加拿大: World rankings: Third largest proven oil reserve Gas production ranked 4th Timber production ranked 5th potash production ranked 1st Canola production ranked 1st Gold production ranked 5th Nickel production ranked 6th Potassium production rank 1st Wheat production ranked 5th Soybean production ranked 7th Diamonds production ranked 3rd 重有好多好多, 尤其是希有金屬
Agree totally. Canada is known to be resources rich. In fact, if not because of the rich natural resources, with our very low manufacturing and service industry export revenue, we'd be even poorer. 😞 And I can add more to the list above: water resources (aquatic water for bottling, for hydroelectricity e.g., Quebec), fisheries industry (Newfoundland, Nova Scotia's Grand Banks, BC), wind resources at thr North ...
Canada will have more money if they are willing to invest and develop the Oil sand in Alberta and Saskatchewan. BC and Eastern governments are willing to pay for foreign oil instead of building more pipelines to transfer the oil resources. There are also a lot of mineral resources in Ontario and Quebec, but it is hard to develop those mines due to environmental concerns. People might think the medical is good in Canada but you might not get any treatment if it is not life-threatening. People with money will travel outside of Canada for surgeries.
If we have a refinery in Alberta/BC and produce oil in large scale, the beautiful scenery in the West might be affected. Some of them can't be bought with money.
Why didn't register a corporation to run her business? A Canadian corporation with annual taxable profit less than $500,000 can enjoy tax rate of 12.5%.
稅太高，吸引唔到極多人口/企業家來加拿大定居/投資，就算來咗，有好大機會住幾年頂唔順就回流，導致人口唔夠多； 而人口唔夠多，又導致要以高稅率政策去維持政府運作⋯⋯根本就係一個死胡同⋯⋯ 唯一方法，真係要開採更多資源賣到全世界賺外匯，從而減低打工仔的 income tax，否則人民生活只會比共產主義國家更辛苦⋯⋯🤦♂️🤷🏻😢
I left Australia after living there for 10 yrs, partly because I don't want to be a tax slave any more. The ugly truth is people in Canada, the US and other Western countries are deemed as tax slaves by their governments.
加拿大稅重係政府缺乏效率。特別係所謂‘’精英‘’。講得難聽啲個個都係用公帑買選票。無一個有理念改變呢個國家。加拿大人亦俾政府想懶曬，收到少少福利就好開心。有鬥心想發達嘅就去曬美國。Elon Mask 就係好例子。其實仲有好多好多。我識有個華人少女Waterloo Computer Science 畢業。佢話我知佢班上最好成績個同學，未畢業就已經開公司。一畢業就即飛美國Silicon Valley 繼續經營間公司。希望可以揾到angel fund 投資。最後上市。
what I want to know is... which countries are best for immigration, as a Hong Kong Chinese. Cananda, US, UK, Australia are all high tax. Countries in the Middle East may not be the best choice for Chinese.
you don’t tax worldwide income based on passport/citizenship 。，Those rich Canadian may live outside Canada and not paying Canadian income tax . The rich immigrants go to Canada 。But they don’t stay after receiving the passport 😅
Very interesting though, you mentioned that one of the main reasons for those low-tax countries is because they have rich natural resources. I'd like to say that Canada ranks the third in oil reserves in the world. Yet Canada's oil prices are even higher than the US, let alone to help to draw down other community costs. Why is this so? I think it is lack of some patriotic politicians of Canada in the right start to draw up rules to rule out the oil reserves from being dominated by the oligarchy composed of several big companies. The lack of oil refinery in Canada is just a pretext, the oil profit is well enough to build many refineries in Canada. On comparison, the US did much better in this area, including making use of Canada's cheap oil, and so their people enjoy much better oil prices.
