crew of The Chosen!
I could not agree any more with you @amandaRNnNC.
I loved that scene. The love and compassion Jesus had was so real. Jesus even prayed in the garden of Gethsemane to let that cup pass, but God's will be done. Jesus is our intercessor who prays for us to the Father even now.
The controversial Judas scene left me weeping as I confessed the many times I, like Judas, have broken Jesus's heart & made Him cry.
Watching others react w/animosity caused more tears as I realize they prefer to strain at gnats rather than humbling themselves before God. So, like Jesus, I pray for them to be moved by the Holy Spirit and believe on Him.
The only issue I see is Judas and the predestination question. We, me and family, watched the trailer and end up having a very long theological discussion about Judas, human agency, salvation and freewill. Thank you Dallas for providing feedback.
Judas was 100% predestined to turn Jesus in and do everything he ended up doing though
It was the father's will
An all powerful god that predestines some to succeed and some to fail is not a benevolent being. The only way to logically justify the existence of a loving God is to accept that everyone is impacted by their choices and the choices of others. God allows us to choose to follow him or not and his arms are always outstretched with the invitation to come follow me. The adversarial forces of this world will continue to try to influence us to make choices to limit the ability to choose. Goodness leads to greater agency, wickedness seeks to control and bind. Predestination is the phylosophical encapsulation of humankind's attempt to understand the complexity of life. As the saying goes we can't "see the forest for the trees". It's not possible for us to comprehend the effects of all the choices people make or why things happen. An all-knowing Father in heaven does hold the power to comprehend in realtime the precise future that will unfold based on the choices being made by every person in this world. Like an awesome GPS, you make a wrong turn, and God "recalculates" the path forward.
Dallas! Fantastically said! We love you and your entire crew! Keep up the awesome work and praying for rest from your ever resisting enemies!💕🙏🙌🎉
When Jesus asked Judas "Who has your heart? I want it" it broke me in pieces. I mean, Jesus gave us free will, we're allowed to choose what we want to do, the problem here isn't that Judas betrayed Him, because this was God's plan, but the problem is that he decided to take his own life bc he regretted what he did. For me, I saw Jesus's question not as he didn't want Judas to hand Him over to the Romans, bc this what Judas needed to do, but Jesus didn't want Judas to give his life and soul to the evil.
I think you did a great job in Judas and Jesus relationship, bc with The Chosen we can understand a bit what was Judas motivations
Jesus would have known Judas was going to kill himself. I can imagine, if nothing else, Jesus was pleading for Judas' life. If Judas had lived long enough for the resurrection, it's possible he could have been reconciled to Christ. Why are the critics so stirred up about Jesus praying for any of humanity??
I think it definitely is a problem that Judas betrayed Him, God didn't make Judas do that, he chose it himself
@@cynthiabush1784Judas died before the resurrection, thus salvation, so he will have a chance to be eternally saved, just as others who died before Jesus was crucified; I cannot believe Judas is the one man in history with no chance of salvation because he died before Jesus was crucified.
Appreciate ur addressing these things that pop up.
Beautifully explained as always! So grateful for you and everyone on the team’s attention to everything. Thank you so much!
Not that I feel you needed to explain, because I thought the scene between Jesus and Judas was beautifully done.. Thank you for explaining your thoughts and reason why.. BIG HUGE FAN!!
And how many of us have wondered if God really knows what He is doing? How many of us have challenged or even been angry or disappointed with God? How many of us have betrayed or denied our Lord? We are all Judas. We are all Thomas. We are all Simon Peter.
Well said , Amen we all fall short.
I haven't seen the scene yet, but I love the idea of Jesus saying he would pray for Judas. Jesus lived what He preached.
Dallas you have a hard job. Thanks for all you do. I can tell your intentions are good.
You did NOT get this wrong Dallas. This is amazing!!!
He definitely got it wrong. It is an unbiblical scene. The derision here is why this series is so dangerous. The Word of God is all we need. Not made up scenes for the benefit of Hollywood. This scene and its dialogue are not found in Scripture. WAKE UP Christians.
@@enterprisecreations1492 This series isn't hollywood.
@@enterprisecreations1492 We don't really know what George Washington said in the boat when crossing the Delaware, either; it's called artistic license, and as long as the facts are right, I'm okay with it.
Do you remember all the crap Jewish people gave Mel Gibson in the of 'The Passion'?.
Dallas, you are doing an incredible job! Don't let these bumps bring you down. Heavenly Father is well pleased.
Geezzzzzzz PPL!!! Keep up the great work Dallas!
I took as Jesus saying that he will pray for Judas so that after he does what he's supposed to do, that way judas will repent and be saved even after he betrayed Jesus.
Jesus wouldn't have prayed for Judas to change his mind bc the betrayal had to happen, but he could've prayed sp that Judas repented AFTER
@@lianet777 I totally agree.
My thoughts exactly. Judas despaired. Peter repented.
My thoughts exactly!
Judas did not repent. Judas is in his own place that he deserves, Acts 1:15
I also feel that’s was Jesus meant when He said that! In John 17 Jesus prayers for all his followers including us!
It's amazing how many "Pharisees, Sadducees and Teachers of the law" are still around.
Isn't it though?
Apparently Jesus knew this would be a persistent problem 😔
@@kimartist It's very disappointing.....
Great scene. People have to stop picking everything apart. Jesus prayed for many people, even His enemies. Keep doing what you are doing. It is AWESOME❤️🙏🏻✝️
Appreciate that. Means a lot.
Remember always what you and all the support cast, workers, and staff have accomplished, in being obedient to God’s purpose for this present day. We are so close to our eternal home, when we look at the souls being reached with the Gospel of Christ, the other Countries, the translations that I or any one of us could not have done. I thank God for all you have done. From its beginnings until now you have spoken to and reached out the hand of Gods love and truth to faces I’ll never see. During the pandemic when so many churches, pastors, and Christians effort’s were muffled, thru you answering God’s call on your life, “Hope “was shed abroad. So remember there will always be the doughtier, the naysayer, ad skeptic. I loved the scene and felt it made me think of Christ, the man of sorrows. Your series has been such a blessing to me, my family. I pray God give you peace, strength , and joy. When God said Go into all the world, you continue to respond in such beautiful and careful ways the urgent message of God’s love. Thank you again. God bless you always. ( sorry it’s so long. ❤)
YOU ARE JUST FINE!!!!❤❤❤ We love you and will continue to support and pray for all of you. Ignore the trolls.
Why are you referring to people who would prefer more Biblical content than Dallas’ imagination “trolls”.
From my perspective, I don't know that Judas ever stopped believing. It seems to me that his betrayal wasn't driven, necessarily, by unbelief but by a misguided belief that he was, in some way, helping the "revolution" that he (and many others) were expecting to take place at the coming of the Messiah. I don't think he believed Jesus would be killed. I think he believed Jesus would, ultimately, take "his rightful place" as King. But that's just my speculation, especially given his obvious regret of that betrayal afterwards.
That is a very plausible thought. The man who walks on water and raises the dead should be able to defeat the Romans with a wave of his hand. What Judas didn't get was that that was not the mission.
Whatever was in Judas's mind, he was chosen for this task.
Well, that's the way the Ian McShane version was written.
That makes sense, Judas even went back to the temple to ask for Jesus' release, and threw away his coins, when he realized what a big mistake he made. He was very regretful and hated himself enough to end his life 😢 what a terrible outcome.
One thing we know is that Judas, despite his beliefs and intentions, was never saved
@@ScribeAlicioushe was. In fact, he became a king in Jesus’s kingdom in heaven, according to Jesus.