Typical short term immigrant mentality. Canadians pay more tax for wealth distribution so everyone contributes to free healthcare good public schools and universities. 20% of Americans only drink bottled water because their local tap water is contaminated. US Maternity leave is 1 month, it costs more to give birth in America than the royal family pays the private hospital for the birth of princes and princesses. If you are so concerned with taxes, try Somalia, base rate 6%, top rate 18%, and you probably won’t have to pay any if only get paid in cash, just don’t expect the government to do anything for you
雖然計入醫療美國嘅稅都唔輕 但係比起加拿大 美國搵錢機會多好多 加拿大好難搵錢 而且稅又咁重 所以在加拿大生活困難好多
Data有點錯誤, 加拿大天然資源絕對豐富,加拿大擁有世界第三大石油儲量！ Calgary 油絕對夠加拿大洗，第一喺加拿大無平價煉油廠，通通益美國，第二喺左派政府停止所有跨省輸油計劃。最大得益，點講都好喺美國。個問題如果您問我喺加拿大productivity差， 蝕比美國!
同意!!
1. 加拿大油價高, 有助於增加對於Gasoline的稅收, 包括Federal Excise Tax, 10cents per Litre. Provincial Motor Fuel Tax, 17.72 cents per Litre, in B.C. , 國內油價低就減少了整體稅收. ..
2. 加拿大天然資源可以說是十分豐富!! 例如94% BC 的土地都是Crown Land, 但這些資產不會在financial report 體現. 只當作1 加元.
簡單來說, 加拿大將稅收應付日常開支, "取之於民重新分配於民"。 但不會變賣國有資產是來補貼居民。賣出有限的non-reusable natural resource會收入袋進了provinal government, 但這些收入對於整體開支來說, 算是杯水車薪。 不知道我的理解有沒有錯, 希望大家指出。總結加拿大"好大使", 敗家子孫。
BC Public Accounts 2022/23:
www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/british-columbians-our-governments/government-finances/public-accounts/2022-23/public-accounts-2022-23.pdf
Alberta就算將所有bitumen royalties, 和non-renewable resource revenue 加起來, 才應付到其中一項政府開支 - 醫療開支(Health) 。
Alerta Financial Report 2022-23:
open.alberta.ca/dataset/7714457c-7527-443a-a7db-dd8c1c8ead86/resource/e700b94a-bf65-49d1-bdac-af4915338c2c/download/tbf-goa-2022-2023-final-results-year-end-report.pdf
佢講加拿大無天然資源，我都呆左，加拿大有油，有木材喎
FYI, 加拿大擁有世界第三大石油儲量，加拿大已探明儲量相當於其年消耗量188.3倍。 這意味著，如果沒有淨出口，石油還可以加拿大本地使用約 188 年（按目前消費水平，不包括未探明的儲量）!
加拿大有那一任政府會考慮咁長遠為國？誰當選, 首要開始就是如何可以連任.
@@cpyue7237杜魯多條粉頭，淨係識討好trans-gender、變性人、all-gender廁所，為拉選票，以及成為維尼熊出氣袋，其餘就一無是處🤷🏻🤡🤦♂️
卖到邻居美国的油价比自己用的还低，自己酿的啤酒在美国买更便宜。
加拿大是真正的国际共产主义战士，是佛教的最高境界，是毫不利己专门利人的光辉典范。
只是苦了百姓，灭了未来
生活質量一直在下降。衛生服務很差。沒有家庭醫生，需要等待一年多的專科醫生。住房和生活成本很高。隨著越來越多的人湧入，犯罪變得更加嚴重。
只会越来越差，因为政府无钱，印钱就是通胀来了，特别是房屋税，简直是政府话事，包租公！😂
二十萬收入買到什麼屋呀。落袋得一萬鬆一個月。宜家買個townhouse仔月供都7千幾啦加兩三百水電煤加地稅4000一年。如果買埋車就真係仆街啦。top1% 最盡只能負擔小townhouse。而且要節衣縮食。旅行就唔洗想
真，好多加拿大人根本無錢旅行，餐搵餐食
@@JL-oi8di 最悲哀系top1%都系餐搵餐食
呢㸃真珠都無咁真，抄樓 d 人係吸血鬼
@@tommywong3147 收入只係定義有錢人其中的一個指標, 財富/資產才是最通常的指標, 未變賣已升值的資產不會算做收入(capital gains), 最有錢的人往往能夠將生活中需要用錢的開支透過公司扣除, 所以單單用收入作為衡量的指標是不準確的
@@JL-oi8di 全世界打工 同做生意的分別都是這樣的. 資本主義的遊戲規則 . 所以先製造到機會給共產黨...可悲. 哪裡有完美的制度, 告訴我, 我都想知道
住咗喺加拿大咁多年都知道, 贏嘅就同政府分, 輪就係自己...
家下每年仲要養多百幾萬新移民, 仲有越嚟越多天災人禍, 火災水災, 又要聽美國話不停供錢去 烏克蘭 .. 真係睇唔到轉機🥲🥲
解釋清楚❤＂。我亦是四十多年加拿大會計師 非常多謝 全部讃成。 亦極之喜歡居住 （艱難大）
加拿大:
World rankings:
Third largest proven oil reserve
Gas production ranked 4th
Timber production ranked 5th
potash production ranked 1st
Canola production ranked 1st
Gold production ranked 5th
Nickel production ranked 6th
Potassium production rank 1st
Wheat production ranked 5th
Soybean production ranked 7th
Diamonds production ranked 3rd
重有好多好多, 尤其是希有金屬
加拿大資源咁多，典解要徵收咁高稅？Why?Why?Why?🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
@@Hongkongyou2874因為開採太多資源，又會彈出班環保左膠出嚟批評唔環保，成班都硬膠膠，被共產党恰到上心口了⋯⋯🤷🏻🤦♂️🤡
Agree totally. Canada is known to be resources rich. In fact, if not because of the rich natural resources, with our very low manufacturing and service industry export revenue, we'd be even poorer. 😞
And I can add more to the list above: water resources (aquatic water for bottling, for hydroelectricity e.g., Quebec), fisheries industry (Newfoundland, Nova Scotia's Grand Banks, BC), wind resources at thr North ...
加拿大食飽飯唔難，要發達就好難。同呢個國家嘅左傾政策有關。
加拿大政府基建工程效率差，項目由討論到完成至少10年，當然超支喇。看看香港人口稠密也可每2/3年起一新地鈇綫就知道冇得比。所有政客重視debate, 講多过做，浪費時间和纳税人辛苦掙來的金錢也不羞愧。政府赤字的解决方法就是增加地税和其他收费，從來不會检討和反省政府的效率，或三级政府互相推搪，叫其他政府資助又咪係纳税人付錢！不思進取如何能提高工業生產力，衹靠地產，推高樓价，另市民入不敷支。我希望加拿大成立独立廉署去整肅政客的貪污情況，使市民安心！！
講得好! 完全同意!
非常同意。加拿大政府低層係晤敢貪。反而高層貪咗無事。
我覺得還有第五點：人太少。有些必要政府大支出，攤分在三千萬人和攤分在一億人是完全不同的。
所以現在的移民政策是很正確
太少歐洲移民，未來必定係南亞人為主力
Canada will have more money if they are willing to invest and develop the Oil sand in Alberta and Saskatchewan. BC and Eastern governments are willing to pay for foreign oil instead of building more pipelines to transfer the oil resources. There are also a lot of mineral resources in Ontario and Quebec, but it is hard to develop those mines due to environmental concerns.
People might think the medical is good in Canada but you might not get any treatment if it is not life-threatening. People with money will travel outside of Canada for surgeries.
If we have a refinery in Alberta/BC and produce oil in large scale, the beautiful scenery in the West might be affected. Some of them can't be bought with money.
My daughter is a radiologist and she pays $250,000 income tax.That is 50% of her annual income.
Why didn't register a corporation to run her business? A Canadian corporation with annual taxable profit less than $500,000 can enjoy tax rate of 12.5%.
I handled some physicians, dentists and optometrist do it in this way
@@davezhang8866 She works at the hospital so as her husband works as an ER.
稅太高，吸引唔到極多人口/企業家來加拿大定居/投資，就算來咗，有好大機會住幾年頂唔順就回流，導致人口唔夠多；
而人口唔夠多，又導致要以高稅率政策去維持政府運作⋯⋯根本就係一個死胡同⋯⋯
唯一方法，真係要開採更多資源賣到全世界賺外匯，從而減低打工仔的 income tax，否則人民生活只會比共產主義國家更辛苦⋯⋯🤦♂️🤷🏻😢
亦可改善政府行政效率和投資，然後減稅同吸引人才黎做大個餅，但前提係要有管治人才同political will……
分析得十分之好👍👍
了解更多👍👍👍
You really have no idea what you are talking about. Please do not mislead people.
是否有天然資源是一回事，是否願意開採是另一問題。美國不是缺乏天然資源，只是當全球商品均是以美元定價時，開動油印機就可以買到外國資源，這不是更好嗎？當其他國家拒絕以美元買賣商品時，到時你就才會知到美國究竟有多少資源。從前不是說美國是石油入口第一大國嗎？信不信由你，過去幾年美國已成為石油出口第一大國，不信可去搜尋一下。
Thanks for the information
有油和氣，有油沙，重金屬，林木，六成水力發電， 這些全都是天然資源。
至於點解會咁重税我畀啲提示你地，i.e. 加拿大醫療效率在發達國家中排最尾， 點解錢洗咗好多但係病人得不到適切的服務？ 聯邦政府出錢的alberta/BC 油管超資三倍，遲咗一年仲未啟用？ 省政府出錢 ttc新線造價貴預期一倍要遲兩年啟用？
税重。。係因為政府出錢的基建或服務都係超支！
啲錢都唔知落咗邊個個袋？
Great Content!
多謝分享❤😊🎉
I left Australia after living there for 10 yrs, partly because I don't want to be a tax slave any more. The ugly truth is people in Canada, the US and other Western countries are deemed as tax slaves by their governments.
加拿大稅重係政府缺乏效率。特別係所謂‘’精英‘’。講得難聽啲個個都係用公帑買選票。無一個有理念改變呢個國家。加拿大人亦俾政府想懶曬，收到少少福利就好開心。有鬥心想發達嘅就去曬美國。Elon Mask 就係好例子。其實仲有好多好多。我識有個華人少女Waterloo Computer Science 畢業。佢話我知佢班上最好成績個同學，未畢業就已經開公司。一畢業就即飛美國Silicon Valley 繼續經營間公司。希望可以揾到angel fund 投資。最後上市。
Maybe you should compare the tax in HK AFTER you factor in that big indirect tax call real estate price.
稅制本身係唔公平 所以吸引唔到人材或者留唔到人材
例如一個人做醫生 假設佢好勤力加班 搵多左錢
結果income tax稅率要加到咁懲罰性
不過一人一票的制度就好易產生咁的現象
政客要派錢討好選民
You can buy RRSP to reduce tax or set up as self employed , pay less tax .
what I want to know is... which countries are best for immigration, as a Hong Kong Chinese. Cananda, US, UK, Australia are all high tax. Countries in the Middle East may not be the best choice for Chinese.
Australia,weather is better,not as cold,good welfare for citizens
其實大把國家有公共醫療，加拿大有咩咁特別？成日同美國比，大部分已發展國家都有近乎免費醫療
所有福利型国家，只是适宜去罗钱而不适宜去挣钱，甚至乎都不适宜投资
有腦喎，落地獄收金銀衣紙免稅
@@GDKNDJN怪吾知，你收甘多
you don’t tax worldwide income based on passport/citizenship 。，Those rich Canadian may live outside Canada and not paying Canadian income tax . The rich immigrants go to Canada 。But they don’t stay after receiving the passport 😅
加拿大如日韓台星馬泰,東西歐,中亞,
有尾駐軍,是尾租界,沒主權,
買大量尾軍火,被割韭菜,🤭
富了收回扣政客,
苦了人民😭
Very interesting though, you mentioned that one of the main reasons for those low-tax countries is because they have rich natural resources. I'd like to say that Canada ranks the third in oil reserves in the world. Yet Canada's oil prices are even higher than the US, let alone to help to draw down other community costs. Why is this so? I think it is lack of some patriotic politicians of Canada in the right start to draw up rules to rule out the oil reserves from being dominated by the oligarchy composed of several big companies.
The lack of oil refinery in Canada is just a pretext, the oil profit is well enough to build many refineries in Canada. On comparison, the US did much better in this area, including making use of Canada's cheap oil, and so their people enjoy much better oil prices.
中東國家的低稅，係資源出口強勁，所以可以有很多對外投資資產益自己國家人民。與其說香港的土地係資源，其實香港或新加坡呢類開放小型經濟係由其獨特金融貿易地位所賦與，用金融貿易專業服務出口既對外盈餘增加對外投資資產，從而不用向人民收重稅。
另外，嚴格來講，香港土地收入，對自己人係收間接稅。用呢個睇法，又唔同中東國家既低稅了。
計埋高地價換算成稅既話香港既稅分分鐘高過加拿大
Thx
美國 ER 等待時間係 2.5 小時，加拿大呢邊係 22 小時，人哋比多60%但效率高8倍，等睇醫生等到死咗嘅話免費又有乜用?
又咁講 最緊要係個國家收咗幾多稅 而洗返幾多錢係國民身上 呢個先係重點
其實加拿大花名係「大家拿」因為只要你識玩，囉福利既錢仲多過你出去打工既人工。
對加拿大資源數據沒掌握好，胡亂分析
加拿大稅高外，樓價都好非常高
版主， 你讀過英國法律同稅例嗎？
加拿大點算冇天然資源呀？
佢應該口誤, refer to my reply below.
@@chaujay1181 佢不停提播，應該係冇做功課姐
日本天然资源匮乏吗？日本税收又是什么情况？
日本位處地震帶，天然資源亦不多
起码加拿大的税是公开的。大陆的税更重，只是你表面看不到。
政府收的税都不够人情世故花费的钱夸张
平心而論,加拿大人一生交出的稅,以現時醫療成本,一個大病都已經“賺回本”。當然不希望會發生。
國家來做保險公司效率高, 還是私人保險公司效率高? 明顯是後者。
但私人保險公司將沒辦法繳納保費的貧窮人口排外....所以加拿大比較左的原因在這裡。
不同意，私人保險賺錢效率高而已，服務國民的效率一點不高
雖然美國稅低,但加上醫保支出後與加拿大相若。分別在美國擁有Mayo Clinic 神級的醫療機構，在那裏隨時找到由加拿大的一級醫生。加拿大基本是醫療兩級制,不過第二級是在美國。
香港的天然資源-有地？？加拿大冇天然資源？？冇地？？以前睇下你視頻但今日覺得冇做功課
亂噏廿四。
@@davezhang8866 27🤣
我都話佢唔喺加拿大住，好多嘢根本唔清楚
Typical short term immigrant mentality. Canadians pay more tax for wealth distribution so everyone contributes to free healthcare good public schools and universities. 20% of Americans only drink bottled water because their local tap water is contaminated. US Maternity leave is 1 month, it costs more to give birth in America than the royal family pays the private hospital for the birth of princes and princesses. If you are so concerned with taxes, try Somalia, base rate 6%, top rate 18%, and you probably won’t have to pay any if only get paid in cash, just don’t expect the government to do anything for you
奇怪中共國不入列
一年有八個月係落雪搵鬼去
似乎你没有去過加拿大的城市，不小心去錯了北極？